1. Introduction
Bread wheat (
Triticum aestivum L.) is a major staple cereal adapted to diverse climatic conditions, largely due to its high genetic diversity (it has experienced intensive natural and artificial selection in history), while also serving as a primary source of energy and protein in the human diet worldwide [
1]. Wheat alone provides around 20% of the total calories and protein consumed worldwide, and the three major cereals—wheat, rice, and maize—together account for almost 60% of the calories consumed each day [
2]. However, in recent years, climate change has caused a significant decline in the production and quality potential of these important plants, which could pose a problem for food safety. Climate change poses severe constraints on agricultural production in Europe and Asia by intensifying heat and drought stress, increasing rainfall variability, and amplifying extreme weather events. These pressures lead to significant crop yield losses, reduced water availability, and damage to agricultural land and infrastructure, while ecosystem disruptions further limit the adaptive capacity of cropping systems [
3]. Similar to other crops, wheat also faces a decrease in production level because of extreme climate events (e.g., heat waves, drought, and floods) [
4,
5,
6]. Future projections show that the Mediterranean region is particularly sensitive to climate change, and the possible decrease in precipitation in coastal parts of Türkiye is higher than in other regions [
7]. In addition, almost all the Mediterranean regions already experience drought repeatedly each year, and the frequency and intensity of drought seasons are expected to increase, which highlights the urgent need for crop–climate adaptation strategies [
8]. Drought in winter cereals most often occurs after the consumption of the winter water supply and the need for rainfall occurs when plants have the largest leaf area and increasing transpiration during the most critical generative growth stages (stem elongation, heading, and grain-filling periods) to maintain optimal yield and quality. During the crucial stages, low rainfall and high evapotranspiration due to high temperatures cause plants to be unable to draw sufficient water from the soil to transpire it. The stomata close, reducing photosynthesis and insufficiently cooling the plant surface, which results in stress in plants, and thus causes reduced productivity [
9,
10].
Field studies of wheat yield variability have shown that drought stress at 50% field capacity markedly reduced plant height and growth indices (biomass accumulation, days to maturity, and grain-filling period) and forced earlier maturity/phenological shortening across genotypes. Drought stress at stem elongation and anthesis causes yield reduction of approximately 14–25% compared with irrigated crops. Heading and grain filling are the growth periods most sensitive to drought stress, especially in late sowing [
11]. In addition to these periods, delayed flowering and late sowing increase the risk of adverse effects on wheat caused by terminal drought, which poses a threat to productivity [
12,
13]. Drought stress shows similar adverse effects on grain number set and grain mass as high temperature occurring before and post-anthesis, and the grain mass is reduced with higher temperature conditions due to remobilization of assimilates at a faster rate and shortened grain-filling duration [
14]. Early heading/anthesis, early sowing, maintaining stay-green duration (delayed senescence), and optimal development durations of post-anthesis stages are the main drought escape strategies for improving wheat potential [
15,
16,
17,
18]. In another drought escape strategy, deeper root development was found to potentially enable subsoil water to maintain a stay-green genotype and produce higher yield per plant under moderate water stress [
19]. In addition to all these strategies, drought tolerance is a complex multi-trait quantitative plant characteristic. High genotype and environment interactions and low heritability are responsible for drought tolerance, which is controlled by numerous genes and other plant traits [
20]. The adverse changes observed in yield formation due to drought and heat stress do not occur to the same extent for grain and functional quality; on the contrary, they lead to significant positive changes in quality characteristics [
21]. The concurrence of limited water availability and elevated spring temperatures leads to drought stress in wheat, together with key environmental stress conditions. Pre-heading drought treatments were found to be more related to yield and physico-morphological traits while post-heading drought had a greater effect on quality traits [
22].
