Sign in to use this feature.

Years

Between: -

Subjects

remove_circle_outline
remove_circle_outline
remove_circle_outline
remove_circle_outline
remove_circle_outline
remove_circle_outline
remove_circle_outline
remove_circle_outline
remove_circle_outline

Journals

Article Types

Countries / Regions

Search Results (24)

Search Parameters:
Keywords = Content and Language Integrated Learning (CLIL)

Order results
Result details
Results per page
Select all
Export citation of selected articles as:
12 pages, 1326 KB  
Article
Future Teachers Speak Up: Exploring Pre-Primary and Primary Trainees’ Beliefs About Bilingual Education Programs in Spain
by Isabel Alonso-Belmonte
Educ. Sci. 2026, 16(1), 131; https://doi.org/10.3390/educsci16010131 - 15 Jan 2026
Viewed by 205
Abstract
The present exploratory study investigates how pre-primary and primary student teachers (STs) at the Universidad Autónoma de Madrid (UAM) perceive the impact of bilingual education programs (BEPs) on children’s learning experience. Specifically, it examines student teachers’ views on the benefits and challenges of [...] Read more.
The present exploratory study investigates how pre-primary and primary student teachers (STs) at the Universidad Autónoma de Madrid (UAM) perceive the impact of bilingual education programs (BEPs) on children’s learning experience. Specifically, it examines student teachers’ views on the benefits and challenges of implementing Content and Language Integrated Learning (CLIL) in pre-primary and primary education and explores whether there are differences between the opinions of the two groups. The analysis is based on data from six items of a structured questionnaire, validated in previous studies and completed by 170 prospective pre-primary and primary teachers at the UAM. The results suggest a shared perception among STs that BEPs enrich the learning experience of students in both pre-primary and primary education. Most STs recognize that CLIL enhances language proficiency and supports cognitive development, although they also point to insufficient teacher training and the low motivation of children with learning difficulties as major challenges. While no major differences emerged between the views of pre-primary and primary STs, subtle variations point to the existence of two distinct trainee profiles that determine their views on BEPs and that would require further mid-term investigation. The findings highlight areas for targeted support in teacher training programs. Full article
(This article belongs to the Special Issue Research, Innovation, and Practice in Bilingual Education)
Show Figures

Figure 1

20 pages, 1735 KB  
Article
AI-Enhanced CLIL for Embodied Learning: Applying the CLPS Framework in Secondary Physical Education
by Cristina Ramírez-Aroca and Arash Javadinejad
Educ. Sci. 2026, 16(1), 62; https://doi.org/10.3390/educsci16010062 - 2 Jan 2026
Viewed by 378
Abstract
This study examines how Artificial Intelligence (AI) can enhance Content and Language Integrated Learning (CLIL) through embodied, multimodal instruction in secondary Physical Education (PE). Drawing on Fernández Fontecha’s Content and Language Processing Sequence (CLPS) model, four AI-supported CLIL modules were designed and partially [...] Read more.
This study examines how Artificial Intelligence (AI) can enhance Content and Language Integrated Learning (CLIL) through embodied, multimodal instruction in secondary Physical Education (PE). Drawing on Fernández Fontecha’s Content and Language Processing Sequence (CLPS) model, four AI-supported CLIL modules were designed and partially implemented in a Spanish secondary school. The exploratory, design-based study involved 25 students (aged 13–14) enrolled in second-year secondary education (2° ESO). Data were collected through a student perception survey and structured teacher observations to examine learners’ perceived content understanding, language use, engagement, and embodied participation in AI-supported CLIL tasks. Results indicate high levels of student engagement and positive perceptions of learning, particularly regarding vocabulary use, task comprehension, and the integration of physical movement with language use. Students reported that AI tools such as NaturalReader and Gliglish supported pronunciation practice, comprehension, and interactive language use when embedded within guided CLIL tasks. The findings highlight the pedagogical potential of AI as a mediating scaffold in embodied CLIL contexts, while underscoring the importance of teacher guidance and task design. The study contributes to emerging research on AI-enhanced CLIL by offering empirically grounded insights into the affordances and limitations of integrating AI in Physical Education. Full article
Show Figures

