Review Reports
- Lilian Cristine Camillo 1,
- Paula Polastri 2 and
- Aline Lopes 1,3,4,*
- et al.
Reviewer 1: Anonymous Reviewer 2: Anonymous
Round 1
Reviewer 1 Report
Comments and Suggestions for Authors
General Comments:
This extensive review paper provides a broad examination of the biological attributes of L. leucocephala, and how those attributes contribute to this plant’s invasiveness as well as it utilization for “restoration” and food source. The authors have done a very good job at accessing published reports as well as applying reasonable screen (exclusions) to focus on the purpose of the review.
The conclusions reached appear quite reasonable and align with the review papers.
I believe some verbiage could be cut or more focuses (see specific comments below),and some of the finding summarized in the text might be more “digestible: as simple graphs (e.g. pie charts to show relative percentages by type of study).
A final “summary graphic” might be useful to convey the three of four main conclusions, comparing invasiveness with “utility” and the habitats the correspond to, in their opinion, the best use for the habitats.
I suggest the authors conduct a careful re-read and tighten up some of the narrative so as to reduce repetitive phrases.
Specific Comments:
I wonder why the authors excluded “physiological” studies when they also claim the physiological plasticity is a key attribute? They also use the phrase “ecophysiolgical perspective” (See also comment below). Very often research on the physiology of invasive plants reveal extremely important characteristics that can drive more effective management. Perhaps these authors might re-review those papers originally excluded as “physiological”?
There seems to be some repetition at various places. For example:
From p. 6 The species exhibits high photosynthetic rates and
efficient resource use, favoring its competitive performance in disturbed environments
https://do
From p.7 From an ecophysiological perspective, the species exhibits high photosynthetic rates and biological nitrogen fixation capacity, favoring its establishment in poor or degraded
soils [2,27].
and:
from P. 9
The literature further indicates that effective management of L. leucocephala in wet-
“...lands strongly depends on the integration of physical methods (cu ing/thinning), selec-
tive chemical control (herbicides applied directly to stumps), active revegetation with na-
tive species adapted to flooded conditions, and long-term monitoring to prevent reinva-
sion via the persistent soil seed bank [1,2,6,7]. Isolated strategies are rarely sufficient: cut-
ting or herbicide application without restoring native vegetation cover often results in
rapid reinfestation.”
“Overall, the results indicate that integrated methods, particularly the combination of
mechanical cu ing and localized herbicide application, demonstrate higher effectiveness
in controlling the species. In several studies, this approach achieved mortality rates be-
tween 80% and 100%, significantly reducing resprouting after cu ing [6,26,50]. In contrast,
mechanical removal alone tends to be ineffective, as the vigorous root system allows rapid
plant regeneration. In many cases, simple cuting results in the production of multiple
shoots per stump, requiring complementary interventions [2,26].”
- 3 Why wert physiological studies not included? Note p.6 reference to “physiolgical plasticity 28 studies
This plant is an eco-/habitat engineer.
note p. 9 (integrated methods most successful) This is a repetitive theme-
p 9-note similarities-
The literature further indicates that effective management of L. leucocephala in wet-
lands strongly depends on the integration of physical methods (cutting/thinning), selec-
tive chemical control (herbicides applied directly to stumps), active revegetation with na-
tive species adapted to flooded conditions, and long-term monitoring to prevent reinva-
sion via the persistent soil seed bank [1,2,6,7]. Isolated strategies are rarely sufficient: cut-
ting or herbicide application without restoring native vegetation cover often results in
rapid reinfestation.
and:
Overall, the results indicate that integrated methods, particularly the combination of
mechanical cutting and localized herbicide application, demonstrate higher effectiveness
in controlling the species. In several studies, this approach achieved mortality rates be-
tween 80% and 100%, significantly reducing resprouting after cu ing [6,26,50]. In contrast,
mechanical removal alone tends to be ineffective, as the vigorous root system allows rapid
plant regeneration. In many cases, simple cu ing results in the production of multiple
shoots per stump, requiring complementary interventions [2,26].
