1. Introduction
Chronic pain is a major public health concern in Western countries, with point prevalence estimates ranging from 12% to 48% of the adult population [
1,
2]. It encompasses a wide range of clinical conditions, including migraine, vulvodynia, low back pain, and other chronic pain syndromes [
3,
4]. Chronic pain imposes a substantial burden on affected individuals and is associated with high healthcare utilization and indirect costs, such as work disability and reduced quality of life [
5].
Fibromyalgia (FM) is among the most disabling chronic pain syndromes [
6]. It affects between 0.2% and 6.6% of the general population, predominantly women, with prevalence increasing with age [
7,
8]. Its clinical impact is amplified by diagnostic challenges, limited treatment options, and frequent social invalidation [
9,
10]. According to the 2016 American College of Rheumatology criteria [
11], FM is primarily characterized by widespread pain lasting more than three months, often accompanied by other symptoms such as fatigue, cognitive difficulties, and depression, which further complicate the clinical picture [
9].
Beyond persistent pain, one of the most distressing and distinctive symptoms of FM is sleep disturbance [
12,
13,
14]. Compared to healthy controls, individuals with FM report poorer sleep quality and efficiency, reflected in longer wake times after sleep onset, shorter sleep duration, and lighter sleep in objective assessments, as well as greater difficulties initiating sleep in subjective reports [
13]. In a longitudinal study, Bigatti et al. [
14] found that baseline sleep disturbances predicted pain one year later, suggesting that sleep plays a pivotal role in the exacerbation of FM symptoms. Evidence also points to sleep dysfunction as a potential pathogenic factor in FM. Experimental studies have shown that sleep deprivation can induce FM-like symptoms in healthy individuals and impair descending pain-inhibitory pathways. Moreover, clinical trials have demonstrated that improving sleep quality leads to reductions in pain [
15]. These findings highlight the importance of identifying sleep disturbances and the factors that contribute to poor sleep in individuals with FM, to guide targeted interventions aimed at improving sleep quality.
According to Harvey’s Cognitive Model of Insomnia [
16], excessive and negatively valanced cognitive activity can heighten pre-sleep arousal and increase selective attention to internal threat cues (e.g., somatic tension, intrusive thoughts), thereby delaying sleep onset. This delay reinforces the perception of poor sleep quality, which in turn represents a stressor maintaining the cycle of disturbed sleep. Two common forms of heightened cognitive activity are worry and rumination. Worry refers to a chain of uncontrollable thoughts, images, and doubts concerning potential future threats [
17]. Rumination, on the other hand, involves a passive and repetitive focus on the causes, implications, and consequences of past stressful events and negative emotions, rather than on their solutions [
18]. Worry and rumination are commonly conceptualized as forms of Repetitive Negative Thinking (RNT) [
19,
20]. Both processes have been observed across a range of psychological and physical health conditions [
21,
22,
23,
24,
25,
26,
27].
A recent meta-analysis revealed a consistent association between higher RNT (i.e., worry and rumination) and poorer sleep quality in non-clinical populations [
28]. In the context of chronic pain, however, relatively few studies have examined the role of worry and rumination in sleep disturbances. In a sample of patients with benign chronic pain, Smith et al. [
29] reported that pre-sleep pain-related thoughts were significantly associated with sleep continuity, independent of depression and nightly pain severity. In a study of adolescents with chronic pain, Palermo et al. [
30] found that bedtime worry significantly predicted self-reported sleep quality. Moreover, in a sample of patients with myofascial temporomandibular disorder, Buenaver et al. [
31] observed that the rumination component of catastrophizing (i.e., worrying about pain with an inability to shift attention away from pain-related thoughts [
32]) had a significant indirect effect on pain intensity through sleep disturbance. This effect was not observed for the helplessness or magnification components of catastrophizing. Qualitative evidence further supports these findings. In a study by Edwards et al. [
33], over one-quarter of participants spontaneously reported experiencing nocturnal rumination. Many described being unable to “switch off” when trying to fall asleep, with some even ruminating about their inability to sleep. Notably, approximately 30% of participants indicated that rumination negatively impacted their sleep, primarily by delaying sleep onset.
Taken together, these findings underscore the role of RNT processes, such as worry and rumination, in disrupting sleep among individuals with chronic pain. Importantly, some evidence also suggests that worry and rumination may exacerbate pain itself, contributing to greater pain intensity by heightening attentional focus on pain-related cues and sustaining negative affective states [
34,
35,
36,
37,
38]. However, other studies have reported no significant correlation between pain intensity and worry or rumination [
39,
40]. These inconsistencies may reflect methodological differences, such as variability in sample characteristics or measurement instruments.
