Skip to Content
  • Article
  • Open Access

1 March 2012

A Historical and Current Analysis for the DPM Acquiring an MD or DO Degree and an Unrestricted Medical License

Office of Education, Planning, and Research, Family Medicine/Public Health/Biomedical Informatics, Nova Southeastern University College of Osteopathic Medicine, 3200 S University, Fort Lauderdale, FL 33328, USA

Abstract

The podiatric medical profession has evolved substantially in the past 80 years. This evolution includes major changes in scope, in the requirements necessary to enter a podiatric medical school, and in the curriculum that must be completed to earn the degree of Doctor of Podiatric Medicine. Entrance requirements to the schools are now identical to the prerequisites for admission to MD and DO institutions, and licensure requires the completion of graduate medical education. Much of the curriculum also is the same as it is in MD and DO schools. In the past decade, discussion focusing on the ability of the DPM to acquire the MD or DO degree has intensified. An analysis is provided using a historical context regarding this potential initiative.
In the 1930s, an article in the Journal of the National Association of Chiropodists, the precursor to the Journal of the American Podiatric Medical Association and, before that, the Journal of the American Podiatry Association, offered a caution to podiatric physicians (then chiropodists) who prescribed “arch supports,” a modality that was introduced to the profession during that period. The author of the article expressed strong concern that chiropodists using such devices would be “antagonizing the physician,” something that podiatric medicine almost always has been alleged to have done as the profession evolved over the decades. Indeed, many of the current initiatives in podiatric medicine and more than likely many of those that will come after us in the future will likely result in what will be perceived by some as “antagonizing the physician. [1,2]” Although podiatric medicine hardly resembles what it was 80 years ago, the present movement by many DPMs to also acquire an MD or DO degree and an unrestricted medical license has escalated significantly since 2000.

History of Oral and Maxillofacial Surgery and the Dual Degree: Lessons Learned

Indeed, podiatric medicine is not the only doctoral-level health profession in which there was an issue of acquiring a dual degree and an unrestricted medical license. For many decades, beginning at the dental school of Harvard University, dentists who were oral and maxillofacial residents also completed additional training to receive the MD degree and obtain an unrestricted medical license. This was not for the purpose of providing a channel to leave the dental profession through some “back door” to practice a discipline other than oral maxillofacial surgery but rather to bring added value to dental practice. In the early 1970s, dentists were allowed to take Part I of the National Medical Board, enabling them to be admitted to a medical school with 2 years of advanced standing, which led some oral and maxillofacial surgery training programs to develop a 6-year integrated curriculum with the motivation not being to change the scope of practice but to expand the medical knowledge of the practitioner. At that time, having the MD degree seemed to be a way to resolve the issues for the oral maxillofacial surgeon to be able to admit patients and perform the medical history and physical examination.
In addition, the International Association of Oral and Maxillofacial Surgeons developed guidelines favoring the dual degree. In 1997, 38% of oral maxillofacial surgery training programs offered an integrated MD degree, and 43% of trainees in those programs were candidates for the dual degree. In an editorial in the Journal of Oral and Maxillofacial Surgery, Laskin [3] concluded that the argument for the dual degree is not the ability to provide proper medical care but that it is really territorial. He also raised the question of whether the two-track system (ie, one a DDS/MD degree and the other not electing the dual degree) would have a divisive effect on the specialty. An additional issue Laskin [3] raised is that with managed care looking to save dollars, instances have arisen where practitioners who are able to provide the broadest scope of service, namely, those with the dual degree, are in a better position to compete for such contracts. Finally, he questioned what will happen if competition for patients increases between practitioners with one versus two degrees.[3]

