Review Reports
- Amira Daouk 1,2
Reviewer 1: Anonymous Reviewer 2: Anonymous Reviewer 3: Anonymous
Round 1
Reviewer 1 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsThe attached article, “Transactional Leadership and Organizational Citizenship Behavior in Fine Dining Hospitality Establishments: A Moderated Mediation Analysis of Employee Engagement and Perceived Organizational Support in Lebanon,” examines how Transactional Leadership is related to Organizational Citizenship Behavior (OCB) through Employee Engagement, and how this relationship is moderated by Perceived Organizational Support (POS) in the Beirut, Lebanon fine dining / upscale hospitality context.
To improve the quality of the article, the following revisions are recommended.
In the Abstract, the text uses “this study will explore,” although the study has already been conducted; therefore, this should be changed to “This study examined.” The Abstract states that 441 legitimate questionnaires were collected, but 428 questionnaires were used in the analysis. It is recommended to briefly explain why 13 questionnaires were excluded, or to report only the final analytical sample - 428 valid questionnaires. In addition, because the study uses a cross-sectional design, overly strong causal wording such as “impact” should be avoided, and more cautious terms should be used, such as „is associated with“, „positively predicts“, „is positively related to“.
In the Introduction and the “Research Gap and Novelty” section, repetitions should be reduced. The article repeats the same idea several times: that hospitality leadership literature has focused more on transformational, servant, ethical, and authentic leadership, whereas Transactional Leadership has received less attention in crisis-affected hospitality contexts.
In the theoretical section, the model is logical, but the text is too long and in some places too general. It is recommended to distinguish more clearly which theory supports which path in the model: SET - Transactional Leadership → Employee Engagement → OCB; OST - POS as a moderator.
The language should be revised for grammatical, technical, and terminological accuracy. Specifically, “employee-exchanging relationships” is not an appropriate term in Social Exchange Theory and should be replaced with “social exchange relationships” or “employee–organization exchange relationships”; “Оrganizational” appears to contain a non-Latin character and should be corrected to “Organizational”; and “leadership methods” should be replaced with a more precise term, such as “leadership practices” or “leadership behaviors,” depending on the intended meaning.
It is recommended to use consistent construct names throughout the article and to avoid alternating between full construct names, abbreviations, capitalization patterns, and British/American spelling variants. The article should consistently use: Transactional Leadership, Employee Engagement, Perceived Organizational Support, and Organizational Citizenship Behavior.
The hypotheses section is generally appropriate, but it should be made more precise. H1 states that Transactional Leadership positively affects Organizational Citizenship Behavior; however, because of the cross-sectional design, the word “affects” is too strong. It should be reformulated as: “Transactional Leadership is positively associated with Organizational Citizenship Behavior” or “Transactional Leadership positively predicts Organizational Citizenship Behavior.”
In Figure 1 and, correspondingly, in Figure 2, it is recommended to present the X → Y relationship more clearly.
Methods section should explicitly state item numbers, adaptation procedure, translation/back-translation procedure, and pilot-test sample size. It is also recommended to clearly acknowledge the limitations of convenience sampling and to avoid generalized claims about the entire Lebanon hospitality sector.
Tables 1-4 should be reformatted with visible borders and consistent table styling, in line with the formatting used in later tables.
The table numbering should be checked, because Table 6 is followed immediately by Table 8; it is likely that Table 7 is missing or the numbering is incorrect. The presentation of p-values, beta coefficients, confidence intervals, and standardized coefficients should be consistent across all hypothesis-testing tables.
The Common Method Bias and Non-Response Bias sections are important, but they should be rewritten more clearly. It is recommended to write in a simpler way: because all data were collected at one time point and from the same respondents, procedural remedies and statistical tests were applied. In the Non-Response Bias section, it is recommended to clearly specify how early and late respondents were defined.
In the Discussion and Conclusions, it is recommended to link the results more clearly to the all specific construct relationships. The following relationships should be discussed separately. It is also necessary to avoid practical recommendations that go beyond the data.
Comments on the Quality of English LanguageThe English could be improved to more clearly express the research.
Author Response
Comments and Suggestions for Authors
The attached article, “Transactional Leadership and Organizational Citizenship Behavior in Fine Dining Hospitality Establishments: A Moderated Mediation Analysis of Employee Engagement and Perceived Organizational Support in Lebanon,” examines how Transactional Leadership is related to Organizational Citizenship Behavior (OCB) through Employee Engagement, and how this relationship is moderated by Perceived Organizational Support (POS) in the Beirut, Lebanon fine dining / upscale hospitality context.
To improve the quality of the article, the following revisions are recommended.
In the Abstract, the text uses “this study will explore,” although the study has already been conducted; therefore, this should be changed to “This study examined.”
Response: we have done the change based on your recommendation
The Abstract states that 441 legitimate questionnaires were collected, but 428 questionnaires were used in the analysis. It is recommended to briefly explain why 13 questionnaires were excluded, or to report only the final analytical sample - 428 valid questionnaires.
Response: we have done the change based on your recommendation.
In addition, because the study uses a cross-sectional design, overly strong causal wording such as “impact” should be avoided, and more cautious terms should be used, such as „is associated with“, „positively predicts“, „is positively related to“.
Response: we have done the necessary changes.
In the Introduction and the “Research Gap and Novelty” section, repetitions should be reduced. The article repeats the same idea several times: that hospitality leadership literature has focused more on transformational, servant, ethical, and authentic leadership, whereas Transactional Leadership has received less attention in crisis-affected hospitality contexts.
Response: Thank you for this comment. We removed the repetitive discussion regarding transactional leadership and revised the “Research Gap and Novelty” section to focus directly on the study’s specific research gaps, improving the clarity and flow of the manuscript.
In the theoretical section, the model is logical, but the text is too long and in some places too general. It is recommended to distinguish more clearly which theory supports which path in the model: SET - Transactional Leadership → Employee Engagement → OCB; OST - POS as a moderator.
Response: Thank you for this suggestion. We revised the theoretical foundation section to more clearly identify Social Exchange Theory as the basis for the direct and mediating relationships, and Organizational Support Theory as the basis for the moderating relationship
The language should be revised for grammatical, technical, and terminological accuracy. Specifically, “employee-exchanging relationships” is not an appropriate term in Social Exchange Theory and should be replaced with “social exchange relationships” or “employee–organization exchange relationships”; “Organizational” appears to contain a non-Latin character and should be corrected to “Organizational”; and “leadership methods” should be replaced with a more precise term, such as “leadership practices” or “leadership behaviors,” depending on the intended meaning.
