Review Reports
- Salete M. Newton and
- Phillip E. Klebba *
Reviewer 1: Anonymous Reviewer 2: Anonymous
Round 1
Reviewer 1 Report
Comments and Suggestions for Authors The manuscript by Newton and Klebba entitled "Internal Ion Pairs Control Transport through TonB-dependent Siderophore Receptors" investigates the role of ion pairs within FepA and FhuA. The hypothesis is approached by mutating a set of residues (identified by sequence and structure analysis of the two proteins) to alanines and measuring siderophore uptake (plates and fluorescence assay), as well as colicin susceptibility. The structural effects are also investigated by SDS-PAGE and Western blots. The authors also measured binding affinities with fluorescence. The hypothesis that conserved residues are important for the function is rather straightforward, however, to distinguish structural and functional effects of each residue needs experimental validation. The main issue is the paper is that many of the FepA mutants (and one of FhuA) were unstable (Fig. 5), the results obtained with those mutants shown in previous figures should be at least annotated as cautionary. For instance, the very low susceptibility to colicin for R75 in Fig. 4 should be marked with at least "?" (if not completely excluded from the figure?), as it is impossible to say how much of the effect is due to proteolysis. The authors need to rewrite the result section taking that important control into account when interpreting all presented results. This applies also to Fig. 6, where for instance again with R75A the lack of uptake can be simply explained by the lack of FepA, and not by the importance of R75. The authors discuss it in l. 346-373, suggesting large structural changes to FepA. In my opinion, the results presented in the paper have to be reevaluated, and the effects of removing a charge (mutation to alanine) vs structural effects of disrupting the proteins clearly separated. If feasible, reproducing the results of the questionable mutants in ∆ompT background could shed some light. Fig. 2 is extremely difficult to read. I can track the cyan lines and a few of the other colors, but the rest is just incomprehensible, in particular in the top part of the figure. The authors need to find a better way to represent those pairs, or split the figure into many subfigures that show only some of the pairs (supplementary), and only show the most important ones in the main figure. I have an issue with the references in the paper. The numbering of references does not seem to follow an order, as the first reference cited is 5? (L. 33). More concerning, out of 94 cited papers, 22 are authored by at least one of the authors of the paper. That is 23%. This is excessive even for highly accomplished researchers. Of minor concern, the references section needs serious proofreading, as there is no consistency in journal names (eg. "The Journal of biological chemistry" in 1 vs "J Biol Chem" in 4). L. 42 should read "electron transport chain". L. 62-72. The outer membrane in Gram-negative bacteria is generally fully permeable due to the presence of unspecific porins, and there is no known biochemical mechanism that could build a chemiosmotic gradient over the outer membrane (no known pumps). Establishing and maintaining gradient would require energy input from the periplasm. The wording of the paper suggests the porins are the main reason for lack of such a gradient, whereas in reality, there is no need for a proton-motive force in the outer membrane.Author Response
Please see the attached file.
Author Response File:
Author Response.pdf
Reviewer 2 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsThe article titled "Internal Ion Pairs Control Transport through TonB-dependent Siderophore Receptors" describes in detail several ionic interactions necessary for binding and internalizing siderophores in diverse cellular contexts. However, Figure 2 is excessively confusing and does not provide the necessary information that the authors claim. It is suggested that a clearer way be found to represent the presence of these interactions in the form of a primary sequence alignment. Likewise, it is suggested that the visualization of the tertiary structures of these proteins highlight the ion pairs involved in their function more clearly with the use of inserts and transparencies that allow for a clearer differentiation of those interactions (Fig. 1). Furthermore, what percentage of these pairs are found on the solvent-exposed surface in other proteins? And even more importantly, which of these interactions are essential for stabilizing the binding of the corresponding siderophore, besides site 2? On the other hand, Table 2 uses italic characters interchangeably, which also causes some confusion. It is also recommended that the data in Figure 6 be filtered or that the F/Fo scale be changed, since the role of these salt bridges in the function of the corresponding proteins is clear, and the excessive signal noise obscures the interpretations. It is suggested that each curve be adjusted and these differences clarified.
In sum, it's a good piece of work, although it's still far from being published in its current form.
Author Response
Please see the attached file.
Author Response File:
Author Response.pdf
Round 2
Reviewer 1 Report
Comments and Suggestions for Authors The authors have now improved the presentation of the manuscript and most importantly, clarified the confounding effect of protein degradation in the ∆ompT background. I appreciate the effort put into this improvement, yet the authors need to still be careful in their conclusions about the results. Fig 5a for instance shows no function for the mutants that also exhibited proteolysis (compared to Fig 2C), so I see the careful discussion section being appropriate. Probably only the R126 is a real result given it's the only one that did not show any degradation in Fig 2C. I would appreciate if the authors marked the mutants that caused proteolysis in the subsequent figures, so the reader does not need to skip back and forth to Fig 2 for comparison. Despite those improvements, I cannot assess the reasonability of citing over 20 of own papers for this article. There are only a few experiments in this article: the siderophore nutrition test, colicin uptake and FeEnt uptake. Moreover, I still don't see any improvement to the references section, for instance the inconsistent naming of cited articles ("The journal of biological chemistry" in ref 1 and "J Biol Chem" in ref 4, just to show the very first example). Such accomplished authors that have produced dozens of articles throughout their careers should be able to produce a coherent and consistent reference section. Especially of their own articles. The authors did not comment on that point in their response to my review.Author Response
Please see the attached file.
Author Response File:
Author Response.pdf