Review Reports
- Ru-Rong Chen 1,2,*,
- Yan Zhu 1,2 and
- Hai-Yan Zhang 1,2
Reviewer 1: Anonymous Reviewer 2: Anonymous
Round 1
Reviewer 1 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsIn this paper, the authors propose a new method for measuring the signal path length and its variations in a radio telescope system and present results obtained from actual observations. The proposed method utilizes the astronomical observing system itself to acquire calibration data and has several advantages, including a relatively simple measurement setup and high measurement accuracy. The study contains meaningful and novel contributions, and the manuscript is written clearly. Therefore, I consider this paper worthy of publication.
On the other hand, there are several places where the description is insufficient for readers to fully understand the methodology and results. I list six points below that should be addressed.
(1) A block diagram of the system should be provided.
The manuscript states that a noise signal is injected into the receiver, sampled, and then analyzed to measure the signal path length. However, a block diagram of the observing and calibration system should be included. How is the calibration signal injected into the receiver? Through which components does the signal propagate? What is the observing frequency? Where and how is the frequency conversion performed? Providing these details together with a block diagram would enable readers to properly understand the proposed method.
(2) The sampling process should be described in more detail.
The sampler (A/D converter) is the key component of this calibration system. However, I could not find the sampling rate, which is one of the most important parameters, in the manuscript. Without a sufficient description of the sampler, readers cannot assess whether the proposed calibration method can operate as intended. Please provide a more detailed description of the sampler, including the input signal bandwidth, the number of channels, the reference signal source, and the relationship between the timing control of the injected noise switching and the sampler clock system.
(3) The target accuracy should be clearly stated.
Since this work concerns a method for measuring signal path length, it would be desirable to clearly specify the target accuracy and explicitly state whether the proposed method achieves this goal.
(4) A description of the conventional measurement method is needed.
Figures 5-7 include results obtained using a conventional measurement method. The manuscript should explain what this method was and what measurement accuracy it achieved. Furthermore, it would be helpful to quantitatively demonstrate how much the proposed method improves the accuracy compared with the conventional approach.
(5) Line 159.
The manuscript states that the signal path length changed after a component in Beam 10 was replaced in April 2023. On what MJD did this replacement take place? Unless this date is explicitly given, readers cannot identify where in Figure 6 this change occurred.
(6) Comparison between Beam 8 and the other beams.
Figure 7 presents the measurement results for Beam 8, and the authors claim that the fluctuations are larger than those of the other beams. To support this claim, measurement results from the other beams should also be shown together with those of Beam 8.
Author Response
(1) A block diagram of the system should be provided.
The manuscript states that a noise signal is injected into the receiver, sampled, and then analyzed to measure the signal path length. However, a block diagram of the observing and calibration system should be included. How is the calibration signal injected into the receiver? Through which components does the signal propagate? What is the observing frequency? Where and how is the frequency conversion performed? Providing these details together with a block diagram would enable readers to properly understand the proposed method.
Response: We agree with the referee. We have added the block diagram of the FAST 19-beam receiver signal chain as Figure 1. Components, observing frequency and the way of injecting the noise are described in Lines 28-38.
(2) The sampling process should be described in more detail.
The sampler (A/D converter) is the key component of this calibration system. However, I could not find the sampling rate, which is one of the most important parameters, in the manuscript. Without a sufficient description of the sampler, readers cannot assess whether the proposed calibration method can operate as intended. Please provide a more detailed description of the sampler, including the input signal bandwidth, the number of channels, the reference signal source, and the relationship between the timing control of the injected noise switching and the sampler clock system.
Response: We agree with the referee. The ADC sampling rate is described in Line 33 and illustrated in Figure 1. The relationship between the timing control of the injected noise switching and the sampler clock is described in Lines 38-42. The bandwidth of the input signal is also described in Line 33 and illustrated in Figure 1. There is no local oscillator in the FAST 19-beam receiver, as explained in Lines 32-33. Since baseband data are used in the study, the number of channels for the channelized power spectral data is not specified.
