Review Reports
- Qingyue Li 1,
- Zhi Zhao 2 and
- Xiaoxia Li 2,*
- et al.
Reviewer 1: Ali Rafe Reviewer 2: Corina Predescu Reviewer 3: Anonymous
Round 1
Reviewer 1 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsThe study investigates the synergistic effects of the probiotic Bifidobacterium animalis subsp. lactis IU100 and type III resistant starch (RS3) on the aroma and sensory characteristics of fermented milk. The authors report that combining these components not only enhances the flavor profile of the yogurt but also optimizes fermentation time and texture properties. The paper is well-structured and provides a comprehensive understanding of the subject, but it could benefit from addressing broader implications and further statistical validation.
M&M section:
Texture analysis should be given with detail information such as test speed. I recommend using and comparing your findings with mozzarella cheese in this work “Effect of inulin/kefiran mixture on the rheological and structural properties of mozzarella cheese” you can see they analyzed the penetration test on cheese and give the details of the experiment.
Please use the details information of the experiment for SEM. You can use the previous work in your citation and compare the findings with them.
While the study covers a wide range of aspects, the statistical analysis could benefit from a broader dataset to validate the findings further.
The potential sensory implications (e.g., consumer acceptability) should be explicitly mentioned, as these are crucial for practical applications.
Results and discussion:
Please use the for mentioned paper in your comparison with your data.
Please use recent works in your discussion such as “Comparative effects of the probiotic bacteria and carob powder on the quality properties of peanut butter” (2025) which is closely related to the prebiotic effects. This is also for the youghurt “Application of microencapsulated propolis extract in yoghurt production” (2024).
Furthermore, It is interesting to have an analysis on nutritional properties and provide some comparison with the paper “Nutritional composition, physicochemical, microbiological, and sensory properties of flavored biofermented camel milk containing chickpea milk”. It seems it improve the quality of the work and increase its readings.
Additionally, the environmental impact of using such supplements in large-scale productions could be discussed.
Author Response
Please see the attachment.
Author Response File:
Author Response.pdf
Reviewer 2 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsDear authors,
You did a great job regarding your manuscript entitled "Impact of Co-Supplementation with Bifidobacterium animalis subsp. lactis IU100 and Type III Resistant Starch on the Aroma Profile of Fermented Milk." There are some required improvements:
- Regarding the title, "Impact of Co-Supplementation with Bifidobacterium animalis subsp. lactis IU100 and Type III Resistant Starch on the Aroma Profile of Fermented Milk," the most natural scientific interpretation assumes that the milk was already fermented, and then it was co-supplemented with B. animalis subsp. lactis IU100 and Type III resistant starch. I checked the materials and methods, and it is clearly detailed that milk was homogenized with RS3, and after this, you added the fermentation strains as "(1). Fermented milk with only the 4.0 starter culture; (2). Fermented milk supplemented with the 4.0 starter culture and B. lactis IU100; (3). Fermented milk containing the 4.0 starter culture and 1.5% RS3 (4). Fermented milk with the 4.0 starter culture, B. lactis IU100, and 1.5% RS3". I suggest changing the title. If the authors actually meant fermentation with the strain, the title would need to be adjusted, for example: “Impact of Fermentation with Bifidobacterium animalis subsp. lactis IU100 and Supplementation with Type III Resistant Starch on the Aroma Profile of Fermented Milk” or "Impact of Co-Fermentation with Bifidobacterium animalis subsp. lactis IU100 and Type III Resistant Starch on the Aroma Profile of Fermented Milk."
- The summary doesn't need this phrase: "UHPLC‑Q Exactive HF‑X combined with KEGG pathway analysis revealed that 24 differential metabolites were predominantly enriched in purine metabolism and amino acid‑related pathways." "Placed it in the discussion section! Is KEGG pathway the abbreviation for Kyoto Encyclopedia of Genes and Genomes? You didn't mention it!
