Next Article in Journal / Special Issue
Estimating Eulerian Energy Spectra from Drifters
Previous Article in Journal
Boundary Layer Flow and Heat Transfer of FMWCNT/Water Nanofluids over a Flat Plate
Previous Article in Special Issue
Meridional and Zonal Wavenumber Dependence in Tracer Flux in Rossby Waves
Comment published on 26 April 2017, see Fluids 2017, 2(2), 19.

Neutrality Versus Materiality: A Thermodynamic Theory of Neutral Surfaces

Department of Meteorology, University of Reading, RG6 6BB Reading, UK
Academic Editor: Pavel S. Berloff
Fluids 2016, 1(4), 32;
Received: 16 February 2016 / Revised: 12 September 2016 / Accepted: 14 September 2016 / Published: 28 September 2016
(This article belongs to the Collection Geophysical Fluid Dynamics)
In this paper, a theory for constructing quasi-neutral density variables γ directly in thermodynamic space is formulated, which is based on minimising the absolute value of a purely thermodynamic quantity J n . Physically, J n has a dual dynamic/thermodynamic interpretation as the quantity controlling the energy cost of adiabatic and isohaline parcel exchanges on material surfaces, as well as the dependence of in-situ density on spiciness, in a description of water masses based on γ, spiciness and pressure. Mathematically, minimising | J n | in thermodynamic space is showed to be equivalent to maximising neutrality in physical space. The physics of epineutral dispersion is also reviewed and discussed. It is argued, in particular, that epineutral dispersion is best understood as the aggregate effect of many individual non-neutral stirring events (being understood here as adiabatic and isohaline events with non-zero buoyancy), so that it is only the net displacement aggregated over many events that is approximately neutral. This new view resolves an apparent paradox between the focus in neutral density theory on zero-buoyancy motions and the overwhelming evidence that lateral dispersion in the ocean is primarily caused by non-zero buoyancy processes such as tides, residual currents and sheared internal waves. The efficiency by which a physical process contributes to lateral dispersion can be characterised by its energy signature, with those processes releasing available potential energy (negative energy cost) being more efficient than purely neutral processes with zero energy cost. The latter mechanism occurs in the wedge of instability, and its source of energy is the coupling between baroclinicity, thermobaricity, and density compensated temperature/salinity anomalies. Such a mechanism, which can only exist in a salty ocean, is speculated to be important for dissipating spiciness anomalies and neutral helicity. The paper also discusses potential conceptual difficulties with the use of neutral rotated diffusion tensors in numerical ocean models, as well as with the construction of neutral density variables in physical space. It also emphasises the irreducible character of thermobaric forces in the ocean. These are argued to be the cause for adiabatic thermobaric dianeutral dispersion, and to forbid the existence of density surfaces along which fluid parcels can be exchanged without experiencing buoyancy forces, in contrast to what is assumed in the theory of neutral surfaces. View Full-Text
Keywords: neutral surfaces; stirring; mixing; energetics; thermodynamics; first-principles neutral surfaces; stirring; mixing; energetics; thermodynamics; first-principles
Show Figures

Figure 1

MDPI and ACS Style

Tailleux, R. Neutrality Versus Materiality: A Thermodynamic Theory of Neutral Surfaces. Fluids 2016, 1, 32.

AMA Style

Tailleux R. Neutrality Versus Materiality: A Thermodynamic Theory of Neutral Surfaces. Fluids. 2016; 1(4):32.

Chicago/Turabian Style

Tailleux, Rémi. 2016. "Neutrality Versus Materiality: A Thermodynamic Theory of Neutral Surfaces" Fluids 1, no. 4: 32.

Find Other Styles
Note that from the first issue of 2016, MDPI journals use article numbers instead of page numbers. See further details here.

Article Access Map by Country/Region

Back to TopTop