RETRACTED: Influence of Different Rotations of Organic Formamidinium Molecule on Electronic and Optical Properties of FAPbBr₃ Perovskite

Abstract

Hybrid organic–inorganic halide perovskites (HOIPs) have recently represented a material breakthrough for optoelectronic applications. Obviously, studying the interactions between the central organic cation and the Pb-X inorganic octahedral could provide a better understanding of HOIPs. In this work, we used a first-principles theoretical study to investigate the effect of different orientations of central formamidinium cation (FA⁺) on the electronic and optical properties of FAPbBr₃ hybrid perovskite. In order to do this, the band structure (with and without spin–orbit coupling (SOC)), density of states (DOS), partial density of states (PDOS), electron density, distortion index, bond angle variance, dielectric function, and absorption spectra were computed. The findings revealed that a change in the orientation of FA⁺ caused some disorders in the distribution of interactions, resulting in the formation of some specific energy levels in the structure. The interactions between the inorganic and organic parts in different directions create a distortion index in the bonds of the inorganic octahedral, thus leading to a change in the volume of PbBr₆. This is the main reason for the variations observed in the electronic and optical properties of FAPbBr₃. The obtained results can be helpful in solar-cell applications.

1. Introduction

Since the dawn of civilization, solar energy has been hailed as one of the most promising renewable energy resources [1,2,3,4,5,6]. By utilizing readily available materials and simple fabrication processes, thin-film technology promises to cut the cost of solar energy [7,8,9,10,11]. In recent years, a variety of light absorber materials have been studied in both organic and inorganic systems [12,13,14,15]. Due to their great processability, wide optical absorption cross-section, and good thermal stability hybrid organic–inorganic halide perovskites are regarded as being suitable materials for mesoscopic solar cells [16,17,18,19,20,21]. They have the general chemical formula ABX₃, where A is an organic/inorganic cation (e.g., Cs⁺: cesium, (CH₃NH₃)⁺: methylammonium, MA⁺; (CH(NH₂)₂)⁺: formamidinium, FA⁺), X is a halogen anion (e.g., X = I⁻, Br⁻, Cl⁻), and B is a divalent metal cation (e.g., Pb²⁺) [10,22,23,24,25].

Changing the cations or anions in HOIPs can change their bandgap energy. For example, when iodide anions are substituted by a smaller halide, the bandgap increases [26,27,28,29,30]. While keeping the cubic structure, the bandgap reduces also upon substitution of formamidinium (FA) cation by smaller methylammonium (MA) cation [8,31,32,33]. FA-based lead bromide perovskite (FAPbBr₃) has been reported to have an optimum bandgap of ~2 eV, which translates to absorption up to 560 nm [7,12,26,28,34]. Altogether, it can be said that FAPbBr₃ could be a better active material than MAPbBr₃ for perovskite solar cells (PSCs) [35,36,37,38]. However, pure FAPbBr₃ has been discovered to be unstable because its trigonal-phase is sensitive to humidity and quickly transforms to a non-photoactive hexagonal-phase at room temperature [39,40,41,42,43].

In a wide range of molecular systems, such as organic and hybrid materials, molecule rotations play a key role in the dynamical and relaxation properties. In addition, in gases and liquids, the rotational disorder can also be seen in solid materials (e.g., hybrid perovskites) [44,45]. Several experimental techniques, including dielectric relaxation, infrared and Raman spectroscopy, spin relaxation, and fluorescence depolarization, have been used to offer information about the relaxation timeframes required to reestablish equilibrium after an appropriate perturbation of the molecular motion [46,47].

The organic cation formamidinium has an asymmetric charge distribution resulting in a net dipole moment. At temperatures around 330 K, FAPbBr₃ has a cubic structure, and the dipolar organic cation can rotate almost freely inside the metal-halide lattice. This leads to a high dielectric screening compared to halide perovskites with non-dipolar cations, such as Cs⁺ and Rb⁺. The rotational freedom of organic cation has been found to be highly dependent on temperature. The dipolar nature of the central cation has a great effect on the optoelectronic properties of hybrid halide perovskites [19,48,49,50,51].

