Review Reports
- Hang Yang 1,
- Longfei Kang 1 and
- Kailang Ding 1
- et al.
Reviewer 1: Anonymous Reviewer 2: Anonymous Reviewer 3: Anonymous Reviewer 4: Anonymous
Round 1
Reviewer 1 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsThe manuscript, entitled "Synergistic Effects of Coal Gasification Slag-Based Soil Conditioner and Vermicompost on Soil-Microbe-Plant Systems Under Saline-Alkali Stress", publishes the results of a study on the effect of soil conditioner and vermicompost on soil characteristics and plant growth in saline areas. The research is of an applied nature and is of practical interest. The text is written competently, the narration is consistent, and the graphic design is satisfactory. There is no doubt about the study of samples and data processing, but there are some questions about the choice of research methods. The findings indicate a significant improvement in the indicators, which seems to be a slight exaggeration. It is recommended to accept the article after minor changes.
1) Formal design notes.Line 39: The title is separated from the text of the chapter. Lines 121, 384, 389 and others: the font size is too large. Lines 207-208: it is advisable to shift the formulas to the right. It is advisable not to separate the caption to Figure 4 from the figure itself. There is too much free space at the end of page 9 that is not occupied by the text. There is no numbering of references to literary sources. Line 277: The Latin name of the plant should be written in italics. Figure 8 is shifted, part of it is not visible.
2) The experimental site is an open area of the field. The experimental conditions did not provide any protection from other external factors that could affect the result. Excavation (3 soil samples and 10 plants) is extremely small for judging the results.
3) It is desirable to make the captions to the figures more understandable. Instead of T1, T2, T3, T4 and T5, it is advisable to sign abbreviations corresponding to the variants.
4) Based on these figures, the T2 variant has good performance. As for the synergistic effect, this very concept implies an increase in the effect, compared with the total effect of the two factors, when applied separately. Rather, it is not about synergy, but about joint application.
5) In Figure 8, the differences are barely discernible.
6) It is advisable to give some information about the substances used: vermicompost and soil conditioner.
Author Response
Response to Reviewers’ Comments
(Note: All page numbers refer to the revised manuscript file with tracked changes)
Referee #1:
The manuscript, entitled "Synergistic Effects of Coal Gasification Slag-Based Soil Conditioner and Vermicompost on Soil-Microbe-Plant Systems Under Saline-Alkali Stress", publishes the results of a study on the effect of soil conditioner and vermicompost on soil characteristics and plant growth in saline areas. The research is of an applied nature and is of practical interest. The text is written competently, the narration is consistent, and the graphic design is satisfactory. There is no doubt about the study of samples and data processing, but there are some questions about the choice of research methods. The findings indicate a significant improvement in the indicators, which seems to be a slight exaggeration. It is recommended to accept the article after minor changes.
Response: Thank you for your positive comments and valuable suggestions to improve the quality of our manuscript. We would like to express our sincere appreciation for your constructive comments. We have made extensive modifications to our manuscript and carefully checked the data to make our results convincing.
Formal design notes.Line 39: The title is separated from the text of the chapter. Lines 121, 384, 389 and others: the font size is too large. Lines 207-208: it is advisable to shift the formulas to the right. It is advisable not to separate the caption to Figure 4 from the figure itself. There is too much free space at the end of page 9 that is not occupied by the text. There is no numbering of references to literary sources. Line 277: The Latin name of the plant should be written in italics. Figure 8 is shifted, part of it is not visible.
Response: Thank you for your valuable suggestion. Based on your feedback, we have revised and refined the proposed issues. Please refer to the red-marked revisions and annotations in the revised draft for specific details. We have organized the references in sequence and adjusted the formatting of the entire manuscript according to the journal's requirements to ensure compliance with its standards.
- The experimental site is an open area of the field. The experimental conditions did not provide any protection from other external factors that could affect the result. Excavation (3 soil samples and 10 plants) is extremely small for judging the results.
Response: Thank you for your valuable feedback. Based on your suggestion, we have supplemented and refined this important information in the Materials and Methods section. Please refer to the text below or lines 131–134, 141–144, and 165–168 in the revised manuscript.
2.2. Experimental Design:with adjacent plots separated by 1.5 m-wide buffer zones planted with L. chinensis to prevent cross-contamination of soil amendments and reduce competition from surrounding native vegetation. To mitigate animal disturbances, each plot was enclosed with 50 cm-high plastic fencing (buried 20 cm into the soil).
2.3. Soil Physicochemical Properties:Within each experimental plot, five soil cores (0-20 cm depth) were collected randomly along an S-shaped transect to ensure uniform coverage of the plot. The five cores were homogenized thoroughly and composited into one mixed sample to minimize spatial variability.
2.4. Plant Traits:In plant trait measurements, each experimental plot was subdivided into five representative 1×1 meter quadrats (also arranged in an S-shaped pattern to mitigate edge effects). Within each quadrat, 15 randomly selected erect plants were measured for natural height (from base to uppermost leaf tip; accuracy ±1 mm).
Thank you for your assistance in refining the experimental design section. Your suggestions have enabled readers to gain a clearer and more intuitive understanding of our experimental setup. This serves as a valuable reminder for us to give greater consideration to the impact of external factors at the experimental site on results in future experimental designs, thereby minimizing experimental errors.
- It is desirable to make the captions to the figures more understandable. Instead of T1, T2, T3, T4 and T5, it is advisable to sign abbreviations corresponding to the variants.
Response: Thank you for your valuable feedback. Based on your feedback, we have added specifications regarding the application rates of earthworm castings and coal gasification slag-based soil conditioners for treatments T1, T2, T3, T4, and T5 in the Figure 3 caption. Please refer to the text below or lines 244–248 of the revised manuscript for the specific details.
T1: Sole application of coal gasification slag-based soil conditioner (CGSS) at 45,000 kg·ha⁻¹; T2: Sole application of vermicompost (VC) at 45,000 kg·ha⁻¹; T3: CGSS-VC co-application (1:1 ratio), both applied at 22,500 kg·ha⁻¹; T4: CGSS-VC co-application (1:2 ratio), applied at 15,000 kg·ha⁻¹ and 30,000 kg·ha⁻¹ respectively; T5: CGSS-VC co-application (2:1 ratio), applied at 30,000 kg·ha⁻¹ and 15,000 kg·ha⁻¹ respectively.
- Based on these figures, the T2 variant has good performance. As for the synergistic effect, this very concept implies an increase in the effect, compared with the total effect of the two factors, when applied separately. Rather, it is not about synergy, but about joint application.
Response: Thank you for your rigorous and insightful comments on the definition of "synergistic effects." Based on your feedback, we have reviewed relevant literature and discussed within our research group to explain our rationale for the synergistic effects proposed in the paper. First, we established the significance of synergistic effects based on findings from prior scholars (Ai et al., 2023; Rezapour et al., 2021) in soil improvement studies. Specifically, in composite improvement systems (A and B), the combined effect of A and B surpasses the individual effects of either A or B applied alone, while the effects of applying A or B individually are still present. This confirms the existence of synergistic effects. Secondly, the T2 variant you proposed demonstrated excellent performance, showing favorable results in soil available phosphorus, available potassium, and Simpson's index. However, T4 significantly outperformed both T1 and T2 in enriching functional microorganisms (such as actinomycetes and nitrifying spirillum) and enhancing enzyme activity (with a 65.33% increase in PPO and a 47.52% increase in CAT). We attribute this to CGSS optimizing the physical habitat (porosity increased by 11.8%) while VC provided the nutrient substrate. Their synergistic effect created an ecological niche for functional microorganisms—an outcome unattainable with either amendment alone. Finally, our data analysis revealed that T1 lacked sufficient organic nutrients, resulting in low microbial functional activity (with a microbial diversity abundance function score of only 0.04). Meanwhile, T2 demonstrated limited capacity to regulate soil physical structure (pore volume increased by only 5.2% compared to CK, far below the 14.10% improvement of T1 and 11.8% of T4). T4's synergistic effect integrated the advantages of both amendments, achieving balanced improvements in soil structure, salinity regulation, nutrient supply, and microbial function. Consequently, it received the highest overall evaluation score (vegetation score 8.47, soil score 8.05).
We hope the above response addresses your concerns. We sincerely appreciate your feedback, which has significantly enhanced the scientific rigor and clarity of this study's core conclusions. It has also clarified our line of reasoning in the analysis and discussion, laying a solid foundation for subsequent work.
References
Ai F , He L , Li Q ,et al.Vermicompost Combined with Soil Conditioner Improves the Ecosystem Multifunctionality in Sa-line-Alkali Land[J].Water, 2023, 15(17):17.DOI:10.3390/w15173075.
Rezapour ,S.,Asadzadeh , et al.Organic amendments improved the chemical–nutritional quality of saline-sodic soils[J].International Journal of Environmental Science and Technology,2021,19(6):1-14.DOI:10.1007/S13762-021-03599-2.
5.In Figure 8, the differences are barely discernible.
Response: Thank you for your valuable feedback. Based on your feedback, the colors in Figure 6(a) have been adjusted to clearly distinguish between different bacterial phyla, making them easier to identify. For details, please refer to Figure 6(a) in Section 3.5 of the revised manuscript.
- It is advisable to give some information about the substances used: vermicompost and soil conditioner.
Response: Thank you for your valuable feedback. Information regarding earthworm castings and soil conditioners is described in Section 2.1, lines 102–109, but the presentation may be unclear. The relevant details for both substances are now restated. For specific content, please refer to the text below or lines 99-106 of the revised draft.
Commercial vermicompost (VC) is supplied by an environmental technology company in Shaanxi, primarily composed of earthworm castings (50%), sewage sludge (30%), and cattle manure (20%). The coal gasification slag-based soil conditioner (CGSS) independently developed by the research team primarily consists of coal gasification slag (80%), fly ash (10%), citric acid (5%), and sheep manure (5%). Prior to experimental setup, both VC and CGSS underwent a 15-day indoor fermentation process (at a constant temperature of 55°C and 65% humidity) (Fig. 1b, c).
Author Response File:
Author Response.docx
Reviewer 2 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsThe article addresses a relevant problem of saline-alkali soil remediation using a combination of industrial waste (coal gasification slag, CGSS) and organic fertilizer (vermicompost, VC). The research has practical significance; however, it contains numerous substantial methodological, stylistic, and analytical shortcomings that require correction prior to publication.
- Methodology and experimental design
- Unjustified choice of doses and ratios. The authors do not explain why these specific doses of CGSS and VC (e.g., 45,000 kg/ha for mono-application) and ratios (1:1, 1:2, 2:1) were chosen. This creates an impression of arbitrary selection.
- Lack of heavy metal monitoring. Although Table 2 indicates that the heavy metal content in the materials meets national standards, their accumulation in the soil or plants was not tracked during the experiment itself. This is critically important, given the origin of CGSS.
- Unclear replication. It is stated that there were three replicates per treatment, but it is unclear how spatial soil heterogeneity was accounted for.
- Statistical analysis and data interpretation
- Incorrect use of ANOVA. It is not specified whether tests for normality of distribution and homogeneity of variances were conducted. Without this, the use of ANOVA is incorrect.
- Lack of multivariate statistics for microbial data. The analysis of microbiome data was limited to alpha-diversity and RDA, without using more advanced methods (e.g., PERMANOVA, LEFSe), which reduces the depth of the analysis.
- Incorrect interpretation of correlations. In section 3.6, the authors make strong conclusions about cause-and-effect relationships based on correlation analysis, which is methodologically unsound.
- Results and their presentation
- Unreadable graphs and tables. Figures 3, 4, and 6 lack explanations for notations, and the fonts are too small.
- Contradictory data. For example, section 3.1 states that MDA in T2 increased by 40%, but MDA is a marker of oxidative stress, and its increase should be interpreted negatively, not as an improvement.
- Discussion and conclusions
- Weak cause-and-effect relationships. The authors frequently use phrases like "likely," "presumably," indicating the speculative nature of the conclusions.
- Ignoring alternative explanations. For instance, the increase in SOM in T4 could be related not only to the action of VC but also to changes in microbial activity influenced by CGSS.
- Exaggeration of result significance. Statements about "constructing a functionally complete community structure" (section 4.3) are not supported by in-depth functional analysis (e.g., metagenomic sequencing).
- Style and language
- Language errors. Numerous grammatical and stylistic errors (e.g., "The MDA activity in T2 treatment increased significantly… improving by…" – an increase in MDA cannot be an "improvement").
- Repetitions and redundancy. The same ideas are repeatedly stated in the Discussion section.
- Incorrect literature citations. For example, the in-text citation [M1] (p. 2) does not match the format of the reference list.
- Technical and formal shortcomings
- Incomplete method description. PCR conditions, sequencing parameters, and software versions used for bioinformatic analysis are not specified.
- Lack of plant survival data. Plant density or survival percentage is not indicated, which is important for assessing treatment effectiveness.
- No economic analysis. For the claimed "sustainability," there is no cost assessment of the proposed technology.
Conclusion
The article addresses an important topic and contains valuable experimental data; however, in its current form, it does not meet the standards of a scientific publication. I recommend returning the article for revision considering the noted comments. After corrections, the work may be of interest to the journal Sustainability.
Author Response
Response to Reviewers’ Comments
(Note: All page numbers refer to the revised manuscript file with tracked changes)
Reviewer #2:
The article addresses a relevant problem of saline-alkali soil remediation using a combination of industrial waste (coal gasification slag, CGSS) and organic fertilizer (vermicompost, VC). The research has practical significance; however, it contains numerous substantial methodological, stylistic, and analytical shortcomings that require correction prior to publication.
Response: Thank you for your positive comments and valuable suggestions to improve the quality of our manuscript. We would like to express our sincere appreciation for your constructive comments. We have made extensive modifications to our manuscript and carefully checked the data to make our results convincing.
1)Methodology and experimental design
1.Unjustified choice of doses and ratios. The authors do not explain why these specific doses of CGSS and VC (e.g., 45,000 kg/ha for mono-application) and ratios (1:1, 1:2, 2:1) were chosen. This creates an impression of arbitrary selection.
