Review Reports
- Mariyam Masood 1,2,
- Zafar Iqbal 3,* and
- Rob W. Briddon 1
- et al.
Reviewer 1: Anonymous Reviewer 2: Sujan Dawadi
Round 1
Reviewer 1 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsMajor Comments
Lines 89–100: The study investigates not only Arsenophonus but also other endosymbionts. Revise the study aim to ensure consistency with the title and results.
Table 1: The table includes a primer set for Fritschea, which is not mentioned in the Introduction. Include relevant information about this bacterium in the Introduction.
Lines 177–182: Add information to the Introduction about Bemisia tabaci species, particularly their distribution in the study region.
Subsection 3.2: Restructure this subsection for clarity. First, report negative PCR results for Asia II-5 and Asia II-7. Then, present all other findings. Clarify the discrepancy: why do 274 whiteflies represent only four species here, when lines 121 and 132 refer to six species? Verify the numbers and rewrite accordingly.
Subsection 3.4: The prevalence percentages for each symbiont do not align with those in Figure 2 (e.g., “Arsenophonus was more common, 80% (100/124) in the Punjab region,” but Figure 2 shows 100 (43.1%)). Explain this discrepancy. Standardize the presentation of frequencies throughout (e.g., by frequency then region, or region then frequency).
Lines 218–220: Provide data on cryptic species distribution in the study regions (as described in Subsection 3.1) to support this statement.
Subsection 3.5: The term “infection probability” is inappropriate in this context. Replace it with a more suitable term throughout the manuscript and figures, or justify its use.
Figure 4:
- Explain why Cardinium and Hamiltonella have many more sequences than Arsenophonus, despite the latter's prevalence.
- On the Arsenophonus tree, three sequences lack GenBank accessions. Correct or explain this.
- Indicate the loci used for tree reconstruction.
- Some labels on the Cardinium tree are bolded. Clarify if this has significance.
Lines 286–294: Justify emphasizing Arsenophonus as dominant when Cardinium frequency is nearly as high.
Line 295: Clarify why reference is made to only two samples when Figure 4 and supplementary materials (SM) show five.
Lines 376–378: in Supplementary Table: List all GenBank accession numbers for symbionts directly in the cells (replacing letters A, C, H, etc.). Remove the last column, as it is unnecessary. Define abbreviations in the “Prov.” column. Explain the yellow highlighting. Improve table formatting overall. Address the absence of Hamiltonella data for sample 213.
Minor Comments
Lines 109–110: Report any correlation between host plant and B. tabaci endosymbiont community if possible.
Table 1: Align the primer name “23GISR” at the same level as the primer sequences (currently, it aligns with part of U23GISR).
Line 173: Clarify “Asia II-1ll the figures were generated…” and define “Asia II-1ll,” which is not mentioned earlier.
Line 179: prevailed.
Line 180: common biotype
Line 186: Standardize “Asia 1” or “Asia I” throughout the manuscript, figures, and main text.
Subsection 3.3: Consider adding a visualization (e.g., like Figure 2 or a bar chart) for these results.
Line 200: Define “biotype” (is it synonymous with “cryptic species”)?
Line 216: Add missing bracket.
Line 351: Clarify “ticks’ spider.”
Comments on the Quality of English LanguageExtensive proofreading and editing by a specialist (not AI) is required!
Author Response
Please find the authors' point-by-point response to Reviewer 1's queries in the attached PDF file.
Author Response File:
Author Response.pdf
Reviewer 2 Report
Comments and Suggestions for Authors- Title (Lines 1–3): The title is long and does not clearly highlight novelty. I would include a clearer novelty focus, for example: ‘highlighting its role in virus transmission’ to make the title more impactful.
- Abstract (Lines 16–42): No clear statement of novelty, and I believe it overclaims Arsenophonus' role. I would include a clear novelty line, like: ‘This is the first study linking symbiont distribution with cryptic species in Pakistan. I would also write more cautiously: ‘suggesting a potential role’ instead of direct claims about virus transmission.
- Lines 53–57: Weak problem statement for Pakistan. That should be like this: “There is limited data linking symbionts and virus dynamics in Pakistan.”
- Lines 63–66: No clear research gap explanation. I would suggest you write something like: ‘Despite known roles of symbionts, their distribution and epidemiological role in Pakistan remain unclear.’
- Lines 97–102: No clear hypothesis or research question. Please include a hypothesis in a measurable or directional way, like: ‘We hypothesize that Arsenophonus dominance is linked with Asia II-1 and virus spread.’
- Lines 110–112: It is an old sampling (2012–2014) and is not justified. Please add the justification. Do these data provide baseline information for long-term trends? Do they take this long to analyze after data collection? Or any other reason?
