Abstract
We study gravitational complexity in the framework of Generalized Vaidya geometry for the first time. Adopting a general semi-tetrad covariant approach, we find the structure scalars of a Type II fluid in this spacetime and establish the relationship between the covariant quantities and these structure scalars. By calculating the complexity factor in terms of the Misner–Sharp mass and the matter variables, we obtain a non-trivial class of spacetimes with vanishing complexity. Furthermore, we show that the Vaidya spacetime with a pure Type II matter field yields a negative complexity factor, highlighting the fundamental difference between the complexity of Type I and Type II matter fields. We also compute the propagation and evolution equations of the structure scalars to showcase their interdependency through the kinematical variables. Finally, we study the wave equation of the gravitational mass of the 2-shell and analyze its dependence on these structure scalars.
1. Introduction
A gravitational system can have a simple or a highly complicated configuration, depending on how matter is distributed and how the gravitational field responds to it. This provides a natural setting for the notion of complexity: a configuration becomes more complex when its properties involve features such as density inhomogeneity, pressure anisotropy, and tidal gravitational effects. Quantifying such complexity in a covariant manner is, however, not straightforward. Herrera et al. [1] proposed a geometric prescription based on the structure scalars obtained from the orthogonal splitting of the Riemann tensor with respect to a timelike observer [2]. For a spherically symmetric system, the corresponding complexity factor combines the electric Weyl tensor with the pressure anisotropy. Since the electric Weyl tensor characterizes the local tidal gravitational field and is related to density inhomogeneity, captures the interplay between the matter distribution and the gravitational field. In spherical symmetry the magnetic Weyl tensor vanishes, so the electric part contains the complete local tidal contribution.
The Herrera prescription was initially developed for static, spherically symmetric systems [1] and was subsequently extended to dynamical configurations by Herrera et al. [3]. It was later applied to axially symmetric static systems [4] and to cylindrical symmetry [5,6]. A substantial body of work has since explored this prescription in different settings [7,8,9,10,11]. More recently, complexity in static fluid systems with hyperbolic symmetry has also been investigated [12,13,14]. The prescription has further been extended to various modified theories of gravity [15,16,17,18,19,20,21]. A broader overview of these developments can be found in [22] and the references therein. In recent years, Naseer, Sharif and collaborators have also investigated the complexity of Type I fluids in modified theories of gravity, including , and Rastall gravity [23,24,25,26,27]. These studies have obtained different classes of solutions satisfying vanishing-complexity conditions and further demonstrate the applicability of the Herrera prescription to non-GR settings.
This Paper
The situation is different when the matter contains a null component. Type II matter fields describe configurations containing null radiation together with ordinary matter and arise naturally in dynamical systems such as radiating stars and black holes. The generalized Vaidya spacetime provides a natural setting for such configurations [28,29] and has been widely used in studies of gravitational collapse, naked singularity formation, black-hole evaporation, and Hawking radiation. The recent work of Dadhich and Goswami [30], relating classical Vaidya radiation to quantum Hawking radiation, further emphasizes the relevance of Type II matter in dynamical black-hole spacetimes.
Despite the considerable development of the Herrera complexity prescription, the complexity of Type II matter has not been systematically investigated. This leads to the central question of this work: does the presence of null radiation lead to a complexity factor different from that of Type I matter?
Addressing this question is not straightforward because the structure scalars are defined with respect to a timelike observer, whereas Type II matter contains an intrinsically null component. A suitable covariant formulation is therefore needed.
In this work, we adapt the Herrera prescription to the covariant formalism and apply it to generalized Vaidya spacetimes. The framework provides a natural description of LRS II spacetimes, with spherical symmetry as a special case, and expresses the relevant geometrical and matter variables in terms of covariant scalars. We obtain the structure scalars for Type II matter and determine the corresponding complexity factor. In particular, we examine the pure Vaidya limit and show how the complexity factor behaves for a spacetime containing null radiation.
We further investigate the relations among the structure scalars and derive their propagation and evolution equations. Their influence on the Gaussian curvature of the spherical 2-sheets and their relation to the Misner–Sharp mass are also examined. These results provide a covariant description of the structure and complexity of Type II matter and clarify how the Herrera prescription behaves in the presence of null radiation.
The paper is organized as follows. In Section 2, we introduce the covariant description of LRS II spacetimes, with spherical symmetry as a special case. Section 3 reviews the covariant decomposition of the Riemann tensor and the structure scalars and expresses them in terms of variables. In Section 4, we apply the formalism to generalized Vaidya spacetimes and investigate the complexity factor, together with the evolution and propagation equations of the structure scalars. Their relation to the Gaussian curvature and Misner–Sharp mass is then examined. Finally, Section 5 summarizes our results.