- 10 – generic “steps” for management. These are standard steps so this
nothing new here. The authors could incorporate their points about social/ cultural
components in development management plans.
Author Response
Thank you for your careful evaluation and constructive suggestions. We appreciate your positive assessment of the manuscript and your valuable comments, which helped us to significantly improve clarity, structure, and synthesis.
This extensive review paper provides a broad examination of the biological attributes of L. leucocephala, and how those attributes contribute to this plant’s invasiveness as well as it utilization for “restoration” and food source. The authors have done a very good job at accessing published reports as well as applying reasonable screen (exclusions) to focus on the purpose of the review.
The conclusions reached appear quite reasonable and align with the review papers.
I believe some verbiage could be cut or more focuses (see specific comments below),and some of the finding summarized in the text might be more “digestible: as simple graphs (e.g. pie charts to show relative percentages by type of study).
A final “summary graphic” might be useful to convey the three of four main conclusions, comparing invasiveness with “utility” and the habitats the correspond to, in their opinion, the best use for the habitats.
I suggest the authors conduct a careful re-read and tighten up some of the narrative so as to reduce repetitive phrases.
Response:
We appreciate this suggestion. The manuscript has been carefully revised to reduce redundancy and improve conciseness throughout the text. In addition, we have incorporated graphical summaries (Figures 2–4) to improve the visualization of key patterns in the literature.
Furthermore, following your suggestion, we have added a new conceptual summary figure (Figure 6) synthesizing the main findings of the review, integrating:
(i) invasiveness drivers,
(ii) ecological impacts,
(iii) management strategies, and
(iv) contexts in which the species may be beneficial or harmful.
Specific Comments:
I wonder why the authors excluded “physiological” studies when they also claim the physiological plasticity is a key attribute? They also use the phrase “ecophysiolgical perspective” (See also comment below). Very often research on the physiology of invasive plants reveal extremely important characteristics that can drive more effective management. Perhaps these authors might re-review those papers originally excluded as “physiological”?
Response
We appreciate this important observation. The exclusion criterion has now been clarified in the Methods section.
Physiological studies were excluded only when they were not explicitly linked to invasion processes or management implications. However, when physiological traits (e.g., photosynthetic efficiency, nitrogen fixation, and plasticity) were directly associated with invasion success or ecological performance, these findings were incorporated into the synthesis.
To improve clarity and consistency, we have revised the text to explicitly state this criterion and ensured alignment between the methodological description and the discussion of ecophysiological traits.
This plant is an eco-/habitat engineer.
note p. 9 (integrated methods most successful) This is a repetitive theme p 9-note similarities-
Response:
We agree with this observation. The manuscript has been carefully revised to eliminate redundant statements, particularly in Sections 3.2 and 3.4.
Repetitive descriptions of physiological traits and management strategies were consolidated, and overlapping explanations were removed to improve readability and flow.
The literature further indicates that effective management of L. leucocephala in wetlands strongly depends on the integration of physical methods (cutting/thinning), selective chemical control (herbicides applied directly to stumps), active revegetation with native species adapted to flooded conditions, and long-term monitoring to prevent reinvasion via the persistent soil seed bank [1,2,6,7]. Isolated strategies are rarely sufficient: cutting or herbicide application without restoring native vegetation cover often results in rapid reinfestation.
and:
Overall, the results indicate that integrated methods, particularly the combination of mechanical cutting and localized herbicide application, demonstrate higher effectiveness in controlling the species. In several studies, this approach achieved mortality rates between 80% and 100%, significantly reducing resprouting after cutting [6,26,50]. In contrast, mechanical removal alone tends to be ineffective, as the vigorous root system allows rapid plant regeneration. In many cases, simple cutting results in the production of multiple shoots per stump, requiring complementary interventions [2,26].
Response:
We appreciate this comment. The discussion of integrated management strategies has been streamlined. Detailed explanations are now concentrated in Section 3.4, while Section 3.5 presents only a synthesis of evidence, avoiding repetition.
