Review Reports
- Gebretsadik Kifle Gebreegziabiher 1,2,†,
- Shuyan Kou 1,† and
- Ping Huang 1,*
- et al.
Reviewer 1: Anonymous Reviewer 2: Anonymous Reviewer 3: Anonymous
Round 1
Reviewer 1 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsSimple Summary & Abstract
Good overall. In line 49 and following instances, it’s probably not necessary to spell out “Integrated Pest Management” since “IPM” is defined in the Abbreviations section at the end of the manuscript. There are also other instances where abbreviations are provided in this section and so the term doesn’t need to be spelled out in the text.
Lines 57-58 – “conservation biological control” would also be a good search term to include in the Keywords
Introduction
Good overall. I think it would help readers who are not familiar with rice production if a summary of rice growing and harvesting is provided in the Introduction. This might include defining terms such as “bunds,” which is defined in line 467 as a “levee.” It would be better to define this term earlier in the paper. I also think “banker plants” should be defined when it is first used in line 102. You might also include a summary of economic injury level/economic threshold for rice/rice pests and how this relates to the potential for effective biological control. Biocontrol agents will still result in some crop damage, however for rice this damage may well be below economic injury levels, which would help make biological control economically advantageous. Is cosmetic damage important in rice production?
Lines 86-88 – sentence fragments need fixing.
Line 111 – You might also acknowledge that one disadvantage of generalist predators such as spiders is that they also potentially prey on beneficial insects.
Rice Pests and Beneficial Insects in Rice Ecosystems
Nice job overall. Just a few comments:
Line 166 – Need to be consistent with format of subheadings (italics vs not italicized)
Lines 171-175 – I think more explanation/clarification is needed about this. Does this mean that web-building spiders selectively target adult planthoppers, and ground-hunting spiders target nymphs? If so, then I think inclusion of the word “respectively” would help make that clear. Also, I think you should explicitly state how this suppression allows parasitic wasps to achieve greater oviposition efficiency. Finally, there are several statements in this paragraph that I think need references.
Line 177 – Table 1 has words/columns that run together. Maybe it should be on a landscape-oriented page to allow more spacing.
Principles of Habitat Management for Conservation Biological Control
Nice job. A few comments:
Line 256 – “. . . boost parasitoid (abundance/diversity/effectiveness?) Need to state what is being boosted.
Line 266 – if natural vegetation is maintained around rice fields (the periphery), have there been any studies on how far into the rice fields the beneficial insects penetrate and provide pest control?
Lines 270-286 – How compatible are these ecological engineering practices with rice planting/management/harvesting activities?
Lines 288-329 – Same as above: how can these practices be incorporated into the crop production system in an affordable manner?
Line 300 – It would be helpful to the reader to include the common name (Chinese milkvetch) and the family (Fabaceae). I think many readers won’t be familiar with the scientific name of these plants. This should also be done for other species that are mentioned. Also, should the author name be included with the scientific name?
Line 374 – If referring to the genus, Coccinella should be italicized.
Lines 383-384 – “delphacids” would be more succinct.
Line 385 – don’t need “the”
Lines 393-408 – scientific names should be italicized
Line 469 – Is there any information on how far into the rice fields these natural enemies migrate? Or is the benefit limited to the area near the flower strip?
Integrated Pest Management
Good summary of IPM.
Case Studies and Evidence from Biocontrol Systems
Good examples.
Lines 559-560 – This is an important point regarding the necessity of taking life-history traits into account.
Table 2 – I think this table would also be better landscape-oriented if possible.
Challenges and Future Research Agenda
Nice summary.
568-570 – Yes, long-term studies (and the funding needed to do them) are badly needed.
Conclusion and Prospects
Good conclusion.
References
References are appropriate and adequate. I noticed a few errors:
Line 677 – Journal title should be in italics.
Line 877 – First letters of journal title should be capitalized.
Line 913 – Journal title should be in italics.
Line 928 – Should journal title be abbreviated?
Author Response
Response to Reviewer 1
Thank you very much for taking the time to review our manuscript. We sincerely appreciate your constructive comments and suggestions. Below, we provide a detailed, point-by-point response to each of your comments. All corresponding revisions and corrections have been incorporated into the revised manuscript and are highlighted using Track Changes in the resubmitted files.
