Skip to Content
HeritageHeritage
  • Review
  • Open Access

18 May 2026

28 Pages

Decoding the Microclimate in Subterranean Heritage Structures

and
1
School of Architecture, Faculty of Engineering, Aristotle University of Thessaloniki, 54124 Thessaloniki, Greece
2
Department of Civil Engineering, Demokritos University of Thrace, University Campus Xanthi-Kimmeria, 67100 Xanthi, Greece
*
Authors to whom correspondence should be addressed.

Abstract

This paper addresses the important issue of the proper management and protection of subterranean monuments. It concerns the analysis and decoding of the microclimate that is created in heritage structures, which are structures located beneath the soil or carved into rock. The aim of this study is to understand the hygrothermal processes occurring in the mass of underground structural elements, such as evaporation, condensation, water content, and heat fluxes, based on the principles of building physics. The methodology used is the following: a systematic literature review on the topic, an overview of the factors affecting the microclimate, the assessment methodology, and the simulation tools used to decode and evaluate microclimate in subterranean heritage structures; a discussion of the current gaps; and finally, a proposal for future directions for research. A review of the literature reveals that researchers worldwide have employed similar methodologies to approach this complex issue. Recordings and analyses of the microclimate inside underground monuments lead to decision-making and the formulation of actions for optimal preservation. Due to the large number of parameters involved in microclimate analysis, computer software for numerical simulation has been used in many cases. Following the review of the relevant literature in the field of study, a critical discussion concludes by proposing directions for future research on this important topic. Basic results of this research identify current gaps, problems, and limitations. These include technical and practical issues or gaps concerning lack of data for material properties and weather conditions. Another significant limitation arises from the complexity of physical interactions, as well as from the human factor, which involves the proper use of the simulation program and the correct interpretation of the calculation results. This study demonstrates that the microclimate of subterranean heritage structures is the result of complex interactions between climate, geology, architectural design, material properties, and human use. Across different geographical and cultural contexts, subterranean monuments exhibit distinct microclimatic behaviors. The comparative analysis of case studies highlights that while subterranean environments generally benefit from thermal stability, they remain highly vulnerable to moisture dynamics, ventilation changes, and external climatic coupling. Hence, there is a necessity for context-specific approaches rather than generalized conservation solutions. Decoding subterranean microclimates requires a multidisciplinary framework that combines environmental monitoring, material indicators, architectural analysis, and numerical modeling.

1. Introduction

This paper concerns the analysis and decoding of the microclimate inside subterranean heritage structures that are under an embankment or carved into rock. It is not a typical review paper, as it examines iconic subterranean monuments of world cultural heritage, whether or not they are listed on the UNESCO World Heritage List.
In order to present our work, a critical narrative review approach is followed. This approach permits a comprehensive analysis, especially when interdisciplinary areas of science are involved.
Notably, we synthesize and review published work of others and of ourselves. Regarding our own work, we clarify and emphasize in a better manner the results and conclusions of our own research. A review paper on this subject is challenging indeed since all aspects involve interdisciplinary scientific work as well as field research.
In particular, this paper studies the proper management of underground heritage structures to achieve preservation, sustainability, and resilience to climate change. A review of the work that has been carried out on monuments with similarities all over the world is presented, aiming to critically analyze current gaps or problems and provide recommendations for future research.
Monumental subterranean structures were created throughout the world, in different historic periods, for different uses. Royal tombs in northern Greece, for example, designated as Macedonian tombs, were constructed to become the burials of important people, kings, and emperors. They are unique and valuable examples of the architecture of their era. Some of these tombs have been carved into a soft rock (rock-cut cavities), and others have been built with large blocks of stone with vaulted roofs, having as a special characteristic the artificial covering by earth, named “tumulus”. All of them are decorated with exceptional wall paintings of great archaeological importance in the interior and on their façades. They are buildings constructed to remain underground, covered with soil, because of their special use as afterlife homes for the dead. Most of them have been preserved over the centuries in excellent condition, being in a stable microclimate, which was disturbed after the excavation works. After the excavation they were converted into visiting places or museums because of their historical significance.
Proper protection of these heritage structures can be achieved by adjusting the microclimatic conditions. There is a need to intervene in their microenvironment in order to control—as far as possible—the microclimate. The main objective is to stop any potential deterioration processes and to take precautionary measures for sustainable management and future preservation of cultural heritage. Sustainable management of archaeological sites and built heritage is a topic of the UNESCO Sustainable Development Goals, specifically SDG11: “Make cities and human settlements inclusive, safe, resilient and sustainable”, target 11.4: “Strengthen efforts to protect and safeguard the world’s cultural and natural heritage” [1,2].
In attempting to define the challenge of deterioration in subterranean monuments due to their hygrothermal status, scholars all over the world have been involved in recording and analyzing their particular characteristics. Systematic monitoring and evaluation of the indoor climatic conditions have shown that the deterioration processes are mainly caused by cyclical changes in temperature and relative humidity when the monuments are exposed to the environment and the presence of visitors. Protection against future deterioration can only be assured through proper interventions to stabilize the indoor microclimate. Specific protection measures are needed on the site during and after the excavation procedure. Mainly, the protection measures include a proper shelter that will operate as a regulator for the microclimate. Case studies worldwide show that the main issue to be addressed by constructing shelters on the site is the stabilization of the temperature and humidity, thus reducing and minimizing the fluctuations of the exterior climate [3].
To decode the microclimate in subterranean heritage structures, we should define research questions, which are:
  • What are the physical and environmental laws governing microclimatic behavior?
  • What are the foundational building physics principles?
  • What shapes a specific monument’s microclimate in different geographical locations? What are the determining factors in each location?
  • How is microclimate observed and quantified?
  • How data are interpreted and integrated into assessment methods?
Those questions will be answered in the following sections.
Based on a critical narrative approach, this paper is organized as follows.
In Section 2 the problem of the deterioration processes in underground monuments is studied, and their hygrothermal behavior is analyzed based on building physics science. More specifically, Section 2.4.1 investigates the “ideal conditions” for preserving ancient materials.
In Section 3 a review of case studies is presented. By examining case studies applied to important subterranean monuments worldwide, valuable conclusions are drawn regarding their protection. At the end of this section, we constructed a comparative table presenting environmental and accessibility control aspects.
In Section 4 there is a discussion regarding the concept of sustainability and how it could be balanced with the monuments’ preservation. Climate change adaptation and resilience of the archaeological sites are also very important issues.
In Section 5 a critical analysis of the literature and a discussion are presented, including the working methodology, the use of hygrothermal simulation computer programs, and an example application using the WUFI® Pro 4.1 software.
Section 6 identifies current gaps, problems, and limitations and examines in detail all aspects covered in our paper.
Finally, Section 7 provides future directions for further research.

3. Research Background–Applied Case Studies

Underground monuments have been the subject of research since the middle of the 20th century. Many scholars have been involved in recording and analyzing the characteristics of subterranean monuments all over the world.
Studies and management plans have been formulated and, in many cases, implemented to safeguard underground monuments.
All of these monuments have been constructed below the ground level, either as rock-cut cavities or built with stone and covered with a tumulus. They have different features in building technology and decoration techniques, according to their historic period. Nevertheless, all of them have similar characteristics concerning the indoor microclimatic conditions due to their contact with the soil or rock.
By examining different case studies, valuable conclusions can be drawn regarding subterranean monument protection.
Additionally, more recent studies dealing with subterranean monuments are authored by the following researchers:
Becherini et al. (2010) [22], Scatigno et al. (2016) [23], Kim and Lee (2019) [24], Kyriakou and Panoskaltsis (2019) [25], Frasca, et al. (2020) [26], Zicarelli, et al. (2023) [27], Xia, et al. (2025) [28], Hu, et al. (2025) [29], Choi, and Lee (2025) [30].

