Search Results (80)

Chyulu Hills, Kenya, serves as one of the region’s water towers by supplying groundwater to surrounding streams and springs in southern Kenya. In a semiarid region, this water is crucial to the survival of local people, farms, and wildlife. The Chyulu Hills is also very prone to fires, and large areas of the range burn each year during the dry season. Currently, there are no detailed fire records or burn scar maps to track the burn history. Mapping burn scars using remote sensing is a cost-effective approach to monitor fire activity over time. However, it is not clear whether spectral burn indices developed elsewhere can be directly applied here when Chyulu Hills contains mostly grassland and bushland vegetation. Additionally, burn scars are usually no longer detectable after an intervening rainy season. In this study, we calculated the Differenced Normalized Burn Ratio (dNBR) and two versions of the Relative Differenced Normalized Burn Ratio (RdNBR) using Landsat Operational Land Imager (OLI) and Sentinel-2 MultiSpectral Instrument (MSI) data to determine which index, threshold values, instrument, and Sentinel near-infrared (NIR) band work best to map burn scars in Chyulu Hills, Kenya. The results indicate that the Relative Differenced Normalized Burn Ratio from Landsat OLI had the highest accuracy for mapping burn scars while also minimizing false positives (commission error). While mapping burn scars, it became clear that adjusting the threshold value for an index resulted in tradeoffs between false positives and false negatives. While none were perfect, this is an important consideration going forward. Given the length of the Landsat archive, there is potential to expand this work to additional years. Full article

To evaluate the radiometric performance of top-of-atmosphere reflectance images, Deep Convective Clouds (DCCs) can be used as temporally, spatially and spectrally stable targets. The DCCs method has been developed more than 20 years ago and applied recently to Sentinel-2 and Sentinel-3 sensors. In this paper, among other developments, we built a new methodology upon those existing by using the bootstrap method and spectral band adjustment factors computed with the Hyper-Spectral Imager (HSI) from the Environmental Mapping and Analysis Program (EnMAP). This methodology is applied to the two Multi-Spectral Imager (MSI) instruments onboard Sentinel-2A and 2B, but also the two Operational Land Imager (OLI) instruments onboard Landsat 8 and 9, from visible wavelength at 442 nm to shortwave-infrared at 2200 nm, using images with a ground resolution spanning from 10 m to 60 m. The results demonstrate the good inter-calibration of MSI units A and B, which are within one percent of relative difference on average between January 2022 and June 2024 for all visible, near-infrared and shortwave-infrared bands, except for the band at 1375 nm for which saturation prevents the use of the method. Similarly, OLI and OLI-2 are found to have a relative difference on the same period lower than one percent for all 30 m resolution bands. Evaluation of the relative difference between the MSI sensors and the OLI sensors with the DCCs method gives values lower than three percent. Finally, these validation results are compared to those obtained with Pseudo-Invariant Calibration Sites (PICSs) over Libya-4: an agreement better than two percent is found between the DCCs and PICSs methods. Full article

Coastal areas support seagrass meadows, which offer crucial ecosystem services, including erosion control and carbon sequestration. However, these areas are increasingly impacted by human activities, leading to habitat fragmentation and seagrass decline. In situ surveys, traditionally performed to monitor these ecosystems, face limitations on temporal and spatial coverage, particularly in intertidal zones, prompting the addition of satellite data within monitoring programs. Yet, satellite remote sensing can be limited by too coarse spatial and/or spectral resolutions, making it difficult to discriminate seagrass from other macrophytes in highly heterogeneous meadows. Drone (unmanned aerial vehicle—UAV) images at a very high spatial resolution offer a promising solution to address challenges related to spatial heterogeneity and the intrapixel mixture. This study focuses on using drone acquisitions with a ten spectral band sensor similar to that onboard Sentinel-2 for mapping intertidal macrophytes at low tide (i.e., during a period of emersion) and effectively discriminating between seagrass and green macroalgae. Nine drone flights were conducted at two different altitudes (12 m and 120 m) across heterogeneous intertidal European habitats in France and Portugal, providing multispectral reflectance observation at very high spatial resolution (8 mm and 80 mm, respectively). Taking advantage of their extremely high spatial resolution, the low altitude flights were used to train a Neural Network classifier to discriminate five taxonomic classes of intertidal vegetation: Magnoliopsida (Seagrass), Chlorophyceae (Green macroalgae), Phaeophyceae (Brown algae), Rhodophyceae (Red macroalgae), and benthic Bacillariophyceae (Benthic diatoms), and validated using concomitant field measurements. Classification of drone imagery resulted in an overall accuracy of 94% across all sites and images, covering a total area of 467,000 m². The model exhibited an accuracy of 96.4% in identifying seagrass. In particular, seagrass and green algae can be discriminated. The very high spatial resolution of the drone data made it possible to assess the influence of spatial resolution on the classification outputs, showing a limited loss in seagrass detection up to about 10 m. Altogether, our findings suggest that the MultiSpectral Instrument (MSI) onboard Sentinel-2 offers a relevant trade-off between its spatial and spectral resolution, thus offering promising perspectives for satellite remote sensing of intertidal biodiversity over larger scales. Full article

