Skip to Content
LawsLaws
  • Article
  • Open Access

18 November 2026

20 Pages

Domestic Courts as Functional Substitutes for WTO Discipline: Learning Resources, Inc. v. Trump and the IEEPA Tariffs

,
,
,
,
and
1
College of Law, Ajman University, Ajman, United Arab Emirates
2
Université de la Formation Continue (UFC), Algiers, Algeria
3
Canadian University of Dubai, Dubai, United Arab Emirates
4
Mohamed Bin Zayed University for Humanities, Abu Dhabi, United Arab Emirates

Abstract

On 20 February 2026, the Supreme Court held in Learning Resources, Inc. v. Trump that the International Emergency Economic Powers Act confers no power to impose tariffs, voiding the “reciprocal” and drug-trafficking duties levied against China, Canada, Mexico and dozens of other trading partners. This article reads the decision against a multilateral order that could not discipline those same measures: with the Appellate Body inquorate and the United States free to appeal adverse reports into the void, duties widely regarded as inconsistent with Articles I and II of the GATT escaped scrutiny in Geneva yet fell in Washington, struck down not for any breach of WTO law but on the domestic statutory ground that IEEPA, read against the Constitution’s allocation of the taxing power to Congress, conferred no tariff authority. The separation of powers review thus functioned as a substitute for the absent international check, a substitution that is partial, contingent and indifferent to multilateral legality. Because the judgment leaves untouched Sections 122, 232 and 301, the substitute offers reformers only a design template, not a durable discipline, and offers other members a check they can neither invoke nor rely upon. The episode shows what follows when a domestic constitution, not the institution designed for the task, supplies the binding limit on unilateral protectionism. The trading system, in short, gains episodic reprieves from domestic constitutionalism, but not durable discipline.

1. Introduction

Two courtrooms had jurisdiction, in the loosest sense of that word, over the tariff programme that the United States unveiled in the first months of 2025. One sat in Geneva, was created for exactly this purpose, and could do nothing. The other sat in Washington, owed no duty whatever to the trading system, and ended the programme in a single stroke. That inversion is the subject of this article.
The facts can be stated briefly, because the Supreme Court itself stated them with unusual precision. Invoking the International Emergency Economic Powers Act (IEEPA), 50 U.S.C. § 1701 et seq.(the U.S. federal law that grants the President broad power to regulate economic and financial transactions during a declared national emergency), the President declared national emergencies concerning drug trafficking and persistent trade deficits and proceeded to tax imports on a scale without precedent in the statute’s half century of existence: a twenty-five per cent duty on most Canadian and Mexican goods, a ten per cent duty on most Chinese goods, and a “reciprocal” duty of at least ten per cent on all imports from all trading partners, with dozens of countries facing higher country-specific rates (Executive Orders 14193, 14194 and 14195 of 1 February 2025; Executive Order 14257 of 2 April 2025). China requested WTO consultations within days (WT/DS633/1); further requests concerning the reciprocal duties and the automobile duties followed in April (WT/DS638/1; WT/DS637/1). The commentary was close to unanimous that duties of this design, levied above bound rates and differentiated by origin, could not be reconciled with Articles I:1 and II:1 of the General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade (GATT) 1994. None of it mattered. The Appellate Body had been unable to sit since 11 December 2019; the United States had already shown, in the Section 232 litigation, that it would appeal adverse panel reports into the void; and it had told the Dispute Settlement Body in terms that it regarded the new duties as matters of national security not susceptible to review at all (WT/DS633/2 and 3). The multilateral check was formally available and practically inert.
The binding check arrived from an unexpected quarter. On 20 February 2026, in Learning Resources, Inc. v. Trump, 607 U.S. (2026), decided together with Trump v. V.O.S. Selections, Inc., the Supreme Court held by six votes to three that IEEPA does not authorise the President to impose tariffs. Chief Justice Roberts anchored the judgment in the constitutional allocation of the taxing power: Article I, Section 8 gives Congress alone the power to lay and collect duties, the power to impose tariffs is, in the words the Court borrowed from Gibbons v. Ogden, very clearly a branch of that power, and a statute permitting the President to “regulate . . . importation” during a declared emergency does not conceal within that quotidian verb a delegation of the legislature’s core fiscal prerogative (slip op. at 5–7, 14–16). The duties that Geneva could not touch were dead within a year of their promulgation, killed by a court whose reasoning had no occasion to refer to the treaty at all.
This article advances a specific claim about that sequence. The separation of powers review functioned, in this instance, as a substitute for the absent multilateral discipline, not by design or mandate but by performing its function: it reached the same measures, on the same timescale the Dispute Settlement Understanding (DSU) once promised, and produced the very outcome, withdrawal of the offending measure, that Article 3.7 of the DSU identifies as the system’s preferred remedy. But the substitution is imperfect in ways that matter enormously, and the article devotes its analytical core to three of them. The substitute is partial, because it polices the source of the power rather than the protectionism, leaving intact the express delegations, Sections 122, 232 and 301, to which the executive turned within hours of the judgment.
It is contingent, since it turns on a statutory ruling that is limited to IEEPA and can be overridden by ordinary legislation; its logic can extend to other tariff statutes only case by case, depending on the text and preconditions of each delegation. And it is indifferent to multilateral legality, since the logic of its remedy is restitutionary and domestic: it repays American importers and reaches trading partners only as a by-product, rather than securing compliance owed to them. The upshot, developed in Section 7, is that the trading system gains episodic reprieves from domestic constitutionalism, but not durable discipline.
The claim matters beyond the case. A generation of scholarship has asked whether the trading system can survive the loss of its enforcement arm (Hoekman and Mavroidis 2020; Wolff 2023; Mavroidis and Sapir 2021), and parallel literature has asked whether national courts can act as agents of international law (Schwartz 2015; Ginsburg 2009; Roberts 2011). Learning Resources sits at the junction of the two and fits comfortably in neither. The resilience debate looks for substitutes inside the trade regime, in arbitration under Article 25 of the DSU or in regional mechanisms, not inside the constitutional law of the member whose defection caused the crisis. The national courts literature presupposes judges who engage with international law, citing it, applying it, or at least orienting themselves toward it; the Learning Resources Court did none of these things. What the case presents is substitution without engagement, a convergence of outcome without any convergence of reasons, and the article argues that this configuration deserves to be recognised as a distinct phenomenon in the relationship between domestic public law and international economic order.
The argument proceeds in six steps. Section 2 sets out the method. Section 3 establishes the first premise, that the multilateral discipline had failed, by tracing the collapse of the appellate function, the practice of appealing into the void, and the fate of the 2025 tariffs in Geneva. Section 4 establishes the second premise, that a domestic discipline existed, by reconstructing the constitutional allocation of the tariff power and the statutory lattice through which Congress has delegated it. Section 5 dissects the judgment itself, because the substitute’s strengths and weaknesses are legible in its doctrinal anatomy. Section 6 develops the substitution thesis in full. Section 7 draws out the implications for the multilateral system, and Section 8 concludes.

