3.3. Worn Surface Morphologies
Figure 8,
Figure 9 and
Figure 10 show the worn surface morphology of the NC5, NC15 and NC20 coatings sliding under the load of 5 N against the alumina ball. The generated wear path at RT shows the creation of wear debris along the sliding direction for all the derived coatings. There is tribo layer formation observed, with varying degrees of coverage and compaction as indicated in
Figure 8a,d,
Figure 9a,b, and
Figure 10a,d. However, at 400 °C, as shown in
Figure 8b,e and
Figure 9d,e, the wear path exhibits deep and shallow grooves over the wear track, whereas the other tested coating (NC20) shows the grooves, cluster of agglomerated wear debris, and delamination also observed in the direction of sliding for the coating NC20 (
Figure 10b,e). The wear path at 800 °C (
Figure 8c,f,
Figure 9g,h and
Figure 10c,f) shows the formation of a glaze layer. In
Figure 9g,h, the wear track shows smooth plateaus at various junctions. These smooth plateaus and glaze layer is channelized across the entire worn surface, helped in reducing the COF and wear, as indicated in
Figure 6 and
Figure 7. The wear debris appears flattened over the surface for the coating NC20 at 800 °C. This glaze layer plus the presence of loose wear debris can potentially increase the COF and wear for the derived coating at 800 °C as shown in
Figure 10c,f.
Figure 9c,f,i display the EDS spectrum at different temperatures, taken over the wear path for the coating NC15. The square bracket over the worn surface of the coatings shows the area selected for EDS analysis. The EDS spectra at different temperatures show the existence of coating ingredients.
Figure 9f,i also confirm the presence of coating materials, possibly with oxides at tested temperatures.
Figure 11 illustrates the morphology of an alumina ball after sliding against the NC15 coating at different temperatures. At RT,
Figure 11a, the morphology of the alumina ball shows a transfer of the coating material. At 400 °C,
Figure 11c, the morphology of the alumina ball exhibits a transfer layer that is loosely adhered. At 800 °C,
Figure 11e, the morphology of the alumina ball shows the existence of smooth zones plus a compacted transfer layer. The existence of said features indicated that the transfer of coating materials is more efficient and results in a more uniform and adherent layer on the counter face. The EDS spectra,
Figure 11b,d,f, reveal the presence of coating materials along with oxygen, suggesting some degree of oxidation or interaction with the environment during sliding at this temperature. At 800 °C, the transfer layer formed on the alumina ball is smoother and more compacted compared to lower temperatures (RT and 400 °C).
The XRD patterns and Raman spectra of the worn surfaces of various coatings (NC5, NC10, NC15, and NC20) tested at different temperatures against the alumina ball under the load of 5 N are depicted in
Figure 12 and
Figure 13. The XRD patterns of the worn surfaces,
Figure 12a–d, exhibit the existence of coating materials over the wear track in the range of temperatures (RT-400 °C) and primarily exhibit phases such as Ni
3Al, NiAl, and NiAl
3, which are consistent with their compositions and matched with the JCPDS file. There is not much change in terms of new phase evolution compared to the as-sprayed coatings till 400 °C, except for the presence of NiMoO
4 [
24,
25] at 400 °C, in all tested coatings. At elevated temperatures (600–800 °C), all the formulated coatings exhibit the creation of various oxides (MoO
3, NiO, NiMoO
4, Ag
2Mo
4O
13, Ag
2Mo
2O
7, and Ag
2MoO
4) which are clearly evident from the XRD patterns. At 800 °C, the XRD pattern for the formulated coating (NC15) exhibits the intensified peak of silver molybdate (Ag
2MoO
4). At 800 °C, the XRD patterns reveal the presence of additional new phases, specifically NiO and Ag
2Mo
2O
7. In the Raman spectra, as shown in
Figure 13, in the range of temperatures RT to 400 °C, a broad peak linked to the Ag
2MoO
4 phase is consistently detected over the wear path for all coatings, which is an indication of the amorphous form of silver molybdates. At 600 °C, new phases started to appear, including MoO
3 [
24,
25,
26], Ag
2MoO
4 [
24,
25] and Ag
2Mo
4O
13 [
24,
25] as confirmed by
Figure 13. At 800 °C, the wear path exhibits intensified peaks of several novel phases: Ag
2Mo
4O
13, Ag
2Mo
2O
7, Ag
2MoO
4, NiO [
24] and NiMoO
4 especially in the coating (NC15) as shown in
Figure 13c. The intensified peaks of said compounds, along with NiO, indicated a significant extent of lubricious oxides over the worn surface. The formation of oxides at elevated temperatures suggests extensive tribo-chemical reactions, which triggered due to the constant sliding motion and thermal exposure. The existence of silver molybdates at elevated temperatures (600–800 °C) indicated a potential enhancement of lubricating conditions and thermal stability [
27]. These phases may contribute to improved tribo performance by prevailing lubricating layers or reducing surface interaction.