Response: Thank you for your valuable feedback. The single application rates of CGSS (coal-based conditioner) and VC (organic conditioner) at 45,000 kg・ha⁻¹ were not arbitrarily determined, but rather referenced the optimal dosage range for similar conditioners in saline-alkali soil improvement. The CGSS-VC ratios were designed based on their complementary functional mechanisms: CGSS dominates in physical structure improvement (porosity, salt leaching) due to its porous structure and high CaO and MgO content, while VC excels in nutrient supply and microbial activation. Through literature review and integration of prior research, we determined the application rates and ratios. For instance, CGSS-VC (1:1) was selected to investigate synergistic effects at equal application ratios, CGSS-VC (1:2) to study soil nutrient enhancement, and CGSS-VC (2:1) to examine how regulating soil physical structure influences improvement outcomes. This approach also facilitates subsequent cost calculations, enabling selection of low-cost, high-efficiency solutions. Specific references will be listed in the following text.
References
Ai F, He L, Li Q, et al. Vermicompost Combined with Soil Conditioner Improves the Ecosystem Multifunctionality in Sa-line-Alkali Land [J]. Water, 2023, 15(17): 3075.
Deng H ,Song Y ,Li W , et al.Performance and economy of antibiotic adsorption by the composite of plant decomposed liq-uid, chemical modifier, and clay[J].Process Safety and Environmental Protection,2024,1921408-1419.
Liu M ,Wang C ,Liu X , et al.Saline-alkali soil applied with vermicompost and humic acid fertilizer improved macroaggre-gate microstructure to enhance salt leaching and inhibit nitrogen losses[J].Applied Soil Ecology,2020,156.
Rezapour ,S.,Asadzadeh , et al.Organic amendments improved the chemical–nutritional quality of saline-sodic soils[J].International Journal of Environmental Science and Technology,2021,19(6):1-14.
Tejada M, Garcia C, Gonzalez J L, et al. Use of organic amendment as a strategy for saline soil remediation: Influence on the physical, chemical and biological properties of Soil [J]. Soil Biology and Biochemistry, 2006, 38(6): 1413–1421.
2.Lack of heavy metal monitoring. Although Table 2 indicates that the heavy metal content in the materials meets national standards, their accumulation in the soil or plants was not tracked during the experiment itself. This is critically important, given the origin of CGSS.
Response: Thank you for your valuable comment regarding heavy metal accumulation monitoring. We fully acknowledge the importance of tracking heavy metal dynamics in soil and plants, especially given that CGSS is derived from coal-based solid waste. To address your concern, we conducted a quantitative analysis of the amendment-to-soil ratio based on the experimental design parameters, We determine the heavy metal risks of soil conditioners through the following calculations.
We first calculate the mass of soil and soil conditioner within the experimental area. With a tillage depth of 20 cm and an area of 45 m², the soil bulk density is 1.5 g/cm³, and the soil conditioner application rate is 45,000 kg·ha⁻¹. Calculations yield a total soil mass of 13,500 kg and a soil conditioner mass of 202.5 kg, resulting in a soil conditioner-to-soil ratio of 1.5%. This indicates a low addition rate of soil conditioner, resulting in minimal potential heavy metal risks after application. While analysis suggests low accumulation risks, we concur with your proposal to monitor heavy metal levels in both soil and plants. We plan to incorporate heavy metal monitoring in subsequent trials and extend the monitoring period to over five years. We sincerely appreciate your constructive suggestion, which has prompted us to emphasize the quantitative safety assessment and outline future monitoring plans to enhance the study’s comprehensiveness.
3.Unclear replication. It is stated that there were three replicates per treatment, but it is unclear how spatial soil heterogeneity was accounted for.
Response: Thank you for your valuable feedback. Regarding your suggestion to address spatial soil heterogeneity, we have made revisions as detailed below or in lines 141–144 of the modified draft.
2.3. Soil Physicochemical Properties:Within each experimental plot, five soil cores (0-20 cm depth) were collected randomly along an S-shaped transect to ensure uniform coverage of the plot. The five cores were homogenized thoroughly and composited into one mixed sample to minimize spatial variability.
2)Statistical analysis and data interpretation
1.Incorrect use of ANOVA. It is not specified whether tests for normality of distribution and homogeneity of variances were conducted. Without this, the use of ANOVA is incorrect.
Response: Thank you for your valuable feedback. We have supplemented and refined the procedures for using analysis of variance (ANOVA). Specific modifications are detailed below or in lines 201–209 of the revised manuscript.
2.6. Data Analysis:Before statistical analysis, all experimental data were subjected to normality test (Shapiro-Wilk test) and a homogeneity of variance test (Levene's test) using SPSS 23.0 to verify the applicability of parametric statistical methods. Results showed that all data conformed to a normal distribution (Shapiro-Wilk test, p > 0.05) and exhibited homogeneous variances (Levene's test, p > 0.05), meeting the basic assumptions of one-way analysis of variance (ANOVA). A subsequent one-way ANOVA was conducted to compare differences among treatments, with significance set at p < 0.05. Tukey’s HSD test was used for post-hoc mean separation, as it is robust for balanced sample sizes and homogeneous variances[44].
2.Lack of multivariate statistics for microbial data. The analysis of microbiome data was limited to alpha-diversity and RDA, without using more advanced methods (e.g., PERMANOVA, LEFSe), which reduces the depth of the analysis.
Response: Thank you for your insightful perspective on the depth of microbial data analysis. We fully agree that employing multivariate statistical methods (e.g., PERMANOVA and LEFSe) enhances the rigor of microbiome research, and we appreciate your suggestion to enrich the analytical approaches. This study selected α-diversity analysis and response-driven data analysis (RDA) as analytical tools because these methods enable us to directly understand the relationships between soil physicochemical indicators and microorganisms, thereby providing a foundation for subsequent discussions and conclusions.
The primary goal of this study was to elucidate the synergistic effects of CGSS-VC co-application on the soil-microbe-plant system under saline-alkali stress, rather than focusing on fine-scale differences in microbial community composition (e.g., identifying unique biomarkers or quantifying subtle intergroup differences). Alpha-diversity indices (Chao1, Shannon, Simpson) directly reflect the richness, evenness, and stability of microbial communities—key indicators of soil ecological function restoration (Bebber et al., 2022). The significant increase in Chao1 index (21.53% in T4 vs. CK) effectively validated that the optimal amendment ratio improved microbial community robustness, which is closely linked to enhanced nutrient cycling and plant growth. RDA (redundancy analysis) was selected to quantify the linkage between soil environmental factors (e.g., pH, EC, SOM, nutrients) and microbial community structure (Fig. 6b). With Axes 1 and 2 explaining 95.78% of total variance and Monte Carlo permutation test confirming significance (p<0.05), this method sufficiently identified key drivers (e.g., porosity, AP, AN) shaping microbial communities. This directly addressed the study’s hypothesis that "co-application optimizes soil conditions to regulate microbial function," forming a closed loop with soil and plant data.The existing analysis of phylum-level relative abundance (Fig. 8a) and correlation with environmental factors (Fig. 9) already clarified that the enriched taxa are functionally linked to remediation efficacy, which aligns with the study’s focus.
In summary, the selection of α diversity indices and the adoption of RDA analysis methods can directly impact our paper. However, we firmly believe that your suggestions provide significant inspiration for our subsequent experimental design. We sincerely appreciate your advice, as these valuable insights will profoundly influence our future experimental planning and paper writing.
3.Incorrect interpretation of correlations. In section 3.6, the authors make strong conclusions about cause-and-effect relationships based on correlation analysis, which is methodologically unsound.
Response: Thank you for your valuable feedback. I have revised the description of relevance in Section 3.6. Please refer to the text below or lines 333–341 of the revised draft for the specific changes.
3.6. Relationships Between Soil Physicochemical and Biological Properties:Figure 7 shows the effects of soil environmental factors and plant enzyme activities on the microbial community at the phylum level. Correlation analysis revealed that soil porosity and EC were key factors shaping the microbial community. Proteobacteria, Gemmatimonadetes, and Planctomycetes were negatively correlated with porosity, whereas Patescibacteria and Actinobacteria showed a positive correlation. Acidobacteria and Chloroflexi were negatively associated with EC, while Actinobacteria increased with EC. Several phyla, including Acidobacteria and Planctomycetes, also showed significant correlations with nutrient availability (AP, AN, AK) and plant enzyme activities (ALP, CAT, SOD, MDA).
Thank you once again for your assistance with our article. Your suggestions have significantly improved its quality and helped us recognize the importance of rigor and meticulousness in the writing process during revisions.
3)Results and their presentation
1.Unreadable graphs and tables. Figures 3, 4, and 6 lack explanations for notations, and the fonts are too small.
Response: Thank you for your valuable feedback. The symbols in Figures 3, 4, and 6 have been annotated, and the font size in the enlarged view has been adjusted. For specific details, please refer to the following text or lines 239–241, 261-262, and 294-295 in the revised manuscript.
Figure 3. Effects of different treatments on the growth and physiology of Leymus chinensis. Lowercase letters indicate whether the samples of the same index are significantly different from each other (p<0.05, n=5).
Figure 4. Physical and chemical properties of Saline-Alkali soil. Lowercase letters indicate whether the samples of the same index are significantly different from each other (p<0.05, n=5).
Figure 5. Alpha diversity of the soil microorganisms. Lowercase letters indicate whether the samples of the same index are significantly different from each other (p<0.05, n=5).
2.Contradictory data. For example, section 3.1 states that MDA in T2 increased by 40%, but MDA is a marker of oxidative stress, and its increase should be interpreted negatively, not as an improvement.
Response: Thank you for your valuable feedback. Based on your feedback, we have revised the analysis in Section 3.1 by consulting relevant literature and experimental data. Please refer to the following text or lines 227–237 in the revised manuscript for the specific changes.
3.1. Growth Parameters and Enzyme Activities of Plant:Different soil amendment combinations effectively enhanced the physiological and biochemical indices of L. chinensis (Figure 3), with CGSS-VC co-application outperforming single amendments and T4 (CGSS: VC=1: 2) as the optimal treatment. Compared with other treatment groups, T4 treatment significantly increased leaf area (48.14%) and biomass (19.89%) (p<0.05). Compared with the CK group, plant height and root volume in the T4 group increased by 12.93% and 12.00%, respectively, while other treatment groups showed smaller gains. T3 and T2 treatments respectively achieved significant increases in regreening rate (70.81%) and stem diameter (44.87%) (p<0.05), and T3 also reduced MDA content by 23.78% (33.91 μmol/g vs. CK, p<0.05). Although CAT, POD, and SOD activities were slightly enhanced across treatments, no significant differences were observed among groups.
Your feedback has been extremely helpful. During the revision process, it has provided us with a clearer understanding of plant indicators, which will greatly assist us in future data analysis.
4)Discussion and conclusions
1.Weak cause-and-effect relationships. The authors frequently use phrases like "likely," "presumably," indicating the speculative nature of the conclusions.
Response: Thank you for your valuable feedback. Based on your feedback, revisions have been made to portions of the Discussion and Conclusions sections. Specific changes can be found in the text below or in the revised manuscript at lines 389-405, 413-423, 457-471.
Soil pH regulation, a critical remediation indicator[57], was most pronounced in T3 (CGSS: VC=1: 1), despite CGSS (pH 5.79) being more acidic than VC (pH 6.78). This counterintuitive result stems from synergistic physicochemical-microbiological interactions: CGSS provides rapid but transient acidity via mineral components (e.g., hematite), while VC sustains proton release through microbial decomposition of organic acids (e.g., citric, oxalic acids) and CO₂ respiration by functional taxa (e.g., Pseudomonas spp.)[58]. Low-molecular-weight organic acids from VC further accelerate acidic mineral dissolution in CGSS[59], extending pH buffering duration beyond single-amendment effects. SOM sequestration in T4 is driven by two synergistic mechanisms: (1) direct organic input from VC (SOM=88.57 g·kg⁻¹, Table 2), which supplies humic acids and plant residues[60]; (2) CGSS-mediated microbial regulation—15,000 kg·ha⁻¹ CGSS optimizes soil porosity (11.8% increase) and pH (reduced to 8.62), enriching functional taxa like Acidobacteria (16.9% higher than the control group) and increasing microbial richness (Chao1 increased by 21.5%) (Figure 5a, 6a). Acidobacteria promote recalcitrant organic matter stabilization[61-62], while elevated sucrase (SUC increased by 25.00%) and polyphenol oxidase (PPO in-creased by 65.33%) activities (Figure 4j,k) enhance microbial conversion of labile carbon to stable SOM[63].
In the saline-alkali soil studied (initial electrical conductivity 272.76 μS·m⁻¹), the combined CGSS-VC amendment significantly reduced soil electrical conductivity through ion leaching and immobilization. The T4 treatment decreased EC by 12.00% compared to the control, effectively alleviating the inhibition of microbial metabolism caused by salt stress. Notably, the moderate reduction in EC created favorable conditions for soil nutrient cy-cling. This was reflected in the T4 treatment, where alkaline hydrolyzable nitrogen (AN) content increased significantly by 18.3% compared to the CK, indicating enhanced nitro-gen transformation processes[66-67]. However, alkaline phosphatase (ALP) activity in T4-treated plants decreased by approximately 26% compared to CK, likely because ALP responds more sensitively to soil phosphorus availability, pH, or specific microbial com-munities rather than being directly regulated by salinity.
Proteobacteria dominated across all treatments (26.73–34.84%) due to their metabolic versatility in carbon, nitrogen, and phosphorus cycling, peaking at 34.84% in T2 (sole VC) as a direct response to VC-derived carbon sources[69]. In contrast, T4 did not prioritize a single phylum but fostered a balanced, functionally coherent microbiome. This is evidenced by its highest microbial α-diversity membership function value (2.88), whereas T1 (sole CGSS) scored only 0.04—reflecting CGSS’s limitation in providing sufficient nutrients and microenvironmental optimization, which compromised community integrity and key functional groups. T4, by integrating CGSS’s physical improvement and VC’s organic matter supply, enriched functional phyla, including Actinobacteria (facilitates complex organic compound decomposition and organic phosphorus mineralization via extracellular enzymes[70]) and Nitrospirae (drives nitrification), while reducing oligotrophic, stress-tolerant phyla (Gemmatimonadetes, Bacteroidetes) prevalent in unamended CK soil [71]. This shift signals a transition from a survival-focused to a function-oriented microbial community, enhancing nutrient cycling efficiency.
