Review Reports
- Zeqin Feng 1,
- Houhun Li 1,2,* and
- Xiuying Zhang 1,*
- et al.
Reviewer 1: Anonymous Reviewer 2: Anonymous Reviewer 3: Anonymous
Round 1
Reviewer 1 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsThis is a valuable contribution to the taxonomy and distribution of Scrobipalpa. While it requires some minor editing, I consider it otherwise suitable for publication. I have indicated my few corrections within the manuscript.
Comments for author File:
Comments.pdf
Author Response
|
Comments 1: The Atlas of Living Australia lists 6 species. If it's actually 5, a comment about that would be nice.
|
|
Response 1: According to the introduction in Bidzilya et al. (2022), a total of 5 species of this genus are distributed in Australia. However, after rechecking, although Bidzilya (2021) also recorded 5 Australian species in the introduction, one additional species, Scrobipalpa ergasima (Meyrick, 1916), was added in the main text of that paper. Therefore, this genus indeed includes six species in Australia. This has been revised in Line 51 of the original text. |
|
Comments 2: Check the numbers: Li and Bidzylia 2019 reported 71 species, later + 1 (S. tenebrata), 72 in total? If in Bidylia and Li 2010 56 sp. +9 +12 in Li and Bidzylia 2019 and +1 (S. tenebrata) is 78? |
|
Response 2: Li and Bidzilya (2019) documented a total of 72 species, and Bidzilya and Li (2010) recorded 56 species. According to statistics, 76 species of the genus Scrobipalpa are distributed in China. Later, Bidzilya et al. (2022) added one further Chinese species, S. tenebrata (Povolný, 2001), and synonymized S. zouhari Povolný, 1984 under S. rebeli (Preissecker, 1915); both species were previously recorded from China. Accordingly, prior to the present study, the total number of species of this genus is 76. The revisions and additions have been made in lines 55–57 of the article. |
|
Comments 3: TD? [Line 866] |
|
Response 3: The TD of this species is unknown at present. |
|
Comments 4: Check the numbers as in introduction. |
|
Response 4: The revisions have been made in lines 1034–1035 of the original text. Revised to A total of four new species and seven newly recorded species for China are identified, and a list of 48 Scrobipalpa species known from Xinjiang is provided. [in lines 886–888]. |
|
Comments 5: I would put this at the beginning of the article, next to the methods. |
|
Response 5: In our initial submission of the paper Taxonomy of the Genus Ornativalva Gozmány, 1955 (Lepidoptera: Gelechiidae) from China to the journal Insects, we placed Abbreviations at the beginning of the article. However, the journal editor requested that they be placed at the end. We therefore followed the editor’s instruction and positioned Abbreviations before the references in that paper. |
|
Comments 6: Was ZIN previously called ZIRAS, or was ZIRAS previously called ZIN? Also, check other places where the name has been changed. |
|
Response 6: Was ZIN previously called ZIRAS. The institution has been revised to its present name ZIN, checked and revised all depositories accordingly in the original text. SDEI Senckenberg German Entomological Institute, Eberswalde, Germany (SDEI formely name as DEI). MINGA Muzeul National de Istorie Naturala Grigore Antipa, Bucharest, Romania. NHMUK Natural History Museum, Department of Zoology, London, UK (NHMUK formerly name as BMNH). TJNHM Insect Collection of Tianjin Natural History Museum, Tianjin, China. DNMNH Ditsong National Museum of Natural History, Pretoria, South Africa (DNMNH formerly name as TMSA). ZIN Zoological Institute, Russian Academy of Sciences, Saint-Petersburg, Russia (ZIN formerly name as ZIRAS). |
Author Response File:
Author Response.pdf
Reviewer 2 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsLines 26–27: Four species, Scrobipalpa apicidentata sp. nov., S. latiuscula sp. nov., S. subargenteonigra sp. nov. and S. xinjiangensis sp. nov. are described as new. For each of these four species, is necessary the registration of each new taxon in ZooBank with one individual LSID (Life Science Identifier) for each new species, in the format: urn:lsid:zoobank.org:pub:XXXXXXXX-XXXX-XXXX-XXXX-XXXXXXXXXXXX
The authorship of the new species is inconsistent. In the section titles (line 87, line 279, etc.), the new species are attributed to “Li, Bidzilya & Zhang sp. nov.”, but in the Abstract and in the Checklist they appear without explicit authors. The authorship should be uniform and correct throughout.
The authors of the manuscript are Feng, Li, Bidzilya, and Zhang. The authors of the species are Li, Bidzilya & Zhang. Please explain why Zeqin Feng is not included among the authors of the species, given that he is the first author of the article.
