Plant and Herbal Extracts as Ingredients of Topical Agents in the Prevention and Treatment Radiodermatitis: A Systematic Literature Review

Abstract

Background: The use of herbal extracts as the source of antioxidant substances capable of neutralizing free radicals and providing protection from ionizing radiation appears to be an alternative therapy for radiodermatitis. As concerns the prevention and treatment of side effects, a lot of recommendations are based on proper experience of radiotherapy centers. We summarize recent research aiming at reducing radiation-induced skin injuries by use of proper skin care, using topical preparations with herbal extracts including onco-cosmetics. Methods: This article is limited to a critical analysis of scientific and professional literature. It concerns preparations in different physicochemical forms, e.g., gels, emulsions, ointments. We stress the connection between the type of applied skin care (type of preparation, its composition, the dose), the properties of the herbal extract and the evaluation of its efficiency in preventing and treating radiation reaction on skin. Conclusions: Herbal extracts can be added to recipes because they are part of a category of cosmeceutical supplements and can be introduced into preparations without prescription. The effectiveness evaluation for herbal extracts in radiotherapy is not an easy task since there are no strict guidelines. Studies should be preceded by the analysis of herbal extracts and recipe in terms of physicochemical, dermatological and performance characteristics.

1. Introduction

Radiotherapy is a treatment method using ionizing radiation (most frequently X rays) applied in oncology for treatment of tumors and for relieving the pain related to the disseminated tumor process [1]. Its purpose is to stop the growth of the tumor tissue while at the same time preserving the healthy tissue surrounding the tumor. High frequency waves used during treatment cause the electron to be knocked out of the atom orbit which in turn leads to tissues’ ionization. Moreover, free electrons lead to the creation of free radicals and peroxides causing negative changes in the DNA, proteins and cellular membranes [2,3]. As concerns free electrons, the damage occurs as a consequence of direct effect, whereas we talk about indirect effect when the damage to the DNA structure is caused by free radicals. Most of the damages occur as indirect effect. In any case, for 6–8 h after the radiation, the enzymes can repair part of the damages [4,5]. The necessity of repeating the radiation sessions leads to the damage of the defensive systems responsible for removing free radicals. In case of large damage, repair may not be successfully completed and cells die by apoptosis. Even if the normal cell function is restored, their incomplete reconstruction causes permanent changes or mutations leading to cells dysfunction [4,6,7].

Among general side effects of radiotherapy, the following examples can be mentioned: general weakness, lack of appetite, decline in activity, changes in bold parameters, post-radiation skin reaction, hair loss, mucosal reactions in the mouth, throat, larynx and nasal cavities, reaction of respiratory tract, the heart, the intestines and the bladder. Complications and secondary effects observed by patients can occur in early stages or later [8]. The early complications concern constantly multiplying cells of marrow, epithelium—including skin, digestive track or urinary tract [2,6,7,9]. Mostly those do not cause serious consequences for patients. The second group of complications appears several months or even years after the radiation. It concerns slowly proliferating tissues like lungs, kidneys, liver, blood vessels and central nervous system [4,6,7]. The importance of secondary effects of the radiation depends on the part of the body it was applied to, the irradiation dose, and the degree of irradiation cumulated by the cells [4,6,7,9,10,11].

In this article, we focused only on secondary effects occurring on the skin, their prevention and treatment, and the possibility of using herbal extracts applied topically on skin.

1.1. Skin Reactions following Radiotherapy

Radiodermatitis (or radiation dermatitis, radiation induced skin reactions or radiation injury, radiation tissue damage) is a significant secondary effect of the ionizing radiation applied to the skin during a cancer treatment but also being a result of nuclear attacks or disasters [8,12]. Radiation skin damages or injuries relate to morphological and functional changes that occur in non-cancerous tissue as a direct result of ionizing radiation [6,13]. The most vulnerable parts of the skin are those at the junction of two skin surfaces like breasts and crotch, those with thin and smooth epidermis (crotch, face, armpits), but also zones with already damaged skin layers (burns, postoperative wounds, skin scales) [14]. Tissue reaction during radiotherapy also depends on the preexisting conditions, age, malnutrition, smoking, medication, chemotherapy, and skin color [9].

Among the first side effects observed by patients are skin dryness, pigmentation disorder, hair loss and erythema [4,11,12,15]. Those symptoms are caused by the damage to sebaceous and sweat glands, to hair follicles and an overstimulation of the pigmentation cells but also an increased pro-inflammatory cytokine release like interleukin 1 and 6 TNF-α, TGF-β [4,8]. Sequentially, following the damage of keratinocytes of the basal layer of the epidermis, there is dry desquamation and moist desquamation accompanied by serous effusion. This leads to the destruction of all the cells in the basal layers of epidermis and the exposure of the dermis [8,12]. Dry desquamation causes a frequent and very nagging symptom, namely itching. In case of a heavy radiation dermatitis, exposure to further fractional doses prevents cell repopulation and hence healing [16].

Late radiation reaction usually appears a few months after the completion of the therapy. It is the fibroblasts’ reaction to the radiation. The decrease in fibroblast population (fibroblasts are cells with low proliferation index) and the resorption of collagen fibers lead to atrophy-like changes causing the skin to lose its elasticity and the appearance of thickening and fibrosis, telangiectasia, atrophy of the sebaceous and sweat glands as well as of hair follicles, and can even lead to skin necrosis [4]. The changes can occur immediately and last up to several months, or become permanent [8,15]. The skin response time to radiotherapy includes hemostasis (immediate), inflammation (day 0–4), granulation tissue formation (day 3–3 weeks), matrix deposition and remodeling (week 3–2 years) [6,17].

Accurate assessment and classification of radiation dermatitis is essential for appropriate treatment, management, and monitoring in clinical practice [8]. Table 1 presents the scale of the skin damage (RTOG scale) according to The Radiation Therapy Oncology Group and European Organization for Research and Treatment of Cancer.

Table 1. The Radiation Therapy Oncology Group and European Organization for Research and Treatment of Cancer acute skin toxicity scale [18].

0	I Degree	II Degree	III Degree	IV Degree	V Degree
no changes	mild erythema, dry desquamation, reduced sweating	moderate to severe erythema, intertriginous moist desquamation usually limited to skin folds and articulations, moderate edema	moist desquamation outside the skin folds and articulations, bleeding caused by minor trauma or abrasion, edematous skin	skin necrosis or ulceration across all the skin layers, spontaneous bleeding in the impacted	death

It is estimated that even 95% of patients subjected to radiation treatment experience radiodermatitis [4,6,19]. Observed post-radiation skin reactions and their complications have a severe impact on a patient’s organism, and may cause countless complications including treatment delay, lowering of the quality of life (physical and psychological pain) or esthetic effects [8,15,18].

Appropriate preventive actions can be applied to improve the quality of life of patients treated for cancer. These therapeutic strategies can be divided in four categories: physical therapy, external-use dressing/cream, biological therapy and surgical reconstruction [4,11]. Properly conducted preventive actions also protect patient’s skin during radiotherapy from additional injuries, irritation or UV radiation [4,16,18,20,21].

1.2. Skin Care during Radiotherapy–Preventive Measures for Radiodermatitis

Skin care during radiotherapy should be properly adapted to patient’s needs. The purpose of a normal care therapy is to ensure the skin is clean, which will facilitate its healing afterwards, but also bring comfort and relief to the irritated skin, reduce pain and protect the skin against injuries, and prevent and fight infections [11,15]. Therefore, the skin care plan should include gentle cleansing, moisturizing and regeneration [11,12,22,23,24]. What is also important in skin care is the protection against UV radiation, appropriate clothing and appropriate diet [8,25]. There is a group of cosmetics available on the market which are dedicated to oncology patients, they are called cosmeceuticals and more precisely onco-cosmetics [11,12,22,23,24].