In this work, we rotated organic FA cation in two axes within the FAPbBr₃ perovskite: (a) the vertical axis going through the C atom and (b) the connecting axis of N-N bond. Because the organic molecule was standing upright in the X direction, two rotation axes of Y and X were chosen with rotations at ideal angles of 15°, 30°, 45°, 60°, and 75°. DFT-based calculations were performed to investigate the influence of different rotations on the electronic and optical properties. We have supplied thorough information on the electrical and optical performance of FAPbBr₃ at different angles. The findings could help researchers figure out which structure is suitable for use in solar cells.

2. Computational Details

Quantum Espresso’s PWSCF Code was used for all calculations [52]. The generalized gradient approximation (GGA) was used in the scheme of Perdew–Burke–Ernzerhof (PBE) [53] to describe the exchange-correlation functional. We focused on the rotation of organic cation (FA⁺) within the pseudo-cubic phase of FAPbBr₃ perovskite. The density of valence electrons and wave functions were also represented by using scalar relativistic ultra-soft and plane-wave basis set pseudo-potentials. The energy cutoffs of wave functions and electron density were set to be 37 and 365 Rydberg, respectively. The Brillouin zone (BZ) of the cubic systems was sampled by using a 10 × 10 × 10 Monkhorst–Pack grid [54,55]. The structure was fully relaxed until the force on each atom was less than 0.0051 eV ${\mathrm{A}}^{-1}$. The frequency-dependent complex dielectric function was computed by using the following equation [52]:

$$\epsilon \left(\omega \right)=1+\frac{8\pi }{\Omega N_k}{\displaystyle \sum }_{k,v,c}\frac{{|\langle {\phi }_{kv}\left|\widehat{v}\right|{\phi }_{kc}\rangle |}^2}{{\left(E_{kc}-E_{kv}\right)}^2\left(E_{kc}-E_{kv}-\omega -i\eta \right)}$$

(1)

where Ω is the cell volume, $N_k$ represents total number of k-points in the BZ, $\widehat{v}$ is the velocity operator, and η is an opportune broadening factor. The indices v and c denote the occupied and unoccupied states, respectively.

It is feasible to acquire the whole dielectric tensor evaluated on the imaginary frequency axe $\epsilon \left(i\omega \right)$ by applying a London transformation on ${\epsilon }_i\left(\omega \right)$ [52].

$$\epsilon \left(i\omega \right)=1+\frac{2}{\pi }{{\displaystyle \int }}_0^{\infty }\frac{{\omega }^{\prime }{\epsilon }_i\left({\omega }^{\prime }\right)}{{\omega \prime }^2+{\omega }^2}d\omega$$

(2)

The electron energy-loss spectrum (EELS), which is proportional to the imaginary of the inverse dielectric tensor, was obtained by using the relation [52];

$$\mathrm{Imm}\left\{\frac{1}{\epsilon \left(\omega \right)}\right\}=\frac{{\epsilon }_i\left(\omega \right)}{{\epsilon }_r^2\left(\omega \right)+{\epsilon }_i^2\left(\omega \right)}$$

(3)

The frequency-dependent absorption coefficient, α(ω), was determined by using the following formula:

$$\alpha \left(\omega \right)=\omega \sqrt{\frac{-{\epsilon }_r\left(\omega \right)+\sqrt{{\epsilon }_r^2\left(\omega \right)+{\epsilon }_i^2\left(\omega \right)}}{2}}$$

(4)

3. Results

Inside a cubic structure of hybrid perovskite, the organic Formamidinium (FA) cation is situated in the X (100) direction (pm3m). The rotational modes of FA⁺ within the PbBr₆ inorganic octahedral are schematically depicted in Figure 1a. Figure 1b also displays the position of FA⁺ and PbBr₆ octahedral in the structure of FAPbBr₃ perovskite. In order to get a clear vision from the FA behavior inside the Pb-Br framework, six different angles, namely 0°, 15°, 30°, 45°, 60°, and 75°, were considered regarding both Y and X axes.

