Review Reports
- Rachel Smid 1,
- Emma MacInnis 1 and
- Shannon Freeman 2,*
- et al.
Reviewer 1: Jasmina Starc Reviewer 2: Anonymous
Round 1
Reviewer 1 Report
Dear Authors,
The manuscript addresses an important and still relevant question: how long-term care staff experienced work during active COVID-19 outbreaks. The focus on an outbreak as a specific work-related and organizational context is appropriate, since staff experiences during an active outbreak differ from broader experiences of working during the pandemic. During an outbreak, infection risk, exposure to death, staffing shortages, limitations in personal protective equipment, resident isolation, and decision-making pressure become substantially intensified.
The manuscript is generally well structured and thematically suitable for the journal COVID. The qualitative material is rich, and participants provide compelling insights into fear, moral distress, grief, increased workload, limited resources, leadership, peer support, and the perceived role of vaccination. Nevertheless, in its current form, the manuscript does not yet reach the level of methodological transparency and analytical depth required for publication. The main issue is not the relevance of the topic, but insufficiently clear reporting on sampling, the thematic analysis procedure, trustworthiness, and the specific contribution of the study to existing research on long-term care during the COVID-19 pandemic.
I therefore recommend major revision. The authors should strengthen the methodological reporting, more clearly justify the research gap related to active outbreaks and the rural/northern context, and reshape the discussion from a descriptive comparison with previous studies into a more interpretative synthsis of the findings.
Comments for author File:
Comments.pdf
Author Response
|
Reviewer Comments |
Authors’ Responses |
|
Reviewer 1 |
|
|
Novelty and definition of the research question The research question is relevant, but the originality of the contribution needs to be defined more clearly. The novelty does not lie in the general finding that long-term care staff experienced fear, burden, and resource shortages during the pandemic, since this is already well documented. The potential novelty lies in sharpening the focus on experiences of working during an active outbreak, particularly in smaller, rural, and northern facilities. This contribution should be presented more consistently and convincingly in the Introduction, Results, and Discussion. |
Thank you for your helpful input. We have refined the research question to highlight the rural and northern focus of this manuscript. |
|
Significance and interpretation of the results The findings are important, but their interpretation is not yet sufficiently developed. The seven themes reported in the Results (lines 125-395) are meaningful and well illustrated with quotations, but the manuscript does not sufficiently show how the themes are interrelated. A stronger contribution would lie in explaining how limited resources, leadership communication, staffing shortages, exposure to death, isolation, and vaccination together shaped the experience of working during an outbreak. The conclusions are broadly consistent with the evidence, but they should be more carefully distinguished from broader interpretative claims, especially regarding vaccination and the effects of specific forms of support. |
Thank you for your insight. We have made an effort to better connect the findings to each other and to provide more clarity with our results. |
|
Scientific soundness and methodological rigor The qualitative design is appropriate for exploring staff experiences, but the methodological rigor is not yet sufficiently evident from the reporting. The manuscript does not include hypotheses, which is appropriate for a qualitative study; however, the research aim should be formulated clearly and precisely. The main methodological weakness is the insufficiently detailed description of the analysis in lines 86-94: it is not clear how many researchers coded the transcripts, how codes and themes were developed, how interpretative differences were handled, and which strategies were used to ensure the credibility, confirmability, dependability, and transferability of the findings. |
Thank you for your insight. The Data Analysis section has been revised. |
|
Reproducibility or traceability of the methods In qualitative research, reproducibility cannot be required in an experimental sense, but analytical traceability can and should be expected. The current description of the methods (especially lines 60-94) does not allow readers to assess clearly how other researchers could understand or evaluate the path from data to themes. The authors should describe in greater detail the sampling strategy, inclusion criteria for the subset of 16 participants, interview guide, transcription process, coding, theme development, and use of Excel. Excel is acceptable as an organizational tool, but it cannot substitute for a clear account of the analytical procedure. |
Thank you for this suggestion. We have added more depth to the methods section. |
|
Tables, figures, and presentation of results The manuscript would be considerably clearer if it included at least one table summarizing participant and facility characteristics and one thematic table presenting the seven themes, subthemes, brief definitions, and representative quotations. This is particularly relevant to the participant description in lines 105-113 and the seven-theme overview in lines 113-124. The current presentation of results is readable, but the lengthy description of participant roles and the sequential presentation of themes reduce clarity. Tables would improve the transparency of qualitative reporting and help readers understand the structure of the findings more easily |
As noted above, we have created a table connecting themes and quotes to be included as a supplemental file |
|
References and self-citation Most of the cited sources are relevant, and part of the literature is recent. There is no obvious impression of excessive self-citation. Nevertheless, the authors should check whether the Introduction includes enough primary or contemporaneous sources for historical data on the early phase of the pandemic, especially the claims in lines 33-39. In particular, reference [3] should be checked. It is relevant to the broader context of systemic challenges in Canadian long-term care, but as a 2025 source it is less direct support for specific historical claims about spring 2020. For these data, it would be advisable to add an official or primary source, such as a public health report, CIHI report, governmental report, or Royal Society of Canada report. |