2. Method

The article employs doctrinal analysis of two bodies of law read against one another: United States constitutional and administrative law on the one hand, and public international trade law on the other. The doctrinal work is supplemented by an institutional reading of the trade regime drawn from the international economic law literature, and the two components answer a single research question: how did the separation of powers review in Learning Resources come to function as a substitute for the WTO’s disabled enforcement discipline, and what limits follow from the substitute’s domestic constitutional grounding? The descriptive part of the answer occupies Section 3, Section 4 and Section 5, which reconstruct the failure of the multilateral check, the constitutional allocation of the tariff power, and the judgment itself. The normative and theory-building part occupies Section 6 and Section 7, which elaborate the category of the functional substitute, a category the literature on national courts and international law does not yet contain, and assess what the substitution is worth to the system that incidentally benefited from it. The doctrinal component rests on close engagement with the primary materials: the slip opinion in Learning Resources, including its concurrences and dissents; the decisions below, Learning Resources, Inc. v. Trump, 784 F. Supp. 3d 209 (D.D.C. 2025), and V.O.S. Selections, Inc. v. Trump, 149 F.4th 1312 (Fed. Cir. 2025) (en banc); the governing statutes and executive orders; and the WTO instruments and dispute records concerning the 2025 tariffs, principally the requests for consultations in DS633, DS637 and DS638, the United States’ responsive communications, and the panel jurisprudence on Article XXI of the GATT. The institutional component draws on the secondary literature on the WTO dispute settlement crisis, on American trade delegation, and on national courts as enforcers of international law, in order to situate the doctrinal findings within the debates they unsettle.
Two methodological choices deserve a word of explanation. First, the article treats the judgment not as an isolated episode of American constitutional and administrative law but as an event within the multilateral trading system, and it therefore reads the domestic and international materials against one another throughout, a juxtaposition that neither body of primary material invites on its own terms. Second, because the decision post-dates nearly all of the academic literature, the article draws, sparingly and only for matters of record, on primary documents issued in the weeks after the judgment, notably the executive order of 20 February 2026 revoking the IEEPA tariff orders and the proclamation of the same date imposing a temporary import surcharge under Section 122 of the Trade Act of 1974. No new empirical data were generated.
A word on the institutional reading and its sources. The reading is qualitative and historical-institutional rather than quantitative: it relies on the existing scholarship on WTO dispute settlement resilience and on documented member practice to situate the case, and it makes no claim to original empirical measurement of dispute settlement outcomes. That choice follows from the research question, which concerns the legal character of a substitution rather than its frequency; quantitative treatment of the post-2019 caseload exists elsewhere (Pahis 2024; Hopewell 2025) and is drawn upon rather than replicated. For the same reason the article cites, alongside the academic literature, a small number of policy and governmental documents, the USTR report of 2020, the Congressional Research Service account of IEEPA, the Peterson Institute policy brief, and a widely read essay on emergency powers (Goitein 2019). These are used as evidence of institutional positions and as background on the emergency powers framework, never as doctrinal authority; the doctrinal propositions in this article rest on the primary legal materials alone.
The method carries limits that should be stated at the outset rather than discovered at the end. The analysis rests on a single case in a single jurisdiction and on one episode in the history of WTO dispute settlement, and its evidence is doctrinal and qualitative throughout. The substitution thesis is analytical rather than empirically quantified: it reads systemic implications off one statutory judgment grounded in constitutional structure and the executive’s immediate response to it, and it does not test whether domestic invalidation deters future protectionist measures beyond documenting the migration to other statutory bases. The contingency assessment in Section 6.3 is, moreover, tied to the current composition and doctrine of the Supreme Court, both of which can change. Whether other trading powers possess an analogous substitutive capacity in their own constitutional or administrative law is a question the article poses but cannot answer within its design; the research directions gathered in the conclusion are addressed to precisely these limitations.

3. A Discipline Formally Intact and Practically Inert

This section establishes the first of the article’s two premises: that by early 2025 the multilateral discipline was, for the measures at issue, no discipline at all. It does so in three steps. Section 3.1 traces the collapse of the appellate function and the paralysis of the Appellate Body since December 2019; Section 3.2 explains the procedural mechanism, appealing into the void, through which paralysis was converted into a unilateral veto over adverse rulings; and Section 3.3 shows that the 2025 tariffs, though widely regarded as inconsistent with the substantive rules of the GATT, were shielded from enforcement behind that mechanism and behind a self-judging plea of national security. Taken together, the three steps demonstrate that the check the Supreme Court would later supply was supplied in the multilateral system’s stead, not alongside it.

3.1. The Collapse of the Appellate Function

The claim that a domestic court substituted for a multilateral discipline presupposes that the discipline had failed, and the failure must be established rather than assumed. The Dispute Settlement Understanding of 1994 was designed, in Jackson’s (1997) canonical account, to complete the shift from a power-oriented to a rule-oriented trading system: compulsory jurisdiction, quasi-automatic adoption of reports, and a standing appellate organ replaced the consensus-blocking diplomacy of the GATT years. Weiler (2001) described the accompanying transformation as the displacement of an ethos of diplomats by a rule of lawyers, and warned, earlier than most, that juridification would generate legitimacy strains that the older diplomacy had quietly absorbed. Those strains accumulated around the Appellate Body itself, which built, in Howse’s (2016) phrase, a project of global governance by judiciary, complete with de facto precedent and a jurisprudence of general principles that at least one member had never accepted it was creating.
That member’s grievances hardened into obstruction from 2017, when the United States began blocking the appointment of new Appellate Body members, and into paralysis on 11 December 2019, when the terms of two of the three remaining members expired and the organ fell below its quorum. The official indictment came shortly afterwards: The United States Trade Representative’s report catalogued the ninety-day deadline breached, prior reports treated as precedent, panel fact-finding reviewed under cover of Article 11 of the DSU, and, in substance, the erosion through interpretation of policy space the United States believed it had reserved (USTR 2020). The academic 198 literature had seen most of it coming. Payosova et al. (2018) diagnosed 199 the causes and canvassed cures while a fix was still possible; Creamer (2019) traced the 200 descents of the system from crown jewel to crown of thorns; Pauwelyn (2019) mapped, 201 presciently, what dispute settlement after 2019 would look like. Survey work by Fiorini et al. (2020) added an uncomfortable finding: insiders 203 broadly conceded that some American criticisms had substance, while disagreeing 204 profoundly about remedies. The ministerial commitments made at the twelfth and 205 thirteenth Ministerial Conferences to restore a fully functioning system, initially by 2024, 206 were not fulfilled. When the 2025 tariffs arrived, the reform conversation was still a 207 conversation.

3.2. Appealing Into the Void

Paralysis alone did not disable the system; the disabling mechanism was procedural and, in its way, elegant. Articles 16.4 and 17 of the DSU preserve a losing party’s right of appeal, and a report under appeal cannot be adopted. An appeal lodged with an organ that cannot sit therefore suspends adoption indefinitely. The practice of appealing into the void converts the right of appeal into a unilateral veto over adverse rulings, and the literature has documented its use in detail. Pahis (2024) sorted the post-2019 panel reports into appeals into the void, appeals redirected to arbitration and appeals foregone, and showed how the absence of appellate review reshapes the incentives of complainants and respondents alike. Hopewell (2025) placed the practice within a broader account of defection from the trade legal order and reported its aggregate consequence: disputes brought to the WTO have fallen to roughly one third of their pre-crisis level, a revealed-preference verdict on the system’s usefulness. The United States has been among the void’s most frequent users, and the detail that matters most for present purposes is which reports it consigned there: the panel reports of December 2022 finding its Section 232 steel and aluminium duties inconsistent with the GATT remain unadopted and unenforceable to this day (WT/DS544/R and parallel reports).
The principal institutional answer, the Multi-Party Interim Appeal Arbitration Arrangement concluded in 2020 under Article 25 of the DSU, illustrates the problem it was designed to mitigate. Its participants renounce the void inter se and route appeals to arbitration before a standing pool, preserving two-tier binding adjudication among themselves (Pauwelyn 2023). The arrangement has grown to fifty-seven members with the accession of the United Kingdom in June 2025 and has produced its first awards. But it binds only its participants, and the United States is not among them. For a dispute between China or Canada and the United States, the MPIA might as well not exist. The point this subsection contributes to the substitution thesis is foundational: whatever check arrived in February 2026 arrived because the multilateral one could be, and was, unilaterally switched off, and the same switch remains available against any successor measure, which is one root of the substitute’s partiality.