Products used for skin care and treatment during radiotherapy can be classified according to their physicochemical form (Table 2) and their purpose (Table 3).

Table 2. Physicochemical form of skin care products for oncological treatment [15,26,27,28].

Product Type	Physicochemical Form	Purpose	Advantages	Disadvantages
For washing	Gel, aqueous solution, foam, soap	Skin cleansing	Cleansed skin, better absorption of other care products, limited exposure to bacteriological infection	Can cause irritation, reddening or desquamation
Lotion	Aqueous solution, emulsion	Skin pH equalization, smoothing, softening	Maintaining the skin in healthy condition by providing proper moisturizing substances, supplement to self-care *	Can cause irritation, requires additional steps in skin care, i.e., application of creams, due to the water content in the composition, it requires preservatives
Serum	Emulsion, gel	Providing of active ingredients	Reinforces and intensifies daily care, increases the action of cremes, additional moisturizing, light gel texture, evaporates quickly, supplement to self-care *	High concentration of active substances can lead to skin irritation, Need to apply a second product like nourishing cream or protection cream against UV radiation
Cream	Emulsion	Moisturization, lubrication, regeneration, nourishing	Moisturizing, soothing of side effects such as itching, burning or reddening	Need to apply several times during the day
Ointment	Emulsion, suspension	Treatment	Eliminates side effects	Greasy, heavy texture, hard to spread on skin

* Self-care: “is the ability of individuals, families and communities to promote health, prevent disease, maintain health, and to cope with illness and disability with or without the support of a health-care provider [29]”.

Table 3. Classification of preparations applied to skin care during radiotherapy according to their type of action.

Type of Action	Mechanism of Operation	Types of Preparations	Advantages Disadvantages, Specific Traits	Active Substances in the Receipe	Ref.
Moisturizing	Maintain moisture, protect the skin in three ways: replacement of deficient agents (present in the product), occlusion, humectant action	Ointments, creams, pastes, foams, lotions, gels	Ointments are more penetrating that other forms such as creams or lotions, but they can be too occlusive and greasy, gels can dry on skin and cause irritation	Natural oils, ceramides, humectants, urea, sorbitol, panthenol hyaluronic acid, plant extracts	[30,31,32]
Emollient	Improve skin barrier function, supplement epidermal lipids, reduce itching and dermatitis	Creams, lotions, oils	Preparations based on petrolatum clog up pores, some emollients can cause hypersensitivity	Lanolin, bee wax, herbal and animal oils like: emu oil, coconut oil, olive oil, avocado oil, evening primrose, vegetable butters (i.e., shea butter), fatty alcohols	[30,33,34,35]
Curative: Anti-inflammatory	Reduce inflammatory skin reactions	Creams, ointments, lotions, solutions	According to MASCC directives, preventive use of steroids to be applied topically prevents and heals radiation dermatitis - there is no standard for the type of topical steroid to be used in the radiation oncology population. The concentration, frequency, and duration of steroid applications vary by institution. Long use of steroids is not indicated because of side effects. Steroid preparations are used together with emollients	Mometasone furoate, hydrocortisone	[30]
Washing (cleansing)	Help remove contaminants such as dirt, perspiration, oil, dead skin cells form the skin within the treatment area, supports cleansing, reduces potential bacterial and biological burden at the treatment site	Soaps, synthetic detergents	Because of its high pH, soap disturbs the hydro-lipid balance of the skin which might lead to irritations and bacterial overgrowth Synthetic detergents do not contain soap, they are based on surfactants, they are neutral or slightly acidic. More strongly recommended for the therapy of oncology patients	Some soaps contain additive antibacterial substances, they also contain humectants additional oils and/or lipids to prevent skin dryness Synthetic detergents also contain free fatty acids, lipids, proteins, preserving the natural epidermal barrier	[30]
Sisnfectant and antiinfective	Cleansing aids in decreasing potential bacterial and bio burden on the treatment site (especially dry and exfoliating)	Solutions, ointments, creams, powder forms	Antibacterial and antifungal preparations for local application are active in the application zone with a minimal systemic absorption	Chlorhexidine gluconate, clotrimazole, miconazole, nystatin, bacitracin, mupirocin, silver sulfadiazine cream	[30,36,37]
Dessicants and astringent agents	They have astringent, antibacterial properties, High humidity can cause skin irritation and maceration	Solutions for compresses, powders	Powders dry out macerated skin and reduce friction by absorbing humidity. Some has tend to clump which may cause irritation. Depending on the applied substance applied, granuloma may appear but also conditions conductive to fungus development	Burrow’s solution (5% aluminium sulfate tetradecahydrate) aluminum chloride solution, corn starch, talk	[30,38]
Barrier measures	Protect the skin against mechanical damage, abrasion by clothes or other parts of the skin. Reduces skin reaction severity	Cremes, ointments, liquids, protective films	Reduce injuries, keep moisture in intact skin and hence the limit potential friction and irradiated skin reactions, thereby reducing radiation injury. Reduction in frequency and duration of moist desquamation.	Create physical film barrier: polymers PVA, copolymer ethylene/acrylic acid, acrylate terpolymer, emollients: coconut oil, dimethicone, mineral oil, Because of high volume of water, liquid and creme preparations must contain preservatives.	[14,18,39]

Their composition should not include any irritating substances, preservatives or colorants. Whereas they are rich in substances rebuilding protective barrier (like free fatty acids, ceramides, squalene, phospholipids), moisturizing (like urea, niacinamide, hyaluronic acid), reducing itching (hemp oil, calendula oil, polidocanol), regenerating, oiling (squalene), soothing (allantoin, panthenol, epigallocatechin gallate) anti-inflammatory, protecting skin from oxidative stress caused by free radicals and environmental factors such as UV radiation or pollution (ascorbic acid, plant extracts or chemical substances isolated from plants: polysaccharides, anthocyanins, galantonin, polyphenols) [30,40]. Their pH is appropriate for sensitive skin. They mostly come as light lotions to prevent unpleasant viscosity and difficulty spreading [2,12].

A separate group of preparations widely applied for skin care and treatment during radiotherapy are dressings: collagen [41,42], hydrogels [43,44,45], based on alginate [46], silicon [47] or containing silver ions [48]. They are applied for soothing the skin friction, preventing irritations, reducing pain, improving comfort or controlling moist peeling [4,30].

1.3. Active Substances in Skin Care Preparations after Radiotherapy

In case of a strong radiation reaction, skin care alone after radiotherapy may be insufficient. In such cases patients receive treatment by topical glucocorticosteroids for their anti-inflammatory action, special dressings and antibiotics [18,30]. Despite general use of steroids and some chemical-containing ointments, e.g., trolamine and biaffine, their prolonged use may cause serious side effects [2].

The main factors that damage skin are the free radicals originating from irradiated water molecules and from granulocytes in the inflammation area (H₂O ≥ H^• + ^•OH + e⁻ + H₃O⁺ + H₂O₂ ≥ e⁻ + O₂ ≥ O₂^•−) [49]. Hence, the use of antioxidant substances including herbal extracts containing antioxidants, capable of neutralizing free radicals and providing protection from ionizing radiation appears as an alternative therapy for radiodermatitis [18,50]. Studies of radioprotective action of herbal extracts components are of immense use because in addition to protecting the normal tissue, they will also permit the use of higher doses of radiation to obtain better cancer control and possible cure. Unfortunately, radioprotective action of many of the substances is limited. These substances possess inadequate clinical application principally due to their inherent systemic toxicity at their optimal protective concentrations [51].

Despite this, herbal extracts are applied in skin care and treatment during radiotherapy. The first research direction concerns their application as diet supplement and as drugs administered either orally or intraperitoneally where they demonstrate radioprotective systemic action. Not only do they act as antioxidants, but they also show a range of beneficial biologic properties such as anti-inflammatory, antiemetic or antibacterial effects which contribute to improvements of patients’ quality of life [52,53,54,55,56]. Another research concerns their introduction into medicated preparations and cosmetics in form of creams, ointments and gels. Applied topically, they act as antioxidants, they reduce irritations and redness, they help heal and protect from UV radiations.

