Review Reports
- Mauricio J. Machado 1,
- Fernanda R. Jacinavicius 1 and
- Maria Paula C. Schneider 2,*
- et al.
Reviewer 1: Anonymous Reviewer 2: Anonymous Reviewer 3: Anonymous
Round 1
Reviewer 1 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsDear authors
Regarding the review of the manuscript entitled " Genomic and metabolomic insights from Amazonian Oyster-Associated Cyanobacteria", the manuscript is well written, and the experiments were well designed. This manuscript requires additional details and essential corrections and then it will be resubmitted to Phycology.
General comments
Title: Suggest a more captivating title that highlights the uniqueness of the research. i.e., the taxonomic results should be expressed in the title rather than metabolic
Abstract:
- Carefully review and correct any typographical errors.
- Address any grammatical issues to enhance clarity.
- The standard contents of the abstract were not followed
- More quantitative results should be added to the abstract
- /
Introduction:
- The introduction concise and informative
- Enhance the overall English language usage.
- Improve the flow of the introduction for better coherence.
- Integrate more citations to support your statements. Clearly articulate the study's objectives and consider incorporating graphical representations for clarity.
- Align the objectives with the actual results to ensure completeness.
- A novelty statement should be added in the last paragraph of the introduction, especially since you mentioned Novel cyanobacteria in the abstract
Material and Methodology:
- Expand and provide more detailed information in the Materials and Methods section.
- L71 The strains CENA 647 and CENA 648 were isolated which strains, you have to be accurate and mention if it is cyanobacteria or others
- L75 what do you mean with The strains were isolated and maintained in (unicyanobacterial) BG-11 culture medium
Results and Discussion:
- Expand and provide more detailed information in the Results and Discussion section.
- Figure 1, the light microscope photos are low quality and did not show the structure of the filament and should be modified
- Figure 2 also the resolution is bad and di not show any thing
- Inspite the authors obtained a lot of results and performed several techniques, the discussion is weak and should be improved
- Conclusion:
The conclusion should be strong and summarize the whole study and the obtained results. The conclusion should
Author Response
Dear reviewer,
We have followed your suggestions and changed the title, revised the language, expandend on details about the isolation of the strains, improved the quality of figures and rewrote the conclusions. The especific details are in the Response Letter attatched.
All authors would like to thank you immensily for your contributions to the improvement of our manuscript.
Author Response File:
Author Response.pdf
Reviewer 2 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsAttached as pdf.
Comments for author File:
Comments.pdf
Author Response
Dear reviewer,
We have followed your suggestions and expandend on details about the isolation of the strains, improved the quality of figures and updated the version of our bioinformatic tools. The especific details are in the Response Letter attatched.
All authors would like to thank you immensily for your contributions to the improvement of our manuscript.
Author Response File:
Author Response.pdf
Reviewer 3 Report
Comments and Suggestions for Authors-
Inappropriate methodology for isolate assembly
Strain CENA647 (a unicyanobacterial isolate) was processed using metagenomic assembly (Flye with -meta) and binning (SemiBin2). This is methodologically incorrect. The authors must clarify potential contamination or re-assemble using standard isolate pipelines. -
Taxonomic placement of CENA648 is unresolved and inconsistently reported
CENA648 clusters with Nodosilineales by 16S rRNA but with Oculatellales by phylogenomics, with ANI/DDH below species thresholds. Yet it is repeatedly called "Nodosilineales cyanobacterium". The authors must either resolve the conflict or refer to it only as Cyanobacterium sp. CENA648. -
Overinterpretation of results without sufficient evidence
Claims about the rarity and unique organization of egtE in ergothioneine biosynthesis are based solely on in silico predictions without systematic genomic survey or functional validation. Similarly, metal tolerance and osmoregulation inferences lack transcriptomic or phenotypic support. These should be toned down to hypothesis-generating statements.
Author Response
Dear reviewer,
We have followed your suggestions and revised the language, toned down our interpretations, changed the way we report the taxonomic placement of CENA648 and provide clarity towards our decision on using our assembly method. The especific details are in the Response Letter attatched.
All authors would like to thank you immensily for your contributions to the improvement of our manuscript.
Author Response File:
Author Response.pdf
Round 2
Reviewer 1 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsThe authors considered all the comments that I made in the first version of this manuscript
Comments on the Quality of English LanguageThe authors considered all the comments that I made in the first version of this manuscript
Author Response
We would like to thank the reviewer for all of the insightful comments.
Have a great week!
Reviewer 3 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsThe manuscript has been improved and can be accepted in its current form.
Author Response
We would like to thank the reviewer for all of the insightful comments.
Have a great week!