2. Covariant Description of LRS II Spacetimes
In this section we briefly summarize the semi-tetrad covariant description of LRS II spacetimes, which contains the spherically symmetric spacetimes as a subclass. These spacetimes are non-rotating and contain a continuous non-trivial isotropy group of spatial rotations at every point. For more details please refer to [31,32,33,34,35]. Hence, we have a covariantly defined preferred spatial direction at each point. Now, by choosing the timelike unit vector (usually defined along the fluid flow lines) and the orthogonal unit vector along the preferred spatial direction , we can decompose the spacetime as [36]
where is the projection tensor on the spherical 2-shells and is defined as . Here, is the projection tensor orthogonal to and spans the 3-space.
Therefore, in the description, this gives rise to two kinds of derivatives:
- The dot derivative: This is the covariant time derivative along the observers’ worldlines. Therefore, for any tensor it is defined as .
- The D derivative: This spatial derivative is defined by orthogonally projecting the covariant derivative onto the 3-space using the projection tensor . Hence we have .
Further, in the formulation the preferred spatial vector introduces two new derivatives by splitting the 3-space, for any 3-tensor :
- The hat derivative: This is the spatial derivative along the vector defined as .
- The delta derivative: It is the projected spatial derivative on the 2-sheet by the projection tensor on all the free indices. Hence
As a result, we get the geometrical quantities for the chosen timelike congruence . These are the expansion scalar , acceleration 3-vector and the shear 3-tensor . It also uniquely defines the electric part of the Weyl tensor (which is responsible for tidal forces and inhomogeneity), as . Moreover, the magnetic part of the Weyl tensor (due to rotation or time-varying spacetime) , vanishes identically [37]. This timelike congruence also splits the energy-momentum tensor of the matter field (EMT) into the energy density , isotropic pressure p, heat flux 3-vector and the anisotropic stress 3-tensor .
In this class of spacetimes the only non-vanishing geometrical quantity related to the preferred spacelike congruence is the volume expansion , as other geometrical quantities due to this congruence vanish identically in spherical symmetry.
Further, we can extract a set of covariant scalars from the above-mentioned 3-vectors and 3-tensors as , , , and . Finally, we get the set of scalars that fully describes the spherically symmetric class of spacetimes
The obtained geometrical and thermodynamical scalars (from EMT), with their directional derivatives along (denoted by a dot) and (denoted by a hat), completely specify the Ricci identities and the Bianchi identities. Therefore, they can completely specify the dynamics of the spacetime. Another useful geometrically defined quantity is the Misner–Sharp mass (the amount of mass enclosed within the spherical 2-shell at a given instant of time). In terms of the covariant scalars it is given as [38,39]
Hence, in vacuum spacetimes, the mass is entirely due to the electric part of the Weyl tensor . Here, K is the Gaussian curvature of the spherical shells, which provides a geometric notion of the area radius of the spherical shells , and is defined as the inverse square of . The Gaussian curvature is also related to the obtained covariant scalars in Equation (2) as
Another set of important relations is given by the directional derivatives of along and in terms of the covariant scalars
We can also write the following commutation relation for any scalar
In the decomposition we can write the EMT of a general matter field in the following manner
In the plane (the spherical 2-shells are trivial), the discriminant () of the quadratic equations for the eigenvalues of the above EMT (8) takes the form
Therefore, when , we obtain two distinct eigenvalues corresponding to one timelike and one spacelike eigenvectors on this plane, making the matter field necessarily of Type I (timelike matter field).
However, when the discriminant vanishes, we have the following relation
This makes both the eigenvalues equal, with double degenerate null eigenvectors, and fixes the value of the heat flux Q. Therefore, the resulting matter field is always of Type II (null). Please note that in our subsequent calculations we take Einstein’s gravitational constant .
3. Orthogonal Decomposition of Riemann Tensor: Structure Scalars and Complexity
The orthogonal splitting of the Riemann tensor was first studied in [40], and since then it has been used in many places. Define the left, right and double dual of the Riemann tensor in the standard fashion
Next we introduce the following spatial tensors [41]
where the symmetries of the Riemann tensor entail the following properties
These tensors contain all the information in the Riemann tensor, as is easily checked by a simple count of their total number of independent components. They also enable us to find the orthogonal splitting () of the Riemann tensor, which reads
where
Here, is the spatial volume element and is defined by From the above expression we get the orthogonal splitting of the Ricci tensor as
These second-rank tensors (11) are decomposed into their trace and trace-free parts to obtain the ‘structure scalars’.