In the Simple Summary, the authors state that 15 species of the genus Scrobipalpa are treated (line 18) and that the number of Scrobipalpa species now recognized in Xinjiang is 48. However, in the Introduction (lines 61–65), the authors state that they describe 4 new species, report 7 species as new for China based on material collected in Xinjiang, and add 4 species new for Xinjiang. In that case, if 7 are new for China (and therefore also new for Xinjiang) plus another 4 species are new for Xinjiang, this would mean 11 species are newly recorded for Xinjiang. This paragraph needs to be clarified, and the Simple Summary should be revised accordingly.
The total number of Scrobipalpa species known from China is given as 76 in the Introduction (line 56), but in the Discussion (line 878), the authors state that 48 of the 71 species have been recorded from Xinjiang. How many species are actually known from China: 76 or 71?
Of the 4 newly described species, Scrobipalpa apicidentata Li, Bidzilya & Zhang sp. nov. is described only on the basis of males, while females remain completely unknown. Although this is sometimes unavoidable, the authors do not discuss this limitation either in the Abstract or in the Discussion. The authors should explicitly indicate which new species lack female descriptions and discuss the implications for identification.
In the manuscript, the GPS coordinates of the collecting localities are given in the format 37.44° 89 N, 78.14° E. In my opinion, they would be much more useful in decimal degrees format (i.e. in the format 38.8897°, 77.0089°).
Lines 340–342 note significant forewing variability in S. latiuscula. The authors should address this issue more fully in the Discussion section and discuss whether this variability could cause confusion with other species.
Line 364: “Paratypes: Xinjiang: 4 ♂, same data as holotype, slide Nos. FZQ25407, ZYQ25255.” Four paratypes are mentioned, but only two slides are listed. Why?
Line 424: “Paratypes: Xinjiang: 130♂96♀, …” The authors examined a very large number of specimens, but the number of slides studied is significantly lower. Why?
Line 425: the fifth slide, with code number ZYQ286♂, should probably be corrected to ZYQ25286♂.
Lines 510–871, Checklist of the genus Scrobipalpa in Xinjiang, China: In this chapter, I think it is necessary to clearly indicate which species were previously known from Xinjiang, which are newly recorded for Xinjiang, which are new to science, and which are newly recorded for China.
Lines 510–871, Checklist of the genus Scrobipalpa in Xinjiang, China: The species are presented in alphabetical order, but species 21, 22, 23, and 24 (species whose names begin with the letter “g”) should come after species number 15, Scrobipalpa fusca Bidzilya & Li, 2010. For consistency, the species order should be revised.
For a taxonomic revision of this scope (48 species, of which 4 are newly described), a dichotomous identification key is needed. Or at least a key covering the newly described species and the newly recorded ones.
The Discussion section is rather weak and, in its current form, too short. I suggest that the authors discuss more extensively the biogeographic context of the new species and the new records. Altitudinal distribution and possible habitat preferences could also be addressed. A comparison with Palaearctic diversity is also needed, together with an argument for the importance of Xinjiang for the diversity of the genus Scrobipalpa.
Author Response
|
Review 2 |
|
Comments 1: Four species, Scrobipalpa apicidentata sp. nov., S. latiuscula sp. nov., S. subargenteonigra sp. nov. and S. xinjiangensis sp. nov. are described as new. For each of these four species, is necessary the registration of each new taxon in ZooBank with one individual LSID (Life Science Identifier) for each new species, in the format: urn:lsid:zoobank.org:pub:XXXXXXXX-XXXX-XXXX-XXXX-XXXXXXXXXXXX. |
|
Response 1: Thank you for reminding me. Due to recent network issues, we have applied to resolve them as soon as possible. |
|
Comments 2: The authorship of the new species is inconsistent. In the section titles (line 87, line 279, etc.), the new species are attributed to “Li, Bidzilya & Zhang sp. nov.”, but in the Abstract and in the Checklist they appear without explicit authors. The authorship should be uniform and correct throughout. |
|
Response 2: Agreed; the revisions have been made in both the abstract and the species list. |
|
Comments 3: The authors of the manuscript are Feng, Li, Bidzilya, and Zhang. The authors of the species are Li, Bidzilya & Zhang. Please explain why Zeqin Feng is not included among the authors of the species, given that he is the first author of the article. |
|
Response 3: The first author is a student. Based on the current situation, she will not continue working in taxonomy after graduation, nor will she take any responsibility for these new species. |
|
Comments 4: In the Simple Summary, the authors state that 15 species of the genus Scrobipalpa are treated (line 18) and that the number of Scrobipalpa species now recognized in Xinjiang is 48. However, in the Introduction (lines 61–65), the authors state that they describe 4 new species, report 7 species as new for China based on material collected in Xinjiang, and add 4 species new for Xinjiang. In that case, if 7 are new for China (and therefore also new for Xinjiang) plus another 4 species are new for Xinjiang, this would mean 11 species are newly recorded for Xinjiang. This paragraph needs to be clarified, and the Simple Summary should be revised accordingly. |