3.3. The 2025 Tariffs in Geneva: Per Se Inconsistency Behind a Justiciability Wall

Against this machinery, or its absence, the legal position of the 2025 duties was almost embarrassingly clear. They were additional ad valorem charges applied on top of, and without regard to, the bound rates in the United States’ Schedule of Concessions, and they applied at different rates to like products depending on national origin. On their face they contravened the most-favoured-nation obligation of Article I:1 and the tariff bindings protected by Articles II:1(a) and (b) of the GATT 1994, and that was precisely the theory of the complaints: China’s requests for consultations of 4 February and 4 April 2025 invoked those provisions (WT/DS633/1; WT/DS638/1), as did Canada’s request concerning automobiles and parts (WT/DS637/1). No colourable route to consistency existed absent an affirmative defence, and the defence the United States signalled was not, in the ordinary sense, a defence at all. Its communications to the Dispute Settlement Body described the measures as issues of national security not susceptible to review or capable of resolution by WTO dispute settlement (WT/DS633/2 and 3), reviving the self-judging reading of Article XXI under which each member is the sole arbiter of its essential security interests.
The self-judging position had already been litigated and had already lost. The panel in Russia—Measures Concerning Traffic in Transit held that Article XXI(b) is justiciable, that the existence of an emergency in international relations is an objective condition open to panel review, and that invocation of the exception is disciplined by good faith (WT/DS512/R, 2019). Panels then applied that framework against the United States itself, in the origin-marking dispute brought by Hong Kong, China (WT/DS597/R, 2022) and in the Section 232 steel and aluminum disputes (WT/DS544/R, 2022), rejecting the non-justiciability plea and finding the measures GATT-inconsistent. Claussen (2020) had already given the underlying pathology its name: trade’s security exceptionalism, the migration of security claims across the trade regime precisely because they promise immunity from ordinary discipline. What happened after those panel victories is the heart of the matter: nothing. The reports went into the void. A panel established in DS633 or DS638 could be expected, on the precedents, to condemn the trafficking and reciprocal tariffs and to reject the justiciability plea; the United States could be expected, on its record, to appeal that condemnation into the void. The expectation is not cynicism but induction. The syllogism that closes this section is therefore uncomfortable but sound. The substantive rules of the GATT condemned the 2025 tariffs; the adjudicative machinery could not enforce the condemnation against a respondent that blocks the appellate stage and denies the justiciability of its security rationale; the multilateral check on the most significant act of unilateral protectionism since the organisation’s founding was, in practice, no check at all. This is the first premise of the substitution thesis: the discipline that the domestic judgment would later replicate was not merely weak but inoperative, so that anything the Supreme Court supplied was supplied in the multilateral system’s stead rather than alongside it.
The security plea was, moreover, weak on its merits. Under the Russia-Traffic in Transit framework, political or economic differences between members do not by themselves constitute an emergency in international relations (WT/DS512/R, paras 7.75–7.76), and a persistent trade deficit, the declared predicate of the reciprocal duties, is precisely such a difference. The trafficking predicate engages law-and-order interests more plausibly, but an across-the-board duty on most goods from three major trading partners is difficult to reconcile with the requirement that a measure be at least minimally plausible as protective of the security interest invoked (WT/DS512/R, para. 7.138). The obstacle to multilateral discipline was therefore the void, not the merits of Article XXI.

4. The Constitutional Allocation of the Tariff Power

4.1. Congressional Primacy and the Lattice of Confined Delegations

American law approaches tariffs from the opposite direction. The question is not whether a duty is consistent with an international obligation but which branch of government may impose it, and on that question the constitutional text is unambiguous. Article I, Section 8 vests in Congress the power to lay and collect taxes, duties, imposts and excises, and the historical record shows how completely Congress once exercised it. Irwin (2017) narrates two centuries of congressional tariff-making, product schedule by product schedule, culminating in the Smoot-Hawley Tariff Act of 1930 and its aftermath. The delegation that followed, beginning with the Reciprocal Trade Agreements Act of 1934, was an institutional solution to a collective action pathology: legislators who could not resist particularistic protection when voting product by product bound themselves by transferring agenda control to an executive with a national constituency (Bailey et al. 1997), and the postwar management of trade politics was engineered, as Destler (2005) showed, to diffuse and deflect protectionist pressure away from Capitol Hill. Meyer and Sitaraman (2019) reframed this history for public lawyers: trade law is, and has always been, a separation of powers problem, and the twentieth-century settlement rested on a bargain in which Congress delegated broadly but confined each delegation with procedures, findings, caps and clocks.
The confinement is visible in the statutes that survived Learning Resources untouched, and their design matters to everything that follows. Section 232 of the Trade Expansion Act of 1962 permits the President to adjust imports that threaten national security, but only after an investigation and report by the Secretary of Commerce. Section 301 of the Trade Act of 1974 authorises retaliation against unjustifiable or discriminatory foreign practices, but only upon a formal determination by the Trade Representative. Section 122 of the same Act permits an import surcharge for balance-of-payments purposes, but caps it at fifteen per cent and one hundred and fifty days absent congressional extension. Each statute names the trigger, prescribes the process and bounds the remedy. The Supreme Court treated this lattice as the interpretive foil for IEEPA: when Congress intends to convey the tariff power, the Court observed, it does so expressly and subject to strict limits, as it consistently has in other tariff statutes (slip op., Part II–B). The dissenters read the same history the other way, as proof that Congress routinely and constitutionally confers sweeping import authority on the President, from the embargo statutes of the 1790s onwards. The disagreement is real, but both sides accepted the frame: the fight was over what Congress gave away, never over whether the power was Congress’s to give.

4.2. IEEPA: A Statute of Restraint Read as a Statute of Empowerment

IEEPA occupies a peculiar place in this architecture because it was enacted, in 1977, to discipline emergency economic power rather than to enlarge it. Congress carved the peacetime emergency authority out of the Trading with the Enemy Act of 1917, whose open-ended delegations had sustained emergencies declared decades earlier, and subjected the new authority to the procedural framework of the National Emergencies Act. The Congressional Research Service’s standard account documents both that origin and the statute’s subsequent career as the workhorse of American sanctions policy, invoked in dozens of emergency declarations, none of which, in nearly five decades, had been used to impose a tariff (Casey et al. 2024). The scholarship of emergency powers had long warned that the post-Vietnam framework statutes were weaker than they looked. Koh (1990) argued that they failed to restore congressional control because courts systematically deferred to executive claims in foreign affairs; Goitein (2019) catalogued, for a wider audience, the extraordinary powers a presidential emergency declaration unlocks and the feebleness of the congressional check once the legislative veto fell. The 2025 tariffs converted these anxieties into a test case: a statute drafted to restrain the executive was invoked to support the broadest assertion of unilateral taxing authority in American history.
Two precedents dominated the ensuing litigation. In United States v. Yoshida International, Inc., 526 F.2d 560 (C.C.P.A. 1975), the Court of Customs and Patent Appeals upheld President Nixon’s temporary ten per cent import surcharge of 1971 as an exercise of the TWEA power to regulate importation, and the dissenters in Learning Resources treated Congress’s re-enactment of that language in IEEPA as ratification of the Yoshida gloss. In Federal Energy Administration v. Algonquin SNG, Inc., 426 U.S. 548 (1976), the Supreme Court read Section 232’s authority to adjust imports as encompassing licence fees and not merely quotas. How the majority confined each is examined in Section 5.2. What deserves emphasis here is a feature of the entire debate that will bear analytical weight later: it was conducted, on both sides, wholly within domestic materials. Text, structure, history, precedent. The United States’ obligations under Articles I and II of the GATT, and the pending Geneva disputes over the very duties before the Court, appear nowhere in any opinion.

4.3. The Litigation Path: Speed, Finality and a Specialist Forum

The procedural history matters to the substitution thesis because it displays what the domestic forum could offer and the multilateral forum could not. The V.O.S. Selections plaintiffs, five small businesses joined by twelve states, obtained summary judgment in the Court of International Trade in the spring of 2025 (772 F. Supp. 3d 1350). The Learning Resources plaintiffs, two small businesses, obtained a preliminary injunction in the District Court for the District of Columbia (784 F. Supp. 3d 209). The Federal Circuit, sitting en banc, affirmed the core holding in August 2025, concluding that IEEPA’s grant of authority to regulate importation did not authorise tariffs unbounded in scope, amount and duration (149 F.4th 1312, 1338). The Supreme Court granted certiorari, in one case before judgment, heard argument on 5 November 2025 and decided the consolidated cases on 20 February 2026, vacating the D.C. judgment with instructions to dismiss for lack of jurisdiction and thereby confirming the exclusive jurisdiction of the Court of International Trade over such challenges. From first executive order to final judgment, the domestic process consumed slightly more than a year. The parallel WTO disputes had not, in the same period, progressed beyond consultations. Nor is the jurisdictional holding a technicality: by channelling tariff challenges into a specialist Article III court with nationwide jurisdiction, the Court consolidated a standing domestic venue for the review of trade measures at the very moment the international venue stood empty.