Mediterranean climates cause differential genotypic responses that affect grain quality in addition to yield formation. Under drought conditions, the anthesis period is a key window for spike fertility and grain set (via complete or partial sterility of florets/grain set), whereas post-anthesis drought during the grain-filling period strongly modulates grain composition and technological and functional quality traits [
23,
24]. It has been reported that high temperature conditions (>35 °C) may alter flour and baking quality, and moderate temperature (25–32 °C) has a positive effect on dough quality [
25,
26]. On the other hand, while moderate stress enhances grain quality traits (improves bread-making quality by increasing protein content), severe drought stress conditions cause quality (protein, gluten rate, and sedimentation value) reductions. It has been demonstrated that extremes of high temperature and water-limited conditions during the grain-filling period result in substantial detrimental effects on grain quality, thereby exerting a considerable influence on the final quality of the product. This situation clearly demonstrates the crucial importance of an understanding of environmental stress factors [
27]. Water limitation is also found to be directly linked to changes in storage protein synthesis/gluten structure and bread-making quality [
28,
29]. Gluten structure is determined by storage proteins (gliadin/glutenin) that accumulate during the grain-filling period. A shortened grain-filling period in response to a short period of heat stress has been linked to increased gliadin/glutenin ratio results with weak dough properties [
30,
31]. Drought stress is known to increase the protein content of grain and reduce carbohydrate content (including starch), but this effect is highly dependent on the timing and duration of water-limited conditions and their interactions with other environmental stress conditions [
32]. Additionally, insufficient water availability in the grain-filling period can also result in decreased protein content value, and water stress during this period can lead to smaller and lighter grains, which may reduce overall physical and chemical quality [
33].
Aside from the nutritional and technological quality properties of wheat grain, it also has unique biochemical compounds that have health-promoting properties. Whole-grain products are well known to be rich in phenolic compounds, which are primarily concentrated in the outer layers of grain, such as aleurone, testa, and pericarp [
34,
35]. White flour is the preferred usage product for bakeries; however, the process of milling removes the bran fraction, which is the primary reservoir of phenolic compounds. Consequently, the phenolic content declines markedly with increasing refinement from whole grain to white flour due to these compounds being concentrated in the outer grain layers. Beyond postharvest processing, the antioxidant activity of wheat grain is significantly influenced by genotype, agronomic practices (for example, organic versus conventional management, sowing date, fertilization, and crop protection), and environmental conditions [
36,
37]. Changes observed in yield and, as with many quality traits, due to environmental factors arising during generative growth stages, also affect the accumulation of biochemical compounds in grain content. Water deficiency in these periods causes changes in the synthesis of polyphenolic compounds and their derivatives, which are rich in antioxidants. Drought stress affecting wheat productivity by inducing biochemical changes is also responsible for the antioxidant defense system against stress conditions [
38,
39]. Water limitation during the grain-filling period has been demonstrated to modify the biochemical quality of wheat grains, frequently resulting in alterations to phenolic accumulation and antioxidant activity. In addition, phenolic compounds and antioxidant properties have been shown to shift under stress, with these shifts being mostly determined by environment and, secondly, by genotype [
34,
40].
The present study aims to conduct the following: (i) evaluate how drought stress occurring after heading and simulated changes in spring precipitation patterns influence the processes of yield and quality formation and possible challenges in the future; (ii) examine how post-heading drought significantly modifies multiple evaluated grain quality traits (nutritional, functional, and technological properties); (iii) examine the exact responses of different adaptive and developmental characteristics of bread wheat genotypes for yield and quality relationships under drought and rainfed conditions; (iv) elucidate the relationships between these traits and their association with post-heading drought stress under changing climatic conditions by multivariate analyses.