The source of plant materials used for this purpose include crops and harvest from natural stands. As the content of active substances in plants of a given species varies and depends on many factors, they are subject to the process of standardization from processing (collection, drying, stabilization, storage) to clinical study in the process of product development. Standardization is based on the pharmacopoeia standards of a given country or on the basis of quality standards for a given raw material or preparation. The standardized raw material contains a strictly defined amount of ingredients responsible for the therapeutic effect.

Some market products containing herbal extracts for treatment of dermatosis are: My Girls^TM Skin Care, RadiaGel^®, RadiaPlex^® Gel, Medline Remedy^® Lotion, DIFINSA53 Skin Protectant Lotion, Miaderm^® Radiation Relief, Pharmaceris X—Xrays Liposubtilium, AQUASTOP^® Radiotherapy cream, VICCO Turmeric Skin Cream, Holoil^® gel, Holoil^® oil, RayGel, Capilen^® cream, RadioProtect, RadioXar, Radx Oncology Therapy Cream, OnCosmetics.

Some of the above-mentioned preparations are specifically intended for skin care after radiotherapy whereas others are well known for their therapeutic actions, namely anti-inflammatory, antioxidant, and healing. The research of safe and efficient preparations containing herbal extracts is subject to R&D research and clinical trials.

2. Materials and Methods

2.1. Scope

The first attempt to gather all the information concerning the application and the role of herbal extracts in prevention and treatment of radiodermatitis was carried out by Kalekhan et al. [57] and Heydariard et al. [58]. Heydariard and co-workers [58] focused on collecting data from randomized control trials, which compared herbal compounds against a standard medication or placebo treatment or prevention of radiodermatitis. Five dimensions were evaluated: bias related to the errors in the randomization process, bias due to not receiving the desired treatment, bias due to missing data related to the outcome, bias in evaluating and measuring the outcome variables and incomplete or selective reporting outcomes. Kalekhan et al. [57] summarizes clinical observations on the prevention of radiodermatitis by plant products such as: Adlay bran, Aloe vera, Calendula officinalis, Cucumis sativus, honey, Achillea millefolium, Matricaria chamomilla, olive oil and green tea (containing epigallocatechin-3-gallate) and some of polyherbal creams.

As concerns the prevention and treatment of side effects, a lot of recommendations are based on proper experience of radiotherapy centers [23]. That is why in our literature review we summarize recent research aiming at reducing radiation-induced skin injuries by use of proper skin care, using topical preparations with herbal extracts. Our literature review concerns preparations in different physicochemical forms, e.g., gels, emulsions (creams, lotions), ointments. We stress the connection between the type of applied skin care (type of preparation, its composition, the dose), the properties of the herbal extract and the evaluation of its efficiency in preventing and treating radiation reaction on skin.

2.2. Methods

This overview article is limited to a critical analysis of scientific and professional literature (included guidelines, clinical and preclinical studies and reports of clinical trials). Patents and articles in a language other than English were excluded. Animal research and basic laboratory-based research are included. In order to prepare a literature review, search engines such as PubMed, MEDLINE, Scopus, NCBI, Google Scholar, Google Books, and ResearchGate were used. Date of access: 15 December 2021 and revisited on 20 April 2022.

Main search terms chosen were: radiodermatitis treatment; topical agents in treatment radiodermatitis; herbal in radiotherapy; topical antioxidants in radiodermatitis; skin care of patients undergoing radiotherapy; herbal creams; plant extract in prevention of radiodermatitis; Aloe vera extract; Achillea millefolium extract; Azadirachta indica extract; Boswellia serrata extract; Calendula officinalis extract; Centella asiatica extract; Chamomilla recutita extract; Cucumis sativus extract; Glycyrrhiza glabra extract; Green Tea extract; Silymarin extract, Turmeric curcuma longa extract; Nigella sativa extract; Ocimum sanctum extract; Angelica gigas extract; Lithospermum radix extract; Annona muricata extract; Camellia sinensis extract; Hypercium perforatum extract; Thunbergia caurifolia. Relevant research was systematically categorized by name of plant and appraised according to study design. To exclude risk of bias, two authors independently collected and evaluated quality of all selected data and extracted data on recipe and form product, its applications, purpose of study, subjects, methodology, and key findings. Evaluation was based on reviewers’ knowledge. Reference lists of relevant articles were reviewed to identify further studies. The review was performed in accordance with PRISMA guideline. The review was not registered. The protocol was not prepared. Automation tools were not used in the process.

3. Results

The study flowchart for the selection of the relevant research is presented in Figure 1.

Figure 1. The study flowchart for the selection of the relevant research, e.g.,: randomized clinical trail, clinical trial, articles, clinical and preclinical studies.

A total of 327 articles were evaluated, of which 34 are included in review. Summaries of analyzed research are provided in Table 4. Plant species from which the extract was obtained were sorted in alphabetical order.

Table 4. Type of plant, form of the preparation for topical use, the recipe, study descriptions and key findings. Index of abbreviations: ARD—Acute Radiation Dermatitis; ARMSC—Acute Radiation Morbidity Scoring Criteria; ARSR—Acute Radiation Skin Reactions, Radiation-induced Acute Skin Reactions; BC—breast cancer; CT—Clinical trials; CTC—Common Toxicity Criteria; CTCAE—Common Terminology Criteria for Adverse Events; NCI-CTCAE National Cancer Institute Common Terminology for Adverse Events; PL—placebo; QLQ-C30—Core Quality of Life Questionnaire; QoL—Quality of life; RCT—Randomized Clinical Trial; RD—Radiation-induced Dermatitis; RISR—Radiation-induced Skin Reactions; RT—Radiotherapy Treatment; RTOG—Radiation Oncology Group; SARO—Scientific Association of Swiss Radiation Oncology, VAS—Visual Analogue Scale.

