Review Reports
- Loye Daniel Paterno Onesimo and
- Jørund Aasetre *
Reviewer 1: Anonymous Reviewer 2: Anonymous Reviewer 3: Anonymous
Round 1
Reviewer 1 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsNumbering if the chapters must be revised
Reseach question number 1 is unclear. What is "positive attitudes" and who will suggest what is positive or negative?
This research question should be revised, and in my view, changed.
Ubuntu is a concept that does not necessarily relate to this cultural context. This must be made clear.
The theoretical perspective of "Whole school" is deceloped in a Western context, and could be legt out. Pedagogical perspectives are relevant, together with experience and educational background of the teachers
Author Response
First, we want to thank the reviewers for their good and helpful comments.
We have tried to address all those comments and adjusted the documents accordantly.
Some places where we have not made big changes we have tried explaining our position. We hope our responses and changes has made the manuscript much better
Language improvement is done through the service given by the publisher. This has been done and
In the rest of this document we have replied to the comments of the reviewers and given our response marked in yellow.
Also, in the manuscript we have marked new/ changed text with yellow.
Author Response File:
Author Response.pdf
Reviewer 2 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsThis manuscript addresses a significant knowledge gap by investigating the intersection of environmental attitudes and pedagogical practices among primary school teachers in the fragile, post-conflict urban contexts of South Sudan. The study successfully avoids imposing standard Western environmental scales that lack localised relevance, opting instead for a context-bound, community-oriented framework that aligns with survival-driven pragmatism and African philosophical principles like Ubuntu. This conceptual framing proves valuable in its explanation of why teachers express strong pro-environmental sentiment toward localised, livelihood-related issues (e.g., soil erosion, tree planting) while remaining detached from abstract global challenges like industrial climate change.
Methodologically, the study adopts an exploratory survey design with a sample size of 254 teachers. The authors are highly transparent about their sampling constraints, explicitly acknowledging the convenience/urban bias, hierarchical structural barriers via school headmasters, and political sensitivities that led to a lower response rate in some locations. Despite these limitations, the statistical analyses, exploratory factor analysis, reliability testing, and multivariate OLS regressions are appropriately cautious in their generalisations.
The empirical results clearly reveal the paradox: while systemic resource constraints and minimal formal training force teachers to rely heavily on traditional "talk and chalk" instruction, these teachers concurrently exhibit deep relational care, trying to heavily motivate and protect their students. The discussion of these findings recognizes that these mixed instructional behaviours reflect an immediate reaction to classroom realities and large class sizes rather than a unified, deliberate pedagogical strategy.
The article concludes with well-supported insights into how contextual realities impede the seamless translation of positive environmental mindsets into progressive, learner-centred instruction.
The paper requires some minor corrections that include statistical formatting and notation (for example, change all commas used as decimals to standard academic periods in tables and text); Standardise the multivariate regression notation in Table 6 (Change the column header St. Beta to \(\beta \) or \(\beta \). Change Std. Error to SE); Standardise notations in Table 5, Table 6, and Figure 6 (clarify if single asterisks mean \(p < 0.05\) or \(p \le 0.05\) across all figures); Report Exact P-Values (Replace <,001 with exact exponential forms like \(< .001\) in Table 5 and Table 6. Remove the leading zero before the decimal point to match standard styles).
There are also some duplicate figure numbers (Change the second "Figure 1" on page 10 to Figure 2, and "Figure 2" on page 11 to Figure 3. Shift subsequent figures up sequentially)
Clean unformatted text in lines 270, 288, 307, 322, 334, and 374.
Correct spelling errors in the analysis text. Change "rater weak" on line 536 to "rather weak". Change "resample to some degree" on line 468 to "resemble to some degree".
Finally, add missing publication details in the references section. Provide the missing volume, issue, and page numbers for Breidlid (2019) on lines 558–559.
Check the year mismatch for the citation Wals et al. (2023) on line 143. The references section lists this entry as Wals et al. (2024) on line 657.