In order to get a canonical covariant description in semi-tetrad formalism, we first adapt Herrera’s complexity prescription in the formulation. We will use the general form of the EMT and decompose it accordingly. We begin our analysis with the matter energy-momentum tensor of the fluid distribution involving the energy density , radial pressure , tangential pressure , heat flux , four-velocity of the fluid , and the unit four vector along the radial direction . These quantities also satisfy the following normalization conditions
Therefore, the energy-momentum tensor in the canonical form is the following
with
From the previously discussed orthogonal decomposition of the Riemann tensor and the matter stress-energy tensor, we can split the curvature tensors in terms of matter variables. Subsequently, the tensors and may be expressed in terms of their trace and trace-free parts, i.e., in terms of four scalar functions . The scalar Z is constructed from the self-contraction of the tensor . Therefore, we can write the following
These scalars are known as the structure scalars and specifically, is called the complexity factor. In spherical symmetry the magnetic part of the Weyl tensor vanishes and therefore the electric part of the Weyl tensor may be written as
After using the field equations we can obtain the structure scalars. For a detailed derivation please see [1,2,3,22,41].
Now, we can always take the corresponding timelike vector to be the same as and the orthogonal spacelike vector along . Consequently, we can split the projection tensor along and the sheet projection tensor to get the following relations
where are the covariant scalars in decomposition. Further, in LRS II spacetimes, the matter stress-energy tensor can be rewritten as Equation (8). Finally, in terms of the covariant scalars, the structure scalars can be expressed as
Using Equation (3) we can also express the Misner–Sharp mass (per volume) in terms of the structure scalars (magnetic part of the Riemann tensor) in the following manner
The magnetic and electric parts of the Riemann tensor in the decomposition can now be written as
We can now transparently express the energy-momentum tensor for a general matter field (in decomposition) in terms of structure scalars as
with the following radial and tangential pressures (on the spherical 2-shell)
Consequently, we compute the Ricci tensor and the Ricci scalar in terms of these scalars as
Finally, for a Type II matter field, the structure scalars should satisfy the following relation
This can be derived from the condition of Type II matter field discussed previously, as in Equation (10).
4. Generalized Vaidya: Type II Matter Field
We consider a spherically symmetric non-static spacetime in Eddington-Bondi coordinates
which satisfies the Einstein field equations
We introduce a local mass function m via , which is related to the gravitational energy within a given radius r. Therefore, the Misner–Sharp mass is also . We can now demand that the EMT satisfies the conditions and to obtain . Subsequently, we can always define another null coordinate and set , without any loss of generality. Finally, we obtain the familiar form of the generalized Vaidya spacetime [28,29]
and the EMT can be generally expressed in the following manner
This EMT in general belongs to a Type II fluid with a double null eigenvector. When , the null coordinate v represents the Eddington advanced time, in which r is decreasing toward the future along a ray (ingoing), while when , it represents the Eddington retarded time, in which r is increasing toward the future along a ray (outgoing).
Using Equation (32) with the Einstein field Equation (31), the corresponding EMT can be written as
with
where is the pure null radiation component (Type II matter) that moves along the null hypersurfaces If we take , the solutions reduce to the pure Vaidya solution with . Here, is the Type I component. Although, as a whole is of Type II classification. Projecting the EMT of Equation (34) into the form, spanned by
we find that
which in general belongs to the Type II fluids and has the form of Equation (8). The null vector is a double null eigenvector of the EMT, where is the energy density, is the radial pressure, is the heat flux and the tangential pressure is represented by . Hence, the matter variables are obtained as the following
In other words, a timelike observer will encounter the matter field with an energy density , isotropic pressure p, radial heat flux Q and anisotropic pressure with the aforementioned values given in Equation (38). Consequently, using Equation (23) we can readily obtain the structure scalars as
where the electric part of the Weyl tensor is determined () by the following
Subsequently, using Equation (39), we obtain the complexity factor for the generalized Vaidya spacetime
It is important to mention that the obtained forms of the structure scalars are covariant. In order to calculate the values further, we need to choose a preferred congruence. We consider the following null vectors proposed in [28]
The corresponding matter variables become
where
In particular, when , as we mentioned previously, the solutions reduce to the Vaidya solution. When , we have , and the matter field degenerates to Type I fluid [28], i.e., the non-dissipative case corresponding to . In general, the complexity increases with the Weyl tensor. However, in the isotropic case , the complexity factor is proportional to the Weyl scalar or the gravitational entropy [42]. From the obtained expression of the complexity factor it is clear that both the geometrical (Misner–Sharp mass) and the matter/thermodynamical contributions are at play. The gravitational entropy is only one of the contributors in the measure of complexity. The other contribution comes from the matter sector, via the pressure anisotropy. In the subsequent section we will analyze specific examples to understand the complexity further.
