Review Reports
- Diana S. Paiva 1,*,
- Luís Fernandes 1 and
- António Portugal 1,2,*
Reviewer 1: Anonymous Reviewer 2: Anonymous Reviewer 3: Anonymous
Round 1
Reviewer 1 Report
The article is well written. Figures, where degradation / protection would be illustrated, would add the value to the paper.
The article is well written and deals with hot topic of green bio-conservation technologies of stone and the use of fungi.
Include references for the statements in the introduction.
Some minor typos and comments:
Line 37: … finish the sentence
Line 38: delete among many others!
Line 70: including cultural heritage materials [13–15] – specify which materials
Line 133: add "(" after the reference
Line 206: can you specify which quantitative data?
Figure 1. Is it known what kind of secondary minerals are presented on the figure?
Author Response
Dear Reviewer,
Thank you very much for taking the time to review this manuscript and for your overall positive assessment. We appreciate your feedback and your recognition of the relevance of the review. Based on your suggestions, we have thoroughly revised the article to address all concerns and recommendations. We have ensured that all the points you raised have been appropriately incorporated into the manuscript. Please find the detailed responses below and the corresponding revisions/corrections highlighted in the re-submitted files.
Comment: “Include references for the statements in the introduction.”
Response: References were added accordingly to support the statements presented in the Introduction.
Comment: “Some minor typos and comments:”
- Line 37: finish the sentence.
Response: Corrected accordingly.
- Line 38: delete ‘among many others!’
Response: Deleted as suggested.
- Line 70: “including cultural heritage materials [13–15]” – specify which materials.
Response: The sentence was revised for clarity, and the term “materials” was replaced with “assets”.
- Line 133: add “(” after the reference
Response: Corrected accordingly.
- Line 206: can you specify which quantitative data?
Response: The term “quantitative data” refers to the challenge of distinguishing and quantifying the point at which fungal activity causes deterioration and where it shifts toward bioprotective effects. This distinction is particularly difficult, if not practically impossible, under real-world conditions. The text was revised to clarify this point.
Comment:” Figure 1. Is it known what kind of secondary minerals are presented in the figure?”
Response: Unfortunately, the secondary minerals shown in Figure 1 were not analysed in terms of their composition. Providing specific information would therefore be speculative, and for this reason, such details were not included. We hope the reviewer understands this position.
We trust that these revisions have addressed your comments and contributed to improving the overall quality of the article.
On behalf of all the authors,
Kind regards.
Reviewer 2 Report
The review examines the impact of microorganisms on cultural heritage objects. The authors describe destructive impact of microbiota on monument materials and also note the positive role of microorganisms in improving the stone monuments state. While the destructive role of microorganisms has been well studied and discussed in numerous studies, the potential role of microbial biofilms and fungi in the conservation of monuments has been less widely explored and discussed. The authors examine the role of microbiota in biocleaning and bioconsolidation processes, which can contribute to the improvement of monuments. Cases of studies are provided. Overall, the review provides well-known information characterizing the various types of interactions between microorganisms, including fungi, and stone monuments. The information presented in the review may be useful when exploring the problem of preserving cultural heritage sites.
However, there are a number of points to improve the overview. First of all, the review lacks information specifically on fungi, which are primarily known as inhabitants of stone materials. Fungi are mentioned in the title of the article, but very little is said about them. A number of unique microcolonial fungi have been found on stone monuments. These fungi are mentioned only in the reference list but not discussed in the text of the review. It would be interesting to reflect the adaptations of lithobiotic fungi to rocky substrates, localization on stone surfaces, mechanisms of bio-inert interactions, and the phylogenetic diversity of lithobiotic fungi. Unfortunately, the review is dominated by general theses and formulations well known to specialists involved in the study of the biological colonization of stone monuments. Furthermore, the role of fungi in the multispecies biofilms on monuments surface and the interaction of fungi with other organisms in the lithobiontic community is also practically not discussed. Lichens are noted as organisms capable of protecting monuments. However, this controversial topic has received insufficient attention. Significant interest in the impact of lichens on stone monuments is evident in studies of petroglyph biofouling, which deserves greater attention in the context of this topic. This review would likely be more appropriate for publications specializing in the protection and preservation of monuments. Overall, the review devotes insufficient attention to fungi.
The review examines the impact of microorganisms on cultural heritage objects. The authors describe destructive impact of microbiota on monument materials and also note the positive role of microorganisms in improving the stone monuments state. While the destructive role of microorganisms has been well studied and discussed in numerous studies, the potential role of microbial biofilms and fungi in the conservation of monuments has been less widely explored and discussed. The authors examine the role of microbiota in biocleaning and bioconsolidation processes, which can contribute to the improvement of monuments. Cases of studies are provided. Overall, the review provides well-known information characterizing the various types of interactions between microorganisms, including fungi, and stone monuments. The information presented in the review may be useful when exploring the problem of preserving cultural heritage sites.