5. Anatomy of the Judgment

5.1. The Taxing Power Backdrop

The opinion’s constitutional backdrop is set out in Part II–A–1, and its opening move is worth quoting for what it does not say. The Framers, the Chief Justice wrote, gave Congress alone “access to the pockets of the people”, and the power to impose tariffs is “very clear[ly]” a branch of the taxing power (slip op. at 5–6, quoting The Federalist No. 48 and Gibbons v. Ogden, 9 Wheat. 1, 201). The Government conceded that the President enjoys no inherent authority to impose tariffs in peacetime and rested its entire defence on IEEPA. That concession framed the case as one of statutory interpretation conducted in the shadow of a constitutional allocation, and the shadow did the work: every interpretive presumption the majority deployed drew its force from the premise that what the executive claimed to find in the statute belonged, in the first instance, to the legislature. The structure of the reasoning is familiar to students of the delegation literature, but its application to the taxing power, the oldest and most jealously guarded of Congress’s prerogatives, gave it unusual bite.
A word on classification, since it governs everything that follows. Learning Resources is a statutory decision. The Court held that IEEPA does not authorise tariffs. It did not hold IEEPA, or any delegation, unconstitutional, and the statute remains exactly as valid as it was before. The Constitution does figure in the reasoning, but in three supporting roles rather than as the rule of decision. In Part II–A–1, joined by six Justices, Article I’s assignment of the taxing power to Congress serves as the backdrop against which any claimed delegation has to be read. In Part II–B, the Court turns to constitutional avoidance: if “regulate” included taxation, IEEPA would authorise export taxes, which Article I, Section 9 prohibits. And in Part II–A–2, which speaks for only three Justices, the Court applies the major questions doctrine, which Justice Gorsuch defends as a clear-statement rule that protects Article I. What the Court did not apply was the nondelegation doctrine, which asks whether Congress may delegate a power, not whether it has. So, when this article refers to “separation of powers review,” it means enforcing the Constitution’s allocation of powers through the tools of statutory construction. Those tools now do most of that work, largely because the nondelegation doctrine has been dormant since 1935, the last of the only two occasions on which the Court struck down a statute on that ground. The discipline is structural in its source but statutory in its form, and as Section 6 shows, that combination accounts for both its reach and its limits.

5.2. Text and Structure: Part II–B

The portion of the opinion that spoke for six Justices is an exercise in ordinary-meaning textualism. IEEPA authorises the President to “investigate, block during the pendency of an investigation, regulate, direct and compel, nullify, void, prevent or prohibit … importation or exportation” (50 U.S.C. § 1702(a)(1)(B)). Absent from that lengthy list, the Court observed, is any mention of tariffs or duties, and Congress’s pattern of usage is plain: when it delegates the tariff power it says so, expressly, and hedges the grant with limits (slip op., Part II–B). The statutory pairing of importation with exportation reinforced the reading, since export taxes are constitutionally forbidden, so “regulate” cannot carry a taxing sense for one noun and not the other. The majority then confined the two precedents on which the Government had staked its case. Yoshida became a single, expressly limited opinion of a specialised intermediate court, incapable of establishing a settled meaning that Congress could be presumed to have ratified in 1977, particularly for duties that, unlike Nixon’s surcharge, were bounded by neither rate nor time. Algonquin became a decision about a differently worded statute, whose expressly limited holding the Court declined to extend. The interpretive method is conventional; the result, measured against fifty years of executive practice under IEEPA’s sanctions authorities, is not small. The statute that had grown into the presidency’s most versatile economic instrument was held never to have contained a taxing power at all.

5.3. The Major Questions Plurality: Part II–A–2

Three members of the majority went further. For the Chief Justice, joined by Justices Gorsuch and Barrett, the Government’s reading failed for the additional reason that it collided with the major questions’ doctrine, the clear-statement requirement consolidated across the quartet of cases ending in West Virginia v. EPA and Biden v. Nebraska (Sohoni 2022). The stakes of the asserted authority, duties of unlimited amount and duration on any product from any country, were said to dwarf those of the doctrine’s prior applications, and the half-century absence of any tariff invocation of IEEPA supplied the telling lack of historical precedent. Two features of the plurality’s reasoning carry systemic weight. First, it held that there is no exception to the doctrine for emergency statutes: emergencies, the Framers understood, afford a ready pretext for usurpation, and a clear-statement rule that dissolved on the declaration of an emergency would be no rule at all. Second, it held that the foreign affairs setting does not displace the doctrine, at least where, as with tariffs, the President holds no concurrent constitutional authority (slip op. at 12–13). The reasoning tracks the independent-powers qualification that Bradley and Goldsmith (2024) proposed for the nondelegation doctrine, under which scrutiny relaxes only where a delegation touches an area of independent presidential power; it departs, however, from their expectation that the major questions doctrine will often not be triggered by foreign affairs authorisations. The plurality also rejected, at least for the taxing power, the warning of Meyer and Sitaraman (2023) that a muscular major questions doctrine in the security domain would destabilise national security governance built on broad delegations. Both propositions were contested in the scholarship before the decision; both now have the imprimatur of three Justices, and only three.

5.4. One Holding, an Unsettled Doctrine

The structure of the majority matters to the argument, though not in the way a count of separate writings might suggest. Six Justices joined Parts I, II-A-1 and II–B of the Chief Justice’s opinion, which hold, as a matter of text, structure and statutory history, that the power to “regulate . . . importation” does not include the power to tax. That holding, and the rationale supporting it, command a majority. The disagreement lies elsewhere: only three Justices joined Part II-A-2’s major questions analysis. Justice Kagan, joined by Justices Sotomayor and Jackson, joined the remainder of the opinion but declined that Part as unnecessary, since ordinary tools of construction suffice to exclude tariffs, and Justice Jackson wrote separately to rely on IEEPA’s legislative history. Justice Barrett, who joined in full, treated the doctrine as an ordinary incident of contextual textualism rather than a substantive canon; Justice Gorsuch, who also joined in full, defended it as a substantive clear-statement rule protecting Article I, and read the Kagan concurrence as applying the doctrine under another name. The opinions therefore present not two incompatible rationales but one agreed statutory holding and an unresolved dispute over the status of the doctrine that accompanied it. Justice Kavanaugh, joined by Justices Thomas and Alito, dissented on the merits, reading “regulate . . . importation” in light of Yoshida, Algonquin and two centuries of practice to include the traditional tool of tariffs, and locating the case in the first Youngstown category, where the President acts with express congressional authorisation and the major questions canon, in the dissent’s view, has no proper office. Justice Thomas joined Justice Kavanaugh’s dissent but wrote separately to advance a distinct constitutional argument: the authority to impose duties on foreign imports falls outside the scope of the nondelegation doctrine because it does not constitute core legislative power. Congress could therefore delegate that authority to the President without violating the doctrine. By contrast, Kavanaugh’s dissent depended mainly on statutory interpretation and his objection to applying the major questions doctrine in the foreign-affairs context. Although he also rejected the nondelegation challenge, he did so without embracing Thomas’s broader constitutional theory. This point is important in relation to Section 6.3: while the majority’s decision is limited to IEEPA, its statutory reasoning could be of use in interpreting other tariff delegations, depending on the particular text and conditions of those delegations, without resolving the constitutional question.
The Court’s treatment of the emergency itself deserves note. It did not decide whether the declared emergencies were genuine or whether the tariffs dealt with them, and it did not rule on the Government’s claim that emergency declarations are unreviewable. The three-Justice major-questions portion of the Chief Justice’s opinion cited that claim only as part of what made the asserted power extraordinary, observing that on the Government’s reading the sole restraint would be a veto-proof majority in Congress. That political restraint had in fact failed: Senate joint resolutions terminating the tariff emergencies passed in April and October 2025, by margins far short of two-thirds, but did not produce legislative termination of the emergencies (S.J. Res. 37, 77 and 88, 119th Cong.). The Court therefore decided the scope of the authority triggered by an emergency declaration, not the validity of the emergency itself.

6. The Substitution Claim

The argument of this section can be stated as three findings, each demonstrated in turn below. First, the substitute is partial: because the judgment polices the statutory source of the tariff power rather than the protectionism itself, the express delegations of Sections 122, 232 and 301 survive, and replacement protection was announced under them on the day of the judgment (Section 6.2). Second, the substitute is contingent: it rests on a statutory holding confined to one statute and reversible by ordinary legislation, and whether its reasoning reaches other tariff statutes will be worked out statute by statute, through the reading of each delegation’s text and preconditions (Section 6.3). Third, the substitute is indifferent to multilateral legality: its remedy runs backwards to domestic importers and reaches trading partners only incidentally, and it would evaporate before a congressionally enacted tariff of identical design (Section 6.4). Section 6.1 first establishes the phenomenon these findings qualify: a substitution that occurred without any engagement with the legal order whose function it replicated.

