Skip to Content
  • Article
  • Open Access

1 February 2001

Manipulation Method for the Treatment of Ankle Equinus

Division of Podiatry, Faculty of Health University of Western Sydney–Macarthur PO Box 555 Campbelltown, New South Wales 2560 Australia

Letter to the Editor

To the Editor:
I read with great interest the article published in the September 2000 issue of the Journal by Howard J. Dananberg and colleagues on the use of manipulation to increase ankle joint dorsiflexion (“Manipulation Method for the Treatment of Ankle Equinus”). While I commend the authors for attempting to evaluate their clinical practice in a structured manner, the flaws in the study design cast doubt on the validity of the results.
First, previous studies that have addressed reliability of ankle joint dorsiflexion measurement using the goniometer have found the device to be subject to considerable error,[1] so the differences in dorsiflexion before and after manipulation may simply reflect measurement error rather than the effect of the intervention. Although the authors took the average of two measurements, the intratester reliability of the measurements was not adequately evaluated or reported. Furthermore, bias on behalf of the clinician taking the ankle joint dorsiflexion measurements was not controlled for, so the greater range of dorsiflexion following manipulation may have been due to increased force exerted by the clinician compared with the baseline measurement. The validity of assisted dorsiflexion (ie, with the subject actively pulling the foot toward him or her) could also be questioned, as the ankle reaches its maximally dorsiflexed position at a period of the gait cycle when the anterior leg musculature is electromyographically silent.[2]
Second, the study used a pre-post design with no control group. This flaw could have been rectified by using the subject’s contralateral leg as the control. Interestingly, a previous article by Nield et al[3] (which was not cited by Dananberg et al), employing a more rigorous method, reported no significant improvements in ankle joint dorsiflexion range of motion following manipulation. In this study, 20 asymptomatic subjects received a single longitudinal manipulation, with the contralateral leg acting as the control. Ankle joint dorsiflexion was measured at five different torques using the “Lidcombe Template,” which has been shown to produce highly reliable (intraclass correlation coefficient, 0.91) results between clinicians.[4] There were no significant changes in ankle dorsiflexion range of motion at any level of torque following the manipulation, leading the authors to conclude that while vertebral manipulation may increase joint range of motion, no such effect can be produced at the ankle joint.
Manipulative techniques are receiving increasing interest in the podiatric profession, despite the lack of supporting evidence for their use.[5] Thus investigations into the effect of these therapies are desperately required, and Dananberg and colleagues are to be commended for conducting such a study. However, given the limitations of the study design, as well as the conflicting results obtained by Nield et al,[3] I urge readers of the Journal to approach this article with an appropriate level of caution, and to consider carefully whether the weight of the evidence is sufficient to justify the use of this technique in clinical practice.