In the micro-Raman spectrum shown in
Figure 14, which analyzes the transfer layer developed onto the counter face after sliding against the NC15 and NC20 coating, several key phases are observed at different temperatures. In
Figure 14a, in the regime RT to 400 °C, the transfer layer on the counter face body primarily contains a broad peak corresponding to the Ag
2MoO
4 phase. At 800 °C, the transfer layer shows the presence of several phases: NiO, Ag
2MoO
4, Ag
2Mo
2O
7, Ag
2Mo
4O
13, and NiMoO
4. The development of a transfer layer enriched with these intensified phases indicates that material transfer and chemical interactions played a substantial role in the tribological behavior of the coating NC15.
Figure 14b shows relatively low intensified peaks, which give a hint of lubricious phases being transferred in a lower extent in the counter face slid against the said coating (NC20).
X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS) as shown in
Figure 15 was employed to identify the chemical states of silver (Ag), molybdenum (Mo), and oxygen (O) on the worn surface of the NC15 composite coating after sliding at 800 °C.
Figure 15a corresponds to the O1s spectrum and shows two distinct peaks at binding energies of approximately 530.1 eV and 532.2 eV, which can be attributed to different oxygen environments O1s (1) and O1s (2) within the Ag
2MoO
4 structure. These peaks likely correspond to lattice oxygen and surface-adsorbed oxygen, respectively, which can yield two Ag
2MoO
4 Gaussian peaks.
Figure 15b depicts the Mo 3d spectrum in which the Mo 3d region exhibits two prominent peaks at 232.1 eV and 236.1 eV, corresponding to Mo 3d
5/2 and Mo 3d
3/2, respectively. These binding energies are consistent with the presence of Mo 3d
5/2 and Mo 3d
3/2 chemical states in the Ag
2MoO
4 phase, indicating Mo exists in a high oxidation state.
Figure 15c shows the Ag 3d spectrum in which peaks located at 368.1 eV and 371.1 eV are assigned to Ag 3d
5/2 and Ag 3d
3/2, respectively. These values confirm the presence of Ag
+ ions, which is also indicative of Ag
2MoO
4 formation. The XPS findings align with previously reported results [
28] and are further supported by micro-Raman spectroscopy. The combination of XPS data with micro-Raman spectroscopy confirms that a silver molybdate (Ag
2MoO
4) tribo layer forms on the contact surface during sliding at elevated temperatures. Since Ag
2MoO
4 has a relatively low melting point (~528 °C) [
29], it softens under high-temperature conditions, aiding in the formation of a lubricious and protective layer. The formed tribo layer plays a dual role: it reduces friction and wear by acting as a solid lubricant and protects the underlying material by minimizing direct contact between the sliding surfaces. The improved tribological performance at 800 °C by the NC15 coating could be attributed to the formation and transfer of this Ag
2MoO
4-based tribo layer to the wear path and counter face, respectively.