Comment 1: In line 49 and in the following instances, it’s probably not necessary to spell out “Integrated Pest Management” since “IPM” is defined in the Abbreviations section at the end of the manuscript. There are also other instances where abbreviations are provided in this section, so the term doesn’t need to be spelled out in the text.
Response 1: Thank you for your valuable suggestion. We agree and have removed the full names of the abbreviations throughout the manuscript, as suggested.
Comment 2: Good overall. I think it would help readers who are not familiar with rice production if a summary of rice growing and harvesting is provided in the Introduction. This might include defining terms such as “bunds,” which is defined in line 467 as “levees.” It would be better to define this term earlier in the paper. I also think “banker plants” should be defined when it is first used in line 102. You might also include a summary of the economic injury level/economic threshold for rice/rice pests and how this relates to the potential for effective biological control. Biocontrol agents will still result in some crop damage; however, for rice, this damage may well be below economic injury levels, which would help make biological control economically advantageous. Is cosmetic damage important in rice production?
Response 2: Thank you for this valuable suggestion. We have revised the Introduction to improve accessibility for readers unfamiliar with rice production systems. Specifically, we have added a brief overview of the rice production cycle, including crop establishment, vegetative and reproductive growth, and harvesting. We now define bunds at their first occurrence as raised earthen embankments (levees) that surround rice fields, retain irrigation water, and separate adjacent paddies. Likewise, banker plants are now defined at their first mention as non-crop plants deliberately established to maintain alternative hosts or prey that sustain populations of natural enemies in the absence of target pests.
Following your recommendation, we also included a brief discussion of the concepts of the economic injury level (EIL) and economic threshold (ET) in rice pest management and their relevance to conservation biological control. The revised text explains that biological control aims to maintain pest populations below economically damaging levels rather than eliminate them, allowing low pest densities and minor feeding damage that generally do not reduce grain yield or economic returns. We further clarify that cosmetic damage to rice leaves is usually of limited economic importance because rice is primarily cultivated for grain production, and moderate foliar injury during certain growth stages often does not translate into significant yield loss when pest populations remain below the economic threshold. Appropriate references have been added to support these statements.
“Rice is typically grown annually using transplanted seedlings or direct seeding in flooded or irrigated fields [72, 105]. Bunds separate the fields, retaining water and providing habitat for beneficial organisms [45]. The rice plant progresses through stages of seedling establishment, vegetative growth, reproductive development, grain filling, and maturation before harvest [37, 45]. After harvest, crop residues are either removed or incorporated into the soil”. Page 2, paragraph 1, lines 65-70.
“Key predators, such as ladybird beetles, spiders, dragonflies, damselflies, rove beetles, and mirid bugs, as well as parasitoids such as Anagrus spp. and Trichogramma spp., are fundamental to regulating herbivore populations in rice ecosystems [1, 133]. These natural enemies mitigate pest populations through predation and parasitism, thereby supporting integrated pest management strategies and decreasing reliance on synthetic pesticides [9, 84, 114]. However, the success of biological control largely hinges on the availability of appropriate habitats, food resources, and refuges to sustain natural enemy populations throughout the cropping season [40, 45].” Page 3, paragraph 3, lines 92-100.
“Banker plants are non-crop plants intentionally established within or adjacent to rice fields to provide alternative hosts, prey, or floral resources that maintain predator and parasitoid populations during periods of low pest abundance, thereby enhancing long-term conservation biological control [36, 141]. Page 3, paragraph 4, lines 107-110.
“However, because spiders are generalist predators, they may also consume beneficial arthropods, including predators and parasitoids, leading to intraguild predation that can reduce natural enemy populations and, under certain conditions, weaken biolog-ical control [45]. Nevertheless, field studies show that the overall impact of spiders in rice ecosystems is positive, as their pest suppression outweighs any negative effects on other natural enemies. “Page 3, paragraph 5, lines 124-128.
