Vibrational Property of α-Borophene Determined by Tip-Enhanced Raman Spectroscopy
, Xirui Tian 3,†, Shaoxiang Sheng 1,2,†, Chen Ma 1,2, Linjie Chen 4, Baojie Feng 1,2, Peng Cheng 1,2, Yiqi Zhang 1,2, Lan Chen 1,2, Jin Zhao 5,* and Kehui Wu 1,2,6,*
Round 1
Reviewer 1 Report
The paper is devoted to investigations of the recently founded α polymorph of borophene by scanning tunneling microscopy and tip-enhanced Raman scattering, so the results are extremely interesting for specialists both in material science and in Raman spectroscopy. Reliable data on the structure are obtained, new spectral features are found and interpreted using contemporary ab initio simulations. The extremely high spatial resolution of Raman data and confirmations of the asymmetric buckled structure of the α polymorph should be noted especially. I'm highly impressed.
Two minor remarks.
It's not quite clear why the M point at the Brillouin zone was selected to interpret the higher frequency Raman line. According to the symmetry of the buckled structure, any A1 mode is supposed to have some transversal component all over the zone. Focusing on the M point you suppose some special distortion of the structure that activates only this point, but not the whole higher frequency branch.
Designations of phonons in the table (A4 1, A3 1, A3 2) and at lines 164, 184 should be corrected, to agree with Fig. 3. Check sub- and superscripts.
Author Response
Thank you very much for valuable comments, our responses are included in the attached file.
Author Response File: 
Author Response.pdf
Reviewer 2 Report
See the File.
Comments for author File: Comments.pdf
Author Response
Thank you for valuable comments. Our responses were included in the attached file to reviewer comment 1
Author Response File: Author Response.pdf