To identify the composition of the glaze film on the worn surface of the NC15 composite coating after sliding, elemental maps of the wear track were acquired at 800 °C.
Figure 16a displays the worn surface morphology, while
Figure 16b–g illustrate the elemental distributions of Ni, Al, Ag, Mo, O and S, respectively. These maps reveal a continuous oxide layer that blankets the wear track, coexisting with coating elements. The detected presence of Ni and O indicated the formation of a stable oxide (NiO)—a part of the protective glaze. Meanwhile, the simultaneous detection of Ag, Mo, and O strongly suggests the emergence of silver molybdate compounds. Silver molybdates (e.g., Ag
2MoO
4) are well-known, high-temperature solid lubricants, formed via in situ tribo-chemical reactions between Ag and Mo oxides. Under elevated temperatures (600–800 °C), silver molybdate phases develop readily and impart low shear strength, leading to reduced friction [
27].
The continuous decline in micro-hardness of the formulated coatings (NC5, NC10, NC15, and NC20) as the Ag content increases can be attributed to the inherent softness of Ag that contributed to lower micro-hardness values in coatings. These findings align with research carried out by other investigators [
30]. The average COF behavior of the derived coatings in the range of temperatures (RT to 200 °C) shows a decreasing trend, as indicated in
Figure 6. This trend can be attributed to the following factors: Silver is known for its smooth and soft nature, which can facilitate easier shearing and sliding between mating bodies. This property contributes to reduced friction and thus a lower COF in the tested coatings. The average COF of the coatings increases notably at 400 °C. At 400 °C, the ability of silver to maintain its lubricating properties diminishes, leading to higher friction between the mating surfaces. This increase can be explained by the limitations of silver as a solid lubricant at the tested temperature (400 °C). In atmospheric air, the lamellar lubricating structure of MoS
2 becomes unstable as the temperature increased to 400 °C due to the generation of oxides like MoO
3. These oxides are hard, brittle, and not easy to shear, leading to increased friction. Even if at the prevailing temperature (400 °C), MoS
2 does not fully decompose, some oxidation products can produce mixed Mo–O–S phases that alter shear characteristics in such a way that an increased friction coefficient is attained, effectively contributing to a “peak” in friction around intermediate temperatures. Earlier research findings also validate the point and suggest that silver may not effectively create optimal lubricating conditions at 400 °C [
19,
30]. At 400 °C, the worn surfaces showed the development of the NiMoO
4 phase. This suggests that NiMoO
4 begins to form on the surfaces of the materials being tested at this temperature. Despite the formation of NiMoO
4 at 400 °C, it has been noted that NiMoO
4 does not effectively lubricate the mating surfaces in the lower temperature range (RT-400 °C). Earlier findings also strengthen the point; the ineffectiveness of the NiMoO
4 phase as a solid lubricant in delivering sufficient lubrication caused the uplift in the COF [
31]. In
Figure 8b,e, the worn surface of the NC5 coating, at 400 °C, shows the generation of shallow channels, abrasion, and minute-size free loose wear debris. Mechanically, the tribo layer over the worn surface at ~400 °C exhibits evidence of instability, including spallation, delamination, and abrasive wear modes. As tribo-oxides accumulate over the worn surface and the original low-shear tribofilm is consumed or replaced, frictional contacts tend to produce abrasive debris, cracks and flaking rather than a smooth shear-friendly interface. The existence of these features for the NC5 coating can lead to increased contact between mating surfaces. This increased contact can contribute to higher values of average COFs and wear. The catalytic action of sulfur over the worn surface promotes the creation of molybdates of silver. The XRD pattern,
Figure 12a, shows the creation of several novel phases at elevated temperatures (600–800 °C). These phases include Ag
2MoO
4, Ag
2Mo
2O
7, Ag
2Mo
4O
13, MoO
3, NiO, and NiMoO
4. The declining trend of average COFs observed for the coatings can be attributed to the formation of these novel phases.