Author’s Response

To the Editor:
Mr. Hylton Menz has questioned the accuracy of the results presented in our article, citing flaws in the study design and other studies on manipulation. I would like to respond to his comments.
Mr. Menz questions the study’s measurement technique as a way in which to evaluate changes in motions associated with ankle equinus. He cites an article by Rome[1] previously published in JAPMA as showing differences between testers in measurement of the ankle with equinus with a goniometer. To address this issue, only one of the authors performed both pre- and post-treatment measurements on all subjects. This tester was completely blinded to the manipulation process. Additionally, the clinicians who performed the manipulations were blinded to the measurement process and were not present in the room when measurements were taken. The actual measurement procedure was practiced repeatedly prior to its actual performance until all of the authors and clinician participants were in agreement as to the method’s accuracy. The leg and foot were marked prior to evaluation, and the same marks were used for the post-treatment measurement. The test subject was then asked to dorsiflex the ankle using a cloth band, and the single tester then measured the response. At no time did the tester apply any force to the ankle to either encourage or discourage range of motion of the subject. We attempted to remove as much clinician bias as possible from the assessment process so as to ensure reasonable accuracy for this rather simple study. While it was recognized that errors in measurement were possible, the fact that increases in range of motion were so pronounced (an average of 5°, with the greatest increase being 17°) is more indicative of the technique’s effectiveness than of measurement inaccuracy. Further, in personal correspondence with Keith Rome, when questioned as to the potential accuracy of goniometer measurements, he replied, “I think that a single observer could reliably measure the same person as long as a standardized procedure is undertaken and the instrument is reliable.”
The issue of the study lacking a control is a reasonable criticism, and was acknowledged in the article as a shortcoming of the study. It was our understanding that ankle equinus has never been shown to spontaneously resolve in the span of a single office visit without some type of intervention. Two pretreatment measurements were taken to ensure that the differences following manipulation were not due to chance. Mr. Menz suggests that the opposite side can be used as a control. Precisely that approach was taken in a prior calf-stretching study, and it was found that the range of motion of the unstretched side actually showed increases comparable to those of the stretched side. It would appear that some reflexive response to stretching occurs and that this can affect both sides. Considering this, we felt that the two-measurement approach would better demonstrate the consistency of motion prior to and following manipulation.
Mr. Menz, in justifying his argument of measurement inaccuracy for the substantial increases in motion reported, cites the study by Nield et al[2] as demonstrating the failure of ankle manipulation to increase ankle motion. In this study, the authors used asymptomatic subjects without any restrictions in ankle joint ranges of motion. Following manipulation, they describe no change despite numerous and precise measurements. This can be likened to giving aspirin to people without fever, and then concluding that aspirin cannot lower body temperature because no change was found in a subject group that began the study with normal body temperature. The fact that no motion change was evident in a group without equinus does not in any way suggest outcomes of ankle manipulation in a group with known ankle equinus. In addition, the Nield et al study measured ankle range of motion with the knee in the flexed position, while the current study performed measurements with the knee extended. Even more significant, a very different manipulative technique was described. Nield et al manipulated only the distal ankle and did not attempt to manipulate the proximal fibular head as in the current study. Because the protocols, manipulation method, and patient selection criteria were so different, no justifiable comparison can be made between these two studies.
We strongly believe that our equinus study demonstrates that the two-pronged approach of manual manipulation of the fibular head and ankle joint results in a statistically significant increase in ankle joint dorsiflexion (with the knee extended) in those subjects diagnosed with ankle equinus. This study was intentionally designed in a very simple manner to demonstrate the clinical effect in the equinus population. If the clinician is properly trained, the procedure appears to be extremely valuable and without ill effects. The authors therefore feel justified in concluding that this form of manipulation is a safe and effective method of resolving ankle equinus.
HOWARD J. DANANBERG, DPM
21 Eastman Ave
Bedford, NH 03110

References

  1. ROME K: Ankle joint dorsiflexion measurement studies: a review of the literature. JAPMA 1996, 86, 205. [CrossRef] [Scilit] [PubMed]
  2. ROSE, J.; GAMBLE, J.G. ffuman Walking, 2nd Ed ed; Williams and Wilkins: Baltimore, 1994. [Google Scholar]
  3. NIELD, S.; DAVIS, K.; LATIMER, J. ET AL: The effect of manipulation on range of movement at the ankle joint. Scand J Rehab Med 1993, 25, 161. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  4. MOSELEY A, ADAMS R: Measurement of ankle dorsiflexion: procedure and reliability. Aust J Physiother 1991, 37, 175. [CrossRef] [Scilit] [PubMed]
  5. MENZ HB: Manipulative therapy of the foot and ankle: science or mesmerism? Foot 1998, 8, 68. [CrossRef] [Scilit]

References

  1. ROME K: Ankle joint dorsiflexion measurement studies: a review of the literature. JAPMA 1996, 86, 205. [CrossRef] [Scilit] [PubMed]
  2. NIELD, S.; DAVIS, K.; LATIMER, J. ET AL: The effect of manipulation on range of movement at the ankle joint. Scand J Rehab Med 1993, 25, 161. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]

Article Metrics

Citations

Article Access Statistics

Multiple requests from the same IP address are counted as one view.