Thank you for your insight on how the citations can be refined. We have selected another source, a Statistics Canada article, to better support this statement. |
|
Ethics and data availability The statements on ethical approval, informed consent, and data protection are generally appropriate (lines 95-104 and 559-569). However, because the study uses a small sample and potentially identifiable staff roles in small communities, the authors should further explain how they minimized the risk of deductive disclosure. The Data Availability Statement is acceptable, since full public release of interview data would not be appropriate for confidentiality reasons. It would be advisable, however, to state more clearly that the data are not publicly available because of confidentiality, the sensitive nature of the experiences, and the risk of participant identifiability. |
Thank you for pointing out the importance of insuring participant confidentiality. We have amended the Data Availability Statement and Ethics section to better reflect our efforts to respect participant confidentiality. |
|
Quality of writing and level of English The English is mostly understandable, but the manuscript requires careful linguistic and stylistic editing. Language weaknesses are not in themselves a reason for a negative assessment, but some formulations reduce academic precision and clarity. The authors should particularly address grammatical errors, terminological inconsistency in the naming of staff roles and personal protective equipment, and isolated citation errors. |
We have carefully proofread our manuscript. |
|
Strengthen the methodological reporting, especially because the manuscript appears to be based on a subset of interviews from a broader multi-method study. |
We have made substantial edits to the methods section. The larger study was a qualitative study which collected participant demographics (e.g. age, sex, role, location) at the start of the interview. |
|
Clarify the sampling logic, inclusion criteria, and suitability of the subset of 16 participants with experience of working during an outbreak. |
As we noted in our response above, we have added more detail to section 2.1. |
|
Describe the thematic analysis in greater detail, including coding, theme development, researcher involvement, and strategies used to ensure trustworthiness. |
Thank you for your suggestion. We have expanded the data analysis section to address this. |
|
Deepen the interpretation of the results so that it is clear how the themes are interrelated and how they reflect organizational, relational, and structural conditions in long-term care. |
Thank you for your helpful suggestion. We have refined the results to better interrelate the themes |
|
Expand the limitations and practical implications so that they are specific, credible, and directly derived from the findings. |
Thank you for this insight. We have added to the limitations to highlight additional gaps and biases not previously listed. |
|
Correct citation, terminological, and language inconsistencies, while ensuring that language editing does not replace the necessary substantive and methodological revisions. |
Thank you for pointing out the need to refine the citations, we have done so throughout the paper. |
|
Title The title is clear and appropriately reflects the empirical focus of the study. However, in its current form it suggests a broader study of long-term care, although the data are drawn from a specific regional sample. The authors should consider adding the context to the title, for example“inWestern Canada” or “in rural and northern long-term care settings.” This wouldclarifythescopeand transferability of the findings from the outset. |
We appreciated your insight into how we can improve the clarity of our title. We have added the setting context into the title. |
|
Abstract The abstract (lines 10-24) is largely descriptive and should highlight the specific contribution of the study more clearly. The authors should define the research gap more precisely, especially the lack of qualitative evidence on working during active outbreaks in rural and northern long-term care settings. The findings should be synthesized rather than merely listed. The abstract would be stronger if the authors explained what the seven themes collectively show: for example, that active outbreaks deepened pre-existing structural weaknesses in long-term care while also generating forms of solidarity, adaptation, and dependence on external support. The concluding sentence of the abstract should be more concrete. Instead of a general statement about improved outbreak management, the authors should indicate the types of improvements suggested by the findings, such as clearer communication, reliable access to personal protective equipment, contingency staffing plans, psychological support, grief support, and locally adapted outbreak protocols. |
Thank you for showing how the abstract can be improved. We have added context to better define the research gap and added more to the conclusions. |
|
Keywords The keywords (lines 25-26) are relevant, but they could be improved. The terms “Long-term care facilities” and “Long-term care” partially overlap. The authorsshould consider morespecificterms,such as “long-term care staff,” “outbreak management,” “moral distress,” “qualitativeresearch,”“rural health,” “staff well-being,” or “emergency preparedness.” The spelling error shouldalsobecorrected: “emergency prepardness” should read “emergency preparedness. |
Thank you for your insight into keywords that help describe this paper. We have adjusted the key works to better reflect our paper. |
|
1. Introduction The Introduction (lines 28-58) appropriately presents the vulnerability of long-term care facilities during the COVID-19 pandemic and situates the study within the Canadian context. However, the research gap needs to be developed more systematically. The authors state that previous studies have addressed long-term care during the pandemic, while less is known about staff experiences during outbreaks and in rural settings. This is a promising line of argument, but it requires stronger support and clearer differentiation between general pandemic experiences and experiences of working during an active outbreak. The aim of the study should be stated more precisely. The authors should clarify whether they aim to describe outbreak experiences, identify stressors and sources of support, or contribute to preparedness for future outbreaks in long-term care. A clearer aim would improve the coherence of the entire manuscript. |