Pre–World War II and Medicine

Similar to the MD and DO, immediately after a DPM completes podiatric medical school, he or she does not yet have adequate knowledge and skills to engage in the broad spectrum of practice in the specialty. In fact, as with the MD/DO, in almost every state a DPM must complete a minimum of 1 year of graduate medical education to be eligible for a license. In essence, similar to the new MD or DO graduate, graduation from podiatric medical school prepares one only to enter graduate medical education as a podiatric medical resident. Indeed, the MD, DO, and DPM are the only health professions that require graduate education after completing the undergraduate professional degree. Decades ago, a person who completed medical school leading to an MD or DO degree was able to go directly into practice. In fact, just before World War II, approximately 90% of MDs and DOs were referred to as general practitioners.
Ophthalmology, otolaryngology, dermatology, and obstetrics and gynecology were the only active specialties in medicine up to June 1933, with ophthalmology being the first to become a specialty in 1916. In 1935, orthopedic surgery, pediatrics, psychiatry and neurology, radiology, and urology were finally approved by the American Board of Medical Specialties, and in 1936, internal medicine and pathology followed. The American Board of Surgery was officially organized as late as January 9, 1937. The formation of the American Board of Surgery was the result of a committee formed a year earlier by the American Surgical Association with representatives from the American College of Surgeons, the American Medical Association, and the Southern, Western, Pacific Coast, and New England Surgical Associations. They recognized for some time the need to differentiate well-trained surgeons who had limited their practice to surgery from doctors in general practice. They also believed that surgery as a field of medicine had matured into a full-time specialty. Many of the other specialty boards were established in 1940 or later, with family medicine not becoming a specialty until 1969, initially having only 15 residency programs compared with 300 in 1979. However, it really was not until after World War II that the movement toward specialty medicine began to accelerate.[4]

Modern Podiatric Medical History

It was not until April 1967 that the Joint Commission on Accreditation of Hospitals permitted DPMs to operate in hospital operating rooms without the presence of a gowned, scrubbed MD or DO surgeon.[5] Three years later, podiatric medicine appeared in Joint Commission on Accreditation of Hospitals standards for the first time. Medicare included DPMs as physicians within the scope of their practice in 1968. In 1977, the American Medical Association and the American College of Surgeons finally recognized the right of podiatric physicians to have practice privileges in hospitals based on their education, training, and experience. Then in 1976, podiatric medical house staff (residents) were recognized by the Joint Commission of Health Care Organizations, which also confirmed that a podiatric physician can perform the medical history and physical examination for patients admitted to hospitals subject to state laws and the determination by the medical staff that high-risk patients require confirmation or endorsement by a duly licensed MD/DO.
After considerable and often heated debate, in 1975, the American Board of Podiatric Surgery was created, initiating the process of board certification in the podiatric medical profession. However, unlike specialties in the MD community, podiatric surgical, orthopedic, and primary care certification did not and still do not require a podiatric physician to limit practice to the area in which board certification is received. Many DPMs fought against creating board certification, arguing that the creation of a board might lock them out of hospital privileges or threaten insurance reimbursement for podiatric surgery if they were not certified. Shortly after, in 1978, the Medical College Admission Test replaced the Colleges of Podiatry Admissions Test, the same year that the American Board of Podiatric Orthopedics and Primary Podiatric Medicine was created.[4]
These steps paved the way for requirements for entrance into podiatric medical schools duplicating those needed for entrance into DO and MD programs. Similar to the DO and MD graduate, today almost all states require those who complete the DPM degree to also complete a 1-year accredited graduate medical education experience to obtain a license to practice. In addition, because of the need to acquire board certification, almost every podiatric medical graduate completes at least 2 years of graduate medical education, and although a 3-year residency requirement is not yet in effect, it is becoming the trend. This is partially due to the profession continuing its efforts to achieve parity among its MD and DO colleagues. Recognition of this is provided by the fact that students in the College of Podiatric Medicine and Surgery at Des Moines University complete the same basic science courses as osteopathic medical students. Reciprocally, osteopathic medical students completed the podiatric medical basic science curriculum when Touro University College of Osteopathic Medicine was founded in San Francisco the 1990s. Increased interest in the combined DPM/DO or MD degree was further catalyzed by the requirements of managed care plans, which have become very pervasive in the reimbursement scheme, as well as the requirement for the acquisition of surgical privileges in hospitals and even freestanding surgery centers.
As a result of the combined phenomena of prerequisites for podiatric medical schools mirroring those required for entrance into MD and DO programs, the establishment of board certification for DPMs, and the requirement that podiatric physicians complete graduate medical education for licensure and board certification, it is perhaps inevitable that the profession is now squarely in the midst of a debate that seems to be leaning toward making the ability of DPMs to acquire a dual degree feasible (ie, DPM/MD or DO).

