Review Reports
- Stefano Botti 1,2,*,
- Luana Conte 3 and
- Elsa Vitale 14
- et al.
Reviewer 1: Anonymous Reviewer 2: Anonymous Reviewer 3: Elissa Foster Reviewer 4: Hepeng Jia
Round 1
Reviewer 1 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsThis is a manuscript by Botti et al that investigates oncology and hematology provider communication skills, perceived communication competence, and training particularly in the area of breaking bad news to patients, within Italy. This is a self-report study, the results of which are striking particularly regarding the heavy emotional and personal burden and toll on health care providers. Results of this can be used to craft better supportive training programs, resources, and systems level interventions to help providers in their role, not only to improve provider quality of life, but thus in turn, ensure quality patient-provider communication, support, and shared decision-making. I have all minor comments as follows.
Line 46 and 47 – The syntax of “increasing stress level was significantly correlated to higher difficulties in breaking bad news evidenced based methods use”. Particularly the “Evidenced based methods use” phrase, can you please re-word this to clarify? To which methods are you referring? Detail would be helpful so that we could craft appropriate training programs.
Line 47 – The conclusion mentions “specific issues”, but the abstract results did not mention any specific issues? Can you please clarify in detail which specific issues? Again, detail would be helpful to help craft training programs.
Line 34 - The first sentence of the abstract: “many nurses and physicians reported difficulties”. For clarity, I think the tense of the verb should be “report” (present tense), rather than “reported” as you are not referring to or citing a single particular study?
Line 38-39 – Please briefly indicate that you used the validated measure the Perceived Stress Scale in addition to the questionnaire in the Methods section of the Abstract as this is a main feature of the analysis.
Line 73-77 – Do you have a citation for this or is this anecdotal evidence?
Line 76 – “engage” to “may engage” would be encouraged as this may not be in all cases
Line 105 – The phrase “with the tool of specialized nurses compared to physicians” I am unclear what these results are saying, can you please reword to clarify?
Line 125 – Were post treatment survivors included in this sample?
Line 146 – Please briefly mention validity and reliability of the PSS as originally reported in its validation papers.
Line 147 – You indicate 508 participants were reached, but only 221 enrolled? Please clarify what you mean by reach and why only 221 were enrolled of these?
Line 151 – It says “obtained” 219 subjects, but I think you mean you “aimed to obtain a sample size of 219”?
Line 165-168 – Please add if you had ethical Institutional Review Board review and what the application number and institution is.
Table 1 – It is unclear why the Degree in Medicine is only 3.2% of your sample, when 68 identified job role as physicians? PhD seems high at 27.6%, but your sample was of nurses and oncologists?
Line 181 – “The text continues here (Figure 2 and Table 2).” I think this sentence should be removed for clarity, I am not sure to what it is referring?
Table 2 – it is unclear what “important to accept patients” means in this context. Is this the original scale item?
209-220 – Given this section is important to assist with training development, can you include the most pressing items from this section in the abstract, so that the reader of the abstract can more directly understand what to highlight when developing training programs?
Table 5 – To help with translation of your findings into education and training, would it be somehow possible to show the frequencies of the items that are in Table 5 overall, in addition to being broken out by PSS score? I think that is what lines 226 through 234 are stating, but it is confusing because the paragraph starts by referring to the PSS (line 226)? Additionally, I am not certain about the use of the word “not” in 233? Regardless, it would be helpful to the reader to indicate which of these items seems to be most frequently reported overall, so that when develop training programs it is clear what the most pressing considerations should be, with a more direct call to action in the Abstract and Discussion based on your findings.
Line 253 and 254 – “A total of 221 Italian physicians”, I think this sentence can be removed as it belongs in the Results section?
Line 310- 328 – To promote clarity in the Discussion for the reader, I think the comparison to other studies paragraphs should go after you discuss your results. I suggest lines 304 to 335 should be moved up to before the comparisons to other study paragraphs to facilitate interpretation.
Line 322 – Do you mean HCPs “worked under moderate stress”, or did they report feeling moderate perceived stress?
Lines 344 – 345 The last sentence of the study is unclear to me, I am not sure what it means and how it would be a limitation?
Comments on the Quality of English LanguageLine 44 - suggestion to change "didn’t" to "did not"
Line 61 – check grammar/syntax
Line 66 – check grammar/syntax
Line 68 – Do you mean hopeful rather than hoping?
Line 112 – Do you mean “communication-related” rather than “communicating”?
Line 117 – check grammar/syntax
Line 123 – check grammar/syntax
Line 147, 151, 158, 161, 164, 187, 227- check use of word “had” versus “were”?
Line 161 – disseminate should be past tense disseminated?
Line 154 – describes should be past tense described?
Line 183 – check grammar/syntax
Line 199 – check grammar/syntax
Line 233 – check tense of observed
Line 289 – check grammar/syntax
Line 295 – check grammar/syntax
Author Response
Please, see the attachment.
Author Response File:
Author Response.pdf
Reviewer 2 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsThis is great work!! Congratulations on your diligent work to expand communication in healthcare.
Edits for article:
Line 35 – “report” instead of “reported”
Line 38 – remove the word “the” before oncology
Line 69 – do you need a reference here?
Line 70 – remove the word “however”
Line 78 – remove “so as”
Line 83 – change “him or herself” to “themselves”
Line 105 – consider just referencing your article instead of saying “our previous study”
Line 114 – throughout the paper, consider relabeling “communication process” as the “difficult conversation” or something along the lines? I find it hard to follow when you say “we explore communicating knowledge and attitudes….after the communication process”. However, I am just saying this because it took me reading that line 3-4 times to understand. So if it makes sense to you all, don’t change it!
