Search Results (14)

The church of Saint Felix in Girona (Spain) is crowned by an octagonal bell tower with a stone pinnacle at each corner. It was built using dry-joint stone masonry, a technique that involves laying stones in a precise pattern to create a solid and durable structure. In order to strengthen the connection between the stone blocks of the pinnacles, a wooden bar was placed through a central hole carved in the stone structure. Today, the inner structure has completely disappeared. During maintenance and repair work, it was decided to restore the functionality of the disappeared reinforcement by installing a titanium bar in its place. Due to the uncertainty associated with the pinnacle’s behaviour and the lack of both, a proper numerical model of the monument, and an extensive characterization of the materials, a strategy based on multiple approaches was designed. The proposed strategy was based on combining numerical and experimental models, the final objective being to determine the length and mechanical properties of the metallic inclusion, considering the effects of gravity, wind, and seismic forces. A scale model of the pinnacle was evaluated in laboratory conditions. The results were used to calibrate a numerical model representing the scale specimen. After calibration, the results were extrapolated to a full-scale numerical model. The experimental and numerical results showed that the pinnacles needed to be reinforced along their entire height. The tensile stresses cause by wind and seismic forces at different levels, could not be compensated without the contribution of the titanium bar inserted into the pinnacle. Full article

Bell towers, due to their slender geometry and structural configuration, are among the buildings most susceptible to deterioration from weathering and seismic events. These aspects influence the structural assessment of these historic towers, which is essential for their conservation and maintenance. The “Carmine Maggiore” bell tower in Naples (Italy) has been an important and prominent landmark of the city for centuries. It is square in plan and 72 m high. Over time, it suffered extensive damage and was severely damaged by the earthquake of 1456. Reconstruction began in the first decade of the 17th century and the original design was modified, adding two stories and changing the shape of the plan to octagonal. In the centuries that followed, the structure was damaged again and further interventions were carried out, adding tie-rods and replacing damaged elements. Today, the bell tower has very elaborate façades with mouldings and decorations, so that the supporting structure appears to be covered with plaster, stucco, and stone elements. This paper describes the results of FEM analyses of the bell tower, obtained from models with different levels of complexity to evaluate the influence of stone cladding elements on the seismic behaviour. In particular, the difference in the IS safety indices, calculated as the ratio of capacity to demand, exceeds 15%, due to the mechanical consistency of the cladding elements, which contribute significantly to both stiffness and strength. Full article

The seismic assessment of historical masonry bell towers is of significant interest, particularly in Italy, due to their widespread presence and inherent vulnerability given by their slenderness. According to technical codes and standard practice, the seismic evaluation of masonry bell towers can be conducted using a range of methodologies that vary in their level of detail. This paper presents a case study of a historical masonry bell tower located in the Caserta Province (Italy). Extensive investigative efforts were undertaken to determine the tower’s key geometric and structural characteristics, as well as to document ongoing damage phenomena. The dynamic behavior of the tower was assessed through ambient vibration testing, which enabled the identification of the principal modal shapes and corresponding frequencies, also highlighting peculiar dynamical characteristics caused by the damage conditions. Subsequently, the seismic assessment was carried out using both Level 1 (simplified mechanical) and Level 2 (kinematic limit analysis) methodologies. This assessment helped identify the most probable collapse mechanisms and laid the foundation for employing more advanced methodologies to design necessary retrofitting interventions. The study emphasizes the importance of Level 2 analyses for structures where out-of-plane failure mechanisms are likely due to pre-existing cracking. Both approaches provide less-than-unity acceleration factors, ranging from 0.45 for Level 1 (assuming non-ductile behavior) to 0.59 for Level 2, in this case specifically using the information available about existing cracking pattern. Full article

Masonry towers are peculiar structures with complex structural behavior despite biased conclusions deriving from their geometrical regularity and simplicity. Their geometrical features and the epistemic uncertainty that masonry material bears strongly influence their static and seismic behavior. This paper investigates a remarkable and representative case study. The bell tower of Portogruaro (Italy) is a 57 m high tall construction, built in the XII-th century, and has a notable inclination. The Italian Guideline for the safety assessment of masonry towers is a key focus in this paper, highlighting the pros and cons of different suggested approaches. Some relevant proposals are presented in this paper in order to address the seismic safety assessment of masonry bell towers. The findings show that very slender structures do not meet the guidelines recommendations due to limitations in their current stress state. In addition, in similar cases, the recommended values for the mechanical properties of masonry material led to predicting non-withstanding structural behavior, questioning the correct choice of the adapted material properties. Advanced pushover analysis has been conducted in order to investigate the results of the simplified approach in terms of failure patterns and seismic safety estimation. The simulations are implemented for four different hypothetical scenarios of the existing masonry mechanical properties. The results obtained for the case study tower reflect a different perspective in the seismic assessment of masonry towers when specific approaches are defined. The preliminary results on the safety of Portogruaro Tower show a significant variability of seismic safety based on the adopted scenario, highlighting the necessity to pay attention to the preservation state of the present case and of similar ones. Full article