We appreciate this suggestion and have made substantial edits to the introduction section. |
|
2. Materials and Methods The Methods section (lines 59-104) contains the basic elements of recruitment, data collection, analysis, and ethics. However, the reporting is too brief for a qualitative study. The authors should consider reporting in accordance with established qualitative research guidelines, such as COREQ or SRQR. This would help ensure that necessary information is included on sampling, interviewer characteristics, reflexivity, data analysis, and trustworthiness. |
Thank you for this suggestion. We have completed the SRQR and included it as an appendix. |
|
2.1 Participant Recruitment This subsection (lines 60-74) requires more detail. The authors state that purposive sampling was used in the broader project and that the present study included participants who spoke about 5 working during COVID-19 outbreaks. However, the inclusion criterion for the current analysis is not sufficiently precise. The authors should clarify whether participants had to work in a facility with an officially declared outbreak, whether they personally worked on site during the outbreak, and whether clinical staff, other health professionals, administrative staff, and support workers were included. The manuscript should provide more information about the included facilities. The Discussion later mentions facility size, but this information should be reported earlier. The authors should report, in a non-identifying way, how many facilities were included, whether they were rural, northern, urban, public, private, or non-profit, and whether more than one participant came from the same facility. The statement that saturation was achieved in the original study should also be treated cautiously. Saturation in the broader dataset does not necessarily mean that saturation, information power, or thematic sufficiency was achieved in the subset of 16 participants with outbreak experience. The authors should explain how they assessed the adequacy of the present sample. |
Yes, all the outbreaks were officially declared. This is why we have to be careful about the degree of details regarding the participants that are provided to ensure that we protect participant confidentiality. All staff who were included in this study worked on site during an outbreak in their LTCF in a paid role. Details of these staff are noted in the first paragraph of the results section. Our team confirms that what is currently noted in the paper is as much as we feel comfortable to disclose and while we appreciate the request for more information, providing such would risk our ethical protocols. |
|
2.2 Data Collection The authors should state who conducted the interviews, what the professional or disciplinary background of the interviewers was, whether they had any prior relationship with participants, and whether they had experience in qualitative interviewing. The interview guide should also be described more clearly. The authors should indicate whether questions about outbreaks were included in the guide or whether outbreak experiences emerged within broader interviews about the pandemic (lines 75-85). This is particularly important if the manuscript is based on a focused analysis of a broader dataset. The authors should also describe more precisely how recordings and transcripts were handled. The phrase “auto recorded” should be corrected to “audio-recorded.” The manuscript shouldstatewhether interviews were professionally transcribed, checked against the recordings, and anonymized by the research team. If participants did not review the transcripts or findings, this should be clearly stated. |
We have included a copy of the interview guide as a supplemental file. |
|
2.3 Data Analysis This subsection (lines 86-94) requires substantial revision. The authors state that thematic analysis according to Braun and Clarke was used, but the analytical procedure is described too generally. Readers of a qualitative study need a clearer account of how the authors moved from transcripts to codes, from codes to candidate themes, and from candidate themes to the seven final themes. The authors should specify which orientation of thematic analysis they used. Was it reflexive thematic analysis, codebook thematic analysis, or a more structured team-based approach? This distinction matters because it affects expectations regarding coding, discussion among researchers, and the role of interpretation. A short statement on the trustworthiness of the qualitative analysis is also needed. The authors should explain how they addressed credibility, dependability, confirmability, and transferability. Suitable strategies include team discussions, analytic memos, an audit trail, peer debriefing, thick description, attention to negative cases, and systematic use of participant quotations. |
Thank you for your insight into how we can clarify our methods in this section. We have added to the Data Analysis section to address this. |
|
2.4 Ethical Considerations Ethical approval, informed consent, anonymization, and secure data storage are adequately described (lines 95-104). The authors should additionally explain how they reduced the risk of deductive disclosure. This is important because the combination of a small number of participants, specific staff roles, rural settings, and concrete outbreak experiences may increase the possibility of identification. |
Thank you for pointing out how we can ensure readers that measures were taken to protect participant confidentiality. We have refined the Ethical Considerations section to reflect this. |
|
3. Results The Results section (lines 105-395) is one of the stronger parts of the manuscript. The quotations are vivid, relevant, and mostly well selected. They provide readers with rich insight into staff experiences during outbreaks. The seven themes are meaningful and consistent with the study aim. Nevertheless, the results are more descriptive than analytical. The authors should show more clearly how the themes are connected and what makes them specific to active outbreaks rather than to the pandemic in general. Several findings, such as fear, staffing shortages, and problems with personal protective equipment, are already known from the broader COVID-19 literature. The manuscript therefore needs to show what intensified, changed, or became particularly salient during active outbreaks in long-term care facilities. A table presenting the seven themes, subthemes, brief definitions, and representative quotations would improve readability and analytical transparency. Participant characteristics should also be presented more clearly, preferably in a short. The current description of roles is difficult to follow and contains terminological inconsistencies. |