4. Discussion
In Mediterranean climates, recent climatic changes have had an adverse effect on winter cereal production as a result of annual precipitation reduction. This is due to increased precipitation variability in spring and altered seasonal distribution of precipitation resulting from higher temperatures, with a progressive shift of winter rainfall toward spring [
50,
51,
52]. Consequently, water stress during wheat reproductive stages has increased, leading farmers to rely more on supplemental spring irrigation. Water limitation and drought stress adversely affect photosynthetic efficiency, nutrient uptake, and support assimilate transfer to grains of wheat. This situation results with plant senescence and, in particular, has detrimental effects on generative growth periods, such as anthesis and grain-filling periods leading to lower grain yield [
53,
54]. The results of this study suggest that post-heading drought conditions adversely affect wheat yield formation and reduced flag leaf chlorophyll content resulted in grain yield reduction. The findings indicate that, under drought conditions, grain yield decreased from 54.4 (dt/ha) to 34.0 dt/ha, and the SPAD value decreased from 42.3 to 37.9, in comparison with the rainfed condition. During the anthesis period, the chlorophyll content of flag leaf is one of the most important factors affecting yield and decreases significantly under drought conditions. Changes in photosynthetic pigments under drought stress are a key indicator of photosynthesis and one of the fundamental elements affecting yield. In wheat, this is particularly associated with the flag leaf of wheat, as it is the most significant organ in this process and is responsible for 90% of the grain yield that is derived from photosynthetic production; moreover, the flag leaf is sensitive to drought stress, which causes flag leaf senescence [
55,
56]. Previous studies have shown that leaf chlorophyll concentration decreases by 9% under dry conditions, which has a negative effect on photosynthesis [
57].
According to PCA and correlation results, the yield formation and related yield components responsible for final yield value in drought condition, the CD, EY, TGW and TW parameters were found to be related to GY. Despite the occurrence of drought stress during the generative phase, CD and EY emerge as primary factors that determine wheat yield in dry conditions. This is primarily due to the fact that plant density exerts a significant regulatory influence on ear number, which constitutes a substantial component of final grain yield. Appropriate sowing density increases wheat grain yield and water productivity by promoting efficient use of limited rainfall and irrigation through greater crop transpiration [
58]. EY is another significant parameter in the formation of yield and is found to be considerably influenced by climatic conditions and stress conditions occurring between heading and flowering. The results obtained demonstrate a 19.3% decrease in the EY under the post-heading drought conditions. The PCA results revealed that, particularly under rainfed conditions, EY significantly contributed to the increase in grain yield values of the Ceyhan 99 and Tosunbey, including TW and GN. During the reproductive phases, exposure to drought and heat stress conditions reduces pollen viability and induces floret abortion, leading to declines in GN and final grain yield under water-limited conditions [
20,
59,
60]. Maintaining optimal GN and grain formation (weight) under drought stress is hypothesized to enhance wheat yield formation by supporting a higher number of ears per unit area. EY is also a robust (correlated with GY; r = 0.48 ***) trait for explaining final grain yield under drought conditions and was found to decrease in drought conditions by about 19.3% compared with rainfed conditions. In a previous study, it was revealed that positive relationships of grain weight, CD, spike length, chlorophyll index, grain filling duration, and GN with yield caused wheat genotypes to exhibit higher performance under drought stress [
61]. It is noteworthy that genotypes maintaining higher TW, GW and EY under drought conditions exhibit better floret survival and heavy with plump grain, longer flag leaf stay-green duration (higher SPAD values during this period), and effectively assimilate remobilization to grain in generative stages, bringing these traits to the forefront as potential high-yield properties in Mediterranean climates. Furthermore, this study highlights that genotypes exhibit different responses (even adapted to region) regarding yield under varying water treatment conditions, with the lowest yield of winter growth habit cultivar (Bozkır, 30.3 dt/ha) being particularly noteworthy during experimental period in rainfed and drought conditions. However, winter and facultative growth habit genotypes had the lowest yield values in the second experimental year of the study in drought condition. In general, early flowering/heading, which enables wheat to shorten its life cycle and complete the most sensitive generative growth stages before exposure to severe stress conditions (heat and drought), constituting and effective drought escape strategy [
18,
62]. Moreover, the cultivars adapted to the region (i.e., Ceyhan 99, Golia, and Tosunbey) have facultative growth habits that had better advantage of ensuring earlier maturity and anthesis/heading by supporting higher flag leaf SPAD values (particularly in the second year) in drought conditions. This may be explained as these cultivars experience shorter exposure to arid conditions than other genotypes exposed to prolonged spring drought.
