Review Reports
- Jessica Grenfell1,2,* and
- Andrew Soundy2,*
Reviewer 1: Anonymous Reviewer 2: Anonymous
Round 1
Reviewer 1 Report
Some recommendations are provided as below:
P2-L67: The ENTREQ acronym should be demonstrated its full compound term (Enhancing Transparency in Reporting the synthesis of Qualitative research) such as COREQ in P3-L118.
P2-L84: The SPIDER acronym should be described much more clear. (eg. S:Studies; E: Exploration, et al).
P2-L85, 87, P3-L94, 96: The first word of a sentence would be capitalized.
P3-L137: The PRISMA acronym should be demonstrated its full compound term (Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic reviews and Meta-Analyses).
P4-Figure 1: The initially included 1508 articles were collected from 1490 records through database searching and 17 additional records through citation chaining. 1490+17=1507, Why?
P7-Figure 2: The capitalization of all words in 4 blocks should be consistent.
P10-13: All the references must be re-arranged.
Author Response
Some recommendations are provided as below:
P2-L67: The ENTREQ acronym should be demonstrated its full compound term (Enhancing Transparency in Reporting the synthesis of Qualitative research) such as COREQ in P3-L118.
JG: This has been updated
P2-L84: The SPIDER acronym should be described much more clear. (eg. S:Studies; E: Exploration, et al).
JG: This has been updated
P2-L85, 87, P3-L94, 96: The first word of a sentence would be capitalized.
JG: This has been updated.
P3-L137: The PRISMA acronym should be demonstrated its full compound term (Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic reviews and Meta-Analyses).
This has been updated.
P4-Figure 1: The initially included 1508 articles were collected from 1490 records through database searching and 17 additional records through citation chaining. 1490+17=1507, Why?
JG: The incorrect diagram was used. This has been updated with correct numbers.
P7-Figure 2: The capitalization of all words in 4 blocks should be consistent.
JG: This has been updated
P10-13: All the references must be re-arranged
JG: This has been ammended, all references are in numerical order when they first appear in the text
Author Response File: 
Author Response.docx
Reviewer 2 Report
This is a thorough and excellent review of a hard to assess area.
Author Response
Thank you for your positive comments.