3.1. Case Studies Review

This section presents a narrative synthesis of selected case studies involving significant subterranean monuments worldwide. The objective is to extract practical insights into conservation strategies and environmental management approaches.
The case studies, which were selected, belong to different geographic regions and different climatic conditions and are analyzed comparatively.
The case studies analyzed belong to the following regions:
Eastern Europe. Thracian Tombs (Bulgaria)
Southern Europe. Etruscan Tumuli (Italy) and Macedonian Tombs (Greece)
Egypt Rock-Cut Tombs
East Asian Japanese Tumuli (Kofun)
Chinese Rock-Cut Grottoes

3.1.1. The Thracian Tomb in Kazanluk, Bulgaria

Worldwide, since the middle of the 20th century, local cultural services and world organizations have begun to raise awareness of the issue of subterranean tombs. The pioneer in this field proved to be the UNESCO team. In 1966 they undertook the study on the protection of a Thracian tomb in Kazanluk, in Bulgaria.
Discovered in 1944, the tomb dates from the late 4th to early 3rd century B.C., and it was inscribed on the UNESCO World Heritage List in 1979. It is one of the most significant monuments of Thracian funerary architecture and mural paintings of Hellenistic-style frescoes. The first systematic stabilization of the wall paintings and structural reinforcement has been completed by Bulgarian conservation specialists. In 1964 the tomb was secured under a permanent protective shelter with air conditioning to ensure a stable temperature. The negative impact of the visitors was minimized by constructing, in 1973–1974, a nearby museum that contains a full-scale replica of the tomb and its decoration for public display [31,32].
As is seen in the Figure 2, there is a wide range of fluctuations during 1964, when the shelter’s construction took place. After that, measurements in 1965 show that the range of relative humidity has been minimized but still remained high due to the impact of the visitors. Measurements in 1988, after the construction of the replica, show a significant relative humidity stabilization.
Figure 2. The Thracian tomb of Kazanluk. (a) The tomb chamber and the protective shelter. (b) Fluctuations in the relative humidity before the construction of the shelter in 1964 and after the construction, in two different periods, 1965 and 1988 (from [31,32]).

3.1.2. Nefertari’s Tomb and the Tomb of Amon, in Egypt

In 1985, UNESCO, in collaboration with the Getty Institute, undertook a study on the protection of Nefertari’s tomb in Egypt (1255 B.C.). Nefertari was the wife of Rameses II (1279–1213, B.C.).
Complete recordings of conservation status, analyses, evaluations of up-to-date interventions, microclimate recordings, and guest control program proposals were studied by the Getty Institute. The UNESCO team has performed great pilot studies and has shown that the right approach to the problem should be based on two main parameters:
–
The composition of a team of scientists from different disciplines on one hand;
–
The systematic and long-term documentation before any intervention on the other.
Past mistakes have shown that temporary interventions can lead to major disasters. Interdisciplinary cooperation between many scientific fields is a necessity. Archaeologists, architects, civil engineers, geotechnical engineers, mechanical engineers, environmental engineers, conservationists, chemists, biologists, and geologists need to work together [33,34,35].
Figure 3b shows that the relative humidity is stable before the opening of the tomb to visitors. After that, it rises to very high levels and drops again after the exit of the visitors.
Figure 3. The tomb of Queen Nefertari. (a) Plan and longitudinal section of the tomb and the preservation facilities, showing the sensors’ positions, with numbers 1 to 6; (b) Diagrams showing the fluctuations of the relative humidity and CO2 (from [34,35]).

3.1.3. The Etruscan Tombs in Italy

Since the 1980s, the Etruscan tombs, dated between the 7th and 2nd centuries B.C., have been explored in Italy. All of them are carved out of bedrock, featuring exceptional wall paintings. Problems of humidity were addressed inside the tombs. After the frescoes had been repaired, transparent barriers, low-heat lighting, and climatic monitoring systems were installed.
On-site research with monitoring has been carried out in the necropolis of Tarquinia and Cerveteri. Its purpose was to assess the possible relationship between the state of deterioration of the painted surfaces of the tombs and the microclimate conditions in the interior resulting from heat and moisture exchanges [36,37].
The experiments were conducted with the door of the shelter open or closed and in the presence of ten visitors. As Figure 4b shows the values of humidity are very high, and the fluctuations are very intense, meaning that the stable microclimate is interrupted.
Figure 4. Tombs in Tarquinia. (a) Cross section of the tomb of the Giocolieri and the shelter; (b) Monitoring of the relative humidity during experiments (from [37]).
The authors used a mathematical model by which the quantities of water vapor in the space were calculated, and their changes were interpreted as exchanges of water absorbed or released by the materials. The conclusion was that hygrometric dynamics is determined by the movement of water through the walls, which is due to the circular flow of thermal energy. It became apparent that the microclimate is affected by thermal energy flows and water flows, which occur mainly between materials and the interior [37,38].

3.1.4. The Tombs of the Emperors in Japan

In Japan, similar research was carried out in 1983 at the Tombs of the Emperors dated to the 7th century A.D. These are monuments built with stone and covered by soil embankments. Scientific investigation of the conditions in the Emperors’ Tombs began in 1983, and protective shelters with adjustable climatic conditions were constructed. The goal in all operations was to ensure stable temperature and humidity conditions with different technical solutions and to restore, to some degree, the lost hygrothermal equilibrium (see Figure 5) [39,40,41].
Figure 5. The Takamatsuzuka tomb. (a) Annual changes in temperature inside and outside of the stone chamber of the Takamatsuzuka tomb. (b) Longitudinal sections of the preservation facilities, shelter, and mechanical equipment (from [39,40,41]).
Before constructing the preservation facilities in 1973, the range of temperature values was very high in the interior of the tomb. After the construction of the shelter in 1982, there was a stabilization of the temperature, as Figure 5a shows.

3.1.5. The Macedonian Tombs in Greece

Macedonian tombs in Greece have been excavated since the 1950s [42,43]. During this period protective shelters were constructed over the tombs in Imathia, the ancient Mieza (see Figure 6). After 2000, shelters were constructed over the tombs in Agios Athanasios (see Figure 7) [43] and Foinikas [43], in Derveni [44], in Aigai-Vergina [45,46,47] (see Figure 8), and in Pella [48] (see Figure 9).
Figure 6. Shelters for Macedonian tombs in ancient Mieza—Imathia [1].
Figure 7. (a,b) The Macedonian tomb in Agios Athanasios. (c) Plan of its shelter [43].
Figure 8. The shelter over the tombs at Vergina. (a,b) Drawings of the tumulus-shaped shelter (by Dimakopoulos and Zaglaniki [46,47]). (c) 3D model of the Macedonian tomb (from [46,47]).
Figure 9. Open shelters in Pella. (a) Macedonian tumulus Δ. (b) Macedonian tumulus Γ. (Photos by authors).
Over the Royal Tombs at Aigai (modern-day Vergina), a museum was constructed during 1993–1997 [45,46,47]. It is a built shelter in the shape of a tumulus with a soil embankment. This construction regulates the temperature and relative humidity conditions using mechanical equipment.
In Pella, there are excavations more recent than Vergina’s, where open shelters were constructed (Figure 9). The names—from the Greek alphabet—Γ and Δ are given by the excavators.
Recordings of the microclimate inside three tombs, i.e., the tombs Γ and Δ in Pella and one tomb in Agios Athanasios, provided comparative diagrams for temperature and relative humidity (Figure 10). All these results were obtained by using the simulation environment WUFI, which will be presented in detail in Section 5.2 [48,49].
Figure 10. Comparison between three tombs and the environment. Diagrams of temperature and relative humidity during one year (starting in July) show the annual fluctuations inside the three tombs and the environment (blue line). (a) Temperature. (b) Relative humidity (from [48,49]).
Comparing the three tombs to the surrounding environment, there is a significant difference in temperature and relative humidity between the interior and exterior spaces. The temperature is quite stable, but the relative humidity experiences many fluctuations. The diagrams represent the conditions recorded while the tombs were covered by temporary, not closed shelters.

