Review Reports
- Audrey DeClue 1,*,
- Kate Workman 2,3 and
- Sharon May-Davis 4,*
Reviewer 1: Anonymous Reviewer 2: Nicola Pilati Reviewer 3: Anonymous
Round 1
Reviewer 1 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsOne of the main flaw of the manuscript:
Considering the study below, what is the novelty of the current authors’ findings? Because in terms of both radiographic technique and the correlation between radiographic images and vertebral anatomy, although the authors described the anatomy of the muscle and the C7 foramen, they did so without providing actual images.
Gee, C., Small, A., Shorter, K., & Brown, W. Y. (2020). A Radiographic Technique for Assessment of Morphologic Variations of the Equine Caudal Cervical Spine. Animals, 10(4), 667. https://doi.org/10.3390/ani10040667
- The title is very long and should be shortened and made understandable for a general audience.
- The title should definitely include transverse process.
- Caudal should be removed, and the scientific name should not be italicized.
- There is no need to mention Grade 4.
Abstract:
- Should be revised in a simple format according to the journal’s guidelines.
- The methods should be specifically described (animal, number, breed, and methods studied).
Introduction and Aim:
- A brief description of cervical vertebrae, with emphasis on transverse processes, and specifically C6 in horses, should be included.
- Line 94: What is meant by tracheal ridge?
- According to lines 100–101, it seems that the intention was to provide a radiographic protocol, but no specific imaging protocol was provided, and the imaging angle is similar to the study by Gee et al.
Gee, C., Small, A., Shorter, K., & Brown, W. Y. (2020). A Radiographic Technique for Assessment of Morphologic Variations of the Equine Caudal Cervical Spine. Animals, 10(4), 667. https://doi.org/10.3390/ani10040667
- Lines 107–108 mention differences in arterial blood flow to the brain, but the reference used is unrelated, and the page number is incorrect.
- Lines 108–109: Considering these points, can such a cervical vertebra anomaly in horses be detected by palpation? Is it normally possible to palpate this process?
Materials and Methods:
- Anatomical terminology should be updated according to the latest NAV version.
- The method of euthanasia of the horses should be briefly described.
- Preparation of the vertebrae should be briefly described.
- Age determination should be described.
- Details about the horses: breed, age, male/female should be categorized and specified.
- An image showing the positioning of the X-ray tube relative to the horse’s neck for C6 imaging should be provided.
- Imaging details should be specified, e.g., film focal distance, etc.
Results:
- In all images, the cranial and dorsal anatomical directions of the vertebra and radiograph should be shown on the image.
- Lines 391–392: The sentence is unclear and should be revised.
- Lines 393–394: What is meant by cranial?
- Use a contrasting background for cervical vertebrae, and a scale should be included in the image.
- Table and figure titles should be complete so that information can be obtained without referring to the text. For example, the type of animal should be specified.
- A lateral view of the bone and lateral radiograph of C6 should also be provided to give readers a better understanding of vertebral differences. The details of C6, especially the transverse process, should be fully labeled and marked.
- Lines 156 and 198: What is meant by lateral arterial foramen?
- Line 168: The description should be anatomically revised. The question arises: does this situation normally exist in C5, C4, and C3?
- Line 168: The following description needs to be corrected from an anatomical perspective. Moreover, the question arises whether such a condition does not naturally occur in vertebrae C5, C4, and C3.
“the connection between the caudal curvature of the transverse process to the vertebral bod”
- Differences between male and female findings should be clearly reported.
- The connection between the caudal curvature of the transverse process and the vertebral body:
- Line 205: The description below is not anatomically scientific and should be revised, as in the previous comment:
Unification of the caudal transverse process with the vertebral body
- Line 208: Are the radiographs in this section similar in angle to figure 2 or figure 1? It does not appear so.
- Table 1: What does the red arrow indicate?
- In Table 1, the trachea should be labeled in the radiographs.
- Line 275, Figure 3: The actual anatomical image should also be shown since the cadavers were available and dissected.
- Regarding the schematic images of the longus colli muscle, as shown in the authors’ figures, can it be concluded that the muscle only attaches to the ventral surface of the cervical vertebrae? This is not correct; lateral views and related explanations should also be shown. The main difference is likely visible in this view.
- Table 1: How can you confirm that the vertebral bones presented belong to C6 and not C3, C4, or C5, considering that the only distinguishing feature is the specific process found in C6? It is necessary to show complete images of the cranial and caudal of the vertebra. This issue is also observed in the radiographs
- In Table 1, a ventral view of C6 should also be shown, as the absence of the transverse process is better visualized from this view.
- Lines 185–201: Images corresponding to each finding should be included.
- Line 198: An image should be provided, especially for C7.
- Lines 225–272: Descriptions of the muscle should be written clearly so that readers can understand without consulting other articles. Details regarding origin and insertion should be clearly described. Rombach et al. (2014)
- Line 303: This percentage (approximately 70%) is considered normal, but such a finding is not mentioned in English or non-English anatomy references and seems unusual:
Replication of the C7 lateral arterial foramen was observed in 13/19 horses
- The unilateral and bilateral conditions should be clearly specified, and an actual image should be provided.
- Line 311: What is meant by deeper?
