Abstract
Background: Patient-centred decision-making is a central component of high-quality healthcare. In managerial practice, it requires balancing patients’ needs with organisational constraints and sustainability. Understanding how nurse managers navigate this balance may inform strategies that support both care quality and organisational performance. Objectives: To explore key barriers and facilitators influencing patient-centred managerial decision-making among middle nurse managers (MNMs) in hospital settings. Methods: A qualitative descriptive study was used. Semi-structured interviews were conducted with 38 MNMs across three Italian hospitals between January and March 2026. Data were analyzed using inductive content analysis based on the framework developed by Elo and Kyngäs. Results: Participants described patient-centred managerial decision-making as being shaped by complex barriers and facilitators. Barriers included emotional accountability, institutional constraints, time pressures, and organisational instability, which were perceived as limiting managerial autonomy and opportunities for reflection. Facilitators, such as multidisciplinary collaboration, shared decision-making, professional experience, and organisational coherence, were described as supporting the feasibility and contextual relevance of decisions. Together, these factors were perceived as helping MNMs translate patient-centred principles into operational decisions. Conclusions: The findings suggest that patient-centred managerial decision-making is a dynamic, context-dependent process embedded within organisational systems. Structural constraints and enabling factors may have implications for nursing leadership and managerial practice, but further research is needed to determine whether modifying these factors improves PCMDM or patient outcomes.
1. Introduction
Patient-centred care (PCC) requires more than respectful interactions between patients and healthcare professionals [1,2,3,4]. In this study, PCC is understood as care that respects and responds to patients’ individual needs, preferences and values, and involves them as partners in their care [5]. The implementation of PCC also depends on organisational decisions concerning staffing, resource allocation, workflow design and service priorities [6,7,8,9]. These decisions can either enable or constrain professionals’ ability to respond to patients’ needs, values and preferences [6,7,8,9].
Embedding PCC within managerial practice is nevertheless challenging. Healthcare organisations operate under simultaneous clinical, financial and workforce pressures, requiring managers to reconcile patient-related priorities with limited resources, institutional requirements and competing organisational demands [7,8,10,11,12,13]. Consequently, patient-centred managerial decision-making cannot be understood solely as an expression of individual commitment. It must also be considered in relation to the broader organisational and professional context in which managerial decisions are made [6,7,8,9]. Middle nurse managers (MNMs) are particularly exposed to these tensions. Positioned between executive leadership and frontline clinical teams, they translate strategic priorities into operational decisions concerning staffing, care organisation, resource use and service delivery [14,15,16]. Their decisions may substantially affect patients’ experiences, although their influence is often indirect and exercised through the organisational conditions created for nursing care [6,9].
Our previous qualitative study explored patient-centred managerial decision-making (PCMDM) as a distinct aspect of managerial practice and identified the dimensions that MNMs consider essential when attempting to place patients’ interests at the centre of organisational decisions [17]. That study clarified what PCMDM means from the perspective of MNMs: PCMDM refers to the process through which MNMs take patients’ needs, preferences and values into account when making managerial decisions that shape care organisation and delivery [17]. It is related to, but distinct from: clinical decision-making, which concerns decisions about an individual patient’s care; care management, which concerns the coordination and administration of care; and patient-centred or transformational leadership, which refer to leadership orientations or behaviours. These approaches may support PCMDM, but PCMDM focuses specifically on the patient-centred orientation of managerial decisions.
The present study represents a complementary second phase of the broader research project [17], involving the same 38 MNMs through a new round of interviews focused specifically on the barriers and facilitators influencing PCMDM in everyday managerial practice. These interviews generated separate recordings and transcripts that were analysed independently; no qualitative data from the previous study were reused. Whereas the previous study examined how MNMs defined PCMDM and identified its broad underlying dimensions, the present study focused specifically on the barriers and facilitators influencing its enactment in everyday managerial practice. Although both publications originate from the same research programme and involve the same participants, they address distinct research questions and draw on separate datasets. The present study extends the previous conceptual exploration by examining the specific conditions that MNMs perceive as enabling or constraining the application of PCMDM in practice, rather than repeating or reanalysing the findings of the first phase.
The present study is conceptually informed by McCance and McCormack’s Person-centred Nursing Framework (PCNF), which describes person-centred nursing in relation to staff prerequisites, the care environment, person-centred processes and outcomes [18]. Although the PCNF was not developed specifically to explain PCMDM, it provides a contextual reference for considering how the environment in which care is organised may support or constrain person-centred practice. It is used as a conceptual lens, not as a predetermined set of factors or an analytical coding structure.
Previous research has examined nurse middle managers’ contributions to PCC in hospital practice [9], managers’ perspectives on PCC implementation challenges in an oncology setting [6], and nurse managers’ decision-making competencies more broadly [16]. These studies provide relevant but partly distinct insights into managerial practice, PCC, and decision-making. However, limited evidence explains how MNMs experience and navigate the conditions that facilitate or hinder the integration of patient-centred values into their everyday managerial decisions. This is the specific gap addressed by the present study.
The present study, therefore, explores how MNMs describe the factors that facilitate or hinder PCMDM in healthcare organisations. Understanding these enabling and constraining conditions may help healthcare organisations move from the normative endorsement of PCC to its practical integration within managerial processes. It may also inform leadership development, governance arrangements and organisational interventions designed to support patient-centred nursing management.
Aim
This study aimed to explore how middle nurse managers experience and understand the factors that facilitate or hinder patient-centred managerial decision-making in healthcare organisations.
2. Materials and Methods
2.1. Design
This study adopted a qualitative descriptive design to describe the factors that MNMs experienced as facilitating or hindering PCMDM, while remaining close to their accounts [19,20]. This design was selected because the aim was to provide a comprehensive description of these factors. Unlike grounded theory, which focuses on the development of a theory, or phenomenology, which is dedicated to exploring the meaning of lived experience primarily, the analysis of this study focused on identifying and describing patterns across participants’ narrations. Consistent with this design, semi-structured interviews elicited participants’ accounts, which were analysed inductively using content analysis [21]. Reporting followed the Consolidated Criteria for Reporting Qualitative Research (COREQ) guidelines to support transparency and completeness; the completed checklist is provided in Supplementary File S1.
2.2. Setting and Participants
This study was conducted in three hospitals, two private and one public, located in central Italy. A purposive sampling strategy targeted MNMs with direct experience in managerial decision-making affecting patient care processes in inpatient and outpatient settings. The research team invited by email the same pool of 45 eligible MNMs identified during the previous research phase [17]. The same 38 MNMs who had participated previously agreed to participate again; the remaining seven did not respond.
The Directors of Nursing had facilitated the initial identification of potentially eligible participants according to predefined criteria but were not contacted again for the present phase. They had no involvement in invitations, consent, data collection or analysis, were not informed of participation decisions, and had no access to interview schedules or study data. Participants were explicitly assured that their responses would remain confidential and would not be shared with organisational leadership.
Invitations for the interview were sent by a member of the research team who did not work with participants. The invitation included information about the study aim, the voluntary nature of participation, the procedures for data collection and the role of the researchers. Potential participants were informed that their decision to participate or decline would have no professional or employment-related consequences. Written informed consent was obtained before data collection. No detailed information about the researchers’ personal motivations or assumptions was provided. Fifteen of the 38 participants were professionally known to the interviewers because they worked in the same hospitals. No direct hierarchical, supervisory, or evaluative relationship existed between the interviewers and the participants. The remaining 23 participants had no prior professional relationship with the interviewers.
