Skip to Content
  • Article
  • Open Access

1 September 2014

An Assessment of Hallux Limitus in University Basketball Players Compared with Noncompetitive Individuals

Centre Audomarois de Recherche Biomécanique, 22 rue des Epeers, 62500 Saint Omer, France

Abstract

Background: Injuries of the first metatarsophalangeal joint have lately been receiving attention from researchers owing to the important functions of this joint. However, most of the studies of turf toe injuries have focused on sports played on artificial turf. Methods: This study compared the range of motion of the first metatarsophalangeal joint in collegiate basketball players (n = 123) and noncompetitive individuals (n = 123). Results: A statistically significant difference (P < .001) in range of motion was found between the two groups. The difference between the two sample means was 21.35°. Conclusions: With hallux rigidus being a potential sequela of repeated turf toe injuries, it seems likely that subacute turf toe injuries occur in basketball players, leading to degenerative changes that result in hallux limitus.

In normal forward gait, the first metatarsophalangeal joint serves as a pivot point in final propulsion, transferring the forces to the ground.[1,2] Thus, normal gait mechanics require a properly functioning first ray of the foot,[3] and loss of range of motion at this joint can lead to gait abnormalities and pathologic disorders that present elsewhere in the lower extremity.[4,5] In sports, loss of range of motion has been documented as a sequela of traumatic injury[6,7] and has also been shown in dance,[8] soccer,[9] and American football.[10,11] Problems with first metatarsophalangeal joint function may develop and remain asymptomatic.[4]
In sports, especially those that involve running and sprinting, the first ray of the foot and, in particular, the first metatarsophalangeal joint are important to optimal performance.[7] The first metatarsophalangeal joint bears the full weight of the body at the toe-off phase of gait, and via the windlass mechanism helps lock the foot into a stable lever for propulsion.[12,13] With this in mind, it seems that any restrictions to this joint have the potential to hinder athletic activity.
Concerning the lower extremity, playing basketball exerts tremendous stresses on the foot of the player owing to the nature of the sport, with its necessary sprinting, pivoting, and jumping. Also, the shoe-surface interaction may play a part: a soft pliant shoe and an unyielding surface.[10] The relationship between the shoe and the surface was noted as long as ago as 1976,[10] with further research stating that the properties of surfaces are a factor to consider in chronic injuries.[14] It is possible that athletes undergo repetitive microtrauma to their feet, which may be one factor in the etiology of hallux rigidus,[15] and also why the development of this may be asymptomatic, as the critical loads are below the threshold for acute injury, although damage may occur.[16]
Hallux rigidus is generally seen as a chronic condition that is the end result of repeated trauma to the first metatarsophalangeal joint,[6,7,9] with the acute condition generally referred to as turf toe.[17] Although there is no set standard of anatomical or pathologic criteria currently existing to define this condition, it is generally recognized as a plantar capsule sprain, or any capsular disruption of the joint.[11,18] Complete dislocation, however, is not included in this description. The loss of dorsiflexion, which is characteristic of hallux rigidus, has been identified as a long-term sequela of turf toe.[7,17,19]
For an athlete, hallux rigidus not only may adversely affect sports performance but also could lead to further foot problems. Without an adequate range of toe dorsiflexion, the plantar fascia will remain lax and, thus, will not stabilize the longitudinal arch of the foot as the foot bears the weight of the body.[20,21] This places greater stresses on the other structures in the foot.[22] Repeated incidences of turf toe, leading eventually to hallux rigidus, may eventually predispose the athlete to biomechanical dysfunction or further injuries.[12,13] Although an acute episode that is properly diagnosed and treated may resolve without sequelae, it is possible that repetitive loading may cause subacute levels of tissue damage, whether to the ligaments, joint capsule, or articular surfaces, remaining asymptomatic.
It was the intent of this project to evaluate the incidence of hallux limitus in a sample of university basketball players. With the knowledge that this condition may be the result of subacute trauma, measurement of great toe range of motion could indicate whether this type of injury occurs in basketball.

Methods

To determine the likelihood of the development of hallux limitus in a specific sports population, we measured range of motion in a sample of competitive basketball players compared with a cohort of noncompetitive individuals in a similar age range.