Table 1. Lattice parameters and bandgaps (with and without SOC) of FAPbBr₃ perovskite for all rotational modes.

Rotational Mode	Lattice Parameter (Å)	Bandgap without SOC (eV)	Bandgap with SOC (eV)
0°-X	5.97	1.61	0.40
15°-Y	5.93	1.65	0.62
30°-Y	5.89	1.70	0.65
45°-Y	5.81	1.79	1.35
60°-Y	5.85	1.73	1.04
75°-Y	5.91	1.68	0.72
15°-X	5.96	1.62	0.49
30°-X	5.94	1.64	0.55
45°-X	5.90	1.72	0.98
60°-X	5.92	1.66	0.61
75°-X	5.95	1.63	0.52

and Figure 2l represent the computed bandgaps for different rotational modes. As can be seen, from 15° to 75°, the lattice parameter of the FAPbBr₃ in Y mode exhibits a valley-like behavior (solid red line in Figure 2l).

The significant decrease in the lattice parameter from 15° to 75° indicates a decrease in the structure volume. From Table 1, it is evident that 45°-rotated FA leads to the smallest unite cell for FAPbBr₃. Calculations on X-rotated FA, however, show that the variation of lattice parameter in this mode is small (less than 0.07 A°). This can be attributed to the fixed positions of NH₂ and NH₂ for X rotational modes (see Figure 2l). On the other hand, we may deduce from the computed band structures and energy bandgaps that the bandgap and the lattice parameter have a direct relationship as a function of rotational orientation. The bandgap energies of FAPbBr₃ increased to a maximum of 1.79 eV (45° Y-rotated values) from 1.61 eV (non-rotated data). As a result, we can say with certainty that decreasing the structure size (as determined by the lattice parameter) causes an increase in the organic cation and inorganic octahedral interaction radius, pushing the conduction band to higher energies. Figure 2 depicts the band structure of FAPbBr₃ perovskite for rotational angles of 0°, 15°, 30°, 45°, 60°, and 75° in both Y and X modes. The band structure corresponding to the stable 0°-rotated FA for FAPbBr₃ is shown in Figure 2a. A direct bandgap was discovered at the points R and M of BZ (shown with yellow and green dots). The band degeneracy is observed at points R and M in the CBM. The band structures in which the organic cation (CH(NH₂)₂)⁺ rotates in Y mode with an angle of 45° is represented by Figure 2d. The bands stay direct at high-symmetry R and M points despite FA⁺ rotation.

Furthermore, we may deduce from Figure 2 that changes in the structure volume affect the interaction between organic cation and inorganic octahedra and as a result cause considerable changes in the band structure.

Figure 2g–k illustrates the band structures related to the rotation of FA⁺ in X mode, demonstrating a direct bandgap at the R and M points of BZ. Unlike traditional semiconductors, such as GaAs, which have a dual-degeneracy at Γ point of VBM, but FAPbBr₃ structure has a triple degeneracy at R point of CBM in BZ. The orientational disorders of organic cations in HOIPs cause this fundamental divergence. It is worth noting that organic cation does not have a direct role in VBM and CBM. However, the size, shape, and position of organic cations inside the Pb-Br framework have a considerable effect in the electronic and optical properties of HOIPs. The rotation of FA in Y and X modes affects the band structure while maintaining its original shape at the R point of BZ. Organic cations interact with the inorganic octahedral, which results in the change of band structure.

The presence of d orbital of lead atom in the HOIPs structure makes the spin–orbit coupling (SOC) effect remarkable. Therefore, the band structure and bandgap (Eg) size were calculated taking into account this effect, as shown in Figure 3 and Table 1.