- Lines 314–316: If there are two foramina, are two arteries seen? Does only this structure pass through this foramen?
- Lines 317–329 and 330–331: Corresponding anatomical images should be added.
- Lines 225 and 331: Mentioning other authors’ names in the Results section is not standard and should be revised.
- Lines 334–335: Vertebrae in the figures should be labeled, and the transverse process should be indicated.
- Figure 4: The condition of the C6 transverse process should be shown, and relevant processes labeled.
Discussion:
- One of the main goals of this article is to provide a radiographic protocol for identifying the absence of part of the transverse process, but it has not been compared with the findings of other studies.
- Lines 391–393: The sentence is unclear and should be revised. What is meant by the cranial portion of the muscle? Muscle categorization is not correct and should be revised.
- A table should be included comparing the presence or absence of unilateral or bilateral C6 transverse processes in this study with previously published studies to show prevalence in horses of different breeds and sexes.
- Regarding the presence of a foramen in C7, results should be compared with published studies.
Author Response
Reviewer 1 - Open Review
We thank the reviewer for the overall assessment of the manuscript and providing valuable insight in all sections. These revisions have improved consistency and contextual interpretation of the findings.
Unfortunately, there appeared to be line jumps and we were not always unable to clarify the comment in relation to our manuscript, even so, to the best of our knowledge, we have addressed and revised most of the manuscript according to the suggestions in red.
Comments and Suggestions for Authors
One of the main flaw of the manuscript:
Considering the study below, what is the novelty of the current authors’ findings? Because in terms of both radiographic technique and the correlation between radiographic images and vertebral anatomy, although the authors described the anatomy of the muscle and the C7 foramen, they did so without providing actual images.
Gee, C., Small, A., Shorter, K., & Brown, W. Y. (2020). A Radiographic Technique for Assessment of Morphologic Variations of the Equine Caudal Cervical Spine. Animals, 10(4), 667. https://doi.org/10.3390/ani10040667
Response: The techniques are identical; however, in this study the reading of the images provides new guidelines that isolates a specific grade 4 aplasia of C6 by identifying the relevant bony landmarks to this grade. Gee et al (2020) does not discuss grades nor the correlation to C7 transposition or associative neck pain as these studies came later. The strength of this study lies in the isolation of a C6 grade 4 and the strong correlation in transposition to C7, where coinciding neck pain is commonly reported. Thus, indicating further diagnostic imaging of C7 is necessary with the possible inclusion of the 1st/2nd sternal ribs thereafter. In some cases, the field imaging can be difficult and to further benefit the outcome for both horse/owner/trainer/rider, this C6 grade 4 supports the practitioner’s suggestion for further investigations, especially as 19/20 horses in this study transposed to C7.
A previous study did provide actual images of the longus colli variation (May-Davis and Walker 2015), however, a common flaw reported with this study was that the actual images were difficult to interpret. Hence, considering reported neck pain in association with C6 aplasia and C7 transposition, the authors felt it would be prudent to revisit the muscle morphology should the clinical signs of neck pain be relevant to altered muscle morphology and the potential of biomechanical strain due to such variations. Especially in light of recent surgical procedures in these cases where the variable morphology of the musculature, blood vessels and neural pathways are not yet fully reported for anatomical clarity.
- The title is very long and should be shortened and made understandable for a general audience.
Response: This has been adjusted
- The title should definitely include transverse process.
Response: Could you please explain further as in this study the transverse process is a bony landmark indicator only and the caudal lamina ventralis is the radiographic focus of the study?
- Caudal should be removed, and the scientific name should not be italicized.
Response: Could you please explain further as in this study the caudal lamina ventralis is the radiographic focus of the study? The italic application of the scientific name has been removed.
- There is no need to mention Grade 4.
Response: Could you please explain further as in this study the Grade 4 distinguishes the aplasia of the caudal lamina ventralis from other studies and aids in the focus of the study?
Abstract:
- Should be revised in a simple format according to the journal’s guidelines.
Response: Both the ‘Simple Summary’ and ‘Abstract’ have been revised.
- The methods should be specifically described (animal, number, breed, and methods studied).
Response: These have been included.
Introduction and Aim:
- A brief description of cervical vertebrae, with emphasis on transverse processes, and specifically C6 in horses, should be included.
Response: Description placed in Materials and Methodology Figure 2 and 3.
- Line 94: What is meant by tracheal ridge?
Response: Rewritten to describe location on the dorsal ridge line of the trachea. Line 93
- According to lines 100–101, it seems that the intention was to provide a radiographic protocol, but no specific imaging protocol was provided, and the imaging angle is similar to the study by Gee et al.
Gee, C., Small, A., Shorter, K., & Brown, W. Y. (2020). A Radiographic Technique for Assessment of Morphologic Variations of the Equine Caudal Cervical Spine. Animals, 10(4), 667. https://doi.org/10.3390/ani10040667
Response: Thank you for pointing this out – the focus of this study is to build on the protocols by Gee et al (2020) and this sentence has been reworded accordingly to highlight the need to isolate the relevant bony landmarks to determine a grade 4 aplasia.
- Lines 107–108 mention differences in arterial blood flow to the brain, but the reference used is unrelated, and the page number is incorrect.