|
Response 4: From a taxonomic perspective, new species and newly recorded species from China represent the key innovations of this study. The 48 Scrobipalpa species recorded from Xinjiang already include the newly recorded species for China, so we do not specifically state that the number of newly recorded species for Xinjiang increases to 11. |
|
Comments 5: The total number of Scrobipalpa species known from China is given as 76 in the Introduction (line 56), but in the Discussion (line 878), the authors state that 48 of the 71 species have been recorded from Xinjiang. How many species are actually known from China: 76 or 71? |
|
Response 5: The total of 76 species of Scrobipalpa known from China in the Introduction does not include the 4 new species and 7 newly recorded species. I have revised line 60 to state that "Prior to the present study, 76 species of Scrobipalpa were known from China". However, in the Discussion section (Line 893), we think the new species and newly recorded species identified in this study should be added. I have accordingly revised the total to 87 species (76 + 4 + 7 = 87). |
|
Comments 6: Of the 4 newly described species, Scrobipalpa apicidentata Li, Bidzilya & Zhang sp. nov. is described only on the basis of males, while females remain completely unknown. Although this is sometimes unavoidable, the authors do not discuss this limitation either in the Abstract or in the Discussion. The authors should explicitly indicate which new species lack female descriptions and discuss the implications for identification. |
|
Response 6: From a taxonomic perspective, it is common to not obtain heterosexual specimens. In the study of moths, the complexity and importance of male genitalia are much complex than that of females, which can confirm the species. On the contrary, identification based solely on females is often unreliable. Of course, having both sexes is the best condition for describing a species. |
|
Comments 7: In the manuscript, the GPS coordinates of the collecting localities are given in the format 37.44° 89 N, 78.14° E. In my opinion, they would be much more useful in decimal degrees format (i.e. in the format 38.8897°, 77.0089°). |
|
Response 7: The longitude and latitude data are entirely derived from the information on the specimen labels, which are fixed and cannot be altered. Nevertheless, thank you for your valuable suggestion. In future collecting activities, we will take this matter into consideration in future fieldwork. |
|
Comments 8: Lines 340–342 note significant forewing variability in S. latiuscula. The authors should address this issue more fully in the Discussion section and discuss whether this variability could cause confusion with other species. |
|
Response 8: Thank you for your suggestion. In fact, we have already compared this species with morphologically similar species in its diagnosis and documented its variation in the "Variations" section. Therefore, it seems unnecessary to repeat these in the discussion. |
|
Comments 9: Line 364: “Paratypes: Xinjiang: 4 ♂, same data as holotype, slide Nos. FZQ25407, ZYQ25255.” Four paratypes are mentioned, but only two slides are listed. Why? |
|
Response 9: As the diagnostic characters of this species are distinct, it can be distinguished from other species by morphology alone. Therefore, under the same collection locality, date and collector, only two specimens are generally dissected. Since we have four specimens in total, the other two were not dissected so as not to waste the material. Similar situations are handled in this way, and there is no need to dissect all specimens. |
|
Comments 10: Line 424: “Paratypes: Xinjiang: 130♂96♀, …” The authors examined a very large number of specimens, but the number of slides studied is significantly lower. Why? |
|
Response 10: Please see above. |
|
Comments 11: Line 425: the fifth slide, with code number ZYQ286♂, should probably be corrected to ZYQ25286♂. |
|
Response 11: This is indeed ZYQ25286 (Line 434), and revised in the original text. Thanks. |
|
Comments 12: Lines 510–871, Checklist of the genus Scrobipalpa in Xinjiang, China: In this chapter, I think it is necessary to clearly indicate which species were previously known from Xinjiang, which are newly recorded for Xinjiang, which are new to science, and which are newly recorded for China. |
|
Response 12: From a taxonomic perspective, the new species and newly recorded species represent the key innovations of this study. Therefore, the new species are marked with ‘sp. nov.’ in the checklist, and comments are added “Note” at the end of the newly recorded species. However, if the newly added species in Xinjiang are also marked, it would fail to highlight the importance of the former two. |
|
Comments 13: Lines 510–871, Checklist of the genus Scrobipalpa in Xinjiang, China: The species are presented in alphabetical order, but species 21, 22, 23, and 24 (species whose names begin with the letter “g”) should come after species number 15, Scrobipalpa fusca Bidzilya & Li, 2010. For consistency, the species order should be revised. |
|
Response 13: Thank you for your suggestion. We have revised the relevant part in the original text and adjusted the order of some references accordingly (Line 652-671). |
|
