Skip to Content

940 Results Found

  • Article
  • Open Access
6 Citations
3,595 Views
13 Pages

The Influence of Criteria Selection Method on Consistency of Pairwise Comparison

  • Vladimír Bureš,
  • Jiří Cabal,
  • Pavel Čech,
  • Karel Mls and
  • Daniela Ponce

10 December 2020

The more criteria a human decision involves, the more inconsistent the decision. This study experimentally examines the effect on the degree of pairwise comparison inconsistency by using the (im)possibility of selecting the criteria for the evaluatio...

(This article belongs to the Special Issue Multiple Criteria Decision Making)
  • Article
  • Open Access
8 Citations
4,425 Views
23 Pages

7 February 2021

Recent soundscape research is notable owing to the increasing demand for “multisensory” tourism experiences. However, the traditional economic value assessment of tourism destinations mostly takes each type of landscape as a whole for measurement, an...

(This article belongs to the Section Sustainability in Geographic Science)
  • Feature Paper
  • Article
  • Open Access
22 Citations
6,704 Views
12 Pages

29 October 2020

One of the most popular methods of calculating priorities based on the pairwise comparisons matrices (PCM) is the geometric mean method (GMM). It is equivalent to the logarithmic least squares method (LLSM), so some use both names interchangeably, tr...

(This article belongs to the Special Issue Multi-Criteria Optimization Models and Applications)
  • Article
  • Open Access
6 Citations
3,071 Views
29 Pages

1 September 2021

There are numerous priority deriving methods (PDMs) for pairwise-comparison-based (PCB) problems. They are often examined within the Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP), which applies the Principal Right Eigenvalue Method (PREV) in the process of priori...

(This article belongs to the Special Issue Decision Making, Classical and Quantum Optimization Methods)
  • Article
  • Open Access
3,483 Views
20 Pages

Detection of Decision-Making Manipulation in the Pairwise Comparison Method

  • Michał Strada,
  • Sebastian Ernst,
  • Jacek Szybowski and
  • Konrad Kułakowski

4 October 2024

Most decision-making models, including the pairwise comparison method, assume the honesty of the decision-maker. However, it is easy to imagine a situation where the decision-maker tries to manipulate the ranking results. This problem applies to many...

(This article belongs to the Section Computing and Artificial Intelligence)
  • Article
  • Open Access
21 Citations
4,066 Views
13 Pages

5 March 2021

In this paper, we compare three methods for deriving a priority vector in the theoretical framework of pairwise comparisons—the Geometric Mean Method (GMM), Eigenvalue Method (EVM) and Best–Worst Method (BWM)—with respect to two features: sensitivity...

(This article belongs to the Special Issue Mathematical Methods for Operations Research Problems)
  • Article
  • Open Access
9 Citations
2,607 Views
16 Pages

8 November 2022

Port state control (PSC) plays an important role in enhancing maritime safety and protecting the marine environment. Since the inspection resources are limited and the inspection process is costly and time-consuming, a critical issue for port states...

(This article belongs to the Special Issue Sustainable Operations in Maritime Industry)
  • Article
  • Open Access
22 Citations
7,005 Views
30 Pages

A Fuzzy Extension of Simplified Best-Worst Method (F-SBWM) and Its Applications to Decision-Making Problems

  • Maghsoud Amiri,
  • Mohammad Hashemi-Tabatabaei,
  • Mehdi Keshavarz-Ghorabaee,
  • Arturas Kaklauskas and ,
  • Edmundas Kazimieras Zavadskas and
  • Jurgita Antucheviciene
  • + 1 author+ 0 author

28 December 2022

Today, most of the issues and challenges faced by managers and decision makers are complex and multifaceted. More clearly, due to the developments of technologies, emerging trends in various industries, competitive markets, and rapid and transformati...

(This article belongs to the Section A: Computer Science)
  • Article
  • Open Access
5 Citations
2,711 Views
25 Pages

Introducing a Novel Method for Smart Expansive Systems’ Operation Risk Synthesis

  • Nikolay Zhigirev,
  • Alexander Bochkov,
  • Nataliya Kuzmina and
  • Alexandra Ridley

28 January 2022

In different areas of human activity, the need to choose optimal (rational) options for actions from the proposed alternatives inevitably arises. In the case of retrospective statistical data, risk analysis is a convenient tool for solving the proble...