However, there are a number of points to improve the overview. First of all, the review lacks information specifically on fungi, which are primarily known as inhabitants of stone materials. Fungi are mentioned in the title of the article, but very little is said about them. A number of unique microcolonial fungi have been found on stone monuments. These fungi are mentioned only in the reference list but not discussed in the text of the review. It would be interesting to reflect the adaptations of lithobiotic fungi to rocky substrates, localization on stone surfaces, mechanisms of bio-inert interactions, and the phylogenetic diversity of lithobiotic fungi. Unfortunately, the review is dominated by general theses and formulations well known to specialists involved in the study of the biological colonization of stone monuments. Figure 1 is uninformative and of rather low quality. The role of fungi in the multispecies biofilms on monuments surface and the interaction of fungi with other organisms in the lithobiontic community is also practically not discussed. Lichens are noted as organisms capable of protecting monuments. However, this controversial topic has received insufficient attention. Significant interest in the impact of lichens on stone monuments is evident in studies of petroglyph biofouling, which deserves greater attention in the context of this topic. This review would likely be more appropriate for publications specializing in the protection and preservation of monuments. Overall, the review devotes insufficient attention to fungi.
Author Response
Dear Reviewer,
Thank you very much for taking the time to review this manuscript and for your detailed and thoughtful feedback. We appreciate your careful reading of the review and your recognition of its relevance in the context of cultural heritage preservation.
We acknowledge your comments regarding the limited emphasis on fungi in the original version of the manuscript. In response, we revised the text to better incorporate information on fungi, including aspects related to their diversity, colonisation of stone substrates, and general mechanisms of interaction with stone materials. These additions were made with the aim of strengthening the fungal component of the review, in line with your suggestions.
At the same time, we would like to clarify that the primary objective of this article is to provide a concise review focused on the dual role that microorganisms — particularly fungi — can play in stone heritage conservation, acting both as agents of deterioration and as contributors to bioprotection and conservation strategies. For this reason, we intentionally avoided expanding the discussion into highly detailed topics such as fungal phylogeny, the full complexity of multispecies biofilms, or the extensive and still controversial literature on lichens. Each of these subjects, while highly relevant, involves a level of complexity and volume of information that would require dedicated reviews of their own and would substantially exceed the scope and length of this mini-review.
Nevertheless, we made a concerted effort to address your suggestions in a balanced manner, incorporating additional detail where possible while preserving the focus and readability of the manuscript. Our intention was to improve the article without shifting its emphasis away from its central theme, namely the emerging and less-explored positive roles of microorganisms in bioprotection and bioconsolidation, rather than providing an exhaustive review of all aspects of biological stone colonisation.
We hope that these revisions clarify the intended scope of the review and that the changes made adequately address your concerns, contributing to an improved and more focused manuscript. We thank you again for your valuable feedback and constructive suggestions.
On behalf of all the authors,
Kind regards.
Reviewer 3 Report
The article on "Fungi and stone heritage conservation: friend, foe, or a bit of both" is a review article. Its aim is to use fungi and other microorganisms as conservation agents. The article explores topics relevant to stone conservation, particularly in terms of preserving cultural heritage for future generations. It presents several methods that are in line with the policy of sustainable and environmentally friendly repair and conservation of building materials. The article is interesting and easy to read. However, the lack of illustrations makes it a bit of a monoblock to read. If possible, the authors should consider adding illustrations or tables to liven up the article. It also seems that a summary in the form of a table of all the methods described, highlighting their advantages and disadvantages, would be a good way to summarise the whole topic.
none
Author Response
Dear Reviewer,
Thank you very much for taking the time to review this manuscript and for your overall positive assessment. We appreciate your feedback and your recognition of the relevance of the review. We are grateful for your constructive suggestions regarding the visual presentation of the manuscript. In response, and following comments from another reviewer, we have added more focused information on stone-colonising fungi and included several figures to improve the visual clarity of the text. We chose not to include tables, as they would largely repeat information already presented in the text and unnecessarily increase the length of the manuscript. We trust that these changes have addressed your comments and contributed to improving the overall quality of the article.
On behalf of all the authors,
Kind regards.
Round 2
Reviewer 2 Report
The authors took into account comments and suggestions and significantly enriched the article with data from various modern publications. The list of references was also significantly expanded. The updated version of the article is significantly improved. The problem with Figure 3 remains to be fixed.
A comment remains regarding Figure 3. It remains unclear what is depicted in Figure 3. The authors obviously refer to mineral structures. However, it is unclear what these structures are, what minerals they belong to, and there is no confirmation of their composition. They could easily have simply precipitated in the B4 nutrient medium, and whether this medium was used for control without fungi. Furthermore, black yeast-like fungi are the least active in biomineralization. Their significance on the stone is largely determined by localization in microzones and mechanical action on the substrate, as well as EPS production. In order to use this photo in an article, a reference to each of the three images is required, along with confirmation of the attribution of the crystals to specific minerals. Based on this, I propose either removing this image from the article, either explaining in detail what it depicts, or replacing it with crystallization in the B4 medium with a another fungal species that is more active in the secondary mineralization process. However, the best solution is to replace Figure 3 with another clear figure from some published work (there are many such works) with an appropriate reference as was done for Figure 2.
Author Response
We thank the reviewer for the positive overall assessment of the manuscript and for the constructive comments. Regarding Figure 3, we have followed the reviewer’s suggestion and removed this figure from the manuscript. We believe this revision improves the clarity of the study and helps to avoid potential misinterpretation. We thank the reviewer for the valuable suggestions.