2.Ignoring alternative explanations. For instance, the increase in SOM in T4 could be related not only to the action of VC but also to changes in microbial activity influenced by CGSS.
Response: Thank you for your valuable feedback. Based on your feedback, we have explained the potential contribution of microbial activity changes influenced by CGSS, in addition to the role of VC, to the increase in soil organic matter in Zone T4. For specific details, please refer to the following text or lines 389-405 in the revised manuscript.
SOM sequestration in T4 is driven by two synergistic mechanisms: (1) direct organic input from VC (SOM=88.57 g·kg⁻¹, Table 2), which supplies humic acids and plant residues[60]; (2) CGSS-mediated microbial regulation—15,000 kg·ha⁻¹ CGSS optimizes soil porosity (11.8% increase) and pH (reduced to 8.62), enriching functional taxa like Acidobacteria (16.9% higher than the control group) and increasing microbial richness (Chao1 increased by 21.5%) (Figure 5a, 6a). Acidobacteria promote recalcitrant organic matter stabilization[61-62], while elevated sucrase (SUC increased by 25.00%) and polyphenol oxidase (PPO in-creased by 65.33%) activities (Figure 4j,k) enhance microbial conversion of labile carbon to stable SOM[63].
3.Exaggeration of result significance. Statements about "constructing a functionally complete community structure" (section 4.3) are not supported by in-depth functional analysis (e.g., metagenomic sequencing).
Response: Thank you for your valuable feedback. Based on your suggestion, we have reviewed and analyzed the content discussed in Section 4.3. Section 4.3 is titled Regulatory Effects of Vermicompost and Coal Gasification Slag-Based Soil Conditioner Addition on Soil Microbial Communities,We have considered the effects of the composite soil conditioner on soil microbial communities. In the subsequent analysis, we gradually deviated from the central theme. Following your reminder, we have revised portions of Section 4.3. Your suggestions have made the article's message clearer and more precise. Please refer to the following text or lines 458-476 in the revised manuscript for the specific modifications.
Redundancy analysis (RDA) and correlation heatmap analysis further delineated the linkage between soil environmental factors and microbial community structure: Available phosphorus (AP) and alkali-hydrolyzable nitrogen (AN) emerged as key drivers, with Actinobacteria, Proteobacteria, and Acidobacteria showing significant correlations with AP/AN content[72]. VC optimized nutrient cycling to boost the relative abundance of these functional phyla[73], while CGSS’s porous structure shaped bacterial communities by providing aerobic microhabitats for taxa like Patescibacteria (highly positively correlated with porosity) and modulating pH to favor salt-adapted groups. Notably, Acidobacteria exhibited a strong positive correlation with AP, confirming targeted enrichment of phosphorus-cycling taxa under T4’s high-AP environment.
In summary, the co-application of VC and CGSS exerts multifaceted regulatory effects on saline-alkali soil-plant systems via a synergistic cascade: improvement of soil physicochemical properties, activation of enzymatic activities, and optimization of microbial functionalities. Future research should focus on three priorities: (1) Elucidating interactions between soil aggregate stability and microbial colonization dynamics; (2) Delineating linkage pathways between functional microbial consortia and plant stress resistance; (3) Decoding microbial metabolic regulation governing nutrient cycling. These advancements will provide targeted theoretical frameworks for precision ecological restoration of saline-alkali soils.
5)Style and language
1.Language errors. Numerous grammatical and stylistic errors (e.g., "The MDA activity in T2 treatment increased significantly… improving by…" – an increase in MDA cannot be an "improvement").
Response: We sincerely appreciate this valuable comment. Based on your suggestions, we have revised the analysis of the MDA in Section 3.1. Please refer to the following text or lines 233–235 of the revised draft for the specific changes.
T3 and T2 treatments respectively achieved significant increases in regreening rate (70.81%) and stem diameter (44.87%) (p<0.05), and T3 also reduced MDA content by 23.78% (33.91 μmol/g, p<0.05).
2.Repetitions and redundancy. The same ideas are repeatedly stated in the Discussion section.
Response: We sincerely appreciate this valuable comment. Based on your feedback, we have removed repeated statements expressing the same viewpoint from the discussion section and refined the wording. For specific details, please refer to the following sections or lines 396-405, 413-423,447-457,462-467 in the revised draft.
SOM sequestration in T4 is driven by two synergistic mechanisms: (1) direct organic input from VC (SOM=88.57 g·kg⁻¹, Table 2), which supplies humic acids and plant residues[60]; (2) CGSS-mediated microbial regulation—15,000 kg·ha⁻¹ CGSS optimizes soil porosity (11.8% increase) and pH (reduced to 8.62), enriching functional taxa like Acidobacteria (16.9% higher than the control group) and increasing microbial richness (Chao1 increased by 21.5%) (Figure 5a, 6a). Acidobacteria promote recalcitrant organic matter stabilization[61-62], while elevated sucrase (SUC increased by 25.00%) and polyphenol oxidase (PPO in-creased by 65.33%) activities (Figure 4j,k) enhance microbial conversion of labile carbon to stable SOM[63].
In the saline-alkali soil studied (initial electrical conductivity 272.76 μS·m⁻¹), the combined CGSS-VC amendment significantly reduced soil electrical conductivity through ion leaching and immobilization. The T4 treatment decreased EC by 12.00% compared to the control, effectively alleviating the inhibition of microbial metabolism caused by salt stress. Notably, the moderate reduction in EC created favorable conditions for soil nutrient cy-cling. This was reflected in the T4 treatment, where alkaline hydrolyzable nitrogen (AN) content increased significantly by 18.3% compared to the CK, indicating enhanced nitrogen transformation processes[66-67]. However, alkaline phosphatase (ALP) activity in T4-treated plants decreased by approximately 26% compared to CK, likely because ALP responds more sensitively to soil phosphorus availability, pH, or specific microbial com-munities rather than being directly regulated by salinity.
This is evidenced by its highest microbial α-diversity membership function value (2.88), whereas T1 (sole CGSS) scored only 0.04—reflecting CGSS’s limitation in providing sufficient nutrients and microenvironmental optimization, which compromised community integrity and key functional groups. T4, by integrating CGSS’s physical improvement and VC’s organic matter supply, enriched functional phyla, including Actinobacteria (facilitates complex organic compound decomposition and organic phosphorus mineralization via extracellular enzymes[70]) and Nitrospirae (drives nitrification), while reducing oligotrophic, stress-tolerant phyla (Gemmatimonadetes, Bacteroidetes) prevalent in unamended CK soil [71]. This shift signals a transition from a survival-focused to a function-oriented microbial community, enhancing nutrient cycling efficiency.
VC optimized nutrient cycling to boost the relative abundance of these functional phyla[73], while CGSS’s porous structure shaped bacterial communities by providing aerobic microhabitats for taxa like Patescibacteria (highly positively correlated with porosity) and modulating pH to favor salt-adapted groups. Notably, Acidobacteria exhibited a strong positive correlation with AP, confirming targeted enrichment of phosphorus-cycling taxa under T4’s high-AP environment.
3.Incorrect literature citations. For example, the in-text citation [M1] (p. 2) does not match the format of the reference list.
Response: Thank you for your positive comments and valuable suggestions to improve the quality of our manuscript. Based on your feedback, we have systematically numbered all references throughout the text and revised the reference section to comply with journal formatting requirements.
6)Technical and formal shortcomings
1.Incomplete method description. PCR conditions, sequencing parameters, and software versions used for bioinformatic analysis are not specified.
Response: Thank you for your positive comments and valuable suggestions to improve the quality of our manuscript. Based on your feedback, we have supplemented and refined the relevant information in Section 2.5. Please refer to the text below or lines 184-194 of the revised draft for the specific content.
Genomic DNA was extracted from 0.25 g of homogenized composite soil samples (n = 5 biological replicates per treatment) using the PowerSoil® DNA Isolation Kit (Mo Bio Laboratories). DNA quality was assessed via NanoDrop spectrophotometry, with acceptance criteria: OD₂₆₀/OD₂₈₀ = 1.8-2.0, OD₂₆₀/OD₂₃₀ > 1.5, and concentration ≥5 ng/μL. Libraries were prepared from 30 ng qualified DNA per replicate using Illumina TruSeq® DNA Library Prep Kit. The V4 region of bacterial 16S rRNA genes was amplified with primers: 338F (5′-barcode+ACTCCTACGGGAGGCAGCA-3′); 806R (5′-GGACTACHVGGGTWTCTAAT-3′). The amplicon libraries were sequenced on an Il-lumina MiSeq platform using the 2×250 bp paired-end chemistry. This sequencing effort yielded an average of 60,000 high-quality reads per sample, providing sufficient depth for subsequent microbial community analysis.
2.Lack of plant survival data. Plant density or survival percentage is not indicated, which is important for assessing treatment effectiveness.
Response: Thank you for your positive comments and valuable suggestions to improve the quality of our manuscript. Based on your feedback, we reviewed the experimental process and data. While plant density and survival rate were not measured during the plant maturation period, we assessed overwintering recovery rate in the second year. Analysis revealed that the overwintering recovery rate for treatment T3 was 82.5%, representing a 70.81% increase compared to the control (CK). Regarding the experimental design section, we have included details on plant planting density. For specific content, please refer to the following text or lines 135 and 233-235 in the revised manuscript.
Section 2.2 L. chinensis was drill-seeded at 6.0 g·m⁻² with 1 cm sowing depth and 25 cm row spacing[28].
Section 3.1 T3 and T2 treatments respectively achieved significant increases in regreening rate (70.81%), and stem diameter (44.87%) (p<0.05), and T3 also reduced MDA content by 23.78% (33.91 μmol/g vs. CK, p<0.05).
3.No economic analysis. For the claimed "sustainability," there is no cost assessment of the proposed technology.
Response: Thank you for your positive comments and valuable suggestions to improve the quality of our manuscript. Based on your feedback, we compared the costs of using soil conditioners and vermicompost in our study with other similar soil improvement methods available on the market. The results indicate that the lowest cost for soil improvement was achieved using vermicompost and soil conditioners, amounting to 444.31 $ per hectare. For detailed information, Please refer to Supporting Information Table S1. Additionally, revisions have been made to the abstract and conclusion sections. For specific details, please refer to the text below or lines 33–35 and 492-494 of the revised draft.
From an economic perspective, the T4 treatment (corresponding to a VC-CGSS application ratio of 2:1) exhibits a lower cost compared to other similar soil conditioners and organic fertilizer combinations for saline-alkali soil remediation.
From an economic perspective, the application ratio of VC-CGSS at 2:1 demonstrates lower costs compared to other similar conditioners and organic fertilizers for soil improvement.
Author Response File:
Author Response.docx
Reviewer 3 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsThe manuscript addresses a relevant topic and presents substantial field data. However, major revisions are required
Summary and objective of the study
This manuscript investigates whether co-application of a coal gasification slag–based soil conditioner (CGSS) and vermicompost (VC), applied at different ratios, can synergistically improve saline-alkali soil physicochemical properties, soil microbial communities (16S rRNA), and the growth/physiological performance of Leymus chinensis. The study aims to identify an optimal CGSS:VC ratio using a multi-indicator membership function approach. The topic is relevant for saline-alkali land reclamation and coal-waste valorization, and the field experiment provides valuable data. However, substantial revisions are needed to improve clarity, consistency, and alignment between Results, Discussion, and Conclusions.
Major comments
1) Abstract needs improved focus and context
The abstract does not clearly mention salinity mitigation (e.g., EC reduction or salt indicators), although this is central to reclamation of saline-alkali soil.
The rationale for choosing Leymus chinensis is not stated (a short justification would strengthen the abstract).
The abstract is overly detailed, reporting many percentage changes; it would be clearer to summarize only the most important outcomes (especially for the best-performing treatment vs. CK).
Treatments (CK, T1–T5) are clearly listed, which is a strength.
2) Introduction is overly long and contains inconsistencies
The introduction is dense and could be shortened to improve readability and logical flow.
The salinity statistics appear inconsistent: the manuscript reports ~1.125×10⁹ ha globally affected but also suggests China alone may reach ~9.0×10⁸ ha; this requires careful verification and clearer definition of what is being reported.
Terminology is inconsistent (“salinization-alkalization”, “saline-alkali soil”, “saline-alkali land”); use one consistent term throughout.
3) Materials and Methods: key clarity and reproducibility issues
Figure 2 description is reversed: the text states Figure 2a shows salt content and 2b shows water, but the figure indicates the opposite (2a water content; 2b salt content). Please correct.
Soil texture classification seems inconsistent with the reported particle fractions (21.1% sand, 61.7% silt, 17.2% clay), which typically corresponds to silty loam, not sandy loam.
Groundwater fluctuation description is unclear (“salt-accumulating seasons: 30–40 cm; dry seasons: 1.5–2.0 m”). Please clarify whether this refers to groundwater table depth, salt accumulation depth, or seasonal ranges.
Data analysis (Section 2.6) is under-specified:
For ANOVA, specify the post-hoc test used for mean separation and whether assumptions (normality, homoscedasticity) were checked.
The membership function analysis is not sufficiently explained for reproducibility: please state why it was used, list the indicators included, explain how final composite scores were calculated (sum or average), and clarify whether weights were equal or different.
4) Results: structure, clarity, and statistics require major improvement
The Results are long, fragmented, and sometimes mix interpretation with reporting of findings. Interpretation should be reserved for the Discussion.
Figures are very dense (many sub-panels), and the text repeats many values. Consider summarizing key outcomes and/or moving secondary variables to Supplementary Material.
Statistical reporting is inconsistent: statements about “no significant differences” conflict with figure letter annotations and later claims. Please re-check ANOVA/post-hoc results and ensure text, figures, and captions agree.