In this study, modal and structural identification of a historic masonry bell tower in Čuntići, Croatia, damaged during the recent Petrinja earthquake, was performed. The results of the ambient vibration tests (AVT) and operational modal analysis (OMA) were used to update the finite element numerical model of the bell tower. Three modes were experimentally determined: the first two were bending modes (f₁ = 4.395 Hz and f₂ = 4.639 Hz), and the third was a torsional mode (f₃ = 10.303 Hz). The experimentally determined and the originally calculated (preliminary NM) modal shapes agreed well, but in terms of modal frequencies, the correlation was poor. After model updating, some structural parameters were identified, and a reliable finite element numerical model was established. The proposed method can provide a reliable evaluation of the structural parameters of historic masonry buildings. Full article

In seismic-prone areas, ecclesiastical masonry complexes have shown very high vulnerability, as detected after the last Italian earthquakes, such as those that occurred in L’Aquila (2009), Emilia-Romagna (2012), Central Italy (2016), and Ischia (2017). Partial collapses often affect these types of aggregate buildings due to the presence of highly vulnerable elements, such as bell towers. Preliminary analyses, including straightforward and quick methods, are necessary to assess their vulnerability. This paper proposes a simplified method to analyse bell tower dynamic behaviour and the results obtained are compared with several different approaches. The first is based on the dynamics of two rigid blocks (bell tower and lower building), and the second concerns a single block (bell tower only). The proposed method can be considered as a quick procedure involving few parameters to provide a preliminary analysis before use of more complex models such as finite element models. It aims to provide a valuable tool for the initial evaluation of the stability and risk index of the structure. The double-block model considers the associations between the rocking of the bell tower and the sliding motion of the underlying building. A parametric evaluation for different friction coefficients is proposed. The results are represented as rotation time histories and compared with analysis of the single vulnerable element, i.e., the bell tower subjected to the floor spectrum. The results show that high excitation frequency and friction coefficient values make the bell tower stable, and that the simplified model provides a clear safety advantage. Full article

Resonance frequencies of a masonry bell tower were estimated by means of ambient noise measurements and compared with those computed by using fixed base, Winkler, and FE numerical, including subsoil. Given the geological complexity that characterizes the subsurface of the analyzed area, despite the presence of massive volcanic outcrops near the bell tower, we carried out a geophysical characterization of the subsoil by using active and passive seismic surveys. These surveys have identified a soft substrate underneath the construction; for this reason, the dynamic identification of the tower was performed, including the interaction with the soil. The resonance frequencies of the masonry bell tower computed by the models are very similar to those obtained using ambient noise. Results suggest that building resonance frequencies, estimated by ambient noise surveys, can be used because of their reliability especially when quick analyses are required at historical buildings located in seismically active areas needing plan actions to reduce their vulnerability. Moreover, such analyses, being performed on samplings acquired within the structure, allow for estimating its dynamic response, taking into account the effect of subsurface characteristics as well. Full article

The paper presents a failure analysis of the bell tower of the church of St. Francis of Assisi on Kaptol in Zagreb subjected to seismic activity using the finite-discrete element method—FDEM. The bell tower is a masonry building, and throughout history it has undergone multiple damages and reconstructions. It was significantly damaged during the earthquake in Zagreb which occurred on 22 March 2020 with a magnitude of 5.5. The analysis was performed on a simplified FDEM 2D numerical model which corresponds to the structure in its current pre-disaster state and the structure after the proposed post-disaster reconstruction. The obtained results showed a good agreement of the crack pattern in the numerical model and the cracks that occurred due to these earthquakes. In addition, the conclusions based on the conducted analysis can provide a better insight into the behaviour and serve as guidelines to engineers for the design of such and similar structures. Full article

The preservation of cultural heritage needs a restoration design format that can only be achievable by an in-depth multidisciplinary approach. Besides, a sustainable project requires that the link between architecture and technology be expressed through a “conscious” approach to the building. Therefore, each design must be based on the in-depth knowledge of history, construction rules, and mechanical properties of buildings to be restored. The bell towers are among the most exposed to degradation and earthquake damage constructions for their intrinsic geometry and structure. The “Carmine Maggiore” bell tower is one of the most important symbols of Naples (Italy) and, at 72 m high, it has stood out for centuries against the city. The tower underwent many significant damages and structural changes over time. The design, here illustrated, was aimed at restoring and repairing this bell tower, preserving existing materials, without altering the signs of time. The paper shows the methodology followed in the project, which, starting from an in-depth historical analysis and a detailed geometric and diagnostic survey, through several structural analyses, allowed an “inclusive” project (restoration, structural, and lighting project) based on suitable solutions that meet all the requirements of compatibility, sustainability, and structural safety. Full article