4.1. Some Subclasses of Generalized Vaidya
- Vanishing complexity: From the above expression of complexity (43), we want to explore which spacetime corresponds to minimal complexity, i.e., which spacetime has vanishing complexity. We obtain the general condition for vanishing complexity asEssentially, the geometrical part should balance the matter part , making the complexity vanish. It turns out if we make and , we getThis corresponds to the known de Sitter spacetime withIf we do not take into account, the simplest spacetime corresponds to the flat Minkowski spacetime, with .Apart from the above-mentioned trivial solution, we can substitute Equation (45) in Equation (46) to compute the general condition for vanishing complexity asThe non-trivial solution of this partial differential equation is obtained aswhere . J and Y denote the Bessel functions of the first and second kind respectively, with s as constants of integration. We also note that for a viable mass function.In the limit (small r), the dominant terms becomeConsequently, the term (with its coefficient) becomes the dominant contributor as a linear function of r, and the term behaves as . Similarly, and terms contribute as . This makes the mass function linear in r asHence, the , where , as needs to be negative for a positive mass. This makes the matter density , i.e., near the center, it has a diverging matter density profile, indicating a curvature singularity with a vanishing pressure . The null radiation density also diverges as . Note that can never vanish at a finite radius to define a true horizon surface, leaving the singularity exposed.However, if we impose , we obtain a surprising result for the small r limit. The only surviving Bessel functions becomeAs a result terms cancel each other to make the resulting mass function as the followingTherefore, for a positive mass function, has to be positive. This makes the matter density finite, positive, and homogeneous near the central region; the null radiation density vanishes at the center and the pressure becomes homogeneous but negative. Therefore, it has no central singularity. For the condition in Equation (54), we obtain the mass , which resembles an evolving de Sitter mass. In general, makes the mass grow exponentially (accretion) and negative implies evaporation.In the large distance limit, i.e., for large values of z, we can write the Bessel functions asConsequently, the combination of and in (50) varies as , whereas the term involving and behaves as . In other words, the second term dominates and the general mass function becomes oscillatory in nature with the following formwhere . We can now choose with positive for regularity of mass at small distances. Additionally, for a positive mass function, has to be negative, implying that there exist solutions of positive mass shells for different intervals of r (for ). Sticking to the first positive mass shell region, the plausible domain of r can be truncated and matched with an external spacetime at or by simply restricting the solution to the core region (avoiding oscillations completely). It is clear that in general the system is not asymptotically flat (similar to the de Sitter case). It can always be adjusted by matching it with an external metric at a finite radius or embedding it (the solution is not isolated) in a dynamic background.
- Monopole: If we now take the mass parameter as , we obtain the thermodynamic variables as . Under such conditions the fluid reduces to a Type I matter field and satisfies all three energy conditions when . It is again a well-known solution, which represents the gravitational field of a monopole, and the corresponding complexity is given by the followingTherefore, from the complexity perspective, the monopole and de Sitter/Minkowski solutions are not different. To understand these phenomena further we now proceed to analyze other spacetimes.
- Pure Vaidya: As mentioned earlier we get the complexity of the pure Vaidya spacetime when we take , which implies the mass function has no radial dependence . The expression of becomesAll three energy conditions (weak, strong and dominant) demand , making the complexity a negative quantity. This is a very interesting result for a pure Type II fluid. To understand it further we substitute the respective values of mass and energy density to get the followingFor the sake of argument if we want to be positive, then it implies has to be a negative quantity. For , the only possible solution is when , making a negative quantity. This violates the energy conditions. Further, the heat flux Q also becomes negative. This is a situation where matter-energy flux is flowing inwards; however, we have a mass loss. Clearly, this cannot be a physical situation. Similarly, when , has to be negative following the same arguments. However, in this case, a positive complexity factor is possible when f becomes negative, making the mass function a negative quantity. Hence, the second situation is also not physical. Therefore, in Vaidya spacetime, a pure Type II fluid has to have a negative complexity factor. It seems that a negative complexity factor means the system is purely Type II null radiation fluid. This might be an artifact of using a timelike observer for a null fluid. However, it is interesting to see that under Herrera’s scheme of complexity, pure Type II fluid has a negative value favored by all three energy conditions.
- Charged Vaidya: For the charged Vaidya solution the corresponding mass function is , giving the energy density and pressure as , . We can now easily obtain the corresponding complexity factor as followsWe can clearly observe the extra contributions due to charge in the complexity as opposed to the pure Vaidya case. The three energy conditions ensure that we are beyond the critical radius with a physically plausible condition , and the term is always positive. The non-negativity of mass implies is also positive. Therefore, the complexity factor can now be rewritten in the following mannerThe above equation clearly demonstrates that the complexity has both positive and negative contributions. The complexity can be of any sign, including zero, depending upon which term dominates or balances the other. In the following we neatly present the signs of complexity with their corresponding conditions.The introduction of charge makes the complexity of the system richer. If the charge terms dominate or are equal to the “neutral terms”, then we have positive or vanishing complexity. However, in a physically realistic system the charge is minute. Therefore, the neutral terms dominate over the charge terms, giving rise to a negative complexity factor.