Salinity is an essential parameter for evaluating water quality and plays a crucial role in maintaining the stability of lake ecosystems, particularly in arid and semi-arid climates. Salinity responds to changes in climate and human activity, with significant impacts on water quality and ecosystem services. In this study, Sentinel-2A/B Multi-Spectral Instrument (MSI) images and quasi-synchronous field data were utilized to estimate lake salinity using machine learning approaches (i.e., XGB, CNN, DNN, and RFR). Atmospheric correction for MSI images was tested using six processors (ACOLITE, C2RCC, POLYMER, MUMM, iCOR, and Sen2Cor). The most accurate model and atmospheric correction method were found to be the extreme gradient boosting tree combined with the ACOLITE correction algorithm. These were used to develop a salinity model (N = 70, mean absolute percentage error = 9.95%) and applied to eight lakes in Inner Mongolia from 2016 to 2024. Seasonal and interannual variations were explored, along with an examination of potential drivers of salinity changes over time. Average salinities in the autumn and spring were higher than in the summer. The highest salinities were observed in the lake centers and tended to be consistent and homogeneous. Interannual trends in salinity were evident in several lakes, influenced by evaporation and precipitation. Climate factors were the primary drivers of interannual salinity trends in most lakes. Full article

Researchers and environmental managers need big datasets spanning long time periods to accurately assess current and historical water quality conditions in fresh and estuarine waters. Using remote sensing data, we can survey many water bodies simultaneously and evaluate water quality conditions with greater frequency. The combination of existing and historical water quality data with remote sensing imagery into a unified database allows researchers to improve remote sensing algorithms and improves understanding of mechanisms causing blooms. We report on the development of a water quality database “EstuarySAT” which combines data from the Sentinel-2 multi-spectral instrument (MSI) remote sensing platform and water quality data throughout the coastal USA. EstuarySAT builds upon an existing database and set of methods developed by the creators of AquaSat, whose region of interest is primarily larger freshwater lakes in the USA. Following the same basic methods, EstuarySAT utilizes open-source tools: R v. 3.24+ (statistical software), Python (dynamic programming environment), and Google Earth Engine (GEE) to develop a combined water quality data and remote sensing imagery database (EstuarySAT) for smaller coastal estuarine and freshwater tidal riverine systems. EstuarySAT fills a data gap that exists between freshwater and estuarine water bodies. We are able to evaluate smaller systems due to the higher spatial resolution of Sentinel-2 (10 m pixel image resolution) vs. the Landsat platform used by AquaSat (30 m pixel resolution). Sentinel-2 also has a more frequent revisit (overpass) schedule of every 5 to 10 days vs. Landsat 7 which is every 17 days. EstuarySAT incorporates publicly available water quality data from 23 individual water quality data sources spanning 1984–2021 and spatially matches them with Sentinel-2 imagery from 2015–2021. EstuarySAT currently contains 299,851 matched observations distributed across the coastal USA. EstuarySAT’s primary focus is on collecting chlorophyll data; however, it also contains other ancillary water quality data, including temperature, salinity, pH, dissolved oxygen, dissolved organic carbon, and turbidity (where available). As compared to other ocean color databases used for developing predictive chlorophyll algorithms, this coastal database contains spectral profiles more typical of CDOM-dominated systems. This database can assist researchers and managers in evaluating algal bloom causes and predicting the occurrence of future blooms. Full article