Figure 1

32 pages, 2250 KB  
Article
Divergent Role of AI in Social Development: A Comparative Study of Teachers’ and Students’ Perceptions in Online and Physical Classrooms
by Qianye Wen, Jianliang Wang, Zhuoqi Guo and Daniel Badulescu
Behav. Sci. 2025, 15(12), 1649; https://doi.org/10.3390/bs15121649 - 30 Nov 2025
Viewed by 743
Abstract
This study addresses a critical gap in understanding Artificial Intelligence (AI)’s role in education by empirically investigating and comparing the distinct perceptions of teachers and students regarding AI’s role in a comprehensive range of social development aspects in both online and physical classroom [...] Read more.
This study addresses a critical gap in understanding Artificial Intelligence (AI)’s role in education by empirically investigating and comparing the distinct perceptions of teachers and students regarding AI’s role in a comprehensive range of social development aspects in both online and physical classroom settings. In particular, we evaluated how teachers utilize AI in their teaching methods, namely, Communicative Language Teaching (CLT), the Direct Method (DL), Task-Based Language Teaching (TBLT), Content and Language Integrated Learning (CLIL), and Community Language Learning (CLL), and students in their learning methods, namely, Communicative Learning (CL), Immersive Learning (IL), Task-Based Collaborative Learning (TBCL), Content Integrated Learning (CIL), and Community-Based Reflective Learning (CBRL), to configure their social development. We interviewed 20 teachers (10 from online and 10 from physical classes) and 40 students (20 from online and 20 from physical classes) and evaluated their perceptions regarding AI usage in teaching and learning methods towards social development. The results of our study are convincing enough to suggest that both teachers and students perceive AI usage helpful in teaching models; however, variation in their perception is observed. Notably, the divergence in the perception of teachers and students with regard to AI’s role is a key observation of this study. For instance, the teachers perceived AI as a highly effective tool in fostering community building during online sessions; in contrast, the students viewed its role as being moderately effective. Likewise, the teachers perceived AI’s role as a critical tool in traditional classrooms rather than in virtual ones, whereas the students associated AI with online learning—in terms of digital tools, learning opportunities, and critical discussion—by rating its impact on social confidence and verbal–nonverbal communications significantly more strongly in physical settings. On the contrary, the teachers emphasized AI’s relevance to their self-confidence, emotional intelligence, and community engagement in online teaching platforms; yet, the ratings dropped to moderate in physical contexts. The students’ perceptions in this regard matched those of the teachers, as they also emphasized the importance of social confidence and overall well-being in physical classrooms, where the teachers’ assessment was comparatively low. These patterns provide analytical insights that are decisively valuable for designing AI-integrated pedagogical models that support social development within the educational environments. Full article
(This article belongs to the Special Issue Artificial Intelligence and Educational Psychology)
Show Figures

Figure 1

21 pages, 1254 KB  
Article
AI-Enhanced PBL and Experiential Learning for Communication and Career Readiness: An Engineering Pilot Course
by Estefanía Avilés Mariño and Antonio Sarasa Cabezuelo
Algorithms 2025, 18(10), 634; https://doi.org/10.3390/a18100634 - 9 Oct 2025
Cited by 1 | Viewed by 1220
Abstract
This study investigates the utilisation of AI tools, including Grammarly Free, QuillBot Free, Canva Free Individual, and others, to enhance learning outcomes for 180 s-year telecommunications engineering students at Universidad Politécnica de Madrid. This research incorporates teaching methods like problem-based learning, experiential learning, [...] Read more.
This study investigates the utilisation of AI tools, including Grammarly Free, QuillBot Free, Canva Free Individual, and others, to enhance learning outcomes for 180 s-year telecommunications engineering students at Universidad Politécnica de Madrid. This research incorporates teaching methods like problem-based learning, experiential learning, task-based learning, and content–language integrated learning, with English as the medium of instruction. These tools were strategically used to enhance language skills, foster computational thinking, and promote critical problem-solving. A control group comprising 120 students who did not receive AI support was included in the study for comparative analysis. The control group’s role was essential in evaluating the impact of AI tools on learning outcomes by providing a baseline for comparison. The results indicated that the pilot group, utilising AI tools, demonstrated superior performance compared to the control group in listening comprehension (98.79% vs. 90.22%) and conceptual understanding (95.82% vs. 84.23%). These findings underscore the significance of these skills in enhancing communication and problem-solving abilities within the field of engineering. The assessment of the pilot course’s forum revealed a progression from initially error-prone and brief responses to refined, evidence-based reflections in participants. This evolution in responses significantly contributed to the high success rate of 87% in conducting complex contextual analyses by pilot course participants. Subsequent to these results, a project for educational innovation aims to implement the AI-PBL-CLIL model at Universidad Politécnica de Madrid from 2025 to 2026. Future research should look into adaptive AI systems for personalised learning and study the long-term effects of AI integration in higher education. Furthermore, collaborating with industry partners can significantly enhance the practical application of AI-based methods in engineering education. These strategies facilitate benchmarking against international standards, provide structured support for skill development, and ensure the sustained retention of professional competencies, ultimately elevating the international recognition of Spain’s engineering education. Full article
(This article belongs to the Special Issue Artificial Intelligence Algorithms and Generative AI in Education)
Show Figures

