Review Reports
- Åke Elden
Reviewer 1: Susanna Bellander Reviewer 2: Denghao Zhang Reviewer 3: Anonymous
Round 1
Reviewer 1 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsThank you for an interesting reading, addressing a relevant topic. The manuscript presents a promising and relevant conceptual idea with clear potential. However, to fully realize this potential some improvements are suggested. Some of the comments are more central to the rigor and clarity of the manuscript, while other reflect more minor suggestions and matters of preferences.
The manuscript would benefit from a clearer distinction between “concept” and “framework”. At present, the contribution is at times described as a framework and at other times as a concept, but these are not equivalent. Clarifying whether the aim is to introduce a concept or to propose a framework would improve the precision.
Section 3.2 (“Conceptual Distinctions”) would likely be more effective if introduced earlier, as it provides important definitional clarity that would support the reader throughout the text.
The manuscript also contains a substantial amount of repetition. Several arguments are reiterated across multiple sections, which makes it difficult at times to distinguish what is new from what has already been established. Examples of such repetition (more or less) can be found in lines 246-248, 254-255, 270-271, 279, 309-310, 336-337, and 344-346, among others. Reducing redundancy and sharpening the progression of the argument would significantly improve clarity.
Section 4.1 is particularly strong in its use of illustrative examples. Expanding this approach throughout the manuscript would be beneficial. Additional concrete examples could help clarify subtle conceptual distinctions.
Figure 1 is a valuable addition and helps communicate the proposed model. It would benefit from a more detailed explanation in the text. In particular, further clarification of what is included in each phase and how transitions occur between phases would strengthen its interpretability. More explicit references to the figure throughout the manuscript would be appreciated.
Although the manuscript is presented as a conceptual rather than empirical study, the methodological approach remains insufficiently specified. It is currently unclear how the analysis was conducted, how the literature was selected, and how the synthesis across different theoretical traditions was developed. If the manuscript is intended as a theoretical synthesis, this should be clearly stated and described. In addition, the manuscript would benefit from engaging more consistently with existing literature throughout the analysis, as several sections currently lack sufficient referencing.
Furthermore, the manuscript does not currently include a discussion of limitations. Without a clear account of the study’s limitations, it becomes difficult for the reader to assess the robustness of the contribution. Taken together, the absence of a clearly articulated method, limited transparency in how the analysis was conducted, gaps in referencing, and the lack of a limitations section, make it challenging to determine to what extent the manuscript represents a systematic synthesis versus a more selective argument. As a result, the proposed concept/framework currently risks being interpreted more as an interesting identification of a gap than as a fully developed and well-substantiated theoretical contribution.
I hope you find this feedback helpful and that it can support further development of the manuscript.
Author Response
Response to Reviewer 1
We thank the reviewer for a careful and constructive evaluation. The comments have been highly valuable in strengthening the conceptual clarity, structure, and rigor of the manuscript. All suggested changes have been implemented in the revised manuscript.
1. Clarification of “concept” and “framework”
We agree that this distinction required clarification. The manuscript has been revised to explicitly define micro-discipline as a conceptual construct that is developed into a theoretical framework. This clarification is now stated in the Introduction and applied consistently throughout the manuscript.
2. Placement of conceptual distinctions
We appreciate the suggestion to introduce conceptual distinctions earlier. The section previously titled “Conceptual Distinctions” has been moved forward in the manuscript to provide definitional clarity at an earlier stage, thereby improving readability and coherence.
3. Reduction of repetition
We agree that the manuscript contained redundancy. Repetitive passages have been removed or consolidated, and the progression of the argument has been sharpened so that each section now contributes more distinctly without reiterating previously established points.
4. Use of examples
We appreciate the positive feedback on the use of examples. Additional clarifying elements have been incorporated where appropriate to support conceptual distinctions, while maintaining the theoretical focus of the paper.
5. Clarification of Figure 1
We agree that the figure required stronger integration. The manuscript now includes a more detailed explanation of Figure 1, including clarification of its components, the transitions between phases, and the role of feedback processes. The figure is now more explicitly referenced and discussed in the relevant sections.
6. Methodological clarification
We fully agree that the methodological approach needed to be made explicit. A new subsection titled “Methodological Approach: Conceptual Synthesis” has been added to the Introduction. This section clarifies the interdisciplinary basis of the analysis, the principles guiding literature selection, and the integrative aim of the conceptual synthesis.
