Review Reports
- Mona Püttner 1,
- Matthias Kohl 2 and
- Wolfgang Kemmler 2,*
- et al.
Reviewer 1: Zbigniew Szygula Reviewer 2: Anonymous
Round 1
Reviewer 1 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsThe paper presented to me for review is a meta-analysis based on a systematic literature search as part of a comprehensive systematic review and evidence map by Reinhardt et al. However, more detailed eligibility criteria concerning study outcomes were applied in the work. The project strictly adhered to the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses (PRISMA) guidelines.
The aim of this systematic review and meta-analysis was to provide reliable evidence of the beneficial effects of WB-EMS on jumping ability, sprint, and agility performance among recreationally and advanced physically active individuals, as well as athletes from various disciplines.
The authors formulated six research hypotheses. The research methodology was described by the authors correctly and in great detail, as were the statistical analyses used. Five electronic databases were reviewed, and from the works published up to March 2025, 12 studies meeting the PRISMA guidelines were selected. After a detailed analysis, the authors rejected all the proposed research hypotheses. In the conclusion, they wrote that generally speaking, WB-EMS provides only limited additional effects on jumping, sprinting, and ability performance—at least compared to predominantly voluntary exercises performed at near-maximal or maximal intensity. However, considering that even small improvements in endurance are important for athletes and individual players, the sample size and statistical power may still be too limited to determine clinically significant changes.
The manuscript presented to me for review is extremely interesting, and I have only a few minor comments: 1) In my opinion, it would be better if the explanation of the abbreviations used in the manuscript were placed at the beginning of the paper. 2) There is no explanation for abbreviations such as "ng" in tables 1 and 2, and "FU" in table 2. 3) In line 420, after the word sportspeople, a quotation mark is missing.
Author Response
see attached file;
Thank you
Author Response File:
Author Response.pdf
Reviewer 2 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsEffects of Whole-Body Electromyostimulation on jumping, sprinting and agility performance in Sportspeople and Athletes. A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis. REVIEW
This study aimed to determine the effect of WB-EMS on maximum jump, sprint and agility performance in exercising cohorts.
The consistent and robust application of the methodology of systematic review and meta-study represents the greatest strength, it should be added that the addressed question is important and interesting for theorists but has even more implications for practitioners in the field of sports training. As a limitation, the number of studies that were addressed can be cited, which reflects the state of the research field and provides guidelines for future researchers in which direction they should direct their research.
Considering all that has been said, I have no major complaints or advice for the authors to improve the final look of the study. They could possibly think about keywords that are quite similar to the title. I also advise that Figure 1 be moved to the methodological section, it is not mandatory, it seems clearer and more logical to me that way. As for the rest of the text and the study, I can say that it is well thought out, informative and ultimately quite well implemented. I congratulate the authors on that. When we have an important research question, practical implications and a robust methodology, I have no other option but to recommend publication. I regret that I do not have more suggestions for authors to help them.
Author Response
Thank you!
Effects of Whole-Body Electromyostimulation on jumping, sprinting and agility performance in Sportspeople and Athletes. A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis
Thank you very much for reviewing the manuscript so quickly. Time is especially precious at Christmas, so we are very grateful that you were able to act as a reviewer. We had difficulties interpreting the data appropriately in some respects, so we are very pleased with the reviewer's approval. We have now highlighted the changes in the manuscript in yellow.