The coating (NC15) shows a decreasing trend in the COF across the temperature range RT to 200 °C. This decrease is owing to the soft nature of silver and ability to develop easily shearable junctions that are easier to shear off, thereby reducing friction. Interestingly, at 400 °C, as listed in
Figure 6, the said coating (NC15) shows the highest average COF in comparison to other testing temperatures. It could be due to insufficient lubrication prevailed by the silver particles. In
Figure 9d,e, the worn surface of the coating, at 400 °C, shows grooves and abrasion. The rise in the average COF at the said temperature is attributed to a lack of effective lubrication between the coating and the counter face. The counter face morphology,
Figure 11c, shows loosely bound, uneven coating material on the counter face at 400 °C. This loosely adhered transfer layer and coating material could contribute to a higher COF and wear due to incomplete or ineffective lubrication between the counter face and the NC15 coating. At 800 °C, the worn surface shows a glaze layer, as depicted in
Figure 9g,h. The manifestation of this smooth glaze layer avoids the paired bodies’ direct contact. As a result, a reduced COF and wear is observed at 800 °C compared to lower temperatures. At higher temperatures, such as 800 °C, the counter face morphology,
Figure 11e, exhibits smooth regions and well-compacted transfer layers. This suggests that effective lubricants have been formed on the worn surface. The XRD patterns,
Figure 12c, show the presence of phases, i.e., Ag
2MoO
4, Ag
2Mo
2O
7, Ag
2Mo
4O
13, MoO
3, NiO, and NiMoO
4. These phases act as effective lubricants that deliver efficient lubrication, particularly at elevated temperatures [
19]. The Raman spectra,
Figure 13c, also provide the signals of these lubricating phases, which enhance the tribo performance as the temperature increases. The Raman spectrum, as given in
Figure 14a, indicated the signals of novel lubricating phases in the transfer layer onto the counter face. The mutual interaction of the lubricious phases present onto the counter face and those developed on the worn surface minimized the contact between mating bodies. These phases enabled the easily shearable junctions, and allows the mating bodies to slide over each other without making direct contact. This mechanism leads to a continuously decreasing trend in the average COF and wear for the derived coating. At elevated temperatures (600–800 °C), the more crystalline lubricating oxides (such as NiO, Ag
2MoO
4) increase significantly as depicted in
Figure 12c and
Figure 13c. The inter-diffusion of the elements over the whole volume beneath the track, oxidation by frictional heating plus testing temperature and the ideal content of Ag (15 wt.% Ag) and its synergistic interaction with MoS
2 contributed to the reduced friction and wear as observed in the optimized NC15 coating. This synergy enhanced the effectiveness of the lubricating phases and promoted a smoother sliding interface, thus lowering friction and wear. During sliding under high-contact pressure, MoS
2 sheets align along their basal plane on the traced wear path. This alignment occurs due to the shearing forces that promote the orientation of MoS
2 layers. As per the calculation of the density function theory, MoS
2 is a 2D material with weak Van der Waals forces between its layers [
32]. This makes it susceptible to exfoliation, especially under mechanical stress like rubbing. The stress-induced shear forces can cause these layers to separate, which is beneficial for forming uniform tribo layers. The existence of a sharp band at 820 cm
−1 in the Raman spectrum, as indicated in
Figure 13c, corresponds to MoO
3. This band is associated with the symmetric stretching of Mo–O–Mo bonds, which is a characteristic of MoO
3. Due to environmental conditions (the existence of oxygen and moisture), along with a sufficient temperature increase, MoS
2 undergoes oxidation. This oxidation process converts MoS
2 into MoO
3. The tribo-chemical reaction for this process is: MoS
2 + 3.5 O
2 → MoO
3 + 2 SO
2. The development of the MoO
3 band at 820 cm
−1 is a clear indication of the oxidation process. It indicates that MoS
2 has been converted to MoO
3, and the band reflects the symmetric stretching of terminal oxygen atoms in the MoO
3 structure [
33]. At the same time silver also oxidizes, leading to the creation of AgO, a thermodynamically unstable compound [