Response: Thank you for this helpful observation. We revised the manuscript for greater grammatical and terminological accuracy by replacing “employee-exchanging relationships” with “employee–organization exchange relationships,” correcting the spelling of “Organizational,” and replacing “leadership methods” with the more appropriate term “leadership practices.”
It is recommended to use consistent construct names throughout the article and to avoid alternating between full construct names, abbreviations, capitalization patterns, and British/American spelling variants. The article should consistently use: Transactional Leadership, Employee Engagement, Perceived Organizational Support, and Organizational Citizenship Behavior.
Response: We appreciate your feedback. We have revised the writing and made changes to the naming, abbreviating, capitalizing, and spelling of constructs to ensure consistency within descriptions throughout the paper.
The hypotheses section is generally appropriate, but it should be made more precise. H1 states that Transactional Leadership positively affects Organizational Citizenship Behavior; however, because of the cross-sectional design, the word “affects” is too strong. It should be reformulated as: “Transactional Leadership is positively associated with Organizational Citizenship Behavior” or “Transactional Leadership positively predicts Organizational Citizenship Behavior.”
Response: we have done the change based on your recommendations.
In Figure 1 and, correspondingly, in Figure 2, it is recommended to present the X → Y relationship more clearly.
Response: Thank you for this suggestion. We revised Figures 1 and 2 to present the direct Transactional Leadership → Organizational Citizenship Behavior relationship more clearly and improved the overall visual presentation of the proposed model and hypothesized paths.
Methods section should explicitly state item numbers, adaptation procedure, translation/back-translation procedure, and pilot-test sample size. It is also recommended to clearly acknowledge the limitations of convenience sampling and to avoid generalized claims about the entire Lebanon hospitality sector.
Response: Thank you for this comment. We included more details regarding the item numbers, scale adaptation procedure, translation/back-translation process, and the sample size of the respondents utilized in the pilot-test. Additionally, we mentioned the limitation of convenience sampling and refrained from over-generalizing our findings on the Lebanese hospitality sector.
Tables 1-4 should be reformatted with visible borders and consistent table styling, in line with the formatting used in later tables.
Response: Thank you for this comment. We reformatted Tables 1–4 by adding visible borders and applying consistent table styling, including uniform headings, spacing, alignment, and formatting in line with the later tables.
The table numbering should be checked, because Table 6 is followed immediately by Table 8; it is likely that Table 7 is missing or the numbering is incorrect.
Response: Thank you for this comment. We have checked the running number of all the tables and, where necessary, have readjusted the numbers so that all the tables in the text are numbered in strict sequence.
The presentation of p-values, beta coefficients, confidence intervals, and standardized coefficients should be consistent across all hypothesis-testing tables.
Response: Thank you for this valuable suggestion. We reviewed all hypothesis-testing tables and standardized the presentation of statistical results. Beta coefficients (β), p-values, confidence intervals, and indirect-effect estimates are now reported consistently across all hypothesis-testing tables. In addition, p-values were reported using standard notation and the presentation format was harmonized throughout the results section.
The Common Method Bias and Non-Response Bias sections are important, but they should be rewritten more clearly. It is recommended to write in a simpler way: because all data were collected at one time point and from the same respondents, procedural remedies and statistical tests were applied. In the Non-Response Bias section, it is recommended to clearly specify how early and late respondents were defined.
Response: Thank you for this comment. We rewrote the Common Method Bias and Non-Response Bias sections more clearly and specified how early and late respondents were defined.
In the Discussion and Conclusions, it is recommended to link the results more clearly to the all-specific construct relationships. The following relationships should be discussed separately. It is also necessary to avoid practical recommendations that go beyond the data.
Response: Thank you for this helpful comment. We revised the Discussion and Conclusion to reference each construct relationship separately, including the direct, the mediating, the moderating, and the conditional indirect effects. We also revised the practical implications to ensure that recommendations are still directly supported by our study.
Comments on the Quality of English Language
The English could be improved to more clearly express the research.
Reviewer 2 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsDear authors,
Congratulations on your paper on a relevant topic. Please find below some comments for improvement of the manuscript.
Abstract
- Expand the acronym OCB
Introduction
- Although detailed, it must be shortened. Some of the content in the introduction is later repeated in the literature review (for example, explanations of theories). This can be avoided.
Conceptual model and research model
- The figure is not numbered. Although it is referred to as Figure 1 in the text.
- Additionally, the arrow representing the moderating variable should be aimed at the connection between transactional leadership and employee engagement, as hypothesised. At present, the arrow points directly to Employee Engagement, which is incorrect. The figure should be updated to accurately reflect this.
Research Methodology
- Justify the use of CB-SEM for this study. Why is this a better approach for this research context compared to other approaches (such as PLS-SEM). This should be clearly discussed appropriate citations.
- The quoted response rate of 88.2% for an online survey is exceptionally high. How did the researchers manage to get such a high response rate? Elaborate on the sample recruitment process and strategies used to get responses for more clarity and transparency.
- It is uncommon for electronic surveys to have missing data as the fields can be made mandatory to answer. However, it is said that seven responses had excessive missing values/inconsistent responding and hence excluded. Explain this anomaly. Further, only excessive missing values were excluded is what is mentioned in the paper. Does that mean there were few responses which has less missing values, but considered for the research? How do you quantify “excessive”? Also, if responses were considered that had few missing values, what strategy was used to account for the missing values while doing the analysis?
- Specify the minimum sample size required using the G*Power sample size calculator according to the criterias mentioned in the paper
- Table 1 requires to be formatted correctly
- Usually, content validity is done by 5 to 6 experts. Justify the content validity by only one academic expert. What were the results of content validity? How many questions were modified or deleted?
- Table 2 is also not formatted correctly and is not in a readable format.
- The pilot study section is vaguely written. How many samples were collected for the pilot study? What reliability and validity measures were used to evaluate questionnaire items?
- Was informed consent obtained from participants prior to data collection? If so, was is written or verbal consent? Clarify.
- For common method bias, include the VIF values rather than merely stating it was below 3.3
- Table 3 also not formatted correctly
- It is mentioned that non-response bias test was conducted between early and late respondents? What was the gap between the two sets of responses and how was it determined? Were the responses collected in two waves? Elaborate the data collection process.
Results
- Table 7 is missing
- All tables must be referenced in the text
- It is recommended to show item wise factor loadings, rather than merely showing the range.
- Improve the clarity of result figure (Figure 2)
- There are too many tables in the hypothesis results section. It is recommended to combine the results into a single table. Please refer past research on how CB-SEM results are presented in a compact table.
Discussion
- At present, the discussion section restates the study results without adequate interpretation. A section should critically evaluate the findings in relation to prior research, identify consistencies and discrepancies with previous literature, and discuss the possible reasons for these observations.
Another concern is that, there are very few new citations, that are published post 2022. Authors need to incorporate current references in all sections.