Line 123 – remove “in this case”
Line 140 – throughout the paper the word “had” is used where I feel like “was” or “were” is more appropriate? I understand this may be a cultural
Line 149 – I am struggling with the grammar in this paragraph
Line 153 – sample size noted as 219 here but study discusses 221 enrollees?
Line 163 – change to “…who disseminated the questionnaire to all…”
Line 166 – more “hads”
Line 174 – change oncology to say heme-onc (basically include hematology here as well)
Line 183 – is the first sentence a mistake? I don’t see a figure 2.
Line 185 – consider saying “taught them” instead of “learned”
Line 187 – remove the parentheses around self-perceived
Line 189 – change “confident” to “confidence”
Line 225 (after this) – “Talking to the patient” needs to have fixed parentheses
Line 295 – having a hard time understanding these few sentences
Line 310 – this is great!
Line 321 – where did this come from??
Line 331 – use the word concerning instead of worrying
Line 354 – ideally I would like some more elaboration on this aspect
Comments on the Quality of English LanguageThank you for allowing me to be a part of this!
Author Response
Please, see the attachment
Author Response File:
Author Response.pdf
Reviewer 3 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsThe stress experienced by HCPs when breaking bad news, and the relationship between that stress and HCPs preparation to do so, is an important topic of study. The authors emphasize evidence-based techniques and training (such as the SPIKES protocol) as potential antidotes to the stress experienced by HCPs when addressing the needs of patients who are facing difficult diagnoses. In the conclusion of the paper, the authors mention that self awareness, self reflection, and understanding of one's personal communication style are also important factors when addressing stress and increasing communication competence in challenging situations. I would like to see the authors give some consideration, also, to the institutional culture and practices around breaking bad news. The research focused on the "bad news" scenario as one that falls disproportionately to individual practitioners--whether nurses or physicians. The absence of dedicated space for breaking bad news to patients is an indicator that health care institutions do not give adequate consideration to how this is to be done, except that one HCP must take primary responsibility for the conversation, which is stressful. I would like the authors to consider how creating organizational cultures of support for practitioners who regularly work with patients who have life-limiting illnesses might also alleviate some or much of the stress of breaking bad news. Ensuring that there is adequate baseline education around communication principles is a good starting point; however, these skills require development over time in practice with real patients, and having systems of relational support for the HCPs will serve them, then patients, and potentially reduce incidence of burnout.
Comments on the Quality of English LanguageAlthough most of the text was clear, the manuscript needs careful proof reading for conformity to written English. There were many instances of incorrect verb form; in particular, the word "had" was used several times in place of "were" or "was." Also, toward the end of the manuscript, there were some sentences where some meaning had been lost in translation, and one phrase, "unwelcome tidings sharing" (page 12), which seemed to have been generated by an automatic translation system, and was quite strange.
Author Response
Please, see the attachment
Author Response File:
Author Response.pdf
Reviewer 4 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsThe manuscript addresses an important topic in oncology and hematology care: healthcare professionals’ communication difficulties when delivering bad news, with emphasis on the relationship between stress levels and communication competencies.
The article is relevant for the journal Nursing Reports, aligns with its scope, and presents original data from a relatively large nationwide sample. However, there are major issues requiring revision before publication—mainly in theoretical originality, structure, methodological rigor, and English language quality.
First of all, while the study found most participants reported having difficulty in giving bad news to the patient and family members (84.2%), this finding is very common and can be more deeply explored. What is the unique situation of the studied sample? Are there any specific factors besides lacking training? Does Italian culture matter? The finding that increasing stress level was significantly correlated to higher difficulties in breaking bad news can be similarly further explored? I suggest the authors well document what we have known regarding nursing practitioners’ communication difficulties when delivering bad news with oncology and hematology patients and then explore the major difference this study’s sample may have revealed. For example, the findings that most participants reported learning how to conduct difficult conversations from a mentor (61.1%) or by attending specific courses (56.6%) yet they still have difficulties may mean the training courses are insufficient and maybe their organization and deliveries can be problematic. Please try to focus on any unique contribution this study may have.
In addition, the objectives are spread across different sections. A clearer, more concise statement is needed in the Introduction:
- What exactly is being explored? (knowledge, attitudes, skills, difficulties, stress levels?)
- What gaps in literature justify the study?
- What hypotheses (if any) were tested?
Third, for methods, survey design should be better introduced for clarity
- Explicitly state that this is a cross-sectional observational study in the first sentence.
- Describe questionnaire validation (previous use, psychometric properties).
For sampling and recruitment
- The paper states 508 professionals “reached” → 221 answered (response rate = ~43%).
This should be clearly reported.
For statistical analysis
- Several p-values are given but effect sizes or confidence intervals are missing.
- No correction for multiple testing is mentioned, despite many comparisons.
Fourth, English language has to be improved. See below.
Despite the problem, the study’s merit should still be confirmed and much more analyses can be done.
Comments on the Quality of English LanguageThe manuscript requires substantial language editing. Many sentences contain grammar, syntax, or clarity problems, e.g.:
- “have had a mentor who learned them to conduct difficult conversations…”
- “sample perceived moderate stress managing bad news breaking”
- “communication may occur in patient’s room or physician room mostly”
A professional English editing service is strongly recommended .
Author Response
Please, see the attachment
Author Response File:
Author Response.pdf
Round 2
Reviewer 4 Report
Comments and Suggestions for AuthorsI believe the current ms has met the publication standards.