Participants

The study participants were collegiate basketball players and college-aged individuals. A total of 123 male university basketball players from three levels of competition (National Collegiate Athletic Association divisions 1, 2, and 3) were measured. An identical number of noncompetitive university students served as a control sample. Both groups were all male owing to the possibility that hormonal variations of the menstrual cycle could affect joint laxity in women.[23-25]

Procedures

The research was approved by the ethics committee of Glassboro State College (Glassboro, New Jersey) before any data collection took place, and all of the procedures were performed in accordance with the Helsinki Declaration on Human Rights. All of the participants signed a written informed consent form before data collection.
Great toe range of motion was measured with a universal goniometer because this has been shown to be a reliable and valid instrument when used to measure the first metatarsophalangeal joint.[26] One arm was aligned with the first metatarsal and the other with the proximal phalanx of the great toe. The toe was then passively dorsiflexed while maintaining the alignment of the goniometer arms. The angle in degrees of movement was noted at the end point of the movement. All of the data used in this study were collected by the investigator (P.T.).
For the basketball players, measurements were taken before practice to ensure similarity of conditions, to limit the effect that physical exertion might have on range of motion, and, thus, to decrease variability within the study groups. Similarly, all of the noncompetitive individuals were measured before any strenuous physical activities.

Validation of the Test Procedures

Before data collection, the repeatability of the test method was examined by having the examiner take measurements on a sample of 15 volunteers on 3 consecutive days. The intraclass correlation coefficient of 0.93 indicated that the test method was repeatable and accurate, within the limits of the instrument.

Statistical Analysis

Data were analyzed with an independent groups t test to compare the range of motion measurements using a statistical software program (StatView 5.0.1; SAS Institute Inc, Cary, North Carolina), with α = 0.05 and a power of 0.8 stated as the values needed to detect a difference between the two groups.

Results

The results of the data analysis indicate a significant difference in the range of motion of the first metatarsophalangeal joint when compared between basketball players and noncompetitive individuals. The mean ± SD range of motion of the noncompetitive individuals (87.76° ± 11.69°) was significantly greater than that of the basketball players (66.41° ± 15.98°) (t = 16.84; P < .001). This difference was 21.35°, which corresponds to approximately 30% of the expected range of motion at this joint.