“Within IPM, pest control decisions are guided by the economic injury level (EIL), the lowest pest density at which the cost of pest damage equals the cost of control, and the economic threshold (ET), the pest density at which management actions should be taken to prevent populations from reaching the EIL [12, 122]. Conservation biological control aims to maintain pest populations below these thresholds rather than eradicate them. Consequently, low pest densities and minor feeding damage are often acceptable because they seldom reduce grain yield or economic returns [98, 106] [2,4]. In rice, cosmetic leaf injury generally has limited economic significance compared with damage occurring during critical growth stages or injury to reproductive structures that directly affects grain production [52, 97]. Therefore, effective biological control can provide economically sustainable pest management even when minor visible pest damage remains.” Page 3, paragraph 6, lines 132-142.
Comments 3: Lines 86-88 – sentence fragments need fixing.
Response 3: Thank you for your valuable suggestion. We have reorganized the paragraph structure on page 3 (paragraph 3, lines 92–100) to improve clarity and readability.
Comments 4: Line 111 – You might also acknowledge that one disadvantage of generalist predators such as spiders is that they also potentially prey on beneficial insects.
Response 4: Thank you for your valuable suggestion. We agree that acknowledging the limitations of generalist predators strengthens the discussion. Accordingly, we have included the disadvantage of generalist predators, such as spiders, on page 3, paragraph 5, lines 110–120.
“Among these natural enemies, spiders are particularly important because, as generalist predators, they capture large numbers of prey throughout their lifetimes and contribute substantially to biological pest control [34, 1133]. Higher spider diversity contributes to pest suppression as species vary in their hunting strategies and can target a broader range of pests [34, 88]. However, because spiders are generalist predators, they may also consume beneficial arthropods, including predators and parasitoids, leading to intraguild predation that can reduce natural enemy populations and, under certain conditions, weaken biological control [45]. Nevertheless, field studies show that the overall impact of spiders in rice ecosystems is positive, as their pest suppression outweighs any negative effects on other natural enemies.” (Page 3, Lines 118-129).
Comments 5: Line 166 – Need to be consistent with format of subheadings (italics vs not italicized).
Response 5: Thank you for your valuable suggestion. We have revised the subtitle to the “Palatino Linotype” font as suggested.
Comment 6: Lines 171-175 – I think more explanation/clarification is needed about this. Does this mean that web-building spiders selectively target adult planthoppers, and ground-hunting spiders target nymphs? If so, then I think inclusion of the word “respectively” would help make that clear. Also, I think you should explicitly state how this suppression allows parasitic wasps to achieve greater oviposition efficiency. Finally, there are several statements in this paragraph that I think need references.
Response 6: Thank you very much for your valuable suggestion. We agree with your observation and have revised the paragraph to address the identified gap and provide a clearer explanation, as suggested.
” Generalist predators, such as mirid bugs and spiders, and specialized egg parasitoids, such as Anagrus spp., often attack different life stages of rice planthoppers simultaneously [43]. Although intraguild predation may occur, structurally complex habitats help reduce interference among natural enemies [43, 109, 159]. For example, web-building and ground-dwelling spiders primarily prey on planthopper adults and nymphs, lowering pest populations and reducing crop damage [88, 142]. This enables egg parasitoids to parasitize the remaining host eggs more effectively. Together, these complementary foraging strategies enhance biological control and promote stable pest suppression throughout the rice-growing season [43, 159].” (Page 5, lines 194-203).
Comments 7: Line 177 – Table 1 has words/columns that run together. Maybe it should be on a landscape-oriented page to allow more spacing.
Response 7: Thank you for your valuable suggestion. We agree and have revised Table 1 accordingly (page 5, lines 204–205).
Comments 8: Line 256 – “. . . boost parasitoid (abundance/diversity/effectiveness?) Need to state what is being boosted.
Response 8: Thank you for your suggestion. We agree and have revised the sentence accordingly.
The modified sentence “For example, enhancing compositional heterogeneity in rice landscapes has been found to boost the abundance, richness, and biological control services of parasitoids (such as parasitic wasps” (page 7, lines 285–286).
Comments 9: Line 266 – if natural vegetation is maintained around rice fields (the periphery), have there been any studies on how far into the rice fields the beneficial insects penetrate and provide pest control?