According to Figure 3, considering the SOC effect, for HOIPs at R and M points of CBM, degeneracy leads to a non-degenerate state at the CBM. For HOIPs while maintaining double degeneracy at transition point M, there is a band splitting from triple to double at transition point R. In fact, due to the presence of d orbital of lead atom and since the most of the conduction band is affected by the lead atom, the band splitting occurs in the conduction band and a red shift appears in the CBM.

Figure 4 depicts electron density of FAPbBr₃ structure in 2D representation from the crystallographic planes. It appears that interacting (CH(NH₂)₂)⁺ with PbBr₆ octahedral, results in some structural disorders that alters the octahedral volume as well as the total volume of the structure (refer to Table 1 and Figure 5).

Due to the relatively greater ionic radius of NH₂, its interaction is substantially higher than that of CH, as shown in Figure 4’s 2D counter plots in (001) plane and also

Table 2. Ionic radii; atomic radii; Van Der Waals radii; and atomic masses of I, Pb, N, C, and Br [56].

Atom Name	Ionic Radius (A°)	Atomic Radius (A°)	Van der Waals Radius (A°)	Atomic Mass
Br	1.96	1.14	1.85	79.90
N	1.46	0.74	1.55	14.00
C	0.15	0.77	1.70	12.01
Pb	1.19	1.75	2.16	207.20
H	0.20	0.46	1.20	1.00

. On the basis of rotational angles, the average distortion index (bond length), bond angle variance and volume of the octahedral were calculated and shown in Figure 5. When FA is rotated, the interaction between the FA⁺ and PbBr₆ is greatly enhanced (see (001) plane in Figure 4). As shown in Figure 5a, the average volume of the octahedral is reduced, leading to an increase of the bandgap energy (refer to Figure 2).

According to Figure 5, it is clear that, at a rotation angle of 45° for both rotation axes Y and X, the bond angle variance of PbBr₆ inorganic octahedral is maximized. This is a direct result of the reduced volume of PbBr₆ at 45°.

We can conclude from this section that the distance and radius of interaction between the inorganic octahedral and the organic cation could be regarded as controlling tools of electron density and bandgap energies. The electron density of the structure was calculated regarding the rotational mode of 30°-X on the (001) plane, indicating no significant changes in comparison to the FA-0°X (Figure 4a). The reason for this could be related to the fixed positions of N atoms and the only displacement of CH in the X rotational mode. Thus, the existence of FA organic cation formed from two distinct ionic radii (CH and NH₂) is the main reason of the structural disorders in FAPbBr₃ perovskites. FA plays a significant role in cation–cation (FA⁺–Pb²⁺) and cation–onion (FA⁺–Br⁻) molecular interactions in HOIP structure.

We calculated total DOS and PDOS, as illustrated in Figure 6. It depicts the contribution of atom valence orbitals in the structure for non-rotated and all rotated modes. Figure 6a corresponds to the PDOS of FA-0°x and shows that the VBM for the present system is dominated by 4p orbitals of Br and partly by 6s orbitals of Pb, and also the CBM is dominated by 6p orbitals of Pb atom. As can be seen, rotating FA from 0° to 75° in Y mode boosts the roles of 4p orbital of Br and 6p orbital of Pb in the valance and conduction bands, respectively. According to the electron-density data, the energy level of an organic cation in the (001) plane increases at these angles (compared to non-rotated states). This could be related to electron interactions between the p orbitals of lead and bromide atoms and those of organic cation. Notably, there is a blue shift in DOS of the conduction band at angles of 15°, 30°, 45°, 60°, and 75° when compared to non-rotated states. Energy states at 45°-Y show a greater variance than those at 15°-Y, 30°-Y, 60°-Y, and 75°-Y, which similarly influences the 6s and 6p orbitals of Pb at CBM. Due to the decreased structure volume and also the greater interactions between inorganic octahedral at 45°, CBM is moved to higher energies at this angle.