As noted above, we have created a table connecting themes and quotes to be included as a supplemental file |
|
3.1 Personal fear and distress among staff In section 3.1 (lines 125-157), the authors should define moral distress and distinguish it from fear, anxiety, occupational stress, and professional responsibility. The quotation from Participant 3 is particularly strong because it shows an ethical conflict between personal safety, professional obligation, and concern that residents might be cared for by staff who did not know them. This should be interpreted more explicitly. |
Thank you for addressing this point of potential confusion. We have since defined moral distress. |
|
3.2 Coping with resident deaths due to COVID-19 Section 3.2 (lines 158-177) is one of the strongest and most original subsections in the manuscript. The accounts of repeated resident deaths, emotional numbness, and collective memorial practices are compelling. The interpretation should be deepened. The theme is not only about coping with death, but also about constrained grieving, emotional suppression or the temporary deferral of grief, disruption of usual end-of-life practices, and the moral weight of caring for residents whose families could not accompany them in the usual way. A more precise naming of the theme could better capture this complexity. |
We have renamed this theme to be more precise. |
|
3.3 Relationship Dynamics The broad theme of relationship dynamics (lines 178-254) is relevant, but its internal logic should be explained more clearly. The section includes relationships with co-workers, relationships with residents, and staff isolation. These are related but not identical phenomena. The authors should frame the theme more explicitly as a relational tension: outbreaks strengthened some staff bonds, strained relationships with residents, and simultaneously reduced access to informal social support. This would give the section a stronger interpretative focus. |
We appreciate this suggestion and have adjusted the title. |
|
3.3.1 Relationships with co-workers The analysis should treat more cautiously the division between staff who worked during outbreaks and those who did not. The manuscript should not imply that unwillingness to work during outbreaks reflected a lack of commitment. It may also have reflected fear, vulnerability, burnout, family responsibilities, vaccination mandates, or unequal exposure to risk. The role of external staff with outbreak experience is also important. The authors should distinguish between support that was promised but did not materialize and support that actually arrived and was experienced as useful by staff. This would make the finding more nuanced. |
Thank you for your insight into what our wording could imply. We have adjusted our wording in that section. |
|
3.3.2 Relationships with residents This subsection identifies an important consequence of outbreak measures: fewer interactions, resident isolation, frustration, and staff guilt. The analysis should more clearly distinguish resident behavior from the structural conditions that shaped it. Residents’ frustrations should be understood in the context of isolation, loss of activities, fear, cognitive impairment, and reduced contact with family. The authors should also say more about the impact of personal protective equipment on relational care. Infection prevention measures may have reduced facial expression, touch, ease of communication, and emotional closeness. This would link the subsection more directly to the specific conditions of working during an outbreak. Guilt about being unable to meet residents’ needs also overlaps with moral distress. The authors should connect these themes more clearly. |
Thank you for your thoughts on how we can better describe this theme. We have added to the “relationships with residents” theme to better reflect this experience. |
|
3.3.3 Feelings of Isolation The content shows that isolation operated at two levels: staff isolated themselves from families and communities to protect others, while infection prevention measures also isolated them from coworkers. This distinction should be stated clearly. |
Thank you for your insight regarding the need to better clarify this distinction. We have adjusted the “Feelings of Isolation” subtheme to better reflect this. |
|
3.4 Changes in Workload Expectations In section 3.4 (lines 255-284), the authors should distinguish more clearly between workload intensification and role expansion. The section would be stronger if it explained how these changes affected staff well-being, quality of care, and professional identity. The data show both pride in contributing and exhaustion from sustained overload. This duality should be made more visible. |
Thank you for pointing out how we can better distinguish the aspects of this theme. We have added to the “changes in workload expectation” theme to differentiate the aspects of this theme. |
|
3.5 Finite resources The theme presented in section 3.5 (lines 285-347) is important, but the title “Finite resources” is not sufficiently precise. The section actually addresses limited resources, leadership shortcomings, access to personal protective equipment, communication gaps, and staffing shortages. A title such as “Resource constraints and organizational support gaps” would better capture the content. The section should more clearly connect individual distress with organizational and structural conditions. Participants were not distressed only because of COVID-19 itself; their distress was intensified by limited access to protective equipment, unclear communication, inconsistent leadership, and staff shortages. |
Thank you for your comment on how we can better express this theme. We have changed the theme title. We have also added context to how these challenges compounded to shape outbreak experiences |
|
3.5.1 Issues with Management This subsection contains some of the strongest evidence in the manuscript, especially the quotation suggesting that staff were blamed for the outbreak, but it requires careful interpretation. The authors should not analyze management simply as supportive or unsupportive, but through leadership communication, psychological safety, trust, accountability, and perceived respect. The statement that staff were held responsible for the outbreak suggests a serious erosion of trust and a possible additional moral burden. This should be connected to the broader findings on moral distress, burnout, and staff retention. |