- The introduction section doesn't give any information about Bifidobacterium animalis subsp. lactis IU100. What bibliography led to this decision to use it? Why is resistant starch a prebiotic for yogurt? Can you give some arguments?
- The Materials and Methods section describes the methods. Section 2.1 Preparation of Fermented Milk presents the milk preparation in order to be fermented. So please modify the subtitle section. In my opinion, section 2.2, Preparation of Set-Type Yogurt, should start with the description of the four yogurts and then describe the additions.
- NAD is correctly written like this. Modify in figure 6.
- "The formation of the volatile aldehyde 4-ethylbenzaldehyde is related to glutamic acid within the cocaine addiction pathway." That sentence is not correct in a scientific food context, and it raises a big red flag! Modify it!
Author Response
Please see the attachment.
Author Response File:
Author Response.pdf
Reviewer 3 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsDear Autors
The submitted manuscript presents comprehensive and rigorous research on the synergistic effect of Bifidobacterium animalis subsp. lactis IU100 and type III resistant starch (RS3) on the textural, microstructural, and aromatic properties of fermented milk. The authors employ a wide array of analytical methods—from HS‑SPME‑GC‑MS and LC‑MS/MS to KEGG analysis—enabling a multifaceted assessment of metabolic and sensory changes. The work is well grounded in the current state of knowledge and has high applicative value for the dairy industry. The manuscript is clearly written, logically structured, and scientifically sound. The results are convincing and well visualised.
The study stands out for its very broad methodological scope, encompassing fermentation kinetics, texture and microstructure analysis, profiling of volatile and non‑volatile metabolites, and metabolic pathway analysis (KEGG). Such an integrated approach not only describes sensory changes but also elucidates their metabolic underpinnings—an important added value of the work. The authors go beyond the mere presentation of results and propose clear biochemical mechanisms explaining the increased production of esters (e.g., octyl acetate), the intensified formation of alcohols and ketones, and the roles of NAD⁺, α‑keto acids, and amino‑acid precursors. The interpretations are coherent, supported by the literature, and represent a strong point of the manuscript. The combination of B. lactis and RS3 significantly shortens fermentation time, improves protein gel consistency and water retention, and enhances the aroma profile (with an increase in esters exhibiting fruity and creamy notes). The findings can be directly leveraged by producers of functional yoghurts.
Although the authors provide a detailed analysis of metabolites, the study does not include a sensory panel involving consumers or trained experts. Incorporating such an assessment would substantially strengthen the conclusions regarding flavour and aroma perception.
In addition, the manuscript does not report data on aroma stability during storage or on textural changes during refrigerated storage. These aspects could be critical for evaluating industrial applications.
Partial results are presented, but the discussion could place greater emphasis on the differences between B. lactis alone, RS3 alone, and their combination.
In several places, the following additions would be helpful:
- more detailed descriptions of GC‑MS parameters (column, temperature programme);
- information on the number of biological replicates in the metabolomics analyses (technical replicates are provided, but not biological);
- a brief justification for the choice of RS3 at a concentration of 1.5%.
The paper makes a significant contribution to research on functional foods, particularly in the area of probiotic–prebiotic synergy and its impact on the aroma profile of fermented products. The application of comprehensive metabolomics renders this publication modern and attractive to readers. The manuscript is of high scientific quality, and its main theses are well substantiated.
The proposed amendments concern only formal and interpretative elements—the core results and methodology are coherent and sound.
Author Response
Please see the attachment.
Author Response File:
Author Response.pdf
Round 2
Reviewer 2 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsDear authors,
You did a great job regarding the manuscript "Impact of Co-Fermentation with Bifidobacterium animalis subsp. lactis IU100 and Type III Resistant Starch on the Aroma Profile of Fermented Milk." Still, I didn't find the aim of the study clearly written in the last part of the introduction. Can you write it?
Author Response
Please see the attachment.
Author Response File:
Author Response.pdf