Avoid reporting broad percentage ranges across multiple variables (e.g., “47.09%–179.00%”), as this obscures which variable changed most; link each percentage to a specific variable or summarize qualitatively.
Interpretation of MDA should be handled carefully: increased MDA is typically a marker of higher oxidative stress. If MDA is treated as a “negative indicator” in the membership analysis, this should be explicitly reflected in the Results narrative.
5) Discussion and Conclusions: inconsistencies and over-interpretation
There are critical inconsistencies in treatment labeling (e.g., statements implying “sole CGSS application (T2)”, while T2 is defined as VC alone in Methods). This must be corrected throughout.
Some Discussion claims are mechanistic and overly causal without direct measurements (e.g., ion fixation, dual-phase acidification, microhabitat claims). Please soften wording (“may”, “likely”, “consistent with”) or support with direct evidence.
Discussion/Conclusions sometimes claim significance that is not supported by Results (e.g., antioxidant enzyme activities described as “significantly elevated” despite earlier non-significant statements). Align Conclusions strictly with statistical outcomes.
EC interpretation should be consistent with reported units and measured ranges; avoid using salinity thresholds (e.g., 8 or 15 dS m⁻¹) if they do not correspond to the study’s EC values or units are unclear.- Figure 4 looks much lower.
Typo/abbreviation error in Conclusions: “CGR” should be CGSS in the T4 dosage statement.
Author Response
Response to Reviewers’ Comments
(Note: All page numbers refer to the revised manuscript file with tracked changes)
Reviewer #3:
This manuscript investigates whether co-application of a coal gasification slag–based soil conditioner (CGSS) and vermicompost (VC), applied at different ratios, can synergistically improve saline-alkali soil physicochemical properties, soil microbial communities (16S rRNA), and the growth/physiological performance of Leymus chinensis. The study aims to identify an optimal CGSS:VC ratio using a multi-indicator membership function approach. The topic is relevant for saline-alkali land reclamation and coal-waste valorization, and the field experiment provides valuable data. However, substantial revisions are needed to improve clarity, consistency, and alignment between Results, Discussion, and Conclusions.
Response: Thank you for your positive comments and valuable suggestions to improve the quality of our manuscript. We would like to express our sincere appreciations for your constructive comments. We have made extensive modifications to our manuscript and carefully checked the data to make our results convincing.
1) Abstract needs improved focus and context
The abstract does not clearly mention salinity mitigation (e.g., EC reduction or salt indicators), although this is central to reclamation of saline-alkali soil.
The rationale for choosing Leymus chinensis is not stated (a short justification would strengthen the abstract).
The abstract is overly detailed, reporting many percentage changes; it would be clearer to summarize only the most important outcomes (especially for the best-performing treatment vs. CK).
Treatments (CK, T1–T5) are clearly listed, which is a strength.
Response: Thank you for your positive comments and valuable suggestions to improve the quality of our manuscript. Based on your feedback, we have revised the abstract section. Please refer to the following text or lines 14–39 of the revised draft for the specific changes.
Soil salinization is a major driver of global land degradation, threatening agricultural productivity and sustainable development. To address this issue, field experiments were conducted to evaluate the synergistic effects of earthworm castings (VC) and coal gasification slag-based soil conditioner (CGSS) on saline-alkali soil remediation, soil microbial communities, and the growth of Leymus chinensis. This high-quality forage grass, selected for its inherent salt tolerance, was chosen as the experimental subject due to its ecological adaptability and economic value in arid/semi-arid saline-alkali regions. Five treatment groups were established: CK (unamended), T1 (CGSS alone), T2 (VC alone), T3 (CGSS: VC = 1: 1), T4 (CGSS: VC = 1: 2), and T5 (CGSS: VC = 2: 1). Results indicate that the combined application of CGSS-VC outperformed individual amendments, with the T4 treatment demonstrating the most effective results. Treatment T4 significantly alleviated saline-alkali stress, reducing soil electrical conductivity (EC) by 12.00% and pH by 5.17% compared to the control (p<0.05). It also enhanced soil fertility (soil organic matter and available C, N, and P nutrients). It promoted the growth of L. chinensis, with the most sig-nificant improvements observed in dry biomass, leaf area, and plant height. Additionally, the T4 treatment increased soil microbial richness (Chao1 index) by 21.5% and elevated the relative abundance of the Acidobacteria functional group by 16.9% (p<0.05). Hence, T4 treatment (CGSS: 15,000 kg·ha⁻¹; VC: 30,000 kg·ha⁻¹) was identified as the optimal remediation strategy through a fuzzy comprehensive evaluation that integrated multiple soil and plant indicators. From an economic perspective, the T4 treatment (corresponding to a VC-CGSS application ratio of 2: 1) exhibits a lower cost compared to other similar soil conditioners and organic fertilizer combinations for saline-alkali soil remediation. Our findings provide an effective approach for saline-alkali soil reclamation and a sustainable pathway for the resource utilization of coal-based solid waste. This study also provides new insights into the response of the soil-microbe-plant system to the application of soil conditioner under saline-alkali stress.
The introduction is dense and could be shortened to improve readability and logical flow.
The salinity statistics appear inconsistent: the manuscript reports ~1.125×10⁹ ha globally affected but also suggests China alone may reach ~9.0×10⁸ ha; this requires careful verification and clearer definition of what is being reported.
Terminology is inconsistent (“salinization-alkalization”, “saline-alkali soil”, “saline-alkali land”); use one consistent term throughout.
Response: Thank you for your positive comments and valuable suggestions to improve the quality of our manuscript. Based on your feedback, we have reviewed the literature on saline-alkali soil data and made corresponding revisions. The introduction has been refined to enhance readability. The data sources for saline-alkali land are listed below. The term "saline-alkali soil" is now used consistently throughout the text, and other terminology has been updated accordingly. Specific changes are detailed below or in lines 41–82 of the revised draft.
Saline-alkali soil is a major global challenge that threatens natural resources, ecological sustainability, and agricultural productivity[1]. Globally, salt-affected soils (defined as soils with total salt content >1 g·kg⁻¹, including saline, sodic, and saline-sodic soils of all severity levels) cover approximately 1.3×10⁹ hectares (ha)[2-4]. In China, the total area of different-degree saline-alkali soils (excluding non-saline soils) is reported to be 9.9×10⁷ ha (99 million ha), accounting for 10.3% of China’s total land area[5-6]. Notably, 60.0% of China’s saline-alkali soils are distributed in the arid and semi-arid regions of the northwest, where fragile ecological conditions and improper land use further exacerbate salinization[7]. Saline-alkali soil expands globally at 1–2 million ha annually, driven by improper irrigation and sealevel rise, threatening agricultural sustainability and ecological stability[8]. While traditional chemical amendments (e.g., gypsum, humic acid) temporarily regulate salt migration, they suffer from high costs and secondary contamination risks[9-10]. Single organic amendments like compost improve soil fertility but lack effective saline ion adsorption[11-12], creating an urgent need for composite materials that synergistically enhance soil physicochemical properties and microbial activity.
China’s coal consumption reached 4.35×10⁹ tonnes in 2023, projected to peak at 4.37×10⁹ tonnes by 2025[13], generating over 3.3×10⁷ tonnes of coal gasification slag annually[14]. Mostly disposed of via open-air stockpiling or mine backfilling, this slag has inherent potential for saline-alkali soil remediation—its porous structure and high CaO and MgO content (>30%) enable Na⁺ displacement and improved soil permeability[15-16]—though existing research focuses primarily on its physical effects[17]. In contrast, vermicompost (VC) is a high-quality organic fertilizer rich in humic acids and functional microorganisms (e.g., Pseudomonas, Streptomyces), which activates soil enzymes, pro-motes root development, and enhances halophyte stress tolerance[18-20]. Despite their individual merits, standalone use has limitations: CGSS may cause nutrient imbalances[21], while VC efficacy depends on initial soil conditions[22]. Though recent studies have explored CGSS-organic material combinations for saline soil improvement on the Loess Plateau[23], micro-scale mechanistic interactions—especially regarding soil microbial community structure and function—remain unclear.
To address these limitations, this study proposes a synergistic remediation approach through the co-application of CGSS and VC. The objectives were to evaluate their synergistic effects on saline-alkali soil and establish a practical reclamation framework. Specifically, we aimed to (i) elucidate their impacts on soil physicochemical properties and microbial communities, and (ii) quantify the enhancements in plant growth and stress resilience. We hypothesized that the co-application would improve soil physicochemical properties, optimize soil microbial community structure and enhance physiological characteristics of plants.
References
Li J ,Pu L ,Han M , et al.Soil salinization research in China: Advances and prospects[J].Journal of Geographical Sciences,2014,24(5):943-960.DOI:10.1007/s11442-014-1130-2.
Hossain M S. Present scenario of global salt affected soils, its management and importance of salinity research[J]. Interna-tional Journal of Biological Sciences, 2019, 1(1): 1-3.
3) Materials and Methods: key clarity and reproducibility issues
Figure 2 description is reversed: the text states Figure 2a shows salt content and 2b shows water, but the figure indicates the opposite (2a water content; 2b salt content). Please correct.
Response: We sincerely appreciate this valuable comment. The description for Figure 2 has been revised. For details, please refer to the text below or line 118 of the revised manuscript.
Notes:(a)water content of saline-alkali soil ;(b)Salt content of saline-alkali soil
Soil texture classification seems inconsistent with the reported particle fractions (21.1% sand, 61.7% silt, 17.2% clay), which typically corresponds to silty loam, not sandy loam.
Response: We sincerely appreciate this valuable comment. Through literature review and data comparison, the soil texture classification has been revised to loamy silt. Your feedback has helped us improve the quality of our articles, and it also reminds us to be meticulous and rigorous in our writing process. For details, please refer to the following text or lines 87-92 of the revised manuscript.
According to the World Reference Base for Soil Resources (WRB) [24-25], the soil was classified as silty loam—consistent with its mechanical composition (21.1% sand, 61.7% silt, 17.2% clay). This classification aligns with WRB criteria, where silty loam is defined by a dominant silt fraction (>50%) and subordinate sand and clay contents, matching the particle size distribution observed in the study.
Groundwater fluctuation description is unclear (“salt-accumulating seasons: 30–40 cm; dry seasons: 1.5–2.0 m”). Please clarify whether this refers to groundwater table depth, salt accumulation depth, or seasonal ranges.
Response: We sincerely appreciate this valuable comment. Based on your feedback, please supplement and complete this section. For specific details, refer to the text below or lines 96-98 of the revised draft.
The groundwater level in the salt return period was only 30–40 cm, and the average groundwater level in the salt spraying period was 1.5-2 m.
Data analysis (Section 2.6) is under-specified:
Response: We sincerely appreciate this valuable comment. Based on your feedback, positive and negative indicators have been detailed. Specific revisions are outlined below or in lines 216–224 of the revised draft.
Where: Equal weight was assigned to each indicator, and the comprehensive score was calculated as the average of membership degrees of all indicators. Equation (1) calculates membership degrees for positive directional indicators (where higher values indicate better outcomes), for example soil water content, porosity, SOM, AvP, AvN, AvK, enzyme activities (CAT, SUC, PPO, ALP), plant growth traits (height, biomass, leaf area), and microbial α-diversity indices; Equation (2) applies to negative directional indicators (where lower values are desirable), For example soil pH, EC, and plant MDA content. Here, xi denotes the measured value of indicator , while Xmin and Xmax represent the minimum and maximum values of that indicator's dataset across all treatments.
For ANOVA, specify the post-hoc test used for mean separation and whether assumptions (normality, homoscedasticity) were checked.
Response: We sincerely appreciate this valuable comment. Your feedback has made the article's expression in this section clearer and more precise, and its logical flow more coherent and straightforward. Section 2.6 regarding the analysis of variance has been revised and refined. For specific details, please refer to the text below or lines 203-209 of the revised draft.
Results showed that all data conformed to a normal distribution (Shapiro-Wilk test, p > 0.05) and exhibited homogeneous variances (Levene's test, p > 0.05), meeting the basic assumptionns of one-way analysis of variance (ANOVA). A subsequent one-way ANOVA was conducted to compare differences among treatments, with significance set at p < 0.05. Tukey’s HSD test was used for post-hoc mean separation, as it is robust for balanced sample sizes and homogeneous variances[44].
The membership function analysis is not sufficiently explained for reproducibility: please state why it was used, list the indicators included, explain how final composite scores were calculated (sum or average), and clarify whether weights were equal or different.
Response: We sincerely appreciate this valuable comment. We adopted membership function analysis for three core reasons. This study evaluated remediation efficacy across three systems (soil physicochemical properties, plant growth traits, microbial diversity), involving 20 indicators (e.g., soil pH, SOM, plant biomass, microbial Chao1 index). These indicators are mutually independent and have different dimensions, making it impossible to directly compare or synthesize. Membership function analysis effectively converts discrete indicators into normalized membership degrees (0-1), enabling comprehensive evaluation of overall remediation effects; the evaluated indicators include positive indicators (higher values = better efficacy, e.g., SOM, plant biomass, enzyme activities) and negative indicators (lower values = better efficacy, e.g., soil pH, EC, plant MDA content). Membership function analysis uses two sets of complementary formulas to standardize these indicators to a consistent evaluation scale, avoiding bias caused by conflicting indicator directions; This method is widely used in composite amendment efficacy evaluation for saline-alkali soils, as it can objectively reflect the synergistic effects of multiple amendments without being affected by indicator dimensional differences. Its rationality has been verified in similar studies, ensuring the comparability of our results with existing literature.
Positive indicators include soil water content, porosity, SOM, AvP, AvN, AvK, enzyme activities (CAT, SUC, PPO, ALP), plant growth traits (height, biomass, leaf area), and microbial α-diversity indices; Negative indicators include soil pH, EC, and plant MDA content. The comprehensive score is calculated by summing the individual scores, with each indicator assigned equal weight.