3.1.6. Hypogeal Sites: The Mithraeum of the Baths of Caracalla (Rome) [26]

Frasca et al. studied the deterioration processes inside the subterranean Mithraeum of the Baths of Caracalla (Rome). In their paper they presented the environmental monitoring campaign that was conducted over a period spanning 10 years(see Figure 11). The study proposed a methodology to assess the frequently occurring hazards in such sites and evaluate the deterioration before and after maintenance interventions.
Figure 11. Hygrothermal conditions inside the monument. (a) Temperature. (b) Relative humidity (from [26]).

3.1.7. The Ancient Tombs of the Baekje Dynasty in the Republic of Korea [24]

Goguryeo tombs (Figure 12) are found throughout North Korea and in the Jian region of China. Sixty-three of these tombs have been designated as UNESCO World Heritage Sites since 2004. Ten tombs of this type are in the Republic of Korea, constructed from the 5th to the 15th centuries. They have been managed as historical sites due to their cultural importance. Currently, access to these tombs is restricted because of damage caused by exposure to the external environment and influx.
Figure 12. Microclimatic characteristics inside the tomb (from [24]). The indoor temperature differs from the outdoor temperature, as the heat transfer is minimized due to the tumulus.

3.2. Comparative Analysis Across Regions

A comparative overview of subterranean monuments from different regions—Southern Europe, Eastern Europe, East Asia, and Egypt—demonstrates that subterranean microclimates are governed by regional climate acting through local geological and architectural characteristics.
All share defining characteristics: construction below ground level, massive masonry or rock-cut envelopes, tumulus earth cover, and decorated interiors. Comparatively, while absolute temperature and moisture levels vary regionally, the governing processes remain consistent: slow heat transfer through soil, moisture buffering by porous materials, and limited air exchange.

3.2.1. Southern Europe: Macedonian Tombs (Greece) and Etruscan Tumuli (Italy)

Mediterranean climate: Hot, dry summers. Mild, wet winters. Strong seasonal contrasts in surface temperature.
Macedonian tombs, such as those at Vergina and Lefkadia, exhibit microclimatic behavior comparable to Etruscan tumulus tombs: high relative humidity (often >90%), minimal diurnal temperature variation, and strong dependence on soil cover thickness, which reduces diurnal and seasonal fluctuation.
Implications: Good long-term preservation. Wall paintings are vulnerable to salt crystallization and moisture infiltration from winter rains. Ventilation affects condensation cycles.

3.2.2. Eastern Europe: Thracian Tombs (Bulgaria)

Continental climate: hot summers, cold winters, sometimes severe, greater seasonal temperature amplitude than Mediterranean regions.
Microclimate: subterranean tombs buffer extremes effectively. Strong seasonal moisture gradients in surrounding soils. Freeze–thaw cycles affect overlying mounds and entrances.
Implications: interior temperatures are relatively stable once sealed. Structural and decorative damage often results from: water infiltration, pressure and cracking from seasonal expansion/contraction, and painted reliefs vulnerable to humidity fluctuations rather than heat.

3.2.3. East Asia Japanese Tumuli (Kofun)

Humid temperate to subtropical: high rainfall. Strong monsoonal influence. Frequent typhoons and seasonal saturation of soils.
Microclimate: earthen tumuli with stone chambers exhibit: high and persistent humidity and less thermal stability than deep rock-cut caves. Water infiltration is a dominant factor.
Implications: organic materials degrade rapidly. Stone chambers are subject to condensation and biological growth (moss and algae); long-term preservation depends on drainage and mound integrity.

3.2.4. Chinese Rock-Cut Grottoes

Highly variable by region: Northern China: arid to semi-arid, large temperature ranges. Central China: continental monsoon climate; seasonal extremes are common.
Microclimate: rock-cut grottoes are often semi-subterranean. Microclimates are less stable than in deep caves: temperature and humidity fluctuate seasonally, and there is exposure to wind and dust.
Implications: major risks include salt efflorescence, wind erosion, and thermal stress on stone and pigments. Preservation is more challenging than in sealed subterranean tombs.
Asian tumuli and grottoes similarly demonstrate delayed but measurable coupling to external climate conditions, particularly through moisture ingress driven by seasonal rainfall and groundwater dynamics.

3.2.5. Egypt Rock-Cut Tombs

Hyper-arid desert climate. Extremely low rainfall, high surface temperature extremes, and minimal biological activity.
Microclimate: subterranean tombs exhibit very low relative humidity and high thermal stability despite extreme external heat; rock-cut chambers are often cool relative to the surface.
Implications: excellent preservation of pigments and reliefs over millennia. Threats: increased humidity from tourism, condensation from human respiration; preservation historically favored by dryness rather than isolation.

3.3. Lessons Learned and Transferability

  • Microclimatic stability is more critical than achieving a predefined “optimal” range.
  • Numerical modeling, based on long-term monitoring, is a powerful tool for testing intervention scenarios without risking irreversible damage.
  • Management strategies must prioritize access control and passive measures before considering technical systems.
  • Evidence remains fragmented and site-specific, indicating a research gap in comparative climate change assessment. A greater availability of measured data for documentation of these issues would offer further guidance for the sustainable management of subterranean monuments.
  • Transferability lies primarily in the methodological framework—observation, interpretation, modeling, and careful intervention.
The following table (Table 1) presents all the monuments included in this comparative study, organized by the specific criteria they fulfill regarding accessibility and environmental control.
Table 1. Comparative table: accessibility and environmental control in subterranean monuments (by the authors).