Discussion

Playing basketball, as with most sports, affects the body in various ways, either positively or negatively. Owing to the nature of the sport, injuries to the feet are common (NCAA Injury Surveillance 1990).[19] These repeated insults might, in some cases, lead to deviance in the normal functioning of the foot, with one of these alterations being hallux rigidus.
Most of the participants in this investigation gave no history of injury to the first metatarsophalangeal joint. This would thus seem to support the premise that repeated cyclic loads below the injury threshold may combine to produce a fatigue effect.[16] The marked limit in great toe range of motion seems to indicate previous trauma to the joint, yet, for the most part, there was no history of an acute injury.
Another factor, similar to the aforementioned one, is also a result of the nature of the sport: basketball involves a considerable amount of jumping. In landing from a jump, there is very high forefoot loading, which helps attenuate the shock of landing.[27] It seems likely that this repetitive loading at such high values could be another contributing factor to the etiology of hallux rigidus in the basketball players examined. Such high forefoot loading can also be seen in ballet, where the incidence of hallux rigidus has been previously noted.[28,29]
Further biomechanical factors affecting the joint involve the sprinting and pivoting necessary for play. These actions generally require a notable amount of extension of the joint. Repeated hyperextension, while seemingly a minor incident, will put excessive strains on the ligaments and plantar capsule of the metatarsophalangeal joints. One author noted that repetitive, especially untreated, insults to this joint probably lead to osteoarthritis and ankylosing of the joint. This progressively limited range of motion at the joint is what is generally classified as hallux rigidus, and it seems to be a long-term consequence of turf toe injuries.[18]
The results of this investigation were similar to those of a previous investigation in which range of motion of the great toe was measured. The authors found a significant (P < .001) decrease in range of motion of the first metatarsophalangeal joint when comparing injured versus uninjured sides of the same athlete. The participants in this instance were football players with definitive diagnoses of turf toe injuries.[18]
Results from a previous investigation indicated that 21% of the 459 individuals who took part in a survey on the prevalence of foot pain and deformity had hallux deformities.[30] Additional research also reported that the presence of foot symptoms does not necessarily correlate with the presence of dysfunction and that patients may be experiencing dysfunction without having any accompanying symptoms.[31]
The basketball players who participated in this investigation exhibited a similar loss of range of motion as the football players noted previously herein. However, only three of the 123 basketball players examined reported an acute case of turf toe, with another having had surgery on his first metatarsophalangeal joint. This would seem to coincide with a report concerning hallux rigidus in which six individuals, of seven involved, could not remember any specific incident leading to the injury.[32] The author stated that repetitive unrecognized minor incidents are likely to be what leads to the degenerative changes described as hallux rigidus.[32]
The results of this investigation showed a significant loss of dorsiflexion of the first metatarsophalangeal joint. These data seem to coincide with the results of a previous study that measured dorsiflexion of the metatarsophalangeal joint in football players.[18] Note that the present research did not record diagnoses of injury to the first metatarsophalangeal joint.
Also, the participants in the present research were different from those involved in previous studies. For all but three of the participants there was no history of trauma to the first metatarsophalangeal joint. Furthermore, the athletes studied were basketball players. Most other studies examined athletes engaged in outdoor sports, especially those on artificial turf (soccer and American football). This artificial turf playing surface does seem to be a predisposing factor for an acute injury of this type.[10,14,33,34]
The present results agree with previous work that showed a decrease in range of motion at the first metatarsophalangeal joint as a result of strenuous long-term sporting activity.[6-9,19] What is lacking is an exact reason for this discrepancy between the two groups studied in this investigation regarding first metatarsophalangeal joint range of motion.
The theory of repeated loads below the injury threshold may account for this condition.[35] Another explanation, similar in nature to the previous one, is the cumulative effect of such high forefoot loading.[7,11,19,27] The end result, however, may be that repetitive, unrecognized, and untreated trauma to this joint has an overall effect on the development of hallux rigidus in collegiate basketball players. Because it has been noted that this condition stems usually from what is classified as a turf toe injury, it can be reasonably stated that this injury does occur in collegiate basketball players, although at a subacute level.
A significant difference between this and previous studies is the population groups examined. However, the results were similar in that a loss of range of motion was seen in both types of groups. It can then be surmised that turf toe injuries do occur in basketball players, with long-term sequelae similar to those of sports played on artificial turf. Further research is warranted in this area to determine exactly what the causes of this type of turf toe are and their further effects on this population.
Most radiographic analyses of joints identified as having hallux rigidus have yielded similar results. Almost all have shown marked degenerative changes. Osteochrondritis dissecans has been noted, and in most cases, osteophytes on the dorsal surface of the metatarsal base have been observed.[6,15,18,32] These changes were most frequently observed at the same site: on the metatarsal base between the apex of the dome and the dorsal margin. This seems to indicate a trauma in which the proximal phalange is extended and axially loaded such that it affects the metatarsal.[11,32] The presence of an osteophyte on the metatarsal head seems to support this possible mechanism. It would also provide a means by which dorsiflexion is limited. Although such exostoses have been noted, there is also soft tissue in the area that, when scarred, could also limit range of motion. Scarring of para-articular tissues has previously been noted in an in vitro examination of individuals with hallux rigidus.[36]
It seems that further research is needed in this area with respect to sports participants and the changes induced by this injury. It would be interesting to know what effect hallux rigidus has on the biomechanics of the foot. Compensatory changes in gait as a result of first metatarsophalangeal joint restrictions have been proposed, and these may lead to unusual loading on the other structures, with pathologic consequences.[37,38] Also, perhaps more extensive investigation could determine what, if any, morphologic changes are occurring in the first metatarsophalangeal joint. Another area to examine would be to determine whether this condition developed in basketball players over a long period or whether it preexisted. A longitudinal study would be helpful in this respect. Furthering this line of reasoning, it would be useful to know whether other injuries affect the first metatarsophalangeal joint. In basketball, there are numerous ankle sprains.[39,40] With inversion sprains, there is a secondary muscular inhibition of the peroneus longus muscle.[41,42] Because the peroneus longus muscle stabilizes the first metatarsal head against the support surface,[43] lack of stabilization results in first metatarsal dorsiflexion and jamming of the first metatarsophalangeal joint. Therefore, ankle sprains may also be a hidden etiology of hallux rigidus. As a further study, assessing athletes with a history of ankle sprain to evaluate any changes in first metatarsophalangeal range of motion may be of clinical interest.
Note that hallux rigidus is a progressive condition and most likely the result of trauma, either acute or subacute. A variety of physical changes in and around the joint are associated with this condition.[44,45] Osteochondritis dissecans, dorsal osteophytes/exostoses, scarring of soft tissues, flexion contractures, and degenerative hypertrophic osteoarthritis all play a role in the development of this condition.[6,44] As it relates to clinical relevance, the loss of an effective windlass mechanism can affect gait and alter the normal biomechanics.[5,46] As has been noted, the pathologic abnormalities that stem from altered gait, and the attendant change in coupled motions as a result of restricted range of motion at the hallux and transmission of forces, may affect other parts the body.[4,47] Therefore, clinicians should be aware of sports participation history as a potential influencing factor on foot structure and gait biomechanics, and these could affect the etiology of symptoms presenting elsewhere in the kinetic chain.

