4.1. Analysis of the Spontaneous Emission
Spectral properties of CdSe/ZnS QDs-doped POFs were calculated and analyzed through our theoretical theory and formulas considering the influence of some important factors. When the pump power was below the threshold of ASE, the output spectra were mainly produced by SE, and the obvious spectral red shift and width decrease caused by the re-absorption effect appeared.
Figure 3 shows the comparison of SE spectra between calculation and experiment under different fiber lengths (1–15 cm) with a QDs doping concentration of 3 ppm, fiber diameter of 100 μm, and pump power of 50 mW. The calculation results were highly consistent with the experiments. The output SE intensity first increased with the length of the doped fiber and reached the maximum at 4 cm. The short-wavelength and long-wavelength parts of the spectra were approximately symmetric, and the peak wavelength shifted slightly from 581.9 nm to 584.6 nm. It indicates that the pump power was sufficient, and the re-absorption effect was not significant. As the fiber continued to increase, the output power appeared to decrease, and the symmetry of the spectra was broken. The intensity of the short-wavelength part was significantly reduced, indicating that the pump power appeared to be insufficient, and the percentage of output light caused by re-absorption effect increased significantly. The peak wavelength increased from 584.6 nm to 594.3 nm with the increase of the fiber length from 5 to 15 cm.
To further verify the correctness of our theoretical model mentioned above, CdSe/ZnS-doped fibers with concentrations of 2 ppm, 3 ppm, 4 ppm, and 5 ppm were prepared, and the peak wavelengths were measured and compared with the calculated results (shown in
Figure 4). The peak wavelength variations of the output SE spectra of the four kinds of CdSe/ZnS QDs-doped fibers within the length of 1–17 cm were 582.3–592.8 nm, 583.1–600.3 nm, 583.9–606.5 nm, and 585.1–610.4 nm, with red shifts of 10.5, 17.2, 22.6, and 25.3 nm, respectively. The absolute value of red shift becomes larger as the doping concentration increases, which may be due to the fact that in the case of fixed pump power, the larger the doping concentration, the more the pump power could be absorbed, and the larger the generated SE spectrum intensity. Therefore, the re-absorption effect will be more pronounced, and the percentage of output light caused by re-absorption effect will increase, making the red shift more obvious. The values of the calculated peak wavelength red shift at the four doping concentrations were in general agreement with the experimental results, indicating the accuracy and feasibility of our theoretical model.
We can also see from
Figure 4 that the peak wavelength red shifts of the four doping concentrations show an approximate linear growth in the initial fiber length. The lengths in which the slope of the red shift with fiber length remain essentially unchanged for the four doping concentrations were 17, 10, 7, and 5 cm. The larger the doped concentration, the shorter the length of the linear variation in peak wavelength. As the length continues to increase, the slope will become smaller, and the peak wavelength red shift curve will become flatter. In order to exclude the effect of PL stability on red shift, the peak wavelength and output PL intensity of 15-cm-long QDs-doped POFs with concentration of 2 ppm as a function of time were measured and shown in
Figure 5. As we can see, the peak wavelength was almost equal after 60 min, and the SE intensity decreased slightly, indicating the stability of our QDs-doped POFs.
According to our analysis, there are two possible reasons: (1) it is related to the pump power; (2) it is related to the overlap of absorption and emission cross-section.
Firstly, under the same pump power, the number of QDs that can be excited was fixed, and the length of the fiber with linear increase of peak wavelength multiplied by the doping concentration was almost a constant value for the four concentrations. The higher doping concentration of QDs will result in a higher rate of pump light consumption and stronger output SE intensity in a shorter fiber length, so the re-absorption effect will be more pronounced and the red shift of peak wavelength will be larger. When doped QDs exceeds the maximum number that can be excited, the pump light will be rapidly consumed, and the pump power became very low at the back of the fiber, leading to an increase in the percentage of SE with longer wavelength generated by the re-absorption effect in the whole output spectrum. However, since the absolute intensity of SE light was much lower than that of pump, the slope of the spectral red shift due to the re-absorption effect did not increase with the fiber length but decreased gradually. To verify our assumptions, we introduced the concept of average wavelength [
24], which was defined as:
λ was the wavelength,
P(λ)was the intensity of the light at the wavelength of
λ. The discretization of
λ was carried out by dividing the full wavelength spectrum into several small areas, each one with its own step size d
λ. If the re-absorption effect existed, then the SE light in the short wavelength band between
λ1 to
λ1 + d
λ might be re-absorbed and generated a new light with relative longer wavelength at
λ2 to
λ2 + d
λ, which would lead to the symmetry of the whole spectrum being broken and the average wavelength will be larger than the peak wavelength. The curves of peak wavelength and average wavelength of two kinds of fiber with doping concentrations of 2 ppm and 5 ppm as a function of doped fiber length are shown in
Figure 6.