4. The Concept of Sustainability and Climate Change Adaptation

This section explores the intersection between cultural heritage preservation and sustainability principles. The discussion emphasizes the growing importance of climate change adaptation and site resilience.
Sustainability in cultural heritage can be stated as “preserving heritage assets as well as possible, at the same time as providing access as well as possible, given limited resources”. The UNESCO SDGs (Sustainable Development Goals) included the preservation of built heritage in Goal 11 [50]. The question is how to balance preservation with sustainability, the lack of resources, overtourism, and climate change. The Climate Change Response Strategy sets out four primary pillars for the management of protected areas: science, adaptation, mitigation, and communication [51,52].
First, the science pillar collects all the work that has been performed to gather climatic data (measurements, modeling, and related issues). There is science to identify and track impacts of climate change on cultural heritage, and there is science that learns from or works with cultural heritage for an improved and broader understanding of climate change.
Adaptation aims to determine what needs to be done about climate change, policy, planning, and decision-making. There is adaptation of management approaches to address the impacts of climate change on cultural heritage, and there is learning from cultural heritage in order to assist in adapting resource management and society to climate change. For example, the impacts side of the science pillar focuses on methods and data that characterize the interactions of climate change phenomena with components of cultural heritage. Materials science compiled in the Atlas of Climate Change Impact on European Cultural Heritage is one example of such work [50]. Mitigation includes efforts to reduce greenhouse gas emissions. Finally, communication means sharing information among resource managers and with the public [53].
The impacts aspect of the adaptation pillar addresses questions of what to do about the impacts of climate change on cultural heritage identified by work in the science pillar. Key parts of this process include scenario planning [54] and development of cultural heritage management options that address climate change impacts and maintain historical integrity [55]. As the outputs from global climate models project that climatic changes will grow larger over the current century with the magnitude of the projected change dependent on the selected path of greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions and the model selected, strategies need to be developed to reduce the negative consequences of climate change on sites of historical value in addition to mitigating climate change by curtailing GHG emissions.
Our tangible cultural heritage is threatened by gradually shifting weather patterns and extreme events. An increase in temperature together with changes in precipitation, relative humidity, and wind, for instance, can negatively impact the materials comprising cultural heritage assets. This is because a change in average climatic conditions as well as changes in the frequency and intensity of severe weather events can affect the biological, chemical, and physical mechanisms leading to degradation of the assets [56].
Sabbioni et al. [53] developed guidelines for adapting the European cultural heritage to climate change impacts, which were later adopted by the Italian Strategic Agenda. These included strategies for both physical adaptation and for adjusting management practices. Examples of the latter include improving the monitoring, maintenance, and preparedness for floods and landslides at cultural heritage sites. Cassar [57] investigated the impacts of climate change on archaeological sites and suggested adopting solutions that are sensibly designed for the specific conditions of the site after a long-term program of monitoring and maintenance. Additionally, Cassar [58] summarized the adaptation measures suggested by the UN Educational, Scientific, and Cultural Organization (UNESCO) and by the International Council on Monuments and Sites (ICOMOS), which recommend increasing research, knowledge, education, engagement, the upgrading of management plans, including risk assessments, and monitoring procedures to increase the resilience of the sites. However, natural processes have often been ignored in previous assessments of vulnerability.
Climate change adaptation is thus a relatively new challenge, and this is particularly the case in the field of cultural heritage. The impacts of climate change on cultural heritage were first mentioned in the chapter on Europe of the Fifth Assessment Report (AR5) of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) in 2014. Following the adoption of the Paris Agreement, the World Heritage Committee of UNESCO, at its annual session in 2017 in Krakow, Poland, noted the pressing issue of climate change impacts on World Heritage properties and requested that the UNESCO World Heritage Centre support State Parties in managing climate change impacts and in strengthening collaboration with the UNFCCC and the IPCC [59].
The World Heritage Committee is responsible for the World Heritage Convention and consists of representatives from twenty-one of the State Parties, who are elected by the General Assembly. This led to the IPCC consulting with UNESCO to identify topics to be incorporated as part of AR6 to be published in 2021. Climate change impacts were only briefly mentioned in AR5, and the impacts presented in the report were mainly the results of initiatives funded by the European Commission (EC) over the last 15 years, such as the Noah’s Ark (2003–2007) and Climate for Culture (2009–2015) projects. These projects focused on the threats of climate change to cultural heritage, with limited attention given to the adaptation of cultural heritage to climate [54].
The change in global climate affects underground microclimates, primarily through indirect and delayed mechanisms. Rising mean surface temperatures and increased frequency of extreme weather events progressively modify the boundary conditions governing heat and moisture exchange between soil, rock, and enclosed underground spaces.
Subterranean monuments should no longer be treated as climatically isolated systems. Instead, they must be understood as coupled surface–subsurface environments, where climatic conditions interact with local geology, hydrology, and human use. Conservation strategies should therefore prioritize continuous monitoring, early detection of threats and baseline shifts, and flexible management approaches aligned with preventive conservation principles and long-term risk assessment methods [60,61,62,63].

5. Critical Analysis of Literature–Discussion

This section provides a critical discussion of the reviewed literature, the evaluation of existing research methodologies, and a discussion of hygrothermal simulation tools used in heritage studies.
Researchers worldwide have been using similar methodologies to approach the complicated issue of analyzing the microclimate inside underground monuments in order to support the decision-making and propose actions for optimal preservation.
Due to the large number of parameters to be considered in analyzing the microclimate, the use of computer software is essential to achieve this objective. The computer can perform repeated test cycles using different data and enables experimentation with alternative approaches, e.g., the use of different materials and building techniques (see Table 2).
Table 2. Hygrothermal simulation tools (from [64] and addition of websites by authors).
In order to demonstrate the role of simulation in analyzing moisture and thermal behavior in underground structures, an example application using WUFI® Pro is presented.

5.1. The Working Methodology

Decision-making should be completed with a full understanding of the monuments’ behavior and the contribution of each individual factor to the deterioration processes. Strategic management and control of the microclimate in the tombs will be based on the result of the evaluation, which can assess strategies using a simulation program.
Through data collection, analysis, simulation, and interpretation of the results, research provides an assessment methodology for microclimate control strategies aimed at protecting subterranean tombs.
The following methodology can be applied to all the subterranean monuments:
–
The first step consists of the investigation of the microclimatic conditions in the subterranean monuments, i.e., temperature and relative humidity (RH) recordings. A specific recording methodology must be followed for at least one year. By specific methodology, we mean the positions of the instruments in the monument and the time step of data recording. Digital recorders, which have the appropriate sensors in order to record both temperature and relative humidity, are commonly used.
–
The second step pertains to the input of data, i.e., of the recordings, into the computer program that will be used. The simulation provides results regarding fluxes of heat and humidity inside the structural elements of the monuments.
–
The third step is the analysis and interpretation of the output; with this, we are able to assess the hygrothermal performance of the monuments’ structural elements.
–
Then, in case a shelter has been built over the monument, the program is executed again, using the new boundary conditions.
–
The last step consists of the interpretation of the results and leads to conclusions about the effect of the applied microclimate on the hygrothermal performance of the monument due to the built shelter.

5.2. Hygrothermal Computer Programs

Many software programs have been developed for hygrothermal simulation. Until 2010 more than 57 hygrothermal software programs existed; see Table 2 [64].
Hejazi et al. [64] compared results from WUFI® and DELPHIN programs for three different materials and concluded that the results obtained are very close, except for total water content during the wetting period. Mundt-Petersen and Harderup [65] compared results from WUFI® and DELPHIN for the risk of mold growth.
Delgado et al. [66,67,68] used the DELPHIN [69] program to verify the WUFI® program [70] and concluded that DELPHIN gives more realistic results for moisture.
WUFI® is a family of software products that allows realistic calculation of the transient coupled one- and two-dimensional heat and moisture transport in walls and other multi-layer building components exposed to natural weather. WUFI® is an acronym for Wärme Und Feuchte Instationär, which, translated, means heat and moisture transiency.
WUFI® has four products: WUFI® Pro is used for one-dimensional analysis of building components under predefined indoor climates, WUFI® 2D for two-dimensional analyses, WUFI® Plus for analyzing energy usage and interior comfort, and WUFI® Passive has the same energy usage capabilities as WUFI® Plus, but it also enables optimization of ‘passive house’ design by providing monthly energy balances [70].