4) Results: structure, clarity, and statistics require major improvement
The Results are long, fragmented, and sometimes mix interpretation with reporting of findings. Interpretation should be reserved for the Discussion.
Response: We sincerely appreciate this valuable comment. We have revised and refined the results section. Specific changes are detailed below or in the revised manuscript at lines 227-237, 269-279, 306-326and 333-341.
Section 3.1 Content: Different soil amendment combinations effectively enhanced the physiological and biochemical indices of L. chinensis (Figure 3), with CGSS-VC co-application outperforming single amendments and T4 (CGSS: VC=1: 2) as the optimal treatment. Compared with other treatment groups, T4 treatment significantly increased leaf area (48.14%) and bio-mass (19.89%) (p<0.05). Compared with the CK group, plant height and root volume in the T4 group increased by 12.93% and 12.00%, respectively, while other treatment groups showed smaller gains. T3 and T2 treatments respectively achieved significant increases in regreening rate (70.81%) and stem diameter (44.87%) (p<0.05), and T3 also reduced MDA content by 23.78% (33.91 μmol/g, p<0.05). Although CAT, POD, and SOD activities were slightly enhanced across treatments, no significant differences were observed among groups.
Section 3.3 Content: Membership function analysis was applied to evaluate plant physio-biochemical indicators and soil parameters across treatments. For vegetation assessment, normalized values of physiological traits were calculated using membership functions (inverse calculation for malondialdehyde, MDA); for soil evaluation, key properties (water content, porosity, SOM, AP, AK, AN, and enzyme activities including PPO, CAT, SUC, ALP) were normalized with inverse functions applied to pH and EC. Higher comprehensive scores indicate superior improvement: T4 (CGSS: VC=1: 2) achieved the highest aggregate reclamation score for vegetation (8.47, Figure S2a) and integrated soil quality (8.05, Fig S2b). All amendment treatments outperformed CK, confirming the positive effects of amendments, while T4’s top scores highlight its superiority in enhancing L. chinensis physio-biochemical properties, soil fertility, physical structure, and enzyme activities.
Section 3.5 Content: Bacterial community composition differed significantly among treatments at the phylum level, with 16S rDNA sequencing identifying 38 phyla—20 of which were dominant (mean relative abundance >0.05%) (Figure 6a). Proteobacteria dominated across all samples (26.73–34.84%), with the highest relative abundance (34.84%) in T2. The ranking of major phyla by relative abundance was: Actinobacteria > Chloroflexi > Acidobacteria > Gemmatimonadetes > Bacteroidetes > Firmicutes > Rokubacteria > Cyanobacteria. Compared to amended treatments, unamended CK soils had higher relative abundances of Gemmatimonadetes, Bacteroidetes, Verrucomicrobia, Latescibacteria, Armatimonadetes, and BRC1. In contrast, CGSS-VC coamended soils showed enriched relative abundances of Actinobacteria, Firmicutes, Nitrospirae, Entotheonellaeota, Patescibacteria, and Deinococcus-Thermus compared to CK.
Redundancy analysis (RDA) was performed to explore associations between soil physicochemical properties and microbial community structure at the phylum level (Figure 6b). Axes 1 and 2 collectively explained 95.78% of total variance, with Axis 1 alone accounting for 75.68%. Soil moisture content (MC), porosity, pH, electrical conductivity (EC), soil organic matter (SOM), alkali-hydrolyzable nitrogen (AN), available phosphorus (AP), and available potassium (AK) were identified as environmental factors associated with microbial community structure. AP showed high overlap with Gemmatimonadetes in the RDA plot. The arrow representing porosity formed small angles with Firmicutes and Actinobacteria, and T1 and T5 treatments exhibited greater changes in soil porosity com-pared to other treatments.
Section 3.6 Content: Figure 7 shows the effects of soil environmental factors and plant enzyme activities on the microbial community at the phylum level. Correlation analysis revealed that soil porosity and EC were key factors shaping the microbial community. Proteobacteria, Gemmatimonadetes, and Planctomycetes were negatively correlated with porosity, whereas Patescibacteria and Actinobacteria showed a positive correlation. Acidobacteria and Chloroflexi were negatively associated with EC, while Actinobacteria increased with EC. Several phyla, including Acidobacteria and Planctomycetes, also showed significant correlations with nutrient availability (AP, AN, AK) and plant enzyme activities (ALP, CAT, SOD, MDA).
Figures are very dense (many sub-panels), and the text repeats many values. Consider summarizing key outcomes and/or moving secondary variables to Supplementary Material.
Response: We sincerely appreciate this valuable comment. Based on your feedback, we have revised and refined the content of the results analysis section. Based on your feedback, we have moved the functional charts for plants, soil, and microorganisms to the supplementary materials and revised the data presentation in the text. Please refer to the attached documents for specific details. We have adjusted Figure 5 to become Figure S2, Figure 6 to become Figure 5, Figure 7 to become Figure S3, Figure 8 to become Figure 6, and Figure 9 to become Figure 7.
Thank you for raising concerns regarding the charts in the article. Following revisions, the charts now meet the requirements and have provided valuable insights for our future work.
Statistical reporting is inconsistent: statements about “no significant differences” conflict with figure letter annotations and later claims. Please re-check ANOVA/post-hoc results and ensure text, figures, and captions agree.
Response: We sincerely appreciate this valuable comment. Based on your feedback, we have re-examined the results of the analysis of variance and post-hoc tests, and revised the main text and other relevant sections to ensure consistency. Your feedback has significantly improved our article, greatly enhancing the quality of its written expression. We will prioritize reviewing this aspect in our subsequent work to ensure such issues do not recur.
Avoid reporting broad percentage ranges across multiple variables (e.g., “47.09%–179.00%”), as this obscures which variable changed most; link each percentage to a specific variable or summarize qualitatively.
Response: We sincerely appreciate this valuable comment. Based on your feedback, revisions have been made to the results analysis section. Specific changes are detailed below or in the revised manuscript at lines 227-237, 306-316.
Section 3.1 Content: Different soil amendment combinations effectively enhanced the physiological and biochemical indices of L. chinensis (Figure 3), with CGSS-VC co-application outperforming single amendments and T4 (CGSS: VC=1: 2) as the optimal treatment. Compared with other treatment groups, T4 treatment significantly increased leaf area (48.14%) and bio-mass (19.89%) (p<0.05). Compared with the CK group, plant height and root volume in the T4 group increased by 12.93% and 12.00%, respectively, while other treatment groups showed smaller gains. T3 and T2 treatments respectively achieved significant increases in regreening rate (70.81%) and stem diameter (44.87%) (p<0.05), and T3 also reduced MDA content by 23.78% (33.91 μmol/g, p<0.05). Although CAT, POD, and SOD activities were slightly enhanced across treatments, no significant differences were observed among groups.
Section 3.5 Content: Bacterial community composition differed significantly among treatments at the phylum level, with 16S rDNA sequencing identifying 38 phyla—20 of which were dominant (mean relative abundance >0.05%) (Figure 6a). Proteobacteria dominated across all samples (26.73–34.84%), with the highest relative abundance (34.84%) in T2. The ranking of major phyla by relative abundance was: Actinobacteria > Chloroflexi > Acidobacteria > Gemmatimonadetes > Bacteroidetes > Firmicutes > Rokubacteria > Cyanobacteria. Compared to amended treatments, unamended CK soils had higher relative abundances of Gemmatimonadetes, Bacteroidetes, Verrucomicrobia, Latescibacteria, Armatimonadetes, and BRC1. In contrast, CGSS-VC co-amended soils showed enriched relative abundances of Actinobacteria, Firmicutes, Nitrospirae, Entotheonellaeota, Patescibacteria and Deinococcus-Thermus compared to CK.
Interpretation of MDA should be handled carefully: increased MDA is typically a marker of higher oxidative stress. If MDA is treated as a “negative indicator” in the membership analysis, this should be explicitly reflected in the Results narrative.
Response: We sincerely appreciate this valuable comment. The analysis of the MDA has been revised based on your feedback. Please refer to the following text or lines 227-237 of the revised draft for the specific changes.
T3 and T2 treatments respectively achieved significant increases in regreening rate (70.81%) and stem diameter (44.87%) (p<0.05), and T3 also reduced MDA content by 23.78% (33.91 μmol/g, p<0.05). Although CAT, POD, and SOD activities were slightly enhanced across treatments, no significant differences were observed among groups.
5) Discussion and Conclusions: inconsistencies and over-interpretation
There are critical inconsistencies in treatment labeling (e.g., statements implying “sole CGSS application (T2)”, while T2 is defined as VC alone in Methods). This must be corrected throughout.
Response: We sincerely appreciate this valuable comment. We have thoroughly reviewed the descriptions of T2 throughout the article and revised any erroneous sections. Specific changes are detailed below or in the revised manuscript at lines 21–22, 124–129 and 444-446.
Five treatment groups were established: CK (unamended), T1 (CGSS alone), T2 (VC alone), T3 (CGSS:VC = 1:1), T4 (CGSS:VC = 1:2), and T5 (CGSS:VC = 2:1).
A randomized block design was implemented with five treatments: T1: Sole application of coal gasification slag-based soil conditioner (CGSS) at 45,000 kg·ha⁻¹; T2: Sole ap-plication of vermicompost (VC) at 45,000 kg·ha⁻¹; T3: CGSS-VC co-application (1: 1 ratio), both applied at 22,500 kg·ha⁻¹; T4: CGSS-VC co-application (1: 2 ratio), applied at 15,000 kg·ha⁻¹ and 30,000 kg·ha⁻¹ respectively; T5: CGSS-VC co-application (2: 1 ratio), applied at 30,000 kg·ha⁻¹ and 15,000 kg·ha⁻¹ respectively, each replicated five times[26-27].
Proteobacteria dominated across all treatments (26.73–34.84%) due to their metabolic versatility in carbon, nitrogen, and phosphorus cycling, peaking at 34.84% in T2 (sole VC) as a direct response to VC-derived carbon sources[69].
Some Discussion claims are mechanistic and overly causal without direct measurements (e.g., ion fixation, dual-phase acidification, microhabitat claims). Please soften wording (“may”, “likely”, “consistent with”) or support with direct evidence.
Response: We sincerely appreciate this valuable comment. Based on your feedback, we have supplemented and refined portions of the discussion section. Specific revisions can be found in the text below or in the revised draft at lines 394-405, 420-427, 451-457 and 462-467.
4.2. Effects of Vermicompost and Coal Gasification Slag-Based Soil Conditioner Addition on Soil Physicochemical Properties:Low-molecular-weight organic acids from VC further accelerate acidic mineral dissolution in CGSS[59], extending pH buffering duration beyond single-amendment effects. SOM sequestration in T4 is driven by two synergistic mechanisms: (1) direct organic input from VC (SOM=88.57 g·kg⁻¹, Table 2), which supplies humic acids and plant residues[60]; (2) CGSS-mediated microbial regulation—15,000 kg·ha⁻¹ CGSS optimizes soil porosity (11.8% increase) and pH (reduced to 8.62), enriching functional taxa like Acidobacteria (16.9% higher than the control group) and increasing microbial richness (Chao1 increased by 21.5%) (Figure 5a, 6a). Acidobacteria promote recalcitrant organic matter stabilization[61-62], while elevated sucrase (SUC increased by 25.00%) and polyphenol oxidase (PPO in-creased by 65.33%) activities (Figure 4j, k) enhance microbial conversion of labile carbon to stable SOM[63].
However, alkaline phosphatase (ALP) activity in T4-treated plants decreased by approximately 26% compared to CK, likely because ALP responds more sensitively to soil phosphorus availability, pH, or specific microbial communities rather than being directly regulated by salinity. Future studies should further investigate the relationship between ALP activity and key processes in phosphorus cycling. Additionally, VC-derived organic acids and CGSS’s porous matrix chelate competing cations (e.g., Na⁺, Ca²⁺), modulating K⁺ leaching-fixation equilibrium to ameliorate available potassium (AK) deficiency under saline-alkali stress.
4.3. Regulatory Effects of Vermicompost and Coal Gasification Slag-Based Soil Conditioner Addition on Soil Microbial Communities:T4, by integrating CGSS’s physical improvement and VC’s organic matter supply, enriched functional phyla, including Actinobacteria (facilitates complex organic compound decomposition and organic phosphorus mineralization via extracellular enzymes[70]) and Nitrospirae (drives nitrification), while reducing oligotrophic, stress-tolerant phyla (Gemmatimonadetes, Bacteroidetes) prevalent in unamended CK soil [71]. This shift signals a transition from a survival-focused to a function-oriented microbial community, enhancing nutrient cycling efficiency.
VC optimized nutrient cycling to boost the relative abundance of these functional phyla[73], while CGSS’s porous structure shaped bacterial communities by providing aerobic microhabitats for taxa like Patescibacteria (highly positively correlated with porosity) and modulating pH to favor salt-adapted groups. Notably, Acidobacteria exhibited a strong positive correlation with AP, confirming targeted enrichment of phosphorus-cycling taxa under T4’s high-AP environment.
Discussion/Conclusions sometimes claim significance that is not supported by Results (e.g., antioxidant enzyme activities described as “significantly elevated” despite earlier non-significant statements). Align Conclusions strictly with statistical outcomes.
Response: We sincerely appreciate this valuable comment. Based on your feedback, we have revised and refined the conclusion section. Please refer to the following text or lines 478-496 of the revised draft for the specific changes.
