Effects of an Alternating Magnetic Field/Ag Multi-Alloying Combined Solidification Process on Cu–14Fe Alloy
Round 1
Reviewer 1 Report
The manuscript entitled: 'Effects of an alternating magnetic field/Ag multi-alloying combined solidification process on Cu-14Fe alloy' focuses on modifying the microstructure of the Cu-Fe alloy with the minor addition of Ag. I have the following minor comments:
- Even though the addition of Ag is a kind of motivation, the motivation of the present work has to be emphasized and should be clear
- All data points should accompany with error bars
- English language should be polished
- Typos should be checked carefully
Author Response
Response to Reviewer Comments
Point 1: Even though the addition of Ag is a kind of motivation, the motivation of the present work has to be emphasized and should be clear.
Response 1: We have listed the aims of this work in manuscript.
Point 2: All data points should accompany with error bars
Response 2: We have revised the Figures.
Point 3: English language should be polished
Response 3: We have requested a native English expert to revise the language
Point 4: Typos should be checked carefully
Response 4: We have revised the manuscript again and again.
Author Response File: 
Author Response.pdf
Reviewer 2 Report
Paper can be published after some revisions, such as:
1) Experimental. Please replace "irons" and "coppers" with "iron" and "copper"
2) Experimenal or Results and discussion. Does samples interact with crucible at melting? Please describe this point. If so, please give the characteristics of impurity.
3) Fig 4, axes legend. Please replece it with "Fe content, wt. %" and "Ag content, wt. %".
4) Figs 6 and 8, X axe legend. Please replece it with "Ag content, wt. %".
Author Response
Response to Reviewer Comments
Point 1: Experimental. Please replace "irons" and "coppers" with "iron" and "copper"
Response 1: We have revised in the manuscript.
Point 2: Experimenal or Results and discussion. Does samples interact with crucible at melting? Please describe this point. If so, please give the characteristics of impurity.
Response 2: The alloys and crucible do not reract at melting. And we have explained in Results and discussion.
Point 3: Fig 4, axes legend. Please replece it with "Fe content, wt. %" and "Ag content, wt. %".
Response 3: We have revised the Figure 4.
Point 4: Figs 6 and 8, X axe legend. Please replece it with "Ag content, wt. %".
Response 4: We have revised the Figure 6 and 8.
Author Response File: Author Response.pdf