Response 9: Thank you very much for your valuable suggestion. However, the optimal distance between rice fields and natural vegetation varies depending on the type of vegetation and the mobility of the natural enemies involved. Consequently, it is difficult to recommend a specific distance that would consistently facilitate the movement of natural enemies into rice fields for effective pest control. But we put some generalized distance as “Maintaining natural vegetation around rice fields, such as field margins and hedgerows (typically within 0–5 m of the field edge) [43], can enhance biodiversity and create refuges for beneficial insects [84, 127].” (page 7, line297).
Comments 10: Lines 270-286 – How compatible are these ecological engineering practices with rice planting/management/harvesting activities?
Response 10: Thank you for your excellent comment. Accordingly, we have added a paragraph explaining how ecological engineering practices can be integrated with rice planting, crop management, and harvesting operations. The revised text is provided below.
“Ecological engineering practices are generally compatible with rice production when properly designed [45, 159, 160]. Flower strips, hedgerows, and nectar-producing plants are typically planted along field edges, where they provide habitat and food resources for natural enemies without reducing the cultivated rice area [44, 158]. These habitats provide nectar, shelter, and alternative resources for natural enemies [45, 77]. During planting and routine crop management, these habitats require only occasional maintenance, such as trimming or replanting, and do not interfere with irrigation, fertilizer application, or pest monitoring [43, 44]. For instance, a well-known ecological engineering program in Zhejiang Province, China, integrated sesame Sesamum indicum planting on rice bunds, reduced nitrogen fertilizer inputs, and avoided insecticide applications during the first 30 days after transplanting. These practices significantly increased the abundance of parasitoids and predatory arthropods, suppressed rice planthopper populations, reduced pesticide use, and maintained rice yields, demonstrating that ecological engineering can be successfully incorporated into routine rice production with minimal disruption to standard farming operations [20, 44, 158].”(page 8, lines 318-332)
Comments 11: Lines 288-329 – Same as above: How can these practices be incorporated into the crop production system in an affordable manner?
Response 11: Thank you for your valuable comment. Accordingly, we have added a paragraph explaining how shelter belts for natural enemies work in the rice cropping system and their affordability.
“Most shelter-based habitat management practices can be incorporated into rice production with minimal additional cost by utilizing existing non-cropped areas and routine field operations [45, 159]. Flower strips, hedgerows, and shelterbelts can be established on field bunds, irrigation canals, and field margins, thereby avoiding competition with rice cultivation while providing shelter and floral resources for natural enemies [20, 45]. Likewise, rice straw can be retained or incorporated after harvest instead of being burned or removed, while green manure crops such as Astragalus sinicus can be grown during the fallow period to provide overwintering habitat for beneficial arthropods while improving soil fertility [74, 159, 161]. Conserving naturally occurring grasses and compatible vegetation around field edges requires little additional investment, and integrating Zizania latifolia or vegetable crops into suitable production systems can provide both ecological and economic benefits by enhancing natural enemy populations and strengthening biological control [45, 156, 159]. Because these practices rely primarily on locally available resources and are incorporated into routine crop management, they require relatively low establishment costs while reducing pesticide dependence, conserving biodiversity, and supporting long-term biological control.” (page 9, lines 355-370).
Comments 12: Line 300 – It would be helpful to the reader to include the common name (Chinese milkvetch) and the family (Fabaceae). I think many readers won’t be familiar with the scientific names of these plants. This should also be done for other species that are mentioned. Also, should the author's name be included with the scientific name?
Response 12: We agree with this comment. Therefore, we have included the common names and family names of plant species throughout the manuscript as suggested.
[Chinese milkvetch (Astragalus sinicus L.) (Fabaceae), Manchurian wild rice (Zizania latifolia (Griseb) (poaceae), sesame (Sesamum indicum L.) (Pedaliaceae), Leersia (Leersia sayanuka Ohwi) (Poaceae), Chinese chaste tree (Vitex negundo L.) (Lamiaceae), peach (Prunus persica (L.) Batsch) (Rosaceae), Basil (Ocimum basilicum L.) (Lamiaceae), Mung bean (Vigna radiata (L.) R. Wilczek) (Fabaceae), buckwheat (Fagopyrum esculentum Moench) (Polygonaceae), sweet alyssum (Lobularia maritima (L.) Desv.) (Brassicaceae), green leafhopper (Nephotettix virescens Distant) (Cicadellidae)).