Response: This sentence has been removed.
Lines 108–109: Considering these points, can such a cervical vertebra anomaly in horses be detected by palpation? Is it normally possible to palpate this process?
Response: The palpation of this region is very subjective between practitioners, and horses. Often the depth of musculature can be an issue, location of the shoulder in relation to the caudal cervical vertebrae and the muscle tension in the region can all impact upon the ability to accurately decide conclusively whether the anomaly exists. Also, the placement of other structures such as the trachea and oesophagus needs to be taken into consideration.
Materials and Methods:
- Anatomical terminology should be updated according to the latest NAV version.
Response: This has now been revised and the latest NAV for anatomical terminology has been referenced [25]. Line 121
- The method of euthanasia of the horses should be briefly described.
- Response: This has now been described Lines 146 and 177
- Preparation of the vertebrae should be briefly described.
Response: This has been described towards the end of methods.
- Age determination should be described.
Response: Originally, this information was detailed in Supplementary Table 1 with reasons for euthanasia. Now this has been moved to the main text and is labelled Table1.
- Details about the horses: breed, age, male/female should be categorized and specified.
Response: Originally, this information was detailed in Supplementary Table 1 with reasons for euthanasia. Now this has been moved to the main text Table 1.
- An image showing the positioning of the X-ray tube relative to the horse’s neck for C6 imaging should be provided.
Response: This has now been provided (Figure 1) and adapted from Gee et al. [16].
- Imaging details should be specified, e.g., film focal distance, etc.
- Response: This has now been provided (Figure 1) and adapted from Gee et al. [16].
Results:
- In all images, the cranial and dorsal anatomical directions of the vertebra and radiograph should be shown on the image.
Response: The cranial directional arrow has been provided in all images; however, in the radiographs the dorsal anatomical direction has been substituted with noting the trachea (as per Reviewer 2s request). Hopefully, this will provide directional clarity.
- Lines 391–392: The sentence is unclear and should be revised.
- Lines 393–394: What is meant by cranial?
Response: There seems to have been a misplacement between the text and line numbers. According to our manuscript - Lines 391–392: and Lines 393–394: are located after the Conclusion.
- Use a contrasting background for cervical vertebrae, and a scale should be included in the image.
Response: Due to dark pictures or contrasts within the vertebra, a white background was determined as the best option due to images such as R7, R28, R29, R38 and A4 being less favourable with a dark background. This was then kept throughout the manuscript for continuity. With regard to the scale, unfortunately not all the bones are in our possession. However, this will be a consideration in future research and thank you for making this point.
- Table and figure titles should be complete so that information can be obtained without referring to the text. For example, the type of animal should be specified.
Response: Could you please elaborate – are you requesting additions to the allotted identification code with details per animal in the captions, e.g. R7 – PRE 14-year-old male?
Just to clarify, the Supp. Table 2 has now been included in the main text to aid in recognition of animals with specific C6 aCLV4 definition – Unilateral (left or right, or bilateral).
- A lateral view of the bone and lateral radiograph of C6 should also be provided to give readers a better understanding of vertebral differences. The details of C6, especially the transverse process, should be fully labeled and marked.
Response: We only compared the lateral 30° dorsal-ventral oblique view in this study. At present, we don’t have normal C6 lateral views that we can compare to corresponding morphology. Hopefully the new Figure 2 and revised Figure 3 will meet with your approval.
- Lines 156 and 198: What is meant by lateral arterial foramen?
Response: This terminology has now been changed to foramen vertebrale laterale according to NAV [25].
- Line 168: The description should be anatomically revised. The question arises: does this situation normally exist in C5, C4, and C3?
Response: To date the morphology of all the cervical vertebrae have been relatively static during the process of evolution. According to the literature, the anomalous C6 and C7 has only been a recent event 300 years or so. As for the terminology, this has been difficult to engage anatomical correctness due to the description not being readily available in new or old anatomy books. Happy to read suggestions on correct terminology of where the caudal aspect of the transverse process curves and blends into the vertebral body.
- Line 168: The following description needs to be corrected from an anatomical perspective. Moreover, the question arises whether such a condition does not naturally occur in vertebrae C5, C4, and C3.
“the connection between the caudal curvature of the transverse process to the vertebral bod”
Response: I believe the response above might answer this comment.
- Differences between male and female findings should be clearly reported.
Response: This is now reported in the Materials and Methods and in the Results. Tables 1 and 3.
- The connection between the caudal curvature of the transverse process and the vertebral body:
Response: I think this is a continuation from above?
- Line 205: The description below is not anatomically scientific and should be revised, as in the previous comment:
Unification of the caudal transverse process with the vertebral bod
Response: Replaced with ‘Curvature of the caudal transverse process’. Lack of anatomical descripts in old and new anatomy books is making this description difficult.
- Line 208: Are the radiographs in this section similar in angle to figure 2 or figure 1? It does not appear so.
- Response: The radiographs in Figure 4 (aplastic C6) are the same radiographic orientation as Figure 3 where C6 is normal. This provides a comparison between a normal C6 and one with an aplastic caudal lamina ventralis.
- Table 1: What does the red arrow indicate?