In the QDs-doped POF with 2 ppm concentration, the peak wavelength and average wavelength were basically consistent in the initial length of 7 cm, and the wavelength increased from 581.9 nm to 587.5 nm, with a red shift of 5.6 nm. Starting from about 7.5 cm, the peak wavelength and the average wavelength were obviously separated, and the average wavelength became larger, indicating that the proportion of the re-absorption effect in the output SE spectrum increased significantly. In the QDs-doped POF with 5 ppm concentration, the peak wavelength and the average wavelength reached to 591.4 nm at 2 cm with a red shift of 9.5 nm, and then appeared to be clearly separated when the fiber length exceeded 3 cm. The peak and average wavelengths reached 610.4 and 615.1 nm at the end of the 17 cm fiber, respectively. The red shift was much more than that when the doping concentration was 2 ppm, indicating that the higher the doping concentration, the greater the re-absorption effect. However, it is worth noting that the difference remained roughly the same after 8 cm when the doping concentration was 5 ppm, showing that the re-absorption effect was mainly in the initial length of 8 cm. This may be related to the reduced intensity of the output light after 8 cm.
In order to verify our hypothesis, we measured and calculated the output SE light under different fiber lengths and found a good match between them, as shown in
Figure 7. To increase the comparability, we normalized the output SE intensities of the four kinds of QDs-doped POFs with concentrations of 2 ppm, 3 ppm, 4 pm, and 5 ppm. The doped fiber lengths corresponding to the maximum output SE intensity were about 7.8, 6.1, 4.7, and 2.9 cm, respectively. Overall, 7.8 and 2.9 cm were roughly equivalent to the lengths (7.5 and 2 cm) that peak wavelength and average wavelength appear to be clearly separated for the fibers with concentrations of 2 ppm and 5 ppm, as shown in
Figure 6. The output SE intensity reached the maximum, indicating that the pump light was basically absorbed, and the output spectrum will be mainly generated by the re-absorption effect as the fiber length continues to increase. The higher the doping concentration, the more obvious the re-absorption effect, the greater the absolute value of red shift, and the faster the output SE intensity decreases. This can also be demonstrated from the variation of the full width at half maximum (FWHM) of the four kinds of doped fiber with different concentrations in
Figure 8. It can be seen that the larger the concentration, the faster the FWHM decreased, indicating that the re-absorption effect was also more obvious. This result was in general agreement with the analysis in
Figure 6 and
Figure 7. The decrease rates of the FWHM became smaller in the rear part of the fibers, mainly because the absolute SE intensity became small as the fiber lengths increased. Therefore, although the proportion of re-absorption effect in the output spectrum increased, the absolute amount of red shift was still small.
The slope of the red shift curve shown in
Figure 4 decreases with the increase of fiber length, which may also be related to the absorption and emission cross-sections of QDS. It can be seen from
Figure 9 that there were obvious overlaps between the absorption and emission cross-sections of CdSe/ZnS QDs. Since the absorption cross-sections are almost unchanged, the larger the peak wavelength of the output SE spectrum, the less overlap between the emission and absorption cross-section. In other words, the output SE spectrum that can be re-absorbed will become smaller and smaller with the increase of the peak wavelength. To verify our speculation, we introduced the concept of overlap coefficient, which was defined as:
σ
e and σ
overlap were the emission cross-section and the emission cross-section that can be reabsorbed, respectively. We calculated the overlap coefficients of ten kinds of SE spectra with the peak wavelength from 581.9 to 626.9 nm and intervals of 5 nm, under the assumption that the SE spectra shapes were consistent. The overlapping coefficients were 0.34, 0.27, 0.21, 0.16, 0.12, 0.17, 0.078, 0.064, 0.05, and 0.05, respectively, which gradually decrease with the increase of peak wavelength. The average wavelength red shift of the output spectra at the end of the 17-cm-long fibers with the overlap coefficient for four doping concentrations of 2 ppm, 3 ppm, 4 ppm, and 5 ppm is shown in
Figure 9. Under the same doping concentration, the larger the overlap coefficient, the larger the red shift. The maximum red shift under 2 ppm and 5 ppm doping concentration were 8.6 and 29.6 nm. It should be noted that as the SE wavelength becomes larger, the overlap coefficient decreases, so the maximum red shift in the experiment should be somewhat smaller than the value shown in
Figure 10. The calculated red shift was smaller than that of 12.0 and 33.1 nm obtained in the experiment shown in
Figure 6 because the effect of output SE intensity was not considered. The final red shift of the output spectra was the result of the combined effect of SE intensity and overlap coefficient.