Comments 13: Line 374 – If referring to the genus, Coccinella should be italicized.
Response 13: Thank you for your valuable suggestion. We agree and have italicized the genus Coccinella as suggested.
Comments 14: Lines 383-384 – “delphacids” would be more succinct.
Response 14: Agree. We have replaced Delphinidae with “delphacids” as suggested on page 11, line 449.
Comments 15: Lines 393-408 – scientific names should be italicized
Response 15: Thank you for your valuable suggestion. We agree and have italicized L. sayanuka and Zizania accordingly (page 11, lines 461 and 471).
Comments 16: Is there any information on how far into the rice fields these natural enemies migrate? Or is the benefit limited to the area near the flower strip?
Response 16: Thank you very much for your constructive suggestions. We have tried to search for and read papers that show how far the natural enemies of rice pests can migrate from flower strips to the entire rice field, and included one short paragraph on pages 13 and 14, lines 553-562, as indicated below. “Generally, Predators and parasitoids typically disperse from flower strips into adjacent rice fields, where their biological control effects are greatest near the habitat and gradually decline with increasing distance [20, 45, 160]. The extent of dispersal varies among species and is influenced by landscape structure, habitat connectivity, and the rice growth stage. Egg parasitoids, such as Anagrus spp. and Oligosita spp., actively disperse up to 10–30 m from flowering strips while searching for host insects [56]. Likewise, generalist predators, including spiders and ladybird beetles, move from flower strips into rice crops, although their abundance generally decreases farther from the habitat [56]. In contrast, highly mobile flying predators, such as dragonflies and lacewings, can readily colonize entire rice fields and are therefore less dependent on the proximity of flowering strips [3].”
References
Comment 17: Line 677 – Journal title should be in italics.
Response 17: Agree. We have abbreviated and italicized the journal title as suggested (page 18, line 759).
Comments 18: Line 877 – First letters of journal title should be capitalized.
Response 18: Thank you for your valuable suggestion. We have revised the journal title by capitalizing the initial letters and italicizing it, as suggested (page 22, line 987).
Comment 19: Line 913 – Journal title should be in italics.
Response 19: Thank you for your valuable suggestion. We have italicized the text as suggested (page 23, line 1027).
Comments 20: Line 928 – Should the journal title be abbreviated?
Response 20: Thank you for your valuable suggestion. We have abbreviated the journal title as suggested (page 23, line 1043).
Reviewer 2 Report
Comments and Suggestions for Authorsthe text requires some corrections
Comments for author File:
Comments.pdf
Author Response
Response to Reviewer 2
Thank you very much for taking the time to review our manuscript. We sincerely appreciate your constructive comments and suggestions. Below, we provide a detailed, point-by-point response to each of your comments. All corresponding revisions and corrections have been incorporated into the revised manuscript and are highlighted using Track Changes in the resubmitted files.
Comment 1: Revise the text in the table
Response 1: We appreciate your observation on this matter. We have made the necessary modifications to the columns of the table for improved clarity (page 5, lines 204-205).
Comments 2: Add space before "1" on line 247.
Response 2: Thank you for your suggestion. We have added a space before "1" as recommended (page 7, line 276).
Comment 3: Space added before "2" on line 257.
Response 3: We appreciate your input on this. A space before "2" has been added as suggested (page 7, line 288).
Comment 4: Add space before "1&2" on line 299.
Response 4: Thank you for bringing this to our attention. We have added a space before "1&2" as requested (page 8, line 345).
Comment 5: Add “L.” after Astragalus sinicus on line 300.
Response 5: Thank you for your recommendation. We have included "L." after Astragalus sinicus as suggested (page 8, lines 346-347).
Comment 6: Add “Turcz. ex-Stapf” after Zizania latifolia on line 303.
Response 6: We appreciate your suggestion. We have added "Turcz. ex-Stapf" after Zizania latifolia as you indicated (page 8, line 350-351).
Comment 7: Delete L. after Astragalus sinicus on line 317.