Financial Disclosure

None reported.

Conflicts of Interest

None reported.

References

  1. MannRA, HagyJL:The function of the toes in walking, jogging and running. Clin Orthop Relat Res142: 24, 1979.
  2. Donatelli R: The Biomechanics of the Foot and Ankle, 2nd Ed, FA Davis Co, Philadelphia, 1996.
  3. LevangiePK, NorkinCC: Joint Structure and Function: A Comprehensive Analysis, 5th Ed, FA Davis Co, Philadelphia, 2011.
  4. DananbergHJ:Gait style as an etiology to chronic postural pain: part I. Functional hallux limitus. JAPMA83: 433, 1993.
  5. HallC, NesterCJ:Sagittal plane compensations for artificially induced limitation of the first metatarsophalangeal joint: a preliminary study. JAPMA94: 269, 2004.
  6. LichniakJE:Hallux limitus in the athlete. Clin Podiatr Med Surg14: 407, 1997.
  7. NihalA, TrepmanE, NagD:First ray disorders in athletes. Sports Med Arthrosc17: 160, 2009.
  8. KadelNJ:Foot and ankle injuries in dance. Phys Med Rehabil Clin N Am17: 813, 2006.
  9. SteinackerT, SteuerM, HoltkeV:Injuries and overload-damages at players of the German lady-soccer-national-team [in German]. Sportverletz Sportschaden19: 33, 2005.
  10. BowersKDJr, MartinRB:Turf-toe: a shoe-surface related football injury. Med Sci Sports8: 81, 1976.
  11. ClantonTO, ButlerJE, EggertA:Injuries to the metatarsophalangeal joints in athletes. Foot Ankle7: 162, 1986.
  12. GarciaCA, HoffmanSL, HastingsMK, et al: Effect of metatarsal phalangeal joint extension on plantar soft tissue stiffness and thickness. Foot18: 61, 2008.
  13. FullerEA:The windlass mechanism of the foot: a mechanical model to explain pathology. JAPMA90: 35, 2000.
  14. NiggBM, SegesserB:The influence of playing surfaces on the load on the locomotor system and on football and tennis injuries. Sports Med5: 375, 1988.
  15. HawkinsBJ, HaddadRJ Jr: Hallux rigidus. Clin Sports Med7: 37, 1988.
  16. NiggBM:Biomechanics, load analysis and sports injuries in the lower extremities. Sports Med2: 367, 1985.
  17. ClantonTO, FordJJ:Turf toe injury. Clin Sports Med13: 731, 1994.
  18. RodeoSA, O'BrienS, WarrenRF, et al: Turf-toe: an analysis of metatarsophalangeal joint sprains in professional football players. Am J Sports Med18: 280, 1990.
  19. HockenburyRT:Forefoot problems in athletes. Med Sci Sports Exerc31 (suppl): S448, 1999.
  20. HetheringtonVJ, JohnsonRE, AlbrittonJS:Necessary dorsiflexion of the first metatarsophalangeal joint during gait. J Foot Surg29: 218, 1990.
  21. Kappel-BargasA, WoolfRD, CornwallMW, et al: The windlass mechanism during normal walking and passive first metatarsalphalangeal joint extension. Clin Biomech13: 190, 1998.
  22. Bojsen-MollerF, LamoreuxL:Significance of free-dorsiflexion of the toes in walking. Acta Orthop Scand50: 471, 1979.
  23. DragooJL, CastilloTN, KorotkovaTA, et al: Trends in serum relaxin concentration among elite collegiate female athletes. Int J Women's Health3: 19, 2011.
  24. ParkSK, StefanyshynDJ, RamageB, et al: Alterations in knee joint laxity during the menstrual cycle in healthy women leads to increases in joint loads during selected athletic movements. Am J Sports Med37: 1169, 2009.
  25. EilingE, BryantAL, PetersenW, et al: Effects of menstrual-cycle hormone fluctuations on musculotendinous stiffness and knee joint laxity. Knee Surg Sports Traumatol Arthrosc15: 126, 2007.