Other sections look fine.
Author Response
Dear authors,
Congratulations on your paper on a relevant topic. Please find below some comments for improvement of the manuscript.
Abstract
- Expand the acronym OCB
Response: thank you for your comment, we expand it.
Introduction
- Although detailed, it must be shortened. Some of the content in the introduction is later repeated in the literature review (for example, explanations of theories). This can be avoided.
Response: The introduction should be improved and condensed with no repeated generalities. The introductory section should be written in less quantity than any other part of the paper. General discussion and review of the literature regarding transactional leadership style and how it relates to degree of hospitality offered throughout the course of business transactions were reduced.
Conceptual model and research model
- The figure is not numbered. Although it is referred to as Figure 1 in the text.
Response: Thank you for this comment. The figure has been properly numbered and labeled as Figure 1, and all references to the figure within the manuscript have been checked for consistency.
- Additionally, the arrow representing the moderating variable should be aimed at the connection between transactional leadership and employee engagement, as hypothesized. At present, the arrow points directly to Employee Engagement, which is incorrect. The figure should be updated to accurately reflect this.
Response: Thank you for this valuable comment. The conceptual framework was revised to accurately reflect the hypothesized moderation effect. The moderating role of Perceived Organizational Support is now shown on the relationship between Transactional Leadership and Employee Engagement, consistent with the proposed theoretical model and hypotheses.
Research Methodology
- Justify the use of CB-SEM for this study. Why is this a better approach for this research context compared to other approaches (such as PLS-SEM). This should be clearly discussed appropriate citations.
Response: Thank you for this valuable suggestion. Additional justification for the use of CB-SEM was added to the Research Design section. The manuscript now explains that CB-SEM was selected because the study is theory-driven, confirmatory in nature, seeks to assess overall model fit, and is supported by an adequate sample size. A comparison with PLS-SEM and relevant methodological references has also been incorporated.
- The quoted response rate of 88.2% for an online survey is exceptionally high. How did the researchers manage to get such a high response rate? Elaborate on the sample recruitment process and strategies used to get responses for more clarity and transparency.
Response: Thank you for this valuable comment. Additional information regarding the sample recruitment process was added. The manuscript now explains that managerial approval was obtained prior to data collection, that HR representatives facilitated distribution through official communication channels, and that the questionnaire’s relevance, brevity, and anonymity likely contributed to the relatively high response rate.
- It is uncommon for electronic surveys to have missing data as the fields can be made mandatory to answer. However, it is said that seven responses had excessive missing values/inconsistent responding and hence excluded. Explain this anomaly. Further, only excessive missing values were excluded is what is mentioned in the paper. Does that mean there were few responses which has less missing values, but considered for the research? How do you quantify “excessive”? Also, if responses were considered that had few missing values, what strategy was used to account for the missing values while doing the analysis?
Response: Thank you for this important observation. Additional clarification was added to the Data Collection section. The manuscript now explains that some respondents exited the survey before completion, resulting in missing values. Responses containing more than 10% missing data or showing inconsistent response patterns were excluded. Cases with only negligible missing values were examined and did not require imputation. The data-screening procedure has been clarified accordingly.
- Specify the minimum sample size required using the G*Power sample size calculator according to the criterias mentioned in the paper
Response: thank you for your comment. We have done the necessary changes.
- Table 1 requires to be formatted correctly
Response: Thank you for this comment. Table 1 has been reformatted and its presentation has been improved to enhance readability and consistency with the formatting used throughout the manuscript.
- Usually, content validity is done by 5 to 6 experts. Justify the content validity by only one academic expert. What were the results of content validity? How many questions were modified or deleted?
Response: Thank you for this valuable comment. Additional clarification regarding content validity has been added. The manuscript now explains that the review focused on item clarity, relevance, wording, and contextual appropriateness. Based on the feedback received, minor wording modifications were made to improve readability and contextual fit. No items were deleted because all items were deemed conceptually relevant to the study constructs.
- Table 2 is also not formatted correctly and is not in a readable format.
Response: Thank you for this comment. Table 2 has been reformatted and its presentation has been improved to enhance readability and consistency with the other tables in the manuscript.
- The pilot study section is vaguely written. How many samples were collected for the pilot study? What reliability and validity measures were used to evaluate questionnaire items?
Response: Thank you for this comment. The Pilot Study section has been expanded to specify that 30 hospitality employees participated in the pilot test. The manuscript now clarifies that internal consistency was assessed using Cronbach’s alpha, while content validity was evaluated through expert review. The pilot results supported the clarity, relevance, and reliability of the questionnaire items.
- Was informed consent obtained from participants prior to data collection? If so, was is written or verbal consent? Clarify.
Response: Thank you for this important comment. Additional clarification has been added to the Ethical Considerations section. The manuscript now states that informed consent was obtained electronically from all participants prior to completing the questionnaire and that participation was voluntary.
- For common method bias, include the VIF values rather than merely stating it was below 3.3
Response: Thank you for this valuable suggestion. The Common Method Bias section was revised to provide additional clarification regarding the full collinearity VIF assessment. The manuscript now explicitly states that all VIF values were below the recommended threshold of 3.3, indicating that common method bias was not a significant concern.
- Table 3 also not formatted correctly
Response: Thank you for this comment. Table 3 has been reformatted and its presentation has been improved to enhance readability and consistency with the other tables in the manuscript.
- It is mentioned that non-response bias test was conducted between early and late respondents? What was the gap between the two sets of responses and how was it determined? Were the responses collected in two waves? Elaborate the data collection process.
Response: Thank you for this valuable comment. Additional clarification has been added to the Non-Response Bias section. The manuscript now explains that the survey was administered during a single data-collection period and that early and late respondents were identified according to the order in which completed questionnaires were received, following Armstrong and Overton (1977).
Results
- Table 7 is missing
Response: Thank you for this observation. The issue resulted from table numbering inconsistencies in the previous version of the manuscript. The tables have been renumbered and Table 7 is now correctly presented in the revised manuscript.
- All tables must be referenced in the text
Response: Thank you for this comment. All tables were reviewed and are now explicitly referenced and discussed within the text to improve clarity and ensure consistency throughout the manuscript.
- It is recommended to show item wise factor loadings, rather than merely showing the range.
Response: Thank you for this valuable suggestion. To strengthen the presentation of the measurement model, a new table reporting the item-wise standardized factor loadings has been added. As shown in the revised manuscript, all standardized factor loadings exceeded the recommended threshold of 0.70, ranging from 0.721 to 0.871, indicating satisfactory indicator reliability and convergent validity.