6.1. Shared Results, Separate Reasons

Begin with what the judgment accomplished, measured by the metrics of the system it never mentioned. The DSU’s declared preference, in Article 3.7, is the withdrawal of the measure found inconsistent; its declared aim, in Article 3.3, is the prompt settlement of disputes as essential to the effective functioning of the WTO. Learning Resources delivered both. The offending duties were withdrawn, wholesale and permanently, thirteen months after their promulgation, a timetable that compares favourably not merely with the paralysed present but with the appellate system in its prime. It delivered them, moreover, against the one respondent that the surviving multilateral machinery cannot reach: the MPIA does not bind the United States, retaliation invites escalation, and the void swallows panel reports. Functionally, the Supreme Court did in Washington what the Appellate Body was created to do in Geneva and could not.
It did so without engaging the international legal order, and there was no occasion for it to do so. WTO compliance was not before the Court: Section 102 of the Uruguay Round Agreements Act denies the covered agreements self-executing effect and any private right of action, and no party pleaded them. The Charming Betsy canon, under which statutes are construed where fairly possible in conformity with international obligations, does not appear in any of the opinions.1 The pending Geneva disputes over the very duties before the Court appear in none of the opinions. The point is not that the Court should have proceeded otherwise, but that its reasons and the trading system’s reasons ran on entirely separate tracks. What Geneva and Washington share is the result; what they do not share is a single reason for it.
The terminology is deliberate. The article describes separation of powers review as a functional substitute for the multilateral discipline, a substitute identified by the work it performed rather than by any relationship to the order it replaced. Nothing in Learning Resources was undertaken on the WTO’s behalf: no organ of the trading system authorised or invited it, and the Court owed the regime neither duty nor deference. The vocabulary of agency, deputation or surrogacy suits national courts that apply international law in the service of the international order. It would misdescribe a court that never mentioned that order. What connects Geneva and Washington in this episode is equivalence of outcome, not delegation of function, and the properties examined below follow from precisely that absence of mandate. “Engagement” here names a mechanism, not a duty: the article records that the Court kept its reasons separate from international law, and draws no conclusion that it ought to have done otherwise.
This configuration, substitution without engagement, is what the existing scholarship does not capture. The literature on national courts as agents of international law, from Schwartz’s (2015) account of courts reclaiming democratic space through the strategic use of foreign and international law, through Ginsburg’s (2009) account of inter-judicial coordination, to Roberts (2011) on national courts as simultaneous enforcers and creators of international law, presupposes engagement as the mechanism: the domestic judge does international work by using international materials. Learning Resources falls outside that assumption while performing the same function. The trading system received the benefit of a national court’s discipline through channels entirely internal to the national constitution, and the theoretical accounts on offer have no category for that. Nor does the resilience literature, which searches for substitutes inside the regime, in Article 25 arbitration, regional dispute settlement or unilateral enforcement instruments, rather than inside the public law of the defecting member (Hoekman and Mavroidis 2020; Wolff 2023). The substitute was real, but it was nobody’s design, and its properties must therefore be read off the constitutional machinery that produced it. Three such properties define its limits.

6.2. Partial: The Substitute Polices the Source, Not the Protectionism

The first limit follows from the ground of decision. Because the Court held only that this statute confers no tariff power, the judgment addressed the scope of a single statutory delegation, not the legality of tariff policy itself. The executive understood this immediately. On the day of the judgment, the President issued an executive order ending the IEEPA tariff actions and, simultaneously, a proclamation imposing a ten per cent temporary import surcharge under Section 122, effective 24 February 2026 and expiring, absent congressional extension, one hundred and fifty days later; the Trade Representative announced accelerated Section 301 investigations of major trading partners; and the substantial body of Section 232 duties on steel, aluminium, automobiles and other products, none of which was before the Court, remained in force throughout. The Treasury Secretary’s public estimate that the combination would leave tariff revenue in 2026 largely unchanged underscores the limited economic impact of the judicial intervention. Separation of powers review polices the source of the power; it is agnostic about the protectionism.
The pattern did not stop there. When the Section 122 surcharge reached its statutory ceiling of one hundred and fifty days, the administration opened a third track, and this one revealed the fiscal motive with unusual clarity. On 23 July 2026 the President directed the Trade Representative to impose duties of ten or twelve and a half per cent on sixty economies under Section 301 of the Trade Act of 1974, on the ground that each had failed to prohibit, or to enforce a prohibition on, the importation of goods produced with forced labour; the duties took effect the following day, as the Section 122 surcharge they replaced expired at the same hour (Notice of Action, 91 Fed. Reg. 47318 of 28 July 2026; Memorandum of 23 July 2026, 91 Fed. Reg. 47717). The rationale was novel, but its architecture was familiar: the new measures reached roughly the same partners at roughly the same rates as the tariffs the Court had struck down, and covered almost the whole of American imports. A labour-rights justification, in other words, was fitted to a revenue objective that the invalidated Learning Resources duties had been designed to serve, and independent analysts across the spectrum read the forced-labour predicate as a pretext for reconstructing the lost tariff base rather than as a genuine trade remedy (Congressional Research Service 2026). That reading draws force from the Court’s own premise that a tariff is “very clearly … a branch of the taxing power”: if the duty is in substance a tax, the label affixed to it, emergency, balance of payments, or forced labour, does not alter what it does. The episode confirms the substitute’s limit from the other side. Domestic review disciplined the statutory form of the tariff power, and the executive answered by migrating through successive statutory forms toward the same protectionist and revenue ends, each migration lawful until a court says otherwise.
From Geneva’s standpoint the replacement architecture raises substantially the same questions as its predecessor. A Section 122 surcharge applied across the board would raise comparable questions under Articles I and II, even if its legislative basis differs from that invoked for the reciprocal customs duties, though its statutory cap and temporal limitation confine its scope and duration in a way the IEEPA duties never were. The Section 232 measures are already the subject of adverse panel reports suspended in the void (WT/DS544/R and parallel reports, circulated 9 December 2022); new Section 301 actions would revive the unilateralism that the DSU was intended to discipline through binding multilateral procedures. There is nonetheless a difference in kind that the partiality critique should not obscure. The surviving statutes are bounded delegations, with triggers, procedures, caps and time limits, and measures adopted under them are reviewable in the Court of International Trade under ordinary administrative law standards. What the judgment forecloses is therefore not protectionism as such, but protectionism exercised through an unconstrained delegation of emergency power: duties of unlimited amount and duration, imposed and revised at will, on the strength of an emergency declaration alone. The substitute, in this sense, restored the confined-delegation bargain that Meyer and Sitaraman (2019) identified as the constitutional settlement of American trade politics. That is a genuine discipline. It is simply not the discipline of Articles I and II GATT, which govern the level and structure of duties rather than the domestic branch or authority that imposes them. The two disciplines do different things: one polices which branch may tax imports and under what constraints, the other polices the level and structure of the duties themselves. Functional substitution occurs only where they happen to overlap, where a measure is at once an unconfined executive exercise of the taxing power and inconsistent with a member’s bindings. Whether that overlap recurs depends on how courts read the delegations to which the executive has since turned, a question already arising in challenges to the successor measures.

