Review Reports
- Caroline Arbuckle MacLeod 1,*,
- Megan J. Daniels 2 and
- M. Willis Monroe 3
Reviewer 1: Anonymous Reviewer 2: Aleksandra Kubiak-Schneider Reviewer 3: Anonymous
Round 1
Reviewer 1 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsThe article presents a relevant contribution to the studies of religion, cultural heritage and digital humanities by describing the development and potential of the Database of Religious History (DRH) as an open-access resource.
The structure of the text is clear and progressive, leading the reader from the database's theoretical and methodological foundations to its applications in research and teaching. Particularly noteworthy are the discussion of data collection by experts, the integration of qualitative and quantitative information, and the platform's potential to enable comparative analyses on a global scale, with a special focus on the ancient Mediterranean world.
Among the strengths of the manuscript are the detailed description of the architecture of the HRD, the presentation of the different survey categories ("Religious Group", "Religious Place", "Religious Text" and the future "Religious Object Poll") and the reflection on the importance of digital literacy in higher education.
The section dedicated to pedagogical resources is especially pertinent, convincingly demonstrating how the platform can contribute to the development of data analysis skills among students in the humanities. Examples from the ancient Mediterranean effectively illustrate the database's analytical potential and demonstrate its usefulness to researchers across different specialities.
There are some aspects that can be reinforced before publication.
First, the article often takes on a descriptive and promotional tone, benefiting from a more critical discussion of the database's limitations, including potential biases in expert selection, uneven geographic and chronological coverage, and the challenges inherent in quantifying complex religious phenomena.
Second, they should provide more concrete examples of scientific results obtained using HRD, in addition to a description of its functionalities.
Comments on the Quality of English LanguageA linguistic and stylistic revision is recommended to eliminate some repetitions and improve the fluidity of certain sections.
Author Response
Point 1: First, the article often takes on a descriptive and promotional tone, benefiting from a more critical discussion of the database's limitations, including potential biases in expert selection, uneven geographic and chronological coverage, and the challenges inherent in quantifying complex religious phenomena.
Response: Thank you for pointing this out - we have added in a reference to an article that highlights the strengths and weaknesses of the database, and have acknowledged several weaknesses including those pointed out here.
Second, they should provide more concrete examples of scientific results obtained using HRD, in addition to a description of its functionalities.
Response: We have added in references to some of the projects that have integrated DRH data, and noted that as more data is included more in-depth research projects will be possible.
We also completed a final editing looking out for repetitive sections.
Reviewer 2 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsThe paper "The Database of Religious History as an Open Access Digital Resource for the Study of the Ancient Mediterranean World" is original and of a high importance for the studies on the history of religions. It concerns the ambitious and innovative project of collecting the data about ancient and modern religions from the entire world. The authors of the paper explain carefully the structures, principles and usefulness of the database as well for the researchers as for the broader public. The structure of the paper is clear, arguments logically managed. The attention merits the part concerning the DRH as a pedagogical tool. The authors provide information about the pedagogy packages which can be used by the teachers: both in academia and in the schools. They signal also the collaboration with museum curators in preparing entries concerning the object poll. The multifaceted collaboration as the work on the database shows is very important for understanding the world religions and their history. It enables the dialog between different specialists and non-specialists.
The authors provide examples of the Egyptian and Greek religions. The reviewer has suggestion to put maybe in the content few exemplary images of such entries to the database. Another suggestion would be extending the conclusion with the potential limitations of the usage of the DRH. Furthermore, the reviewer did not notice in the text if the DRH follows FAIR principles with re-usability of the data.
The reviewer observed a small inconsistency within the references: they are sometimes cited with the full first name and in other places they appear only with the initial of the first name, particular cases: Jadwiga and J. Iwaszczuk; Laura and L. Gawlinski; Adam Wiznura. The reviewer puts "accept after minor revision" only for the uniformity of the bibliographical references otherwise the quality of the paper is very high.
Author Response
Suggestion: The reviewer has suggestion to put maybe in the content few exemplary images of such entries to the database. Another suggestion would be extending the conclusion with the potential limitations of the usage of the DRH. Furthermore, the reviewer did not notice in the text if the DRH follows FAIR principles with re-usability of the data.
Response: Thank you for your comments - we added in a few additional examples of entries, which can then be accessed with the link. We decided not to include screenshots of the entries, as the links will provide better access to these entries. We added in several references to the limitations of the DRH, as well as statements discussing the DRH's work towards FAIR principles (interoperability is an ongoing challenge that is currently being worked on).
Reviewer 3 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsThis article makes a valuable contribution to the literature by introducing the Database of Religious History (DRH) and highlighting its potential as a significant resource for future scholarship. It is likely to serve as a useful point of reference for researchers across a range of disciplines. One suggestion for further strengthening the manuscript would be to more explicitly emphasize that the database also contains records pertaining to the Abrahamic traditions (Judaism, Christianity, and Islam) within the Mediterranean context, as well as entries related to Muslim polities such as the Ottoman Empire.
Author Response
Suggestion: One suggestion for further strengthening the manuscript would be to more explicitly emphasize that the database also contains records pertaining to the Abrahamic traditions (Judaism, Christianity, and Islam) within the Mediterranean context, as well as entries related to Muslim polities such as the Ottoman Empire.
Response: Thank you for this suggestion, we have added in a discussion of entries that pertain to these traditions as well.