One of the main goals of this study is to evaluate the response of multiple quality traits of wheat to reproductive drought conditions. The quality of wheat grain, particularly protein composition and gluten characteristics, plays a critical role in determining processing performance and the quality of final products such as bread, pasta, and other cereal-based foods. This study observed that the multitude of quality traits exhibited variations in response to drought conditions depending on genetic and seasonal climatic factors. The results underscore the importance of such evaluations for developing wheat cultivars with stable yield and quality under increasing climate variability. This study determined that bread-making quality characteristics vary depending on the growing season (year) and genetic factors rather than drought and rain-dependent treatments. Environmental conditions (including heat/drought) strongly affect grain yield, and several quality traits (i.e., gluten quality) are determined and controlled by genotype [
63]. Moreover, this study revealed a significant relationship between protein content and (WG, r = 0.73 ***) gluten quantity. However, significantly negative relationship was found between other bread quality characteristics (GluIN: r = −0.54 *** and FN: r = −0.40 **) and protein content in the post-heading drought condition.
Cultivars (Ceyhan 99, Golia, Tosunbey and Efe) that have adapted to the regional conditions of the experiment under which this study was conducted regarding gluten strength have become more noticeable with higher results compared to other genotypes. It has been established that sedimentation and falling number values are typically in the medium–low range in relation to bread-making quality characteristics. Protein content, wet gluten, gluten index, and sedimentation value traits were not affected significantly by rainfed and post-heading drought conditions in this study. Genotypes showed differential responses to growing seasons and water regimes, confirming that protein content and quality traits (especially GluIN) are predominantly under genetic control [
64]. The negative correlation between WG and GluIN may be linked to heat and drought stress cause to increase protein concentration while altering gluten composition and reducing polymeric gluten fractions, ultimately weakening gluten structure and functionality [
65]. In conclusion, an increase in protein content is not associated with an improvement in protein quality.
Although previous studies have reported increased protein content under drought and heat stress during grain filling, this trend was not supported by the ANOVA results in the present study. However, PCA and correlation analyses revealed a negative relationship between grain yield and protein content under post-heading drought, suggesting that reduced yield may have led to a relative increase in protein concentration due to a dilution effect [
66,
67].
Consistent with bread-making quality traits, treatment (rainfed vs. post-heading drought) effects on grain nutritional quality were not significant when the factors were considered independently, while genotypic responses were found to be significant and varied across climatic and water-stress environments (year x treatment x genotype). A negative and significant relationship (r = −0.68 ***) has been found between protein and ash content [
68] and positive correlation found with fiber content (r = 0.51 ***) in the post-heading drought condition. In daily diets, the awareness of consumers mainly focuses on healthy, high-fiber products. This situation may be attributed to genotypic variation and its response to different drought and environmental conditions, as well as proportional changes between them within the grain. Nevertheless, the positive correlation between protein and fiber content under arid conditions is consistent with the beneficial effects of such conditions on nutrition. Under warmer (in 2020) and water-limited (post-heading drought) spring conditions, Müfitbey tends to show higher protein and fiber contents, along with a lower grain weight value compared to other cultivars. This finding was supported by the correlation results, with the TGW exhibiting a significant negative correlation with the protein content (r = −0.73 ***) and fibre content (r = −0.63 ***).