Response: The red arrows indicate the caudal curvature of the transverse process and this description has been added where necessary to clarify.
- In Table 1, the trachea should be labeled in the radiographs.
Response: This has now been indicated with a white asterisk with the addition of mentioning that it lies along the ventral line of the cervical vertebrae.
- Line 275, Figure 3: The actual anatomical image should also be shown since the cadavers were available and dissected.
Response: Unfortunately, these images are not available.
- Regarding the schematic images of the longus colli muscle, as shown in the authors’ figures, can it be concluded that the muscle only attaches to the ventral surface of the cervical vertebrae? This is not correct; lateral views and related explanations should also be shown. The main difference is likely visible in this view.
Response: Unfortunately, lateral views were not imaged as the study evolved with only the ventral view in mind.
- Table 1: How can you confirm that the vertebral bones presented belong to C6 and not C3, C4, or C5, considering that the only distinguishing feature is the specific process found in C6? It is necessary to show complete images of the cranial and caudal of the vertebra. This issue is also observed in the radiographs
Response: Aside from C1, C5 demonstrates the widest transverse processes, and this is identified with palpation prior to radiographic imaging. This way caudal to the C5 TPs, is the articulation from C5 to C6. Hence, in most cases a radio dense marker is placed above the C5 TPs for clarification as per Gee et al. [16] describes. There are a number of C6 distinguishable features differentiating it from the more cranial vertebrae – it’s shorter and narrower than C5, and it presents a larger dorsal spinous process that is situated more cranial along the sagittal line. Unfortunately, further imaging is impossible, and during the process of diagnosing, owners are present and in some cases, finances are limited to image further along the cervical spine.
- In Table 1, a ventral view of C6 should also be shown, as the absence of the transverse process is better visualized from this view.
Response: The aim of the study is to identify C6 aCLV4 in the live horse, and a ventral view cannot be imaged with a portable machine in the field.
- Lines 185–201: Images corresponding to each finding should be included.
Response: There may have been a line jump and wondered if you are referring to incidental finds? If so, we don’t have images, the incidental findings are reported just to indicate further variations for future practitioners and surgeons to consider when examining a patient.
- Line 198: An image should be provided, especially for C7.
Response: I suspect another line jump, as line 198 is discussing C6 radiographic images.
- Lines 225–272: Descriptions of the muscle should be written clearly so that readers can understand without consulting other articles. Details regarding origin and insertion should be clearly described. Rombach et al. (2014)
Response: This has now been described in Results – 3.2 Longus colli muscle - First paragraph
- Line 303: This percentage (approximately 70%) is considered normal, but such a finding is not mentioned in English or non-English anatomy references and seems unusual:
Replication of the C7 lateral arterial foramen was observed in 13/19 horses
Response: This was reported in May-Davis et al. [22] and it was only evident when the C6 aplastic caudal lamina ventralis transposed from C6 to the ventral surface of C7. Both studies report 68% (Study 1 - 30/44 [22]) and this study (13/19).
- The unilateral and bilateral conditions should be clearly specified, and an actual image should be provided.
Response: These images and descriptions have been replicated in multiple studies. With the focus on one specific grade (4), it was imperative to stay specific without too many distractions. Duplication of other studies results has already mentioned as an issue in this study, so we have tried to limit the distractions from the main focus.
- Line 311: What is meant by deeper?
Response: There is definitely a line jump as this is mentioned in line 413. The word ‘deeper’ has been removed.
- Lines 314–316: If there are two foramina, are two arteries seen? Does only this structure pass through this foramen?
Response: In the presence of 2 foramina (left and right), two arteries are seen passing through – left and right. Line 323.
- Lines 317–329 and 330–331: Corresponding anatomical images should be added.
Response: these lines are located in discussion. There may have been a line jump and wondered if you are referring to incidental finds? If so, we don’t have images, the incidental findings are reported just to indicate further variations for future equine practitioners and surgeons to consider.
- Lines 225 and 331: Mentioning other authors’ names in the Results section is not standard and should be revised.
Response: These have been removed.
- Lines 334–335: Vertebrae in the figures should be labeled, and the transverse process should be indicated.
Response: Yes they are labelled re left column. The transverse process is now identified.
- Figure 4: The condition of the C6 transverse process should be shown, and relevant processes labeled.
Response: C7 dorsal spinous process, lamina ventralis and the transverse process have been added.
Discussion:
- One of the main goals of this article is to provide a radiographic protocol for identifying the absence of part of the transverse process, but it has not been compared with the findings of other studies.
Response: There are only two other studies that discuss radiographic protocols for the C6 aCLV, and neither describe how to identify the C6 aCLV4. This grade 4 is the main correlating factor in the transposition of the lamina ventralis from C6 to C7, where neck pain is commonly associated. Ros et al. [19], describes techniques without corresponding the radiographic findings to gross morphology. Gee et al. [16] describes radiographic protocols to gross morphology with no grading or correlation to C7 transposition. This was mentioned in the Introduction as to why the current study is relevant. In addition, the inclusion of associative morphological variations is trying to aid veterinary practitioners in understanding a more complete picture of the underlying structures that are dependent on these C6 aCLV4 cases, which the latter is identifiable by radiographs.