34]. In the temperature range 83 to 134 °C, the formed AgO can decompose to Ag
2O and oxygen as per the following chemical equation: 4 AgO → 2 Ag
2O + O
2 [
35,
36]. Although Ag
2O is expected to develop, it could not be found in the Raman spectra owing to the continuous conversion of Ag
2O into Ag
2MoO
4 as per the chemical route: Ag
2O + MoO
3 → Ag
2MoO
4 [
37]. Silver (Ag) and molybdenum disulfide (MoS
2) work together to provide reliable lubrication across a broad temperature range: at lower temperatures, MoS
2’s layered structure enables ultra-low friction, while Ag, due to its low shear strength, forms a soft, load-bearing tribofilm and dissipates heat due to high thermal conductivity. As temperatures exceed ~350 °C, Ag reacts with oxidized MoS
2 products to form layered silver molybdate phases (e.g., Ag
2MoO
4, Ag
2Mo
2O
7, and Ag
2Mo
4O
13), which shear easily and sustain low friction, and at higher temperatures MoS
2 oxidizes into MoO
3 (lubricious oxide) and reacts with Ag
2O to create a stable, adaptive tribo-chemical layer maintaining low wear and friction, even up to 800 °C. The optimal content of Ag (15 wt.%) with MoS
2 produces more synergy and so stimulates the optimal content of lubricating oxides which is clearly evident in the XRD patterns and Raman spectra as shown in
Figure 12c and
Figure 13c, respectively. The formation of various oxides by the process discussed above causes the development of a dense layer over the worn surface which protects from further wear and also helps in the reduction in the COF. The designated coating NC15, which contains 15 wt.% of Ag, shows superior lubricious phases compared to NC10 at 800 °C. The reason behind the perceived behavior shown by the coating NC15 can be explained on the basis of the XRD and Raman spectra of the wear path. There is evidence of the intense peaks of NiO and Ag
2MoO
4 in the XRD and Raman spectra of the wear path of coating NC15 as shown in
Figure 12c and
Figure 13c, respectively. The formulated coating NC15 with 15 wt.% of Ag significantly reduces the COF and wear compared to NC10, as shown in
Figure 6 and
Figure 7. At temperatures beyond 400 °C, the continuous lessening in the COF and wear is attributed to the existence of lubricious oxides such as MoO
3 and NiO, as well as silver molybdates. The transformation sequence involves MoO
3 oxidizing into Ag
2Mo
4O
13 at 600 °C through the following chemical reaction: 2Ag + 4MoO
3 + 1/2 O
2 → Ag
2Mo
4O
13. Due to the available silver (Ag) combining with Ag
2Mo
4O
13 and O
2 to form Ag
2Mo
2O
7 via the chemical reaction 2Ag + Ag
2Mo
4O
13 + 1/2 O
2 → 2Ag
2Mo
2O
7, further transformation of Ag
2Mo
2O
7 to Ag
2MoO
4 at 800 °C occurs through the chemical reaction 2Ag + Ag
2Mo
2O
7 + 1/2O
2 → 2Ag
2MoO
4, as indicated earlier by other researchers [
38]. The silver molybdate phases, Ag
2MoO
4 and Ag
2Mo
2O
7, formed within the coating system are known for their layered crystal structures, which contribute to effective lubrication [
27]. The silver molybdate (Ag
2MoO
4) exhibits weak O–Ag–O bonding, which makes it particularly beneficial for continuous lessening of the friction coefficient and wear [
27]. The incorporation of 15 wt.% Ag in the NC15 coating composition facilitates the in situ formation of these lubricious molybdate phases, enhancing its high-temperature tribological performance. At increased temperatures (RT to 800 °C), there is an observable increase in crystallinity. This is supported by XRD patterns shown in
Figure 12c, where more intense and sharper diffraction peaks appear at elevated temperatures. These changes suggest a temperature-induced recrystallization process, where higher thermal energy allows atoms to reorganize into more ordered crystalline structures. The presence of an optimal content of Ag plays a pivotal role in this transformation. The inclusion of an optimal content of Ag (15 wt.%) not only aids in the nucleation of silver molybdates but also stabilizes the growing crystals by lowering the activation energy for phase formation. This is evident from
Figure 12c and
Figure 13c, where the heightened intensity of specific peaks indicates an excess precipitation of crystalline silver molybdates. These precipitates contribute to the formation of a stable, compact crystalline layer at the contact surface. The interplay between increased temperature, an optimal content of Ag, and intense formation of molybdates fosters an ideal surface condition that resists wear and maintains low friction. Additionally, prior studies have linked this behavior to the emergence of a glaze layer—a smooth, crystalline tribofilm formed during sliding which serves as a protective interface and further reduces the COF and wear [