2.3. Inclusion and Exclusion Criteria
Participants were included if they held an MNM position, including interim coordination roles, for at least one year; were employed within the organisation on a stable contractual basis; and were fluent in Italian. To be included, they also had to be directly involved in managerial decision-making affecting patient care processes and provide written informed consent.
Participants were excluded if they had less than one year of experience in the role, had recently returned to work following a prolonged absence, or were working in positions distant from direct patient care, such as primarily administrative roles. Those who did not provide written informed consent were also excluded.
2.4. Data Collection
This study represents the second phase of the broader research project [17]. The first phase, conducted between April 2025 and July 2025, explored how MNMs understood and conceptualised PCMDM, using an interview guide focused on its meaning, translation into managerial practice and the dimensions considered relevant to decision-making. In contrast, the second phase specifically investigated the barriers and facilitators influencing the enactment of PCMDM. Supplementary File S2 provides a comparative overview of the two phases, highlighting differences in research aims, questions, interview guides, data collection procedures, and analytical focus.
A second and distinct round of semi-structured interviews was conducted between January and March 2026. The same 38 MNMs who had participated previously agreed to participate again, and written informed consent was obtained before the new interviews. A new interview guide was developed specifically to explore the facilitators and barriers experienced by MNMs when enacting PCMDM. The interviews generated new audio recordings, field notes and transcripts; no recordings, transcripts or coded data from the first phase were included in the present analysis. Most interviews were carried out face-to-face; however, due to the geographical distance of some districts, eight interviews were conducted via Microsoft Teams. Both face-to-face and online interviews were conducted during the same data collection period and followed the same interview guide, ensuring consistency across modes of data collection. All interviews were scheduled at a time convenient for participants and took place in a quiet and private setting to ensure confidentiality and facilitate open dialogue. Interviews lasted between 40 and 60 min.
Data collection and analysis proceeded concurrently and iteratively, with emerging findings informing the assessment of informational redundancy. Following completion of the interviews at each participating hospital, the research team met to discuss the interviews collected, review emerging codes and categories, and assess whether additional interviews were generating new information relevant to the research question. These site-by-site meetings enabled informational redundancy to be assessed cumulatively across settings. Informational redundancy was considered to have been reached after the 30th interview, when additional interviews no longer generated substantively new codes or meaningful variations in the developing categories related to facilitators and barriers to PCMDM [22]. The remaining eight interviews were completed as planned and confirmed the previously identified categories without providing substantively new information. Separate thresholds for informational redundancy were not established for individual hospitals or organisational types, as the study was not designed as a comparative analysis of public and private settings.
Two researchers were present during each interview. One acted as the primary interviewer, while the second supported the interview process and recorded observational notes. All interviews were audio-recorded with participants’ consent and subsequently transcribed verbatim. Field notes were taken during and immediately after each interview to capture contextual elements, interactional aspects, and preliminary analytical reflections. The interview guide (Table 1) explored facilitators and barriers to PCMDM in MNMs daily work. Open-ended questions were used to elicit in-depth narratives and to encourage participants to describe their experiences freely, without being constrained by predefined response options.
Table 1.
Semi-structured interview guide.
The interview guide was developed by the research team in relation to the study aim, the findings of the previous phase [17], and relevant literature. It began with a broad question about factors facilitating or hindering PCMDM and included more focused open-ended questions on personal and professional, organisational and contextual factors, leadership, and communication. These areas ensured that topics relevant to the research question were explored. The open-ended format allowed participants to describe their experiences in their own terms. In the analysis, coding began with the current interview transcripts and proceeded inductively; neither the categories identified in the previous phase nor the topics included in the interview guide were used as predefined coding categories or as an a priori codebook.
2.5. Data Analysis
Data were analysed using an inductive content analysis according to Elo and Kyngäs methodology [21]. The analysis proceeded through a recursive process of moving between the transcripts, codes, categories, and higher levels of abstraction. In the first phase, all transcripts were read and re-read several times to achieve immersion in the data, and open coding was undertaken to identify meaningful units related to facilitators and barriers influencing PCMDM. In the second phase, codes were compared and grouped based on similarities and differences, generating categories and broader themes that reflected emotional, personal, organisational, relational and contextual influences. In the third phase, themes were further interpreted and clustered into overarching themes that captured the main patterns shaping PCMDM across participants’ accounts.
Coding was conducted in the original Italian language to preserve contextual meanings and linguistic nuance. Once the analytical structure had been finalised, the themes, overarching themes and illustrative quotations were translated into English for reporting purposes. The translated quotations were subsequently checked against the original Italian transcripts to ensure conceptual and linguistic fidelity. Coding was undertaken independently by two researchers, with discrepancies discussed until consensus was reached. A third researcher reviewed the final coding structure, including the relationships between codes, categories, themes and overarching themes, to ensure coherence, consistency and grounding in the data. Regular meetings within the research team supported the progressive refinement of the emerging analytical structure throughout the process. Data were organised and managed using Microsoft Excel (Microsoft Corporation, Redmond, WA, USA).
2.6. Rigour and Reflexivity
To ensure scientific rigour, this study followed the criteria proposed by Lincoln & Guba [23,24], in terms of credibility, dependability, confirmability and transferability. Credibility was supported through sustained engagement with the data, repeated reading of the transcripts and independent coding by two researchers, followed by reflexive discussions to compare interpretations and refine the emerging analytical structure. The research team reflected as well on how prior professional familiarity might influence the interpretation of participants’ narrations. During analytical discussions, research team members questioned assumptions arising from shared institutional knowledge and checked interpretations against the interview transcripts, distinguishing participants’ explicit statements from researchers’ contextual assumptions. Alternative interpretations that challenged the developing categories were discussed to ensure that findings remained grounded in participants’ perspectives. This process supported a careful interpretation of the facilitators and barriers influencing PCMDM across emotional, personal, organisational, relational and contextual dimensions. Dependability was enhanced by maintaining a transparent and systematic audit trail throughout the study, including documentation of coding decisions, category development and progressive abstraction into overarching themes. Confirmability was strengthened through the independent review of the coding structure, categories, themes, and overarching themes by a third researcher who was not involved in the initial coding process, thereby supporting coherence between the findings and the original data. Transferability was facilitated by providing rich descriptions of the study setting, participant characteristics, data collection procedures and analytic process, enabling readers to assess the relevance of the findings to other hospital and managerial contexts.
The research team included nurses with experience in clinical practice, healthcare management and qualitative research. This positioning enabled a nuanced understanding of the organisational and relational dynamics underlying PCMDM. However, the researchers acknowledged that their professional background and familiarity with the healthcare context could shape data interpretation. To address this, reflexivity was maintained throughout the study by engaging in ongoing critical reflection, team-based discussions, and comparison of interpretations during data analysis. Additionally, 10 participants were individually identified by the research team through purposive selection to represent different professional experiences within the study sample. Each participant received a summary table presenting the preliminary analytical structure, including the codes, categories, themes, and overarching themes. Feedback was collected exclusively during a subsequent group meeting. During this meeting, participants were invited to discuss whether the analytical structure accurately reflected their experiences and perspectives. Their feedback confirmed the relevance and accuracy of the findings, and no discrepancies or additional insights requiring changes to the analytical structure were identified. Therefore, no modifications to the codes, categories, themes, or overarching themes were considered necessary following this member-checking process. Member checking had not been conducted during the first phase due to feasibility constraints related to the organisational context, as reported in the previous publication [17]. Greater participant availability during the second phase subsequently made it possible to organise a group meeting for member checking. This procedure focused exclusively on the preliminary findings derived from the second dataset and did not involve retrospective validation of the findings reported in the previous publication.