Example of an Application of the Simulation Software WUFI® Pro

The software WUFI® Pro is a one-dimensional program that determines the content of the moisture in the building elements as well as its transfer. It also determines the simultaneous transfer of heat through the building components. This program solves numerically a set of partial differential equations—Equations (1) and (2)—and has been validated repeatedly [71,72,73,74].
Equation (1). Heat transport
∂ H ∂ θ ∂ θ ∂ t = ∂ ∂ x ( λ ∂ θ ∂ x ) + h v ∂ ∂ x ( δ μ ∂ p ∂ x )
Equation (2). Moisture transport
ρ w ∂ u ∂ ϕ ∂ ϕ ∂ t = ∂ ∂ x ( ρ w D w ∂ u ∂ ϕ ∂ ϕ ∂ x ) + ∂ ∂ x ( δ μ ∂ p ∂ x ) )
where
Dw [m2/s] is the liquid transport coefficient
H [J/m3] the enthalpy of moist building material
Hυ [J/kg] the evaporation enthalpy of water
p [Pa] the water vapor partial pressure
u [kg/m3] the water content
δ [kg/msPa] the water vapor diffusion coefficient in air (kg·s−1·m−2·Pa−1)
θ [°C] the temperature
λ [W/mK] the heat conductivity of moist material
μ [-] the vapor diffusion resistance factor of dry material
ρw [kg/m3] the water density
φ [-] the relative humidity.
The software WUFI® generates geometric representations of the component under study.
The section of the building component unit introduced in the simulation tool is presented in the following Figure 13. Then the output of the program consists of diagrams showing the variation of temperature, the humidity percentage, and the water content, as well as the evolution of fluxes during one year [75].
Figure 13. (a) Profile of the building element created in the simulation software; (b) output showing the variation of water content inside the building element, created in the simulation environment WUFI©Pro 4.1 (from [48]). The diagram shows that the water content increases during the condensation period.
It should be stressed that the diagrams for Macedonian tombs, presented earlier in Figure 10, were obtained by us with the use of the methodology described here.
The export data of the simulation program are numerical data and diagrams, presenting the following:
  • The variation of temperature and relative humidity in the interior of the exposed building elements.
  • The water content evolution in the mass.
  • The condensation period.
  • The heat fluxes in the mass.
  • The moisture fluxes in the mass.
  • The air pressure evolution.
The range of fluctuations inside the monuments depends on [48]:
  • The dimensions of the interior (volume).
  • The size of the tumulus.
  • The degree of excavation and exposure of the structural body to the external environment.
  • The type of protection shelters constructed.
Further research must be completed to identify deterioration processes taking place. Energy dissipation in structural materials under the action of general stress and strain histories has been dealt with in detail in Panoskaltsis, (2025) [76].

5.3. Decision-Making in the Case Studies

In order to protect and preserve the subterranean monuments, we should establish stable hygrothermal conditions by implementing the following actions.
These were applied in case studies presented in Section 3.

5.3.1. Procedures Throughout the Excavation Process

Provisional protective actions are required at the entrance to the monument throughout the excavation phase.
These measures are intended to prevent air circulation in front of the monument’s entrance, as well as to stabilize temperature and relative humidity inside.
This can be accomplished by a second room before the monument’s gateway to reduce air exchange. Adding thermal insulation could further reduce the impact of the external climatic conditions [3,48].

5.3.2. Actions to Control the Microclimate

The following are recommended. See for more details [3,48].
–
A shelter must ensure the control of microclimate conditions and their correct setting to provide protection from humidity, temperature, and other effects.
–
The choice of shelter design influences to a great degree the internal climatic conditions as well as the cost of supplementary control systems.
–
Thermal insulation of the shelter is needed in order to protect the enclosure from overheating in the summer and frost in the winter.
–
A double entrance for the shelter is needed—so that one door will be closed when the other opens—in order to minimize the air exchanges.
–
In the case of mechanical systems operating—in order to regulate the variations in temperature and relative humidity—energy consumption should be taken into account. Additionally, constant maintenance and good functioning should be ensured.
–
Energy consumption may also be influenced by modifications in the adjacent environment.
In order to alter microclimatic conditions outside the shelter, proper planting and artificial barriers may be used for shading and also for changing the direction and speed of the winds.
Shelter design, climate control, and access policies must therefore be site-specific, reversible, and informed by long-term empirical data.
Across regions and monument types, the literature converges on a central principle: successful conservation of subterranean heritage depends on respecting existing microclimatic equilibria while minimizing anthropogenic disturbance.

6. Identifying Current Gaps, Limitations, and Challenges

This section identifies current gaps in literature and limitations in existing approaches. It addresses methodological constraints, data availability issues, limitations of simulation models, and challenges in implementation.
Research on the themes presented above involves interdisciplinary scientific subjects and additionally, field research. Therefore, there exist limitations to its course. These may be either technical and practical issues or gaps in knowledge concerning lack of data for material properties as well as weather conditions.
Other limitations are the following:
  • The complexity of physical interactions.
  • The human factor, i.e., the right use of the software and the correct interpretation of the calculation results.
All these are analyzed in more detail in the following subsections.

6.1. Technical Limitations

The electronic equipment may provide incorrect measurements in case they have not been calibrated. The recorders may not have adequate data input channels, so simultaneous recordings may be restricted. Additionally, there may be data gaps due to the limited memory of the recorders. Also, the recording must be temporarily paused in order to check the instruments’ calibration.
The simulation program also has limitations concerning the criteria for choosing the specific simulation tool. It should be user-friendly and also commercially available. It must have been validated by comparison with experimental results [64]. The results should be checked for plausibility. Some possible problems are input errors, e.g., insufficient knowledge of the required data, and program errors (convergence failures; convergence during all calculations must be checked to be zero [67]). Additional problems are insufficient knowledge of the required data, limitations of the underlying mathematical model, and numerical problems [67]. Clearly, a correct model of the building element must be created in the program. It is essential that reliable outdoor climate boundary conditions be used. Calculations must be made using real climate conditions because there are significant outdoor climate variations between different years that affect the results. Differences in temperature can have a great effect on relative humidity.
The properties of materials used as input to the program is a difficult task since there is a significant lack of data related to the hygrothermal properties of ancient materials. In addition, the materials’ properties change over time and under different conditions, especially when they have been buried under the soil for centuries. Material data may be taken from laboratory testing. In case of material unavailability from the monument or of laboratory limitations, data may be taken from the program’s database [67,69,70].
As discussed by Camuffo [60], laboratory-scale investigations remain essential but must be adapted to heritage constraints, favoring small-sample sorption tests, pore-structure characterization, and moisture-dependent thermal measurements. However, laboratory-derived values should be interpreted as effective rather than intrinsic properties, owing to the heterogeneity, aging, and alteration of historic materials.

6.2. Interpretation of the Calculation Results

The correct interpretation of the exported data is very important. A very good knowledge of the software and also an excellent understanding of the mathematical equations are needed to avoid wrong conclusions.

6.3. Unpredictable Constraints

Extreme weather conditions and lack of appropriate arrangements at the archaeological sites could be the reasons to interrupt the recordings and lose important data.
Additionally, the uncontrolled entry of workers and visitors into the monuments may alter the recordings’ readings.

6.4. Gaps of Knowledge and Conclusions

The above limitations and gaps are not equally problematic. Some of them, such as weather data, could be available from national meteorological stations. Others, such as the properties of ancient materials, require extensive research and laboratory testing. The interactions of moisture with other agents and its impact on human health are issues so complex that high levels of uncertainty still remain in this scientific area.
An updated framework for the assessment of the monument’s hygrothermal behavior should therefore be incorporated into the design, construction, and use procedures. Regulations and standards should be improved as knowledge increases rapidly in the scientific area of building physics. Corresponding standards include ISO13788-2012 [12] EN 16893-2018 [77], EN 15757-2010 [78], and ASHRAE Guideline 34-2019 [79].