From Figure 6g–k, it is clear that, similar to the Y mode, a change in the orientation of FA in the X mode leads to the change of PDOS.

We calculated the dielectric function for the FAPbBr₃ structure in FA-0°, Y, and X rotating modes (see Figure 7, Figure 8 and Figure 9 and

Table 3. Wavelength of absorption edge and static dielectric constants of FAPbBr₃ perovskite for all rotational modes.

Rotational Mode	${\mathit{\epsilon }}_0$	α (nm)
0°-X	6.31	770
15°-Y	6.73	751
30°-Y	7.07	729
45°-Y	7.34	692
60°-Y	7.27	716
75°-Y	7.04	738
15°-X	6.35	765
30°-X	6.50	756
45°-X	7.04	720
60°-X	6.75	746
75°-X	6.40	760

). The real parts of the dielectric function for Y mode rotations are shown in Figure 7a. As a result, for non-rotated FA, the static dielectric constant at E = 0 is predicted to be 6.31. Nonetheless, when the FA is rotated in the Y mode, the static dielectric constant of the structure increases at all rotational angles. Moreover, Figure 8 shows the imaginary parts of the dielectric function. The first peak in these spectra represents the direct optical transition known as the optical gap (R transition point in BZ). For the non-rotated case, this peak is positioned at 1.61 eV. The peak also experiences a blue shift when the FA organic cation is rotated at all angles. In addition, the effect of FA rotation with X mode is displayed in Figure 7b, which shows a different result than Y with a significant change in static dielectric constant.

From the large changes in the positions of NH₂ and CH molecules, it can be concluded that rotating FA with Y mode increases cation–cation (FA⁺–Pb²⁺) and cation–onion (FA⁺–Br⁻) interactions. As a result, it can be inferred that the dielectric function of the system varies by changing the structure size and bandgap value at all rotational modes.

To confirm the accuracy of the static dielectric constant calculations, the ε(iω) spectrum was evaluated for all rotational modes and shown in Figure 9. It is clear that the starting point of these spectra actually corresponds to the static dielectric constant. According to the electron energy-loss spectra (Figure 9), it is observed that, at the location of the first peak, there is the least amount of electron energy loss, which is strong confirmation for the results obtained for the dielectric function.

The optical absorption spectra of FAPbBr₃ for FA-0° and rotational modes are shown in Figure 10a,b. For FA-0°, the absorption edge begins at 770 nm. Table 3 and Figure 10 provide detailed optical absorption data for Y and X modes, including blue-shifted absorption edges for all rotational modes. The largest change in absorption edge wavelength corresponds to a 45°-Y rotation (a blue shift of 78 nm). The smaller volume of the structure and the greater interactions between FA and Pb⁺² result in a blue shift in the absorption spectrum at 45°-Y. The location and orientation of the organic cation, as well as its interaction with inorganic octahedra in various angles and directions, can potentially decrease the wavelength of the absorption edge, resulting in a tunable absorption spectrum for HOIP perovskites.

4. Conclusions

The effect of different FA rotations was investigated on the band structure, electron density, DOS, dielectric function, and absorption spectra of FAPbBr₃. We found that FA has no direct contribution to the electronic band structure. However, due to the presence of cation–cation (FA⁺–Pb²⁺) and cation–anion (FA⁺–Br⁻) interactions within the structure of the FAPbBr₃, FA rotation changes the structural, electronic, and optical properties. The rotation of FA cation causes two important factors of distortion index and band-angle variance to affect the bonds of PbBr₆ inorganic octahedral. The influence of these factors in the structural properties of HOIPs, in turn, causes some changes in the electronic and optical properties. Modifying the rotational mode, position, and orientation of organic cations within the structure of a hybrid perovskite can be used for tuning the bandgap, static dielectric constant, and absorption edge.