2.7. Ethical Considerations
Participants were informed about the study and provided written informed consent prior to participation. Confidentiality, privacy, and anonymity were ensured throughout the research process. All personal identifiers were removed from the interview transcripts, which were labelled using numerical codes (e.g., Participant 1, Participant 2, Participant 3), corresponding to the chronological order of the interviews. Audio recordings were deleted after transcription, and all study materials were stored securely with access restricted to the research team. The study was conducted in accordance with the Declaration of Helsinki [25] and approved by the local Ethics Committee (95.24CET2 cbm, 11 April 2024). The original research protocol approved by the Ethics Committee encompassed both phases of the research programme, including the subsequent round of interviews with the same MNMs. Therefore, the second phase was conducted under the original ethical approval, without requiring protocol amendments, as the relevant data collection procedures had already been included in the approved protocol.
3. Results
3.1. Sample Characteristics
A total of 38 middle nurse managers were included in the study after providing informed consent. Their mean age was 50 years (SD 7.3; range 37–62). Most participants were women (78.9%), and more than half had over 10 years of managerial experience (52.6%). Most had undertaken advanced postgraduate education in healthcare management, including a Level I postgraduate master’s degree (60.5%). Participants were drawn from a variety of hospital departments. A detailed overview of participants’ demographic and professional characteristics is presented in Table 2.
Table 2.
Professional and demographic characteristics of the sample (n = 38).
3.2. Findings of the Qualitative Study
Inductive content analysis produced two overarching themes reflecting the factors that hindered or supported PCMDM. Barriers were organised into two themes, namely “individual barriers” and “organisational barriers”. Facilitators were organised into three themes, including “consultation with others”, “competence and experience”, and “knowledge of the patient and organisational context”. Across these themes, several categories and codes were identified, reflecting the multidimensional nature of PCMDM (Table 3). The “coded excerpts (n)” column indicates the total number of excerpts assigned to each code across all interview transcripts. As the same participant could contribute more than one excerpt to a given code, these counts do not represent the number or proportion of participants. They are reported to describe the volume of quotations included in each code across the dataset and were not used to determine the prevalence or conceptual importance of the findings.
Table 3.
The structure of the findings.
3.2.1. Overarching Theme 1: Barriers to PCMDM
This overarching theme presents the barriers that constrained the enactment of PCMDM. Two themes were identified as “Individual barriers” and “Organisational barriers”. Table 3 presents the full structure of the barriers to PCMDM, including themes, categories and associated codes.
Individual Barriers
Emotional factors emerged as barriers to PCMDM, including fear of making mistakes and empathic involvement with patients. Participants described decision-making as closely linked to personal responsibility, particularly when decisions could affect patient safety. This sense of responsibility was accompanied by fear of making mistakes, especially when an incorrect decision was perceived as having direct consequences for patients: “The fear of making a wrong decision is always there… I give an order, but I keep it under control minute by minute” (participant 1). Patient safety was described as a central concern shaping managerial decisions: “Patient safety is paramount… you must avoid errors along the way because in the operating room, a mistake is a disaster” (participant 13). Participants also described the emotional weight associated with responsibility for patient outcomes: “The responsibility is great… because if you make a mistake, the patient pays the consequences” (participant 4). For some participants, the seriousness of decisions was linked to the vulnerability of patients and the potential impact of managerial choices: “When you’re dealing with lives… you can’t be superficial” (participant 10). The emotional factors were described as barriers when responsibility, fear of error, and empathic involvement increased the psychological burden of decision-making and made patient-centred choices more difficult to manage.
Personal factors, including personal biography and value system, personal life difficulties, and high cognitive load, were identified as factors influencing PCMDM, primarily as barriers.
Participants described decision-making as shaped by the personal context of the manager, including individual values, previous experiences, stress and mental workload. Some participants emphasised that managerial decisions could not be completely separated from the decision-maker’s personal situation: “There is no decision that is not influenced by the manager’s personal factors as problems outside and overload” (participant 11). High cognitive load was described as affecting the clarity and management of decisions, particularly when several issues occurred simultaneously: “Making decisions is difficult… we can have our minds occupied by 3500 problems” (participant 14). This pressure was particularly evident in high-intensity clinical settings: “The operating room puts you under pressure… it really wears you down mentally” (participant 13).
Participants also reported that stress and personal life difficulties could influence their ability to make balanced decisions: “Sometimes stress or personal problems take their toll” (participant 13). Personal biography, character and value systems were also described as shaping managerial style and relational approaches: “My character, experiences and background influence me a lot” (participant 12) and then “Personal experiences and values influence interpersonal relationships and the relational approach, which are reflected in work dynamics” (participant 19). However, lived experience did not function uniformly as a barrier. Some participants described personal difficulties, stress, and cognitive overload as constraining their emotional balance and capacity to manage decisions. In other narrations, experiences of suffering increased empathy and sensitivity to patients’ needs: “Personal experiences, such as pain, make me more empathetic and aware of patients’ needs. This influences my decision-making” (participant 21). Thus, although personal biography and value systems were included among individual barriers, participants’ narrations indicated that their influence was context-dependent and could also support patient-centred decisions by enhancing empathy and sensitivity to patients’ needs. The influence of personal factors therefore depended on how they shaped managers’ emotional balance, cognitive availability, relational approach and sensitivity to patients’ needs. Taken together, these findings indicate that personal factors influenced decision-making by affecting managers’ emotional balance, cognitive availability, relational approach and sensitivity to patients’ needs, sometimes constraining and in other cases shaping patient-centred choices.
Organisational Barriers
Institutional pressures and constraints emerged as barriers to PCMDM, including budget and health policy restrictions and top-down pressures. Participants described decision-making as influenced by healthcare system directives, resource limitations and organisational requirements that shaped what could realistically be decided and implemented. Budget and health policy restrictions were reported as limiting managerial flexibility and affecting the allocation of resources: “SSN directives influence decisions” (participant 5). Participants also described how external factors, such as the number of procedures and scheduling requirements, influenced the resources available for care delivery: “Decisions are influenced by external factors, such as the number of procedures and scheduling, which impact the available resources” (participant 19). Top-down pressures were described as directives imposed from higher organisational levels, which MNMs were required to implement even when these were difficult to reconcile with local circumstances: “In our work, there are situations that are imposed on us from above, and which we may have to be the first to enforce… that’s not easy” (participant 31). Some participants expressed a sense of limited autonomy in relation to these institutional constraints: “Sometimes our hands are tied” (participant 6). These findings indicate that institutional pressures and constraints limited decision-making flexibility and required managers to continuously adapt patient-centred decisions to policy requirements, resource availability, and organisational directives.