(This article belongs to the Special Issue Probability and Stochastic Processes with Applications to Communications, Systems and Networks)
  • Article
  • Open Access
542 Views
20 Pages

Pairwise Agreement Among Field-Based Body-Fat Estimation Methods in Physically Active Adults: A Cross-Sectional Method-Comparison Study

  • Raynier Zambrano-Villacres,
  • Kathy Elisabeth Verdugo Verdugo,
  • Washington David Guevara Castillo,
  • Nelly Andrade Mejia and ,
  • Jaen Cagua-Ordoñez and
  • Daniel Simancas-Racines
  • + 1 author+ 0 author

Background: Field-based body-fat estimates may differ substantially across methods, but similarity in group averages does not necessarily indicate close individual-level agreement. This study characterized pairwise numerical agreement among four fiel...

(This article belongs to the Special Issue Body Composition Assessment: Methods, Validity, and Applications)
  • Article
  • Open Access
8 Citations
2,492 Views
19 Pages

26 November 2023

Agricultural biogas plants are a renewable source of energy and at the same time enable the disposal of biodegradable waste generated in agriculture and the food industry. In Poland, a program aimed at constructing agricultural biogas plants has been...

(This article belongs to the Special Issue Bioenergy Economics: Analysis, Modeling and Application)
  • Article
  • Open Access
2 Citations
1,544 Views
24 Pages

20 December 2025

This paper examines decision-making challenges that arise when information is incomplete, specifically when judgments are missing or unavailable in the context of individual and group applications of the Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP). Two illustra...

  • Article
  • Open Access
1,898 Views
12 Pages

8 December 2022

The decision-maker obtains the pairwise comparisons matrix by comparing two entities. In the process of comparing the two entities, the relationship between the two entities and other entities is not considered. In this way, the judgment may be illog...

(This article belongs to the Special Issue Mathematical Modeling, Artificial Intelligence, Dynamics and Control on Complex Systems from Science, Engineering and Sociological Science)
  • Article
  • Open Access
23 Citations
4,228 Views
28 Pages

Evaluating Life Cycle of Buildings Using an Integrated Approach Based on Quantitative-Qualitative and Simplified Best-Worst Methods (QQM-SBWM)

  • Maghsoud Amiri,
  • Mohammad Hashemi-Tabatabaei,
  • Mohammad Ghahremanloo,
  • Mehdi Keshavarz-Ghorabaee and ,
  • Edmundas Kazimieras Zavadskas and
  • Arturas Kaklauskas
  • + 1 author+ 0 author

17 April 2021

Evaluating the life cycle of buildings is a valuable tool for assessing sustainability and analyzing environmental consequences throughout the construction operations of buildings. In this study, in order to determine the importance of building life...

(This article belongs to the Special Issue Decision Support Systems and Multiple Criteria Decision Making for Sustainable Development)
  • Article
  • Open Access
36 Citations
8,579 Views
21 Pages

The Kashmir Valley is immensely susceptible to soil erosion due to its diverse topography and unstable geological formations in the Himalayan region. The present study helps in assessing the spatial distribution and prioritizing soil erosion zones in...

(This article belongs to the Special Issue Land System Dynamics in Mountainous Watersheds under Global Change: Implications for Science and Policy)
  • Article
  • Open Access
66 Citations
6,993 Views
30 Pages

27 June 2019

Selection of the most appropriate contractor for the installation of solar panels is essential to maximizing the benefit of this renewable, sustainable energy source. Solar energy is one of the 100% renewable energy sources, but implementation may no...