  26. HoganD, KiddR:The reliability and validity of goniometers when measuring the first metatarsophalangeal joint in stance. Australas J Podiatr Med35: 19, 2001.
  27. GrossTS, NelsonRC:The shock attenuation role of the ankle during landing from a vertical jump. Med Sci Sports Exerc20: 506, 1988.
  28. KadelNJ:Foot and ankle injuries in dance. Phys Med Rehabil Clin N Am17: 813, 2006.
  29. RietveldAB:Dancers' and musicians' injuries. Clin Rheumatol32: 425, 2013.
  30. BenvenutiF, FerrucciL, GuralnikJM, et al: Foot pain and disability in older persons: an epidemiologic survey. J Am Geriatr Soc43: 479, 1995.
  31. BalintGP, KordaJ, HangodyL, et al: Regional musculoskeletal conditions: foot and ankle disorders. Best Pract Res Clin Rheumatol17: 87, 2003.
  32. McMasterMJ:The pathogenesis of hallux rigidus. J Bone Joint Surg Br60: 82, 1978.
  33. PasanenK, ParkkariJ, RossiL, et al: Artificial playing surface increases the injury risk in pivoting indoor sports: a prospective one-season follow-up study in Finnish female floorball. Br J Sports Med42: 194, 2008.
  34. TaylorSA, FabricantPD, KhairMM, et al: A review of synthetic playing surfaces, the shoe-surface interface, and lower extremity injuries in athletes. Phys Sportsmed40: 66, 2012.
  35. CawleyPW, HeidtRSJr, ScrantonPEJr, et al: Physiologic axial load, frictional resistance, and the football shoe-surface interface. Foot Ankle Int24: 551, 2003.
  36. ShereffMJ, BejjaniFJ, KummerFJ:Kinematics of the first metatarsophalangeal joint. J Bone Joint Surg Am68: 392, 1986.
  37. BevanL, HarradineP, DurrantB:The effect of temporary immobilisation of the 1st metatarsophalangeal joint upon in-shoe gait analysis parameters: a preliminary study. Br J Podiatry7: 54, 2004.
  38. PayneC, ChuterV, MillerK:Sensitivity and specificity of the functional hallux limitus test to predict foot function. JAPMA92: 269, 2002.
  39. WatermanBR, OwensBD, DaveyS, et al: The epidemiology of ankle sprains in the United States. J Bone Joint Surg Am92: 2279, 2010.
  40. FongDT, HongY, ChanLK, et al: A systematic review on ankle injury and ankle sprain in sports. Sports Med37: 73, 2007.
  41. PalmieriRM, IngersollCD, HoffmanMA, et al: Arthrogenic muscle response to a simulated ankle joint effusion. Br J Sports Med38: 26, 2004.
  42. KnightAC, WeimarWH:Effects of previous lateral ankle sprain and taping on the latency of the peroneus longus. Sports Biomech11: 48, 2012.
  43. GlasoeWM, YackHJ, SaltzmanCL:Anatomy and biomechanics of the first ray. Phys Ther79: 854, 1999.
  44. SchweitzerME, MaheshwariS, ShabshinN:Hallux valgus and hallux rigidus: MRI findings. Clin Imaging23: 397, 1999.
  45. CamastaCA:Hallux limitus and hallux rigidus: clinical examination, radiographic findings, and natural history. Clin Podiatr Med Surg13: 423, 1996.
  46. ThordarsonDB, SchmotzerH, ChonJ, et al: Dynamic support of the human longitudinal arch: a biomechanical evaluation. Clin Orthop Relat Res316: 165, 1995.
  47. DurrantB, ChockalingamN:Functional hallux limitus: a review. JAPMA99: 236, 2009.

Article Metrics

Citations

Article Access Statistics

Multiple requests from the same IP address are counted as one view.