39]. The solid lubricants, formed via in situ tribo-chemical reactions, provide a low-shear-strength tribofilm on the friction pair’s interface [
40], especially at elevated temperatures. The tribo-chemically generated glaze layers can provide effective, wear-reducing protection only when the contact conditions support oxide sintering and stimulate the optimal content of lubricious oxides as indicated in
Figure 12c and
Figure 13c. Debris formation and compaction should proceed continuously, which will help in the generation of a uniform tribo layer over the wear path. The glaze remains crack-free and properly bonded under stress and temperature cycling, which further supports the minimization of the friction coefficient and wear. In summary, the synergistic interaction between temperature, the optimal Ag content, and silver molybdates formation governs the high-temperature performance of the NC15 coating. The enhanced crystallinity, driven by recrystallization and Ag-induced molybdates precipitation, results in a durable lubricating layer that effectively protects against friction and wear under thermal stress.
The formulated coating NC20 at RT,
Figure 10a,d, has shown the cluster of wear debris and broken tribo layers over the formed wear path. At 400 °C,
Figure 10b,e, it possesses deep parallel grooves and loose, channelized, scattered wear debris are observed in the wear track. These features increase the average COF and wear of the NC20 coating at the said temperature. High-temperature tribology is governed more by tribofilm chemistry and dynamic stability rather than by bulk hardness. Too much Ag dilutes the active contact chemistry and weakens the matrix, leading to unstable tribofilms, and higher wear/COF despite softer phases. Excess Ag simply dilutes the chemistry of the produced phases via tribo-chemical reactions that participate actively in creating the shear plane of low shear strength. The derived coating NC20 produced
discontinuous re-deposition of loose debris, early delamination/spallation
or overly soft tribofilms that are not shear-friendly. A soft matrix and high Ag content led to Ag-rich smearing instead of coherent tribofilm. Essentially, the contact zone becomes
too soft and unstable, akin to a “grease” that cannot sustain shear loads. At 600 °C, the formation of Ag
2MoO
4 and NiO takes place. These phases reduced the average COF and wear of the derived coating at 600 °C. At 800 °C,
Figure 10c,f, the evolution of a glaze layer due to high temperatures, presence of a loosely adhered transfer layer, and wear debris are evident over the worn surface. During wear, exfoliated MoO
3 and hard Ni
3Al fragments entered the contact interface, acting as abrasive third-body particles, significantly accelerating wear and raising the wear of the formulated coating. These factors lead to three-body abrasion, which raises the average COF and wear significantly at the testing temperature for NC20. The evidence of less intensified peaks,
Figure 13d, indicated a lower extent of lubricious compounds over the wear path at 800 °C. The low intensified peaks of lubricious phases over the counter face transfer layer at elevated temperatures, shown in
Figure 14b, are somehow not able to separate the mating bodies and cause local touching of the mating surface and leads to a higher COF and wear. The other point of view is that the softening of the derived coating and reduced hardness due to the incorporation of an excessive Ag content (20 wt.%) in the current investigation are identified as causes for this behavior. The formation of a glaze lubricating layer at only some specific spots plus loose wear debris further contributed to the three-body abrasion and increased values of the friction coefficient and wear attained for the derived coating at this temperature. Compared to its closest competitors, NC10 and NC20, the formulated coating NC15 exhibited a consistently lower coefficient of friction and wear rate at all tested temperatures. However, the derived coating NC10 suffered from insufficient formation of high-temperature lubricious oxides and NC20 showed excessive softening and three-body abrasion due to surplus Ag; NC15 provided an optimal balance between mechanical integrity and tribo-chemical lubrication.
