Review Reports

Round 1

Reviewer 1 Report

I felt this was a very interesting paper on anion binding and transport by dendrimers.  There has not been a lot of work on this aspect of dendrimer chemistry and I think this is likely to be a highly cited contribution.  I think it should be accepted as is.

Author Response

The reviewer has not asked for any revisions

Reviewer 2 Report

The work is well done and present, therefore it is recommended for publication. However, it would be better for authors to clarify the following points:

1  Regarding yields, the data should be provided instead of the number with "about" such as "~70%". Surely it is fine to have it with a range. 

2 The molecular weights are present with considering efficient digits, in such case, using exponentiation is better instead of containing numbers of 0. 

Author Response

We have made the changes regarding yields and significant figures (for molecular weight data)