Extreme meteorological events hit our planet with increasing frequency, resulting in an ever-increasing number of natural disasters. Flash floods generated by intense and violent rains are among the most dangerous natural disasters that compromise crops and cause serious damage to infrastructure and human lives. In the case of such a kind of disastrous events, timely and accurate information about the location and extent of the affected areas can be crucial to better plan and implement recovery and containment interventions. Satellite systems may efficiently provide such information at different spatial/temporal resolutions. Several authors have developed satellite techniques to detect and map inundated areas using both Synthetic Aperture Radar (SAR) and a new generation of high-resolution optical data but with some accuracy limits, mostly due to the use of fixed thresholds to discriminate between the inundated and unaffected areas. In this paper, the RST-FLOOD fully automatic technique, which does not suffer from the aforementioned limitation, has been exported for the first time to the mid–high-spatial resolution (20 m) optical data provided by the Copernicus Sentinel-2 Multi-Spectral Instrument (MSI). The technique was originally designed for and successfully applied to Advanced Very High Resolution Radiometer (AVHRR), Moderate Resolution Imaging Spectroradiometer (MODIS), and Visible Infrared Imaging Radiometer Suite (VIIRS) satellite data at a mid–low spatial resolution (from 1000 to 375 m). The processing chain was implemented in a completely automatic mode within the Google Earth Engine (GEE) platform to study the recent strong flood event that occurred in May 2023 in Emilia Romagna (Italy). The outgoing results were compared with those obtained through the implementation of an existing independent optical-based technique and the products provided by the official Copernicus Emergency Management Service (CEMS), which is responsible for releasing information during crisis events. The comparisons carried out show that RST-FLOOD is a simple implementation technique able to retrieve more sensitive and effective information than the other optical-based methodology analyzed here and with an accuracy better than the one offered by the CEMS products with a significantly reduced delivery time. Full article

The Sentinel-2 Multi-Spectral Instrument (MSI) is characterized by short revisit times (5 days), red-edge spectral bands (665 nm and 705 nm), and a high spatial resolution (10 m), making it highly suitable for monitoring water quality in both inland and coastal waters. Unlike SeaWiFS, which can adjust its viewing angles to minimize sunglint, the Sentinel-2 MSI operates with fixed near-nadir angles, which makes it more susceptible to sunglint. Additionally, the complex optical properties of water pose challenges in accurately determining its water-leaving reflectance. Therefore, we compared the effectiveness of six atmospheric correction (AC) algorithms (POLYMER, MUMM, DSF, C2RCC, BP, and GRS) in correcting sunglint using two typical lakes in Xinjiang, China, as examples. The results indicated that POLYMER achieved the highest overall evaluation score (1.61), followed by MUMM (1.21), while BP exhibited the lowest performance (0.62). Specifically, POLYMER showed robust performance at the 665 nm band with RMSE = 0.0012 sr⁻¹, R² = 0.74, and MAPE = 30.68%, as well as at the 705 nm band with RMSE = 0.0014 sr⁻¹, R² = 0.42, and MAPE = 38.44%. At the 443, 490, and 560 nm bands, MUMM showed better performance (RMSE ≤ 0.0026 sr⁻¹, R² ≥ 0.86, MAPE ≤ 28.20%). In terms of band ratios, POLYMER exhibited the highest accuracy (RMSE ≤ 0.093 and MAPE ≤ 22.2%), particularly for the ratio R_rs(490)/R_rs(560) (R² = 0.71). In general, POLYMER is the best choice for the sunglint correction of Xinjiang’s clean lakes. This study assessed the capability of different AC algorithms for sunglint correction and enhanced the monitoring capability of MSI data in clean waters. Full article