(This article belongs to the Special Issue Sustainable Energy Consumption)
  • Article
  • Open Access
3 Citations
1,282 Views
22 Pages

Exploring Consistency in the Three-Option Davidson Model: Bridging Pairwise Comparison Matrices and Stochastic Methods

  • Anna Tóth-Merényi,
  • Csaba Mihálykó,
  • Éva Orbán-Mihálykó and
  • László Gyarmati

23 April 2025

In this paper, data consistency in the three-option Davidson model is investigated. Starting out with the usual consistency definition in pairwise matrices-based methods, we examine its consequences. We formulate an equivalent statement based on the...

(This article belongs to the Section D: Statistics and Operational Research)
  • Proceeding Paper
  • Open Access
1,091 Views
6 Pages

Understanding consumer preferences is vital for rational decision-making in the agri-food sector and for effective product development. This study examines two comparative evaluation methods, Best–Worst Scaling (BWS) and Pairwise Comparison via...

(This article belongs to the Proceedings of The 18th International Conference of the Hellenic Association of Agricultural Economists)
  • Article
  • Open Access
1,008 Views
26 Pages

18 March 2026

Salient object ranking aims to assign a relative importance order to multiple objects in an image, aligning with human visual attention. However, existing methods struggle with ranking ambiguity in complex scenes, particularly when objects are numero...

(This article belongs to the Section Sensors and Robotics)
  • Article
  • Open Access
15 Citations
3,936 Views
17 Pages

3 September 2021

The removal of non-climatic biases, so-called inhomogeneities, from long climatic records needs sophistically developed statistical methods. One principle is that the differences between a candidate series and its neighbor series are usually analyzed...

(This article belongs to the Special Issue Application of Homogenization Methods for Climate Records)
  • Article
  • Open Access
1,029 Views
14 Pages

Automatic Substitution of Prioritization Methods Preserving Information Integrity

  • Joao Batista Mendes,
  • Renato Dourado Maia,
  • Marcos Flávio Silveira Vasconcelos D’Angelo,
  • Iara Sibele Silva and ,
  • Petr Y. Ekel and
  • Matheus Pereira Libório
  • + 1 author+ 0 author

13 November 2025

Companies face multi-criteria problems every day, such as prioritizing projects, investments, and suppliers. In this respect, the literature offers countless methods, some of which provide partial and flawed solutions. Therefore, identifying and repl...

  • Article
  • Open Access
5 Citations
3,116 Views
15 Pages

A Comparison-Based Framework for Argument Quality Assessment

  • Jianzhu Bao,
  • Bojun Jin,
  • Yang Sun,
  • Yice Zhang and ,
  • Yuhang He and
  • Ruifeng Xu
  • + 1 author+ 0 author

17 October 2024

Assessing the quality of arguments is both valuable and challenging. Humans often find that making pairwise comparisons between a target argument and several reference arguments facilitates a more precise judgment of the target argument’s quali...

(This article belongs to the Special Issue New Advances in Affective Computing)
  • Article
  • Open Access
5 Citations
3,078 Views
21 Pages

Multi-Criteria Group Decision-Making Models in a Multi-Choice Environment

  • Qazi Shoeb Ahmad,
  • Mohammad Faisal Khan and
  • Naeem Ahmad

21 November 2022

The best–worst method (BWM) has recently demonstrated its applicability in addressing various decision-making problems in a practical setting. The traditional BWM method is based on deterministic information gathered from experts as pairwise co...

(This article belongs to the Special Issue Multiple-Criteria Decision Making II)
  • Article
  • Open Access
6 Citations
5,160 Views
25 Pages

25 February 2022

We consider the problem of evaluating preferences for criteria used by university students when selecting a hotel for accommodation during a professional development program in a foreign country. Input data for analysis come from a survey of 202 resp...

(This article belongs to the Special Issue Development and Optimization of Mathematical Models for Operations Research)
  • Article
  • Open Access
8 Citations
7,734 Views
15 Pages

A Bradley-Terry Model-Based Approach to Prioritize the Balance Scorecard Driving Factors: The Case Study of a Financial Software Factory

  • Vicente Rodríguez Montequín,
  • Joaquín Manuel Villanueva Balsera,
  • Marina Díaz Piloñeta and
  • César Álvarez Pérez

19 February 2020

The prioritization of factors has been widely studied applying different methods from the domain of the multiple-criteria decision-making, such as for example the Analytic Hierarchy Process method (AHP) based on decision-makers’ pairwise compar...