Organisational instability emerged as a barrier to PCMDM, including sudden changes and immediate reorganisations, time-related constraints, and lack of organisational decision support. Participants described decision-making as taking place within dynamic and often unpredictable environments, where planned activities were frequently disrupted by emerging clinical priorities and organisational demands. Sudden changes and emergency-driven reorganisations required managers to rapidly adapt previously planned activities: “An emergency may arise… and you have to change everything you’ve done up until that moment” (participant 17). Participants described situations in which clinical settings could rapidly increase in complexity, requiring immediate reallocation of staff, equipment, and resources: “The department can change at any moment… from calm to after two hours it becomes a sub-intensive… so the reorganization is: nurses on patients, I start calling to get monitors and everything…” (participant 22).
Participants described time scarcity as a recurrent condition that limited opportunities for reflection, consultation, and comprehensive evaluation of patient-centred options. Limited time reduced what managers felt could realistically be achieved: “If we had had more time we could certainly have done more, that’s for sure” (participant 24). Others described decision-making as occurring under constant time pressure, with little opportunity to pause and reflect: “Many times you don’t have time to think too much about things… you don’t have the time you want” (participant 6). Time pressure was also explicitly linked to decision quality: “Time negatively impacts decision-making” (participant 9) and “Time forces us to make quick decisions that impact the quality” (participant 3). In urgent situations, time was described as a critical resource for reorganising schedules, staff, and resources: “Time is a critical resource, especially in urgent situations where schedules or resources need to be reorganized to optimize care” (participant 19). The lack of organisational decision support further contributed to the difficulty of managing complex decisions. Participants reported that the absence of structured support mechanisms, such as shared decision-making spaces or clear organisational guidance, increased the burden of responsibility and reduced opportunities for collective reflection. These findings indicate that organisational instability constrains PCMDM by requiring continuous adaptation, limiting time for deliberation and increasing the complexity of coordinating care in rapidly changing clinical environments.
3.2.2. Overarching Theme 2: Facilitators to Patient-Centred Managerial Decision-Making
The analysis identified a set of facilitators that support the enactment of PCMDM within healthcare organisations. Overall, facilitators were organised into three themes, encompassing multiple categories and associated codes. The following sections describe themes, categories and codes, providing a detailed account of the factors that facilitate PCMDM (Table 3).
Consultation with Others
Engagement with the Multidisciplinary Team. Consultation and shared decision-making with nursing staff emerged as a facilitator within this category. Participants consistently described PCMDM as a process grounded in dialogue and collective reflection rather than individual managerial authority. Engagement with the nursing team was not perceived as optional but as an essential component of decision-making practice: “Discussion is essential. It’s important to share goals, improve communication, and make decisions with the nursing team” (participant 21). Decisions were often described as the result of shared deliberation, where proposals were discussed and collectively refined: “It’s all a discussion… this proposal has arrived, what do you think?… not an imposition, but an elaboration by the whole group” (participant 2). Participants highlighted that involving nursing staff allowed them to incorporate multiple perspectives, including experiential and context-specific knowledge, into decision-making processes. Patient-centredness itself was described as something developed within this collective space: “The patient-centered decision is made in collaboration with the team” (participant 19). In this sense, the definition and application of patient-centred decisions were shaped through shared assessments of available resources, organisational constraints and care priorities. Participants also reported that discussions with colleagues supported more informed and comprehensive decisions: “Discussions between colleagues and nurses help to make more informed decisions” (participant 18). Beyond nurses, other professional figures, including doctors, administrative staff and healthcare assistants, were described as contributing to decision-making processes: “If you bring your staff on board… think together… in the end the best thing always comes out… unity is strength” (participant 27). Overall, collaborative engagement was described as facilitating decision-making by integrating different perspectives, reducing uncertainty and supporting the practical implementation of patient-centred decisions.
Consultation with middle and top management emerged as a key facilitator supporting PCMDM, operating across different but complementary organisational levels. Participants described engaging in both horizontal consultation with senior coordinators and vertical interaction with top nursing management, each contributing in distinct ways to the decision-making process. Consultation with more experienced coordinators was described as particularly relevant in situations characterised by uncertainty, interpersonal conflict or organisational complexity. In these contexts, participants reported seeking guidance from senior peers who were perceived as having greater experiential knowledge and familiarity with the organisational environment: “Sometimes you even have to compare yourself with other coordinators, in that situation they are more prepared than you, because maybe they have faced it or maybe you respect them”. (participant 34). Similarly, peer consultation was described as useful in managing relational dynamics and personnel-related challenges: and “A personnel management discussion with the other coordinators or maybe there’s a particular conflict with a doctor, you vent, you confront another colleague. I happened to confront XX because she was here before me; therefore, she knows the people better than I do” (participant 22). Through these interactions, participants reported gaining access to context-specific knowledge, including insights into team dynamics, organisational history and relational patterns, which supported them in reframing complex situations and identifying possible courses of action.
In parallel, interaction with top nursing management was described as providing a different form of support, related to organisational alignment and clarity of direction. Participants emphasised that clear communication of expectations and strategic priorities contributed to reducing decisional uncertainty: “ Management gives instructions… you have a clear idea of what you have to do… the work can be done more easily” (participant 14). At the same time, participants described an active process of interpreting and adapting managerial directives to their local context: “I make management decisions on my own, apply them, listen to feedback and then rework them” (participant 5). These narrations suggest that consultation across hierarchical levels supported decision-making by combining experiential knowledge from peers with organisational guidance from leadership. Overall, engagement with both middle and top management was described as facilitating more informed, context-sensitive and operationally feasible decisions.
Competence and Experience in Decision-Making
Training and experience emerged as facilitators of PCMDM by supporting managers in developing the knowledge and confidence needed to address complex situations. Formal training to acquire competencies was described as a useful foundation for strengthening managerial decision-making skills, as reflected by one participant who stated: “Training is a key element in making decisions” (participant 16). However, participants also described learning from professional experience as a resource for guiding everyday decisions. Participants described relying on previous situations, procedures and guidelines to orient their choices: “We make use of procedures, guidelines… previous experience” (participant 5). Experience was also described as a cumulative process through which managers retained lessons from past situations to inform future actions: “We kept a mental or written record of the route for future reference” (participant 12). Within this process, prior errors were also described as a source of learning. Participants reported that experiencing and acknowledging mistakes contributed to their ability to manage future situations more effectively: “We must learn from difficulties to be prepared for the next time” (participant 11) and “You must also know how to accept mistakes” (participant 7). Professional experience was analytically distinguished from personal biography and lived experience because participants described it primarily as accumulated practice-based knowledge developed through previous situations, procedures, successes and errors. Taken together with the narrations reported under personal factors, these findings show that experience did not have a fixed function: personal circumstances and lived experiences could create strain or increase empathy, whereas accumulated professional experience generally supported learning, recognition of situations and preparation for subsequent decisions.
Everyday Managerial Practice. Management of human and instrumental resources emerged as a facilitator within everyday managerial practice. Participants consistently described their role as influencing patient care indirectly through the organisation and coordination of staff and resources, rather than through direct clinical involvement. Several participants emphasised that ensuring appropriate team functioning was central to achieving patient-centred outcomes: “To reach the patient you also have to work on the group… because they then provide direct assistance” (participant 3). Similarly, managers highlighted how their work focused on supporting staff performance, with the expectation that this would translate into better care for patients: “I work for my staff… because if they work well… then they will give the best to the patient” (participant 30). Participants explicitly described their role as ensuring that staff were in the best conditions to provide care: “The coordinator does not provide direct assistance… but must ensure that the staff he coordinates… manage the patient in the best possible way” (participant 25). In this sense, resource management was described as involving the organisation of workloads, allocation of human resources and coordination of care activities in ways that supported staff in delivering appropriate care. Through these processes, managers reported contributing to PCMDM by creating the organisational conditions necessary for care delivery.