Pasture degradation poses significant economic, social, and environmental impacts in the Brazilian savanna ecosystem. Despite these impacts, effectively detecting varying intensities of agronomic and biological degradation through remote sensing remains challenging. This study explores the potential of the eight-band PlanetScope SuperDove satellite constellation to discriminate between five classes of pasture degradation: non-degraded pasture (NDP); pastures with low- (LID) and moderate-intensity degradation (MID); severe agronomic degradation (SAD); and severe biological degradation (SBD). Using a set of 259 cloud-free images acquired in 2022 across five sites located in central Brazil, the study aims to: (i) identify the most suitable period for discriminating between various degradation classes; (ii) evaluate the Random Forest (RF) classification performance of different SuperDove attributes; and (iii) compare metrics of accuracy derived from two predicted scenarios of pasture degradation: a more challenging one involving five classes (NDP, LID, MID, SAD, and SBD), and another considering only non-degraded and severely degraded pastures (NDP, SAD, and SBD). The study assessed individual and combined sets of SuperDove attributes, including band reflectance, vegetation indices, endmember fractions from spectral mixture analysis (SMA), and image texture variables from Gray-level Co-occurrence Matrix (GLCM). The results highlighted the effectiveness of the transition from the rainy to the dry season and the period towards the beginning of a new seasonal rainy cycle in October for discriminating pasture degradation. In comparison to the dry season, more favorable discrimination scenarios were observed during the rainy season. In the dry season, increased amounts of non-photosynthetic vegetation (NPV) complicate the differentiation between NDP and SBD, which is characterized by high soil exposure. Pastures exhibiting severe biological degradation showed greater sensitivity to water stress, manifesting earlier reflectance changes in the visible and near-infrared bands of SuperDove compared to other classes. Reflectance-based classification yielded higher overall accuracy (OA) than the approaches using endmember fractions, vegetation indices, or texture metrics. Classifications using combined attributes achieved an OA of 0.69 and 0.88 for the five-class and three-class scenarios, respectively. In the five-class scenario, the highest F1-scores were observed for NDP (0.61) and classes of agronomic (0.71) and biological (0.88) degradation, indicating the challenges in separating low and moderate stages of pasture degradation. An initial comparison of RF classification results for the five categories of degraded pastures, utilizing reflectance data from MultiSpectral Instrument (MSI)/Sentinel-2 (400–2500 nm) and SuperDove (400–900 nm), demonstrated an enhanced OA (0.79 versus 0.66) with Sentinel-2 data. This enhancement is likely to be attributed to the inclusion of shortwave infrared (SWIR) spectral bands in the data analysis. Our findings highlight the potential of satellite constellation data, acquired at high spatial resolution, for remote identification of pasture degradation. Full article

Eutrophication of inland lakes poses various societal and ecological threats, making water quality monitoring crucial. Satellites provide a comprehensive and cost-effective supplement to traditional in situ sampling. The Sentinel-2 MultiSpectral Instrument (S2 MSI) offers unique spectral bands positioned to quantify chlorophyll a, a water-quality and trophic-state indicator, along with fine spatial resolution, enabling the monitoring of small waterbodies. In this study, two algorithms—the Maximum Chlorophyll Index (MCI) and the Normalized Difference Chlorophyll Index (NDCI)—were applied to S2 MSI data. They were calibrated and validated using in situ chlorophyll a measurements for 103 lakes across the contiguous U.S. Both algorithms were tested using top-of-atmosphere reflectances (ρ_t), Rayleigh-corrected reflectances (ρ_s), and remote sensing reflectances (R_rs). MCI slightly outperformed NDCI across all reflectance products. MCI using ρ_t showed the best overall performance, with a mean absolute error factor of 2.08 and a mean bias factor of 1.15. Conversion of derived chlorophyll a to trophic state improved the potential for management applications, with 82% accuracy using a binary classification. We report algorithm-to-chlorophyll-a conversions that show potential for application across the U.S., demonstrating that S2 can serve as a monitoring tool for inland lakes across broad spatial scales. Full article

Several satellite missions are currently available to provide thermal infrared data at different spatial resolutions and revisit time. Furthermore, new missions are planned thus enabling to keep a nearly continuous ‘eye’ on thermal volcanic activity around the world. This massive volume of data requires the development of artificial intelligence (AI) techniques for the automatic processing of satellite data in order to extract significant information about volcano conditions in a short time. Here, we propose a robust machine learning approach to accurately detect, recognize and quantify high-temperature volcanic features using Sentinel-2 MultiSpectral Instrument (S2-MSI) imagery. We use the entire archive of high spatial resolution satellite data containing more than 6000 S2-MSI scenes at ten different volcanoes around the world. Combining a ‘top-down’ cascading architecture, two different machine learning models, a scene classifier (SqueezeNet) and a pixel-based segmentation model (random forest), we achieved a very high accuracy, namely 95%. These results show that the cascading approach can be applied in near-real time to any available satellite image, providing a full description of the scene, with an important contribution to the monitoring, mapping and characterization of volcanic thermal features. Full article