Plant	Form of Product	Purpose of Study. Subjects. Methodology. Product Applications	Recipe. Add. Information.	Key Findings of Effectiveness of Action	Comments	Ref.
Achillea millefolium L. (Yarrow)	cream	Assess the effect of Glycyrrhiza glabra L. (Licorice root) and Achillea millefolium (Yarrow) on preventing RD RCT. Patients with BC, who undergone mastectomy, receive RT (50 Gray in 25 fractions, over five weeks) Patients were divided into 3 groups: 1 group received Glycyrrhiza glabra cream, 2 group placebo (vanishing cream base), 3 group Achillea millefolium cream. The rate and grade of radiation dermatitis were recorded at baseline, at the end of third week and at the end of treatment using (RTOG) grading tool. Time of application was of five weeks during RT. Preparations were applied daily. Patients were instructed do not to apply other topical skin care products.	The extract of Achillea millefolium L. and Glycyrrhiza glabra Root were incorporated into a vanishing cream base. Dry Extract constituted 0.6%. Vanishing cream ingredients: Stearic Acid 15%, Cetostearyl Alcohol 2%, Mineral Oil 2%, Borax 1%, Ammonium Hydroxide 28% 1%, Preservative 0.2%, Water 71.2%, Propylene Glycol 4%, Glycerin 3%.	At the end of the third week, the group receiving Achillea millefolium cream showed milder skin complications than other groups. At the end of treatment, rate of skin complications in groups receiving herbal drugs was lower than placebo group but it was not statistically significant. The results of this study did not present a significant difference between Glycyrrhiza glabra, Achillea millefolium L. and placebo on preventing RD.	According to Author, this is the first study that has evaluated the possible protective effect of these herbal drugs against radiotherapy induced skin dermatitis. Achillea millefolium L., especially at lower doses of radiation, might decrease radiation induced dermatitis. There were observed only two cases with grade 1 dermatitis at the end of third week in this group, so more research is required to verify this finding.	[59]
Aloe vera L. Burman	gel ointment	To determine: whether a gel with acemannan extracted from aloe leaves affects the severity of ARSR if so, whether other commercially products (personal lubricating jelly and healing ointment) have similar effect and when the gel with extract should be applied for maximum effect. Male C3H mice received graded single doses of gamma radiation ranging from 30 to 47.5 Gy to the right leg. Groups of mice (gel treated, untreated, jelly-treated, ointment-treated) The right inner thigh of each mouse was scored on a scale of 0 to 3.5 for severity of radiation reaction from the seventh to the 35th day after irradiation. EDSo values, and 95% confidence limits were also obtained. The gel was applied daily to the irradiated area beginning immediately after irradiation. To determine timing of application for best effect, gel was applied beginning on day −7, 0, or +7 relative to the day of irradiation (day 0) and continuing for 1, 2, 3, 4, or 5 weeks.	Wound dressing gel: Purified water, Povidone, Panthenol, Carbomer 940, Triethanolamine, Allantoin, Glutamic acid, Sodium chloride, Methylparaben, Imidazolidinyl urea, Sodium Benzoate, Potassium Sorbate, Acemannan hydrogel, Citric acid, Sodium metabisulfite. Personal lubricating jelly (water soluble hydrogel, similar in solubility and consistency to the accemannan gel): Chlorhexidine gluconate, Gluconodelta lactone, Glycerin, Hydroxyethylcellulose, Methylparaben, Purified water, Sodium hydroxide. Healing ointment: Petrolatum, Mineral oil, Mineral wax, Wool wax Alcohol, Panthenol, Glycerin, Bisabolol (Chamomile essence)	The average peak skin reactions of gel-treated mice were lower than those of the untreated mice at all radiation doses tested. The EDSo values for skin reactions of 2.0–2.75 were approximately 7 Gy higher in the wound dressing gel-treated mice. The average peak skin reactions and the EDSo values for mice treated with personal lubricating jelly or healing ointment were similar to irradiated control values. Reduction in the percentage of mice with skin reactions of 2.5 or more was greatest in the groups that received gel for at least 2 weeks beginning immediately after irradiation.	In this case, Aloe vera leaves were the raw material for extraction of Acemannan. Healing ointment contained the essence of chamomile. The authors of the study tried to define the time for starting the application of the preparation.	[60]
Aloe vera L. Burman	gel	To determine effectiveness aloe vera gel for radiation-induced skin reactions. BC patients undergoing RT to breast and/or chest wall, minimum field 10 × 10 cm and minimum dose 50c Gy. RCT. Two groups: aloe vera gel or PL gel—first phase of trial, aloe vera gel or no treatment—second phase of trial. State of the skin was evaluated—patients self-graded skin reactions and clinical assessment by physician. Rated: severity, time of occurrence and duration of severe dermatitis. The evaluation was carried out once a week. Gel (aloe vera or placebo) was applied to the chest wall by the patient twice a day, starting 3 days within of radiation initiation. Usual skin-care (soap) advice were recommended.	No detailed information available concerning the products recipe and their quality control Aloe vera gel—98% aloe gel plus 2% inert gel for consistency.	Aloe vera gel was not effective. The dermatitis was less severe than expected. Allergic reactions were observed among patients both in groups using aloe vera gel and placebo gel.		[11,12,13,14,15,16,17,18,19,20,21,22,23,24,25,26,27,28,29,30,31,32,33,34,35,36,37,38,39,40,41,42,43,44,45,46,47,48,49,50,51,52,53,54,55,56,57,58,59,60,61]
Aloe vera L. Burman	gel cream	To determine if aloe vera gel is beneficial in reducing skin side-effects of RT when compared with aqueous cream. Women with BC undergoing RT post-lumpectomy or partial mastectomy. RCT. Two group: aloe vera gel and topical aqueous cream. Evaluation of the skin by nurse—limitation of side-effects such as erythema, pain, itching, dry desquamation, moist desquamation. Standard care was recommended on top of preparations application. Topical products were applied by patients three times a day after treatment and for 2 weeks after completing care. Weekly skin assessments were performed by nursing staff.	No information available concerning the products recipe and their quality control.	Aqueous cream was significantly better than aloe vera gel in reducing dry desquamation and treatment-related pain. Allergic reactions were observed in patients using both gel and cream.	No information available to objectively evaluate the efficiency of the study (including the dose of radiation administered to patients).	[11,12,13,14,15,16,17,18,19,20,21,22,23,24,25,26,27,28,29,30,31,32,33,34,35,36,37,38,39,40,41,42,43,44,45,46,47,48,49,50,51,52,53,54,55,56,57,58,59,60,61,62]
Aloe vera L. Burman	gel cream	Compare effectiveness of an anionic polar phospholipid (APP)-based cream and an aloe vera-based gel in preventing and treating RD. Pediatric patients with various diagnoses (RT with at least 23.4 Gy dose). Subject’s skin comfort, dermatologic assessment, and CTC were evaluated. The study was carried out before, during and after completion of treatment (4–6 weeks). APP cream and aloe vera gel were symmetrically applied within the irradiated field after each treatment.	Aloe vera (market product) contain: D-panthenol, Triethanoloamine, Carbomer 943P, Hyaluronic acid, Potassium Sorbate, Diazolidinyl Urea, Methylparaben, Propylparaben. APP skin cream (Ocular Research of Boston) is an oil-in-water emulsion, not commercially available. Include: triglycerides and phospholipids, Benzyl Alcohol, Methylparaben, Propyl paraben, Diaxolipinyl urea.	APP cream improves skin comfort variables such as: dry, soft, feels good, rough, smooth and dermatologic variables: dryness, erythema and peely as compared with aloe vera gel (statistically significant differences). APP cream is more effective in prevention and treatment of RD. Grouped CTC scores were supportive of APP cream. In comparing the first and last assessments, two dermatologic variables, dryness and peely, favored APP cream.	Results in concordance with Boosley’s study [63]	[64]