Effective communication was a facilitator in relation to relational management and team coordination. Participants described communication as an essential component of managerial practice, especially when dealing with complex situations under time pressure: “Making a patient-centered decision means managing communication, relationships, teams… in a very short time” (participant 5). Within this category, communication was frequently associated with empathic approaches, enabling managers to engage with staff and address relational dynamics. Participants highlighted the importance of maintaining open and constructive dialogue to manage tensions and support decision-making processes. Dialogue was also described as an important moment within managerial practice, despite constraints related to time and workload: “Time for dialogue is a luxury… but a fundamental one” (participant 5). Participants reported that opportunities for dialogue allowed them to share perspectives, clarify priorities and address emerging issues within the team. In this sense, communication was described as facilitating coordination and supporting the implementation of decisions in complex organisational contexts.
Matching workforce skills to care complexity emerged as a relevant facilitator supporting PCMDM. Participants described decision-making as involving the assessment of alignment between nurses’ competencies and patients’ clinical needs. Managers reported evaluating whether staff members possessed the appropriate skills to manage specific patient situations: “The manager must ask himself if the nurse is suitable… the right skills for the right problem” (participant 17). This process was often supported by existing organisational models, such as the primary nursing model, which facilitated the allocation of patients based on nurses’ competencies: “We have a model that is the primary nurse; therefore, I assign each patient to a nurse… based on the nurse’s skills” (participant 16). Participants highlighted that assigning staff according to their level of competence allowed them to better respond to patient needs and manage care situations more effectively. In this sense, aligning workforce skills with care complexity was described as supporting both the organisation of care and the delivery of appropriate patient-centred interventions.
Knowledge of the Patient and Organisational Context
Within this theme, the analysis distinguished related but analytically separate aspects of the information used in managerial decision-making. Knowledge of patient needs concerned person-specific clinical, experiential and care-related information. Patient safety assessment concerned the identification of potential harm and the conditions required for safe care delivery. Knowledge of the organisational context concerned care pathways, workflows, resource availability and operational capacity. During analysis, excerpts were coded according to their primary focus. Nevertheless, participants’ narrations showed that these forms of knowledge were often combined when managerial decisions were made.
Knowledge of Patient Needs. Knowledge of the patient and direct contact with clinical reality emerged as a facilitator of PCMDM. Participants consistently described that making patient-centred decisions required an in-depth understanding of individual patients, including their needs, expectations, and clinical conditions: “A patient-oriented decision implies knowing that patient… based on his needs, his demands, and his lived experience” (participant 12). This knowledge was not limited to clinical information but also included contextual and experiential aspects of the patient. Maintaining proximity to frontline care was described as essential to support informed decision-making: “The manager must not lose contact with the frontline… otherwise he lives in a parallel world” (participant 2). Participants emphasised that direct contact with patients contributed to the legitimacy and appropriateness of managerial decisions: “To make a decision… you need to know the patient, even as a coordinator” (participant 3). Knowledge of the patient was also described as connected to a broader understanding of the care context, including organisational priorities and available resources: “Knowing the patient and the surrounding environment, optimizing resources, and considering organizational priorities and ethical responsibility” (participant 18). In practice, participants reported engaging in direct observation of care activities and patient conditions to inform their decisions: “When I am on duty in the morning, I go and check and document myself on the patients… I look at pressure injuries, drains, catheters… whether they need anti-decubitus mattresses… whether I need to order devices… These small things help me understand how the ward is going” (participant 32). Overall, maintaining direct knowledge of patients and clinical situations was described as supporting more informed, context-sensitive and patient-centred managerial decisions.
Patient safety assessment emerged as a relevant facilitator within the broader category of knowledge of the patient. Participants described safety as a key consideration guiding managerial decision-making, encompassing both physical and psychological aspects of patient care: “The essential element is the patient’s well-being, which concerns not only the physical but also the psychological aspect… We must always consider infection risk and manage recovery without trauma” (participant 20). Participants also referred to safety in relation to care processes, highlighting the importance of ensuring appropriate conditions for the delivery of care: “Process safety… both from an infectious point of view and from the execution of the procedure… ensuring that all devices are available… I hunt for problems to intercept them” (participant 35). In this sense, risk assessment was described as involving the identification of potential issues and the organisation of care activities in ways that supported safe care delivery. Participants reported actively monitoring care processes and anticipating possible complications to support appropriate and timely interventions. Attention to patient safety was described as supporting PCMDM by guiding the evaluation of risks and the organisation of care in complex clinical situations.
Knowledge of the Organisational Context. Contextual awareness and proactive management emerged as a facilitator of PCMDM, reflecting managers’ ability to integrate an in-depth understanding of care processes with proactive organisational action. Participants described decision-making as grounded in knowledge of patient flow, care pathways and organisational dynamics, which enabled them to anticipate demands and establish priorities. As one participant explained, “My patient-centered decisions are made by knowing the care process very well… I already gather information from the Emergency Department before the patient arrives… I understand how the process works” (participant 23). This contextual understanding was closely linked to anticipatory planning practices. Managers reported that decision-making often began before care delivery, through advance review of schedules, expected workload and resource needs: “My work already starts the day before by reviewing the list for the next day… while I am still working, I have to make decisions about where to schedule a procedure, who should perform it, and how” (participant 10). Participants also emphasised that detailed organisation of staff, materials and activities was necessary to ensure that care processes could be managed effectively: You cannot manage something if it is not well organised in detail… you have to plan everything… I have two or three operating rooms, staff, materials, and everything must be properly prepared… every week we have a meeting where surgical lists are presented in advance… materials are ordered through the pharmacy… day by day I prepare the operating sessions, but I have already been working on them for days” (participant 36). Taken together, these findings indicate that contextual awareness supported managers in identifying priorities and anticipating operational demands, while proactive planning enabled the coordination of resources and organisation of care activities. In this sense, PCMDM was facilitated by the ability to align patient needs with organisational capacity through anticipatory and context-sensitive management practices.
Application of guidelines and procedures emerged as a facilitator of PCMDM by providing structure and support for clinical and organisational choices. Participants emphasised that, although relational proximity to patients was important, decisions also needed to be grounded in evidence, professional standards and informed consent: “The relationship with the patient facilitates the decision, but clinical choices must be based on scientific evidence, guidelines, and informed consent” (participant 19). Structured tools, such as individualised care plans, were described as useful for obtaining a more comprehensive understanding of the patient: “We have the individualized care plan… we can have a complete view of the patient… it is very helpful” (participant 1). Participants also reported relying on procedures and guidelines when managing complex situations: “We rely on procedures, guidelines… and previous experience” (participant 5). Guidelines and procedures were described as supporting decision-making by reducing uncertainty, promoting consistency and helping managers align patient-centred choices with clinical standards and organisational requirements.