(3) The target accuracy should be clearly stated.
Since this work concerns a method for measuring signal path length, it would be desirable to clearly specify the target accuracy and explicitly state whether the proposed method achieves this goal.
Response: We agree with the referee. The target timing accuracy is 100 ns, as described in Lines 100-103. It has been stated that the target accuracy is achieved.
(4) A description of the conventional measurement method is needed.
Figures 5-7 include results obtained using a conventional measurement method. The manuscript should explain what this method was and what measurement accuracy it achieved. Furthermore, it would be helpful to quantitatively demonstrate how much the proposed method improves the accuracy compared with the conventional approach.
Response: All the results in updated Figures 5-7 are obtained using this proposed method. The accuracy of the conventional method is on the order microsecond, as described in Line 51.
(5) Line 159.
The manuscript states that the signal path length changed after a component in Beam 10 was replaced in April 2023. On what MJD did this replacement take place? Unless this date is explicitly given, readers cannot identify where in Figure 6 this change occurred.
Response: We agree with the referee. The numbers of the corresponding MJDs have been added in Lines 182 and 184.
(6) Comparison between Beam 8 and the other beams.
Figure 7 presents the measurement results for Beam 8, and the authors claim that the fluctuations are larger than those of the other beams. To support this claim, measurement results from the other beams should also be shown together with those of Beam 8.
Response: The fluctuations measured for the different beams are presented in Figure 5. The results for Beam 10 are shown in Figure 6 as an example.
Author Response File:
Author Response.docx
Reviewer 2 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsThe paper "Time Delay Measurement of a Radio Telescope Using Baseband Data and Periodic Noise" (universe-4512295) by R.-R. Chen et al. describes a new method to measure the time delay at the FAST radio telescope in China, the single-dish radio telescope that is currently the most sensitive in the world. The method is practically useful, its applicability has been proven. Therefore, this manuscript is worth publishing, even though the community which would be interested in this technical achievement is rather limited.
The manuscript is generally well written, not very long but still sufficiently detailed. I can recommend its publications after a moderate revision. Below I have a main suggestion, followed by a couple of minor comments, mostly of technical nature.
The most important point is that while the title says "of a Radio Telescope", and the Abstract says "in radio telescopes", the whole paper is exclusively about FAST. The authors do not mention whether their time-delay measurement method could possibly be applied at other radio telescopes. If yes, does it have a practical value, difficulty in implementation, what are the possible benefits and drawbacks, etc. If not, the title and the whole manuscript have to be changed to reflect the fact that this method only applies to FAST. In short: please discuss the applicability of the method for radio telescopes other than FAST.
Minor remarks, in the order of their appearance:
1. Abstract: don't start it with "In this paper,". Of course, the following text refers to this paper so this is redundant information.
2. Abstract: spell out the abbreviation FAST here as well: Five-hundred-meter Aperture Spherical radio Telescope (FAST)
3. line 33: flux calibration -> flux density calibration
4. line 54: introduce the abbreviation ADC here; it is used later in line 56
5. Figure labels: note the MDPI style requires that numbers in the order of 10 thousands should be presented with a comma following the digit of thousands, e.g. 20000 -> 20,000 (this does not apply to numbers ~1000); most figures contain such numbers in their horizontal or/and vertical axis labels
6. Figure 4: it is quite redundant and can be merged with Fig. 3 (in practice, Fig. 3 can be omitted) - the only difference is the presence of four vertical lines indicating the beginning and the end of the plateaus, which does not justify duplicating the same curves in another figure
7. lines 181-183: The paper ends with a statement that "This measurement technique provides valuable technical support for the future involvement of FAST in radio interferometry". This gives the false impression to the readers that FIST has not yet participated in VLBI experiments/test, which is certainly not true. The authors may briefly refer to such experiments by citing relevant publications (including, e.g., this one, partly by the same authors, https://dx.doi.org/10.15982/j.issn.2095-7777.2020.20190618001, and maybe others if exist). A brief mention on how the new time delay measurement method would change/improve the FAST participation in interferometric experiments, as compared to the methods applied in the past and at present, would be most welcome.