Figure 1

20 pages, 3847 KB  
Article
Augmented Reality’s Impact on English Vocabulary and Content Acquisition in the CLIL Classroom
by Mar Fernandez-Alcocer and Jose Belda-Medina
Appl. Sci. 2025, 15(19), 10380; https://doi.org/10.3390/app151910380 - 24 Sep 2025
Viewed by 1336
Abstract
This study interrogates whether Augmented Reality (AR) enhances vocabulary and content acquisition within Content and Language Integrated Learning (CLIL), situating the question in the broader debate on how immersive, multimodal technologies shape achievement and engagement. This study’s novelty lies in its direct AR-versus-print [...] Read more.
This study interrogates whether Augmented Reality (AR) enhances vocabulary and content acquisition within Content and Language Integrated Learning (CLIL), situating the question in the broader debate on how immersive, multimodal technologies shape achievement and engagement. This study’s novelty lies in its direct AR-versus-print comparison in a real CLIL classroom using markerless, smartphone-based technology. Using a mixed-methods, classroom-based experiment, we drew on a convenience sample of 129 secondary students (ages 16–18), assigning them to an AR intervention (n = 64) or a print-based control (n = 65). Both cohorts received parallel instruction covering identical objectives and materials; vocabulary attainment was gauged using matched pretest and post-test measures, while engagement, attitudes, and perceived usefulness were captured through paired pre- and post-surveys and open-ended prompts. Quantitative analyses compared change scores across conditions and were complemented by qualitative summaries of learner comments. Results indicate that exposure to AR exerted a positive influence on learners’ engagement and supported learning processes, with perceptible shifts in students’ views of AR between baseline and post-intervention; nevertheless, effects were heterogeneous across instruments, items, and subgroups, suggesting that benefits accrued in a targeted rather than uniform fashion. Compared to the print-based group, students using AR demonstrated greater gains on visually supported vocabulary and content items, while other items showed no significant differences between groups. We conclude that AR constitutes a promising pedagogical resource for CLIL, capable of scaffolding vocabulary/content development and motivating participation, while the observed variability underscores the need for principled, context-sensitive integration. Future work should specify boundary conditions—such as task type, prior proficiency, cognitive load, and technology familiarity—and employ robust mixed-methods designs to determine for whom, and under which instructional circumstances, AR yields the greatest and most sustainable gains. Full article
Show Figures

Figure 1

19 pages, 2706 KB  
Article
CLIL in English-Medium Nursing Education: Teacher Collaboration via Translanguaging–Trans-Semiotising Pedagogy for Enabling Internally Persuasive Discourse and Professional Competencies
by Yiqi Liu and Angel M. Y. Lin
Educ. Sci. 2025, 15(8), 983; https://doi.org/10.3390/educsci15080983 - 1 Aug 2025
Viewed by 1933
Abstract
Academic English support is crucial for English as an Additional Language (EAL) nursing students in English-medium nursing education programmes. However, empirical research on content and language integrated learning (CLIL) within this specific context remains limited. This study, informed by recent advancements in translanguaging [...] Read more.
Academic English support is crucial for English as an Additional Language (EAL) nursing students in English-medium nursing education programmes. However, empirical research on content and language integrated learning (CLIL) within this specific context remains limited. This study, informed by recent advancements in translanguaging and trans-semiotising (TL-TS) theory, investigates the patterns of teacher collaboration in nursing CLIL and its impact when employing a TL-TS pedagogical approach. Analysis of students’ pre- and post-tests and multimodal classroom interactions reveals that effective collaboration between nursing specialists and language experts in CLIL can be fostered by (1) aligning with language education principles through the incorporation of internally persuasive discourse (IPD) about language learning and TL-TS practices; (2) simulating potential professional contingencies and co-developing coping strategies using TL-TS; and (3) elucidating nursing language norms through TL-TS and IPD. We advocate for re-imagination of CLIL in English-medium nursing education through an organistic–procedural TL perspective and highlight its potential to enhance EAL nursing students’ development of language proficiency and professional competencies. Full article
(This article belongs to the Special Issue Bilingual Education in a Challenging World: From Policy to Practice)
Show Figures