The GaoFen-1 wide field of view (GF-1 WFV) has produced level 1 digital number data globally; however, most applications have focused on China, and data quality outside China has not been validated. This study presents a preliminary assessment of the 2020 GF-1 WFV surface reflectance data for Nepal, Azerbaijan, Kenya, and Sri Lanka along “the Belt and Road” route using Sentinel-2 Multi-Spectral Instrument (MSI), Landsat-8 Operational Land Image (OLI), and Moderate Resolution Imaging Spectroradiometer (MODIS) data. A method for obtaining the GF-1 WFV surface reflectance data was also proposed, with steps including atmospheric correction, cross-radiation calibration, and bidirectional reflectance distribution function correction. The results showed that WFV surface reflectance data was not significantly different from MSI, OLI, and MODIS surface reflectance data. In the visible and near-infrared bands, for most landcover types, the bias was less than 0.02, and the precision and root mean square error were less than 0.04. When the landcover types were forest and water, the MSI, OLI, and MODIS surface reflectance data were higher than that of WFV in the near-infrared band. The results of this study provide a basis for assessing the global application potential of GF-1 WFV. Full article

Urbanization is progressing at an unprecedented rate in many places around the world. The Sentinel-1 synthetic aperture radar (SAR) and Sentinel-2 MultiSpectral Instrument (MSI) missions, combined with deep learning, offer new opportunities to accurately monitor urbanization at a global scale. Although the joint use of SAR and optical data has recently been investigated for urban change detection, existing data fusion methods rely heavily on the availability of sufficient training labels. Meanwhile, change detection methods addressing label scarcity are typically designed for single-sensor optical data. To overcome these limitations, we propose a semi-supervised urban change detection method that exploits unlabeled Sentinel-1 SAR and Sentinel-2 MSI data. Using bitemporal SAR and optical image pairs as inputs, the proposed multi-modal Siamese network predicts urban changes and performs built-up area segmentation for both timestamps. Additionally, we introduce a consistency loss, which penalizes inconsistent built-up area segmentation across sensor modalities on unlabeled data, leading to more robust features. To demonstrate the effectiveness of the proposed method, the SpaceNet 7 dataset, comprising multi-temporal building annotations from rapidly urbanizing areas across the globe, was enriched with Sentinel-1 SAR and Sentinel-2 MSI data. Subsequently, network performance was analyzed under label-scarce conditions by training the network on different fractions of the labeled training set. The proposed method achieved an F1 score of 0.555 when using all available training labels, and produced reasonable change detection results (F1 score of 0.491) even with as little as 10% of the labeled training data. In contrast, multi-modal supervised methods and semi-supervised methods using optical data failed to exceed an F1 score of 0.402 under this condition. Code and data are made publicly available. Full article

Crop growth and development exhibit high temporal heterogeneity. It is crucial to capture the dynamic characteristics of crop growth using intensive time-series data. However, single satellites are limited by revisit cycles and weather conditions to provide dense time-series data for earth observations. However, up until now, there has been no proposed remote sensing fusion product that offers high spatial-temporal resolution specifically for farmland monitoring. Therefore, focusing on the demands of farmland remote sensing monitoring, identifying quantitative conversion relationships between multiple sensors, and providing high spatial-temporal resolution products is the first step that needs to be addressed. In this study, a fused Landsat 8 (L8) Operational Land Imager (OLI) and Sentinel-2 (S-2) multi-spectral instruments (MSI) data product for regional monitoring of farmland at high, mid, and low latitudes in China is proposed. Two image pairs for each study area covering different years were acquired from simultaneous transits of L8 OLI and S-2 MSI sensors. Then, the isolation forest (iForest) algorithm was employed to remove the anomalous pixels of image pairs and eliminate the influence of anomalous data on the conversion relationships. Subsequently, the adjustment coefficients for multi-source sensors at mixed latitudes with high spatial resolution were obtained using an ordinary least squares regression method. Finally, the L8-S-2 fused dataset based on the adjustment coefficients is proposed, which is suitable for different latitude farming areas in China. The results showed that the iForest algorithm could effectively improve the correlation between the corresponding spectral bands of the two sensors at a spatial resolution of 10 m. After the removal of anomalous pixels, excellent correlation and consistency were obtained in three study areas, and the Pearson correlation coefficients between the corresponding spectral bands almost all exceeded 0.88. Furthermore, we mixed the six image pairs of the three latitudes to obtain the adjustment coefficients derived for integrated L8 and S-2 data with high-spatial-resolution. The significance and accuracy quantification of the adjustment coefficients were thoroughly examined from three dimensions: qualitative and quantitative analyses, and spatial heterogeneity assessment. The obtained results were highly satisfactory, affirming the validity and precision of the adjustment coefficients. Finally, we applied the adjustment coefficients to crop monitoring in three latitudes. The normalized difference vegetation index (NDVI) time-series curves drawn by the integrated dataset could accurately describe the cropping system and capture the intensity changes of crop growth within the high, middle, and low latitudes of China. This study provides valuable insights into enhancing the application of multi-source remote sensing satellite data for long-term, continuous quantitative inversion of surface parameters and is of great significance for crop remote sensing monitoring. Full article