Aloe vera L. Burman	cream powder	Test the efficacy of quality-tested Aloe vera extract in reducing the severity of radiation-induced skin injury. Examine the effect of a moist cream versus a dry powder skin care regimen. RCT. Patients with BC, previous mastectomy or segmental resection. RT (45–50 Gy). Acute skin toxicity was scored weekly and after treatment at weeks 1, 2, and 4 using a modified 10-point Catterall scale. The patients scored their symptom severity using a 6-point Likert scale and kept an acute phase diary. Standard radiation skin care guidelines were complied. The patients apply nonmetallic baby powder or cornstarch to the irradiated intact skin during the treatment course followed by 1 month of Glaxal base cream twice daily. If they developed moist desquamation, they were advised to discontinue the powder. Patients apply approximately 2.5 cm3 of cream to the irradiated skin, 3 times daily (avoid application within 3 h of radiation) throughout the course of radiation and for 1 month after radiation. Treatment of moist desquamation and other skin reactions, such as infection, was according to each physician’s pattern of practice. Any prescribed treatment was to be applied 30 min before the use of the study creams.	Placebo cream contain: Aquatrix II, Lexamul 56, Methylparaben, Dimethicone, Isopropyl Myristate, Propylene Glycol, Cetyl Alcohol, Stearic acid, triethanolamine. The aloe cream formulation was 30 mg of the processed aloe (1000–5000 MW fraction) per 100 cm3 of placebo cream. This represents the highest concentration possible without causing cream demulsification and is relatively equivalent to 50 mg of the 1000 to 5000 MW fraction of unprocessed fresh leaf gel extract.	The aloe formulation did not reduce acute skin toxicity or symptom severity. Study speaks in favor of dry care instead of introducing herbal extracts into creams or applying creams only.	Were excluded from the study people with confirmed allergy to Aloe vera. Placebo cream was chosen for its ability to penetrate the outermost skin layers and therefore to theoretically enable absorption of the aloe elemental components. The study included also the analysis of the extract itself introduced into the recipe of the cream. Such as: murine bioassay testing under the supervision of 1 of us (F.S.). The assay testing was conducted to determine whether the aloe oligosaccharides that prevent ultraviolet B (UVB)-induced immune suppression of T-cell-mediated immune responses were active in this study. The mechanism of aloe skin protection is unknown, and this element might be necessary for aloe extract to be effective in reducing RSR severity.	[65]
Aloe vera L. Burman	lotion	Evaluation of aloe vera lotion for prevention of RD. CT. Patients with a prescription of RT to a minimum dose of 40 Gy, were treatment area could be divided into two symmetrical halves. The grade of dermatitis in each half was recorded (according to RTOG) weekly until 4 weeks after the end of radiotherapy. In the case of symptomatic dermatitis, topical corticosteroids were prescribed to the patients to use on the entire treatment area. Lotion were use twice daily from the beginning of treatment until 2 weeks after the end of RT, with no medication to be used on the other half.	Market product. The recipe contains: Lanolin oil, Glyceryl Stearate, Diluted Collagen, Tocopherol, Allantoin, and paraben.	Age and radiation field size had a significant effect on the grade of dermatitis. The prophylactic use of Aloe vera reduces the intensity of radiation induced dermatitis. The effect was more evident in patients undergoing radiotherapy with larger treatment field and higher doses of radiation.	The study verified the quantity (dose) of the lotion used.	[66]
Aloe vera L. Burman	gel soap	Determine whether the use of mild soap and aloe vera gel versus mild soap alone would decrease the incidence of skin reactions in patients undergoing RT. RCT. Oncological patients qualified for the RT. Group of patients applying mild soap and additional aloe vera gel and second group—control treatment used only soap. RTOG Acute Radiation Morbidity scale assessed weekly by physician or nurse. Unscented soap plus aloe vera gel or soap was applied liberally to the affected area daily after the RT in case of gel reapplied through day. Gel was washed off before RT. Standard care was recommended.	No information available concerning the composition, the quality assessment of the products. Gel without other active components	Aloe vera gel seemed to offer a protective effect over soap alone when the cumulative dose increased over time. At low cumulative dose levels no difference existed in the effect of adding aloe to soap regimen.	Soap is not a typical product to compare. Besides, the differences in treatment depended on the radiation doses applied and those were different for the control group and for the group using gel with aloe and soap which leads to conflicting results.	[67]
Aloe vera L. Burman	gel cream	Compare a anionic phospholipid-based (APP) cream and an aloe vera-based gel in the prevention and treatment of radiation dermatitis RCT. Pediatric patients treated by radiotherapy (dose of 23.4 Gy). Control group use APP cream. Subject skin comfort and dermatologic assessments were conducted before and weekly during treatment. Photography was performed at each evaluation time point and patients were seen 4–6 weeks after the completion of RT. CTC was used. Aloe vera-based gel or APP cream were applied symmetrically, once a day by nurse daily next to the radiation area after RT.	No information available concerning the composition and the quality assessment of the products.	APP-based cream showed a statistically significant advantage over aloe vera gel for skin comfort and dermatological assessment variables. Cream reduced dryness, redness, desquamation. No changes in CTC score before and after the treatment.	Complete data unavailable for objective evaluation of the study.	[11,63]
Aloe vera L. Burman	cream oil	To evaluate the efficacy of topical application of an aloe vera-based cream (AVC) for the prevention of ionizing RD. Clinical study. Head and neck cancer patients requiring therapeutic radiation treatment (dose >62 Gy). Patients were treated with AVC or Johnson Baby Oil (JBO). Acute skin reaction was monitored and classified according to RTOG four-point rating scale on a weekly basis. The preparation was applied 5 times per day at defined timespans after RT. During the study it was recommended not to use other preparations. When moist desquamation occurred, the topical application of JBO or ACV was discontinued topically and continued on the remaining skin area.	AVC and JBO are is market products Composition unavailable. Application: 5 cm3 JBO and 5 g AVC.	There was a statistically significant delay in the incidence of dermatitis at week three in the AVC application group. Application of AVC reduced the incidence of Grade 1, 2, and 3 dermatitis at subsequent time points, while Grade 4 dermatitis was not seen in either cohort. Continued application of AVC two weeks after the completion of RT was effective in reducing the average grade of dermatitis and was statistically significant.	This research and research with [67] indicate the usefulness of Aloe vera in delaying and mitigating dermatitis and promoting recovery. The action of this preparation is linked to the antioxidant properties of the Aloe vera. Plants from the aloe vera family decrease UVB-induced nociception, leukocyte infiltration, inflammation, and edema. Additionally, are effective in scavenging reactive oxygen and protecting DNA [68,69,70].	[71]
Aloe vera L. Burman	gel lotion	A non-blinded three armed study of the effect of aloe vera gel, Essex lotion and no lotion on erythema was performed. BC patients who had undergone total mastectomy. Treatment with high-energy electrons (total dose 50 Gy). For measuring the erythema Near Infrared Spectroscopy, Laser Doppler Imaging and Digital Colour Photography were applied. Measurements were performed before the start of RT and there after once a week during the course of treatment. Aloe vera gel and Essex lotion were applied twice every radiation day in selected sites.	Aloe vera gel: Aloe barbadensis 97%, Aqua, Carbomer, Sodium Hydroxide, Phenoxyethanol, Methylparben, Butylparben, Ethylparben, Propylparben. Essex lotion consists of: Aqua, Petrolatum, Glycerin, Methyl Glucose Sesquistearate, Dimethicone, PEG-20, Palmitic acid, Steric acid, Cetyl Alcohol, Xanthan Gum, Magnesium Aluminum Silicate, Carbomer, Sodium Hydroxide.	The extent of erythema developed differed between patients. Some of them developed more severe erythema; however, no one had to stop their radiation treatment because of severe skin reactions. No significant median differences were observed between the pairs no lotion-Essex, no lotion-Aloe vera and Essex-Aloe vera for any of the techniques tested.	As indicated in manuscript Essex lotion is a commonly used lotion that is not registered as a medical product and therefore there are no specific recommendations for its use.	[72]
Aloe vera L. Burman	gel	Whether the adjunctive use of aloe vera gel might reduce the prevalence and/or severity of radiotherapy induced dermatitis. Randomized study patients with newly diagnosed BC (total dose 50 Gy). One group received aloe vera gel. Second group no treatment during RT. The patients were examined weekly by 2 physicians and dermatitis grade was registered (according ARMSC). In case of patients with second or higher degree dermatitis, additional local or systemic treatment such as antibiotics, corticosteroid or analgesics were applied. Aloe vera gel was applied twice a day in at least six hour intervals with a thickness of 1–2 mm on the radiation therapy field.	Aloe vera gel contain 1% additive such as: pectin, vitamin C and Natamycin	After 2 weeks first dermatitis was found among patients of both groups. Comparing the time of occurrence of dermatitis and their degree, no significant statistic difference were observed in both groups. Aloe vera gel did not show positive effect on prevalence or severity of radiation dermatitis in this study.		[73]