7. Conclusions and Future Research Directions

This section outlines potential directions for future research, based on the gaps previously identified. The following important points were made:
–
Decoding concerns the analysis of the hygrothermal behavior of the monuments, and this should be the basis for decision-making in order to protect and safeguard the built heritage from climate change.
–
Numerical simulation is a necessary and effective tool to decode the microclimate inside subterranean monuments.
–
An evaluation methodology based on computer simulation is needed. The steps of the methodology are data collection, computer simulation, analysis, and interpretation of the results. This way, the decision-makers will decide, having a full understanding of the monument’s hygrothermal behavior and of its deterioration factors’ contribution.
–
There should be a systematic investigation of the deterioration of the subterranean monuments as a result of human carelessness, abandonment, and environmental conditions.
–
Evidence remains fragmented and site-specific, indicating a research gap in comparative climate change assessments.
–
Further scientific research should be performed on the topic of the built heritage adaptation to climate change. The UNESCO SDGs (Sustainable Development Goals) included the preservation of built heritage in Goal 11.
–
The adaptation to climate change identifies four main categories of adaptation measures: technological, behavioral, managerial, and policy. Each one should be further investigated with scientific tools.
–
In order to increase the resilience of heritage sites, there is a need to upgrade management plans, including risk assessments and monitoring procedures. Resilience has to do with the risk of loss. However, risk in the case of built heritage does not only measure tangible phenomena, e.g., natural disasters, collapse during an earthquake, or the gradual erosion of a wall, which are only half of the risk. The consequences depend on intangible phenomena too, such as loss of value, integrity, and authenticity. Identifying and assessing the risks is a crucial step towards the resilience of cultural heritage sites.
–
There is a need for practical solutions and tools for the incorporation of climate change adaptation in the preservation and management of cultural heritage. Case studies of best practice are needed, both in managerial and decisional aspects.
–
It is essential that interdisciplinary research involving different scientific specialties be done.
–
Energy efficiency, minimized consumption, zero energy shelters, on-site renewable energy production, and distance energy supply are major issues that should be addressed as quickly as possible. Legislation and policies should be updated in order to support these new challenges in the field of built heritage preservation.
–
The impact of shelters is complex; therefore, continuous studies and monitoring are crucial for a long-term assessment.
–
A great challenge to be addressed nowadays is the use of information and communications technology (ICT), i.e., long-distance monitoring, wireless sensor networks, smart management systems, and virtual reality.
–
Finally, monumental and depicted subterranean heritage constructions should be included in the list of UNESCO World Heritage Sites because of their unique and outstanding universal value.

Author Contributions

The authors have contributed equally on all aspects of this publication. All authors have read and agreed to the published version of the manuscript.

Funding

This paper did not receive any funding.

Data Availability Statement

No new data were created or analyzed in this study.

Conflicts of Interest

The authors declare no conflicts of interest.

Correction Statement

This article has been republished with a minor correction to improve its formatting. This change does not affect the scientific content of the article.