Figure 1

17 pages, 271 KB  
Article
Pre-Service CLIL Teachers’ Conceptions on Bilingual Education: Impact of Initial Training on the Development of Their Teaching Skills
by Francisco Zayas-Martínez, José Luis Estrada-Chichón and Natalia Segura-Caballero
Educ. Sci. 2024, 14(12), 1331; https://doi.org/10.3390/educsci14121331 - 4 Dec 2024
Cited by 3 | Viewed by 2537
Abstract
Content and Language Integrated Learning (CLIL) has been adopted by schools to equip students with the competencies and language skills needed in today’s multilingual and multicultural society. However, teaching content courses through a foreign language requires specific teacher training, both initial and ongoing. [...] Read more.
Content and Language Integrated Learning (CLIL) has been adopted by schools to equip students with the competencies and language skills needed in today’s multilingual and multicultural society. However, teaching content courses through a foreign language requires specific teacher training, both initial and ongoing. This qualitative descriptive study analyses the development of bilingual teaching knowledge in terms of teaching skills among pre-service CLIL teachers (n = 15) at the University of Cádiz in Spain. Two reflective reports written by each pre-service teacher before and after participating in the course CLIL I: Foundations and Curricular Proposals for the Primary School Classroom (2022/23) were analyzed. The responses were categorized using Qualitative Content Analysis. The reflective reports included questions about their conception of bilingual teaching; methods for teaching bilingual courses; and justifications for their teaching methods. In addition, a focus group was conducted with a representative sample of participants. The results reveal a significant development in pre-service teachers’ knowledge of the teaching skills required for bilingual teaching. Particularly, there is an increase in contributions related to justifying their teaching methods. Moreover, the findings highlight pre-service teachers’ recognition of the differences between foreign language and CLIL teachers, as well as their ability to plan CLIL teaching effectively. Full article
(This article belongs to the Section Higher Education)
16 pages, 1171 KB  
Article
A Longitudinal Exploration of Perception and Production of English Codas in CLIL Settings
by Francisco Gallardo-del-Puerto and Esther Gómez-Lacabex
Languages 2024, 9(9), 303; https://doi.org/10.3390/languages9090303 - 19 Sep 2024
Viewed by 1923
Abstract
Second language speech perception and production remain an enduring concern in second language acquisition, as research evidence seems to suggest that there is not a straightforward correspondence between these two speech domains and that their interrelationship seems to be of a complex nature. [...] Read more.
Second language speech perception and production remain an enduring concern in second language acquisition, as research evidence seems to suggest that there is not a straightforward correspondence between these two speech domains and that their interrelationship seems to be of a complex nature. The present proposal intends to contribute to the inspection of such a relationship by observing the development of perception and production skills of English codas longitudinally in a group of secondary school learners in Spain involved in a content and language integrated learning (CLIL) program, which increases exposure and production opportunities. Results point to a slight overall improvement of both sound perception and production skills during a two-year period, the coda sounds exhibiting variable realizations. Many coda sounds were found to be identified and produced at near/ceiling levels while other codas remained at less successful identification and production levels even after two years of CLIL exposure. The correlation analyses performed indicated that the two dimensions tended to correlate when the development for each coda sound was inspected. No correlations were found when students’ individual overall performance in each dimension were examined, attesting individual differences. Full article
(This article belongs to the Special Issue Advances in L2 Perception and Production)
Show Figures