- Improve the clarity of result figure (Figure 2)
Response: Thank you for this comment. Figure 2 has been revised to improve readability and presentation quality. Font sizes, path labels, and graphical elements were enhanced to ensure greater clarity and ease of interpretation.
- There are too many tables in the hypothesis results section. It is recommended to combine the results into a single table. Please refer past research on how CB-SEM results are presented in a compact table.
Response: Thank you for this valuable suggestion. To improve the presentation of the hypothesis-testing results, a comprehensive summary table has been added. This table consolidates the findings of all hypotheses and provides readers with a concise overview of the results while preserving the detailed statistical information presented in the individual analysis tables.
Discussion
- At present, the discussion section restates the study results without adequate interpretation. A section should critically evaluate the findings in relation to prior research, identify consistencies and discrepancies with previous literature, and discuss the possible reasons for these observations.
Response: Thank you for this valuable comment. The Discussion section has been substantially revised to provide deeper interpretation of the findings. Each hypothesized relationship is now discussed in relation to prior empirical studies and the underlying theoretical frameworks. Areas of consistency with previous research are highlighted, and contextual explanations relevant to the Lebanese hospitality sector are provided. The revised discussion therefore moves beyond a simple restatement of results and offers a more critical interpretation of the findings.
Another concern is that, there are very few new citations, that are published post 2022. Authors need to incorporate current references in all sections.
Response: Thank you for this valuable observation. To strengthen the currency of the literature base, several recent references published between 2023 and 2025 have been incorporated throughout the Introduction, Theoretical Framework, and Discussion sections. These additions provide updated empirical support for the study variables and help position the findings within the most recent developments in leadership, employee engagement, perceived organizational support, and organizational citizenship behavior research.
Other sections look fine.
Reviewer 3 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsDear Authors,
This paper addresses an important and underexplored question: how transactional leadership can foster discretionary service behaviors in crisis-affected hospitality settings, and through which psychological and contextual pathways. The moderated mediation framework is theoretically coherent, the measures are well-established, and the setting is both topical and valuable. However, this manuscript needs the following revisions:
- The introduction is considerably longer than necessary and contains substantial overlap with Sections 1.1 (Research Gap and Novelty) and 1.2 (Research Objectives). The authors are encouraged to shorten the introduction by removing repetitive explanations, particularly regarding the importance of transactional leadership, employee engagement, and the Lebanese crisis context, and reserve detailed discussions of research gaps and contributions for the dedicated subsection.
- While the manuscript argues that transactional leadership remains relevant in hospitality settings, the rationale would be more convincing if the authors more clearly explain why this leadership style is especially suitable for fine dining establishments and crisis-affected environments, rather than simply contrasting it with transformational or servant leadership.
- Several gaps are presented, but the manuscript would benefit from a clearer synthesis showing how these gaps collectively justify the proposed moderated mediation model. Explicitly identifying what is theoretically and empirically novel compared with prior hospitality leadership studies would enhance the manuscript’s contribution.
- Although the economic crisis in Lebanon is discussed, the introduction would be strengthened by providing more specific evidence on how these conditions have affected fine dining hospitality establishments and employee behavior. This would better justify the choice of context and demonstrate the practical significance of the study.
- The moderated mediation logic is theoretically consistent with SET/OST. However, the cross-sectional design cannot establish temporal precedence (leadership → engagement → OCB). A time-lagged or multi-source design would meaningfully strengthen causal interpretation.
- If possible, disaggregate transactional leadership components. Contingent reward and active management-by-exception often show distinct associations with engagement and OCB, whereas passive management-by-exception can be detrimental. Modeling a second-order TL or separate paths would sharpen inference and could reconcile “mixed” findings in prior studies.
- If possible, consider latent moderated SEM (e.g., LMS/product indicator in AMOS or Mplus) to test the X×W→M interaction on latent composites, mitigating attenuation from measurement error and aligning with your CFA measurement model.
- Employees are embedded in units and share leaders and climates. Without cluster-robust standard errors or multilevel modeling, standard errors may be biased and the POS moderation might partly reflect unit-level variance. If identifiers are available, re-estimate models with cluster-robust SEs or multilevel SEM to check robustness.
- Sampling and nonresponse. Clarify the sampling frame (number of establishments, types, size), unit response rates, and whether managerial gatekeeping influenced participation or item responding. The 88% response rate for online surveys is unusual—explain distribution channels and incentives, and assess nonresponse bias (e.g., early vs late respondent comparisons).
- If possible, consider alternative model forms (e.g., OCB → engagement as reverse mediation; moderation of the b-path) and check whether the direct TL → OCB path remains after mediation. Test nonlinearity for TL (e.g., diminishing returns).
- Discussion. Consider engaging with service-oriented OCB research and JD-R/Conservation of Resources perspectives that connect leadership-supported resources to engagement and citizenship.
- The Lebanon context is a meaningful contribution; however, discuss generalizability. Cultural dimensions (e.g., higher power distance) may amplify the acceptance and effectiveness of transactional leadership; acknowledge this boundary and suggest testing across cultures and service segments.
- Practical implications can be made more granular: specify which transactional practices (contingent reward structures, real-time feedback, role clarity routines) are most engagement-enhancing under high POS, and how to build POS in resource-constrained settings (e.g., transparent scheduling, wellness supports, fair grievance procedures).
- Managerial gatekeeping in recruitment risks perceived coercion; describe safeguards to protect employee autonomy and confidentiality beyond de-identification.
- Please reduce the number of tables, for example, combine the demographic characteristics into one table (Tables 5-8), etc. Furthermore, redraw Tables 1-4.
Author Response
Comments and Suggestions for Authors
Dear Authors,
This paper addresses an important and underexplored question: how transactional leadership can foster discretionary service behaviors in crisis-affected hospitality settings, and through which psychological and contextual pathways. The moderated mediation framework is theoretically coherent, the measures are well-established, and the setting is both topical and valuable. However, this manuscript needs the following revisions:
- The introduction is considerably longer than necessary and contains substantial overlap with Sections 1.1 (Research Gap and Novelty) and 1.2 (Research Objectives). The authors are encouraged to shorten the introduction by removing repetitive explanations, particularly regarding the importance of transactional leadership, employee engagement, and the Lebanese crisis context, and reserve detailed discussions of research gaps and contributions for the dedicated subsection.
Response: Thank you for this valuable comment. The Introduction was revised and streamlined to reduce overlap with the Research Gap and Novelty and Research Objectives subsections. Repetitive explanations related to transactional leadership, employee engagement, and the Lebanese crisis context were shortened, while the detailed discussion of the research gaps, novelty, and objectives was retained in the dedicated subsections.
- While the manuscript argues that transactional leadership remains relevant in hospitality settings, the rationale would be more convincing if the authors more clearly explain why this leadership style is especially suitable for fine dining establishments and crisis-affected environments, rather than simply contrasting it with transformational or servant leadership.