Fix text spacing errors in parenthetical references. Revise "Potter-Nielson & O'Neil 2019" on lines 37–38 or "Potter-Nelson & O'Neil, 2019" in the reference list.
Author Response
First, we want to thank the reviewers for their good and helpful comments.
We have tried to address all those comments and adjusted the documents accordantly.
Some places where we have not made big changes we have tried explaining our position. We hope our responses and changes has made the manuscript much better
Language improvement is done through the service given by the publisher. This has been done and
In the rest of this document we have replied to the comments of the reviewers and given our response marked in yellow.
Also, in the manuscript we have marked new/ changed text with yellow.
Author Response File:
Author Response.pdf
Reviewer 3 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsOverall Evaluation
The manuscript addresses an important and relatively original topic: the relationship between teachers' environmental attitudes in South Sudan and their pedagogical practices in environmental education (EE/ESD). It holds strong potential, particularly due to the unique context of South Sudan, the tension between local/community-survival environmentalism and abstract Western environmentalism, and the observable gap between positive environmental attitudes and classroom instruction that largely remains "talk and chalk."
However, in its current state, the manuscript requires substantial strengthening in three key areas: theoretical precision, methodological clarity, and a major overhaul of the English language writing. The central issue is not the sample size or the statistical analysis per se, but rather that while the manuscript often "correctly understands" its empirical findings, it does not always present them in a sufficiently sharp, polished, and compelling manner.
- Abstract
The abstract contains most necessary components: research objective, target population, methodology, and key findings. It correctly notes that a survey of 254 teachers was conducted, showing that teachers demonstrate positive environmental attitudes grounded in a local-community context, alongside a positive but weak correlation between environmental engagement and learner-centred pedagogy.
However, the abstract is currently wordy, cumbersome, and repetitive. It uses phrasing that requires academic editing, such as:
- "This then gave the paradoxical combination..."
- "Rather, talk and chalk in combination with caring for learners."
These formulations lack sufficient academic rigor. Furthermore, the theoretical contribution is not sharply articulated. The abstract should explicitly state that the paper contributes to the understanding of context-bound environmentalism and the attitude-pedagogy gap within a resource-scarce, post-conflict educational setting.
Regarding research questions: your design encompasses three stages (establishing whether teachers exhibit environmental engagement, identifying implemented pedagogical practices, and examining their relationship). I suggest rephrasing the core objective in the abstract: "This study examines the relationship between teachers' levels of environmentalism and their educational practices in primary schools across South Sudan."
General note: "Talk and chalk" teaching does not inherently contradict learner welfare or care.
- Research Questions
The research questions are clear and well-suited for a quantitative survey study:
- Do teachers in South Sudan exhibit positive environmental attitudes and engagement?
- What teaching practices do they favor when teaching environmental topics?
- How are environmental attitudes and engagement related to their choice of teaching practices?
While these questions fit the study and are adequately answered by the data, Question 3 is the most crucial and should serve as the central axis of the manuscript rather than as one of three equal pillars. Currently, the manuscript drifts between describing attitudes, describing methods, constructing indices, and explaining their relationship.
Recommendation: At the end of the introduction, state a stronger core claim: The study investigates whether teacher environmentalism in South Sudan translates into learner-centred pedagogical practices—and demonstrates that this translation is partial, weak, and heavily mediated by systemic constraints.
- Theoretical Framework
A theoretical framework is present, but it lacks focus. The manuscript blends multiple conceptual threads: EE/ESD, environmental attitudes, NEP, Ubuntu, Western vs. African environmentalism, teacher-centred vs. learner-centred pedagogy, and the attitude–practice gap.