Figure 1

7 pages, 2529 KB  
Proceeding Paper
Willingness, Proficiency, or Supports? Challenges in Implementing Content and Language Integrated Learning for Taiwan K-12 Teachers
by Shing-Yun Jung, Shih-Wen Su, Xiaojing Yu, Shyan-Ming Yuan and Chuen-Tsai Sun
Eng. Proc. 2023, 55(1), 10; https://doi.org/10.3390/engproc2023055010 - 28 Nov 2023
Cited by 1 | Viewed by 1827
Abstract
After the Taiwanese government launched the Blueprint for Developing Taiwan into a Bilingual Nation by 2030, the Implementation Project of Bilingual Instruction in several domains of primary and junior high school education was promoted by the Taiwan Ministry of Education. Content and language [...] Read more.
After the Taiwanese government launched the Blueprint for Developing Taiwan into a Bilingual Nation by 2030, the Implementation Project of Bilingual Instruction in several domains of primary and junior high school education was promoted by the Taiwan Ministry of Education. Content and language integrated learning (CLIL) is a dual-objective strategy in which students simultaneously acquire language skills and subject knowledge. CLIL has been widely implemented and proven to be successful in European countries. This strategy will become the primary method of bilingual education for instructors in grades K-12. Other non-European countries, such as Latin America and Indonesia, however, found difficulties applying CLIL in class. The issues need to be identified to encourage researchers and practitioners to find solutions. The purpose of this paper is to identify the barriers to implementing CLIL from the perspective of K-12 teachers. We surveyed 102 K-12 teachers in Keelung using a questionnaire. The findings indicate that (1) 49.0% of teachers feel concerned if they are required to teach half of their content in English, (2) 64.8% of teachers are willing to improve their English proficiency in their spare time for implementing CLIL in class, and (3) only 36.3% of teachers are willing to adopt CLIL in class, while 50.0% of teachers are willing to implement CLIL if a teaching assistant system supports them with English course materials. Teaching assistant systems that provide English course materials might influence teachers’ willingness to implement CLIL in class. Full article
Show Figures

Figure 1

15 pages, 1676 KB  
Article
Professional Development of Pre-Service Language Teachers in Content and Language Integrated Learning: A Training Programme Integrating Video Technology
by Cristina Díaz-Martín
Languages 2023, 8(4), 232; https://doi.org/10.3390/languages8040232 - 11 Oct 2023
Cited by 3 | Viewed by 3357
Abstract
Over the years, the integration of technology in bilingual education has become increasingly significant. In the European context, particularly in Content and Language Integrated Learning (CLIL), supporting the professional development of future educators has emerged as a crucial aspect. Video-based technology plays a [...] Read more.
Over the years, the integration of technology in bilingual education has become increasingly significant. In the European context, particularly in Content and Language Integrated Learning (CLIL), supporting the professional development of future educators has emerged as a crucial aspect. Video-based technology plays a key role in the training of pre-service language teachers, where it serves as a valuable tool for teacher education. There is a growing demand to enhance language teachers’ professional development programs, especially within the realm of CLIL teacher education. This study presents a video-based technology training programme intended to enhance the professional development of pre-service language teachers in CLIL. After implementation of the video-based training programme, semi-structured interviews with pre-service language teachers were conducted to evaluate the impact of the programme. The results show a positive influence on the pre-service language teachers’ professional development. The utilization of video-based technology was found to significantly improve their comprehension of CLIL while fostering their awareness of their teaching practice. For the research community, these encouraging results should act as a driving force to continue exploring video technology within teacher education programs in CLIL to enhance educators’ professional development. Full article
Show Figures

Figure A1

30 pages, 5741 KB  
Article
Critical Immersive-Triggered Literacy as a Key Component for Inclusive Digital Education
by Chrysoula Lazou and Avgoustos Tsinakos
Educ. Sci. 2023, 13(7), 696; https://doi.org/10.3390/educsci13070696 - 9 Jul 2023
Cited by 25 | Viewed by 5663
Abstract
The present empirical study investigates, analyzes, and discusses the affordances and limitations of an augmented reality (AR)-based educational intervention for the critical digital awareness of secondary school students through a sociocultural framework of instruction. The design of the educational intervention focuses on the [...] Read more.
The present empirical study investigates, analyzes, and discusses the affordances and limitations of an augmented reality (AR)-based educational intervention for the critical digital awareness of secondary school students through a sociocultural framework of instruction. The design of the educational intervention focuses on the empowerment of students’ critical digital skills in the new media produsage ecosystem in parallel with the development of target language skills through content and language integrated learning (CLIL) in a mobile augmented reality (MAR)-based transnational educational setting. This study focuses on examining the usefulness rather than the digital use of MAR from a socio-constructivism perspective with 77 participants from diverse socio-cultural backgrounds and educational settings. More specifically, an investigation of the potential of internalization of new knowledge through immersive-triggered inclusive educational practices is carried out, examining the effectiveness of the universal design for learning principles (UDL) as a pedagogical framework for AR-based instruction related to long-term memory retention, the synthesis of meaningful learning instances, and the creation of new knowledge. The study findings suggest that AR-based instruction, if incorporated into a robust pedagogical framework, can enhance attention and long-term memory retention, provide meaningful, inclusive learning opportunities, and facilitate digital well-being in the ever-evolving complex learning ecosystem. This study concludes by proposing the term of critical immersive-triggered literacy (CIT Literacy), defined as a skill development framework that triggers learners’ attention and facilitates digital well-being for meaningful learning instances via immersive technologies. Full article
(This article belongs to the Special Issue Virtual and Augmented Reality in Education)
Show Figures