Strategic orientation through mission and vision emerged as a facilitator by providing a shared organisational direction for managerial choices. Participants described mission and vision as elements that influenced how decisions were framed and coordinated within the organisation: “Mission and vision influence the decision-making process” (participant 2). Similarly, participants emphasised that these organisational references supported coordination and alignment among professionals: “Mission and vision strongly influence coordination” (participant 8). For some participants, the mission represented a common point of reference that helped orient professionals towards a shared objective: “The mission is unique… it orients everyone toward the same objective” (participant 1). The mission and vision were described as supporting decision-making by promoting coherence, reducing fragmentation and aligning managerial decisions with the broader organisational purpose of PCC.
Taken together, participants’ narrations showed that knowledge of patient needs, assessment of safety risks and understanding of organisational conditions formed connected components of managerial decision-making. Patient-specific information and safety considerations helped managers identify care priorities, while knowledge of organisational processes and resources informed how those priorities could be addressed in practice.
3.3. Relationships Across Themes
Across participants’ narrations, barriers to PCMDM operated in combination. Institutional directives and resource constraints narrowed the decisional options perceived as feasible, while organisational instability and time pressure limited opportunities for reflection and consultation before decision-making. These conditions were associated with cognitive overload, stress, emotional responsibility and fear of making mistakes, particularly when decisions had potential consequences for patient safety. Limited organisational decision support further increased reliance on individual judgement. Thus, participants’ accounts connected structural constraints with the cognitive and emotional demands experienced by managers.
Facilitators similarly formed an interconnected process. Knowledge of patient needs, safety risks, care pathways and available resources supported the identification of priorities and feasible responses to patient care when MNM’s were taking decisions. Consultation with teams, peers and senior management added professional perspectives and organisational direction, while training and experience helped managers interpret information and anticipate consequences. Communication, resource allocation and matching workforce skills to care complexity translated these inputs into operational decisions. Together, these mechanisms were described as reducing uncertainty and supporting managerial decisions responsive to both patient needs and organisational conditions.
4. Discussion
This study explored the barriers and facilitators influencing PCMDM among MNMs in hospital settings. Participants’ narrations described the convergence of organisational constraints, relational dynamics, emotional accountability and time pressures in everyday managerial decision-making. Whereas previous literature has often approached managerial decision-making through individual competencies and leadership attributes [26], the present findings highlight how these influences interacted at the middle-management level. MNMs remained accountable for patient-centred decisions while having limited control over some of the conditions under which those decisions were made. We interpret this recurring pattern as bounded autonomy, through which managers sought to integrate patient-centred values into decisions shaped by organisational demands.
A central finding of this study was that barriers to PCMDM did not operate independently but interacted within a multilevel decision-making environment. Participants described how budgetary restrictions, policy requirements, and top-down directives constrained their decisional autonomy and required them to negotiate continuously between organisational priorities and patient-centred values. Emotional burden and persistent time pressure further compounded these institutional constraints.
Previous research has described healthcare decision-making as influenced by uncertainty, workload, and contextual demands [26,27] while macro-level organisational constraints have been identified as barriers to PCC implementation [8]. The present findings add to this literature by describing how these pressures converged in the everyday decisions of MNMs: organisational requirements narrowed the range of decisional options perceived as feasible, while responsibility for the consequences of those decisions remained with the managers.
Within participants’ narrations, time pressure was not described solely as a shortage of time. It reduced opportunities for reflection and consultation, while the need to make rapid decisions increased cognitive load, emotional responsibility and concern about potential errors. These accounts suggest how organisational conditions could affect the individual manager’s capacity to consider patient needs within complex decisions. Previous studies have similarly associated excessive workloads, time pressure and unrealistic institutional expectations with fragmented or task-oriented managerial practices [9,10]. Stress and burnout have also been associated with reduced decision-making capacity, well-being and job satisfaction among nurse managers [11,13,26,28].
Participants’ narrations further suggested that role expectations and workload shaped the time available for reflection, consultation and continued contact with clinical practice. This interpretation is consistent with previous research indicating that workload and role arrangements may influence nurse managers’ decision-making capacity and well-being [10,29]. It also aligns with Lalleman et al. [9], who highlighted the value of integrating hands-on and heads-on “caring work” to maintain the connection between managerial practice and patient care. Although formal job redesign was not directly proposed by participants, their accounts, interpreted alongside the existing literature, suggest that role and workload arrangements that preserve clinical proximity and allow time for reflection and consultation may support PCMDM [10,29].
Beyond these constraints, participants described consultation, direct knowledge of patients and accumulated professional experience as interconnected facilitators of PCMDM. Consultation with nursing staff, interdisciplinary colleagues, peers and senior management was described as bringing complementary professional and organisational perspectives into the decision-making process, thereby reducing reliance on individual judgement. Direct knowledge of patients and continued proximity to clinical practice anchored managerial decisions in patient-specific needs, experiences and safety concerns. Knowledge of organisational processes and available resources further informed which patient-centred responses could feasibly be implemented. Accumulated professional experience supported the recognition of recurring situations, anticipation of possible consequences, and learning from previous difficulties and errors. The role of consultation is consistent with previous research identifying supportive leadership and shared decision-making as resources for nurse managers [30], whereas limited feedback and insufficient managerial support have been described as barriers to effective decision-making [31,32]. The importance attributed to direct knowledge of patients and continued proximity to clinical practice also echoes Lalleman et al. [9], who highlighted the contribution of both hands-on and heads-on caring work to maintaining the connection between managerial practice and patient care. The present findings extend this literature by suggesting that these facilitators provided complementary forms of knowledge through which MNMs interpreted complex situations and identified contextually feasible patient-centred responses. This interpretation is also consistent with the PCNF’s emphasis on the care environment, including supportive organisational systems and effective staff relationships, as relevant to person-centred practice [18].
Experience did not, however, function uniformly. Professional experience was more consistently described as a source of practice-based knowledge, whereas personal circumstances and lived experiences could increase emotional strain and cognitive burden but could also heighten empathy and sensitivity to patients’ needs. The influence of experience therefore appeared to depend on its nature and on how it entered the decision-making process.
The findings suggest that PCMDM may be difficult to enact consistently when organisational constraints, time pressure, emotional demands and limited decision support converge. In participants’ accounts, however, these conditions did not eliminate managerial agency: consultation, direct knowledge of patients, professional experience and awareness of the organisational context helped MNMs navigate constraints and identify feasible patient-centred responses. These findings support our interpretation of PCMDM as a process enacted through bounded autonomy. Supporting this process may require attention to both organisational conditions and the relational and informational resources available to managers.
Implications for Practice
The findings directly point to several practices that participants described as facilitating PCMDM: multidisciplinary dialogue, consultation with peers and senior management, continued contact with patients and clinical practice, and the alignment of workforce competencies and resources with care complexity. Creating opportunities for reflection and consultation may help MNMs integrate patient needs, safety considerations and organisational conditions within their decisions.
Participants’ narrations of time pressure, workload fragmentation and limited organisational support also indicate areas that may warrant organisational attention. When interpreted alongside the existing literature, these findings suggest that healthcare organisations could consider reviewing managerial roles and workload arrangements [10,29], strengthening supportive leadership and shared decision-making [30], and providing structured feedback and managerial support [31,32]. Existing literature also identifies patient-centred communication training as a possible strategy [33]. Building on participants’ emphasis on experience and learning from errors, leadership development programmes could incorporate experiential learning and reflective practice. The effectiveness of these strategies was not evaluated in the present study; further research is therefore needed to determine their effectiveness in supporting PCMDM across different organisational settings.
