Abstract
By means of the generating function method and Dougall’s formulae for bilateral hypergeometric series, we examine four classes of infinite series, which may be considered as variants of Riemann zeta function. Several summation formulae are established in closed form, which shows remarkably that the values of these series result in multiples of integer powers of either by rational numbers or by algebraic numbers.
Keywords:
Riemann zeta function; the gamma function; generating function; trigonometric function; bilateral hypergeometric series MSC:
11M06; 33C20
1. Introduction and Motivation
Recently, Zhou [1] proposed the following problem. For , let
Prove and, for ,
We find that this problem can be resolved by the generating function approach in conjunction with Dougall’s bilateral series identity. Define the generating function
We can manipulate it by exchange of the summation order
The next step is crucial by rewriting the summand
Then, we can express as a bilateral series
Recall that, for an indeterminate and , the shifted factorial is defined by the -function quotient
For the sake of brevity, the multiparameter -function will be shortened as
For the four complex numbers subject to condition , Dougall ([2]) discovered the following formula for the bilateral series:
Therefore, can further be reformulated and evaluated as follows:
By making use of the reciprocal property (cf. Rainville ([3], §17))
we find the simplified generating function
Observing further that
we can express the above generating function as
Recall Glaisher’s numbers (cf. A002114 in [4]) with the initial terms
that have the following exponential generating function
we find from (4) the following explicit formula:
The values of the first few series are highlighted below as examples:
In view of the power series expansion
rewriting further (4) by
and extracting the coefficient of across the above equation, we find the following homogeneous recurrence relation
This is simpler than Zhou’s recursion (2), since the latter contains an extra constant term. In order to derive Zhou’s equation, we need the triple angle identity
Multiplying (4) by , we obtain another functional equation
Finally, Zhou’s Equation (2) follows by extracting the coefficient of across.
Let p and q be two natural numbers such that . The above solution of Zhou’s problems motivates the authors to investigate further the following four classes of generalized series:
Recall the Hurwitz zeta function and its alternating form (cf. ([5], §25.11))
which play an important role in mathematics and have been investigated extensively. The afore-defined four functions can be considered as bilateral generalizations of and . They will be computed, in closed form, in the remaining four separate sections, with their values being multiples of integer powers of either by rational numbers or by algebraic numbers. These results can be considered as counterparts of two well-known zeta function formulae discovered by Euler:
where and are Bernoulli and Euler numbers with the following trigonometric generating functions:
The strategy for realizing this objective consists of the generating function method and bilateral hypergeoemtric series summation formulae (see [6] and ([7], Chapter 6) for notations), as sketched in presenting our solution to Zhou’s problem. In addition to the identity (3), we shall also utilize another formula of Dougall ([2]) for well poised -series:
provided that and are complex numbers such that the bilateral series is well-defined. The original proofs due to Dougall for both and are standard, which consist of computing the contour integral of certain complex functions through the Cauchy residue theorem (see also Slater ([7], §6.1), and ([8], §5.3)). There are also proofs through transformation from bilateral series to unilateral series, which can be found in Chu [9,10].
In order to ensure the accuracy, we have verified numerically, throughout the paper, all the infinite series evaluations by appropriately devised Mathematica commands.
2. Evaluation of -Series
Consider the generating function
According to (3), we have the closed form expression in terms of -function
which can be simplified into trigonometric functions as in the theorem below.
Theorem 1.
As applications of this theorem, we exhibit five classes of infinite series evaluations by specifying concrete numbers for p and q under the condition .
2.1.
In this case, the generating function in Theorem 1 becomes
Taking into account that
we derive the following explicit formula:
The first five values are displayed below as examples:
2.2.
In this case, the generating function becomes simpler
The same series was previously examined by Elkies [11] in a similar manner.
Observing that
we find the explicit formula
together with the first five values:
2.3.
In this case, the generating function is given by
Keeping in mind that
we derive the following explicit formula:
as well as the evaluations of the first five series:
2.4.
The corresponding generating function reads as
For the series labeled by “” and “”, the resulting expressions are very complicated. Therefore, we are limited, hereafter, to highlighting the first five series by extracting the initial five coefficients from their generating functions:
2.5.
The corresponding generating function reads as
Extracting the first five coefficients across gives the following evaluations:
Comparing the above expressions with those displayed in the last subsection, we notice a quite curious fact that they are “algebraic conjugates”, i.e., one group of formulae becomes another group if the algebraic numbers therein are replaced by their conjugate ones. As the reader can see from the rest of the paper that, for each class of the series defined in (6)–(9), this phenomenon occurs among all the series paired by labels “” and “”.
3. Evaluation of -Series
Similarly, we can manipulate the generating function
Now letting and in (10), we obtain the formula
This can be employed to evaluating the generating function as follows:
By means of the -function reciprocity, we obtain the following simplified expression:
Theorem 2.
The generating function fordefined in (7) is given by
By assigning small integer values for p and q subject to , we can further derive from this theorem concrete infinite series evaluations.
3.1.
In this case, the generating function in Theorem 2 becomes
Taking into account that
we obtain the following explicit formula:
as well as the evaluations of the first five series:
3.2.
We have the corresponding generating function
In view of the power series expansion
we derive the following analytical formula
Its first five values are given explicitly as follows:
3.3.
The corresponding generating function reads as
According to (12), the following power series expansion holds
Hence, we find the explicit formula
The first five series are highlighted as examples:
3.4.