6.3. Contingent: A Discipline Confined to One Statute

Section 6.2 concerned what the executive may still do under the surviving delegations; this section concerns whether the interpretive discipline itself reaches them. The second limit is not that the judgment is fragile but that it is narrow, and narrow in a way that makes the discipline’s extension contingent. As to IEEPA itself, the holding is secure: six Justices joined its statutory core, and statutory precedents attract the strongest form of stare decisis. That security is purchased at the price of scope. The Court decided only whether the power to “regulate . . . importation” in IEEPA embraces the power to impose tariffs, and it expressly declined to speculate about the other tariff statutes the dissent invoked, noting their procedural prerequisites, required agency determinations and limits on amount, duration and scope (slip op. at 16 n. 4). Whether a differently worded delegation authorises a particular tariff measure does not, however, necessarily depend on the major questions doctrine.
In Learning Resources, six Justices agreed on textual and structural grounds that IEEPA conferred no tariff authority, three of whom considered ordinary statutory interpretation sufficient to resolve the case. It is this shared reasoning, rather than the plurality’s clear-statement analysis, that binds lower courts and may guide the interpretation of other tariff statutes. Under those statutes, the question is principally whether the conditions governing an expressly conferred or judicially recognised tariff power have been satisfied and whether the measures remain within the limits Congress established.
The first judicial ruling on the successor measures illustrates the point. In Oregon, the Court of International Trade held, by two votes to one, that the Section 122 surcharge exceeded presidential authority because the proclamation relied on trade and current-account deficits rather than the balance-of-payments deficits contemplated by the statute. The dissenting judge disputed the majority’s interpretation and considered summary judgment premature (Opinion No 26–47, 7 May 2026). The majority expressly relied on the ordinary tools of statutory interpretation endorsed by Justice Kagan’s concurrence in Learning Resources, rather than the plurality’s major questions analysis (Opinion No 26–47, 7 May 2026, 30, footnote 24). It reinforced that reading through constitutional avoidance: the Government’s expansive construction would raise nondelegation concerns by allowing the President to select virtually any deficit within the balance of payments as a statutory trigger (Opinion No 26–47, 7 May 2026, 39–41, footnote 33). The decision thus illustrates the configuration described in Section 5.1: a discipline structural in its source but statutory in its form. Its significance remains qualified, however. The Federal Circuit stayed the divided judgment pending appeal, questioning the majority’s statutory interpretation and constitutional avoidance reasoning without definitively resolving the issue (State of Oregon v. Trump, Nos 2026-1804 and 2026-1805, Federal Circuit, 11 June 2026, nonprecedential order, 5–6). Oregon therefore demonstrates how the discipline may extend beyond IEEPA, rather than establishing that it necessarily will.
The case also has particular resonance for the argument developed here. By examining whether the proclamation identified a deficit of the kind Congress contemplated, while accepting the President’s factual findings as true (Opinion No 26–47, 16–17, 45), the domestic court enforced a condition with a functional parallel in WTO law. Article XII of the GATT 1994 and the Understanding on the Balance-of-Payments Provisions subject restrictions justified on balance-of-payments grounds to multilateral scrutiny. Under the parallel framework of Article XVIII, the Appellate Body confirmed that panels may review compliance with these disciplines (India—Quantitative Restrictions, WT/DS90/AB/R, 1999). The parallel concerns the enforcement of a condition, not the scope of review: WTO scrutiny may examine the actual economic circumstances justifying restrictions, whereas the domestic court confined itself to interpreting the statutory trigger without reassessing the President’s factual determinations.
The extension of the Learning Resources discipline therefore depends on the wording of each delegation and the willingness of courts to enforce its conditions. Broad statutory language may confirm executive authority rather than constrain it. For instance, Section 232 affords the President a broad discretion to take such action as he deems necessary to “adjust” imports, a power interpreted in Algonquin to encompass import licence fees. A clear-statement requirement could make a difference here, but the Court remains divided over the major questions doctrine. Three Justices relied on it, while the three dissenters considered it satisfied or inapplicable in the foreign-affairs context. The remaining three found ordinary statutory interpretation sufficient without resorting to it. This disagreement reflects continuing uncertainty about the doctrine’s foundations (Sohoni 2022) and its application to foreign affairs (Bradley and Goldsmith 2024; Meyer and Sitaraman 2023). Moreover, since Learning Resources rests on statutory interpretation rather than constitutional invalidity, Congress could grant broader tariff powers through later legislation, provided that such powers remain within the constitutional limits. The discipline depends therefore on two factors: the terms of the alternative delegations invoked and whether Congress chooses to confer the tariff authority the Court declined to find in IEEPA.
The contrast with WTO tariff bindings is instructive. Article II binds the United States as a state, with commitments that continue across administrations and entail international responsibility when breached, subject to the exceptions and modification procedures recognised by WTO law. Learning Resources, by contrast, provides a binding interpretation of a particular domestic statute, but the practical reach of its reasoning depends on other delegations, subsequent legislation and judicial interpretation. Trading partners may view domestic judicial review as a means of restraining unilateral protectionism, but it cannot offer the same assurance as multilateral commitments. Moreover, its outcomes do not determine whether tariffs comply with WTO obligations.

6.4. Indifferent: A Remedy That Runs Inward

The third limit is remedial, and it is the most revealing, because remedies expose what a legal discipline is actually for. The DSU’s remedial scheme is prospective and inter-state: compliance secured, in the last resort, by multilaterally authorised suspension of concessions, the whole apparatus oriented to restoring the reciprocal balance of concessions among members. The domestic remedy is retrospective and intra-state. The judgment’s immediate beneficiaries are American importers, who paid the duties as a condition of entry and who, in proceedings before the Court of International Trade in the weeks after the decision, obtained orders directing Customs and Border Protection to liquidate entries without regard to the invalidated duties, a process involving tens of millions of entries and deposits estimated in the range of one hundred and seventy-five billion dollars. Who bore the duties’ economic incidence is a separate and contested question: studies of the 2018–2019 tariffs found pass-through to American purchasers close to complete (Amiti et al. 2019; Fajgelbaum et al. 2020), and the distribution of the 2025 burden remains uncertain. The contrast drawn here therefore concerns the architecture of the remedy, not the final resting place of the burden. In one respect this remedy is stronger than anything Geneva ever offered: it is self-executing, it reaches back to the first dollar collected, and it requires no authorisation from any political organ. In every systemic respect it is weaker. Trading partners benefit, but only as a by-product: the invalidated duties ceased to apply to their exporters, and those not replaced under other statutes have not returned. That benefit is not owed to them. They had no standing to seek it, hold no entitlement to its continuation, and have no assurance against re-imposition under a different statute. Nothing in the remedy engages the most-favoured-nation logic that gives the multilateral system its architecture; nothing in it constrains successor measures adopted under other statutes.
The indifference is structural, not accidental. The constitutional value the judgment vindicates is the allocation of fiscal power between Congress and the President, a value whose beneficiaries are the American taxpayer and the American legislature. That the vindication coincided with the interests of China, Canada, Mexico and the European Union is a contingency of the case, not a feature of the doctrine, and the coincidence will not hold in the run of cases. A future Congress that enacted the identical reciprocal tariff schedule by statute would extinguish the statutory objection entirely while leaving the GATT inconsistency untouched. The substitute and the discipline it replaced are aligned only where unilateral protectionism happens to be executive protectionism. The alignment held in 2025 because the protectionism was executive; the multilateral system has no claim on it holding again.

7. What the Substitution Means for the Multilateral System

The findings can now be brought to bear on the question with which the resilience literature has been occupied since 2019: what sustains the trading system when its enforcement arm is gone? The episode examined here supplies an answer the literature did not anticipate, and the answer cuts in two directions at once.
Read optimistically, Learning Resources is a demonstration that binding adjudication of trade measures remains possible, that it can be fast, and that it can reach the one state the surviving multilateral machinery cannot. For members negotiating the restoration of dispute settlement, the episode is a standing rebuke to the claim that adjudication of sovereign trade measures is inherently unworkable: the United States’ own courts adjudicated the most consequential trade measures in living memory, against the sitting government, and the government complied within days. The episode also supplies, in the confined-delegation model that survived it, a template the reform conversation might study. The statutes the Court left standing pair authority with trigger, process, cap and clock. An appellate mechanism reconstructed on analogous lines, jurisdiction paired with explicit interpretive constraints and hard deadlines, is recognisably the direction in which the post-2019 reform proposals have been groping (Payosova et al. 2018; Hoekman and Mavroidis 2020).
Read pessimistically, the episode teaches trading partners that the only binding discipline on American protectionism is one they cannot invoke, cannot influence and cannot rely upon, and it teaches the United States that defection from multilateral adjudication is costless so long as domestic constitutionalism occasionally, and for its own reasons, cleans up afterwards. The incentive effects on the reform negotiations are perverse in both directions: the demonstrated availability of a domestic check reduces the urgency, for the United States, of restoring an international one, while the check’s partiality, contingency and indifference give other members no reason to accept it as a durable substitute. Mavroidis and Sapir’s (2021) argument that multilateralism still matters because bilateral management of the China problem has failed acquires, after Learning Resources, a domestic corollary: constitutional management of the unilateralism problem succeeds only by coincidence, when the protectionist instrument happens to be an unbounded executive one. Hopewell’s (2025) enforcement-and-defection framing likewise survives the episode intact, because the defection was never punished; it was mooted, on grounds the defector’s own public law supplied, for reasons that owe nothing to the trade legal order.
Between the readings sits the sober one this article defends, and it can be stated as a proposition: the trading system gains episodic reprieves from domestic constitutionalism, but not durable discipline. By “domestic constitutionalism” the article means the constitutional allocation of powers as it is enforced in practice, whether directly through constitutional adjudication or, as here, through statutory interpretation conducted against it. The substitute revealed in February 2026 is real, and the trading system was better off for it: the alternative was not a WTO victory but nothing. It is also unrepeatable by design, because no institution designed it, and each of its three limits identifies a condition under which the reprieve may not recur: a measure grounded in a surviving delegation escapes it, a bench unpersuaded that a clear statement is required may decline to extend it, and a congressionally enacted tariff extinguishes it. Its existence should therefore neither console the resilience debate nor redirect it, but sharpen it, by clarifying precisely what an international discipline provides that even a well-functioning domestic one cannot: continuity across governments, obligations owed to the injured rather than protections owed to the domestic public, and a remedial logic addressed to the balance of concessions rather than the balance of powers. The research agenda that follows from this analysis is gathered in the conclusion.