- Husain solution: Another known general solution is the Husain solution where the mass function is the followingTherefore, the corresponding energy density is obtained asWe also obtain the equation of state in the Type I sector. Therefore, the complexity factor can be readily obtained asThe energy conditions demand that g and k need to be positive. Subsequently, we follow a similar analysis (as for charged Vaidya) and rewrite the in the following mannerIt is evident that the has significant negative contributions, and if it dominates over the positive term, the complexity becomes negative. We can always find out the condition of vanishing complexity by equating the two terms. Therefore, the following condition holdsHere, again we can notice that the complexity deviates from the negative value when the Type I matter is present with the ‘g terms’. If the terms containing g contribute minimally, we have a negative . Now, if we take , the Husain solution complexity corresponds to the charged Vaidya case for .
- Monopole de Sitter charged Vaidya: As the matter variables are linear in terms of derivatives of the mass function, the superposition of previous cases is also a solution of the field equation. Therefore, the mass function is of the following formThe complexity factor then becomesIt is evident that the resulting complexity is the sum of the monopole and charged Vaidya and is independent of the cosmological constant , similar to the de Sitter case. It is interesting to see that the complexity factor is identical to the charged Vaidya case (the monopole and cosmological constant do not contribute), having both positive and negative contributions as discussed previously.
All the above-mentioned mass functions can be obtained by using a linear equation of state of the Type I matter component. Such well-known spacetimes and their corresponding complexity are tabulated in Table 1. Similarly, a quadratic and polytropic equation of state can be considered and the corresponding complexities can be readily obtained. For more details on equations of state and different solutions see [43,44].
Table 1.
Complexity of different subclasses of generalized Vaidya spacetime.
Condition of negative complexity: For Type II fluids, the situation is different from Type I, because the stress tensor is fundamentally radiative with double null eigenvectors (no timelike eigenvector), making the complexity factor behave differently. In general the three energy conditions (weak, strong and dominant) impose restrictions on the matter variables like
Now, using the previously obtained expression of complexity, we can get the following relation if the is to be negative
This means that the pure Type II matter (null dust) energy density and the geometrical gravitational mass should dominate over the Type I matter variables. Hence, the negative sign of the complexity factor originates when the geometrical and null components are dominating. According to our analysis of the Vaidya spacetime, the Type I components are absent, i.e., ; therefore, the sign indicates a qualitative difference in the nature of the matter field, i.e., it corresponds to the geometrical and null nature of the matter field. Unlike Type I, is constrained by Q for Type II matter (10), making the complexity as
It is important to note that a negative sign in the complexity factor may not indicate that the Type II matter field has lower complexity than Type I systems.
4.2. Evolution/Propagation Equations of Structure Scalars
In the previous section we obtained the covariant expression of the complexity and other structure scalars for the generalized Vaidya spacetime. Next, we present how their covariant directional derivatives change through the kinematical variables. Therefore, we compute the propagation and evolution equations of the structure scalars in a general LRS II spacetime. Using (36), we take the and being two orthonormal null vectors as
Therefore, in our chosen frame, the radial component of the observer four-velocity is . Since the area radius r of the 2-shell (i.e., the spherical part of the metric ) is related to the Gaussian curvature of the shells by , we immediately see that the covariant derivative of the non-zero Gaussian curvature vanishes along the timelike direction, i.e., . Physically, this means that the area radius of a given shell remains constant in time for the chosen observer, i.e., . Such a frame can always be chosen locally and does not constrain the spacetime in any manner [45]. From the evolution equation of the Gaussian curvature , it follows that the shear is proportional to the expansion scalar as . As a result, the chosen decomposition simplifies our calculations [32]. Therefore, in the covariant decomposition, we obtain the following equations.
- Propagation:
- Evolution:
- Propagation/evolution:
The above equations clearly demonstrate how the kinematical variables influence the propagation and evolution of the structure scalars. For Type II matter field we impose the additional condition from Equation (29).
4.3. Gaussian Curvature and Shell-Complexity
We will now make use of the 2-shell complexity introduced in [46]. The authors showed that there is a way to define complexity via the information in the change of Gaussian curvature of a given 2-shell. Interestingly, this gives rise to a wave equation (hyperbolic), which shows the causal behavior determined by the second-order source-free differential equation. To obtain the wave equation for the Gaussian curvature the authors introduce two new variables and X defined as
The final closed form of the wave equation becomes
where the term ‘’ behaves like the restoration factor of a traveling disturbance in an elastic medium with the general form
Therefore, in the most general scenario, the restoration factor depends (either explicitly or via the equation of state) on all the geometrical and thermodynamical variables, which form the set
In this prescription the number of independent geometrical and thermodynamical variables that the restoration factor depends on gives a measure of the complexity for the spherical self-gravitating system. In our decomposition of the generalized Vaidya spacetime, the Gaussian curvature simply obeys the condition. Using the evolution Equation (79), we can express the restoration factor in terms of the structure scalars to obtain the second-order propagation equation of the Gaussian curvature as
Now from the previously obtained propagation/evolution equations, Z can be completely expressed in terms of and their directional derivatives in the following manner
Here, T can be interpreted as “Misner–Sharp mass density” as . Therefore, the second-order equation of the Gaussian curvature takes the form
Hence the structure scalars and and their directional derivatives (related through Z) are explicitly driving the second-order Gaussian curvature equation. The complexity factor and the scalar influence this equation (implicitly) via the propagation and evolution equations.