4.2. Analysis of the Amplified Spontaneous Emission
If the pump power is high enough, ASE phenomenon will be produced. The output light intensity at the end of the 17-cm-long fibers with concentrations of 1 ppm, 1.5 ppm, and 2 ppm were calculated and shown in
Figure 11a–c. As we can see, with the increasing of the pump, the slope of the output light increased obviously and appeared a pump threshold (PT). The PTs of the three kinds of doped fiber were about 73, 102, and 127 mW, increasing with the rise of doping concentration. The FWHM and average wavelength
λav of the output spectra generated under different pump power were calculated and shown in
Figure 11d,e. Special attention was paid to clarify the re-absorption effect, especially during the conversion of SE to ASE.
When the pump power was low, the output light was generated by SE. With the increase of pump, the proportion of SE that could be re-absorbed in the transmitted light decreased gradually, and the re-absorption effect weakened, leading to a decrease of
λav and a slow growth of the FWHM. The FWHM of the three kinds of doped fiber with concentrations of 1 ppm, 1.5 ppm, and 2 ppm increased from 26.62, 25.27, and 24.25 nm to their respective maximum values of 27.36 nm, 26.38 nm, and 25.21 nm. The pump powers corresponding to the three maximum FWHM were 43.2, 52.7, and 61.6 mW, and were labeled with vertical lines in
Figure 11a–c. All of them were in the places where the output light intensity would increase significantly later. As we continued to increase the pump power, the output light was in a state of transition from SE to ASE, the slope of
λav became significantly larger, leading to the FWHM of the output spectra narrowing significantly, and a blue shift of the
λav toward the SE peak wavelength, where the position of the maximum emission cross-section was observed. When the pump power was larger than PTs, the number of modes decreases due to energy transfer from lower power modes to those situated near the emission peak and the ASE generates, the output intensity increases sharply and and the
λav will blue shift slightly toward the SE peak wavelength, indicating that re-absorption effect was significantly suppressed. However, the slope of FWHM was still high, and it will continue to decrease as ASE intensity increases.
The FWHM and
λav were greatly affected by the doping concentration. Under the same pump power, the larger the doping concentration, the narrower the FWHM and relatively larger
λav will be. The output ASE intensity and FWHM of many different fibers with concentrations from 0.5 ppm to 5 ppm under the pump power of 150 mW were calculated and shown in
Figure 12. The output light grows rapidly with the increase of doping concentration, the ASE intensity of the 5 ppm POF was about 150 times larger than that of the 0.5 ppm POF. Correspondingly, the FWHM decreased from 20.58 nm to 7.85 nm.
The
λav of these POFs with concentrations from 0.5 ppm to 5 ppm under the pump power of 50 mW, 100 mW, 150 mW, and 200 mW are shown in
Figure 13. The output
λav was much larger when the pump power was 50 mW, which might be attributed to the fact that the pump power was not large enough to reach the ASE PTs, so the output light was mainly generated by the SE. When the pump power up to 100 mW, 150 mW, and 200 mW, the main output light was generated by ASE, and the
λav increased almost linearly, which means that although the re-absorption effect will decrease, it will still exist and affect the
λav slightly.
In order to further discuss the ASE PTs generation at different doping concentrations, we calculated the emission spectra of 20 cm-long QDs-doped fibers with concentrations of 0.1 ppm–5 ppm, as shown in
Figure 14. It can be seen that when the doping concentration is low enough (<0.3 ppm), ASE will not be generated. When the doping concentration is larger than 0.3 ppm, the output intensity of ASE and the ASE PT will increase with the growth of the doping concentration. The PTs increased rapidly at first, then flattened gradually, and the PT value stabilized at about 150–170 mW.
To further clarify the influence of fiber length and doping concentration on ASE PTs, the ASE PTs of fibers with 1–20 cm fiber lengths and 0.1 ppm–10 ppm concentrations were calculated and shown in
Figure 15. As we can see, PT will increase with the doping concentration and fiber length. Under the condition that with higher doping concentration and longer doped fiber length, the corresponding ASE PT will be larger, and the output power will also be higher. It is worth noting that the dark blue color in
Figure 15 means that ASE will not be generated under these conditions and there will be no PTs. Although the dark blue color in
Figure 15 exists either under the condition that short fiber lengths have high doping concentrations or that long fibers have low doping concentrations, the product of fiber lengths and doping concentrations was almost the same based on our analysis, and the product was about 5 ppm×cm, corresponding to a CdSe/ZnS QDs total number of 1.27 × 10
12. This means that if the total number of QDs in POFs is insufficient, ASE will not be generated, and all the output light is produced by SE.