Masonry towers are part of a valuable architectural heritage characterizing the landscape of many historical areas. These towers are vulnerable structures that are prone to earthquake damage. Hence, the design of effective seismic upgrading interventions is an important task for preserving such architectural forms for future generations. In view of that, the objective of this study is to contribute a possible addition to the portfolio of available approaches for seismic upgrading of masonry towers. This goal was pursued by exploring an innovative structural solution that does not alter the external appearance of the tower and its static scheme under gravity loads, yet is able to increase its capacity to withstand seismic actions through added damping. Specifically, the proposed solution consists of a steel structure internal to the masonry tower that incorporates fluid viscous dampers. In order to evaluate its potentialities, a real case study was taken as a testbed structure, historic analysis as well as geometric and architectural surveys were undertaken, an initial design for the upgrading was made, and numerical simulations were performed. The obtained results, although preliminary, highlight the potentialities of the proposed structural solution for the seismic upgrading of masonry towers and might open the way to future developments and applications. Full article

Masonry towers are considered an important part of cultural heritage due to their architectural and historical value. From a structural perspective these kind of buildings are considered slender elements, the same as a cantilever beam. In real cases it is not easy to model with high accuracy these heritage constructions, since the geometry and mechanical properties of the constituent materials are not adequately known. On the other hand, a deep knowledge of the structural and seismic vulnerability of the masonry towers is needed in order to preserve and retrofit, when necessary, their architectural and cultural value. In the present research an exhaustive study is presented, as it regards the assessment of the seismic vulnerability of a heritage masonry bell-tower, built in the 14th century. An innovative protocol of structural survey followed, and it is proposed herein. The geometry of the tower was easily obtained by digital photogrammetry assisted by a drone. The geometrical model was easily converted into a digitalized input, that was introduced into a finite element method (FEM)-based code. The 3D model was used for linear static, linear dynamic and nonlinear static (pushover) structural analyses. The vulnerability of the masonry tower was assessed and at least one kinematic was found to be not verified. Full article

The authors investigated the dynamic behaviour of the San Silvestro belfry in L’Aquila (Italy). The 2009 earthquake in L’Aquila caused severe damages to the entire masonry complex. Extensive rehabilitation works, ended in 2019, repaired the structure and enhanced its seismic safety. In this paper, the authors discuss three aspects typical of masonry towers by interpreting the outcomes of Operational Modal Analysis carried out on December 2019: the interactions between the tower and the masonry complex, the dynamic effects of the bell, and the seismic reliability assessment of the tower. Specifically, the experimental mode shapes drive the estimation of an equivalent cross-section, whose principal axes of inertia match with the directions of oscillation of the mode shapes, and the parameters of an equivalent cantilevered beam roughly representative of the tower dynamics. In a second step, a two-degrees-of-freedom analytical model simulates the dynamic coupling between the tower and the more massive bell. The response of the system to a set of seven strong-motion earthquakes yields the assessment of the bell effects over the seismic performance of the masonry tower. Full article

Historical churches, tall ancient masonry buildings, and bell towers are structures subjected to high risks due to their age, elevation, and small base-area-to-height ratio. In this paper, the results of an innovative monitoring technique for structural integrity assessment applied to a historical bell tower are reported. The emblematic case study of the monitoring of the Turin Cathedral bell tower (northwest Italy) is herein presented. First of all, the damage evolution in a portion of the structure localized in the lower levels of the tall masonry building is described by the evaluation of the cumulative number of acoustic emissions (AEs) and by different parameters able to predict the time dependence of the damage development, in addition to the 3D localization of the AE sources. The b-value analysis shows a decreasing trend down to values compatible with the growth of localized micro and macro-cracks in the portion of the structure close to the base of the tower. These results seem to be in good agreement with the static and dynamic analysis performed numerically by an accurate FEM (finite element model). Similar results were also obtained during the application of the AE monitoring to the wooden frame sustaining the bells in the tower cell. Finally, a statistical analysis based on the average values of the b-value are carried out at the scale of the monument and at the seismic regional scale. In particular, according to recent studies, a comparison between the b-value obtained by AE signal analysis and the regional activity is proposed in order to correlate the AE detected on the structure to the seismic activity, discriminating foreshock, and aftershock intervals in the analyzed time series. Full article

This paper discusses the performance of a terrestrial radar interferometer for the structural monitoring of ancient masonry towers. High-speed radar interferometry is an innovative and powerful remote sensing technique for the dynamic monitoring of large structures since it is contactless, non-destructive, and able to measure fast displacements on the order of tenths of millimeters. This methodology was tested on a masonry tower of great historical interest, the Saint Prospero bell tower (Northern Italy). To evaluate the quality of the results, data collected from the interferometer were compared and validated with those provided by two types of accelerometer-based measuring systems directly installed on the tower. Dynamic tests were conducted in operational conditions as well as during a bell concert. The first aimed at characterizing the dynamic behavior of the tower, while the second allowed to evaluate the bell swinging effects. Results showed a good agreement among the different measuring systems and demonstrated the potential of the radar interferometry for the dynamic monitoring of structures, with special focus on the need for an accurate design of the geometric aspects of the surveys. Full article