Another important quantity on the shell is the Misner–Sharp mass, describing the total gravitational mass-energy inside the shell. The covariant directional derivatives of the Misner–Sharp mass are related to the scalars by the following
and are related to each other via the structure scalars and Z as
where represents the energy density and Z is related to the heat flux. Hence, can be uniquely determined by , subject to required boundary conditions. Taking the second derivatives and using the commutator relation from Equation (7) we can get the following second-order wave equation for
From the above relations it is evident that the and its propagation/evolution are explicitly governed by the and Z scalars (with their directional derivatives), depicting how the Misner–Sharp mass changes through the energy density and heat flux. For Type II matter Z is also constrained by Equation (29).
5. Concluding Remarks
In this paper, we have extended the Herrera complexity prescription to Type II matter fields and formulated the corresponding structure scalars within the covariant framework. We obtained the covariant evolution and propagation equations for these scalars and applied the formalism to generalized Vaidya spacetimes. Our analysis shows that the presence of a null radiation component leads to a complexity structure that is different from that of Type I matter.
We found a non-trivial class of generalized Vaidya solutions with vanishing complexity, which is characterized by the mass function
in addition to the trivial de Sitter and monopole cases. In the appropriate limits, the mass function of this class is proportional to , reminiscent of a time-dependent de Sitter configuration. This provides a non-trivial example of a Type II system satisfying the vanishing-complexity condition.
An important feature of the generalized Vaidya solutions is that the complexity factor need not be positive. In the pure Vaidya limit, where the matter content consists entirely of null radiation, the complexity factor is negative. The Type I matter contribution enters with the opposite sign and can therefore compensate for, or overcome, the negative contribution associated with the null component. For pure Vaidya spacetime,
so that both the gravitational and Type II matter contributions to are negative. Thus, the negative sign reflects the relative contributions entering the Herrera complexity factor. It should not be interpreted as indicating that the configuration is less complex than a configuration; rather, represents the vanishing-complexity condition within the Herrera prescription.
We also investigated the relation between the structure scalars and the geometry of the spherical 2-sheets. In particular, the second-order propagation equation for the Gaussian curvature does not contain the electric part of the Riemann tensor explicitly. Consequently, the complexity factor does not appear directly in this equation, although its influence is encoded indirectly through the coupled propagation and evolution equations of the structure scalars. Similarly, the derivatives of the Misner–Sharp mass can be expressed in terms of the structure scalars and their directional derivatives, leading to a wave equation for . Notably, does not appear explicitly in these equations for either the Gaussian curvature or the Misner–Sharp mass.
The structure of the complexity factor can be further clarified by separating its gravitational and matter contributions. In Petrov type D spacetimes, the Bel–Robinson super-energy is
Since the super-energy characterizes the free gravitational field and is related to the construction of the CET gravitational entropy based on the Weyl curvature hypothesis [42], it provides a useful perspective on the gravitational contribution to the complexity. Using
we can separate the complexity factor into gravitational and matter contributions. For the generalized Vaidya spacetime,
while
Thus, the Type I and Type II matter components contribute with opposite signs, while the gravitational contribution is governed by the electric Weyl scalar. Because gravitational entropy rises with structure formation, we expect the gravitational component of complexity to increase accordingly. For pure Vaidya spacetime, , and hence both and are negative. The negative complexity therefore reflects the combined contribution of the free gravitational field and null radiation in the Herrera scalar. This provides an interpretation of the sign of without assigning to it a direct observable meaning.
Overall, our results show that the Herrera complexity factor contains non-trivial information about Type II matter and cannot simply be identified with its Type I counterpart. The generalized Vaidya spacetime provides a useful setting in which the separate roles of matter, null radiation, and gravitational geometry can be distinguished. The covariant formulation developed here may also be useful for studying more general dynamical configurations, including gravitational collapse and radiating compact objects, as well as for matching Type II exteriors to Type I interiors. Such extensions may help clarify the role of the complexity factor in dynamical gravitational systems. While the complexity factor is not a direct physical observable, it is related to the density inhomogeneity (via the Weyl scalar) and the pressure anisotropy. A radiating star with a Vaidya exterior serves as an excellent complex system for observational studies. Since the junction conditions relate the Type II field variables to the interior Type I parameters, one can employ standard astrophysical techniques, using the mass and radius of known objects, to estimate the complexity factor. Similarly, the vanishing complexity mass function obtained here can be applied to study astrophysical phenomena such as black hole shadows and gravitational waves, offering potentially valuable insights in future research.
