Periodic and Non-Periodic Brainwaves Emerging via Stochastic Syncronization of Closed Loops of Firing Neurons

Round 1

Reviewer 1 Report

The paper studies periodic and aperiodic power spectral components of electro- and magneto-encephalograms via Markov chain modelling.

The paper is well structured and could be published with minor remarks

Minor remarks:

The Norm symbol (ǁ ǁ ) is not appropriate to symbolize matrices and confuses the reader. Matrices are symbolized with capital letters in Bold. The authors must correct the symbols for the defined matrices in the text.

Page 1, Line  2: “correlated in” should be “correlated with”

Page 1, Line  12: The right parenthesis in the end of the line should be deleted

Page 2, Line  65: “analitycal” should be “analytic”

Author Response

Dear Reviewer 1,

Thanks a lot for reading the manuscript and acknowledging the interest of the approach.
All the corrections requested in your report have been  implemented in the revised version of the manuscript that we are ready to upload at the MDPI server.

A thorough check of English grammars and typos has been also carried on all through the manuscript.

Best regards,

Anna Carbone

Reviewer 2 Report

Comments for author File: Comments.docx

Author Response

Dear Reviewer 2,

Thank you very much for the report and for considering the proposed approach interesting.
We deeply appreciate the time spent to read our work.

A thorough check of English grammars and various typos has been also carried on  the manuscript.

Anna Carbone