(This article belongs to the Special Issue Applications of Operational Research and Mathematical Models in Management)
  • Article
  • Open Access
16 Citations
4,269 Views
23 Pages

29 September 2022

In view of increasing supply chain disruption events, for example the China–United States trade war, the COVID-19 pandemic, and the Russia–Ukraine war, the complexity and dynamicity of global freight management keeps increasing. To build...

(This article belongs to the Special Issue Multi-Criteria Decision Making Methods and Their Applications)
  • Article
  • Open Access
52 Citations
5,841 Views
20 Pages

An Integrated Decision Support Model for Evaluating Public Transport Quality

  • Sarbast Moslem,
  • Ahmad Alkharabsheh,
  • Karzan Ismael and
  • Szabolcs Duleba

17 June 2020

Big cities suffer from serious complex problems such as air pollution, congestion, and traffic accidents. Developing public transport quality in such cities is considered an efficient remedy to obviate these critical issues. This paper aims to determ...

  • Article
  • Open Access
4 Citations
4,762 Views
12 Pages

12 March 2020

In sequential tests, typically a (pairwise) multiple comparison procedure (MCP) is performed after an omnibus test (an overall equality test). In general, when an omnibus test (e.g., overall equality of multiple proportions test) is rejected, then we...

  • Article
  • Open Access
28 Citations
8,808 Views
18 Pages

When Fairness Meets Consistency in AHP Pairwise Comparisons

  • Zorica Dodevska,
  • Sandro Radovanović,
  • Andrija Petrović and
  • Boris Delibašić

25 January 2023

We propose introducing fairness constraints to one of the most famous multi-criteria decision-making methods, the analytic hierarchy process (AHP). We offer a solution that guarantees consistency while respecting legally binding fairness constraints...

(This article belongs to the Section D2: Operations Research and Fuzzy Decision Making)
  • Article
  • Open Access
816 Citations
25,047 Views
22 Pages

10 September 2018

In this paper, a new multi-criteria problem solving method—the Full Consistency Method (FUCOM)—is proposed. The model implies the definition of two groups of constraints that need to satisfy the optimal values of weight coefficients. The...

  • Feature Paper
  • Article
  • Open Access
675 Views
27 Pages

A Practical Guide to the Multi-Dimensional Elo Rating System

  • Adam Hamilton,
  • Anna Kalenkova and
  • Matthew Roughan

16 July 2026

The multi-dimensional Elo rating system was designed to be a method of extending the more popular Elo system to model a wider variety of phenomena based on pairwise comparisons. This is useful in comparing the behaviours of machine learning models th...

  • Article
  • Open Access
2,495 Views
21 Pages

21 July 2024

Feature selection is a basic and important step in real applications, such as face recognition and image segmentation. In this paper, we propose a new weakly supervised multi-view feature selection method by utilizing pairwise constraints, i.e., the...

(This article belongs to the Special Issue Applications of Artificial Intelligence, Machine Learning and Data Science)
  • Article
  • Open Access
6 Citations
3,296 Views
10 Pages

Using Data-Compressors for Classification Hunting Behavioral Sequences in Rodents as “Ethological Texts”

  • Jan Levenets,
  • Anna Novikovskaya,
  • Sofia Panteleeva,
  • Zhanna Reznikova and
  • Boris Ryabko

14 April 2020

One of the main problems in comparative studying animal behavior is searching for an adequate mathematical method for evaluating the similarities and differences between behavioral patterns. This study aims to propose a new tool to evaluate ethologic...

(This article belongs to the Special Issue Information Theory, Cryptography, Randomness and Statistical Modeling)
  • Article
  • Open Access
48 Citations
4,108 Views
15 Pages

15 February 2019

Existing fuzzy analytic hierarchy process (FAHP) methods usually aggregate the fuzzy pairwise comparison results produced by multiple decision-makers (DMs) rather than the fuzzy weights estimations. This is problematic because fuzzy pairwise comparis...