Thank you for your helpful insight. We have adjusted the interpretation of the “issues with management” section. |
|
3.5.2 Lack of Resources This subsection appropriately addresses shortages of personal protective equipment, restricted access, lack of N95 masks, unclear procedures, and insufficient information about exposure. These findings are central to outbreak preparedness. The subsection should be organized more clearly, as it currently brings together several issues: access to personal protective equipment, communication, laundry constraints, changing rules, and fatigue from repeated outbreaks. The authors could structure the analysis around personal protective equipment, information flow, and cumulative exhaustion during repeated outbreaks. Terminology regarding personal protective equipment should also be precise. Theterm“PPEs”should generally be replaced with “PPE.” The authors should distinguish betweenactual shortage,restricted access, rationing, and perceived withholding of protective equipment. When participants believe that inadequate protective equipment contributed to transmission, this should be presented as participants’ perception unless facility-level infection data are available. |
Thank you for your ideas on how the “Lack of resources” section can be better organized, we have adjusted it accordingly. |
|
3.6 Resources and Support Section 3.6 (lines 348-366) should define more clearly its relationship to the theme of limited resources. The authors should identify what made support effective when it was experienced as useful. The data suggest several mechanisms: clear communication, visible leadership, access to personal protective equipment, experienced external staff, availability of counselling, and strong peer solidarity. Naming these mechanisms would strengthen the practical contribution of the manuscript. The authors should avoid overestimating formal psychological support. The quotation indicates that counselling was available, but not necessarily widely used. Possible barriers, such as stigma, lack of time, or exhaustion, could be mentioned briefly. |
Thank you for input into how this section can be refined to better connect our findings to the theme. We have added context to the “resources and support” section to better do this. |
|
3.7 Impact of Vaccination The vaccination theme in section 3.7 (lines 367-395) is relevant and should remain in the manuscript. Participants’ comparisons between pre- and post-vaccination outbreaks provide useful insight into changed perceptions of risk and disease severity. However, the authors should be careful not to formulate causal claims that exceed the qualitative data. Claims should therefore be framed as participants’ perceptions that vaccination reduced severity, fear, andmortality, unlesssupported by epidemiological evidence. The brief mention of vaccination mandates and staff retention is important but underdeveloped. If mandates affected staffing, trust, or workplace relationships, this should be analyzed more fully. Otherwise, it should remain part of the contextual background and should not be introduced without sufficient interpretation. The timing of data collection should also be considered. Interviews were conducted in late 2021 and early 2022, when mandates, variants, booster availability, and public health recommendations were changing. This context is important for understanding participants’ views on vaccination. |
We appreciate this suggestion and agree. We have a separate paper focused on this topic in progress. Therefore while it is key to note in this paper, the further elaboration of this point will be illustrated in the subsequent paper. |
|
4. Discussion The Discussion (lines 396-508) links the findings appropriately to previous research, but it requires greater interpretative depth. Several paragraphs mainly restate the results and then note that similar findings have been reported in other studies. The authors should move beyond confirming existing findings and explain what their study adds. The Discussion should also be revised to reduce repetition. Several points, particularly fear, workload, staffing shortages, and problems with personal protective equipment, recur in similar formulations. The revised manuscript should synthesize these aspects rather than repeat them. The strongest contribution probably lies in showing how active outbreaks deepened long-standing vulnerabilities in long-term care while also revealing forms of staff solidarity, role flexibility, and dependence on locally responsive support. This argument should be placed more clearly at the center of the Discussion. The authors should also connect the themes more explicitly. For example, limited resources and unclear communication appear to intensify fear and moral distress; resident deaths and isolation contribute to grief and emotional exhaustion; staffing shortages increase workload and role expansion; peer solidarity and external support partly mitigate distress; and vaccination changes staff perceptions of risk and disease severity. Presenting these connections would make the Discussion more interpretative and less descriptive. Claims of originality should be formulated cautiously. If the authors state that creative grieving practices were not identified in other Canadian studies, this should be presented as a difference in reported evidence, not as proof that such practices did not exist elsewhere. |
We appreciate these suggestions and have made substantial edits to the discussion section. |
|
4.1 Strengths and Limitations The limitations section (lines 509-526) identifies important issues, including geographical specificity and the non-participation of staff who may have left long-term care before recruitment. This is appropriate, but the section should be expanded. Limitations may also include recall bias, social desirability bias, and limited ability to compare experiences by role, facility type, outbreak severity, vaccination status, or rural versus non-rural setting. The strengths of the study should be stated more explicitly. These include rich qualitative data, inclusion of different staff roles, focus on experiences during active outbreaks, and attention to long-term care settings that are often less represented in the literature. There is also a grammatical error in the first sentence of this subsection: “While study focuses” should be correctedto“Whilethis study focuses.” |