- Lines 391–393: The sentence is unclear and should be revised. What is meant by the cranial portion of the muscle? Muscle categorization is not correct and should be revised.
Response: these lines are located after the conclusion. I think you might be referring to this – ‘This also applies to the cranial longus colli bundles whose function is to stabilize and shape individual intervertebral joints’. If so, Rombach et al. [26], describes the cranial longus colli as those muscle bundles cranial to C6.
- A table should be included comparing the presence or absence of unilateral or bilateral C6 transverse processes in this study with previously published studies to show prevalence in horses of different breeds and sexes.
- Response: Table 3 (previously Supplementary Table 2) is now included in the main text.
- Regarding the presence of a foramen in C7, results should be compared with published studies. Lines 406-414
Response: This has now been described in the discussion. Line 362 and 406-415.
Reviewer 2 Report
Comments and Suggestions for Authorsdear authors the paper study a very hot topic for equine clinicans; this is to me an anatomical study while you many times mention throughout the paper clinical relevance and relation to clinical condition of the horse without describing the clinical conditions of the hjorses included in the study. In the aim of the study you introduced the possibility to correlate radiographic informations to possible clinical relevance but no clinical data of your patients were avaible for the reader so i would not point my attention to clinical conditions if you do not expand them. i think that M&M should be clearer i did not understand what was the reason for euthanasia of the horses and their clinical condition related to neck pain. Also the discussion underline several time clinical condition and informations already well described thsat to me are redundant. In my opinion the study is interesting but as an anatomical study so i think an extensive review is needed starting from a more clear title and excluding a clinical cut that to me is not appropriate
below you find some specific comments:
line 49-60: to me this part is off topic, i would not rely on social media contents in a scientific paper, and also this do not add anything important to the paper
line 105- 108: i cannot associate what you write with the results of this study please explain better or remove
line108: what is the cause of variation of blood flow in the brain? i can't understand from the text
113: i would not give importance to the discussion in social media, what is important to me is to clarify this topic in the scientific community
line 135: the concept of differrential examination is not clear, please expand to explain better to the reader
line 187 the radiographic finding is not a suspect, but a definitive diagnosis
line189-191 revealed what?
line 337-348: these informations are already known i would not underline them as findings of the study
Author Response
Reviewer 2 - Open Review
We thank the reviewer for the overall assessment of the manuscript and providing valuable insight through revisions that improved the consistency and contextual interpretation of the findings.
Unfortunately, there appeared to be line jumps and we were not always unable to clarify the comment in relation to our manuscript, even so, to the best of our knowledge, we have addressed and revised most of the manuscript according to the suggestions in red.
Comments and Suggestions for Authors
dear authors the paper study a very hot topic for equine clinicans; this is to me an anatomical study while you many times mention throughout the paper clinical relevance and relation to clinical condition of the horse without describing the clinical conditions of the hjorses included in the study.
Response: Thank you for pointing this out. The clinical presentation of each horse and reasons for euthanasia was described in the Supplementary Tables, including full osseous morphological variations. We have now added these to the main text as a permanent fixture to accompany the text and altered the text accordingly for clarification. Table 1
In the aim of the study you introduced the possibility to correlate radiographic informations to possible clinical relevance but no clinical data of your patients were avaible for the reader so i would not point my attention to clinical conditions if you do not expand them.
Response: The clinical presentation of each horse and reasons for euthanasia was described in the Supplementary Tables. The caudal neck radiographs were part of the clinical work up, but not all could be attributed to the clinical presentations. This has now been rectified in the manuscript. Table 1
i think that M&M should be clearer i did not understand what was the reason for euthanasia of the horses and their clinical condition related to neck pain. Also the discussion underline several time clinical condition and informations already well described thsat to me are redundant. In my opinion the study is interesting but as an anatomical study so i think an extensive review is needed starting from a more clear title and excluding a clinical cut that to me is not appropriate
Response: Hopefully the new revisions with table allocation etc., with the clinical revisions throughout are indicative of the pre mortem findings. The title has been shortened.
below you find some specific comments:
line 49-60: to me this part is off topic, i would not rely on social media contents in a scientific paper, and also this do not add anything important to the paper
Response: The social media content in the opening paragraph is trying to address the concerns practicing veterinarians are experiencing in the field regarding this topic. The level of misinformation on social media is of great concern and here we are trying to provide an answer by showing veterinarians where their input can impact more horse owners by providing science-based guidance. Hopefully our revisions in this area meet with your approval.
line 105- 108: i cannot associate what you write with the results of this study please explain better or remove
Response: Removed
line108: what is the cause of variation of blood flow in the brain? i can't understand from the text
Response: Removed
113: i would not give importance to the discussion in social media, what is important to me is to clarify this topic in the scientific community
Response: Even though the relevance of the scientific community is first to provide rigorous scientific debate and clarification, social media does not hold to these parameters. Recent published research has urged veterinarians to make a positive impact on social media by providing science-based guidance to help limit the growing percentage of misinformation to pet owners. We hope to support these findings by disseminating our findings through both channels and limit the misinformation surrounding the C6 aCLV4 malformation.