8. Conclusions

This article has read the most consequential trade ruling in the Supreme Court’s modern history as an event in the life of an international regime the ruling never mentions. The contrast can be compressed into a sentence: duties widely regarded as inconsistent with Articles I and II of the GATT were untouchable in Geneva, where their author had disabled the appellate stage, and were dead within thirteen months in Washington, on statutory grounds, informed by the Constitution’s allocation of the taxing power, that owe nothing to the treaty with which they were widely regarded as inconsistent. The separation of powers review functioned, in this instance, as a functional substitute for the absent multilateral discipline.
The article’s contribution has been to specify what kind of substitute it was. It was a substitute without engagement, replicating the international discipline’s function while keeping its reasons entirely separate from it, a configuration for which neither the national courts literature nor the WTO resilience literature has a category. And it was a substitute whose limits are legible in its source, a statutory holding grounded in constitutional structure: partial, because it polices the branch that imposes duties rather than the duties themselves, and the executive announced replacement protection under surviving statutes on the day of the judgment; contingent, because it rests on a statutory holding confined to one statute and reversible by ordinary legislation, whose reasoning reaches other tariff statutes only statute by statute, through the wording and preconditions of each delegation, as the first challenge to the Section 122 surcharge has already shown; and indifferent to multilateral legality, because its remedy runs backwards to domestic importers and reaches trading partners only incidentally, and would evaporate entirely before a congressionally enacted tariff of identical design. When the most effective limit on unilateral protectionism is supplied by domestic public law, exercised on domestic grounds, for domestic beneficiaries, the multilateral trading system has not found a durable replacement for its lost discipline. It has found a reprieve, and the difference between a reprieve and a discipline is the measure of what remains to be rebuilt.
Two sets of implications follow, one for institutional actors and one for research. For WTO reformers the normative takeaway can be put in a single sentence: reform efforts should treat domestic rulings of the Learning Resources kind as contingent reprieves, never as reliable substitutes for multilateral enforcement, and should draw from the episode only the narrower lessons it actually teaches, that binding adjudication of sovereign trade measures remains workable, that speed is achievable, and that the confined-delegation model of trigger, process, cap and clock offers a design template an appellate mechanism could adapt. For members other than the United States the lesson is correspondingly austere: the one binding discipline demonstrated in this episode is one they cannot invoke, cannot influence and cannot rely upon.
The limitations acknowledged in Section 2, a single case, a single jurisdiction, doctrinal and qualitative evidence, and dependence on the current composition of the Court, mark out the research agenda. Four questions follow, each addressed to one of those limits. First, a comparative question: under what constitutional or administrative law conditions do other major trading powers possess an analogous substitutive capacity, and how would its presence or absence alter the systemic picture drawn here? Second, an empirical question: does domestic invalidation of trade measures deter subsequent WTO-inconsistent measures, or merely reroute them to surviving statutory bases, a question for which the migration from IEEPA to Sections 122, 232 and 301 already under way supplies the first natural experiment? Third, a doctrinal question: how far will the reasoning of Learning Resources spill over into review of the surviving delegations, whose bounded design the Court treated as the interpretive foil for IEEPA? Fourth, an institutional question: does the demonstrated availability of a domestic check strengthen or weaken the incentives of the United States, and of its trading partners, to restore a functioning multilateral one? Mixed doctrinal and empirical designs, and the methods of comparative public law, are the natural instruments for this agenda, which asks, in the end, under what conditions domestic courts’ invalidations of trade measures produce systemic deterrence rather than mere substitution.

Author Contributions

Conceptualization, A.S., and L.C.; methodology, A.S., L.C., T.B.h., R.S., S.B. and L.B.; bibliography T.B.h., R.S., S.B. and L.B.; writing—original draft preparation, A.S., L.C., T.B.h., R.S., S.B. and L.B.; writing—review and editing, A.S., L.C., T.B.h., R.S., S.B. and L.B.; funding acquisition and project management L.C. All authors contributed substantially and equally to the work. All authors have read and agreed to the published version of the manuscript.

Funding

The authors gratefully acknowledge the support provided by Ajman University Internal Research Grant No. 2025-IRG-COL-4. The findings and conclusions expressed in this article are solely those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the views of the funding institution.

Institutional Review Board Statement

Not applicable.

Data Availability Statement

No new data were created or analyzed in this study. Data sharing is not applicable to this article.

Conflicts of Interest

The author declares no conflicts of interest.

References

  1. Primary Source 

    Corus Staal BV v. Department of Commerce, 395 F.3d 1343 (Fed. Cir. 2005).
    Federal Energy Administration v. Algonquin SNG, Inc., 426 U.S. 548 (1976).
    Federal-Mogul Corp. v. United States, 63 F.3d 1572 (Fed. Cir. 1995).
    Gibbons v. Ogden, 22 U.S. (9 Wheat.) 1 (1824).
    Learning Resources, Inc. v. Trump, 784 F. Supp. 3d 209 (D.D.C. 2025).
    Learning Resources, Inc. v. Trump, Nos. 24-1287 and 25-250, 607 U.S.___ (2026) (slip opinion of 20 February 2026).
    Murray v. The Schooner Charming Betsy, 6 U.S. (2 Cranch) 64 (1804).
    State of Oregon v. United States, Slip Op. 26-47 (Ct. Int’l Trade 7 May 2026), stay pending appeal granted, Nos. 2026-1804 and 2026-1805 (Fed. Cir. 11 June 2026).
    United States v. Yoshida International, Inc., 526 F.2d 560 (C.C.P.A. 1975).
    V.O.S. Selections, Inc. v. United States, 772 F. Supp. 3d 1350 (Ct. Int’l Trade 2025).
    V.O.S. Selections, Inc. v. Trump, 149 F.4th 1312 (Fed. Cir. 2025) (en banc).
    United States Trade Representative, Notice of Actions in Section 301 Investigations of Acts, Policies, and Practices of Various Economies Related to the Failure of Each Economy to Impose and Effectively Enforce a Prohibition on the Importation of Goods Produced with Forced Labor, 91 Fed. Reg. 47318 (28 July 2026).
    Actions by the United States in the Section 301 Investigations of 60 Economies Related to the Failure to Enforce a Prohibition on the Importation of Goods Produced with Forced Labor, Memorandum of 23 July 2026, 91 Fed. Reg. 47717 (28 July 2026).
    Section 301 of the Trade Act of 1974, 19 U.S.C. § 2411.
    West Virginia v. EPA, 597 U.S. 697 (2022); Biden v. Nebraska, 600 U.S. 477 (2023); Youngstown Sheet & Tube Co. v. Sawyer, 343 U.S. 579 (1952).
    Executive Orders 14193, 14194 and 14195 of 1 February 2025, 90 Fed. Reg. 9113, 9117 and 9121; Executive Order 14257 of 2 April 2025, 90 Fed. Reg. 15041; Executive Order of 20 February 2026, Ending Certain Tariff Actions; Proclamation of 20 February 2026 imposing a temporary import surcharge under Section 122 of the Trade Act of 1974.
    The Federalist No. 48 (J. Madison), in The Federalist Papers, ed. C. Rossiter (New York: New American Library, 1961).
    International Emergency Economic Powers Act, 50 U.S.C. § 1701 et seq.; National Emergencies Act, 50 U.S.C. § 1601 et seq.; Trade Act of 1974, §§ 122 and 301; Trade Expansion Act of 1962, § 232; Trading with the Enemy Act of 1917; Uruguay Round Agreements Act, § 102.
    S.J. Res. 37, 119th Cong. (passed Senate 2 April 2025); S.J. Res. 77 and S.J. Res. 88, 119th Cong. (passed Senate 29 and 30 October 2025).
    General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade 1994, Articles I:1, II:1, XII, XVIII:B and XXI; Understanding on the Balance-of-Payments Provisions of the General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade 1994; Understanding on Rules and Procedures Governing the Settlement of Disputes, Articles 3.3, 3.7, 16.4, 17 and 25.
    WTO, Statement on a Mechanism for Developing, Documenting and Sharing Practices and Procedures in the Conduct of WTO Disputes (Multi-Party Interim Appeal Arbitration Arrangement pursuant to Article 25 of the DSU), JOB/DSB/1/Add.12 (30 April 2020).
    WTO, India—Quantitative Restrictions on Imports of Agricultural, Textile and Industrial Products, Appellate Body Report, WT/DS90/AB/R, adopted 22 September 1999.
    WTO, Russia—Measures Concerning Traffic in Transit, Panel Report, WT/DS512/R, adopted 26 April 2019.
    WTO, United States—Origin Marking Requirement, Panel Report, WT/DS597/R, circulated 21 December 2022.
    WTO, United States—Certain Measures on Steel and Aluminium Products, Panel Reports, WT/DS544/R and parallel reports, circulated 9 December 2022.
    WTO, United States—Additional Tariff Measures on Goods from China, Request for Consultations by China, WT/DS633/1 (4 February 2025); Communications from the United States, WT/DS633/2 and WT/DS633/3.
    WTO, United States—Additional Duties on Imports of Automobiles and Automobile Parts from Canada, Request for Consultations by Canada, WT/DS637/1 (3 April 2025).
    WTO, United States—Universal and Country-Specific Additional Duties on Imports from China, Request for Consultations by China, WT/DS638/1 (4 April 2025).
  2. Secondary Source 