Since baked products made with white flour dominate the production of high-quality products, the focus is on two main components that contribute to improving the starchy endosperm composition and health outcomes: starch and dietary fiber [
69]. According to the PCA biplot, STR exhibited a clear negative association with grain yield (GY), as indicated by the opposite orientation of their vectors. In contrast, FB showed a positive relationship with GY, while its association with STR was weakly negative, suggesting differential roles of these traits in yield formation under the rainfed and post-heading drought conditions. The negative relationship observed between traits and the varying responses of genotypes highlights the importance of breeding efforts related to this topic in Mediterranean climate.
Evaluating grain color and biochemical health-related quality traits under drought conditions provided important insights and results into drought-induced changes and contributed a new perspective to literature. In this study, grain color (L*, a*, b*) properties were characterized by a uniform and bright golden yellow color for high-quality pasta production, and their relationships were examined for biochemical properties in drought conditions. However, these characteristics have been linked to the presence of health-promoting biochemical compounds in bread wheat grains [
70]. Flour color is mainly controlled and modified by genetic factors [
71], and this study revealed significant changes between genotypes (with treatment modifying for b*). It is clear that the results show that drought caused higher color values for a* and b* while brightness increased in rainfed conditions. At this point, Müfitbey cultivar, which exhibits a winter-type growth habit, demonstrated substantial outcomes in terms of higher grain yellowness and phenolic content when it is exposed to post-heading drought condition. A key accomplishment of this study is the identification of a significant positive relation between grain yellow pigment and phenolic content, as revealed by PCA analyses. Concurrently, an increase in yellow pigment in the grain has also been observed, which led to an increase in phenolic compounds [
72]. In addition, grain redness (a*) correlated positively and significantly (r = 0.27 *) with total antioxidant activity in the post-heading drought condition. According to the results of the PCA analysis, there was a demonstrable increase in antioxidant and phenolic content levels in response to drought conditions [
38,
73]. The water-limited conditions contributed to the increase in health-related traits in a positive way after heading, depending on seasonal climate conditions and differential genotypic performance. Despite the absence of a significant correlation between total phenolic compounds and antioxidant activity, a notable association (r = 0.29 *) was identified between antioxidant activity and grain lipid content in the post-heading drought condition. This observation suggests a potential contribution of lipid-related antioxidant components. This situation also highlights the importance of whole wheat flour-based products that contain health-related compounds. The embryo is an important part of the wheat grain structure, containing about 10–15% lipids, 25–25% protein, 17% sugar, and 1.5–4.5% fiber; moreover, about 4% minerals and a high amount of lipids are located in the germ part [
74]. However, the embryo is typically discarded during the milling process [
75]. In contrast to the observations made in the context of lipid content, no significant relationship was identified in this study between fiber content and antioxidant properties.
Post-heading drought conditions led to marked reductions in yield and yield components while exerting contrasting effects on grain quality, with some traits being negatively (positive correlated with GY) affected (PHE, ASH, GluIN) and others (negative correlated with GY) showing improvement (STR, PRO, FB, LP, and WG). This is particularly observed between the yield and phenolic content of wheat grain. PCA results showed that facultative growth genotypes (i.e., Ceyhan-99, Tosunbey, Efe and Kayra) were strongly associated with yield-related traits (EY, GN and TW), reflecting their superior performance under rainfed conditions. In contrast, the winter-type growth habit genotypes (i.e., DG4: Müfitbey) showed a stronger association with phenolic accumulation under drought, suggesting that prolonged exposure to post-heading water deficit enhances the synthesis of secondary metabolites in wheat grain. Early maturing cultivars likely sustain yield formation by maintaining flag-leaf photosynthetic activity and assimilate supply during grain filling in rainfed condition, whereas lately maturing genotypes exposed to extended drought tend to produce smaller (opposite side vector of TGW to PHE) and shriveled grains (because of accelerated development) accumulate higher levels of phenolic compounds [
70]. These differential responses highlight genotype-specific and trait-dependent adaptations to drought conditions and seasonal climate variability, underscoring the importance of climate-adapted genetic studies (particularly in challenging Mediterranean climates) for drought resilience [
76].