Thank you for your insight into how we can add more transparency and clarity to what this paper offers. We have added in the mentioned limitations and expanded the strengths to better represent this work. |
|
4.2 Implications The Implications section (lines 527-537) is relevant, but too general. The manuscript states that a person-centered approach is needed and that a one-size-fits-all approach is insufficient. These are 10 appropriate conclusions, but the recommendations need to be more specific and directly linked to the results. |
Thank you for your ideas on how we can improve the implications section. We have expanded it to provide more implications. |
|
5. Conclusions The Conclusion (lines 538-553) summarizes the main findings, but it should be clearer and more conceptually precise. The sentence listing the seven themes is too long and should be divided into shorter sentences. The Conclusion should not merely repeat the themes, but should clearly express the central contribution of the study. The final paragraph appropriately emphasizes that the study gives voice to staff who worked during outbreaks. This should remain, but the practical message should be sharper. The findings indicate that effective outbreak management requires not only infection prevention protocols, but also attention to staff well-being, communication, workload, access to protective equipment, grief, and trust in leadership. |
Thank you for your thoughts on how we can improve the conclusion. We have expanded it to better connect the themes and to define the practical message of this paper. |
|
References The references (lines 575-613) are substantively relevant, but the reference list requires technical checking. The authors should verify compliance with the journal style, including author initials, journal abbreviations, volume, issue, page range, DOI, and access dates for web sources. Reference [3] is relevant and appropriate for contextualizing broader systemic challenges in Canadian long-term care during the COVID-19 pandemic. However, the manuscript also uses this source for specific historical claims about the early phase of the pandemic in 2020 (lines 33-39). The authors should therefore consider adding a primary or contemporaneous source for these data, such as an official public health, CIHI, governmental, or Royal Society of Canada report. This would strengthen the evidentiary basis of the introductory claims. |
Thank you for your insight on to how we can correct the references. An alternative article from Statistics Canada has replaced the claims of 80% of deaths during the first wave of the pandemic being in LTCFs. |
|
Language and style The manuscript is mostly understandable, but it requires careful language editing. The authors should correct grammatical, typographical, and stylistic errors throughout the text. They should pay particular attention to terminology for staff roles, use of the term PPE, grammatical consistency, and citation errors. Language editing should be completed after the substantive revision, since language issues are not currently the central problem of the manuscript; the key issues remain methodological and analytical. |
Thank you. We have carefully edited and proofread this paper. |
Author Response File:
Author Response.pdf
Reviewer 2 Report
Dear Authors,
Your manuscript addresses an important and relevant topic. The qualitative material is rich, the participant quotations are compelling, and focusing on long-term care facilities in Western Canada is a valuable contribution. The seven themes are plausible and clinically meaningful. However, the manuscript requires major revisions. In particular, the Methods section does not adequately explain how the codes and themes were generated, who coded the data, how disagreements were resolved, how saturation was evaluated for the subset specific to the outbreak, and how reflexivity was addressed. The manuscript also needs clearer reporting of participant and facility characteristics and a stronger framing of the interpretation of vaccination effects.
I have highlighted some key issues based on a thorough analysis of your paper. Revising your manuscript will increase its chances of acceptance by the professional community. I wish you all the best in your work.
Sincerely,
Abstract
The Abstract states that 16 participants were interviewed and seven themes emerged. However, it does not state whether the analysis was inductive, reflexive, descriptive, or a secondary analysis of a larger dataset. Please add this information.
The claim "paucity of research" should be more precise. There is now a substantial body of literature on LTCF staff during the pandemic, including outbreak studies. The gap lies in the specific rural/northern outbreak context, not the topic broadly. Please specify.
Introduction
The claim that staff leave their jobs due to burnout and vaccination mandates needs to be handled with caution because it combines two different mechanisms and must be supported carefully. Please revise.
Materials and Methods
The inclusion logic for the 16 transcripts is underdeveloped. It is unclear how "discussed experiences working through an outbreak" were determined and by whom. Please explain.
Additionally, the original study continued sampling until saturation, but this sub-study did not necessarily do so. The saturation claim cannot automatically be transferred to the subset of 16 transcripts.
Recruitment via administrators may introduce selection bias. Staff with negative experiences, retired staff, and staff who left the workforce may have been less likely to participate. This is acknowledged later but should also be noted in the methods or limitations section. Please add this information.
You wrote that each interview was "auto recorded," but it should probably be "audio-recorded." Please revise.
The data collection description partly anticipates the findings. The sentence lists fear, deaths, isolation, and support. It is unclear whether these were interview prompts or emergent topics. Please clarify.
The description of the thematic analysis procedure in the data analysis section is insufficient. It does not state whether coding was inductive or deductive, semantic or latent, reflexive or codebook-based, nor who coded the transcripts. Please add this information.
Moreover, credibility strategies are underreported. There is no mention of member checking, peer debriefing, an audit trail, reflexive memoing, or negative case analysis. Additionally, there is no mention of researcher reflexivity. Please add this information.