Figure 1

16 pages, 1539 KB  
Article
Bilingual Science Lexicon of Pre-Serviced Primary School Teachers
by Magdalena López-Pérez, Juan Luis de la Montaña Conchiña, José Luis Bravo Galán and Guadalupe de la Maya Retamar
Educ. Sci. 2023, 13(5), 464; https://doi.org/10.3390/educsci13050464 - 30 Apr 2023
Cited by 2 | Viewed by 2343
Abstract
Bilingual teaching has experienced rapid growth in the Spanish educational panorama and numerous university programmes have emerged with the aim of training future CLIL (Content and Language Integrated Learning) teachers. However, there is little research assessing the level of linguistic competence in Spanish [...] Read more.
Bilingual teaching has experienced rapid growth in the Spanish educational panorama and numerous university programmes have emerged with the aim of training future CLIL (Content and Language Integrated Learning) teachers. However, there is little research assessing the level of linguistic competence in Spanish and foreign languages of future teachers, especially those who are studying for a bilingual degree. Although this work is part of a broader project that analyses bilingual lexical competence in subjects related to the Social Sciences and Experimental Sciences, we focus on the analysis of lexical availability of content related to the teaching of science. The sample consisted of 46 students of the Degree in Primary Education at the University of Extremadura. Using a lexical availability test, lexical production in Spanish and English is analysed and compared to determine whether the fact of studying in English affects the acquisition and consolidation of lexical knowledge in Spanish. The results show that there are no significant differences in lexical production between Spanish and English. In addition to the quantitative data, results from the qualitative analysis are presented, analysing the most available words and the organisation of the lexicon in both languages. Full article
(This article belongs to the Special Issue English Language Teaching in a Multilingual World)
Show Figures

Figure 1

21 pages, 2030 KB  
Article
The Clash between CLIL and TELL: Effects and Potential Solutions of Adapting TELL for Online CLIL Teaching
by Rongxin Zhu and Simon S. Y. Chan
Appl. Sci. 2023, 13(7), 4270; https://doi.org/10.3390/app13074270 - 28 Mar 2023
Cited by 6 | Viewed by 5175
Abstract
The relationship between technology and society is an ever-changing dynamic, but one in which education is a key domain. In educational practice, the use of computer technology has increasingly become an inseparable part of teaching students in numerous ways across the world. The [...] Read more.
The relationship between technology and society is an ever-changing dynamic, but one in which education is a key domain. In educational practice, the use of computer technology has increasingly become an inseparable part of teaching students in numerous ways across the world. The COVID-19 global pandemic accelerated this dramatically, with online teaching environments becoming the sole way for students to access education for extended periods of time. This shift to online teaching also required that teachers learn new skills and deal with new challenges. Based on mixed-methods research conducted with 20 teachers from an established content and language integrated learning school in mainland China, this research paper investigates the different challenges and problems that were faced by content and language integrated learning teachers in their experiences of online teaching and, in tandem with wider content and language integrated learning and technology-enhanced language learning literature, develops some potential solutions for future use. Full article
(This article belongs to the Special Issue Technologies and Environments of Intelligent Education)
Show Figures