(This article belongs to the Special Issue Fuzzy Sets, Fuzzy Logic and Their Applications)
  • Article
  • Open Access
3 Citations
2,342 Views
23 Pages

19 October 2023

The Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP) is a widely used used multi-criteria decision-making method (MCDM). This method is based on pairwise comparison, which forms the so-called Pairwise Comparison Matrix (PCM). PCMs usually contain some errors, which...

(This article belongs to the Special Issue Entropy Weight Methods of Combining Classifiers in Distributed Learning Area)
  • Article
  • Open Access
27 Citations
4,805 Views
21 Pages

22 March 2021

Current machine intelligence metrics rely on a different philosophy, hindering their effective comparison. There is no standardization of what is machine intelligence and what should be measured to quantify it. In this study, we investigate the measu...

(This article belongs to the Section E1: Mathematics and Computer Science)
  • Article
  • Open Access
511 Views
13 Pages

Postoperative Pneumonia After Minimally Invasive Esophagectomy in Esophageal Squamous Cell Carcinoma: A Weighted Real-World Comparison of Neoadjuvant Treatment Strategies

  • Funa Yang,
  • Tao Zhang,
  • Wei Wei,
  • Xiaocan Jia and ,
  • Lanwei Guo,
  • Fengjuan Liu,
  • Peinan Chen,
  • Haibo Sun,
  • Hongying Shi and
  • Wei Cui
  • + 5 authors+ 0 author

10 August 2026

Background: Postoperative pneumonia (POP) is a critical complication after minimally invasive esophagectomy (MIE) for esophageal squamous cell carcinoma (ESCC). However, the comparative odds of POP among different neoadjuvant treatment strategies rem...

(This article belongs to the Special Issue Current Treatments of Esophageal and Esophagogastric Junction Cancers (2nd Edition))
  • Article
  • Open Access
11 Citations
6,280 Views
18 Pages

Machine Learning-Driven Approach for Large Scale Decision Making with the Analytic Hierarchy Process

  • Marcos Antonio Alves,
  • Ivan Reinaldo Meneghini,
  • António Gaspar-Cunha and
  • Frederico Gadelha Guimarães

26 January 2023

The Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP) multicriteria method can be cognitively demanding for large-scale decision problems due to the requirement for the decision maker to make pairwise evaluations of all alternatives. To address this issue, this paper...

(This article belongs to the Special Issue Multiple Criteria Decision Making, 2nd Edition)
  • Article
  • Open Access
30 Citations
5,179 Views
16 Pages

Novel Extension of DEMATEL Method by Trapezoidal Fuzzy Numbers and D Numbers for Management of Decision-Making Processes

  • Ivan Pribićević,
  • Suzana Doljanica,
  • Oliver Momčilović,
  • Dillip Kumar Das and ,
  • Dragan Pamučar and
  • Željko Stević
  • + 1 author+ 0 author

The decision-making trial and evaluation laboratory (DEMATEL) method is one of the most significant multi-criteria techniques for defining the relationships among criteria and for defining the weight coefficients of criteria. Since multi-criteria mod...

(This article belongs to the Special Issue Dynamics under Uncertainty: Modeling Simulation and Complexity)
  • Article
  • Open Access
9 Citations
2,305 Views
14 Pages

Evaluating the Promethee ii Ranking Quality

  • Boris Coquelet,
  • Gilles Dejaegere and
  • Yves De Smet

24 September 2025

Multicriteria decision aid consists in helping decision makers to compare (rank, choose, sort, etc.) different alternatives which are evaluated on conflicting criteria. One well-known family of multicriteria decision aid methods is Promethee. It is b...

(This article belongs to the Section Analysis of Algorithms and Complexity Theory)
  • Article
  • Open Access
1 Citations
1,729 Views
14 Pages

Generally, following an omnibus (overall equality) test, multiple pairwise comparison (MPC) tests are typically conducted as the second step in a sequential testing procedure to identify which specific pairs (e.g., proportions) exhibit significant di...

