Lidar and Radar Signal Simulation: Stability Assessment of the Aerosol–Cloud Interaction Index
, Juan Antonio Bravo-Aranda 2,3,*,†, MarÃa José Granados-Muñoz 2,3, Elena Montilla-Rosero 1, Juan Andrés Casquero-Vera 2,3, Fernando Rejano 2,3, Sonia Castillo 2,3 and Lucas Alados-Arboledas 2,3Round 1
Reviewer 1 Report
Dear Authors,
I found the revised manuscript to be significantly improved and thus easier to follow than previously. The motivation is now well stated and the methodology is clearer. I have just a few minor comments given below.
Specific comments:
line 122 - "calculated in height" - This is not clear. Did You mean "for each height/altitude" or "with respect to height"?
line 134 - "This two effects causes" - Please change to "These two effect cause" or similar
line 201 - "Despite ACI index uncertainty depending on the number of simulations (h), it converges once h is large enough" - What "converges" here, ACI index or its uncertainty? Please reformulate this sentence.
line 274 - "they are much fewer in number concentration" - Please remove "concentration" or change the expression to "they have a lower number concentration"
line 329 "after" - Maybe "above" would be better here?
Author Response
We acknowledge to the reviewer the effort and time dedicated to the revision. The specific comments have been corrected in the final manuscript as detailed in the attached file.
Author Response File: 
Author Response.pdf
Reviewer 2 Report
The authors addressed all the previously raised issues
Author Response
We acknowledge to the reviewer the effort and time dedicated to the revision. No comments or suggestions addressed in this revision round.