Author Contributions
Conceptualization, S.C., R.G. and S.D.M.; methodology, S.C., R.G. and S.D.M.; software, S.C.; formal analysis, S.C.; investigation, S.C., R.G. and S.D.M.; writing—original draft preparation, S.C.; writing—review and editing, S.C., R.G. and S.D.M.; supervision, R.G. and S.D.M. All authors have read and agreed to the published version of the manuscript.
Funding
This research was funded by the University of KwaZulu-Natal (UKZN). UKZN also covers any relevant APC charges.
Data Availability Statement
No new data were created or analyzed in this study. Data sharing is not applicable to this article.
Acknowledgments
The authors thank the anonymous referees for their insightful comments, which helped improve the quality of the manuscript. SC is thankful to the University of KwaZulu-Natal (UKZN) for postdoctoral funding. Special thanks to Sarbari Guha for her insightful comments. RG thanks UKZN and NRF, South Africa, for support. SDM thanks UKZN for research support.
Conflicts of Interest
The authors declare no conflicts of interest.
References
- Herrera, L. New definition of complexity for self-gravitating fluid distributions: The spherically symmetric, static case. Phys. Rev. D 2018, 97, 044010. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Herrera, L.; Ospino, J.; Di Prisco, A.; Fuenmayor, E.; Troconis, O. Structure and evolution of self-gravitating objects and the orthogonal splitting of the Riemann tensor. Phys. Rev. D 2009, 79, 064025. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Herrera, L.; Di Prisco, A.; Ospino, J. Definition of complexity for dynamical spherically symmetric dissipative self-gravitating fluid distributions. Phys. Rev. D 2018, 98, 104059. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Herrera, L.; Di Prisco, A.; Ospino, J. Complexity factors for axially symmetric static sources. Phys. Rev. D 2019, 99, 044049. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Sharif, M.; Butt, I. Complexity factor for charged spherical system. Eur. Phys. J. C 2018, 78, 688. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Sharif, M.; Butt, I. Complexity factor for static cylindrical system. Eur. Phys. J. C 2018, 78, 850. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Casadio, R.; Contreras, E.; Ovalle, J.; Sotomayor, A.; Stuchlík, Z. Isotropization and change of complexity by gravitational decoupling. Eur. Phys. J. C 2019, 79, 826. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Herrera, L.; Di Prisco, A.; Ospino, J. Hyperbolically symmetric static fluids: A general study. Phys. Rev. D 2021, 103, 024037. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Khan, S.; Mardan, S.; Rehman, M. Framework for generalized polytropes with complexity factor. Eur. Phys. J. C 2019, 79, 1037. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Sharif, M.; Butt, I. Electromagnetic effects on complexity factor for static cylindrical system. Chin. J. Phys. 2019, 61, 238–247. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Sharif, M.; Tariq, S. Complexity factor for charged dissipative dynamical system. Mod. Phys. Lett. A 2020, 35, 2050231. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Contreras, E.; Stuchlík, Z. A simple protocol to construct solutions with vanishing complexity by gravitational decoupling. Eur. Phys. J. C 2022, 82, 706. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Zubair, M. Stable stellar configurations with polynomial complexity factor. Eur. Phys. J. C 2022, 82, 984. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Herrera, L.; Di Prisco, A.; Ospino, J. Dynamics of hyperbolically symmetric fluids. Symmetry 2021, 13, 1568. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Abbas, G.; Nazar, H. Complexity factor for static anisotropic self-gravitating source in f (R) gravity. Eur. Phys. J. C 2018, 78, 510. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Nazar, H.; Abbas, G. Complexity factor for dynamical spherically symmetric fluid distributions in f (R) gravity. Int. J. Geom. Methods Mod. Phys. 2019, 16, 1950170. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Sharif, M.; Majid, A.; Nasir, M. Complexity factor for self-gravitating system in modified Gauss–Bonnet gravity. Int. J. Mod. Phys. A 2019, 34, 1950210. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Sharif, M.; Majid, A. Complexity of dynamical sphere in self-interacting Brans–Dicke gravity. Eur. Phys. J. C 2020, 80, 1185. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Yousaf, Z.; Bamba, K.; Bhatti, M.; Hassan, K. Measure of complexity in self-gravitating systems using structure scalars. New Astron. 2021, 84, 101541. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Zubair, M.; Azmat, H. Complexity analysis of dynamical spherically symmetric dissipative self-gravitating objects in modified gravity. Int. J. Mod. Phys. D 2020, 29, 2050014. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Zubair, M.; Azmat, H. Complexity analysis of cylindrically symmetric self-gravitating dynamical system in f (R, T) theory of gravity. Phys. Dark Universe 2020, 28, 100531. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Herrera, L. New Developments in the Study of Complex Systems in General Relativity. In New Frontiers in Gravitational Collapse and Spacetime Singularities; Malafarina, D., Joshi, P.S., Eds.; Springer: Singapore, 2024; pp. 199–254. [Google Scholar]