5. Limitations and Future Research
This study has several limitations. First, it was conducted in three hospitals within a single national healthcare system. Moreover, 30 of the 38 participants (78.9%) worked in private hospitals. Although one public hospital was included, the predominance of participants from private organisations may have influenced the experiences represented in the findings and should be considered when assessing their transferability to public hospitals and other organisational contexts. Second, the findings are based on self-reported experiences, which may be influenced by recall and social desirability bias, although individual interviews were used to encourage open reflection. Third, the study focused exclusively on MNMs, without including perspectives from frontline staff, senior management or patients. Consequently, the findings represent PCMDM as perceived and described by MNMs and cannot establish whether decisions considered patient-centred by managers were experienced as such by patients or other stakeholders. This is particularly relevant to direct contact with patients, which MNMs frequently described as a facilitator but which was not corroborated through patient accounts or direct observation. Fourth, potential participants were initially identified by Directors of Nursing, which may have introduced gatekeeper or selection bias, as not all eligible MNMs may have had an equal likelihood of being identified. Moreover, given the hierarchical nature of healthcare organisations, this procedure may have influenced the perceived voluntariness of participation. These risks were mitigated by applying predefined eligibility criteria, limiting the Directors’ role to the identification of potentially eligible participants, ensuring that they were not informed of who agreed or declined to participate, and explicitly communicating that participation was voluntary and unrelated to participants’ employment. Participants were also informed that their interviews would remain confidential and would be discussed exclusively within the research team. Nevertheless, the hierarchical context may have influenced their willingness to express critical views about senior leadership, organisational constraints or limited managerial autonomy. Hierarchical influence was not formally examined as a distinct issue during the analysis, and this should be considered when interpreting the findings. Fifth, fifteen participants were professionally known to the interviewers because they worked in the same hospitals. This prior professional familiarity may have influenced participants’ willingness to disclose sensitive experiences and may have introduced social desirability bias. However, no direct hierarchical, supervisory, or evaluative relationship existed, and voluntariness and confidentiality were emphasised before each interview. Sixth, the semi-structured interview guide included topic areas relevant to the research question, such as leadership, communication, and personal and organisational factors. Although the questions were open-ended and the analysis proceeded inductively, the inclusion of these areas may have influenced the emphasis of participants’ accounts. This possibility should be considered when interpreting the findings. Seventh, although the analysis explored relationships among individual, relational and organisational factors, these relationships represent interpretive patterns within participants’ narrations and should not be understood as causal mechanisms. Future research should adopt multi-level and mixed-method approaches to explore how PCMDM operates across organisational levels and how it relates to patient and organisational outcomes. It should also seek to include a more balanced representation of participants from public and private hospitals, and involve patients and top managers in the experience descriptions. Despite these limitations, the study provides important insights into the organisational and relational conditions shaping managerial decision-making in healthcare.
6. Conclusions
The findings of this study suggest that, within the hospital contexts examined, PCMDM as perceived and described by MNMs is a context-dependent process shaped by the interaction of organisational constraints, temporal pressures, relational dynamics and emotional accountability. Rather than being an individual competence alone, it appears to emerge from the conditions within which managers operate. Alongside organisational constraints, consultation with other professionals, accumulated professional experience and direct knowledge of patients were identified as resources that helped MNMs navigate complex decisions and identify feasible patient-centred responses. PCMDM may therefore require organisational environments that support reflection, collaboration and contextual awareness, enabling MNMs to translate patient-centred principles into everyday practice. Further research is needed to examine how the relationships among these factors operate across different healthcare settings and organisational contexts.
Supplementary Materials
The following supporting information can be downloaded at: https://www.mdpi.com/article/10.3390/nursrep16110421/s1, File S1: Consolidated criteria for reporting qualitative studies (COREQ): 32-item checklist; File S2: Comparative overview of the two phases of the research programme on patient-centered managerial decision-making..
Author Contributions
V.D.G.: Conceptualisation, Methodology, Writing—Original Draft, Writing—Review and Editing, Data analysis; R.G.: Conceptualisation, Funding Acquisition, Methodology, Writing—Original Draft, Writing—Review and Editing; M.L.: Data Analysis; D.P.: Data Curation, Visualisation; I.S.: Supervision, Writing—Review and Editing; D.T.: Supervision, Writing—Review and Editing, Project Administration, Funding Acquisition; D.I.: Conceptualisation, Methodology, Writing—Original Draft, Writing—Review and Editing, Data Analysis. All authors have read and agreed to the published version of the manuscript.
Funding
This work was supported by the Centre of Excellence for Nursing Culture and Research (CECRI). Grant Code: 3.24.7.
Institutional Review Board Statement
The study was approved by the Comitato Etico Territoriale Lazio Area 2 (approval number: 95.24CET2 cbm, approved date: 11 April 2024).
Informed Consent Statement
All participants provided written informed consent.
Data Availability Statement
The data presented in this study are available on request from the corresponding author due to ethical restrictions.
Public Involvement Statement
No public involvement in any aspect of this research.
Guidelines and Standards Statement
This manuscript was drafted in accordance with the Consoli- dated Criteria for Reporting Qualitative Research (COREQ) guidelines for qualitative research.
Use of Artificial Intelligence
During the preparation of this manuscript, the authors used ChatGPT Work, 5.6 Sol to refine the wording and improve the clarity, readability, and linguistic expression of the text. The authors subsequently reviewed and edited all AI-assisted content and take full responsibility for the final manuscript. The tool was not used for the study design, data collection, data analysis, or interpretation of the findings.
Acknowledgments
The authors sincerely thank the middle nurse managers who participated in the study for generously sharing their experiences and perspectives. We also acknowledge the Directors of Nursing for facilitating participant recruitment and supporting the dissemination of the study.
Conflicts of Interest
The authors declare no conflicts of interest.
Abbreviations
The following abbreviations are used in this manuscript:
| MNMs | Middle Nurse Managers |
| PCC | Patient-centred care |
| PCMDM | Patient-centred managerial decision-making |
| COREQ | Consolidated criteria for reporting qualitative studies |
References
- Janerka, C.; Leslie, G.D.; Gill, F.J. Development of patient-centred care in acute hospital settings: A meta-narrative review. Int. J. Nurs. Stud. 2023, 140, 104465. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit] [PubMed]
- Lateef, A.M.; Mhlongo, E.M. A literature review on people-centered care and nursing practice in primary health care setting. Glob. J. Health Sci. 2020, 12, 23–40. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- World Health Organization. Framework on Integrated, People-Centred Health Services: Report by the Secretariat; A69/39; World Health Organization: Geneva, Switzerland, 2016; Available online: https://apps.who.int/gb/ebwha/pdf_files/WHA69/A69_39-en.pdf (accessed on 20 August 2026).