Our study demonstrated that the co-application of VC and VC-CGSS significantly enhanced the physicochemical properties of soil and growth characteristics of plant in saline-alkali environments. The amendments improved soil physicochemical properties, with pH and EC decreasing by 1.98%-10.12% and 2.10%-48.68%, respectively, while organic matter, available phosphorus (AP), and alkali-hydrolyzable nitrogen (AN) levels in-creased, leading to enhanced soil conditions and nutrient availability. In addition, physiological performance of L. chinensis was markedly improved, such as T4 treatment leaf area increasing by 48.1%, biomass by 19.90%, plant height by 12.93%, regreening rate by 41.20%, and root volume by 12.0%. Antioxidant enzyme activities (POD, SOD, CAT) were also significantly elevated, indicating enhanced oxidative stress resistance. Soil enzyme activities (PPO, CAT, SUC) improved considerably, while microbial community composition shifted toward functionally beneficial taxa such as Proteobacteria and Actinobacteria, contributing to greater ecological functional stability. Based on a fuzzy membership function analysis, the T4 treatment (15,000 kg·ha-1 CGSS and 30,000 kg·ha-1 VC) achieved the highest integrated score, confirming its superior remediation efficacy. From an economic perspective, the application ratio of VC-CGSS at 2:1 demonstrates lower costs compared to other similar conditioners and organic fertilizers for soil improvement. Therefore, the combined application of VC-CGSS represents a resource-efficient and highly effective eco-logical restoration strategy for rehabilitating degraded saline-alkali land.
EC interpretation should be consistent with reported units and measured ranges; avoid using salinity thresholds (e.g., 8 or 15 dS m⁻¹) if they do not correspond to the study’s EC values or units are unclear.- Figure 4 looks much lower.
Response: We sincerely appreciate this valuable comment. Based on your suggestions, we have revised and refined Section 4.2 of the Discussion section and supplemented the EC data. Please refer to the following text or lines 413-425 of the revised draft for the specific content.
In the saline-alkali soil studied (initial electrical conductivity 272.76 μS·m⁻¹), the combined CGSS-VC amendment significantly reduced soil electrical conductivity through ion leaching and immobilization. The T4 treatment decreased EC by 12.00% compared to the control, effectively alleviating the inhibition of microbial metabolism caused by salt stress. Notably, the moderate reduction in EC created favorable conditions for soil nutrient cy-cling. This was reflected in the T4 treatment, where alkaline hydrolyzable nitrogen (AN) content increased significantly by 18.3% compared to the CK, indicating enhanced nitro-gen transformation processes[66-67]. However, alkaline phosphatase (ALP) activity in T4-treated plants decreased by approximately 26% compared to CK, likely because ALP responds more sensitively to soil phosphorus availability, pH, or specific microbial com-munities rather than being directly regulated by salinity. Future studies should further investigate the relationship between ALP activity and key processes in phosphorus cycling..
Typo/abbreviation error in Conclusions: “CGR” should be CGSS in the T4 dosage statement.
Response: We sincerely appreciate this valuable comment. Based on your feedback, the conclusion section has been revised and refined. Please refer to the following text or lines 490-492 of the revised draft for specific changes.
Based on a fuzzy membership function analysis, the T4 treatment (15,000 kg·ha-1 CGSS and 30,000 kg·ha-1 VC) achieved the highest integrated score, confirming its superior re-mediation efficacy.
Your feedback has been immensely helpful in clarifying the logical flow of the article. It also encourages us to take our future work more seriously.
Author Response File:
Author Response.docx
Reviewer 4 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsThe manuscript study the synergistic effects of coal gasification slag-based soil conditioner (CGSS) and vermicompost (VC) on saline-alkali soil remediation. The results suggest that 15,000 kg ha⁻¹ of CGSS and 30,000 kg ha⁻¹ of VC was the optimal remediation strategy. The study provides an effective approach for saline-alkali soil reclamation and a sustainable pathway for the resource utilization of coal-based solid waste. The topic is of interest, the experimental design is generally sound, the data presented is valuable, and the findings have clear practical applications for sustainable agriculture. Some points should be improved as following.
Line 187: It states "n = 5 biological replicates per treatment" for DNA analysis but the experimental design mentions three replications. This discrepancy must be clarified.
The data analysis of soil microbial communities should be clearly stated.
Please carefully check all numerical data and percentages in text against figures and tables for consistency. For example, Line 221, the text state that leaf area was increased by "47.09%-179.00%" compared to CK. But it’s not correct from Figure 3d. Also, Line 224, “MDA activity in T2 treatment increased significantly (p<0.05), improving by 6.77%-40.09% compared to other treatments”. But it’s not correct from Figure 3. And, "however, there were no significant differences in indicators such as pH and alkali-hydrolyzable nitrogen among treatments." This contradicts data in Figure 4d&h, which show letters indicating differences…….
Figure 3 caption: please add “and physiology” after “growth” (Line 230).
Lines 233-236: please delete “of Leymus chinensis”.
Lines 254-262: please delete “of saline alkali soil with different treatments”.
There are some grammatical errors, awkward phrasing, and typos (e.g., "physicohemical") in the text.
Author Response
Response to Reviewers’ Comments
(Note: All page numbers refer to the revised manuscript file with tracked changes)
Reviewer #4:
The manuscript study the synergistic effects of coal gasification slag-based soil conditioner (CGSS) and vermicompost (VC) on saline-alkali soil remediation. The results suggest that 15,000 kg ha⁻¹ of CGSS and 30,000 kg ha⁻¹ of VC was the optimal remediation strategy. The study provides an effective approach for saline-alkali soil reclamation and a sustainable pathway for the resource utilization of coal-based solid waste. The topic is of interest, the experimental design is generally sound, the data presented is valuable, and the findings have clear practical applications for sustainable agriculture. Some points should be improved as following.
Response: Thank you for your positive comments and valuable suggestions to improve the quality of our manuscript. We would like to express our sincere appreciations for your constructive comments. We have made extensive modifications to our manuscript and carefully checked the data to make our results convincing.
Line 187: It states "n = 5 biological replicates per treatment" for DNA analysis but the experimental design mentions three replications. This discrepancy must be clarified.
Response: We sincerely appreciate this valuable comment. Based on your suggestions, revisions have been made to the experimental design and analysis sections. Specific changes are detailed below or in the revised manuscript at lines 184-186 and 294-295.
2.5. Soil Microbial Communities:Genomic DNA was extracted from 0.25 g of homogenized composite soil samples (n = 5 biological replicates per treatment) using the PowerSoil® DNA Isolation Kit (Mo Bio Laboratories).
Figure 5. Alpha diversity of the soil microorganisms. Lowercase letters indicate whether the samples of the same index are significantly different from each other (p<0.05, n=5).
- The data analysis of soil microbial communities should be clearly stated.
Response: We sincerely appreciate this valuable comment. Based on your feedback, we have supplemented and refined the data analysis of the soil microbial community. For details, please refer to the text below or lines 295–300 of the revised manuscript.
Analysis of differences among treatments showed that the combined application of CGSS and VC effectively improved the Chao1 and Shannon indices, with the T4 treatment per-forming the best (Figure 5), Compared to CK, levels increased by 21.53% and 1.72% respectively (p<0.05). Additionally, the Simpson index in the T2 treatment group was significantly superior to other treatment groups at 0.9986, and other treatment groups also demonstrated varying degrees of improvement compared to the control group.
- Please carefully check all numerical data and percentages in text against figures and tables for consistency. For example, Line 221, the text state that leaf area was increased by "47.09%-179.00%" compared to CK. But it’s not correct from Figure 3d. Also, Line 224, “MDA activity in T2 treatment increased significantly (p<0.05), improving by 6.77%-40.09% compared to other treatments”. But it’s not correct from Figure 3. And, "however, there were no significant differences in indicators such as pH and alkali-hydrolyzable nitrogen among treatments." This contradicts data in Figure 4d&h, which show letters indicating differences…….
Response: We sincerely appreciate this valuable comment. Based on your feedback, we have reviewed and refined all data and textual analysis sections in the main body. Specific changes are detailed below or can be found in the revised draft at lines 227-237 and 254-255.
Section 3.1: Different soil amendment combinations effectively enhanced the physiological and biochemical indices of L. chinensis (Figure 3), with CGSS-VC co-application outperforming single amendments and T4 (CGSS:VC=1:2) as the optimal treatment. Compared with other treatment groups, T4 treatment significantly increased leaf area (48.14%) and biomass (19.89%) (p<0.05). Compared with the CK group, plant height and root volume in the T4 group increased by 12.93% and 12.00%, respectively, while other treatment groups showed smaller gains. T3 and T2 treatments respectively achieved significant increases in regreening rate (70.81%) and stem diameter (44.87%) (p<0.05), and T3 also reduced MDA content by 23.78% (33.91 μmol/g, p<0.05). Although CAT, POD, and SOD activities were slightly enhanced across treatments, no significant differences were observed among groups.
Section 3.2: Compared with the CK…… Meanwhile, the T1 treatment showed a 63.29% reduction com-pared to CK, reaching a level of statistical significance. …….
Thank you for your assistance in revising the article content. Your feedback has enhanced the textual expression of the piece and provided valuable experience for our future work.
- Figure 3 caption: please add “and physiology” after “growth” (Line 230).
Response: We sincerely appreciate this valuable comment. Based on your feedback, the caption for Figure 3 has been supplemented. For specific details, please refer to the text below or lines 239-241 of the revised manuscript.
Figure 3. Effects of different treatments on the growth and physiology of Leymus chinensis. Lowercase letters indicate whether the samples of the same index are significantly different from each other (p<0.05, n=5).
- Lines 233-236: please delete “of Leymus chinensis”.
Response: We sincerely appreciate this valuable comment. Based on your feedback, the relevant content has been revised. Please refer to the following text or lines 241-243 of the revised draft for specific changes.
(a)Stem diameter; (b)Plant height; (c)Biomass; (d)Leaf area; (e)Regreeningrate; (f)Root volume; (g)Catalase activity; (h)Malondialdehyde enzyme activity; (i)Peroxidase activity; (j)Superoxide dismutase activity.
- Lines 254-262: please delete “of saline alkali soil with different treatments”.
Response: We sincerely appreciate this valuable comment. Based on your feedback, the relevant content has been revised. Please refer to the following text or lines 262-266 of the revised draft for specific changes.
(a)Soil moisture content; (b)Electrical conductance (EC); (c) Soil porosity; (d) Soil pH; (e) Soil organic matter; (f) Available phosphorus (AvP); (g) Available potassium (AvK); (h) Alkaline hydrolyzable nitrogen (AvN); (i) Catalase (CAT) activity; (j) Sucrase (SUC) activity; (k) Polyphenol oxidase (PPO); (l) Alkaline phosphatase (ALP) activity.
- There are some grammatical errors, awkward phrasing, and typos (e.g., "physicohemical") in the text.
Response: We sincerely appreciate this valuable comment. Based on your feedback, we have reviewed and revised the entire text. Specific changes are detailed below or at lines 161, 249, and 299 in the revised draft.
Line 161: chromogenesis Modify to a chromogenic reaction
Line 249: Physicohemical Modify to Physicochemical
Line 299: Goods_coverage Modify to Goods-coverage
Author Response File:
Author Response.docx
Round 2
Reviewer 4 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsThe manuscript was revised according to the Reviewers’ comments. I think it can be accepted for publication in the journal. Some points should be improved as following.
Lines 191-194, the sentences are not in the correct position. It should be placed at the Line 198.
Line 249, soil enzymes belong to biological properties, not physicochemical properties. Please delete “physicochemical”.
Figure 5 caption should be placed under figure. There are not lowercase letters in the figure, so please delete the sentence “Lowercase letters indicate whether the samples of the same index are significantly different from each other (p<0.05, n=5)”.
The conclusions should be improved. Please do not repeat the results, such as Line 483, Line 487.
Please check the format of the reference lists.
Author Response
The manuscript was revised according to the Reviewers’ comments. I think it can be accepted for publication in the journal. Some points should be improved as following.
Response: Thank you for your positive comments and valuable suggestions to improve the quality of our manuscript. We would like to express our sincere appreciations for your constructive comments. We have made revisions to the aspects you raised and thoroughly reviewed the language throughout the manuscript to ensure it meets journal requirements.
1) Lines 191-194, the sentences are not in the correct position. It should be placed at the Line 198.
Response: Thank you for your positive comments and valuable suggestions to improve the quality of our manuscript. According to your suggestions, We have revised Section 2.5 of the Materials and Methods section. To ensure logical consistency throughout the manuscript, we have removed the original lines 198–199 and relocated the paragraph you mentioned to a more appropriate position. Specific revisions are detailed below or on lines 204–207 of the revised manuscript.
PCR reactions contained deoxynucleotide triphosphates (dNTPs), Mg²⁺, and high-fidelity DNA polymerase. Amplicons were purified with Agencourt AMPure® XP beads to remove primer dimers, then dissolved in Elution Buffer. Subsequent steps in-cluded end repair, A-tailing, and adapter ligation. The amplicon libraries were sequenced on an Illumina MiSeq platform using the 2×250 bp paired-end chemistry. This sequencing effort yielded an average of 60,000 high-quality reads per sample, providing sufficient depth for subsequent microbial community analysis.
2) Line 249, soil enzymes belong to biological properties, not physicochemical properties. Please delete “physicochemical”.
Response: Thank you for your valuable suggestion. According to your suggestions, we have removed the term "physicochemical" from the heading of Section 3.2. For the specific content, please refer to the text below or line 258 of the revised draft.
3.2. Soil Properties and Ecological Multifunctionality
3) Figure 5 caption should be placed under figure. There are not lowercase letters in the figure, so please delete the sentence “Lowercase letters indicate whether the samples of the same index are significantly different from each other (p<0.05, n=5)”.
Response: Thank you for your positive comments and valuable suggestions to improve the quality of our manuscript. According to your suggestions, we have removed the relevant content from Figure 5 and relocated the discussion of Figure S3 results analysis above Figure 5. This ensures Figure 5 and its caption appear on the same page, enhancing clarity for readers. For specific details, please refer to the revised manuscript at lines 204-310 and 311–314.
Figure 5. Alpha diversity of the soil microorganisms. Note: (a) Intergroup comparison of the Chao1 index; (b) Intergroup comparison of the Simpson diversity index; (c) Intergroup comparison of the Shannon diversity index; (d) Intergroup comparison of Goods-coverage.
4) The conclusions should be improved. Please do not repeat the results, such as Line 483, Line 487.
Response: Thank you for your positive comments and valuable suggestions to improve the quality of our manuscript. According to your suggestions, we have revised and refined the conclusion section of the article, removing redundant content and rephrasing it. Please refer to the text below or lines 507-513 of the revised draft for the specific changes.