Response: Thank you for this valuable suggestion. The manuscript has been revised to provide a clearer justification for the suitability of transactional leadership within fine dining hospitality establishments and crisis-affected environments. Rather than simply contrasting transactional leadership with other leadership styles, the revised text explains how its emphasis on role clarity, performance monitoring, contingent rewards, immediate feedback, and operational consistency makes it particularly appropriate for hospitality organizations operating under high service expectations and economic uncertainty.
- Several gaps are presented, but the manuscript would benefit from a clearer synthesis showing how these gaps collectively justify the proposed moderated mediation model. Explicitly identifying what is theoretically and empirically novel compared with prior hospitality leadership studies would enhance the manuscript’s contribution.
Response: Thank you for this valuable comment. The Research Gap and Novelty section has been substantially revised to provide a clearer synthesis of the theoretical, empirical, and contextual gaps identified in the literature. The revised manuscript explicitly explains how these gaps collectively justify the proposed moderated mediation framework. In addition, the originality of the study is now clearly articulated by highlighting the integration of transactional leadership, employee engagement, perceived organizational support, and organizational citizenship behavior within a single conditional process model tested in the underexplored context of crisis-affected fine dining hospitality establishments in Lebanon
- Although the economic crisis in Lebanon is discussed, the introduction would be strengthened by providing more specific evidence on how these conditions have affected fine dining hospitality establishments and employee behavior. This would better justify the choice of context and demonstrate the practical significance of the study.
Response: Thank you for this valuable observation. The Introduction has been revised to provide a stronger justification for selecting Lebanon as the study context. Additional discussion and recent evidence have been incorporated to explain how the prolonged economic crisis, political instability, and decline in the hospitality and tourism sectors have affected hospitality establishments, employee motivation, and service delivery. These revisions strengthen both the contextual justification and the practical significance of the study.
- The moderated mediation logic is theoretically consistent with SET/OST. However, the cross-sectional design cannot establish temporal precedence (leadership → engagement → OCB). A time-lagged or multi-source design would meaningfully strengthen causal interpretation.
Response: Thank you for this important observation. We acknowledge that the cross-sectional design does not permit definitive causal inferences or establish temporal precedence among the study variables. Accordingly, the Limitations and Recommendations for Future Research section has been expanded to explicitly acknowledge this limitation. The revised manuscript also recommends that future studies employ longitudinal, time-lagged, or multi-source research designs to further validate the temporal ordering of the proposed relationships and strengthen causal interpretation.
- If possible, disaggregate transactional leadership components. Contingent reward and active management-by-exception often show distinct associations with engagement and OCB, whereas passive management-by-exception can be detrimental. Modeling a second-order TL or separate paths would sharpen inference and could reconcile “mixed” findings in prior studies.
Response: Thank you for this valuable observation. We acknowledge that the MLQ distinguishes transactional leadership into contingent reward and management-by-exception dimensions. However, the purpose of the present study was to examine the overall influence of transactional leadership within the proposed moderated mediation framework rather than compare its individual dimensions. Accordingly, transactional leadership was treated as a higher-order construct, consistent with previous empirical studies adopting a similar approach. This methodological justification has now been clarified in the revised manuscript.
- If possible, consider latent moderated SEM (e.g., LMS/product indicator in AMOS or Mplus) to test the X×W→M interaction on latent composites, mitigating attenuation from measurement error and aligning with your CFA measurement model.
Response: Thank you for this important comment. The revised manuscript now clarifies the rationale for selecting PROCESS Macro Model 7. This approach was chosen because it is a widely accepted method for estimating conditional process models using bootstrapped confidence intervals and is particularly suitable for testing moderated mediation relationships. As the measurement model had already demonstrated satisfactory reliability and validity through confirmatory factor analysis, PROCESS Model 7 was considered appropriate for estimating the proposed conditional indirect effects.
- Employees are embedded in units and share leaders and climates. Without cluster-robust standard errors or multilevel modeling, standard errors may be biased and the POS moderation might partly reflect unit-level variance. If identifiers are available, re-estimate models with cluster-robust SEs or multilevel SEM to check robustness.
Response: Thank you for this valuable observation. We acknowledge that employees were nested within different hospitality establishments and that this may introduce clustering effects. Because the distribution of respondents across individual establishments was insufficient to support multilevel modeling, this issue has now been acknowledged as a study limitation. The revised manuscript also recommends that future research employ multilevel analytical approaches when sufficient organizational-level data are available.
- Sampling and nonresponse. Clarify the sampling frame (number of establishments, types, size), unit response rates, and whether managerial gatekeeping influenced participation or item responding. The 88% response rate for online surveys is unusual—explain distribution channels and incentives, and assess nonresponse bias (e.g., early vs late respondent comparisons).
Response: Thank you for this valuable suggestion. The methodology section has been expanded to provide additional details regarding the sampling and data collection procedures. Specifically, the revised manuscript now explains how participating restaurants were approached, confirms that management approval was obtained prior to data collection, describes the questionnaire distribution process, and clarifies the response rate and exclusion of incomplete questionnaires. These revisions improve the transparency and reproducibility of the study.
- If possible, consider alternative model forms (e.g., OCB → engagement as reverse mediation; moderation of the b-path) and check whether the direct TL → OCB path remains after mediation. Test nonlinearity for TL (e.g., diminishing returns).
Response: Thank you for this valuable comment. We have clarified the theoretical rationale for selecting the proposed moderated mediation model over alternative specifications. A paragraph has been added to the Conceptual Framework and Research Model section explaining that the model is grounded in Social Exchange Theory and Organizational Support Theory and is therefore the most appropriate framework for addressing the study objectives.
- Discussion. Consider engaging with service-oriented OCB research and JD-R/Conservation of Resources perspectives that connect leadership-supported resources to engagement and citizenship.
Response: Thank you for this valuable suggestion. We have acknowledged the relevance of alternative theoretical perspectives, including the Job Demands–Resources model and Conservation of Resources theory, while clarifying why Social Exchange Theory and Organizational Support Theory were selected as the primary theoretical foundations of this study. This clarification has been added to the Theoretical Contributions section.
- The Lebanon context is a meaningful contribution; however, discuss generalizability. Cultural dimensions (e.g., higher power distance) may amplify the acceptance and effectiveness of transactional leadership; acknowledge this boundary and suggest testing across cultures and service segments.
Response: Thank you for this valuable comment. We have expanded the Limitations and Recommendations for Future Research section to clarify that the findings should be interpreted within the specific context of Lebanese fine dining restaurants and therefore should not be generalized without caution to other hospitality sectors or countries. We also recommend that future research replicate the proposed model in different hospitality settings and cultural contexts.