Comments 14: For a taxonomic revision of this scope (48 species, of which 4 are newly described), a dichotomous identification key is needed. Or at least a key covering the newly described species and the newly recorded ones. |
|
Response 14: The inclusion of an identification key was indeed considered earlier. However, to achieve a more systematic treatment of the genus, we intend to present a key to the genus Scrobipalpa from China instead. Given its large size, comprising 87 species, this key will be provided in a subsequent study. |
|
Comments 15: The Discussion section is rather weak and, in its current form, too short. I suggest that the authors discuss more extensively the biogeographic context of the new species and the new records. Altitudinal distribution and possible habitat preferences could also be addressed. A comparison with Palaearctic diversity is also needed, together with an argument for the importance of Xinjiang for the diversity of the genus Scrobipalpa. |
|
Response 15: Agree. We have expanded and improved the Discussion section in the original text (Line 883‒935). |
Reviewer 3 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsThis well-written paper provides an overview of the Scrobipalpa genus found in northwestern China, including the description of four new species. From a taxonomic and zoological nomenclature perspective, the work is of exceptional quality. It is based on solid material and illustrated with excellent drawings of the genitalia and images of the butterflies themselves. This is undoubtedly an important step in our understanding of the family Gelechiidae, and it deserves prompt publication to make it accessible to specialists. The manuscript is structured in a manner typical of taxonomic studies. It includes the sections Introduction, Materials and Methods, Taxonomy, and Discussion. While I have no comments on the first three sections, the Discussion section seems inappropriate to its title. It lacks a discussion of the results obtained in the context of the data and knowledge previously obtained by other authors. In principle, I believe the Discussion section is unnecessary for purely taxonomic papers. I would suggest the authors either revise this section to include comparisons and references with previous authors, or simply rename it "Conclusion."
Type localities are uniformly listed as country names, for example, Mongolia, and so on. This is theoretically possible, but somewhat uncertain given the sizes of these countries. For example, northern and southern Mongolia are very different territories in terms of climate, landscape, and biogeography. Personally, while reading the text, I longed for more specific information about the type localities, which I am sure is present in the original descriptions of the taxa.
Overall, I am satisfied with the originality and quality of the information presented in the manuscript. I am confident that the manuscript should be published after minor revisions.
Author Response
|
Review 3 |
|
Comments 1: the Discussion section seems inappropriate to its title. It lacks a discussion of the results obtained in the context of the data and knowledge previously obtained by other authors. In principle, I believe the Discussion section is unnecessary for purely taxonomic papers. I would suggest the authors either revise this section to include comparisons and references with previous authors, or simply rename it "Conclusion." |
|
Response 1: We believe that certain parts of the article (including suggestions from other reviewers) need to be discussed, so we have made corresponding revisions and supplements to the discussion section (Line 883‒935). |
|
Comments 2: Type localities are uniformly listed as country names, for example, Mongolia, and so on. This is theoretically possible, but somewhat uncertain given the sizes of these countries. For example, northern and southern Mongolia are very different territories in terms of climate, landscape, and biogeography. |
|
Response 2: Thank you for your valuable suggestion. In fact, we had already considered your advice. However, this paper primarily focuses on the genus Scrobipalpa in Xinjiang, China, and therefore does not provide detailed type localities for species from other countries. |
Round 2
Reviewer 2 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsDear authors, thank you for your detailed responses and for the substantial improvements you have made to the manuscript. Several points, however, still require attention before the manuscript can be considered fully revised:
- I appreciate the explanation regarding the network issues. However, in the current version of the manuscript, all four new species still appear with an empty placeholder, namely (LSID urn:lsid:zoobank.org:act:?), at lines 91, 284, 362 and 423. According to ICZN Article 8.5, a valid LSID must be obtained for each new taxon prior to publication, otherwise the names will not be available under the Code. Please note also a small clarification: the LSID prefix for newly described taxa is urn:lsid:zoobank.org:act: (for nomenclatural acts), not urn:lsid:zoobank.org:pub: (which is reserved for the publication itself). The latter must additionally be registered for the article. I therefore kindly ask the authors to:
-register each of the four new species in ZooBank and insert the resulting act-LSIDs into the manuscript;
-register the publication itself and add the corresponding pub-LSID, as required by the journal.
This point is essential and must be resolved before the manuscript proceeds further.
