Review Reports
- Rayane Caroline Medeiros do Nascimento 1,*,
- Erik Antônio Barros Guedes 1 and
- Marília Oliveira Fonseca Goulart 1
- et al.
Reviewer 1: Anonymous Reviewer 2: Gerald Fritz Schusser
Round 1
Reviewer 1 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsThe authors conducted an interested research study on oxidative stress and inflammatory biomarkers in Vaquejada trained vs sedentary quarter horses. This topic is relevant to equine sports medicine and welfare. However several methodological, analytical and presentation issues require attention before publication can be recommended.
This study include 60athlets versus 10 controls. this severe imbalance (6:1) compromises statistical power and increase risk of type I/II errors.
sex distribution Ag has 36 male and 24 females while GC has 1 male 9 female, sex is known to influence redox status and hematological parameters.
please perform stratified analysis of sex
include sex x athletic status interaction terms in regression models.
consider recruiting additional male controls or female athletes to balance the groups
please discuss how sexual dimorphism in antioxidant defenses, may affect interpretations.
The manuscript adjusts for sex and body weight but not for age, training volume, or competition frequency. Age distributions are presented but not included in multivariate models.
Add age as a covariate in adjusted models
collect and included the trainig load data
please use mixed effects models with stud farm as random effect to account for clustering.
Samples were collected "four days after competition" - this is a critical methodological detail that significantly affects interpretation of muscle damage markers (CK, AST),
please Justify the 4-day recovery period based on published equine CK clearance kinetics (typically 48-72 hours post-exercise)
please consider serial sampling (24h, 48h, 72h, 96h post-exercise) to capture peak and recovery phases
If only resting samples are available, avoid interpreting CK/AST as "no muscle damage" - instead state "no residual elevation at 96 hours post-exercise.
Several important confounders and outcome measures are absent like Training variables, nutritional data, hydration status, lactate levels.
The manuscript states "lower CAT activity constitutes a key marker of redox imbalance" and attributes it to "enzymatic exhaustion." However, lower CAT could also reflect, downregulation of the antioxidant enzyme expression, genetic variation in CAT promoters regions, different baseline levels unrelated to exercise.
I suggest please measure CAT gene expressions (qPCR from whole blood or muscle biopsy)
Normalize CAT activity to total protein level
consider more direct measures of H202 production to support the exhaustion.
The manuscript simultaneously suggests MPO is a marker of neutrophil activity AND interprets lower MPO in athletes as "reduced neutrophil activity AND a "protective adaptation. This requires more nuanced interpretation
please perform neutrophils counts and correlate with MPO levels
Consider measuring other granule enzymes (elastase, lactoferrin) to distinguish between reduced neutrophil number versus reduced degranulation.
The conclusion that "no significant inflammatory response" exists is weakened by lack of post-exercise samples. Cytokines typically peak within 2-6 hours of exercise, please revise it. check all the references please. Conclusion must be concise please.
Approximately 30 separate comparisons were performed without correction for multiple testing, inflating type I error rate. Apply Benjamini-Hochberg false discovery rate (FDR) correction (q < 0.10 or 0.20), report both uncorrected and corrected p-values.
Figure 1 is described but not provided in the manuscript. the groups information must be consistent please check throughout the manuscript
Tables 1-4 have inconsistent formatting, missing units, and unclear abbreviations. please check carefully units for all parameters analysed.
There are some minor English grammar mistakes please check throughout manuscript
The MDA method uses UV detection at 270 nm, but the Tatum et al. (1990) reference uses fluorescence detection (excitation 515 nm, emission 553 nm). Please clarify.
The manuscript addresses an interesting and clinically relevant question but has substantial methodological limitations that must be addressed. The severe sample size imbalance, sex confounding, lack of training load data, and absence of multiple comparison corrections are the most critical issues. If the authors can address these concerns (particularly by recruiting additional controls and providing a more nuanced interpretation of the resting biomarker data), the paper could make a valuable contribution to equine sports physiology literature.
Comments on the Quality of English Language
n/a
Author Response
Please see the attachment.
Author Response File:
Author Response.docx
Reviewer 2 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsDear Authors, please use SI-units and correct these!
Comments for author File:
Comments.pdf
Author Response
Please see the attachment.
Author Response File:
Author Response.docx
Round 2
Reviewer 1 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsAuthors substantially revised the manuscript as per my suggestions and improved the quality of the manuscript for readers. However the authors generated figure 2 by AI, please prepare it by yourself using different software avoid to use AI to generate figures.
Thanks
Comments on the Quality of English Languagen/a
Author Response
Reviewer Comment: "Authors substantially revised the manuscript as per my suggestions and improved the quality of the manuscript for readers. However, the authors generated Figure 2 by AI; please prepare it by yourself using different software and avoid using AI to generate figures.”
Response: We sincerely thank the reviewer for the positive evaluation of our revisions and for acknowledging the improvement in the manuscript's quality.
Regarding Figure 2 and the Graphical Abstract, we fully accept your recommendation. We have completely redone both illustrations from scratch using standard, non-AI software. Specifically, the new versions were manually prepared using Microsoft PowerPoint and BioRender. We guarantee that no Artificial Intelligence tools or generative AI features were used in the creation of these new figures.
We hope these updated, manually designed illustrations fully satisfy the reviewer’s request.
Author Response File:
Author Response.pdf