Understanding these relationships is critical for identifying modifiable targets for interventions aimed at reducing both pain and sleep disturbances in individuals with FM. Despite growing research on the complex interplay between pain intensity, sleep quality, worry, and rumination, a critical gap remains: to date, no study has systematically examined whether sleep quality mediates the associations between these distinct RNT processes and pain intensity.
The present study aimed to address this gap by investigating two separate mediation models in a large sample of individuals with FM. Specifically, we examined whether sleep quality mediate the relationship between: (1) worry and pain intensity, and (2) depressive rumination and pain intensity. We hypothesized that both worry and depressive rumination would be indirectly associated with higher pain intensity through increased sleep disturbances.
4. Discussion
Despite growing evidence on the relationship between pain intensity, sleep quality, worry, and rumination, no study to date has examined whether sleep quality mediates the associations between these RNT processes and pain intensity.
Our findings support Harvey’s Cognitive Model of Insomnia [
16], highlighting a pathway in which worry and depressive rumination contribute to increased sleep disturbances. This is consistent with previous research showing that RNT processes interfere with sleep continuity and quality in both clinical and non-clinical populations [
28,
29,
30,
31,
33]. By demonstrating that these mechanisms also operate in FM, our results extend previous work and underscore the role of maladaptive cognitive activity in perpetuating poor sleep quality in this population.
Furthermore, our results underscore the negative impact of sleep disturbances on pain intensity. This finding aligns with a substantial body of evidence indicating that sleep disturbances are a robust predictor of pain exacerbation across various chronic pain conditions, including FM. Notably, longitudinal and micro-longitudinal studies have shown that sleep impairments more consistently predict subsequent pain than the reverse, supporting the primacy of sleep dysfunction in the pain–sleep relationship [
53]. Several mechanisms may explain why poor sleep quality has such a strong effect on pain. Mediation studies have highlighted the roles of depression, anxiety, attention to pain, pain helplessness, stress, fatigue, and reduced physical activity as important factors linking sleep disturbances to greater pain intensity [
54]. At the neurobiological level, preliminary evidence suggests that alterations in dopaminergic and opioidergic systems may contribute to this relationship. However, these mechanisms remain incompletely understood and require further investigation [
53].
Another important finding of the present study concerns the direct effect of depressive rumination on pain intensity, independent of sleep disturbances. This suggests that rumination may exacerbate pain not only through its disruptive effects on sleep but also by maintaining negative affective states and attentional biases toward pain-related cues, thereby amplifying the subjective experience of pain. This interpretation is consistent with experimental and neuroimaging evidence indicating that rumination intensifies attentional and anticipatory processes related to pain. For instance, Brookes et al. [
55] demonstrated that experimentally induced rumination increased both distress and pain perception during an acute pain task, partly by promoting a vigilance-avoidance attentional pattern toward pain-related stimuli. Similarly, Kokonyei et al. [
56] found that trait rumination was associated with heightened neural responses during both pain anticipation and perception, as well as with impaired detection of unexpected relief, suggesting that rumination may intensify pain through altered cognitive and emotional processing. Collectively, these findings reinforce the notion that depressive rumination is a cognitive factor that directly exacerbates pain perception, highlighting its relevance as a potential target for psychological interventions in chronic pain management.
From a clinical perspective, these findings highlight the importance of interventions specifically aimed at reducing RNT, which appear to play a role in disrupting sleep and amplifying pain in FM. Metacognitive Therapy (MCT) [
57] and Rumination-Focused Cognitive–Behavioral Therapy (RF-CBT) [
20] represent promising approaches. Specifically, MCT focuses on identifying and modifying dysfunctional metacognitive beliefs (e.g., “My worrying is uncontrollable”, “Worrying helps me to cope…”) that perpetuate worry and rumination. In doing so, it helps individuals disengage attention from intrusive thoughts and RNT, rather than trying to challenge or suppress their content. MCT has demonstrated efficacy in treating a range of emotional disorders, including depressive disorders, generalized anxiety disorder, social anxiety disorder, and other conditions characterized by excessive worry and rumination [
58,
59,
60,
61]. These findings suggest that MCT could be adapted to address similar cognitive processes in FM, although it has not yet been tested in this specific population.