While relevant, the framework currently reads like a broad literature review rather than an analytical framework driving the study. For instance, discussions on Western environmentalism, ecological modernization, deep ecology, degrowth, and Ubuntu are presented, but it is not always clear how these translate into actual empirical measurement. Conversely, the teacher-centred vs. learner-centred section is highly relevant to your research questions. The paper assumes that teachers with strong environmental commitments would adopt learner-centred approaches, but acknowledges that this link may fail in South Sudan due to systemic constraints (rigid curricula, large class sizes, resource scarcity, and exam-driven cultures).
Key Recommendation: Streamline the theoretical framework around three core axes:
- Environmentalism as context-bound: Local, community-based, and survival-oriented environmentalism in South Sudan.
- Pedagogy under constraint: Teacher-centred vs. learner-centred instruction within a resource-scarce educational system.
- The attitude–practice gap: The disconnect between positive environmental attitudes and actual classroom practices.
Additional Notes on Literature:
- The opening paragraph covers broad topics (environmental crisis, ESD, EE, systemic integration) while citing only two sources. Additional citations are necessary for each sub-topic.
- Relying on a source from 2001 to support fundamental assumptions requires updating; we are now a quarter-century ahead. Incorporate more recent literature alongside classic citations (e.g., 1973, 1985).
- Clarify terminology: Are sustainability, environment, and environmental literacy treated as synonymous? Maintain consistent usage throughout to ease readability.
- Caution on the EE vs. ESD debate: Navigating the philosophical distinctions between Environmental Education (EE) and Education for Sustainable Development (ESD) is a conceptual minefield. I advise against getting bogged down in this debate. Instead, ground your definition specifically in the South Sudanese context: define environmental education as an intervention intended not only to impart knowledge but to drive behavioral and practical change. Cite relevant local/regional literature to support this operational definition and avoid repetitive phrasing like "EE and ESD."
- The definition of "broad environmentalism" currently lacks boundaries, making it difficult to distinguish an environmentally engaged teacher from an unengaged one.
- Alignment Between Theory and Findings
There is good alignment between the empirical findings and the theoretical framing, though it requires more elegant articulation. For instance, findings show that teachers express positive environmental attitudes primarily regarding concrete, local issues (tree planting, pollution, soil degradation, future livelihoods). The discussion rightly interprets this as community- and livelihood-based environmentalism rather than abstract environmental ideology.
The connection between "talk and chalk" and teacher care is another compelling paradox: teachers lean on traditional pedagogy while simultaneously expressing strong dedication to supporting and motivating students. The manuscript attributes this partly to limited training, but also suggests a resonance with the Ubuntu ethos ("I am because we are").
Caution on Ubuntu: This interpretation is intriguing, but currently risks sounding overly speculative. Because the study lacks qualitative data or direct survey items measuring Ubuntu values, frame this strictly as an interpretive possibility rather than a direct finding.
Suggested formulation:
"The findings may be read as resonating with Ubuntu-oriented relational commitments; however, because the study did not directly measure Ubuntu values, this interpretation should remain cautious and exploratory."
- Research Approach and Methodology
This is an exploratory quantitative survey study conducted across two districts (Juba and Yei) sampling 45 urban primary schools. The manuscript correctly notes that the sample represents urban contexts rather than South Sudan as a whole.
However, several methodological issues need addressing:
- Sampling terminology: There is confusion between probability, random, and convenience sampling. The text notes schools were selected randomly, but later acknowledges that field constraints prevented true probability sampling. Clarify this as a convenience/purposive sample within selected districts.
- Administration details: Clarify who completed the questionnaires within the schools. Were all teachers invited? Did headmasters select participants? Were there non-respondents? Given that headmasters distributed questionnaires, address this potential selection bias explicitly.
- Ethics section: Include a dedicated ethical considerations paragraph covering informed consent, anonymity, institutional approval/clearance, voluntary participation, and independence from school management.
- Research Stages: If the study comprised three distinct phases—(1) adapting/developing a context-specific instrument, (2) pilot testing and validating with 50 teachers, and (3) administering the validated survey to 250 teachers—state this sequence explicitly. Report factor analysis, Cronbach’s alpha values, and present the survey instrument itself. A validated instrument adapted for South Sudan represents a significant scholarly contribution for future African EE research.