- Institute of Medicine (US) Committee on Quality of Health Care in America. Crossing the Quality Chasm: A New Health System for the 21st Century; National Academies Press: Washington, DC, USA, 2001. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit] [PubMed]
- Santana, M.J.; Manalili, K.; Jolley, R.J.; Zelinsky, S.; Quan, H.; Lu, M. How to practice person-centred care: A conceptual framework. Health Expect. 2018, 21, 429–440. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit] [PubMed]
- AL-Ruzzieh, M.A.; AL-Helih, Y.M.; Haroun, A.; Ayaad, O. Higher and middle management perspectives on patient-centered care in an oncology setting: A qualitative study. Nurs. Rep. 2024, 14, 3378–3390. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit] [PubMed]
- Nkrumah, J.; Abekah-Nkrumah, G. Facilitators and barriers of patient-centered care at the organizational-level: A study of three district hospitals in the central region of Ghana. BMC Health Serv. Res. 2019, 19, 900. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit] [PubMed]
- Taylor, A.; Groene, O. European hospital managers’ perceptions of patient-centred care: A qualitative study on implementation and context. J. Health Organ. Manag. 2015, 29, 711–728. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit] [PubMed]
- Lalleman, P.C.B.; Smid, G.A.C.; Dikken, J.; Lagerwey, M.D.; Schuurmans, M.J. Nurse middle managers contributions to patient-centred care: A ‘managerial work’ analysis. Nurs. Inq. 2017, 24, e12193. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit] [PubMed]
- Udod, S.; Cummings, G.G.; Care, W.D.; Jenkins, M. Role stressors and coping strategies among nurse managers. Leadersh. Health Serv. 2017, 30, 29–43. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit] [PubMed]
- Van Bogaert, P.; Adriaenssens, J.; Dilles, T.; Martens, D.; Van Rompaey, B.; Timmermans, O. Impact of role-, job- and organizational characteristics on nursing unit managers’ work related stress and well-being. J. Adv. Nurs. 2014, 70, 2622–2633. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit] [PubMed]
- Goldsby, E.; Goldsby, M.; Neck, C.B.; Neck, C.P. Under pressure: Time management, self-leadership, and the nurse manager. Adm. Sci. 2020, 10, 38. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Jin, Y.; Cui, F.; Wang, R.; Chen, S.; Hu, L.; Yao, M.; Wu, H. Stress overload, influencing factors, and psychological experiences of nurse managers during early stages of the COVID-19 pandemic: A sequential explanatory mixed method study. Front. Psychol. 2023, 14, 1187433. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit] [PubMed]
- Birken, S.; Clary, A.; Tabriz, A.A.; Turner, K.; Meza, R.; Zizzi, A.; Larson, M.; Walker, J.; Charns, M. Middle managers’ role in implementing evidence-based practices in healthcare: A systematic review. Implement. Sci. 2018, 13, 149. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit] [PubMed]
- Filomeno, L.; Forte, D.; Di Simone, E.; Di Muzio, M.; Tartaglini, D.; Lommi, M.; Ivziku, D. Systematic review and psychometric properties analysis of first-, middle-, and top-level nurse manager’s core competencies instruments. J. Nurs. Manag. 2024, 2024, 2655382. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit] [PubMed]
- González-García, A.; Pinto-Carral, A.; Villorejo, J.S.; Marqués-Sánchez, P. Competency model for the middle nurse manager (MCGE-Logistic Level). Int. J. Environ. Res. Public Health 2021, 18, 3898. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit] [PubMed]
- Di Giuseppe, V.; Gualandi, R.; Tartaglini, D.; De Benedictis, A.; Filomeno, L.; Popa, D.; Ivziku, D. What is the meaning of patient-centered decision-making for a middle nurse manager?—A qualitative study. Nurs. Rep. 2026, 16, 21. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit] [PubMed]
- McCance, T.; McCormack, B. The Person-centred Nursing Framework: A mid-range theory for nursing practice. J. Res. Nurs. 2025, 30, 47–60. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit] [PubMed]
- Sandelowski, M. What’s in a name? Qualitative description revisited. Res. Nurs. Health 2010, 33, 77–84. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit] [PubMed]
- Sandelowski, M. Whatever happened to qualitative description? Res. Nurs. Health 2000, 23, 334–340. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit] [PubMed]
- Elo, S.; Kyngäs, H. The qualitative content analysis process. J. Adv. Nurs. 2008, 62, 107–115. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit] [PubMed]
- Naeem, M.; Ozuem, W.; Howell, K.; Ranfagni, S. Demystification and actualisation of data saturation in qualitative research through thematic analysis. Int. J. Qual. Methods 2024, 23, 16094069241229777. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Guba, E.G.; Lincoln, Y.S. Competing paradigms in qualitative research. In Handbook of Qualitative Research; Denzin, N.K., Lincoln, Y.S., Eds.; Sage Publications: Thousand Oaks, CA, USA, 1994; pp. 105–117. [Google Scholar]
- Lincoln, Y.S.; Guba, E.G. Naturalistic Inquiry; Sage Publications: Beverly Hills, CA, USA, 1985. [Google Scholar]
- World Medical Association. WMA Declaration of Helsinki—Ethical Principles for Medical Research Involving Human Participants. 2024. Available online: https://www.wma.net/policies-post/wma-declaration-of-helsinki/ (accessed on 20 August 2026).
- Gonzalez-Garcia, A.; Marques-Sanchez, P.; Pinto-Carral, A.; Leiros-Rodriguez, R.; Perez-Rivera, J.; Perez-González, S. Characterizing the decision-making competency of nurse managers: A scoping review. J. Nurs. Manag. 2025, 2025, 2771210. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit] [PubMed]
- Johansen, M.L.; O’Brien, J.L. Decision making in nursing practice: A concept analysis. Nurs. Forum 2016, 51, 40–48. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit] [PubMed]
- Abugre, D.; Bhengu, B.R. Nurse managers’ perceptions of patient-centred care and its influence on quality nursing care and nurse job satisfaction: Empirical research qualitative. Nurs. Open 2024, 11, e2071. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit] [PubMed]
- Gruebling, N.; Seymour, B.; Darling, T.; Ray, J. Priorities for nurse managers: Guidance from a national survey. Nurse Lead. 2025, 23, 102421. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Van Bogaert, P.; Peremans, L.; de Wit, M.; Van Heusden, D.; Franck, E.; Timmermans, O.; Havens, D.S. Nurse managers’ perceptions and experiences regarding staff nurse empowerment: A qualitative study. Front. Psychol. 2015, 6, 1585. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit] [PubMed]
- Mohamed, H.A.; Elrais, H.R. Factors affecting decision making among nurse managers and its relation to decision making styles. Port Said Sci. J. Nurs. 2017, 4, 241–266. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Abeje, W.; Tegegne, B.; Tefera, Z.; Zenebe, Y.; Yimam, W.; Desu, B.; Andargie, Y.; Amare, M.; Kassa, M.; W/Selassie, M. Factors affecting decision making among nurse managers working in government hospitals. Front. Health Serv. 2025, 4, 1475402. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit] [PubMed]
- Mielke, K.; Frerichs, W.; Cöllen, K.; Lindig, A.; Härter, M.; Scholl, I. Development of a patient-centered communication skills training: A qualitative exploration of nurse managers’ perspectives. Nurs. Open 2026, 13, e70605. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit] [PubMed]
Disclaimer/Publisher’s Note: The statements, opinions and data contained in all publications are solely those of the individual author(s) and contributor(s) and not of MDPI and/or the editor(s). MDPI and/or the editor(s) disclaim responsibility for any injury to people or property resulting from any ideas, methods, instructions or products referred to in the content. |
© 2026 by the authors. Licensee MDPI, Basel, Switzerland. This article is an open access article distributed under the terms and conditions of the Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY) license.