- Lines 131–139: Is there any limitation of the PCR method? I bet there are many limitations. PCR may miss low-level infections; advanced methods could improve detection. Yes?
- Lines 161–168: It is better to include details such as test values and degrees of freedom for clarity.
- Lines 169–172: I believe it is a weak method (Pearson correlation between binary data). Justify it. This method may not fully represent ecological interactions. Don’t we want to see interactions?
- Lines 24–25 vs 176–178: I find an inconsistency in the number of species (3 vs 6). Is it like six species were identified, but only the major ones were analyzed further?
- Lines 185–186: Sample imbalance (very few Asia I samples). Any justifications? I would be very cautious because an unequal sample size may affect comparisons.
- Lines 194–197: Exclusion of species is not properly explained. Were those excluded due to low sample size or no amplification?
- Lines 230–231: Only p-values given, no full stats. I always prefer full statistical details (f, df, p value), which also increase transparency. Journals may have different rules.
- Lines 251–256: We most of the time think correlation is causation or overinterpret correlations as biological interaction. Please present this as a co-occurrence rather than direct interaction.
- Lines 329–333: I believe Arsenophonus' role is overstated. I would tone it down. It may just contribute to transmission rather than to the strong claims your paper makes.
- Lines 295–300: Weak explanation for low Rickettsia. I would include environmental or ecological reasons behind this.
- Lines 360–363: Can we go over ecological context (climate, cropping, and pesticides)? Do environmental factors influence symbiont distribution?
- For the entire Discussion section. I would include a paragraph in which the paper describes the limitations, obstacles, or factors that might affect the experiment. For example, the study is limited by an old sample, the use of PCR, and a lack of functional validation.
- Conclusion (Lines 369–374): Are we too general? And slightly overclaiming? I would probably write like this: ‘These findings provide a baseline and require further functional studies.’
Author Response
Please find the authors' point-by-point response to Reviewer 2's queries in the attached PDF file
Author Response File:
Author Response.pdf
Round 2
Reviewer 1 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsThe manuscript has improved; however, several critical issues require correction.
Line 230: The designation “(Asia II-1)” requires no parentheses.
Authors' response to previous comment: “Arsenophonus was analyzed using both 16S and 23S rRNA. In the original submission, only 16S-based trees were shown, underrepresenting Arsenophonus. This has now been corrected by constructing a combined 16S+23S phylogeny, improving its representation.”
However:
- The Materials and Methods section contains no mention of 16S rDNA primers for Arsenophonus; only 23S rDNA is referenced in the text and Table 1.
- The initial phylogenetic trees were appropriate, except that the figure legend failed to specify they were based on 16S rDNA. The current Arsenophonus tree is unreadable.
- Combining 16S and 23S sequences in a single tree is inappropriate. Present a 23S rDNA tree for Arsenophonus as a separate figure or, alternatively, as a supplementary figure.
Lines 309–313: Revise according to changes in the phylogenetic tree presentation.
Lines 409–410: Change “Like” to “like”. Also there should be “spider mites” instead of “ticks, spider”. Please read the cited articles carefully.
Supplementary table: Insert the “Symbionts” row above the bacterial designations. Standardize “Asia II 1” to “Asia II-1”, consistent with the main text.
Author Response
Please find the authors' response in the attached file.
Author Response File:
Author Response.pdf
Reviewer 2 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsThe manuscript has become better. There are a number of problems that have been solved quite well. But there are also some problems that require further attention.
The problem of being unable to produce full statistical outputs (F values, etc.) due to the lack of access to initial data should be mentioned somewhere in the text of the manuscript as one of its limitations.
Even though the authors mentioned that their analysis was based on co-occurrence and not on the ecology of viruses, there are some parts of the Discussion section where correlations seem to be exaggerated.
The authors might want to tone down some phrases concerning the role of Arsenophonus since it has not been proved that the bacteria plays any role in virus transmission.
The explanation provided by the authors for the older sampling time frame is quite logical, yet, this information needs to be reflected in the manuscript.
Overall, I still recommend adding a limitations paragraph to the manuscript.
Author Response
Please find the authors' response in the attached file.
Author Response File:
Author Response.pdf
Round 3
Reviewer 1 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsAlthough the comment that “combining 16S and 23S sequences in a single phylogenetic tree is inappropriate,” the authors have retained this unchanged. Moreover, they consider these distinct loci as separate clades within the tree, which constitutes a substantial error.
Additionally, it remains unclear why the authors employed two loci (16S and 23S) to detect Arsenophonus, whereas other bacteria were assessed using only a single locus. No justification is provided in either the Materials and Methods or Results sections.
Line 456: Figure S1 requires a legend.
Author Response
For authors reponse, please see the attached file.
Author Response File:
Author Response.pdf
Reviewer 2 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsNA
Author Response
Authors could not find any comment.