- 10 – generic “steps” for management. These are standard steps so this nothing new here. The authors could incorporate their points about social/ cultural components in development management plans.
Response:
We thank the reviewer for this insightful suggestion. To address this point, we have expanded the discussion to incorporate social, institutional, and governance dimensions of invasive species management.
These aspects are now explicitly integrated into the management framework (Sections 3.7 and 3.8), highlighting the importance of community engagement, policy support, and long-term monitoring for effective management in wetland ecosystems.
Reviewer 2 Report
Comments and Suggestions for Authors
In this manuscript, Lilian Cristine Camillo and colleagues presented a systematic review to address the ecology of invasion and management strategies for Leucaena leucocephala in wetland environments. I have following comments:
1, This is a review paper, but authors incorrectly employed a template for research article. For instance, results section was incorrectly presented. Please use the correct template.
2, As a review paper, picture showing growth of Leucaena leucocephala in wetland environments should be presented.
3, For the section 3.1, pictures showing geographic distribution and ecosystems of Leucaena leucocephala should be included.
4, For the results section, more citation describing the original data should be provided. For instance, there is no citation for the section 3.1.
5, A Figure depicting the present Leucaena leucocephala management strategies and future perspectives should be included, and Table 3 should be replaced with this Figure.
6, As a review paper, discussion section is the most important section. Please present an independent discussion section. Unanswered questions and future perspectives should be discussed in this section.
7, Reference should be standardized according to the MDPI template. For instance, the journal name should be replaced with abbreviations.
Author Response
In this manuscript, Lilian Cristine Camillo and colleagues presented a systematic review to address the ecology of invasion and management strategies for Leucaena leucocephala in wetland environments. I have following comments:
1, This is a review paper, but authors incorrectly employed a template for research article. For instance, results section was incorrectly presented. Please use the correct template.
Response
We appreciate this comment. According to the journal’s editorial guidelines and confirmation from the editorial office, systematic reviews in this journal follow the structure: Introduction, Materials and Methods, Results and Discussion, and Conclusions.
Therefore, the current structure has been maintained. However, to improve clarity, we have strengthened the discussion components within the “Results and Discussion” section and expanded the section on research gaps and future directions.
2, As a review paper, picture showing growth of Leucaena leucocephala in wetland environments should be presented.
Response:
A representative image of Leucaena leucocephala in wetland environments has been added (Figure 5) to improve the visual presentation of the species in its ecological context.
3, For the section 3.1, pictures showing geographic distribution and ecosystems of Leucaena leucocephala should be included.
Response:
We have included Figures 2 and 3, which illustrate the geographic distribution of studies and the ecosystems in which the species occurs.
4, For the results section, more citation describing the original data should be provided. For instance, there is no citation for the section 3.1.
Response:
We agree with this observation. Additional references have been included in Section 3.1 to support the descriptive analysis and ensure proper attribution of the original studies used in the synthesis.
5, A Figure depicting the present Leucaena leucocephala management strategies and future perspectives should be included, and Table 3 should be replaced with this Figure.
Response We appreciate this suggestion. Instead of removing Table 3, which provides detailed quantitative information, we have added a complementary conceptual figure (Figure 7) summarizing management strategies and future perspectives.This approach allows both detailed data presentation (Table 3) and visual synthesis (Figure 7).
6, As a review paper, discussion section is the most important section. Please present an independent discussion section. Unanswered questions and future perspectives should be discussed in this section.
Response:
Although the journal structure integrates Results and Discussion, we have expanded the section “Research gaps and future directions” to strengthen the discussion component.
This section now explicitly addresses:
- unresolved questions
- future research priorities
- interdisciplinary challenges
7, Reference should be standardized according to the MDPI template. For instance, the journal name should be replaced with abbreviations.
Response:
All references have been revised and standardized according to the MDPI format, including journal name abbreviations.
Round 2
Reviewer 2 Report
Comments and Suggestions for Authors
Authors have addressed each of my comments in the revision.