Figure 1

29 pages, 1505 KB  
Systematic Review
Teaching and Learning of Mathematics through CLIL, CBI, or EMI—A Systematic Literature Review
by Raúl Ruiz-Cecilia, Leopoldo Medina-Sánchez and Antonio-Manuel Rodríguez-García
Mathematics 2023, 11(6), 1347; https://doi.org/10.3390/math11061347 - 10 Mar 2023
Cited by 15 | Viewed by 11770
Abstract
This study provides a systematic literature review of research in the field of teaching and learning mathematics through Content and Language Integrated Learning (CLIL), Content-Based Instruction (CBI), and English Medium Instruction (EMI). The review aims to examine the most relevant literature with a [...] Read more.
This study provides a systematic literature review of research in the field of teaching and learning mathematics through Content and Language Integrated Learning (CLIL), Content-Based Instruction (CBI), and English Medium Instruction (EMI). The review aims to examine the most relevant literature with a focus on mathematics and CLIL, CBI, or EMI in Scopus and Web of Science per the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews (PRISMA) guidelines. Based on 151 sources, 52 papers were selected according to predefined selection criteria. The papers were analysed and coded according to the following categories: (1) geographical productivity, (2) diachronic productivity growth, (3) main objectives, (4) methodology, and research design, (5) variables and measurement instruments, (6) context and sample details, and (7) main findings. The results reveal that most of the research analysed has been carried out in the Asian continent, followed by Europe. The analysis of diachronic productivity shows that the study of the application of CLIL, CBI, and EMI programs in the teaching-learning process of mathematics has notably increased in recent years, especially in the last triennium (2020–2022). Regarding the objectives of the selected corpus, the majority aimed at teaching practices and learning processes, and outcomes in mathematics and language proficiency in CLIL, CBI, and/or EMI classrooms. The corpus analysed fits within one or more of the following categories: empirical, qualitative, descriptive, correlational, and cross-sectional. The samples utilized in different studies differ significantly, both in terms of quantity –ranging from one person to 700– and in the educational level being studied, which would be primary, secondary, or tertiary education. The main variables studied in the corpus focus on mathematical competence, language proficiency, teaching practices, teacher training, science competence, and teachers’ perceptions. The most widely used instruments have been objective tests, such as questionnaires, together with standardized tests to measure some aspects related to mathematical competence and language proficiency. They are followed by an analysis of documents (academic records, teaching materials, official documents...), participant or non-participant observation, interviews, and video and audio recordings. In summary, in the scientific literature analysed, a positive or neutral view predominates on the effects of the CLIL, CBI, and EMI approaches on the learning of mathematics and the L2. This can be due to methodological issues fundamentally related to the methodology, research design, sample, and measurement instruments. Thus, we must highlight that some of the results from the selected papers must be interpreted with caution. Taking this factor into consideration, further comparative studies on a wider scale are required to examine thoroughly the effects of CLIL, CBI, and EMI on the teaching and learning of mathematics in an L2. Besides, it is important to study in greater depth the different levels of language acquisition since the research analysed shows that these have not been sufficiently addressed in the mathematical field of knowledge. Full article
Show Figures

Figure 1

20 pages, 448 KB  
Review
Sustaining Content and Language Integrated Learning in China: A Systematic Review
by Hengzhi Hu, Nur Ehsan Mohd Said and Harwati Hashim
Sustainability 2023, 15(5), 3894; https://doi.org/10.3390/su15053894 - 21 Feb 2023
Cited by 27 | Viewed by 6872
Abstract
The past decades have witnessed the rise and boom of Content and Language Integrated Learning (CLIL). As this dual-focused pedagogical approach continues to grow with remarkable vitality and sustainability, however, there is a paucity of knowledge regarding its development and application in China, [...] Read more.
The past decades have witnessed the rise and boom of Content and Language Integrated Learning (CLIL). As this dual-focused pedagogical approach continues to grow with remarkable vitality and sustainability, however, there is a paucity of knowledge regarding its development and application in China, necessitating a systematic review of previous research to apprise the academia of what has been done in the education and research agenda of CLIL. Grounded in four databases (i.e., Web of Science, Scopus, Education Resources Information Center, and Google Scholar), 28 research articles were extracted from 2013 to 2022 with certain exclusion and inclusion criteria considered. Thematic analyses primarily demonstrated that: (1) most studies were conducted in higher education providers, with English being the predominant instructional language; (2) diverse subject matters were embraced, denoting the coordination of “self” and “other” intercultural identities; (3) affective evidence concerning perceptions of CLIL and performance evidence regarding language learning outcomes tended to be the research nuclei, de-emphasizing the other research topics (e.g., assessment, translanguaging, heterogeneity in learning, learning materials, learning process); (4) the research findings were various, with most of them corroborating the benefits of CLIL to different aspects of learning; (5) CLIL learners were the principal source of data, and diverse research paradigms were displayed with appropriate designs as per the research objectives. These findings, by comparison with the knowledge and experience obtained from the Western world, imply that the scope of the CLIL agenda should be extended and deepened in China, encouraging educators and researchers to consider and probe a wider range of issues of interest. Full article
Show Figures

Figure 1

Back to TopTop