Similarly, RF-CBT specifically addresses depressive rumination by helping individuals recognize and modify unhelpful thinking styles, such as abstract, repetitive, and passive thought patterns, and replace them with more concrete and constructive coping strategies. This intervention has been shown to reduce depressive rumination and improve emotional functioning in individuals with depression [
20]. However, to date, no randomized controlled trials have tested this intervention in patients with FM or chronic pain.
Although these approaches have not yet been tested in FM or chronic pain populations, their theoretical framework directly target the cognitive mechanisms identified in this study. Integrating them into multimodal pain management programs could potentially improve outcomes by breaking the cycle of negative thinking, poor sleep, and heightened pain perception.
In addition, mindfulness-based interventions have demonstrated positive effects on both sleep quality and emotional regulation in chronic pain populations, including FM. A recent study showed that a mindfulness-based stress reduction program improved sleep quality over time [
62]. This benefit may result from reducing physiological and cognitive arousal while promoting present-moment awareness and non-judgmental acceptance, thereby counteracting rumination and worry that frequently disrupt sleep.
Future clinical trials are needed to evaluate whether interventions explicitly targeting rumination and worry can improve sleep quality and, consequently, pain outcomes. If confirmed, this would broaden the current range of psychological treatments for chronic pain beyond traditional CBT approaches, opening avenues for tailored interventions addressing transdiagnostic cognitive mechanisms such as RNT.
This study has several limitations. First, the cross-sectional design precludes causality inferences. Future longitudinal studies could provide a dynamic understanding of changes in sleep, cognitive processes, and pain over time, allowing stronger conclusions regarding causal relationships. Second, online data collection through FM-specific patients associations, while cost-effective, may have introduced selection bias and reduced sample representativeness. Individuals without Internet access or with limited digital literacy were likely excluded, and the sample may have been biased toward more engaged participants, limiting generalizability. Third, the lack of control over the testing environment inherent to online surveys may have affected response quality. Future studies could consider diversified recruitment strategies and incorporate attention checks or social desirability measures to improve data quality. Fourth, the internal consistency of the PSQI was lower than typically recommended. In line with prior research [
63,
64,
65,
66], one subscale with a particularly low item–total correlation was excluded to improve reliability. While this step strengthened the measure’s internal consistency, it may have reduced comparability with studies using the full scale. Fifth, a preliminary comparison between respondents and non-respondents revealed significant differences in pain intensity and depressive rumination. This suggests a potential response bias, with participants who completed the survey possibly experiencing higher levels of pain and rumination, further limiting generalizability. Sixth, the proposed mediation models accounted for a small proportion of variance in pain intensity. This is not be surprising, since FM pain is a multifaceted phenomenon influenced by numerous biopsychosocial factors [
67]. While rumination and worry contribute to sleep disturbances and pain, they are insufficient to fully explain their variability. Other factors, such as physical activity, comorbid mood or anxiety disorders, and pain coping strategies, may also play important roles and should be considered in future research. Moreover, hormonal, neurochemical, and inflammatory changes may further contribute to the complexity of sleep disturbances and pain mechanisms in FM [
68,
69,
70,
71,
72]. The absence of a healthy control group or other clinical comparison cohorts represents a further limitation of the present study. Therefore, the specificity of these findings to FM cannot be determined, and future studies should include healthy controls and clinical groups with other chronic pain or affective conditions to disentangle the FM-specific versus transdiagnostic nature of these associations. This could be particularly relevant considering that previous research have shown that certain forms of RNT (specifically, worry and anger rumination) may be more pronounced in individuals with FM compared to both healthy controls and patients with other rheumatologic conditions [
73]. Moreover, the mean PSQI global score observed in our sample (M = 13.45) was substantially higher than the clinical cutoff of 5 and also exceeded the mean value reported in a comparative study involving six medical populations (M = 8.0) [
74]. Finally, since anxiety and depression are common comorbidities in FM and were not controlled in the present analyses. We avoided adding further self-report measures to limit participant burden and maximize data quality, considering the frequent attention and concentration difficulties reported by people with FM. However, future research should include these variables to clarify their potential confounding roles.
In conclusion, our findings extend current knowledge on the interplay among worry, rumination, sleep quality, and pain in FM. They emphasize the importance of targeting worry and rumination in psychological interventions aimed at improving sleep quality and pain intensity. Future research should investigate whether reducing these RNT processes can concurrently improve sleep and pain outcomes. If confirmed, such findings could inform the development of more tailored and mechanistically driven treatments for FM and other chronic pain populations.