7. Referencing and engagement with literature
Additional references have been added in sections where engagement was previously limited, and the manuscript now more consistently integrates relevant literature throughout the analysis.
8. Limitations
A new section titled “Limitations and Scope Conditions” has been added. This clarifies the conceptual nature of the contribution, its boundaries, and directions for future empirical work.
We are grateful for these comments, which have significantly improved the clarity and rigor of the manuscript.
Reviewer 2 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsThis conceptual paper on the Micro-Discipline model generally meets the basic requirements for publication, but several revisions are needed to improve conceptual clarity, theoretical contribution, structural efficiency, and readability.
1、The definition of micro-discipline needs to be more precise and explicit. In particular, the conceptual boundaries between micro-discipline and adjacent constructs—including self-control, conscientiousness, habit, and virtue—are insufficiently clear and should be sharply distinguished.
2、The theoretical contributions of the study are not articulated clearly enough in the Introduction and Conclusion. We recommend that the author condense these contributions into several distinct, concrete points for greater transparency and impact.
3、The background review is somewhat lengthy. Please appropriately compress this section to reach the research gap more efficiently and accelerate the core argument.
4、Adding a visual theoretical model of Micro-Discipline would greatly help readers grasp the framework intuitively. A formal figure illustrating the core constructs, processes, and pathways is strongly encouraged.
Author Response
We thank the reviewer for constructive and precise suggestions that have helped improve the manuscript. All points raised have been addressed in the revised version.
1. Precision of the definition of micro-discipline
We agree that the definition required further precision. The definition has been revised to more explicitly specify its core features and boundaries. In particular, the manuscript now more clearly distinguishes micro-discipline from adjacent constructs, including self-control, conscientiousness, habit, and virtue.
2. Clarification of theoretical contributions
We agree that the theoretical contributions needed to be more explicitly articulated. The Introduction and Conclusion have been revised to present the contributions as clearly delineated points, improving transparency and impact.
3. Compression of the background section
The background section has been reduced and streamlined to reach the research gap more efficiently. This improves the pacing of the manuscript and strengthens the focus on the central argument.
4. Visual model
We appreciate the suggestion regarding the visual model. The existing figure has been retained and strengthened through clearer presentation and more detailed explanation in the text. Its role in structuring the theoretical framework is now more explicit.
We thank the reviewer for these helpful suggestions, which have improved both clarity and structure.
Reviewer 3 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsThis is the best paper that I have reviewed in a long time - beautifully written and argued and its many contributions to the field clear.
The key point of the paper is well outlined & its contributions to theory well argues in the opening and then again evidenced in the Conclusion. The conceptual perspective chosen is well grounded & useful in advancing its 4 claims across the 7 sections of the paper. Its focus on micro-discipline as a clarifying framework is entirely apt throughout. The paper skillfully focusses the place of micro-discipline in relation to "adjacent frameworks." Figure 1 is a useful visual summary for readers as are the examples to support theory development throughout.
It is good that the paper then emphasizes distinctions between behavioral organization and normative evaluation, critically arguing that the former does not per se equate with moral virtue.
Again, the paper argues convincingly the need to address micro-discipline as "a person-environment regulatory system rather than as an internal capacity alone - identifying it as an ecological system.
The outline of a threefold contribution to theory is clearly delineated in the well structured Conclusion and points usefully to future research.
I have only two suggestions: (a) References are needed in lines 550-556; and (b) that this excellent paper in its theoretical perspective could in future be followed up by another suggesting how this work can inform organization leaders and managers, including HR personnel, on how to best understand and work well with their human resources to optimise individual and organizational purposes.
Congratulations to the author/s and please advise when the paper is published so that I may quote it in any future work that I undertake.
Author Response
We sincerely thank the reviewer for the very positive and encouraging evaluation of the manuscript. We are grateful for the recognition of the paper’s theoretical contribution and clarity.
1. Missing references
The references indicated in lines 550–556 have now been added in the revised manuscript.
2. Suggestion for future applied work
We appreciate this valuable suggestion. While the present article is conceptual in focus, we agree that the framework has clear implications for organizational contexts. This direction has been briefly acknowledged in the Conclusion as an avenue for future research.
We thank the reviewer for the supportive assessment and constructive suggestions.
Round 2
Reviewer 2 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsUpon careful review of the authors' revisions and responses to the review comments, all concerns have been fully addressed and appropriately modified. The manuscript now meets the publication standards of this journal, and I recommend acceptance for publication.
Author Response
Thank you very much for the careful review