Additionally, no qualitative reporting standard is mentioned. Did you follow COREQ or SRQR? Please explain.
Results
The participant description is useful, but it needs to be in table form. A table of participant characteristics would improve transparency, especially with regard to role, facility type, rural/urban location, and outbreak timing. Please add one.
The role categories are difficult to understand. The sentence is long and includes nursing, allied health, and other roles. Please revise it.
The seven themes are not parallel. Some are emotional states ("fear"), some are events ("death"), some are resource categories, and "impact of vaccinations" is narrower than the others. The analytic logic should be explained.
Theme 3, "Relationship Dynamics," contains multiple subthemes. It includes relationships with coworkers and residents, as well as isolation from family and staff. This is a large, heterogeneous theme. Consider splitting it.
Themes 5 and 6, "Finite Resources" and "Resources and Support," respectively, seem to overlap; the distinction between them is unclear. Please clarify.
Theme 1 is strong and well-supported. However, the manuscript should define the concept of moral distress.
Vaccine mandates are mentioned but not fully explored. The effects on staff retention are mentioned in one paragraph, but the theme mostly focuses on perceived protective effects.
Discussion
The claim that staffing and supply shortages were more pronounced in rural LTCFs is not fully demonstrated, as there is no comparison sample. Please phrase this cautiously.
The discussion of grief is one of the manuscript’s strongest sections. It would benefit from linking to literature on disenfranchised grief, moral injury, or complicated grief, if appropriate.
The discussion of workload is repetitive when similar points about PPE, staffing, routine tasks taking longer, and role changes are made multiple times. Please revise.
The generalizability paragraph needs qualitative terminology. Qualitative studies usually discuss transferability rather than generalizability.
The limitations are relevant but incomplete. Please add limitations regarding recall bias, self-selection, the lack of resident and family perspectives, limited demographic diversity, and the absence of facility-level detail.
Conclusions
The claim that the study "provides steps for better outbreak management" overstates its empirical output. The study provides insight, not tested steps.
The general style needs improvement, as there are numerous proofreading, typographical, and formatting issues.
The manuscript would benefit from a table presenting each theme, a brief definition, an illustrative quote, and a practical implication. Please consider adding such a table.
Author Response
|
Reviewer Comments |
Authors’ Responses |
|
Reviewer 2 |
|
|
Abstract - The Abstract states that 16 participants were interviewed and seven themes emerged. However, it does not state whether the analysis was inductive, reflexive, descriptive, or a secondary analysis of a larger dataset. Please add this information. |
Thank you for this helpful suggestion. We have added this to the abstract. |
|
Abstract - The claim "paucity of research" should be more precise. There is now a substantial body of literature on LTCF staff during the pandemic, including outbreak studies. The gap lies in the specific rural/northern outbreak context, not the topic broadly. Please specify. |
We appreciate this insight and have revised the abstract accordingly. |
|
Introduction - The claim that staff leave their jobs due to burnout and vaccination mandates needs to be handled with caution because it combines two different mechanisms and must be supported carefully. Please revise. |
Thank you for your insight, this has been corrected on lines 53-54 |
|
Methods - The inclusion logic for the 16 transcripts is underdeveloped. It is unclear how "discussed experiences working through an outbreak" were determined and by whom. Please explain. |
We have added more information to the methods section to provide detail on this in lines 79-83. |
|
Methods - Additionally, the original study continued sampling until saturation, but this sub-study did not necessarily do so. The saturation claim cannot automatically be transferred to the subset of 16 transcripts. |
Thank you for insight, this has been corrected on line 79 |
|
Methods - Recruitment via administrators may introduce selection bias. Staff with negative experiences, retired staff, and staff who left the workforce may have been less likely to participate. This is acknowledged later but should also be noted in the methods or limitations section. Please add this information. |
Great point, it has been added to the limitations section. |
|
Methods - You wrote that each interview was "auto recorded," but it should probably be "audio-recorded." Please revise. |
Thank you for catching that, it has been corrected. |
|
Methods - The data collection description partly anticipates the findings. The sentence lists fear, deaths, isolation, and support. It is unclear whether these were interview prompts or emergent topics. Please clarify. |
Thank you. The themes have been removed from the data collection section |
|
Methods - The description of the thematic analysis procedure in the data analysis section is insufficient. It does not state whether coding was inductive or deductive, semantic or latent, reflexive or codebook-based, nor who coded the transcripts. Please add this information. |
Thank you. We have added more detail to section 2.3. |
|
Methods - Moreover, credibility strategies are underreported. There is no mention of member checking, peer debriefing, an audit trail, reflexive memoing, or negative case analysis. Additionally, there is no mention of researcher reflexivity. Please add this information. |
We have added section 2.4 on rigor. |
|
Methods - Additionally, no qualitative reporting standard is mentioned. Did you follow COREQ or SRQR? Please explain. |
We have included the SRQR as a supplemental file. |
|
Results - The participant description is useful, but it needs to be in table form. A table of participant characteristics would improve transparency, especially with regard to role, facility type, rural/urban location, and outbreak timing. Please add one. |