Even so, the last sentence in the Introduction has been removed, leaving only the opening paragraph discussing social media.
line 135: the concept of differrential examination is not clear, please expand to explain better to the reader
Response: Here a bracket explanation provides further clarification – ‘After a differential examination (a systematic process to identify a specific disease or condition from a lift of possibilities that share similar symptoms) ………….. Line 132
line 187 the radiographic finding is not a suspect, but a definitive diagnosis
Response: Thank you – suspect has been removed.
line189-191 revealed what?
Response: Thank you - this sentence has been altered for clarity.
line 337-348: these informations are already known i would not underline them as findings of the study
Response: I fear there might have been a line jump, if your are referring to the 3rd last paragraph in the discussion, then we are postulating and using the findings of others to support and strengthen our position on the subject.
Reviewer 3 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsThis article provides radiographic protocols for diagnosing C6 aCVL4 in horses and outlines the relevant CVL bony landmarks. The radiographic images were then verified by comparing them to the corresponding gross morphology, which helped establish the efficacy of these protocols. In terms of results, the article presents the radiographic features of C6 aCVL4 and corresponding gross morphology, highlighting changes in surrounding structures such as the longus colli muscle and vertebral artery. The discussion section addresses potential risk factors for C6 aCVL4 and its impact on muscles and blood vessels. However, it lacks a discussion on the practical clinical significance of the diagnostic method established in this study for confirming C6 aCVL4.
Title:
- The title is overly long and detailed. Please condense it to focus on the primary objective. (Line 1-5)
Abstract:
- The methods (radiographic protocol) and results (CVL absent, 20 horses identified, anatomical variations) are mixed, making the abstract difficult to follow. (Line32-41)
Keywords:
- Consider condensing highly similar terms (e.g., Aplasia/Aplastic) for brevity. (Line 44)
Introduction:
- The opening paragraph is heavily focused on social media and anecdotal evidence, but the central scientific rationale is not presented in a concise or progressive manner. (Line 49-60)
- Check the citation style for consistency. For instance, sometimes the author is mentioned with the year (e.g., “Henderson et al (2024)”), while other times only the bracketed reference is used. Maintain a uniform citation style throughout the manuscript. (Line 66)
- The ultimate goal of the study, stated in the final sentence dilutes the focus on the primary clinical and anatomical objectives. Please remove the subjective social media aim and reference [28] from the objectives to strengthen the scientific purpose. (Line 111-114)
Materials and Methods:
- Section 2.3 states horses were selected if they had a “suspect C6 aCVL4” and required euthanasia. Please clarify how this “suspicion” was established prior to their inclusion in the study. (Line 132-133)
- The manuscript must explicitly state the sedation and specific radiographic equipment (model, manufacturer) used for the A prefix horses. It is insufficient to direct the reader to reference [12] for these essential methodological details. (Line 137)
- In Section 2.3, please provide the manufacturer and location (City, State/Country) for the sedation drugs (Butorphanol, Detomidine) used in the 'R' prefix group to ensure full reproducibility. (Line 138-139)
- Please correct the typographical error (double period) at the end of the Figure 2 caption. (Line 183)
Results:
- Move methodological limitations (e.g., “clarity of C7 not apparent in all radiographs”) to the paragraph discussing the limitations. (Line 192)
- Terms such as “greatly altered” lack measurements. Quantitative data are essential for credibility. (Line 264,271)
- “Figure 4” in section 3.4 should be “Figure 5”. (Line 331)
Discussion:
- Please include information on the incidence of C6 aCVL4 in horses in the discussion section.
- After using the radiographic protocol presented in this article for diagnostic assistance, are there any corresponding treatment methods available now? What radiographic findings would lead veterinarians and horse owners to choose euthanasia for affected horses?
- The explicit presentation of demographic ratios and counts (e.g., male cases 13/20, height ratios 13:2:0) belongs in the Results section (Section 3). Please move these data points to the Results section. (Line 349,367)
- A critical limitation is the use of two different radiographic machines and sedation protocols between the A and R horse groups, which must be explicitly mentioned and discussed in the paragraph discussing the limitations regarding its potential impact on image consistency. (Line 409-416)
Conclusion:
- Specific numerical results (e.g., “C7(19/20)” “13/19 replicating the arterial foramen”) should be omittedfrom the Conclusions. (Line 421)
Author Response
Reviewer 3 - Open Review
We thank the reviewer for the overall assessment of the manuscript and providing valuable insight through suggesting revisions that improved the consistency and contextual interpretation of the findings.
Hopefully, we have addressed and revised in red most of the manuscript according to the suggestions.
Comments and Suggestions for Authors
This article provides radiographic protocols for diagnosing C6 aCVL4 in horses and outlines the relevant CVL bony landmarks. The radiographic images were then verified by comparing them to the corresponding gross morphology, which helped establish the efficacy of these protocols. In terms of results, the article presents the radiographic features of C6 aCVL4 and corresponding gross morphology, highlighting changes in surrounding structures such as the longus colli muscle and vertebral artery. The discussion section addresses potential risk factors for C6 aCVL4 and its impact on muscles and blood vessels. However, it lacks a discussion on the practical clinical significance of the diagnostic method established in this study for confirming C6 aCVL4.
Response: Hopefully this has been addressed with revisions in the Simple Summary, Abstract, Introduction and Discussion.