MD/DO Program for DPMs

In recent years, many podiatric physicians have enrolled in medical schools in the Caribbean, often referred to as “offshore” medical schools. Usually, they were granted credit for part of the curriculum they completed as podiatric medical students, accelerating the time it took to complete the MD program. A large percentage of those who completed that course of study, while receiving an MD degree, did not complete the United States Medical Licensing Examination, which is one of the components necessary for the acquisition of an unrestricted medical license, and most did not complete the graduate medical education that also is required for such a license. However, many do use the additional degree even if they do not hold a license as an MD.
In addition, each year relatively few podiatric medical students apply to and are accepted by a US DO or MD school typically before completing their DPM degree, and most start the MD or DO course of study from the beginning with no credit granted for their podiatric medical studies, although still fewer do receive some credit. Occasionally, credit has been granted for DPM students who are accepted to a US MD school if they succeed in passing Step 1 of the United States Medical Licensing Examination. A few graduates of US podiatric medical schools also have applied to and been accepted into MD or DO schools and typically are granted no credit for any aspect of their podiatric medical schooling. Nova Southeastern University College of Osteopathic Medicine in Fort Lauderdale, Florida, began a special program in 2005 called the DO Program for DPMs. It is an accelerated program granting credit for basic science courses completed at podiatric medical schools. This amounts to 1 year of credit toward the completion of the DO degree.
The program is the only US-approved accelerated DO program for DPMs (American Osteopathic Association). Those who complete the accelerated DO at Nova Southeastern University College of Osteopathic Medicine are not eligible to apply unless they are in a residency program and on track to become board certified by one of the Council on Podiatric Medical Education–approved specialty boards. Therefore, only those currently enrolled in or about to complete a Podiatric Medicine and Surgery Residency (24 or 36 months) may apply to the program. The initial development of the program was completed in close collaboration with the American Board of Podiatric Orthopedics and Primary Podiatric Medicine, designed for the expressed purpose of providing added value to the DPM degree.[6]

Potential Benefits and Liabilities of the Dual Degree

There are many reasons why a DPM may want to pursue an MD or DO degree after or concurrent with efforts to acquire a DPM as well as liabilities that need to be considered. The following subsections list a few of both.
Potential Benefits
  • Added knowledge and skills and a license to better manage the growing number of podiatric medical patients with concurrent medical problems.
  • Expanded knowledge and skills in performing physical examinations.
  • Fill a gap in rural and underserved communities that have few or no primary care and podiatric physicians.
  • Potential to perform physical examinations for other podiatric physicians in hospitals that require a fully licensed physician to do so or that limit the privileges of podiatric physicians in this area of patient assessment. Such dually trained podiatric physicians (DPM/DO or MD) have a better understanding of the stresses of podiatric surgical procedures on a patient than do physicians without such podiatric medical knowledge.
  • Potential added attractiveness of DPMs with a DO/MD to managed care organizations.
  • Potential added benefit in the process of acquiring hospital privileges at institutions that still restrict privileges for DPMs.
  • Added confidence by some patients, especially those with concurrent health problems.
  • Avoid borderline issues regarding the scope of podiatric medical practice. For example, the DPM/DO would be able to perform surgery in anatomical areas in which they have received training but are restricted by state statute. Currently, DPM graduates of podiatric medical residency programs may have been trained to do ankle surgery or perform amputations. However, they may not have the legal right to do so in states that prohibit this type of intervention. Similarly, issues may be avoided concerning patients who may have skin, soft-tissue lesions, or bony conditions that are partly above or contiguous with whatever the anatomical line is for the legal scope of practice for DPMs in the state in which they practice.
  • Potential to further enhance relationships with DOs and MDs to a greater degree, including increased ability to receive referrals from them.
  • Eligibility for membership in the American Osteopathic Association and the American Medical Association.
  • Graduate of an American medical school from a program approved by an American medical accrediting body (ie, American Osteopathic Association, Liaison Commission on Medical Education).
  • Potential to improve recognition of DPMs by the various federal services (eg, military, Commissioned Corps of the US Public Health Service, and Department of Veterans Affairs).
  • Eligible for a variety of insurance packages available only from certain medical organizations to licensed MDs or DOs.
  • Potentially eligible for acceptance by and higher reimbursement from managed care organizations that discriminate against non-MDs/DOs for the same procedures/services performed.
  • Enhanced opportunity for student loan forgiveness when practicing in medically underserved areas. This will increase access to podiatric medical care by the population in these areas, especially those at high risk (eg, people with diabetes, older adults, and chronically ill individuals).
Potential Liabilities
  • Need to complete additional years of training.
  • Increased financial burden on DPM graduates who already have large student loans.
  • Concern about cost-effectiveness: will additional income be generated by DPMs with dual degrees that make it practical to pursue the dual degree?
  • Concerns about potential competitiveness between DPMs with and without dual degrees.
  • Fear that there will be a high rate of those who complete the program who will not remain in podiatric medicine, a large percentage pursuing training in other medical specialties.
  • Fear that podiatric medicine will not remain as a separate profession or be integrated as a specialty of medicine or will become absorbed into an existing medical specialty.