  • Article
  • Open Access
5 Citations
3,344 Views
22 Pages

Spaceborne SAR Time-Series Images Change Detection Based on SAR-SIFT-Logarithm Background Subtraction

  • Wenjie Shen,
  • Yunzhen Jia,
  • Yanping Wang,
  • Yun Lin and ,
  • Yang Li,
  • Zechao Bai and
  • Wen Jiang
  • + 2 authors+ 0 author

28 November 2023

Synthetic Aperture Radar (SAR) image change detection aims to detect changes with images of the same area acquired at different times. It has wide applications in environmental monitoring, urban planning and resource management. Traditional change de...

(This article belongs to the Special Issue Advances in Synthetic Aperture Radar Data Processing and Application)
  • Article
  • Open Access
13 Citations
4,206 Views
19 Pages

15 October 2021

The urban ecosystem provides many services that help humans lead physically and mentally healthy lives. The quality of such urban ecosystem services is closely related to various urban forms, such as land cover, land use, buildings, infrastructure, p...

(This article belongs to the Special Issue Application of Geographic Information System and Building Information Modelling)
  • Article
  • Open Access
61 Citations
6,953 Views
16 Pages

9 September 2016

This paper proposes a novel approach to cope with the multi-criteria group decision-making problems. We give the pairwise comparisons based on the best-worst-method (BWM), which can decrease comparison times. Additionally, our comparison results are...

  • Article
  • Open Access
829 Views
14 Pages

Comparison of Fascicular Turnover Flap and Autograft in a Rat Facial Nerve Model

  • Ivan Shpitser,
  • Mark Gabriyanchik,
  • Alexey Fayzullin,
  • Yana Khristidis and ,
  • Kamil Salikhov,
  • Olesya Startseva,
  • Olga Kolesnikova,
  • Kirill Pirogov,
  • Peter Timashev and
  • Anna Vedyaeva
  • + 5 authors+ 0 author

10 April 2026

Background: Fascicular turnover flap (FTF) is a donor-sparing option for segmental facial nerve repair. This study compared autologous nerve grafting with proximally based and distally based FTF in a rat facial nerve model. Methods: Adult male Wistar...

(This article belongs to the Special Issue Advances and Innovations in Reconstructive Microsurgery: Techniques, Outcomes, and Future Directions)
  • Article
  • Open Access
2 Citations
4,006 Views
13 Pages

Pairwise Voting to Rank Touristic Destinations Based on Preference Valuation

  • Francisco E. Cabrera,
  • Manuel Amaya,
  • Gustavo Fabián Vaccaro Witt and
  • José Ignacio Peláez

23 October 2019

This paper presents a novel approach for ranking tourist destinations based on the eigenvector method for pairwise voting (EMPV). The proposed approach relies solely on pairwise comparisons instead of direct-vote polling. The EMPV method was tested o...

(This article belongs to the Special Issue Stakeholder Management in Tourism Destinations)
  • Article
  • Open Access
347 Views
26 Pages

14 August 2026

Paired comparison models are examined from the perspective of the placement of objects within specific comparison structures. For both pairwise comparison matrix-based models and stochastic models, previous studies have examined which comparison stru...

  • Article
  • Open Access
69 Views
32 Pages

4 November 2026

Complex socio-technical decisions require explicit links between environmental analysis, strategic diagnosis and quantitative assessment. This study examines a sequential decision-support procedure using political, economic, social and technological...

(This article belongs to the Section Systems Theory and Methodology)
  • Article
  • Open Access
283 Views
19 Pages

25 September 2026

Background and Objectives: Esophageal atresia (EA) is associated with dysmotility and postoperative morbidity, which may reflect congenital abnormalities of innervation and extracellular matrix (ECM) remodeling. This study compared immunoreactiv...

(This article belongs to the Special Issue Gastrointestinal Surgery: Clinical Innovation and Future Directions)
  • Article
  • Open Access
4 Citations
2,182 Views
28 Pages

16 November 2023

Suppliers can achieve high levels of supply chain sustainability by improving the related factors. An agile supply chain can support sustainability. Identifying and ranking agility factors in the SAIPA company in Iran to reach a sustainable and green...

of 19