- Practical implications can be made more granular: specify which transactional practices (contingent reward structures, real-time feedback, role clarity routines) are most engagement-enhancing under high POS, and how to build POS in resource-constrained settings (e.g., transparent scheduling, wellness supports, fair grievance procedures).
Response: Thank you for this valuable suggestion. We have strengthened the Practical and Managerial Implications section by providing more specific and actionable recommendations for restaurant owners and managers. The revised manuscript now includes practical examples of transactional leadership practices, such as establishing clear performance expectations, providing regular feedback, recognizing and rewarding employee performance, and fostering a supportive organizational environment to enhance employee engagement and organizational citizenship behavior.
- Managerial gatekeeping in recruitment risks perceived coercion; describe safeguards to protect employee autonomy and confidentiality beyond de-identification.
Response: Thank you for this important observation. The Ethical Considerations section has been expanded to clarify the safeguards implemented to protect employee autonomy and confidentiality. Specifically, the revised manuscript now explains that participation was entirely voluntary, managers were unaware of who participated or declined, individual responses were anonymous and confidential, managers had no access to completed questionnaires, and all findings were reported only in aggregate form.
- Please reduce the number of tables, for example, combine the demographic characteristics into one table (Tables 5-8), etc. Furthermore, redraw Tables 1-4.
Response: Thank you for this valuable suggestion. The demographic characteristics previously presented in separate tables have been consolidated into one table. Tables 1–4 have also been reformatted to improve clarity, readability, and consistency with the journal’s presentation style.
Round 2
Reviewer 1 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsThe authors have taken the comments into consideration and revised the article; however, some issues still require correction.
The Conclusion section must be revised. This is the weakest part of the manuscript after the revisions. The current Conclusion section is unclear and contains many grammatical errors and imprecise sentences. Some phrases sound as if they were translated directly or left unfinished. Therefore, this section should not only be edited but rewritten. The Conclusion should clearly state what the study found regarding each relationship: the relationship between Transactional Leadership and Organizational Citizenship Behavior, Employee Engagement as a mediator, Perceived Organizational Support as a moderator, and the overall conditional indirect effect.
It is also necessary to correct the title of Table 16. The table is currently titled “Direct Effect Analysis,” although it presents the mediation / indirect effect rather than the direct effect. This is a technical but important error because it may mislead both the reader and the reviewer. A more appropriate title would be “Mediation Analysis” or “Indirect Effect Analysis.”
Another necessary correction concerns the harmonization of the statistical tables. The hypothesis-testing tables should follow the same logic: coefficients, p-values, confidence intervals, and the decision regarding each hypothesis should be presented consistently. It is recommended to add a brief note below the tables so that the reader can clearly understand how the results should be interpreted.
The construct names should also be standardized throughout the article. At present, full construct names are used in some places, abbreviations in others, and capitalization is inconsistent. One system should be selected and applied consistently. For example, the first mention could use Transactional Leadership (TL), Employee Engagement (EE), Perceived Organizational Support (POS), and Organizational Citizenship Behavior (OCB), followed consistently by either the same abbreviations or the full construct names. The most important point is to avoid alternating between forms.
Because the study uses a cross-sectional design, overly strong causal wording must be removed. The manuscript should not be written as if the study had demonstrated a direct causal effect. Words such as “affects,” “impact,” and “influence” should be avoided when discussing the empirical results. Safer alternatives include “is associated with,” “is positively related to,” “positively predicts,” “may contribute to,” or “the findings suggest.”
The practical recommendations should also be softened. Some recommendations currently sound too categorical, as if the study had proven that specific managerial actions directly improve employee behavior. Instead of “managers should” or “managers can boost,” it would be more appropriate to use “managers may consider,” “organizations could strengthen,” or “the findings suggest that...”.
Finally, the manuscript requires substantial English-language editing. Although many of the reviewer’s comments have been formally addressed, the text still contains many sentences that sound unnatural or are grammatically inaccurate. The Results, Discussion, Practical Implications, and Conclusion sections require particular attention.
Comments on the Quality of English LanguageThe English could be improved to more clearly express the research.
Author Response
The Conclusion section must be revised. This is the weakest part of the manuscript after the revisions. The current Conclusion section is unclear and contains many grammatical errors and imprecise sentences. Some phrases sound as if they were translated directly or left unfinished. Therefore, this section should not only be edited but rewritten. The Conclusion should clearly state what the study found regarding each relationship: the relationship between Transactional Leadership and Organizational Citizenship Behavior, Employee Engagement as a mediator, Perceived Organizational Support as a moderator, and the overall conditional indirect effect.
Response: Thank you for this valuable comment. The Conclusion section has been completely rewritten rather than only edited. The revised version now clearly summarizes the findings for each relationship: the positive association between Transactional Leadership and Organizational Citizenship Behavior, the mediating role of Employee Engagement, the moderating role of Perceived Organizational Support, and the supported conditional indirect effect. The section was also reorganized to improve clarity, remove imprecise wording, avoid causal overstatement, and present the theoretical contributions, practical implications, limitations, and future research directions more clearly.
It is also necessary to correct the title of Table 16. The table is currently titled “Direct Effect Analysis,” although it presents the mediation / indirect effect rather than the direct effect. This is a technical but important error because it may mislead both the reader and the reviewer. A more appropriate title would be “Mediation Analysis” or “Indirect Effect Analysis.”
Another necessary correction concerns the harmonization of the statistical tables. The hypothesis-testing tables should follow the same logic: coefficients, p-values, confidence intervals, and the decision regarding each hypothesis should be presented consistently. It is recommended to add a brief note below the tables so that the reader can clearly understand how the results should be interpreted.
Response: Thank you for this valuable suggestion. We carefully revised the presentation of the hypothesis-testing tables to improve their clarity, consistency, and interpretability. First, the title of Table 16 was corrected to accurately reflect the reported analysis, replacing the previous title with the appropriate mediation/indirect effect title. Second, all hypothesis-testing tables were harmonized to ensure the consistent presentation of standardized coefficients (β), p-values, confidence intervals, and hypothesis decisions throughout the Results section. In addition, explanatory notes were added below the statistical tables to define the reported statistics and facilitate the interpretation of the findings. These revisions improve the consistency, transparency, and readability of the statistical results.
The construct names should also be standardized throughout the article. At present, full construct names are used in some places, abbreviations in others, and capitalization is inconsistent. One system should be selected and applied consistently. For example, the first mention could use Transactional Leadership (TL), Employee Engagement (EE), Perceived Organizational Support (POS), and Organizational Citizenship Behavior (OCB), followed consistently by either the same abbreviations or the full construct names. The most important point is to avoid alternating between forms.