References

  1. Kyriakou, V.; Panoskaltsis, V.P. Shelters for monuments: Contribution to sustainable management and future heritage preservation. In Proceedings of the 8th International Conference EinB2019—Energy in Buildings, Athens, Greece, 28 September 2019; Available online: https://www.ashrae.gr/einb2019.php (accessed on 30 March 2026).
  2. Sustainable Development Goals. Available online: https://sdgs.un.org/goals (accessed on 30 March 2026).
  3. Kyriakou, V.; Panoskaltsis, V.P. Sustainable management approaches for underground heritage structures threatened by the environment and the human presence. World Rev. Sci. Technol. Sustain. Dev. 2021, 17, 23–53. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  4. Appelbaum, B. Guide to Environmental Protection of Collections; Sound View Press: Madison, CT, USA, 1991. [Google Scholar]
  5. Massari, G.; Massari, I. Damp Buildings, Old and New. Bull. Assoc. Preserv. Technol. 1985, 17, 2–30. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  6. Vos, H.B. The Deterioration and Conservation of Stone in Fundamentals of Heat and Moisture Transfer; UNESCO: Venezia, Italy, 1988. [Google Scholar]
  7. Yan, W.; Cudmani, R. A general analytical expression for pore size distribution based on probability theory. Eng. Geol. 2022, 297, 106501. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  8. Sekino, M. A review on the conservation of ornamented tumuli. In Proceedings of the International Symposium on the Conservation and Restoration of Cultural Property, Tokyo, Japan, 17–21 November 1983; pp. 217–228. [Google Scholar]
  9. Ginouvès, R. Macedonia: From Philip II to the Roman Conquest; Princeton University Press: Princeton, NJ, USA, 1994; pp. 178–181. ISBN 0-691-03635-7. [Google Scholar]
  10. Michalski, S. Incorrect Relative Humidity. Available online: https://www.canada.ca/en/conservation-institute/services/agents-deterioration/humidity.html (accessed on 30 March 2026).
  11. Michalski, S. Incorrect Temperature. Available online: https://www.canada.ca/en/conservation-institute/services/agents-deterioration/temperature.html (accessed on 30 March 2026).
  12. ISO 13788:2012; Hygrothermal Performance of Building Components and Building Elements—Internal Surface Temperature to Avoid Critical Surface Humidity and Interstitial Condensation—Calculation Methods. ISO: Geneva, Switzerland, 2012. Available online: https://www.iso.org/standard/51615.html (accessed on 30 March 2026).
  13. Thomson, G. The Museum Environment, 2nd ed.; Butterworth-Heinemann: London, UK, 1986. [Google Scholar]
  14. Michalski, S. The Ideal Climate, Risk Management, and Prices. In Proceedings of the ICOM-CC Expert Meeting on Museum Microclimates, Copenhagen, Denmark, 19–23 November 2007. [Google Scholar]
  15. Lucchi, E. Multidisciplinary risk-based analysis for supporting the decision-making process on conservation, energy efficiency, and human comfort in museum buildings. J. Cult. Herit. 2016, 22, 1079–1089. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  16. ICCROM, International Centre for the Study of Preservation and Restoration of Cultural Property. Teamwork for Preventive Conservation; ICCROM: Roma, Italy, 2004. [Google Scholar]
  17. Eco, U. (Ed.) Idee per un museo. In La Memoria Esposta. Esposizioni e Musei; Mondadori Editore: Milano, Italy, 1986; pp. 55–60. [Google Scholar]
  18. Davies, D. The Museum Transformed: Design and Culture in the Post-Pompidou Age; Abbeville Press: New York, NY, USA, 1990. [Google Scholar]
  19. IIC and ICOM-CC 2014 Declaration on Environmental Guidelines. Available online: https://www.iiconservation.org/archives/about/policy-statements/environmental-guidelines (accessed on 30 March 2026).
  20. Plenterleith, H.J.; Werner, A.E.A. The Conservation of Antiquities and Works of Art: Treatment, Repair and Restoration; Oxford University Press: Oxford, UK, 1972. [Google Scholar]
  21. Michalski, S. Relative humidity: A discussion of correct/incorrect values. In Proceedings of the 10th Triennial Meeting, ICOM Committee for Conservation, Washington, DC, USA, 22–27 August 1993; pp. 624–629. [Google Scholar]
  22. Becherini, F.; Bernardi, A.; Frassoldati, E. Microclimate inside a semi-confined environment: Valuation of suitability for the conservation of heritage materials. J. Cult. Herit. 2010, 11, 471–476. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  23. Scatigno, C.; Gaudenzi, S.; Sammartino, M.; Visco, G. A microclimate study on hypogea environments of ancient roman building. Sci. Total Environ. 2016, 566–567, 298–305. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit] [PubMed]
  24. Kim, S.H.; Lee, C.H. Interpretation on internal microclimatic characteristics and thermal environment Interpretation on internal microclimatic characteristics and thermal environment stability of the royal tombs at Songsanri in Gongju, Korea. J. Conserv. Sci. 2019, 35, 99–115. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  25. Kyriakou, V.; Panoskaltsis, V.P. Constructing sustainable shelters to safeguard monuments from climate change. Environ. Sci. Proc. 2022, 15, 42. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  26. Frasca, F.; Verticchio, E.; Caratelli, A.; Bertolin, C.; Camuffo, D.; Siani, A.M. A Comprehensive Study of the Microclimate-Induced Conservation Risks in Hypogeal Sites: The Mithraeum of the Baths of Caracalla (Rome). Sensors 2020, 20, 3310. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  27. Zicarelli, M.A.; Ricca, M.; Ruffolo, S.A.; Greca, R.; La Russa, M.F. Preventive conservation of the pictorial evidence in the church of Sotterra (Paola, Italy): A microclimatic investigation in a hypogeum environment. In Proceedings of the 2023 IMEKO TC-4 International Conference on Metrology for Archaeology and Cultural Heritage, Rome, Italy, 19–21 October 2023; Available online: https://www.imeko.org/publications/tc4-Archaeo-2023/IMEKO-MetroArchaeo-2023-147.pdf (accessed on 30 March 2026).
  28. Xia, C.; Kong, Z.; Su, B.; Xie, H.; Mu, B.; Hokoi, S.; Li, Y. Tomb murals conservation in humid regions: Hybrid passive-active systems for salt crystallization and condensation mitigation. npj Herit. Sci. 2025, 13, 570. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  29. Hu, X.; Wu, R.; Li, Y.; Xie, H.; Zhang, Z.; Hokoi, S.; Su, B. Impact of opening the entrance on cave temple murals in different climate zones for preventive conservation. npj Herit. Sci. 2025, 13, 100. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  30. Choi, I.K.; Lee, C.H. Microscale movements of an ancient Korean Royal Tomb in Gongju based on environmental changes. Microscale movements of an ancient Korean Royal Tomb in Gongju based on environmental changes. npj Herit. Sci. 2025, 13, 276. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  31. Barov, Z. Thracian painted tombs: Technical notes and conservation procedures. In Proceedings of the International Symposium on the Conservation and Restoration of Cultural Property, Tokyo, Japan, 17–21 November 1983; pp. 197–215. [Google Scholar]
  32. Kadiiski, T. Methodology for control of the microclimate in the Thracian tomb near the village of Svestari. In 2nd International Conference on Non-Destructive Testing, Microanalytical Methods and Environment Evaluation for Study and Conservation of Works of Art, Perugia, Italy, 17–20 April 1988; Istituto Centrale Per Il Restauro—Associazione Italiana Prove Non Distruttive: Rome, Italy, 1988; pp. 10.1–10.10. [Google Scholar]
  33. Wilson, K.M.; Burns, Y.G. The stability of the tomb of Nefertari 1904–1987. Stud. Conserv. 1989, 34, 153–170. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  34. Preusser, F. Scientific and Technical Examination of the Tomb of Queen Nefertari at Thebes. In Proceedings of the Conservation of Wall Paintings, London, UK, 13–16 July 1987. [Google Scholar]
  35. Maekawa, S.; Preusser, F. Environmental monitoring at the tomb of Nefertari. In 10th Triennial Meeting, ICOM Committee for Conservation, Washington, DC, USA, 22–27 August 1993; ICOM Committee for Conservation: Paris, France; Allen Press: Lawrence, KS, USA, 1993; pp. 616–623. Available online: https://archive.org/details/gri_33125011598790 (accessed on 30 March 2026).
  36. Fassina, V.; Stevan, G.A. Le operazioni di environmental-monitoring-at-the-tomb-of-nefertari-washington?_lg=en-US# diagnosi relative agli aspetti igrometrici degli edifici storici. In Proceedings of the Il Cantiere della Conoscenza, Il Cantiere del Restauro, Atti del Convegno di Studi, Bressanone, Italy, 27–30 June 1989; Available online: https://www.lrmh.fr/Default/doc/SYRACUSE/67049/ (accessed on 30 March 2026).
  37. Bettini, G.; Massa, S. Preservation problems. Visitors and deterioration on the painted Etruscan tombs. In Proceedings of the European Symposium Science, Technology and European Cultural Heritage, Bologna, Italy, 13–16 June 1989. [Google Scholar]
  38. De Carli, P.; Massa, S.; Nichi, D. Conservative control of an archaeological excavation. The Tomb of Demoni Azzurri of Tarquinia. In Proceedings of the European Symposium Science, Technology and European Cultural Heritage, Bologna, Italy, 13–16 June 1989. [Google Scholar]
  39. Miyake, S. Preservation facilities for the tumulus Takamatsuzuka. In Proceedings of the International Symposium on the Conservation and Restoration of Cultural Property, Tokyo, Japan, 17–21 November 1983; pp. 87–103. [Google Scholar]
  40. Inokuma, K. Excavation and short historical survey of Takamatsuzuka ancient tumulus. In Proceedings of the International Symposium on the Conservation and Restoration of Cultural Property, Tokyo, Japan, 17–21 November 1983; pp. 83–86. [Google Scholar]
  41. Miura, S.; Saito, H. Temperature and humidity in the tumulus Takamatsuzuka. In Proceedings of the International Symposium on the Conservation and Restoration of Cultural Property, Tokyo, Japan, 17–21 November 1983; pp. 105–115. [Google Scholar]