Aloe vera L. Burman Turmeric curcuma longa L. Valeton Azadirachta indica A. Juss. Ocimum sanctum Linn	paste	Evaluation of efficacy and safety herbal paste compared to Beblomethasone cream in prevention radiation induced skin injury. CT. Patients of head and neck carcinoma. First group—patients received Beclomethasone cream. Second group received herbal paste. To assess radiation-induced reaction RTOG score were applied and group I versus group II compered. EORTC QLC-C30 was used for QoL assessment. Preparations were topically applied from the day-1 of radiotherapy till 4-weeks after completion of RT.	Paste was properly mixed with 100 g of Aloe vera juice and fresh Ocimum sanctum leaves, Azadirachta indica leaves (50 g each) and Curcuma longa roots (5 g). Herbal plants have been grounded up before mixing.	During the timespans of the study, i.e., after the 4th, 5th, 7th week and also after 6 months, skin reactions were less severe within the group using herbal preparation. On evaluating EORTC QLC-C30, on functional scale, physical, emotional, cognitive and role functioning deteriorated in Group 1 patients (except social functioning), while in Group patients all these modalities showed improvement at 6 months post-treatment. Evaluation on symptom scale revealed that fatigue, pain, dyspnea, appetite loss and insomnia got worsened in Beclomethasone group, except for diarrhea, constipation and nausea or vomiting, while in herbal pasta group patients, all 9 symptoms showed improvement 6 months after of completion of treatment.	Aloe vera was the basis for the powdered plants. Patients known to be allergic to ingredients of herbal paste or with allergy to steroids were excluded from study. No information available on the Gy dose applied to patients.	[74,75]
Angelica gigas NakaiLithospermum erythrorhizonSiebold and Zucc.	ointment	Efficiency and security evaluation of adjuvant application of Jaungo (JUG) for RD in comparison with general supportive care (GSC). RTC. Women with unilateral BC, after breast conservation surgery, undergoing RT, (total dose >45 Gy). Both groups will be subjected to GSC, but only the JUG group participants will apply adjuvant JUG ointment on the irradiated skin, twice a day (not applied within 4 h of daily RT). Treatment started at onset of RT and continued until 4 weeks after RT was completed or until radiation dermatitis subsided. Assessment of incidence rate of RD using the RTOG for toxicity gradation of 2 or more. Onset and duration of RD, and maximum pain score were also evaluated. GSC—skin clean and dry by gentle washing with neutral pH soap and patting with soft towel. No prophylactic creams or lotions for radiation dermatitis were allowed to either group.	Jaungo is a herbal ointment consisting of Angelica gigas radix (60.6 mg/g) and Lithospermum radix (72.7 mg/g). Carriers: Sesame Seed Oil, Beeswax, Swine Oil. Bioactive constituents shikonin 0.07 mg/g, decursin 3.6 mg/g.	JUG reduced the incidence of grade >2 and grade >3 RD in comparison with GSC. Delayed the onset of grade 2 dermatitis in terms of time onset of grade 3 and duration dermatitis and maximum pain score showed results comparable to those achieved with GSC, no adverse effect was observed.	Because of a low number of patients (29), the authors recommended further studies with a bigger sample of people. Those studies are currently ongoing [76] and [77]. In this article market product (composition unavailable) was compared with emulsion w/o (X-derm)—composition unavailable.	[78]
Angelica gigas NakaiLithospermum erythrorhizonSiebold and Zucc.	ointment	Estimate clinical application of Shiunko for reducing complications related to cancer treatment such as RD and hand foot syndrome induced by molecular target drugs. Various groups of patients took part in the research: 1st group patients with simple scalp dermatitis induced by RT for brain tumors. 2nd group: severe dermatitis from concurrent treatment with chemotherapy and RT for cancers including nasopharyngeal cancer. 3th group patients with dermal complications caused by molecular target drugs including hand-foot syndrome. Shiunko was applied in the same manner as in the treatment with standard ointment. The efficiency was assessed by defining the improvement degree—excellent (more than 80%), good (more than 50%), fair (less than 50%), and no effect (less than 30%). In comparison people were treated by corticosteroid.	Recipe unavailable.	Ointment is effective in treatment of scalp dermatitis caused by radiation and dermal complications induced by molecular target drugs since favorable therapeutic effects were observed in all group of patients. Shiunko showed prominent analgesic effect in all cases which were not achieved in corticosteroid treatment but also promoted healing in areas eroded by radiations.	Ointment Shiunko is the JUG ointment JUG, the same as in the study [78]. In our document we only showed cases treated with this ointment and its positive effect. No information available on the group using placebo.	[79]
Annona muricata L.	cream	Investigate the protective effects of Annona muricata leaf polysaccharide (ALP) on radiation induced skin injuries by using in vitro and in vivo models. Normal human epidermal keratinocytes (NHEKs) irradiated cell using 137Cs source in a Gammacell 40 Exactor. The dose rate used was 1 Gy/min. Performed cell viability, terminal deoxynucleotidyl transferase-mediated dUTP nic-end labeling assay and annexin V/propidium iodide (PI) staining to detect apoptosis. Pro-inflammatory cytokines (level of TNF-IL-6, and IL-1ß in the cell culture supernatants) were measured using ELISA. The mice were divided into five groups: (1) Normal group; (2) Irradiation + vehicle cream group; (3) Irradiation + 0.04% ALP (w/v) cream; (4) Irradiation + 0.2% ALP cream. The skin on the back was topically treated with 100 µL of vehicle or ALP cream for 7 days before and after irradiation. After treatment, mouse’s skin was under histopathological observation.	Vehicle cream: Water, Butyl Hydroxyl Toluene (0.001%), Dibasic Potassium Phosphate (0.2%), Cetyl Alcohol (0.5%), polyglyceryl-3-methylglucose distearate (5%). ALP extract was added to the vehicle cream at concentrations of 0.04 or 0.2%.	In normal human epidermal keratinocytes (NHEKs), ALP treatments reduced irradiation-induced apoptosis by increasing antioxidant enzymes activities, including (SOD) and catalase. Furthermore, ALP treatments decreased levels of interleukin-1ß, nucleotide-binding domain and leucine-rich-repeat-containing family pyrin 3 (NLRP3), and cleavage of caspase-1 and caspase-3. The topical application of the ALP cream showed protective efficacy against irradiation exposure, including the reduction of epidermal thickening, as well as an increase in the number of apoptotic cells and antioxidant enzyme (SOD and catalase) activities in skin tissue. ALP can be potentially used to treat radiation-induced skin injuries.	To determine whether ALP protects gamma irradiation- induced cell death by regulating antioxidant enzymes and in flammasome complexes, Authors analyzed the intracellular antioxidant enzymes activity and levels of pro inflammator cytokines. Hence, they are ones of the first studies of antioxidant action. Defines the mechanism of action of polysaccharides isolated from the extract and, based on that, the action of the cream, not only clinical studies or skin observation.	[2]