Response: Thank you for this helpful suggestion. We standardized the terminology used throughout the manuscript.
Because the study uses a cross-sectional design, overly strong causal wording must be removed. The manuscript should not be written as if the study had demonstrated a direct causal effect. Words such as “affects,” “impact,” and “influence” should be avoided when discussing the empirical results. Safer alternatives include “is associated with,” “is positively related to,” “positively predicts,” “may contribute to,” or “the findings suggest.”
Response: Thank you for this important methodological observation. We carefully reviewed the entire manuscript and revised the language to avoid implying causal relationships that cannot be established using a cross-sectional design.
The practical recommendations should also be softened. Some recommendations currently sound too categorical, as if the study had proven that specific managerial actions directly improve employee behavior. Instead of “managers should” or “managers can boost,” it would be more appropriate to use “managers may consider,” “organizations could strengthen,” or “the findings suggest that...”.
Response: Thank you for this important methodological observation. We carefully reviewed the entire manuscript and revised the language to ensure that it is fully consistent with the cross-sectional nature of the study.
Finally, the manuscript requires substantial English-language editing. Although many of the reviewer’s comments have been formally addressed, the text still contains many sentences that sound unnatural or are grammatically inaccurate. The Results, Discussion, Practical Implications, and Conclusion sections require particular attention.
Response: Thank you for this valuable comment. We carefully revised the manuscript to improve grammar, sentence structure, clarity, and overall readability. Particular attention was given to the Results, Discussion, Practical Implications, and Conclusion sections, and the language was refined to enhance the manuscript's academic quality and coherence.
Comments on the Quality of English Language
The English could be improved to more clearly express the research.
Author Response File:
Author Response.pdf
Reviewer 2 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsDear Authors,
The manuscript has be substantially improvised and most of the suggested changes have been made. Two points require further attention.
- For the comment. "There are very few new citations, that are published post 2022. Authors need to incorporate current references in all sections" - There were only 2 to 3 references added. Authors might want to add at least a few more recent references.
- For the comment "At present, the discussion section restates the study results without adequate interpretation. A section should critically evaluate the findings in relation to prior research, identify consistencies and discrepancies with previous literature, and discuss the possible reasons for these observations". Though the authors have responded that changes have been incorporated, the revised manuscript does not reflect the changes. Kindly check and revise.
Author Response
The manuscript has be substantially improvised and most of the suggested changes have been made. Two points require further attention.
- For the comment. "There are very few new citations, that are published post 2022. Authors need to incorporate current references in all sections" - There were only 2 to 3 references added. Authors might want to add at least a few more recent references.
Response: Thank you for this valuable suggestion. We carefully revised the manuscript to incorporate a substantially larger number of recent references (published between 2023 and 2026) throughout the paper. Recent studies have been integrated into the Introduction, Research Gap, Literature Review, Methodology (where appropriate), and Discussion sections to strengthen the theoretical foundation and ensure that the manuscript reflects the current state of research. In particular, the Discussion was expanded to compare our findings with recent empirical evidence, including studies by Ha and Moon (2023), Santa et al. (2023), Songio et al. (2023), Santos et al. (2023), Zhou and Segumpan (2024), Albrecht et al. (2024), Caesens and Stinglhamber (2023), and other recent contributions. These revisions enhance the manuscript's currency, strengthen the interpretation of the findings, and address the reviewer's concern regarding the use of post-2022 literature.
- For the comment "At present, the discussion section restates the study results without adequate interpretation. A section should critically evaluate the findings in relation to prior research, identify consistencies and discrepancies with previous literature, and discuss the possible reasons for these observations". Though the authors have responded that changes have been incorporated, the revised manuscript does not reflect the changes. Kindly check and revise.
Response: "We appreciate this insightful comment. We rewrote the Discussion with significant detail in scope where we did not simply relate the statistical findings. Each Hypothesis discussion was respectively expanded to (1) interpret the linkages in agreement with relevant theory, (2) relate them to foundational and recent (2023-2026) empirical literature, (3) refer to contextual reasons the association would be connected in the Lebanese hospitality context, (4) refer to the theoretical and practical value in the findings.
We especially bolstered the H1 discussion incidentally referring to Ha and Moon (2023), Santa et al. (2023), and Zhou and Segumpan (2024). The H2 discussion we enriched further with recent evidence around Songio et al.(2023), Santos et al. (2023), and Albrecht et al. (2024) and a more robust explanation for the specific scenario around Employee Engagement. The H3 discussion was revised in scope to draw in both foundational and new, including Caesens and Stinglhamber (2023), to clarify interpretation around moderators in perceived organizational support. Finally in discussing the conditional indirect effect H4, we more clearly herald the conceptual explanation for why perceived organizational support actually bolstered the indirect link between Transactional Leadership and Organizational Citizenship Behavior via Employee Engagement, illustrating the study's contribution to both Social Exchange Theory and Organizational Support Theory. These all work to raise the sophistication of our Discussion.
Author Response File:
Author Response.pdf
Reviewer 3 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsDear Author(s),
Thank you for your efforts in revising the manuscript entitled "Transactional Leadership and Organizational Citizenship Behavior in Fine Dining Hospitality Establishments: A Moderated Mediation Analysis of Employee Engagement and Perceived Organizational Support in Lebanon." I appreciate the time and attention you devoted to preparing the revised version and the detailed response letter.
However, after carefully comparing the original and revised manuscripts, I noticed that most of my previous comments have not been satisfactorily addressed, despite the responses indicating that they had been. In several instances, the revisions are either minimal or not readily identifiable in the manuscript. To facilitate the review process, I kindly ask that you address the remaining comments below and clearly indicate the revised page number, paragraph, and line numbers in your response letter, while also highlighting all revisions in the manuscript.
The following comments from my previous review remain insufficiently addressed:
1. Introduction length and redundancy: The introduction remains considerably longer than necessary and continues to overlap substantially with Sections 1.1 (Research Gap and Novelty) and 1.2 (Research Objectives). Please shorten the introduction by removing repetitive explanations, particularly those concerning the importance of transactional leadership, employee engagement, and the Lebanese crisis context. Reserve detailed discussions of research gaps, novelty, and contributions for the dedicated subsections.
2. Justification for transactional leadership: While the manuscript argues that transactional leadership remains relevant in hospitality settings, the rationale would be more convincing if you explained more clearly why this leadership style is particularly appropriate for fine dining establishments and crisis-affected environments, rather than primarily contrasting it with transformational or servant leadership.
3. Integration of the research gaps: Although several research gaps are presented, the manuscript would benefit from a clearer synthesis showing how these gaps collectively justify the proposed moderated mediation model. Please explicitly identify what is theoretically and empirically novel compared with previous hospitality leadership studies to strengthen the manuscript's contribution.