- Naseer, T. Complexity and isotropization based extended models in the context of electromagnetic field: An implication of minimal gravitational decoupling. Eur. Phys. J. C 2024, 84, 1256. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Naseer, T.; Sharif, M. Role of decoupling and Rastall parameters on Krori–Barua and Tolman IV models generated by isotropization and complexity factor. Class. Quantum Gravity 2024, 41, 245006. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Naseer, T. Role of non-conserved gravity theory and electric charge in constructing complexity-free stellar models: A novel approach under non-minimal coupling. Chin. J. Phys. 2025, 96, 1212–1231. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Sharif, M.; Naseer, T. Effect of extended gravitational decoupling on isotropization and complexity in f (R, T) theory. Class. Quantum Gravity 2023, 40, 035009. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Naseer, T.; Sharif, M. Implications of vanishing complexity condition in f (R) theory. Eur. Phys. J. C 2024, 84, 554. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Wang, A.; Wu, Y. Generalized Vaidya solutions. Gen. Relativ. Gravit. 1999, 31, 107–114. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Dawood, A.K.; Ghosh, S.G. Generating dynamical black hole solutions. Phys. Rev. D 2004, 70, 104010. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Dadhich, N.; Goswami, R. Accreting black holes radiate classical Vaidya radiation to pave way for Hawking radiation. Phys. Rev. D. 2024, 110, L101501. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- van Elst, H.; Ellis, G.F.R. The covariant approach to LRS perfect fluid spacetime geometries. Class. Quantum Gravity 1996, 13, 1099. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Betschart, G.; Clarkson, C.A. Scalar field and electromagnetic perturbations on locally rotationally symmetric spacetimes. Class. Quantum Gravity 2004, 21, 5587–5607. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Clarkson, C. Covariant approach for perturbations of rotationally symmetric spacetimes. Phys. Rev. D 2007, 76, 104034. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Clarkson, C.A.; Barrett, R.K. Covariant perturbations of Schwarzschild black holes. Class. Quantum Gravity 2003, 20, 3855–3884. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Ellis, G.F.R.; van Elst, H. Cosmological Models. In Theoretical and Observational Cosmology; Lachèze-Rey, M., Ed.; Kluwer: Dordrecht, The Netherlands, 1999; p. 1. [Google Scholar]
- Ellis, G.F.R. Relativistic Cosmology. In Proceedings of the International School of Physics “Enrico Fermi”, Course XLVII: General Relativity and Cosmology; Sachs, R.K., Ed.; Academic Press: New York, NY, USA, 1971; pp. 104–182. [Google Scholar]
- Maartens, R.; Bassett, B.A. Gravito-electromagnetism. Class. Quantum Gravity 1998, 15, 705. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Misner, C.W.; Sharp, D.H. Relativistic equations for adiabatic, spherically symmetric gravitational collapse. Phys. Rev. 1964, 136, B571–B576. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Stephani, H.; Herlt, E.; MacCallum, M.; Hoenselaers, C.; Kramer, D. Exact Solutions of Einstein’s Field Equations; Cambridge University Press: Cambridge, UK, 2003. [Google Scholar]
- Bel, L. Inductions électromagnétique et gravitationnelle. Ann. Inst. Henri Poincaré 1961, 17, 37–57. [Google Scholar]
- García-Parrado Gómez-Lobo, A. Dynamical laws of superenergy in general relativity. Class. Quantum Gravity 2008, 25, 015006. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Clifton, T.; Ellis, G.F.R.; Tavakol, R. A gravitational entropy proposal. Class. Quantum Gravity 2013, 30, 125009. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Brassel, B.P.; Maharaj, S.D.; Goswami, R. Diffusive and dynamical radiating stars with realistic equations of state. Gen. Relativ. Gravit. 2017, 49, 37. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Mkenyeleye, M.D.; Goswami, R.; Maharaj, S.D. Gravitational collapse of generalised Vaidya spacetime. Phys. Rev. D 2014, 90, 064034. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
- Landau, L.D.; Lifshitz, E.M. The Classical Theory of Fields; Pergamon Press: Oxford, UK, 1975; Chapter 12, Section 100. [Google Scholar]
- Singh, S.; Baboolal, D.; Goswami, R.; Maharaj, S.D. Gaussian curvature of spherical shells: A geometric measure of complexity. Class. Quantum Gravity 2022, 39, 235010. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
Disclaimer/Publisher’s Note: The statements, opinions and data contained in all publications are solely those of the individual author(s) and contributor(s) and not of MDPI and/or the editor(s). MDPI and/or the editor(s) disclaim responsibility for any injury to people or property resulting from any ideas, methods, instructions or products referred to in the content. |
© 2026 by the authors. Licensee MDPI, Basel, Switzerland. This article is an open access article distributed under the terms and conditions of the Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY) license.