Note to Editor/Authors: I believe this study addresses an under-researched context and has strong merit. While not acceptable in its current form, it can reach publication standard through a Major Revision. I am open to sharing my contact details via the editorial office should the authors require direct guidance in refining this manuscript.
- Data Collection
Data collection procedures are outlined but require deeper specification. The paper notes that Likert-scale questionnaires were hand-delivered to teachers and included several open-ended items. It justifies avoiding standard Western scales (e.g., NEP) due to cultural mismatch, opting instead for locally adapted items.
This methodological choice is sound, but requires further justification:
- How were the items originally drafted?
- Who verified content validity? Were local South Sudanese educational experts involved?
- In what language(s) was the instrument administered? Was a translation–back-translation process used?
- How were core constructs like "environment," "climate change," and "environmental engagement" operationalized for respondents?
- Were open-ended responses systematically analyzed? If not, do not frame them as a primary data source.
- Pilot Study Details: Expand on the March 2022 pilot study (N=50 across 10 schools in Juba). Specify what modifications were made to the final instrument based on pilot results.
- Data Analysis
Statistical procedures (SPSS, t-tests, Chi-square, Pearson, Spearman, EFA/Factor Analysis, Cronbach's alpha, OLS regression) are largely appropriate. Using alpha > 0.70 as a threshold for index construction is standard practice.
The strongest analytical element is the index construction (constructing an environmental engagement index with alpha = 0.756, and a learner-centred and exploratory approaches index with alpha = 0.712).
However, technical reporting must be improved:
- Report KMO and Bartlett’s Test of Sphericity for factor analyses.
- Specify extraction method (e.g., PCA vs. EFA) and rotation method (e.g., Varimax, Direct Oblimin).
- Explain why certain items were grouped into a "theoretical" index when initial factor structures were ambiguous.
- Correct terminology: Change "explanatory study" to "exploratory study" where appropriate.
- Fix figure/table numbering inconsistencies (e.g., duplicate or mislabeled "Figure 1", "Figure 2").
- Regression interpretation: The OLS model explains only 12.6% of the variance in the pedagogical index and almost none in environmental engagement. Frame this explicitly in the discussion: demographic variables alone are insufficient to explain these pedagogical patterns, highlighting the need for qualitative follow-up research.
- Handling Low Reliability: The authors correctly refrain from forcing items into an index when reliability is low (e.g., alpha = 0.51 for teacher-centred approaches). This academic honesty is a strength. However, in Table 4, reporting Factor 2 (alpha = 0.53) and Factor 3 (single-item) as interpretable factors is problematic—alphas below 0.60 are generally unreliable. Refrain from discussing Factor 2 ("controversial statements") as a primary finding.
- Structure: Do not open the data analysis section with apologies or study limitations. Describe the analytical procedures first, and move discussions of standard field constraints to a dedicated Limitations section.
- Findings
The findings effectively answer the research questions, demonstrating that:
- Teachers hold positive environmental attitudes focused on local, tangible issues.
- Pedagogical practices lean heavily toward teacher-centred "talk and chalk" methods.
- The correlation between environmental engagement and learner-centred pedagogy is positive but weak.
- Stronger correlations exist between environmental engagement and teacher motivation to support and care for students.
The most compelling contribution is the paradox: teachers can be environmentally committed and deeply caring toward students, yet rely strictly on traditional teaching methods. This challenges the naive assumption that positive environmental attitudes automatically yield active, learner-centred pedagogy.
Presentation Note: The findings section is heavily laden with tables and figures but lacks concise interpretive "bottom lines." Conclude each sub-section with a summary sentence tying the statistical output directly back to the research question.
- Discussion
The discussion is stronger than the introduction, successfully bridging empirical results with the South Sudanese context. It clarifies that teacher environmentalism is grounded in community, soil, trees, and livelihood rather than abstract concepts like deep ecology or degrowth.