Response 7: Agree. We have deleted L. after Astragalus sinicus as suggested (page 8, line 381).
Comment 8: Delete “(Griseb.) Turcz. ex-Stapf” after Zizania latifolia on lines 323 and 324.
Response 8: Thank you for your attention to detail. We have removed “(Griseb.) Turcz. ex-Stapf” after Zizania latifolia as suggested (page 9, line 381).
Comment 9: Add a space between the comma and “(e)” in Figure 1 on line 333.
Response 9: We appreciate your keen eye for detail. A space has been added between the comma and “(e)” in Figure 1 as recommended (page 10, line 396).
Comment 10: Please correct the comments under 3.3.2, from page 346 to 436.
Response 10: Thank you for your constructive feedback. We have made the necessary modifications to all comments under the subtitle 3.3.2 as you suggested.
Comment 10: There are comments from pages 624 to 928 that require correction.
Response 10: Thank you very much for your insights. We have carefully revised all the comments as suggestions (page 18, line 704).
Reviewer 3 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsThe presented manuscript provides a valuable literature review on the possibilities of reducing the use of chemical plant protection products in rice cultivation through the application of biological and ecological methods. Based on numerous scientific publications, the authors present the relationships between landscape structure, biodiversity, and the effectiveness of the natural regulation of pest populations. Particularly valuable is the concise synthesis of practical solutions, such as flower strips, banker plants, the conservation of non-crop habitats, and ecological engineering, which may serve as an alternative or complement to conventional chemical plant protection.
This review article provides a comprehensive summary of the current state of knowledge while also identifying directions for the further development of sustainable plant protection strategies. Particular recognition should be given to the authors for emphasizing the need for future research addressing the long-term effectiveness of the proposed approaches, their economic feasibility, and the impact of climate change on the functioning of agroecosystems.
The manuscript is scientifically valuable; however, redundancy of content is evident in several sections. In particular, information concerning the role of natural enemies, the importance of landscape diversity, and the functions of flower strips and banker plants is repeated. Some information also appears twice in different parts of the manuscript, for example: “Diverse flower strips (≥2 sown species) increase natural enemy abundance by 70% (±24.7 SE) on average; each additional plant species increases natural enemy abundance by approximately 3.5–4.1% [59].” - this statement is repeated in lines 456 and also in 501.
Combining the sections devoted to habitat resources, landscape diversity, and the mechanisms supporting beneficial organisms would improve the overall clarity of the manuscript and reduce unnecessary repetition of the same arguments.
Please also pay attention to Table 1. The spacing between the column headings should be increased, as this would improve the readability of the table.
Despite the noticeable repetition of some topics, the manuscript represents a valuable source of information and clearly demonstrates the potential of biological pest regulation methods to reduce reliance on pesticides while supporting more environmentally sustainable agricultural production systems.
Author Response
Response to Reviewer 3
Thank you very much for taking the time to review our manuscript. We sincerely appreciate your constructive comments and suggestions. Below, we provide a detailed, point-by-point response to each of your comments. All corresponding revisions and corrections have been incorporated into the revised manuscript and are highlighted using Track Changes in the resubmitted files.
Comment 1: The manuscript is scientifically valuable; however, redundancy of content is evident in several sections. In particular, information concerning the role of natural enemies, the importance of landscape diversity, and the functions of flower strips and banker plants is repeated. Some information also appears twice in different parts of the manuscript, for example: “Diverse flower strips (≥2 sown species) increase natural enemy abundance by 70% (±24.7 SE) on average; each additional plant species increases natural enemy abundance by approximately 3.5–4.1% [59].” This statement is repeated in lines 456 and also in 501.
Response 1: Thank you for pointing out this comment. We have tried to remove some of the repeated ideas as suggested. Example: “Diverse flower strips (≥2 sown species) increase natural enemy abundance by 70% (±24.7 SE) on average; each additional plant species increases natural enemy abundance by approximately 3.5–4.1% [59]. “Deleted from (page 13, line 523-525).
Comments 2: Please also pay attention to Table 1. The spacing between the column headings should be increased, as this would improve the readability of the table.
Response 2: Agree. We have modified the spacing between column headings as suggested (page 5, lines 204-205).