Author Response
The most important point is that while the title says "of a Radio Telescope", and the Abstract says "in radio telescopes", the whole paper is exclusively about FAST. The authors do not mention whether their time-delay measurement method could possibly be applied at other radio telescopes. If yes, does it have a practical value, difficulty in implementation, what are the possible benefits and drawbacks, etc. If not, the title and the whole manuscript have to be changed to reflect the fact that this method only applies to FAST. In short: please discuss the applicability of the method for radio telescopes other than FAST.
Response: We agree with the referee. Since this method has not been applied at other radio telescopes other than FAST, we have clarified its scope of application. We have replaced “of a Radio Telescope” with “FAST” in the Title, Abstract and Conclusions.
Minor remarks, in the order of their appearance:
- Abstract: don't start it with "In this paper,". Of course, the following text refers to this paper so this is redundant information.
Response: We agree with the referee. The phrase “In this paper” has been removed from the Abstract.
- Abstract: spell out the abbreviation FAST here as well: Five-hundred-meter Aperture Spherical radio Telescope (FAST)
Response: We agree with the referee. The full name of FAST has been added to the Abstract at the first occurrence of the abbreviation.
- line 33: flux calibration -> flux density calibration
Response: We agree with the referee. “flux calibration” has been revised to “flux density calibration”.
- line 54: introduce the abbreviation ADC here; it is used later in line 56
Response: We agree with the referee. The full term “analog-to-digital converter (ADC)”has been introduced in Line 31, where ADC is first mentioned.
- Figure labels: note the MDPI style requires that numbers in the order of 10 thousands should be presented with a comma following the digit of thousands, e.g. 20000 -> 20,000 (this does not apply to numbers ~1000); most figures contain such numbers in their horizontal or/and vertical axis labels
Response: We agree with the referee. The axis labels in Figures 3-7 have been revised to follow the MDPI formatting style.
- Figure 4: it is quite redundant and can be merged with Fig. 3 (in practice, Fig. 3 can be omitted) - the only difference is the presence of four vertical lines indicating the beginning and the end of the plateaus, which does not justify duplicating the same curves in another figure
Response: We agree with the referee. Figure 4 has been removed to avoid redundant presentation of the same curves.
- lines 181-183: The paper ends with a statement that "This measurement technique provides valuable technical support for the future involvement of FAST in radio interferometry". This gives the false impression to the readers that FIST has not yet participated in VLBI experiments/test, which is certainly not true. The authors may briefly refer to such experiments by citing relevant publications (including, e.g., this one, partly by the same authors, https://dx.doi.org/10.15982/j.issn.2095-7777.2020.20190618001, and maybe others if exist). A brief mention on how the new time delay measurement method would change/improve the FAST participation in interferometric experiments, as compared to the methods applied in the past and at present, would be most welcome.
Response: We agree with the referee. We have removed the statement that “This measurement technique provides valuable technical support for the future involvement of FAST in radio interferometry,” as it could give a misleading impression that FAST has not previously participated in VLBI observations.
We have also reconsidered the applicability of the proposed method to multi-beam VLBI observations. Although we initially expected that the method could provide a benefit for multi-beam VLBI observations, further analysis shows that the individual beams still need to independently track and calibrate the calibrator source. Therefore, the practical benefit of the proposed method for multi-beam VLBI observations is limited. To avoid overstating the applicability of the method, we have removed this statement from the manuscript rather than extending the discussion to VLBI applications that are not directly demonstrated by our results.
Round 2
Reviewer 1 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsThe author has revised the manuscript by appropriately incorporating the reviewers' comments. I appreciate these efforts. Based on these revisions, I consider the paper to be worthy of publication.