4. Contextual justification: Although the economic crisis in Lebanon is discussed, the introduction would be strengthened by providing more specific evidence regarding how these conditions have affected fine dining hospitality establishments and employee behavior. This would better justify the choice of research context and demonstrate the practical significance of the study.
In addition, I would like to raise the following comments:
6. Presentation and formatting: The manuscript currently contains 21 tables, which is excessive and affects readability. Please reduce the number of tables by combining related tables where appropriate, removing duplicate or unnecessary tables (for example, Table 8 appears redundant if Table 9 is retained), deleting redundant tables such as Table 21, and moving supplementary tables to an appendix where appropriate.
7. Please ensure that the references are formatted according to the journal's guidelines (e.g., the formatting of Reference 3) and include complete DOI links using the format https://doi.org/ wherever applicable.
8. Literature update: Please reduce the reliance on older references and replace them with more recent and relevant literature wherever possible. This will strengthen the manuscript's theoretical foundation and better reflect current developments in the hospitality and leadership literature.
I hope these comments will assist you in further improving the manuscript. I look forward to reviewing a revised version that clearly addresses each point and identifies all corresponding changes.
Author Response
The following comments from my previous review remain insufficiently addressed:
1. Introduction length and redundancy: The introduction remains considerably longer than necessary and continues to overlap substantially with Sections 1.1 (Research Gap and Novelty) and 1.2 (Research Objectives). Please shorten the introduction by removing repetitive explanations, particularly those concerning the importance of transactional leadership, employee engagement, and the Lebanese crisis context. Reserve detailed discussions of research gaps, novelty, and contributions for the dedicated subsections.
Response: Thank you for this valuable suggestion. We substantially revised and shortened the Introduction to improve its focus and reduce redundancy.
Justification for transactional leadership: While the manuscript argues that transactional leadership remains relevant in hospitality settings, the rationale would be more convincing if you explained more clearly why this leadership style is particularly appropriate for fine dining establishments and crisis-affected environments, rather than primarily contrasting it with transformational or servant leadership.
Response :Thank you for this encouraging recommendation. We have clarified and strengthened the rationale for choosing Transactional Leadership by expanding the Introduction to explain in more detail why this leadership style is especially amenable to fine dining hospitality and crisis hit environments. Rather than focusing mainly on comparing Transactional Leadership with other leadership styles such as transformational, servant, ethical, and authentic, the revised submission provides detail on how the operational characteristics of fine dining restaurants (standardized service procedures, service roles, monitoring performance, timely feedback and rewards, contingent rewards, consistent service) align closely with these core principles of Transactional Leadership. And why these leadership behaviors are particularly relevant under the current economic and operational constraints facing Lebanese hospitality organizations seeking high levels of service, accountability and operational stability.
Integration of the research gaps: Although several research gaps are presented, the manuscript would benefit from a clearer synthesis showing how these gaps collectively justify the proposed moderated mediation model. Please explicitly identify what is theoretically and empirically novel compared with previous hospitality leadership studies to strengthen the manuscript's contribution.
Response: Thank you for this valuable suggestion. We have strengthened Section 1.1 (Research Gap and Novelty) by adding a concluding synthesis paragraph that integrates the identified theoretical, empirical, and contextual research gaps into a unified rationale for the proposed moderated mediation framework. Rather than presenting the gaps separately, the revised section now explains how they collectively justify the inclusion of Employee Engagement as the mediating mechanism and Perceived Organizational Support as the moderating condition within a single conditional process model. We also explicitly clarify the study's theoretical and empirical novelty by highlighting its contribution beyond previous hospitality leadership research and by emphasizing the unique crisis-affected Lebanese fine-dining context. These revisions provide a clearer justification for the proposed model and strengthen the manuscript's overall contribution.
Contextual justification: Although the economic crisis in Lebanon is discussed, the introduction would be strengthened by providing more specific evidence regarding how these conditions have affected fine dining hospitality establishments and employee behavior. This would better justify the choice of research context and demonstrate the practical significance of the study.
Response: Thank you for this valuable suggestion. We strengthened the contextual justification for selecting Lebanon as the study setting by expanding the Introduction with a more specific discussion of how the country's prolonged economic crisis has affected fine dining hospitality establishments.
In addition, I would like to raise the following comments:
6. Presentation and formatting: The manuscript currently contains 21 tables, which is excessive and affects readability. Please reduce the number of tables by combining related tables where appropriate, removing duplicate or unnecessary tables (for example, Table 8 appears redundant if Table 9 is retained), deleting redundant tables such as Table 21, and moving supplementary tables to an appendix where appropriate.
Response: Thank you for this helpful suggestion. We carefully reviewed the presentation of all tables to improve the readability of the manuscript. Following your recommendation, redundant tables were removed, including Table 8 and Table 21. The deletion of Table 8 eliminated duplicated information because the relevant results are already presented in the subsequent table, while Table 21 was removed as it did not provide additional information beyond the main findings. We also reviewed the remaining tables to ensure that only those essential for understanding the methodology and results were retained. These revisions reduce redundancy, improve the organization of the manuscript, and enhance its overall readability.
- Please ensure that the references are formatted according to the journal's guidelines (e.g., the formatting of Reference 3) and include complete DOI links using the format https://doi.org/ wherever applicable.
Response: Thank you for this helpful observation. We carefully reviewed the entire reference list to ensure full compliance with the Administrative Sciences (MDPI) reference style.
Literature update: Please reduce the reliance on older references and replace them with more recent and relevant literature wherever possible. This will strengthen the manuscript's theoretical foundation and better reflect current developments in the hospitality and leadership literature.
Response: Thank you for this valuable suggestion. We carefully reviewed the literature throughout the manuscript to reduce reliance on older references while retaining foundational studies that define the theoretical constructs and measurement scales.
I hope these comments will assist you in further improving the manuscript. I look forward to reviewing a revised version that clearly addresses each point and identifies all corresponding changes.
Submission Date
27 May 2026
Date of this review
27 Jun 2026 03:17:23
Author Response File:
Author Response.pdf
Round 3
Reviewer 3 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsDear Author(s),
Thank you for your careful revision of the manuscript entitled "Transactional Leadership and Organizational Citizenship Behavior in Fine Dining Hospitality Establishments: A Moderated Mediation Analysis of Employee Engagement and Perceived Organizational Support in Lebanon." I appreciate the considerable effort you have devoted to addressing my previous comments and improving the manuscript.
I am pleased to note that my previous concerns have been addressed satisfactorily. The revisions have enhanced the clarity, rigor, and overall quality of the paper, and I am satisfied with the responses provided in the revision process.