Conclusions

The MD or DO degree and the unrestricted medical license are perceived to be needed or sought by many podiatric physicians. Indeed, the DPM diagnoses problems affecting the pedal extremity with little limitation, prescribes and administers virtually any drug, and can perform surgery in almost any area within the bounds of the specialty. Therefore, by definition, the DPM is a physician. However, an increasing number in the profession believe that having an unrestricted medical license will provide added value to how they are perceived (by organized medicine and the public), to how they practice, and to the public that they serve. These factors are similar to those in dentistry and in oral and maxillofacial surgery residencies that often also complete an MD or DO degree.
Furthermore, since the preparatory education, prerequisite courses for entrance to professional school, and even the course of study completed by the MD, DO, and DPM have most of the same components, the option could be made available for a DPM to acquire an MD or DO degree. However, it makes no sense for DPMs who pursue an MD or DO track to duplicate what they have already learned, and, therefore, they should be permitted to do so in an accelerated period. There likely can be multiple pathways to achieve such a goal. However, these pathways need to be identified, explored, piloted, and, after an appropriate forum, evaluated and debated. As a result of such a process, it can be concluded what is feasible and in the best interest of the public. Ultimately, this will lead to a determination of what course the podiatric medical profession should adopt and pursue vigorously. Indeed, the ultimate purpose of such an initiative in the profession should be to permit this phase of its evolution to continue.
The historical origins of and the path leading to the MD or DO degree and the unrestricted medical license after or concurrent with the acquisition of the DPM degree has been discussed. However, it is essential, if such a direction is pursued, that it not only be because it is perceived as being in the profession’s best interest but also because it is in the best interest of the patients and the public that it serves. In fact, it is axiomatic that if the best interest of the public and the patients are served, the profession will also be served. It seems, based on the trajectory that podiatric medicine has taken as a profession during the past 65 years, that such a course will ultimately be attempted. Many questions will be asked by some in the profession, not the least of which will be whether it will survive as a specialty. However, the need for a specialty focused on the prevention, diagnosis, and medical and surgical care of the pedal extremity will not only continue but likely will escalate based on demographics (ie, the aging of America), the epidemic of diabetes, and the increasing prevalence of chronic diseases. How that need will continue to be met is a question that must be addressed. Kramer[7] remarks in a communication in Academic Medicine, “Medical education might become more effective and efficient if we gave up the idea of training all medical students identically for the first four years and allowed them to differentiate from one another at the beginning, as they do on most fields of study.”(p7)

Financial Disclosure:

None reported.

Conflict of Interest:

None reported.

References

  1. Bates, JE, Holloway, LM. :A Fast Pace Forward and Chronicles of American Podiatry: American Podiatric Medical Association (75th Anniversary),Pennsylvania College of Podiatric Medicine. ,Philadelphia, 1987.
  2. American Podiatric Medical Association, Department of Professional Affairs: History and Current Practice of Podiatric Medicine, American Podiatric Medical Association, Washington, DC, 1984.
  3. Laskin, DM: The MD degree: a panacea or a problem [editorial]?J Oral Maxillofac Surg55: 209, 1997.
  4. Levy, LA: The Evolution of Podiatric Medical Practice and Formal Education: Chronological History.,” in Principles and Practice of Podiatric Medicine, 2nd Ed, Vol 1, edited byLevy, LA, VIHetherington, p1-1, Data Trace, Brooklandville, MD, 2006.
  5. Bulletin 44, Joint Commission on Accreditation of Hospitals, April1967, Oakbrook Terrace, IL.
  6. DO Program for DPMs [brochure], Nova Southeastern University College of Osteopathic Medicine, Fort Lauderdale, FL, 2006.
  7. Kramer, TAM: Should medical students major in a specialty?Acad Med85: 1104, 2010.

Article Metrics

Citations

Article Access Statistics

Multiple requests from the same IP address are counted as one view.