Boswellia serrata Roxb. ex Colebr.	cream	The cream was evaluated in terms of its safety, efficiency for the prevention and relief of radiation induced adverse effects. Clinical study. Patients adjuvant RT after surgery for mammary carcinoma. All measures, including photographic evaluations, were performed after the patients received a dose/breast of 50 Gy, usually reached in 5 weeks of irradiation, 5 doses weekly. Skin reactions were evaluated clinically using visual intensity and computer assisted skin color analysis whereas the toxicity was assessed according to RTOG scale. Visual grading scale: slight (slight redness, spotty, and diffuse), moderate (moderate and uniform redness), intense (intense redness). Cream was applied twice daily: immediately after RT and before bed-time in radiation therapy days, in the morning and at night in days with no radiotherapy administration.	Boswellia cream (2%, Bosexil) and placebo cream composition is unavailable. However, based on a cosmeceutical formulation based on Boswellic acids for the treatment of erythematous eczema and psoriasis [80] Bosexil contains: Aqua, Glycerin; Lecithin, Boswellia Serrata Resin Extract; Disodium Ethylenediaminotetraacetic Acid, Imidazolidinyl Urea, Polyacrylamide, C13-C14 Isoparaffin, Laureth-7, Hydrogenated polydecane, Carpylic/Capric Trigliceryde, Lecithin, Tocopherol, Ascorbyl Palmitate, Citric Acid, Phenoxyethanol.	Those studies indicate that applying cream with Boswellia S. is efficient for limiting the use of topical corticosteroids and can reduce the erythema and external dermal symptoms. The degree of reduction depended on the intensity of changes. The results in terms of visual intensity revealed that erythema was recorded as intense in a higher number of patients treated with base cream, compared with patients treated with boswellia cream (49.0% vs. 22.0%). Slight and moderate intensity of erythema were scored more frequently in the boswellia cream group than in base cream group: 36.4% vs. 20.3% and 41.8% vs. 30.5%, respectively. The mode values of the intensity of erythema for these samples were: intense (70.7%) for the base cream group and slight (62.5%) for the boswellia cream group.	It is not clear if 2% is the concentration of the extract in the recipe or the concentration of boswellic acids extracted from Boswellia serrata—those acids have anti-inflammatory properties. B. serrata extract reduces skin reddening and irritation, they even out the color and sooth the skin. According to the authors, further studies are necessary to compare with other topical preparations.	[81]
Calendula officinalis L.	ointment	Compare the effectiveness of calendula ointment with trolamine. Patients operated on for BC, received postoperative RT (2 Gy per session, five session per week). RTC. Two groups: 1st applied trolamine, 2nd calendula on the irradiated fields after each session. Occurrence of acute dermatitis of grade 2 or higher, occurrence of pain, the quantity of topical agent used, and patient satisfaction were investigated. Prognostic factors, including treatment modalities and patient characteristics, were also examined. Preparations were applied twice a day or more, depending on the occurrence of dermatitis and pain, until completion radiotherapy (not to use the agent 2 h or less before an irradiation session or before the treatment evaluation). Acute dermal toxicity was evaluated according to the RTOG scale at each irradiated volume. Pain was assessed each week on a 10-cm visual analog scale (VAS). No other prophylactic creams, lotions, or gels were allowed. Physicians can treat established dermatitis of grade 2 or higher and/or allergy as they considered appropriate.	Calendula ointment (market product) fabricated from a plant of the marigold family, Calendula officinalis. The digest is obtained by incubation at 75 °C in petroleum jelly to extract the liposoluble components of the plant.	The occurrence of acute dermatitis of grade 2 or higher was significantly lower (41% vs. 63%) with the use of calendula ointment than with trolamine. Patients receiving calendula has less frequent interruption of RT and significantly reduced radiation induced pain.	Trolamine is considered in many medical institutions as reference topical agent, Calendula ointment was more difficult to apply, but self-assessed satisfaction was greater.	[82,83]
Calendula officinalis L.	cream	Compare Calendula Weleda cream versus Essex cream in reducing the risk of serve ARSR. RCT. Patients with BC (2 Gy five day a week, total dose 50 Gy). ARSR was assessed by the nurse based on the RTOG score. Cream was applied twice a day, starting at the onset of RT and continuing until two weeks after final RT session or until ARSR was healed. Application topical agent include whole treatment area. Patients do not apply the cream within two hours of their RT. Daily washing with perfume-free soap and tap water were advised.	Calendula Weleda cream (market product) contains extract of Marigold Plants Officinalis 10%, Wool fat and Sesame Oil. Detailed composition not available. Essex cream probably contains: Water, Petrolatum, Liquid Paraffin. Both products contain no perfume nor coloring agent.	No differences in ARSR between calendula cream and aqueous cream and in patient reported symptoms (pain, burning, itching, pulling, tenderness) from the treatment area at any of the evaluation points. Thus, there is no reason to recommend one of the studied skin care product over the other.	Patients describe the calendula cream to be more difficult in application and absorption when compared to the Essex cream. Probably because it contains Wool fat. Essex patients were strongly advised to refrain from using other topical agents in the irradiated area. Calendula cream used in this study was not the same market product as the one used in Pommier [82] study (however, both contained 10% extract), besides, possible differences in efficiency can result from the reference sample, in this case Essex cream.	[83,84]
Calendula officinalis L.	lotion cream	Compare Calendula topical lotion efficacy versus standard of care sorbolene in reducing the prevalence of RD. RCT. Women undergoing BC RT, treatment phase up to 6 weeks Evaluate a prevalence of acute radiation-induced dermatitis (RTOG grade 2+) assessed at multiple skin sites. Participants were encouraged to begin applying their treatment 2–3 days prior to commencement of radiation therapy.	Calendula lotion (<5% v/v): Calendula tincture and extract, Lecithin, Glycerine, Ethanol, Xanthan Gum, Distilates (Rose, Chamomile, witch hazel, extracts (Citrus, Gum, Rosemary), Rice Bran Oil, Ascorbic acid, Wheatgerm Oil, Arrowroot, Guar Gum, Sodium Hyaluronate, Lactacid acid. Sorbolene: 10% glycerin in cetomacrogol cream other ingredients: Ceteareth-20, Cetearyl Alcohol, Glycerin, Mineral oil, p-chloro-m-cresol, Petrolatum, Aqua.	No detectable difference in prevalence of radiation-induced dermatitis grade 2+ between Calendula and Sorbolene groups.	Study carried out on a small group of people. People with allergy to Marigold, salicylate, or taking aspirin were excluded from study.	[85]
Calendula officinalis L.	oil	Efficiency evaluation of Calendula officinalis in relation to Essential Fatty Acids (EFA) for prevention and treatment of RD. RCT. Patients with head and neck cancer, received RT. Two groups: control applied EFA and experimental used Calendula oil. Radiodermatitis were assessed by the toxicity grade, according to the criteria RTOG. The participant’s skin in the irradiation field was evaluated in the first radiotherapy session, every five sessions and 30 days after the end of treatment. The evaluation of skin toxicity was performed by a team of trained researchers. Participants applied EFA or calendula topically. Research protocol: mode of application—application to the skin with a gauze soaked with the product of research in all treatment field every 12 h (twice/day), from the first to the last day of RT session; first application—hospital: conducted by the research collaborator—average of 10 cm3/application; during application, study participant and/or family member.	EFA: Sunflower Oil, 1% Vitamin A, 0.2% Vitamin E and 5% Caprylic acid Calendula oil: 4% Calendula Oil, 1% Vitamin A and Liquid vaseline.	Statistically significant evidence that the proportion of radiodermatitis grade 2 in EFA group is higher than Calendula group. Lower risk of developing radiodermatitis grade 1, form experimental group, it makes the usage of Calendula oil more effective.	Excluded patients with allergic reaction in the use of one of the research products (EFA or Calendula officinalis). Due to the physicochemical form of the products, they were applied to gauze.	[86]
Calendula officinalis L.	ointment	Evaluation of anti-inflammatory action and of the impact on ionizing radiation induced skin toxicity of the extract from Calendula officinalis (CO) and Ching Wan Hung (CWH)—ointment. SKH-hr1 hairless mice (10 Gy/day for 4 days). Skin toxicity and inflammatory factors (Serum interleukin (IL)-1α monocyte, chemotactic protein-1 (MCP1), keratinocyte-derived chemokine (KC), and granulocyte colony-stimulating factor (G-CSF)) were evaluated at multiple time points up to15 days post-radiation. Mice were evaluated every 2 days following IR with and without topical treatment of CO and CWH. IR-induced skin reactions, erythema, blood vessel dilation, and crust/scaling, were noted. Gross assessment of early radiation dermatitis, erythema, edema, dyspigmentation, desquamation, exudation, and ulceration, was conducted using the dermatoscope. Skin toxicity was evaluated and scored as either 0 (no visible lesion), 1 (moderate lesion), or 2 (severe lesion), for both erythema and blood vessel dilation.	CWH is a Chinese herbal ointment which is sold as an over-counter soothing lotion for burns. Some of the active ingredients include: lobelia (27.5%), myrrh (17.5%), tangkuei (12%), borneol (12%), sanguisorba (8.5%), chaenomeles (8.5%), frankincense (8.5%), carthamus (8.5%), and pistacia (8.5%), CO extract to ointment available with the trade name Pommade au Calendula Par Digestion. Contains the extract in 4% concentration.	Both CO and CWH significantly inhibited IR-induced MCP1 KC and G-CSF. IR-induced erythema and blood vessel dilation were significantly reduced by CWH but not by CO at day 10 post-IR. Both agents inhibited IR-induced IL-1α, MCP1 and vascular endothelial growth factor. There were continuous inhibitory effects of CWH on IR-induced skin toxicities and inflammation. In contrast, CO treatment resulted in skin reactions compared to IR alone both CO and CWH reduce IR-induced inflammation and CWH reduced IR-induced erythema.	Looking at the composition, it is not surprising that the preparation with higher quantity of active substances showed better result. The same market product as in Pommier study [82].	[87]