Figure 17 shows the 3D surface scanning profiles of the wear tracks for the NC15 and NC20 coatings at 5 N load and 0.3 m/s sliding speed. The 3D profile data clearly shows the differences in the widths and depths of the wear tracks for different participating coatings. The NC15 coating as shown in
Figure 17a shows the shallowest and smoothest wear track: the groove is broad with gentle slopes, minimal depth variation, and the surface appears more uniform, with reduced asperity height. These observed features suggest the formation of a stable, load-bearing tribofilm or glaze layer. The wear mechanism changes from abrasive wear to oxidation-assisted mild wear. However, the NC20 coating, as shown in
Figure 17b, exhibits a deep and narrow central groove and steep groove walls indicating severe plowing. The wear mechanism changes from abrasive wear to a limited formation of a protective tribofilm, and detached debris likely acted as third-body abrasives. With an increased content 20 wt.% of Ag in the formulated coating NC20, the hardness of the coating decreases due to over-softening, which causes tribofilm rupture and debris delamination. This mechanism leads to discontinuous glaze patches, higher roughness, persistent abrasive grooves, and friction coefficient instability. Thus, although Ag promotes lubrication, its excessive content in NC20 disrupts tribofilm integrity at high temperatures. At 800 °C, NC15 exhibits a pronounced reduction in wear track roughness (Ra ≈ 0.45–0.55 µm) and mean groove depth (dg≈ 0.6–0.9 µm) compared with NC20 (Ra ≈ 1.2–1.5 µm; dg ≈ 1.3–1.8 µm), indicating a transition from severe plowing to a smoothed, load-bearing tribofilm. The reduced COF fluctuation observed for NC15 at 800 °C,
Figure 5d, correlates with the formation of a smooth tribological interface, indicating a stable shear plane within the glaze layer. In contrast, NC20 exhibits higher COF oscillations, consistent with the intermittent rupture and re-formation of an unstable tribofilm due to excessive Ag-rich debris.
When the various formulated coatings are worn as the temperature increases (RT-800 °C), their surface morphologies change and exhibit different worn morphologies due to evolving dominant wear mechanisms and chemical transformations of the participating solid lubricants (Ag and MoS
2), depending on the testing temperatures. At RT, the wear mechanisms in NC5 coatings involve a combination of abrasion with the existence of coating material debris as shown in
Figure 8a,d; however, at 400 °C, abrasion, adhesion and plowing, as clearly evident in
Figure 8b,e, are the dominating wear mechanisms. The SEM morphology at 400 °C suggests the inadequate lubrication and indication of abrasion due to the oxidation of MoS
2 and Ag are not able to produce the favorable lubricants and hence different morphologies could be perceived at 400 °C. At higher temperatures, the formation of a glaze layer becomes predominant, forming silver molybdates-rich tribofilms that create smooth, continuous oxide glaze layers with minimal furrowing, markedly reducing direct abrasive contact and micro-cracking. For the NC15 coating, the wear mechanisms transition from a mix of abrasion and adhesion in the low-temperature range (RT-400 °C), as shown in
Figure 9a,b,d,e, to tribo oxidation, and formation of glaze layers at higher temperatures. In contrast, the NC20 coating consistently shows delamination, a cluster of loose wear debris, and discontinuous tribo layer creation in low-temperature regimes, as shown in
Figure 10a,b,d,e. At elevated temperatures, glaze layer formation with a loosely adhered transfer layer and wear debris formation are evident.