Our study demonstrated that the co-application of VC and VC-CGSS significantly enhanced the physicochemical properties of soil and growth characteristics of plant in saline-alkali environments. The amendments improved soil physicochemical properties, with pH and EC decreasing by 1.98%-10.12% and 2.10%-48.68%, respectively, while organic matter, available phosphorus (AP), and alkali-hydrolyzable nitrogen (AN) levels in-creased, leading to enhanced soil conditions and nutrient availability. In addition, the physiological adaptability of L. chinensis to saline-alkali stress was substantially strengthened, as evidenced by the comprehensive improvement of key growth-related traits and stress resistance mechanisms. Specifically, core physiological indicators (including leaf development, biomass accumulation, plant elongation, re-greening capacity, and root growth) were synergistically promoted, and the enhanced activities of antioxidant enzymes (POD, SOD, CAT) further reinforced its tolerance to oxidative damage caused by saline-alkali stress. Soil enzyme activities (PPO, CAT, SUC) im-proved considerably, while microbial community composition shifted toward functionally beneficial taxa such as Proteobacteria and Actinobacteria, contributing to greater ecological functional stability. Based on a fuzzy membership function analysis, the T4 treatment (15,000 kg·ha-1 CGSS and 30,000 kg·ha-1 VC) achieved the highest integrated score, con-firming its superior remediation efficacy. From an economic perspective, the application ratio of VC-CGSS at 2:1 demonstrates lower costs compared to other similar conditioners and organic fertilizers for soil improvement. Therefore, the combined application of VC-CGSS represents a resource-efficient and highly effective ecological restoration strategy for rehabilitating degraded saline-alkali land.
Thank you once again for your assistance with our article. Your suggestions have significantly improved its quality and helped us recognize the importance of rigor and meticulousness in the writing process during revisions.
5) Please check the format of the reference lists.
Response: Thank you for your positive comments and valuable suggestions to improve the quality of our manuscript. According to your suggestions, we have revised the full text to comply with the reference format requirements of the journal Sustainability. For specific modifications, please refer to the following text or the references section of the revised draft (lines 518–708).
Additionally, we have already revised the grammatical errors in our manuscript. Please see these in our MS according to following list:
(i)Abstract: Page 1 Line 15, 17-18, 21, 23, 25-28 and 39-40.
(ii)Introduction: Page 2 Line 49-51, 59 and 79-81.
(iii)Materials and methods: Page 2 Line 88; Page 3 Line 101, 104 and 109-110; Page 5 Line 142-143 and 171; Page 6 Line 218-220.
(iv)Results: Page 7 Line 239-241; Page 9 Line 264 and 266; Page 1 Line 297, 301 and 307.
(v)Discussions: Page 13 Line 381-385; Page 15 Line 477-480, 488-493.
(vi) Conclusions: Page 15 Line 498-499 and 502; Page 16 Line 513, 518 and 520-521.
- Liu, M.; Wang, C.; Liu, X.; Lu, Y.; Wang, Y. Saline-alkali soil applied with vermicompost and humic acid fertilizer improved macroaggregate microstructure to enhance salt leaching and inhibit nitrogen losses. Appl. Soil Ecol. 2020, 156. 103705. DOI: 10.1016/j.apsoil.2020.103705.
- Du, Y.; Liu, X.; Zhang, L.; Zhou, W. Drip irrigation in agricultural saline-alkali land controls soil salinity and improves crop yield: Evidence from a global meta-analysis. Sci. Total Environ. 2023, 880163226-163226. DOI:10.1016/J.SCITOTENV.2023.163226.
- E. D. C.; M. T. D.; A. S. C.; Thandiwe N. Salinity and Sodicity: A Global Challenge to Food Security, Environmental Quality and Soil Resilience. John Wiley & Sons. Inc.: Hoboken, NJ, USA, 2024. DOI:10.1002/9780891183976.
- Chang, F.; Zhang, H.; Zhao, N.; Zhao, P; Song, J. Green manure removal with reduced nitrogen improves saline-alkali soil organic carbon storage in a wheat-green manure cropping system. Sci. Total Environ. 2024, 926171827-171827. DOI:10.1016/J.SCITOTENV.2024.171827.
- Li, J.; Pu, L.; Han, M.; Zhu, M.; Zhang, R. Soil salinization research in China: Advances and prospects. J. Geogr. Sci. 2014, 24(5):943-960. DOI:10.1007/s11442-014-1130-2.
- Xing, J.; Li, X.; Li, Z.; Wang, X.; Hou, N. Remediation of soda-saline-alkali soil through soil amendments: Microbially mediated carbon and nitrogen cycles and remediation mechanisms. Sci. Total Environ. 2024, 924171641-171641. DOI:10.1016/J.SCITOTENV.2024.171641.
- Li, J.; Pu, L.; Zhu, M.; Zhang, R. Research status and future research hotspots of soil salinization. Acta Geogr. Sin. 2012, 67(9): 1233-1245. Available online: https://kns.cnki.net/kcms2/article/abstract?v=Ow72tX7v2w25IW0w87a5WcO8hM9rrR9QOnA8gT6WLPIk99ss3TNjNQnAibnUtV6knYP4yztbL7U1MpbBk6wsNIhHuEmSO202SXDhkZW53dBMX11pLwrflzFQ2LK2hZrKW7VjEqeY7dr41xiSHYT7z63Yv0VK6zdtb18rvUPMc2lXINw74QeWbg==&uniplatform=NZKPT&language=CHS
- Yousuf, J.; Zhang, W.; Tahira, S.; Muhammad, A.; Abdullah, S.; Zulfikar, K.; Ansar, F. Utilization of sewage sludge to manage saline–alkali soil and increase crop production: Is it safe or not? Environ. Technol. Innov. 2023, 32: 103266. DOI:10.1016/J.ETI.2023.103266.
- Deng, H.; Song, Y.; Li, W.; Fatima, M.; Hamida, B.; Ye, S. Performance and economy of antibiotic adsorption by the composite of plant decomposed liquid, chemical modifier, and clay. Process Saf. Environ. Prot. 2024, 1921408-1419. DOI:10.1016/J.PSEP.2024.11.025.
- Múčka, V.; Čuba, V. Radiation sensitivity of biological systems, its modification by chemical modifiers and its quantitative evaluation. J. Radioanal. Nucl. Chem. 2024, 333(9):4443-4469. DOI:10.1007/S10967-024-09611-6.
- Yang, Z. Progress in Techniques of Improvement and Utilization of Saline-Alkali Land in China and Its Future Trend. Open J. Soil Water Conserv. 2014, 2(1): 1-11. DOI:10.12677/OJSWC.2014.21001.
- Stepanov, A.; Yakimenko, S. Humic Soil Modifiers from Peat and Coal: Effect on Chemical and Biological Properties of Model Soil Mixtures. Russ. Agric. Sci. 2024,49(Suppl 1): S174-S179. DOI:10.3103/S1068367423070212.
- China Energy Outlook 2060; Springer Nature Singapore: Singapore, 2024. DOI:10.1007/978-981-96-7647-7.
- Zhu, J.; Li, J.; Yan, L.; Shang, A.; Wang, Y.; Li, Q.; Wang, J. Research progress and application prospects of coal gasification slag resource utilization. Clean Coal Technol. 2021, 27(6): 11-21. DOI:10.13226/j.issn.1006-6772.21010301.
- Irin, J.; Hasanuzzaman, M. Organic Amendments: Enhancing Plant Tolerance to Salinity and Metal Stress for Improved Agricultural Productivity. Stresses. 2024,4(1):185-209. DOI:10.3390/STRESSES4010011.
- Zhang, K.; Liao, C.; Wang, J.; Jin, P.; Wang, K.; Xu, W. Research progress on characteristic analysis and utilization technology of coal gasification coarse slag. Clean Coal Technol. 2024, 30(7): 13-29. DOI:10.13226/j.issn.1006-6772.CPC24040202.
- Gao, H.; Liang, L.; Jin, K.; Tan, J. Review on Resource Utilization of Coal Gasification Slag. Coal Sci. Technol. 2024, 52(8): 192-208. https://link.cnki.net/urlid/11.2402.TD.20231108.1153.001
- Berhe, S.; Seid, A.; Tsegay, B.; Sato, T.; Lule, G. Effect of Charcoal on the Quality of Vermicompost Produced With Water Hyacinth and Cow Manure. Sci. World J. 2025,2025(1):1086347-1086347. DOI:10.1155/TSWJ/1086347.
- Banerjee, S.; Ghosh, S.; Jha, S.; Bhattacharyya, P. Innovative green vermi-remediation of chromite-asbestos mine waste: From toxicity reduction to soil-crop-microbe health improvement utilizing novel multimodal statistical approach. J. Environ. Chem. Eng. 2025,13(2):116019-116019. DOI:10.1016/J.JECE.2025.116019.
- Pendke, M.; Asewar, B.; Gourkhede, P.; Narkhede, W.; Abdulraheem, M.; Alghamdi, A.; Singh, C.; Abdi, G. Impact of tillage and fertilizer management on Soybean-Cotton rotation system: effects on yield, plant nutrient uptake, and soil fertility for sustainable agriculture. Sci. Rep. 2025,15(1):9991-9991. DOI:10.1038/S41598-025-95116-5.
- Tejada, M.; Garcia, C.; Gonzalez, J.; Hernandez, M. Use of organic amendment as a strategy for saline soil remediation: Influence on the physical, chemical and biological properties of soil. Soil Biol. Biochem. 2005,38(6):1413-1421.DOI:10.1016/j.soilbio.2005.10.017.
- Howell, C.; Jenkins, S.; Abbott, L.; Mickan, B. Amelioration of a saline-alkaline soil using biochar and compost: Impacts on plant growth, soil biological and chemical characteristics. Land Degrad. Dev. 2023,35(1):142-155.DOI:10.1002/LDR.4905.
- Yılmaz, F.; Kurt, S. Effect of biochar and vermicompost applications on some biological properties of soil. Toprak Bilimi Bitki Bes. Derg. 2018,(2):143-150. Available online: https://kns.cnki.net/kcms2/article/abstract?v=Ow72tX7v2w2LgMhQoV2_d27ut7RR4I5nxKwRPvgJ-ulSQt39xa6HW0OACQ9C4B4rqgyKwQlFSc138y5MRyAGYksi50yuw33coyRRG-QpQBvmR-ytebRBdRppxAtJ5Dc4I685vFLLEVI4cN59riPr6pO0cGBNC2-nNNAKcf0byeQYCEJ9Yo2_6q47Xxn4Q7yy3kXz14wIhDw1Vu04ywznzw==&uniplatform=NZKPT&language=CHS
- Nikodemus, O.; Kārkliņš, A.; Dirnēna, B.; Afanasjeva, K.; Anufrijevs, A.; Brūmelis, G.; Kasparinskis, R.; Krievāns, M.; Kukuļs, I.; Lāce, B.; et al. Soil cover on complex glacial terrain and challenges for large-scale soil mapping using the World Reference Base (WRB) classification system. Catena. 2024,245108305-108305. DOI:10.1016/J.CATENA.2024.108305.
- Sorokin, A.; Owens, P.; Láng, V.; Jiang, Z.; Michéli, E.; Krasilnikov, P. “Black soils” in the Russian Soil Classification system, the US Soil Taxonomy and the WRB: Quantitative correlation and implications for pedodiversity assessment. Catena. 2021,196. DOI:10.1016/j.catena.2020.104824.
- Ai, F.; Zhang, S.; Li, Q.; Chen, Z.; Zhang, X.; Zhao, Y.; Zhang, K. Effects of vermicompost combined with soil conditioner on soil properties of saline-alkali land and growth of Leymus chinensis ‘Zhongke’. J. Shanxi Agric. Sci. 2023, 51(5): 531-538. https://link.cnki.net/urlid/14.1113.S.20230505.1404.006
- Ai, F. Effects of Vermicompost Combined with Soil Conditioner on Soil Properties of Saline-Alkali Land and Growth of Leymus Chinensis. Master's Thesis, Yulin University, Yulin, China, 2024. Available online: https://kns.cnki.net/kcms2/article/abstract?v=Ow72tX7v2w06mPfAm-RpbwUKH0lG9pxycaj_R-bjIEt1U6a7LEAYocVk9YMjLCCp-tkj3HrdlIcyqx4dH5b4OKhc5YwnEpZBnLYu2fCUHdbg0VW32_n1FA9RqCtjEsE8ryuQHdervXkAV3O93XvvTpB8mzV1fKwrJE4O7nXU4vTXRcBt6drXGk6eOw6q33pV&uniplatform=NZKPT&language=CHS
- M., W.; Sarah, I.; Ron, H.; Mary, B.; Jason, K.; S., C. Drill and broadcast establishment methods influence interseeded cover crop performance in organic corn. Renew. Agric. Food Syst. 2020,1-9. DOI:10.1017/s174217052000006x.
- Yongde, H. Determination and calculation of soil permeability coefficient. Trans. Chin. Soc. Agric. Eng. 2011,27(5):68-72. Available online: https://kns.cnki.net/kcms2/article/abstract?v=Ow72tX7v2w13yitl_EA3oLgnT9Cco15kIX8Y4iXA1cUS4BDQuf337j1xm8nuj-EcbohU8U6BotbgjJnT5NUZSjwdwelypObNzlBr9V0rpsOfpniowLtG6F6BVwg65Ltc-a8JCrZPtp-0Nz8Ib8vvILyxnsKVe4pB2YVdAyKug8GWKC4c383ihvw1vnJloZf1raxLqn8hL1-qWIuurUlRnw==&uniplatform=NZKPT&language=CHS
- Li, Y.; Yang, X.; Yang, G.; Lin, Y.; Ye, M. Characteristics of Shallow Moisture Changes in Unsaturated Soil Slopes Covered with Vegetation under Different Rainfall Rates. J. Hydrol. Eng. 2025,30(3): DOI:10.1061/JHYEFF.HEENG-6428.