- I understand the authors' argument that, from a taxonomic perspective, the new species and the species newly recorded for China are the principal contributions. Nevertheless, the inconsistency I raised in the first round is a numerical one and remains unresolved. The Simple Summary states that "15 species of the genus Scrobipalpa are recognized during this study", while the Introduction reports 4 new species + 7 newly recorded for China + 4 added to Xinjiang = 15. The arithmetic is internally consistent, but the wording does not make it clear that all 15 of these species are new additions to the Xinjiang fauna (11 of which are also new for China, including 4 new to science). I therefore reiterate my suggestion to add a single clarifying sentence in the Simple Summary or at the end of the Introduction, for example: "Of these 15 species newly added to the Xinjiang fauna, 4 are described as new to science, 7 are newly recorded for China, and 4 are newly recorded for Xinjiang." This adds no length to the manuscript but resolves the ambiguity for the reader.
- I fully agree with the authors that male genitalia in Gnorimoschemini provide reliable diagnostic characters and that female-only descriptions are problematic. My original concern was not the validity of the description but its transparency to the reader. A reader of the Abstract or Discussion currently has no way of knowing that one of the four new species is known only from males. I would therefore suggest a brief mention — a single sentence — in the Discussion, e.g. "The female of S. apicidentata sp. nov. remains unknown; future collecting in the type locality (Pishan and Yecheng counties) is needed to complete its morphological characterisation." This is standard practice in modern revisions and adds value rather than weakening the description.
Line 141: "Shufu 7County" - "Shufu County" (stray digit "7" before "County").
Lines 390–391: "fring" - "fringe" (occurs twice in the description of S. subargenteonigra).
Author Response
|
Review 2 |
|
Comments 1: I appreciate the explanation regarding the network issues. However, in the current version of the manuscript, all four new species still appear with an empty placeholder, namely (LSID urn:lsid:zoobank.org:act:?), at lines 91, 284, 362 and 423. According to ICZN Article 8.5, a valid LSID must be obtained for each new taxon prior to publication, otherwise the names will not be available under the Code. Please note also a small clarification: the LSID prefix for newly described taxa is urn:lsid:zoobank.org:act: (for nomenclatural acts), not urn:lsid:zoobank.org:pub: (which is reserved for the publication itself). The latter must additionally be registered for the article. I therefore kindly ask the authors to: -register each of the four new species in ZooBank and insert the resulting act-LSIDs into the manuscript; -register the publication itself and add the corresponding pub-LSID, as required by the journal. |
|
Response 1: Thanks for the reminder. All registrations have been completed. |
|
Comments 2: I understand the authors' argument that, from a taxonomic perspective, the new species and the species newly recorded for China are the principal contributions. Nevertheless, the inconsistency I raised in the first round is a numerical one and remains unresolved. The Simple Summary states that "15 species of the genus Scrobipalpa are recognized during this study", while the Introduction reports 4 new species + 7 newly recorded for China + 4 added to Xinjiang = 15. The arithmetic is internally consistent, but the wording does not make it clear that all 15 of these species are new additions to the Xinjiang fauna (11 of which are also new for China, including 4 new to science). I therefore reiterate my suggestion to add a single clarifying sentence in the Simple Summary or at the end of the Introduction, for example: "Of these 15 species newly added to the Xinjiang fauna, 4 are described as new to science, 7 are newly recorded for China, and 4 are newly recorded for Xinjiang." This adds no length to the manuscript but resolves the ambiguity for the reader. |
|
Response 2: Many thanks. We have already revised the Simple Summary in the original text. |
|
Comments 3: I fully agree with the authors that male genitalia in Gnorimoschemini provide reliable diagnostic characters and that female-only descriptions are problematic. My original concern was not the validity of the description but its transparency to the reader. A reader of the Abstract or Discussion currently has no way of knowing that one of the four new species is known only from males. I would therefore suggest a brief mention — a single sentence — in the Discussion, e.g. "The female of S. apicidentata sp. nov. remains unknown; future collecting in the type locality (Pishan and Yecheng counties) is needed to complete its morphological characterisation." This is standard practice in modern revisions and adds value rather than weakening the description. |
|
Response 3: Thanks. We have revised the Discussion in the original text. |
|
Comments 4: Line 141: "Shufu 7County" - "Shufu County" (stray digit "7" before "County"). |
|
Response 4: We have removed 7 from the original text. |
|
Comments 5: Lines 390–391: "fring" - "fringe" (occurs twice in the description of S. subargenteonigra). |
|
Response 5: We have revised in the original text. Thank you very much for your careful revision. Provided us with great help. |