Title:
- The title is overly long and detailed. Please condense it to focus on the primary objective. (Line 1-5)
Response: The title has been adjusted accordingly.
Abstract:
- The methods (radiographic protocol) and results (CVL absent, 20 horses identified, anatomical variations) are mixed, making the abstract difficult to follow. (Line32-41)
Response: The Abstract has been revised as per the recommendations.
Keywords:
- Consider condensing highly similar terms (e.g., Aplasia/Aplastic) for brevity. (Line 44)
Response: Thank you for this pointer, and the appropriate adjustments have been made.
Introduction:
- The opening paragraph is heavily focused on social media and anecdotal evidence, but the central scientific rationale is not presented in a concise or progressive manner. (Line 49-60)
Response: The social media content in the opening paragraph is trying to address the concerns practicing veterinarians are experiencing in the field regarding this topic. The level of misinformation on social media is of great concern and here we are trying to provide an answer by showing veterinarians where their input can impact more horse owners by providing science-based guidance. Hopefully our revisions in this area meet with your approval.
Other concerns in this area is the relevance of the scientific community on social media. When change or new ideas are presented, scientists rigorously debate and clarify the facts based on repetitive data, social media does not hold to these parameters. Recently published research has urged veterinarians to make a positive impact on social media by providing science-based guidance to help limit the growing percentage of misinformation to pet owners. We hope to support these findings by disseminating our findings through both channels and limit the misinformation surrounding the C6 aCLV4 malformation.
However, in keeping with the above comments, we have adjusted the first paragraph and removed the final sentence in the Introduction.
- Check the citation style for consistency. For instance, sometimes the author is mentioned with the year (e.g., “Henderson et al (2024)”), while other times only the bracketed reference is used. Maintain a uniform citation style throughout the manuscript. (Line 66)
Response: Excellent – thank you for pointing this out.
- The ultimate goal of the study, stated in the final sentence dilutes the focus on the primary clinical and anatomical objectives. Please remove the subjective social media aim and reference [28] from the objectives to strengthen the scientific purpose. (Line 111-114)
Response: This sentence has been removed.
Materials and Methods:
- Section 2.3 states horses were selected if they had a “suspect C6 aCVL4” and required euthanasia. Please clarify how this “suspicion” was established prior to their inclusion in the study. (Line 132-133)
Response: Originally, reasons for euthanasia were identified in Supplementary Table 1. Now this has been moved to the main text and labelled Table 1. During the differential diagnosis the caudal cervical vertebrae were examined via radiographs.
- The manuscript must explicitly state the sedation and specific radiographic equipment (model, manufacturer) used for the A prefix horses. It is insufficient to direct the reader to reference [12] for these essential methodological details. (Line 137)
Response: Thank you for pointing this out. This has now been corrected.
- In Section 2.3, please provide the manufacturer and location (City, State/Country) for the sedation drugs (Butorphanol, Detomidine) used in the 'R' prefix group to ensure full reproducibility. (Line 138-139)
Response: These additions have now been included.
- Please correct the typographical error (double period) at the end of the Figure 2 caption. (Line 183)
Response: Thank you for pointing this out. This has now been corrected. In all honesty, I could not find the double period and suspect the autocorrect may have intervened before I could address the task.
Results:
- Move methodological limitations (e.g., “clarity of C7 not apparent in all radiographs”) to the paragraph discussing the limitations. (Line 192)
Response: The statement has been moved.
- Terms such as “greatly altered” lack measurements. Quantitative data are essential for credibility. (Line 264,271)
Response: The term ‘greatly’ has been removed.
- “Figure 4” in section 3.4 should be “Figure 5”. (Line 331)
Response: Thank you for pointing out this error. It has been corrected.
Discussion:
- Please include information on the incidence of C6 aCVL4 in horses in the discussion section.
Response: Do you mean a comparison between the number of C6 aCLV horses’ and those in that sample with C6 aCLV4? If so, this was not monitored in this study as it has already been reported by May-Davis et al. [22].
- After using the radiographic protocol presented in this article for diagnostic assistance, are there any corresponding treatment methods available now? What radiographic findings would lead veterinarians and horse owners to choose euthanasia for affected horses?
Response: Table 1 (previously Supplementary Table 1) describes the reason for euthanasia, and it is hard to correlate which is C6 aCLV4 related/symptomatic as there were a huge number of other associative deviations also seen without collecting histopatholgy of nerves, spinal cord datas or even potential dura mater compression etc.
- The explicit presentation of demographic ratios and counts (e.g., male cases 13/20, height ratios 13:2:0) belongs in the Results section (Section 3). Please move these data points to the Results section. (Line 349,367)
Response: This has been removed.
- A critical limitation is the use of two different radiographic machines and sedation protocols between the A and R horse groups, which must be explicitly mentioned and discussed in the paragraph discussing the limitations regarding its potential impact on image consistency. (Line 409-416)
Response: Thank you this has now been included.
Conclusion:
- Specific numerical results (e.g., “C7(19/20)” “13/19 replicating the arterial foramen”) should be omittedfrom the Conclusions. (Line 421)
Response: Removed.
