We found some errors in the paper published in International Journal of Molecular Sciences [1]. The table 1 had some typographical errors, information regarding field intensity missing, and the nomenclature did not match the legend. The corrected version is given below.
Table 1.
Summary of electromagnetic treatments of some microorganisms.
| Organism Class | *EM | Intensity | Biological effect | Reference |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Archaea | ||||
| Methanosarcina barkeri | MW | 13.5–36.5 GHz | Increase in growth, cell count, size and methane production | [5] |
| Eubacteria | ||||
| E. coli | SMF | 0.05–1 mT | Stimulated transposition activity and reduced cell viability | [6] |
| OMF | 16, 60 Hz | Stimulation and suppression of enolase activity | [7] | |
| OMF | 0.05–1 mT | Reduced transposition activity and enhanced cell viability | [6] | |
| OMF | 100 mT | Exposure time dependent stimulation or inhibition of cell viability | [8] | |
| OMF | 30 μT | Cell density dependent changes in AVTD | [9] | |
| DC EF | NA | Increase in growth and removal of inhibitory compounds in medium | [10] | |
| OMF | 0.1–1 mT @ 50 Hz | Significant morphotype changes and alteration during cell division | [11] | |
| ACEF | 2.5–50 V/cm @ 0.05–100 kHz | Stimulation of membrane bound ATP synthesis, optimum at 100 Hz | [12] | |
| 6-polar ACEF | 0.35–2.1 kHz for test tubes 60 Hz for Petri dishes | Increase in growth in test tubes (147 ± 24%) and colonies (42–179%) | [13,14] | |
| Bacillus cereus | 6-polar ACEF | 1 kHz | Increase in growth (196 ± 29%) | [13,14] |
| B. mucilaginosus | SMF | ~0.39 T | Increase in growth | [15] |
| B. subtilis | OMF | 0.8, 2.5 mT, 0.8 and 1 kHz | Increase in growth and a loss of intercellular cohesion | [16] |
| Bacteria & Yeast | OMF | 0–0.3 Hz @ 5–90 mT | Elevated or even diminished growth rates for Bacillus subtilis, Candida albicans, Halobacterium, Salmonella typhimurium, and Staphylococci | [17] |
| Pseudomonas stutzeri | SMF | 0.6–1.3 mT | Increase in growth | [18] |
| Trichoderma reesei | SMF | 1.5 mV cm–1 | Increase in growth and cellulase activity and secretion | [19] |
| Streptomyces noursei | SMF | 1.5 mV cm–1 | Increased antibiotic production, O2 evolution and glucose uptake | [20] |
| Salmonella typhimurium | OMF | 15 mT@0.3Hz | Growth stimulation; Mutation reversion rate unaffected | [17] |
| Micrococcus denitrificans | SMF | 500–800 mT | Growth inhibition followed by stimulation after 6 h | [21] |
| Corynebacterium glutamicum | OMF | 4.9 mT, 50 Hz | Increase in ATP levels by about 30% | [22] |
| Natural Flora | SMF | 22 mT | Enhanced degradation of phenolic waste liquors | [23] |
| Natural Flora | PEF | 1.25 – 3.25 kVcm–1 | Enhanced biosorption of uranium | [24] |
| Bacteria & yeast | OMF | 15 mT@0.3 Hz | 30% increase in growth in gram –ve bacteria (Pseudomonas aeruginosa, Halobacterium halobium) than gram +ve (Bacillus subtilis, Staphylococcus epidermidis) and yeast (Candida albicans). | [17] |
| Rhodobacter sphaeroides | OMF/ SMF | 0.13–0.3 T | Increase in porphyrin synthesis; Enhanced expression of 5-aminolevulinic acid dehydratase | [25] |
| Cyanobacteria | ||||
| Spirulina platensis | SMF | 10 mT | Increase in growth (50%), O2 evolution and sugar and phycocyanin production | [26] |
| 250 mT | Increase in growth (22%), CNP and minerals uptake and chlorophyll content | [27] | ||
| MW | 7.1 mm @ 2.2mWcm–2 | Increased growth (50%) | [28] | |
| Anabaena doliolum | SMF | 300 mT | Increase in growth, pigments, carbohydrate and protein | [29] |
| Algae | ||||
| Chlorella vulgaris | SMF | 10–35 mT | Increase in growth (100%); Stimulated antioxidant defense | [30] |
| Chlorella sp. | SMF | 6–58 mT | Increase in growth (NA) | [31] |
| Dunaliella salina | SMF | 10–23 mT | Increase in growth (90%), and β-carotene content | [32] |
| Scenedesmus sp. | PEF | NA | Enhanced oil extraction | [33] |
| Yeast | ||||
| Saccharomyces cerevisiae | PMF | ~ 4.7 μT | Increased activity of alcohol dehydrogenase | [34] |
| OMF+SMF | 20 mT + 8 mT | Increase in ethanol and sugar utilization | [35] | |
| S. cerevisiae | OMF | 0.28–12 mT | Increase in growth | [36] |
| OMF | 0.2–12 mT @ 50 Hz | Increase in growth (25 +/− 5%) | [37] | |
| AC/DC EF | 100/10 mA | Increase in growth, organic acid production and cell budding | [38] | |
| MW | 42GHz@ < 3 mWcm–2 | Frequency dependent increase or decrease in growth | [39] | |
| 6-polar ACEF | 1 kHz | Increase in gas production (195 ± 20%) | [13,14] | |
| OMF | 0.5 μT, 100–200 Hz | 30% reduction in respiration | [40] | |
| SMF | 7.28 T | Better UV survival; Stimulation of respiration | [41] [42] | |
| S. fragilis | SMF | ~0.26 T | Increase in growth (27–36%) | [15] |
| Kluyveromyces marxianus | PEF | 0.25 kV | Increased ethanol production and cellobiose utilization | [43] |
| Physarum polycephalum | OMF | 45,60,75 Hz | Delayed mitosis by 0.5 to 2 h | [44] |
| OMF | 0.1 mT, 60 Hz | Lower ATP levels but no decreased respiration | [45,46] | |
| 0.2 mT and 60 and 75 Hz | Reduced respiration | |||
| Protozoa | ||||
| Trichomonas vaginalis | SMF | Field strength dependent growth stimulation/inhibition | [47] | |
| Ciliophora | ||||
| Paramecium tetraurelia | OMF | 1.8 mT, 72 Hz | Increase in cell division rates; Alterations in membrane fluidity | [48] |
| Tetrahymena pyriformis | OMF | 10 mT, 60 Hz | Delayed cell division and increased oxygen uptake | [49] |
*AC-EF: alternating current electric field; DC-EF: direct current electric field; MW: microwave; OMF: oscillating magnetic field; SMF: static magnetic field; PEF: pulsed electric field; PMF: pulsed magnetic field.
We apologize for any inconvenience caused to the readers.
References
- Hunt, RW; Zavalin, A; Bhatnagar, A; Chinnasamy, S; Das, KC. Electromagnetic Biostimulation of Living Cultures for Biotechnology, Biofuel and Bioenergy Applications. Int. J. Mol. Sci 2009, 10, 4515–4558. [Google Scholar]
© 2009 by the authors; licensee Molecular Diversity Preservation International, Basel, Switzerland. This article is an open-access article distributed under the terms and conditions of the Creative Commons Attribution license (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/).