Thank you for your insight. To ensure confidentiality, we have purposefully not included this information as outbreak notification was public during this time in the region where this work was conducted and it could lead to possible identification especially among small sized facilities. |
|
Results - The role categories are difficult to understand. The sentence is long and includes nursing, allied health, and other roles. Please revise it. |
Thank you for your insight. We have reformatted the participant roles to make it more clear and with shorter sentences. |
|
Results - The seven themes are not parallel. Some are emotional states ("fear"), some are events ("death"), some are resource categories, and "impact of vaccinations" is narrower than the others. The analytic logic should be explained. |
Thank you for noting this. We have corrected it in the second paragraph of the results section. |
|
Results - Theme 3, "Relationship Dynamics," contains multiple subthemes. It includes relationships with coworkers and residents, as well as isolation from family and staff. This is a large, heterogeneous theme. Consider splitting it. |
We appreciate this suggestion. Upon discussion with our team we would like to keep this as is as it highlights the complexity of relationships dynamics. |
|
Results - Themes 5 and 6, "Finite Resources" and "Resources and Support," respectively, seem to overlap; the distinction between them is unclear. Please clarify. |
Thank you for pointing out this point for potential confusion. We have corrected it under the respective theme headings. |
|
Results - Theme 1 is strong and well-supported. However, the manuscript should define the concept of moral distress. |
Thank you for your inside. We have defined moral distress from line 150-165. |
|
Results - Vaccine mandates are mentioned but not fully explored. The effects on staff retention are mentioned in one paragraph, but the theme mostly focuses on perceived protective effects. |
We appreciate this suggestion and agree. We have a separate paper focused on this topic in progress. |
|
Discussion - The claim that staffing and supply shortages were more pronounced in rural LTCFs is not fully demonstrated, as there is no comparison sample. Please phrase this cautiously. |
Thank you for noting this. We have corrected it to staffing shortages being pronounced in rural LTCFs |
|
Discussion - The discussion of workload is repetitive when similar points about PPE, staffing, routine tasks taking longer, and role changes are made multiple times. Please revise. |
Thank you for your helpful insight into how the discussion can be made more clear and concise. The discussion has been reorganized to avoid repetition. |
|
Discussion - The generalizability paragraph needs qualitative terminology. Qualitative studies usually discuss transferability rather than generalizability. |
Thank you for addressing this, references to generalizability have been corrected. |
|
Discussion - The limitations are relevant but incomplete. Please add limitations regarding recall bias, self-selection, the lack of resident and family perspectives, limited demographic diversity, and the absence of facility-level detail. |
We have added to these suggestions to the Strengths and Limitations section on page 12. |
|
Conclusion - The claim that the study "provides steps for better outbreak management" overstates its empirical output. The study provides insight, not tested steps. |
Thank you for your insight. The use of the term “steps” has been corrected to “insight”. |
|
The general style needs improvement, as there are numerous proofreading, typographical, and formatting issues. |
We have carefully proofread our manuscript and feel the general style has now been improved. |
|
The manuscript would benefit from a table presenting each theme, a brief definition, an illustrative quote, and a practical implication. Please consider adding such a table. |
We have created this table as requested to be included as a supplemental file |
Author Response File:
Author Response.pdf
Round 2
Reviewer 1 Report
Dear Authors,
Thank you for the careful revision of the manuscript and for addressing the comments provided during the previous review round. I appreciate the effort you have made to improve the clarity, methodological transparency, and overall quality of the manuscript.
The revised version provides a clearer explanation of the study rationale, strengthens the description of the research process, and improves the presentation of the findings. The additional clarifications regarding the secondary analysis approach, participant selection, ethical considerations, data confidentiality, and supplementary materials have enhanced the transparency and credibility of the study.
I particularly appreciate the improvements in the description of the qualitative analysis process and the additional information provided to support the interpretation of the themes. The revised limitations section also provides a more balanced discussion of the contextual nature and transferability of the findings.
The manuscript now presents a clearer contribution to understanding the experiences of long-term care staff during the COVID-19 pandemic, particularly within rural and northern healthcare contexts. The remaining issues are minor and mainly related to final language polishing and consistency checks.
In my opinion, the manuscript has been appropriately revised and is now suitable for publication. I congratulate the authors on the improvements made and wish them success with the publication of their work.
Kind regards,
Reviewer
I do not have any detailed comments.
Reviewer 2 Report
Dear Authors,
I would like to express my appreciation for your efforts in revising the manuscript. Your revisions demonstrate that you carefully considered all the comments and adequately addressed the issues. The manuscript is now refined to a standard that effectively communicates the research findings and provides valuable insights to the field.
Sincerely,
After reviewing the updated manuscript, I am pleased to say that it meets the expectations I set forth in my previous comments. The changes you made have improved the clarity and overall impact of the study