  42. Miller, S. Macedonian Tombs: Their Architecture and Architectural Decoration. Stud. Hist. Art 1982, 10, 153–171. [Google Scholar]
  43. Tsimbidou-Avlonitou, M. The Macedonian Tombs at Phoinikas and Aghios Athanassios (Thessaloniki/Greece): Two astonishing funerary monuments of the 4th c. BC. In Interior Decoration in the Eastern Mediterranean During Hellenistic and Roman Times. Mosaics, Paintings, Iconography, Materials, Techniques and Conservation; NARNIA Project Training Course; University of Nanterre: Nanterre, France, 2013. [Google Scholar]
  44. Macridy, T. Un tumulus Macedonien a Langaza. In Sonderabdruck aus dem Jahrbuch des Kaiserlich Archaeologischen Instituts; Georg Reimer: Berlin, Germany, 1911; Band XXVI. [Google Scholar]
  45. Hammond, N.G.L. The Royal Tombs at Vergina: Evolution and identities. Annu. Br. Sch. Athens 1991, 86, 69–82. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  46. Dimakopoulos, I. Protective shells in the form of a tumulus. In An Archaeological and Museum Structure in the Type of a Crypt; Ministry of Culture, Directorate of Restoration: Athens, Greece, 1993. (In Greek) [Google Scholar]
  47. Zaglaniki, L. Preliminary Design of a Shelter for the Protection of the Royal Tombs of Vergina and the Restoration of their Tumulus. In Restoration—Conservation—Protection of Monuments and Sites; Volume B; Ministry of Culture: Athens, Greece, 1987. (In Greek) [Google Scholar]
  48. Kyriakou, V. Numerical Study of the Heat and Moisture Transfer in Subterranean Historic Structures and Regulation of the Conditions for Protection and Sustainable Management. Ph.D. Dissertation, Demokritos University of Thrace, Xanthi, Greece, 11 June 2020. Available online: https://www.didaktorika.gr/eadd/handle/10442/47623 (accessed on 30 March 2026).
  49. Kyriakou, V.; Panoskaltsis, V.P. Hygrothermal performance in underground heritage structures and issues related to their conservation. IJSTRE—Int. J. Sci. Tech. Res. Eng. 2019, 4, 42–50. [Google Scholar]
  50. UNESCO—World Heritage and Sustainable Development. Available online: https://whc.unesco.org/en/sustainabledevelopment/ (accessed on 30 March 2026).
  51. National Park Service. National Park Service Climate Change Response Strategy. In National Park Service Climate Change Response Program; National Park Service: Fort Collins, CO, USA, 2010. [Google Scholar]
  52. Matthew, R.; Star, J. Using Scenarios to Explore Climate Change: A Handbook for Practitioners; Climate Change Response Program; National Park Service: Fort Collins, CO, USA, 2013. [Google Scholar]
  53. Sabbioni, C.; Brimblecombe, P.; Cassar, M.; Noah’s Ark (Project). The Atlas of Climate Change Impact on European Cultural Heritage: Scientific Analysis and Management Strategies; Anthem: New York, NY, USA, 2012. [Google Scholar]
  54. Judson, P.; Iyerraniga, U.; Wong James, P.C.; Horne, R. Integrating built heritage and sustainable development: Can assessment tools be used to understand the environmental performance of existing buildings with heritage significance? In Proceedings of the Facing the Challenges—Building the Capacity: FIG Congress, Sydney, Australia, 11–16 April 2010. [Google Scholar]
  55. Markham, A.; Osipova, E.; Lafrenz Samuels, K.; Caldas, A. World Heritage and Tourism in a Changing Climate; United Nations Environment Program; UNESCO Publishing: Paris, France, 2016. [Google Scholar]
  56. Sesana, E.; Gagnon, A.S.; Bertolin, C.; Hughes, J. Adapting cultural heritage to climate change risks: Perspectives of cultural heritage experts in Europe. Geosciences 2018, 8, 305. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  57. Cassar, M. Climate Change and the Historic Environment; Research report; Centre for Sustainable Heritage, University College London: London, UK, 2005; Available online: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/32886503_Climate_Change_and_the_Historic_Environment (accessed on 30 March 2026).
  58. Cassar, M. Environmental Management: Guidelines for Museums and Galleries; Routledge: London, UK; New York, NY, USA, 1995. [Google Scholar]
  59. The IPPC Directive. European Community (EC) directive 2008/1/EC. Available online: https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/media/5a79cd0940f0b670a8025856/pb13634-ep2010ippc.pdf (accessed on 30 March 2026).
  60. Camuffo, D. Microclimate for Cultural Heritage; Elsevier: Amsterdam, The Netherlands, 2014. [Google Scholar]
  61. Sesana, E.; Gagnon, A.S.; Ciantelli, C.; Cassar, J.; Hughes, J.J. Climate change impacts on cultural heritage: A systematic literature review. Wiley Interdiscip. Rev. Clim. Change 2021, 12, e710. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  62. Badino, G. Underground meteorology—What’s the weather underground? Acta Carsologica 2010, 39, 427–448. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  63. Cardinale, N.; Rospi, G.; Stazi, A. Energy and microclimatic performance of underground historic buildings. Energy Build. 2010, 42, 2040–2050. [Google Scholar]
  64. Hejazi, B.; Sakiyama, N.R.M.; Frick, J.; Garrecht, H. Hygrothermal Simulations Comparative Study: Assessment of Different Materials Using WUFI and DELPHIN Software. Build. Simul. Conf. Proc. 2019, 7, 4674–4681. Available online: https://publications.ibpsa.org/proceedings/bs/2019/papers/BS2019_211033.pdf (accessed on 30 March 2026).
  65. Mundt-Petersen, S.O.; Harderup, L.E. Validation of a One-Dimensional Transient Heat and Moisture Calculation Tool under Real Conditions. In Proceedings of the XII International Conference Thermal Performance of the Exterior Envelopes of Whole Buildings, Clearwater, FL, USA, 1–5 December 2013. [Google Scholar]
  66. Delgado, J.M.; Ramos, N.M.; Barreira, E.; De Freitas, V.P. A critical review of hygrothermal models used in porous building materials. J. Porous Media 2010, 13, 221–234. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  67. Delgado, J.M.; Barreira, E.; Ramos, N.M.; de Freitas, V.P. Hygrothermal Numerical Simulation Tools Applied to Building Physics; Springer Science and Business Media: Berlin, Germany, 2012. [Google Scholar]
  68. Delgado, J.M.; Barreira, E.; Ramos, N.M.M.; de Freitas, V.P. Hygrothermal Simulation Tools. In Hygrothermal Numerical Simulation Tools Applied to Building Physics; Springer Briefs in Applied Sciences and Technology; Springer: Berlin/Heidelberg, Germany, 2013. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  69. DELPHIN Software. 2018. Available online: https://bauklimatik-dresden.de/en/software/delphin/ (accessed on 30 March 2026).
  70. WUFI® The Department of Hygrothermics at Fraunhofer IBP. Available online: https://wufi.de/en/about-us/fraunhofer-institute-for-building-physics/ (accessed on 30 March 2026).
  71. Künzel, H.M. Verfahren Zurein und Zweidimensionalen Berechnung des Gekoppelten Wärme und Feuchtetransports in Bauteilen mit Einfachen Kennwerten. PhD Dissertation, Universität Stuttgart, Stuttgart, Germany, 1994. (In German) Available online: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/260028324_Verfahren_zur_ein-und_zweidimensionalen_Berechnung_des_gekoppelten_Warme-und_Feuchtetransports_in_Bauteilen_mit_einfachen_Kennwerten_PhD_thesis_Universitat_Stuttgart (accessed on 30 March 2026).
  72. Künzel, H.M. Simultaneous Heat and Moisture Transport in Building Components. One and Two-Dimensional Calculation Using Simple Parameters; IBP: Stuttgart, Germany, 1995. [Google Scholar]
  73. Künzel, H.M.; Kiessl, K. Calculation of heat and moisture transfer in exposed building components. Int. J. Heat Mass Transf. 1996, 40, 159–167. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  74. Schmidt, T.; Holm, A. Exterior surface temperature of different wall constructions—Comparison of numerical simulation and experiment. In Proceedings of the 11th Symposium for Building Physics, Dresden, Germany, 26–30 September 2002; pp. 441–449. [Google Scholar]
  75. WUFI® Manual. Available online: https://wufi.de/en/service/downloads/ (accessed on 30 March 2026).
  76. Panoskaltsis, V.P. Energy Dissipation in Engineering Materials and Structures by Using the Laws of Thermodynamics. Thermo 2025, 5, 20. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  77. BS EN 16893:2018; Conservation of Cultural Heritage. Specifications for Location, Construction and Modification of Buildings or Rooms Intended for the Storage or Use of Heritage Collections. BSI Group: London, UK, 2018. Available online: https://www.en-standard.eu/bs-en-16893-2018-conservation-of-cultural-heritage-specifications-for-location-construction-and-modification-of-buildings-or-rooms-intended-for-the-storage-or-use-of-heritage-collections/ (accessed on 4 April 2026).
  78. BS EN 15757-2010; Conservation of Cultural Property. Specifications for Temperature and Relative Humidity to Limit Climate-induced Me-chanical Damage in Organic Hygroscopic Materials. BSI Group: London, UK, 2010. Available online: https://knowledge.bsigroup.com/products/conservation-of-cultural-property-specifications-for-temperature-and-relative-humidity-to-limit-climate-induced-mechanical-damage-in-organic-hygroscopic-materials (accessed on 4 April 2026). [CrossRef] [Scilit]
  79. ASHRAE Guideline 34-2019, Energy Guideline for Historic Buildings. Available online: https://www.ashrae.org/news/esociety/preserving-historic-buildings-saving-energy (accessed on 4 April 2026).
Disclaimer/Publisher’s Note: The statements, opinions and data contained in all publications are solely those of the individual author(s) and contributor(s) and not of MDPI and/or the editor(s). MDPI and/or the editor(s) disclaim responsibility for any injury to people or property resulting from any ideas, methods, instructions or products referred to in the content.

Article Metrics

Citations

Article Access Statistics

Multiple requests from the same IP address are counted as one view.