  3. Amiti, Mary, Stephen J. Redding, and David E. Weinstein. 2019. The Impact of the 2018 Tariffs on Prices and Welfare. Journal of Economic Perspectives 33: 187–210. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  4. Bailey, Michael A., Judith Goldstein, and Barry R. Weingast. 1997. The Institutional Roots of American Trade Policy: Politics, Coalitions, and International Trade. World Politics 49: 309–38. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  5. Bradley, Curtis A., and Jack L. Goldsmith. 2024. Foreign Affairs, Nondelegation, and the Major Questions Doctrine. University of Pennsylvania Law Review 172: 1743–806. [Google Scholar]
  6. Casey, Christopher A., Jennifer K. Elsea, and Dianne E. Rennack. 2024. The International Emergency Economic Powers Act: Origins, Evolution, and Use. CRS Report R45618. Washington, DC: Congressional Research Service. [Google Scholar]
  7. Claussen, Kathleen. 2020. Trade’s Security Exceptionalism. Stanford Law Review 72: 1097–162. [Google Scholar]
  8. Congressional Research Service. 2026. Section 301 Tariffs and Forced Labor: Legal Considerations. CRS Legal Sidebar LSB11460. Washington, DC: Congressional Research Service. [Google Scholar]
  9. Creamer, Cosette D. 2019. From the WTO’s Crown Jewel to Its Crown of Thorns. AJIL Unbound 113: 51–55. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  10. Destler, Irving McArthur. 2005. American Trade Politics, 4th ed. Washington, DC: Institute for International Economics. [Google Scholar]
  11. Fajgelbaum, Pablo D., Pinelopi K. Goldberg, Patrick J. Kennedy, and Amit K. Khandelwal. 2020. The Return to Protectionism. Quarterly Journal of Economics 135: 1–55. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  12. Fiorini, Matteo, Bernard M. Hoekman, Petros C. Mavroidis, Maarja Saluste, and Robert Wolfe. 2020. WTO Dispute Settlement and the Appellate Body Crisis: Insider Perceptions and Members’ Revealed Preferences. Journal of World Trade 54: 667–98. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  13. Ginsburg, Tom. 2009. National Courts, Domestic Democracy, and the Evolution of International Law: A Reply to Eyal Benvenisti and George Downs. European Journal of International Law 20: 1021–26. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  14. Goitein, Elizabeth. 2019. The Alarming Scope of the President’s Emergency Powers. The Atlantic, January/February issue.
  15. Hoekman, Bernard M., and Petros C. Mavroidis. 2020. To AB or Not to AB? Dispute Settlement in WTO Reform. Journal of International Economic Law 23: 703–22. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  16. Hopewell, Kristen. 2025. Unravelling of the Trade Legal Order: Enforcement, Defection and the Crisis of the WTO Dispute Settlement System. International Affairs 101: 1103–17. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  17. Howse, Robert. 2016. The World Trade Organization 20 Years On: Global Governance by Judiciary. European Journal of International Law 27: 9–77. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  18. Irwin, Douglas A. 2017. Clashing over Commerce: A History of US Trade Policy. Chicago: University of Chicago Press. [Google Scholar]
  19. Jackson, John H. 1997. The World Trading System: Law and Policy of International Economic Relations, 2nd ed. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press. [Google Scholar]
  20. Koh, Harold Hongju. 1990. The National Security Constitution: Sharing Power After the Iran-Contra Affair. New Haven: Yale University Press. [Google Scholar]
  21. Mavroidis, Petros C., and André Sapir. 2021. China and the WTO: Why Multilateralism Still Matters. Princeton: Princeton University Press. [Google Scholar]
  22. Meyer, Timothy, and Ganesh Sitaraman. 2019. Trade and the Separation of Powers. California Law Review 107: 583–652. [Google Scholar]
  23. Meyer, Timothy, and Ganesh Sitaraman. 2023. The National Security Consequences of the Major Questions Doctrine. Michigan Law Review 122: 55–96. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  24. Pahis, Stratos. 2024. Appeals after the Appellate Body. World Trade Review 23: 296–323. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  25. Pauwelyn, Joost. 2019. WTO Dispute Settlement Post 2019: What to Expect? Journal of International Economic Law 22: 297–321. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  26. Pauwelyn, Joost. 2023. The WTO’s Multi-Party Interim Appeal Arbitration Arrangement (MPIA): What’s New? World Trade Review 22: 693–701. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  27. Payosova, Tetyana, Gary Clyde Hufbauer, and Jeffrey J. Schott. 2018. The Dispute Settlement Crisis in the World Trade Organization: Causes and Cures. PIIE Policy Brief 18-5. Washington, DC: Peterson Institute for International Economics. [Google Scholar]
  28. Roberts, Anthea. 2011. Comparative International Law? The Role of National Courts in Creating and Enforcing International Law. International and Comparative Law Quarterly 60: 57–92. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  29. Schwartz, Osnat Grady. 2015. Changing the Rules of the (International) Game: How International Law Is Turning National Courts into International Political Actors. Washington International Law Journal 24: 99–140. [Google Scholar]
  30. Sohoni, Mila. 2022. The Major Questions Quartet. Harvard Law Review 136: 262–318. [Google Scholar]
  31. USTR. 2020. Report on the Appellate Body of the World Trade Organization; Washington, DC: Office of the United States Trade Representative.
  32. Weiler, Joseph H. H. 2001. The Rule of Lawyers and the Ethos of Diplomats: Reflections on the Internal and External Legitimacy of WTO Dispute Settlement. Journal of World Trade 35: 191–207. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  33. Wolff, Alan Wm. 2023. Revitalizing the World Trading System. Cambridge, MA: Cambridge University Press. [Google Scholar]
1
It is doubtful that the canon had work to do: the majority found no relevant ambiguity; the Federal Circuit has applied it to the WTO agreements but not to dispute settlement rulings (Federal-Mogul Corp. v. United States, 63 F.3d 1572 (Fed. Cir. 1995); Corus Staal BV v. Department of Commerce, 395 F.3d 1343 (Fed. Cir. 2005)); and the existence of any conflict turned on the Article XXI defence that Geneva could not adjudicate. Its absence is noted not as an omission but because, had it been invoked, it would have pointed in the same direction as the Court’s statutory reading.
Disclaimer/Publisher’s Note: The statements, opinions and data contained in all publications are solely those of the individual author(s) and contributor(s) and not of MDPI and/or the editor(s). MDPI and/or the editor(s) disclaim responsibility for any injury to people or property resulting from any ideas, methods, instructions or products referred to in the content.

Article Metrics

Citations

Article Access Statistics

Multiple requests from the same IP address are counted as one view.