The multispectral imager (MII), onboard the Sustainable Development Science Satellite 1 (SDGSAT-1), performs detailed terrestrial change detection and coastal monitoring. SDGSAT-1 was launched at 2:19 UTC on 5 November 2021, as the world’s first Earth science satellite to serve the United Nations 2030 Sustainable Development Agenda. A vicarious radiometric calibration experiment was conducted at the Dunhuang calibration site (Gobi Desert, China) on 14 December 2021. In-situ measurements of ground reflectance, aerosol optical depth (AOD), total columnar water vapor, radiosonde data, and diffuse-to-global irradiance (DG) ratio were performed to predict the top-of-atmosphere radiance by the reflectance-, irradiance-, and improved irradiance-based methods using the moderate resolution atmospheric transmission model. The MII calibration coefficients were calculated by dividing the top-of-atmosphere radiance by the average digital number value of the image. The radiometric calibration coefficients calculated by the three calibration methods were reliable (average relative differences: 2.20% (reflectance-based vs. irradiance-based method) and 1.43% (reflectance-based vs. improved irradiance-based method)). The total calibration uncertainties of the reflectance-, irradiance-, and improved irradiance-based methods were 2.77–5.23%, 3.62–5.79%, and 3.50–5.23%, respectively. The extra DG ratio measurements in the latter two methods did not improve the calibration accuracy for AODs ≤ 0.1. The calibrated MII images were verified using Landsat-8 Operational Land Imager (OLI) and Sentinel-2A MultiSpectral Instrument (MSI) images. The retrieved ground reflectances of the MII over different surface types were cross-compared with those of OLI and MSI using the FAST Line-of-sight Atmospheric Analysis of Hypercubes software. The MII retrievals differed by <0.0075 (7.13%) from OLI retrievals and <0.0084 (7.47%) from MSI retrievals for calibration coefficients from the reflectance-based method; <0.0089 (7.57%) from OLI retrievals and <0.0111 (8.65%) from MSI retrievals for the irradiance-based method; and <0.0082 (7.33%) from OLI retrievals and <0.0101 (8.59%) from MSI retrievals for the improved irradiance-based method. Thus, our findings support the application of SDGSAT-1 data. Full article

Multispectral images accessible free of charge have increased significantly from the acquisitions by the wide-field-of-view (WFV) sensors onboard Gaofen-1/-6 (GF-1/-6), the Operational Land Imager (OLI) onboard Landsat 8 (L8), and the Multi-Spectral Instrument (MSI) onboard Sentinel-2 (S2). These images with medium spatial resolutions are beneficial for land-cover mapping to monitor local to global surface dynamics. Comparative analyses of the four sensors in classification were made under different scenarios with five classifiers, mainly based on the simulated multispectral reflectance from well-processed hyperspectral data. With channel reflectance, differences in classification between the L8 OLI and the S2 MSI were generally dependent on the classifier considered, although the two sensors performed similarly. Meanwhile, without channels over the shortwave infrared region, the GF-1/-6 WFVs showed inferior performances. With channel reflectance, the support vector machine (SVM) with Gaussian kernel generally outperformed other classifiers. With the SVM, on average, the GF-1/-6 WFVs and the L8 OLI had great increases (more than 15%) in overall accuracy relative to using the maximum likelihood classifier (MLC), whereas the overall accuracy improvement was about 13% for the S2 MSI. Both SVM and random forest (RF) had greater overall accuracy, which partially solved the problems of imperfect channel settings. However, under the scenario with a small number of training samples, for the GF-1/-6 WFVs, the MLC showed approximate or even better performance compared to RF. Since several factors possibly influence a classifier’s performance, attention should be paid to a comparison and selection of methods. These findings were based on the simulated multispectral reflectance with focusing on spectral channel (i.e., number of channels, spectral range of the channel, and spectral response function), whereas spatial resolution and radiometric quantization were not considered. Furthermore, a limitation of this paper was largely associated with the limited spatial coverage. More case studies should be carried out with real images over areas with different geographical and environmental backgrounds. To improve the comparability in classification among different sensors, further investigations are definitely required. Full article