- Caselles, L.; Balsamo, B.; Trincal, V.; Benavent, V.; Bertin, M.; Lahalle, H.; Samson, G.; Cyr, M. Carbonation of alkali-activated materials: changes in mineralogical composition and pH, and qualitative estimation of corrosion risk. Mater. Struct. 2025,58(4):112-112. DOI:10.1617/S11527-025-02640-X.
- Jarosz, R.; Kowalska, J.; Gondek, K.; Bejger, R.; Mielnik, L.; Lahori, A.; Hersztek, M.; The Effect of New Zeolite Composites from Fly Ashes Mixed with Leonardite and Lignite in Enhancing Soil Organic Matter. Agriculture. 2025,15(7):786-786. DOI:10.3390/AGRICULTURE15070786.
- Irshad, S.; Soukup, K.; Klusoň, P.; Frouz, J. The effect of clay minerals, litter quality, and earthworms on soil organic matter storage; clay macro-porosity is more important than surface area. Catena. 2025,252108872-108872. DOI:10.1016/J.CATENA.2025.108872.
- Ghosh, S.; Banerjee, S.; Basak, K.; Prajapati, J.; Majumder, S.; Bhattacharyya, P. Identifying an Appropriate Extractant for Assessing the Presence of Available Potassium in Soils with High Mica Content: A Comprehensive Statistical Analysis. Commun. Soil Sci. Plant Anal. 2025,56(8):1145-1161. DOI:10.1080/00103624.2025.2452162.
- Sudadi; Maro’ah, S.; Minardi, S.; Imawati, F. Efficient use of biochar and biofilm biofertilizer to enhance available phosphorus and increase yield of black soybeans in peat soil. IOP Conf. Ser.: Earth Environ. Sci. 2025,1463(1):012009-012009. DOI:10.1088/1755-1315/1463/1/012009.
- Yang, Q; Sun, Y.; Wang, H.; Pan, H.; Lou, Y.; Zhuge, Y. Research Progress and Prospects of Saline-Alkali Land Improvement and Comprehensive Utilization Technology. J. Shandong Agric. Univ. (Nat. Sci.). 2025, 56(3): 384-395. Available online: https://kns.cnki.net/kcms2/article/abstract?v=Ow72tX7v2w02XraaLDhcU4QPgseVOhoHkUnvFTsu3-W8a0bgQy4t6TmFSnmbcko9lvy2yUmG77mMvwlbuU0EzJ3p6TVViC1tITBCrWn25tka-IKGF_K9KA5hMpPe-emVpCdspc_EVN8w37s4gFunaPVEUfVPzVI0izWyTsVCM3u99BSmmElIWJLJoyJffSlk&uniplatform=NZKPT&language=CHS
- Xie, Y.; Gu, Y.; Li, Z.; Zhang, L.; Hei, y. Effects of exercise on different antioxidant enzymes and related indicators: a systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials. Sci. Rep. 2025,15(1):12518-12518. DOI:10.1038/S41598-025-97101-4.
- Chen, Y.; Zuo, M.; Yang, D.; He, Y.; Wang, H.; Liu, X.; Zhao, m.; Xu, L.; et al. Synergistically Effect of Heavy Metal Resistant Bacteria and Plants on Remediation of Soil Heavy Metal Pollution. Water Air Soil Pollut. 2024,235(5):DOI:10.1007/S11270-024-07100-W.
- Zhu, W.; Hu, M.; Su, G.; Jiang, W.; Du, H.; Chen, K.; Nie, J.; Zhang, L.; Tang, X.; Zhang, Y. Nanoprobe-free nanosensor with Tyndall-effect readout for colorimetric detection of alkaline phosphatase. Microchem. J. 2025,212113295-113295. DOI:10.1016/J.MICROC.2025.113295.
- Chang, X.; Wang, Q.; Dong, T.; Feng, Y. The role of chicory furaneol in reducing potato browning: Inhibiting polyphenol oxidase activity and enhancing antioxidant capacity. Postharvest Biol. Technol. 2025,224113484-113484. DOI:10.1016/J.POSTHARVBIO.2025.113484.
- Turan, F.; Yağci, E. The Effect of Sunflower Seed Priming in Reducing Drought Stress on Antioxidant and Morphological Characteristics During the Germination Stage. J. Plant Growth Regul. 2025,44(8):1-12. DOI:10.1007/S00344-025-11703-W.
- Behtash, F.; Ramezani, R.; Hajizadeh, H.; Eghlima, G. Optimum concentrations of potassium and zinc for better performance, nutritional, and biochemical quality of hydroponically cultivated Spinacia oleracea Cv. Virofly. Sci. Rep. 2025,15(1):12845-12845. DOI:10.1038/S41598-025-96911-W.
- Abdelhameed, R.; Abdalla, H.; Hegazy, H.; Adarosy, M. Interpreting the potential of biogenic TiO₂ nanoparticles on enhancing soybean resilience to salinity via maintaining ion homeostasis and minimizing malondialdehyde. Sci. Rep. 2025,15(1):12904-12904. DOI:10.1038/S41598-025-94421-3.
- Anderson, M.; Gorley, R.; Terlizzi, A. The incremental progression from fixed to random factors in the analysis of variance: a new synthesis. Aust. N. Z. J. Stat. 2025,67(1):3-30.DOI:10.1111/ANZS.70001.
- Sun, Y.; Meng, W.; Wang, F.; Song, Y.; Sui, M. Plant Diversity Characteristics and Environmental Interpretation Under the Land–Sea Gradient in the Yellow River Delta. Appl. Sci. 2025,15(7):4030-4030. DOI:10.3390/APP15074030.
- Pan, C.; Hu, X.; Chen, X.; Chang, Z.; Smagghe, G.; Long, J. Effects of different pollination treatments on the fertilization physiology and fruit production in passion fruit. Sci. Hortic. 2025,343114070-114070. DOI:10.1016/J.SCIENTA.2025.114070.
- Sun, X.; Wang, J.; Hua, D. Research Progress of the Salt Barrier in Saline Alkali Land. E3S Web Conf. 2022,33801041-01041. DOI:10.1051/E3SCONF/202233801041.
- Tang, J.; Zhao, Y.; Qu, D.; Sun, L. Contributions of biochar to mitigating soil salinization and exploration of its mechanisms. Acta Agric. Boreali-Occident. Sin. 2017, 26(2): 294-303.
- Zhu, W.; Gu, S.; Jiang, R.; Zhang, X.; Hatano, R. Saline–Alkali Soil Reclamation Contributes to Soil Health Improvement in China. Agriculture. 2024,14(8):1210-1210. DOI:10.3390/AGRICULTURE14081210.
- Rezapour, S.; Asadzadeh, F.; Barin, M.; Nouri, A. Organic amendments improved the chemical–nutritional quality of saline-sodic soils. Int. J. Environ. Sci. Technol. 2021,19(6):1-14. DOI:10.1007/S13762-021-03599-2.
- Li, S.; Wang, C.; Huang, H.; Zhao, L.; Cao, J.; Wang, B. Vermicompost and flue gas desulfurization gypsum addition to saline-alkali soil decreases nitrogen losses and enhances nitrogen storage capacity by lowering sodium concentration and alkalinity. J. Environ. Manage. 2024,368122156. DOI:10.1016/J.JENVMAN.2024.122156.
- Ai, F.; He, L.; Li, Q.; Li, B.; Zhang, K.; Yang, H.; Zhang, C. Vermicompost Combined with Soil Conditioner Improves the Ecosystem Multifunctionality in Saline-Alkali Land. Water. 2023, 15(17):17. DOI:10.3390/w15173075.
- Shao, T.; Gu, X.; Zhu, T.; Pan, X.; Zhu, Y.; Long, X.; Shao, H.; Liu, M.; Rengel, Z. Industrial crop Jerusalem artichoke restored coastal saline soil quality by reducing salt and increasing diversity of bacterial community. Appl. Soil Ecol. 2019,138195-206. DOI:10.1016/j.apsoil.2019.03.003.
- Sun, W.; Li, Q.; Qiao, B.; Jia, K.; Li, C.; Zhao, C.; Advances in Plant–Soil Feedback Driven by Root Exudates in Forest Ecosystems. Forests. 2024,15(3): DOI:10.3390/F15030515.
- T, D.; W, M.; A, D.; A, M.; M, K. Avoiding the point of no return: Maintaining infiltration to remediate saline-sodic Vertosols in high rainfall environments. Agric. Water Manage. 2022,270. DOI:10.1016/J.AGWAT.2022.107725.
- Otalvaro, I.; Neto, M.; Delage, P.; Caicedo, B. Relationship between soil structure and water retention properties in a residual compacted soil. Eng. Geol. 2016,20573-80. DOI:10.1016/j.enggeo.2016.02.016.
- Kateryna, Z.; Raquel, D.; Dörr, D.; Austin, D.; O, C.; M, C.; P, M.; R, H.; W, T.; Soil pH determines microbial diversity and composition in the park grass experiment. Microb. Ecol. 2015,69(2):395-406. DOI:10.1007/s00248-014-0530-2.
- Salar, R.; Amin, N.; Farrokh, A.; Mohsen, B.; Günay, E.; Sindhu, J.; Qin, R. Combining chemical and organic treatments enhance remediation performance and soil health in saline-sodic soils. Commun. Earth Environ. 2023,4(1): DOI:10.1038/S43247-023-00948-6.
- Li, S.; Wang, C.; Huang, H.; Zhao, L.; Cao, J.; Liu, M.; Vermicompost and Azotobacter chroococcum amendment of saline-alkali soil decreases nitrogen loss and increases nitrogen uptake confirmed by ZmNRT1.1B of maize. Appl. Soil Ecol. 2025,210106062-106062. DOI:10.1016/J.APSOIL.2025.106062.
- Kögel-Knabner, I. The macromolecular organic composition of plant and microbial residues as inputs to soil organic matter: Fourteen years on. Soil Biol. Biochem. 2017,105A3-A8. DOI:10.1016/j.soilbio.2016.08.011.
- Miyashita, N. Contrasting soil bacterial community structure between the phyla Acidobacteria and Proteobacteria in tropical Southeast Asian and temperate Japanese forests. Genes Genet. Syst. 2015,90(2):61-77. DOI:10.1266/ggs.90.61.
- Zhu, B.; Whalen, J.; Wu, J.; Yang, J.; Mao, X.; Wan, B.; Tian, S.; Hu, F.; Chen, X.; Liu, M.; Soil food web structure coordinated by soil omnivores sustains soil multifunctionality in moderate vermicompost amended fields. Soil Biol. Biochem. 2024,192109391-. DOI:10.1016/J.SOILBIO.2024.109391.
- Soria, R.; Rosa, J.; Pérez, J.; Bastida, F.; Ortega, R.; Miralles, I. Assessing organic amendments for improving SOM dynamics and microbial functioning in degraded quarry soils. Environ. Technol. Innov. 2025,39104323-104323. DOI:10.1016/J.ETI.2025.104323.
- Tong, R.; Ji, B.; Geoff, W.; Lou, C.; Ma, C.; Zhu, N.; Yuan, W.; Wu, T. Canopy gap impacts on soil organic carbon and nutrient dynamic: a meta-analysis. Ann. For. Sci. 2024,81(1): DOI:10.1186/S13595-024-01224-Z.
- Ju, J.; Gu, Q.; Zhou, H.; Zhang, H.; Mao, W.; Yang, H.; Mi, W.; Zhao, H. Effects of Organic Fertilizer Combined with Chemical Fertilizer on Nutrients, Enzyme Activities, and Rice Yield in Reclaimed Soil. Commun. Soil Sci. Plant Anal. 2022,53(22):3060-3071. DOI:10.1080/00103624.2022.2101661.
- Rocabruna, P.; Domene, X.; Matteazzi, A.; Figl, U.; Fundneider, A.; Martínez, M.; Venir, E.; Robatscher, P.; et al. Effect of organic fertilisation on soil phosphatase activity, phosphorus availability and forage yield in mountain permanent meadows. Agric. Ecosyst. Environ. 2024,368109006-. DOI:10.1016/J.AGEE.2024.109006.
- Lu, L.; Tong, C.; Liu, Y.; Yang, W. Analysis of Physicochemical Properties, Enzyme Activity, Microbial Diversity in Rhizosphere Soil of Coconut (Cocos nucifera L.) Under Organic and Chemical Fertilizers, Irrigation Conditions. Agriculture. 2024,14(11):1937-1937. DOI:10.3390/AGRICULTURE14111937.
- P, B.; R, R. A meta-analysis of the effect of organic and mineral fertilizers on soil microbial diversity. Appl. Soil Ecol. 2022,175. DOI:10.1016/J.APSOIL.2022.104450.
- Laurent, P.; M, R.; Philippe, L.; H, V. Going back to the roots: the microbial ecology of the rhizosphere. Nat. Rev. Microbiol. 2013,11(11):789-99. DOI:10.1038/nrmicro3109.
- Cantero, J.; López, A.; Recena, R.; Quintero, J.; Delgado, A.; Recycling Manure as Vermicompost: Assessing Phosphorus Fertilizer Efficiency and Effects on Soil Health Under Different Soil Management. J. Soil Sci. Plant Nutr. 2025,25(2):1-16. DOI:10.1007/S42729-025-02446-4.
- Qin, T.; Takeshi, T.; Shi, W.; Li, G.; Norikazu, Y.; Du, S. Land-use types and soil chemical properties influence soil microbial communities in the semiarid Loess Plateau region in China. Sci. Rep. 2017,7(1-4):45289. DOI:10.1038/srep45289.
- Xiao, W.; Lin, G.; He, X.; Yang, Z.; Wang, L. Interactions among heavy metal bioaccessibility, soil properties and microbial community in phyto-remediated soils nearby an abandoned realgar mine. Chemosphere. 2022,286(P1):131638-131638. DOI:10.1016/J.CHEMOSPHERE.2021.131638.
- Geng, M.; Wang, X.; Liu, X.; Lv, P.; Effects of Grazing Exclusion on Microbial Community Diversity and Soil Metabolism in Desert Grasslands. Sustainability. 2023,15(14): DOI:10.3390/SU151411263.
Author Response File:
Author Response.docx