The corresponding generating function becomes
where
Then, by extracting the initial five coefficients from the above generating function, we deduce the following infinite series evaluations:
3.5.
The corresponding generating function can be written as
where
Extracting the first five coefficients from the above , we find the related infinite series evaluations:
4. Evaluation of -Series
The preceding approach to determine the generation functions for the series and does not work directly for . We have to rewrite first the bilateral series as two unilateral ones by making the replacement for the terms with negative summation index k:
Then, we can deal with the generating function
By further rewriting the summand
we can express the generation function in terms of the -series
After some simplifications, we find the following trigonometric expression:
Theorem 3.
The generating function fordefined in (8) is given by
When and , this gives rise to the generating function (4) illustrated in the introduction for the series proposed by Zhou [1]. Further examples are recorded in the next four subsections.
4.1.
In this case, the explicit generating function is given by
By making use of (11), we can expand the trigonometric function into power series
This yields the following explicit formula:
The values of the first five series are displayed as follows:
4.2.
The corresponding generating function reads as
Then, we derive the following explicit formula:
together with the evaluations of the first five series:
The same values were also obtained previously by Elkies [11].
4.3.
The corresponding generating function is given by
where
Extracting the first five coefficients from leads us to the following formulae:
4.4.
The corresponding generating function reads as
where
By extracting the first five coefficients from the above generating function, we find the following infinite series evaluations:
5. Evaluation of -Series
Analogously, by writing first the bilateral series as two unilateral ones
we can proceed with the generating function
By reformulating the summand
we can express in terms of bilateral series
To evaluate the above -series, letting and in (10) yields
Then, the generating function can explicitly be calculated as
Therefore, we obtain the following trigonometric expression.
Theorem 4.
The generating function fordefined in (9) is given by
Particular cases of this theorem are presented in the following examples.
5.1.
In this case, the generating function reads as
Recalling (11), we can expand the trigonometric function into power series
From this, we obtain the following analytical formula:
The values of the first five infinite series are given as follows:
5.2.
In this case, we obtain the following generating function:
By employing the power series expansion
we derive the following analytical formula:
Hence, the closed form evaluations for the first five series follow immediately:
5.3.
In this case, the generating function is given by
Noting that
we find the following explicit formula
as well as the evaluations of the first five series:
5.4.
The corresponding explicit generating function reads as
where
Then, the first five coefficients of give rise to the following formulae:
5.5.
The corresponding generating function reads as
where
Extracting the initial five coefficients from yields the following infinite series evaluations:
Concluding comments For the four series defined in (6)–(9), their generating functions and evaluations are determined under the conditions “ and ”. However, all the theorems are still valid if these conditions are released by “ with p and q being non-proportional: ”. For instance, Theorem 1 can be restated as follows: Let subject to . Then, the following generating function holds
By expanding the above function into power series, it is possible to evaluate theoretically the corresponding infinite series. However, the resulting expressions are too involved to be practically presented.
In addition, the identities presented in this paper suggest that one may further examine, in general, the following bilateral Hurwitz zeta function and its alternating counterpart:
Then, any closed formula of the above bilateral series will result in a reciprocal identity about or . The interested reader is enthusiastically encouraged to make exploration.
Author Contributions
Original draft & supervision, W.C.; Writing & review, N.N.L. All authors have read and agreed to the published version of the manuscript.
Funding
The first author was partially supported by the Key Program of Higher Education of Henan Province (No. 22B110021).
Institutional Review Board Statement
Not applicable.
Informed Consent Statement
Not applicable.
Conflicts of Interest
The authors declare no conflict of interest.
References
- Zhou, L. Problem 12262. Am. Math. Mon. 2021, 128, 563. [Google Scholar]
- Dougall, M.A. On Vandermonde’s theorem and some more general expansion. Proc. Edin. Math. Soc. 1907, 25, 114–132. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Rainville, E.D. Special Functions; The Macmillan Company: New York, NY, USA, 1960. [Google Scholar]
- Sloane, N.J.A. The On-Line Encyclopedia of Integer Sequences (OEIS). Available online: http://oeis.org/ (accessed on 6 June 2022).
- Apostol, T.M. Hurwitz zeta function. In NIST Handbook of Mathematical Functions; Olver, F.W.J., Boisvert, R.F., Eds.; Cambridge University Press: Cambridge, UK, 2010. [Google Scholar]
- Bailey, W.N. Generalized Hypergeometric Series; Cambridge University Press: Cambridge, UK, 1935. [Google Scholar]
- Slater, L.J. Generalized Hypergeoemtric Functions; Cambridge University Press: Cambridge, UK, 1966. [Google Scholar]
- Mitrinovic, D.S.; Keckic, J.D. The Cauchy Method of Residues: Theory and Applications; Kluwer Academic: Dordrecht, The Netherlands, 1993; Volume 2. [Google Scholar]
- Chu, W. Asymptotic method for Dougall’s bilateral hypergeometric sums. Bull. Sci. Math. 2007, 131, 457–468. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef][Green Version]
- Chu, W. Nonterminating well–poised hypergeometric series. Hacet. J. Math. Stat. 2020, 49, 1611–1624. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Elkies, N.D. On the sums . Am. Math. Mon. 2003, 110, 561–573. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
Publisher’s Note: MDPI stays neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations. |
© 2022 by the authors. Licensee MDPI, Basel, Switzerland. This article is an open access article distributed under the terms and conditions of the Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY) license (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/).