Round 2
Reviewer 1 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsAlthough the authors have made revisions, the following issues still remain
- Simple summery:
The simple abstract has not been written according to the journal format, both in terms of content and word count, and therefore requires revision. - Keywords:
The keywords have not been presented according to the journal’s required format and need to be corrected. - Introduction:
I still believe that it is necessary to include a brief description of the transverse process of the cervical vertebrae, and ultimately the sixth cervical vertebra, at the beginning of this section. - Lines 105–106:
The lamina ventralis is not normally palpable according to available anatomy textbooks, and only the dorsal transverse process of this vertebra is palpable. Therefore, this part of the text needs to be corrected. Moreover, the authors’ response to the reviewer’s comment on this issue was not sufficiently convincing. - NAV Terminology:
Although it is stated in the cover letter that the terminology follows the Nomina Anatomica Veterinaria (NAV), the term used in line 121 requires correction. - Lines 146–147:
More explanation should be provided in this section, and the relevant reference must be added. - Lines 161–166 (Figures 2 and 3):
Regarding the transverse process of the sixth cervical vertebra, it appears that the authors have considered the transverse process separately from the lamina ventralis. Is the lamina ventralis not part of the transverse process? - Figure 3:
The term Foramen vertebrale laterale: is incorrect and should be corrected throughout the entire text. This term needs correction. - Reference:
Getty, R. (1975). Sisson and Grossman’s The Anatomy of the Domestic Animals (5th ed.). Philadelphia, PA: W.B. Saunders Company. - Reference:
Nickel, R., Schummer, A., & Seiferle, E. (1973). The Anatomy of the Domestic Animals. Volume I: The Locomotor System. Berlin & Hamburg: Paul Parey. - Reference:
Barone, R. (1997). Anatomie comparée des mammifères domestiques. Tome 1. Paris, France: Vigot Frères. - Figure Titles:
The name of the animal should be included in the figure titles, as each figure title must be self-explanatory on its own. - Lines 146 and 160:
These lines are repetitive and both refer to animal euthanasia; therefore, one of them should be removed or merged. - Line 173:
The type of view should be specified (bone view). - Description of “Curvature of the caudal transverse process”:
Such a description has not been reported for the cervical vertebrae of domestic animals in any of the standard anatomy references. Images from authoritative anatomy textbooks show that this feature is present in all cervical vertebrae from C3 to C7, even in the sixth cervical vertebra, whether with or without the lamina ventralis.
Therefore, this term should be removed from the text, and only the absence of the caudal lamina ventralis should be mentioned.
(Based on images from the following references: Getty, Nickel, and Barone.) - Line 260 – Longus colli muscle:
According to standard veterinary anatomy textbooks, the longus colli muscle does not attach only to the ventral surface of the cervical vertebrae, but also to the lateral surface that includes the transverse process. Therefore, this point must be revised in both the text and the figures. - Line 318 – Presence of a foramen in C7:
It is essential to provide clear anatomical and radiological images demonstrating the presence of a foramen in the seventh cervical vertebra. Based on more than 20 years of experience teaching head and neck anatomy, I have never encountered such a foramen in this vertebra. Moreover, the reported frequency of 70% for this foramen is highly unusual and requires strong supporting evidence.
In addition, since a vertebral nerve passes through this foramen, the condition of this nerve in relation to the described anatomical variations must be clearly explained. - Line 406:
This finding should be compared with the available standard veterinary anatomy textbooks listed above. - Study Limitations:
The small sample size must be explicitly stated as a limitation of the study.
Author Response
Please refer to attachment.
Author Response File:
Author Response.pdf
Reviewer 2 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsDear authors, your paper has improved following revisions but i still have some concerns maybe also because i can't see table and figures on the paper or on the supplementary materials. Materials and methods are better but still not clear to the reader, maybe also because there are too many sub sections that make it heavy for the reader; you still mention sometimes clinical relevance of your findings but i cannot link the findings to clinical features because reading the paper i do not find any clinical information on the horses. the reason for euthanasia is not clear yet. below you find detailed comments
line 125: on M&M you describe the study design, the number of horses included is a result section's data
line 132-136: i did not understand the meaning of this sentence
line 146-147: if you mention euthanasia methods you have to describe the protoloc better with doses premedication eventual induction and so on
line 181-182: you already mentioned this before, or you delete here or before
line 201: i would move this sentence at the beginning of the Materials section
line 275-279: i do not think that this case with unilateral C6 aCLV4 met the inclusion criteria if you did not fully examined the longus colli and so it sholud be excluded from the study in my opinion
line 181-182: you already mention this sentence
line 339-348: i do not know if this section is important for the study and add something to it, i would think to remove it
line375-377: i do not know how you get to this point from your study, reading the study i cannot make this point;
Author Response
Please refer to attachment.
Author Response File:
Author Response.pdf
Round 3
Reviewer 1 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsThe authors have made commendable efforts to improve the manuscript.
Author Response
Please refer the attachment.
Author Response File:
Author Response.pdf
Reviewer 2 Report
Comments and Suggestions for Authorsthe paper has improved only few notes to be addressed below
line 188-192: this paragraph is results no materials
line 212: please mention which sedation you used and the dosage
Author Response
Please refer the attachment.
Author Response File:
Author Response.pdf