Furthermore, it offers a nuanced reading of teacher pedagogy: rather than holding a single rigid ideology, teachers deploy traditional methods while remaining attentive to emotional and social needs.
To increase impact, structure the discussion clearly around three core arguments:
- Environmentalism in South Sudan is not weak; it is differently organized.
- Environmental engagement does not automatically produce learner-centred pedagogy.
- In fragile educational systems, care for learners often coexists with teacher-centred methods rather than replacing them.
- Overall Contribution
- Theoretical Contribution: Highlights that the attitude–practice link is not universal; it is heavily mediated by culture, teacher training, class size, available resources, and institutional structures.
- Practical Contribution: Demonstrates that raising environmental awareness alone is insufficient in South Sudan. Professional development must bridge environmental commitment with active, outdoor, inquiry-based pedagogical techniques.
- Key Policy Insight: Teacher training in South Sudan should build upon existing local environmentalism (trees, land, water, livelihoods, community) rather than imposing abstract Western environmental frameworks.
- Language, Structure, and Style
Language and copyediting represent a major weakness. The manuscript contains numerous grammatical errors, awkward formulations, syntax issues, and inconsistent terminology.
Examples requiring correction:
- "This then gave the paradoxical combination"
- "teachers’ environmental attitudes and engagement was measured" (subject-verb agreement)
- "This indicate"
- "This to some degree this contrast"
- "a very large classes"
- "the study was interesting as an explanatory study" (should be exploratory)
- "citizenship values must be thought" (should be taught)
- "spectre" (used incorrectly instead of spectrum)
- Inconsistent usage: "teacher-based/learner-based" vs. "teacher-centred/learner-centred"
Professional English copyediting is mandatory prior to resubmission. Poor language quality currently obscures valid academic insights.
- Quantitative Reporting Standards
As a quantitative survey study (N = 254), the sample size is acceptable for exploratory research, allowing for descriptive statistics, correlations, basic factor analysis, and regression.
To meet journal standards, supply the following missing technical details:
- Standardize p-value formatting (e.g., p < .001 rather than missing leading zeros or incorrect operators).
- Use standard English decimal notation (0.756 instead of European comma notation 0,756).
- Re-format all tables visually and linguistically according to APA / journal guidelines.
Summary & Final Recommendation
Strengths:
- Examines a critical, under-researched context (teachers, EE/ESD, South Sudan).
- Sound sample size with valuable empirical insights.
- Uncovers a meaningful paradox regarding local environmentalism, teacher care, and traditional instruction.
Weaknesses:
- Overly broad, unfocused theoretical framework.
- Overly speculative reliance on Ubuntu concepts without direct measurement.
- Missing methodological and technical reporting details (instrument validation, sampling, factor analysis specifics).
- Requires extensive English language copyediting and structural sharpening.
Priority Action Items for Revision:
- Sharpen the paper's core thesis around context-bound environmentalism and the attitude–practice gap.
- Streamline the theoretical framework into three distinct analytical axes.
- Provide full methodological transparency regarding instrument development, pilot testing, sampling procedures, ethics, and factor analysis.
- Expand the Limitations section to address sampling constraints and low-reliability scales.
- Obtain professional academic English proofreading.
- Reframing the Abstract and Discussion around a single, cohesive argument: In South Sudan, positive environmental attitudes are prevalent but insufficient to drive active environmental pedagogy without targeted training, institutional resources, and structural support.
Author Response
First, we want to thank the reviewers for their good and helpful comments.
We have tried to address all those comments and adjusted the documents accordantly.
Some places where we have not made big changes we have tried explaining our position. We hope our responses and changes has made the manuscript much better
Language improvement is done through the service given by the publisher. This has been done and
In the rest of this document we have replied to the comments of the reviewers and given our response marked in yellow.
Also, in the manuscript we have marked new/ changed text with yellow.
Author Response File:
Author Response.pdf