Centella asiaticaL.	cream	Attempted to determine whether prophylactic treatment with herbal creams as well as a commercial moisturizing cream could reduce acute skin reaction RCT. BC patients undergoing RT (total physical dose 40-5-Gy). 5 different groups: 1—no treatment (standard care, no creams or substances). Other groups using creams containing respectively extracts from Centella asiatica L., Cucumis sativus L., Thunbergia laurifolia or using moisturizing market product (Johnson and Johnson). Participants’ skin was evaluated by an oncologist-radiologist weekly up to one month after the irradiation in order to identify all kinds of dermatologic reaction (according to RTOG score). Satisfaction with the preparation was also evaluated (scale 1–5 with 5 being mostly satisfied and 1 being least). Creams were applied once a day after the first session of radiotherapy up to one month after the irradiation.	Centella asiatica 7% (w/w) Information on other components unavailable. They do not contain fragrance. Market creams available in Thailand.	Topical application of all herbal cream or the moisturizing cream could neither reduce the severity nor delay onset of dermatitis compared with no treatment group. Cucumis sativus cream was shown to help with skin recovery post-irradiation. Study authors advise to prophylactically use moisturizing preparations on the irradiated area of skin.	One clinical study which evaluated three plants Centella asiatica L., Cucumis sativus L., Thunbergia laurifolia. Before the study allergic tests were made for unwanted reaction to the extracts and the moisturizing cream.	[88]
Chamomilla recutita L. Rauschert (Matricaria chamomilla L.)	gel cream	Assessed safety and potential efficacy of a chamomile gel compared with urea cream to prevent and delay acute RD. Before starting the comparative clinical study chamomile gel in various concentrations was analyzed: 2.5%, 5.00% and 8.35%. Considering the effectiveness and the safety, the concentration of 8.35% was chosen for the clinical study. Safety assessment was based on the presence or absence of skin toxicity according to RTOG score and time to development of erythema, measured as number of sessions of radiation therapy before erythema development. RCT. Patients with head and neck cancer receiving RT with or without concomitant CT. Group chamomile gel comparing with urea cream group. Nurse was evaluated the person’s skin weekly (skin toxicity according RTOG score) until the end of treatment. Photographs of the regions of the participant’s head and neck on a weekly basis were taken. During the study, it was recommended to use skin care with a moisturizing soap (DoveTM) and not to apply any products to the irradiated area to avoid undesirable bolus effects. Product were applied topically 3 times a day (morning, afternoon and night) on the skin of the irradiated area for the entire period of the RT (5 day week for 6–8 week).	Data about composition not available. Both product’s validity was 3 months.	The gel containing 8.35% chamomile was still safe when compared to concentrations of 2.5% and 5.0% used by participants receiving RT for head and neck cancer. Increasing concentrations tended to delay the development of erythema in those participants. Formulation of 8.35% chamomile gel was not statistically different from urea cream in the delay the development of grades 1 (2.08 to 2.2 weeks) and 2 (5.1 weeks to 4.5 weeks) RD, though the effect size of delay of Grade 2 was of moderate size. No statistical differences over time were seen between the groups on adverse events. Itching, burning and hyperpigmentation were more frequently reported in the urea group.	According to the Brazilian Health Surveillance Agency (Agęncia de Vigilância Sanitária—ANVISA), products made of Chamomile recutita do not require proof of safety because chamomile is already registered at the Brazilian Simplified Registry of Traditional Phytotherapic Products. The study in which the concentration of the active substance was defined before starting the comparative study.	[89,90]
Cucumis sativus L.	cream	the same as in Centella asiatica L. research [88]	Cucumis sativus L. 20% (w/w) No information available on remaining components. They do not contain fragrance. Market creams available in Thailand	Topical application of all herbal cream or the moisturizing cream could neither reduce the severity nor delay onset of dermatitis compared with no treatment group. Cucumis sativus cream was shown to help with skin recovery post-irradiation. It is related to the high content of water and soothing properties reducing irritations and skin oedema in cucumber. Cucumber cream proved efficient in regeneration of irradiated skin which most probably is also linked to the presence of tannins and flavonoids.	One clinical study analyzing three plants: Centella asiatica L., Cucumis sativus L., Thunbergia laurifolia. Before the study there were allergic tests made to check on side effects of the extracts and moisturizing creams. Cucumber has protective effects against both reactive oxygen species and reactive carbonyl species by free radical scavenging activity.	[88]
Glycyrrhiza glabra Torr. (Licorice root)	cream	The same as in Achillea milefolium L. research [59]	The same as in Achillea milefolium L. research [59]	The same as in Achillea milefolium L. research [59]	The same as in Achillea milefolium L. research	[59]
Green tee Black tee	cream compress of aqueous tea extracts	To explore the effect of topically-applied tea extracts on the duration of radiation-induced skin toxicity. Patients with head, neck or pelvis area cancer undergoing RT (daily fractions of 1.8–2.0 Gy). During the study, patients used standard skin care program which consisted of once-daily treatment with moisturizing creme. In case of erythema, the cream was applied 2–3 times and stopped with occurrence of moist desquamation. Green or black tea extracts were applied to the irradiated skin area with lesions of 2nd degree and higher (RTOG score) 3 times per day for 10 min from the occurrence of moist desquamation. Dermal toxicity was evaluated daily by the qualified medical personnel before each extract application. The disappearance of moist desquamation was considered as the end of the study. Tea extracts were compared for their ability to modulate IL-1ß, IL-6, IL-8, TNFα and PGE2 release from human monocytes. Effects of tea extracts on 26S proteasome function were also assessed and NF-κβ activity was monitored by EMSAs. Viability and radiation response of macrophages after exposure to tea extracts was measured by MTT assays.	Moisturizing cream—market preparation containing 3% of urea.	Tea extracts are effective for treatment of patients suffering from acute dermal toxicity caused by irradiation. Tea extracts supported the restitution of skin integrity, inhibited proteasome function and suppressed cytokine release. NF-κβ activity was altered by tea extracts in a complex, caspase dependent manner, which differed from the effects of epigallocatechin gallate. Analyzed tea extracts, as well as epigallocatechin-gallate, slightly protected macrophages from ionizing radiation. The molecular mechanisms underlying the beneficial effects are complex, and most likely not exclusively dependent on effects of tea polyphenols such as epigallocatechin-gallate. No difference between green and black tea in duration of grade 2+ skin reactions in patients treated for cancer of the head and neck region.	There is no information, if without the application of moisturizing cream the extracts effect on skin would be the same.	[91]
Camellia sinensis L. Kuntze (Chinese tea)	gel lotion cream	Evaluation of the effectiveness for the preparations with Camellia Sinesis Nonfermentatum extract (CSNF) (NPE®) in prevention and recovery of ARSR and skin care during postoperative whole breast RT. Open label Pilot-study. 20 patients received adapted post-operatory radiotherapy (45 Gy/20 fraction boost: 10–15 Gy/4–6 fractions or ± whole breast: 40 Gy/15 fractions). Data from these study were compared with 100 retrospectively collected matched data sets derived from hospital records. These routine medical care patients were treated according to the hospital treatment guidelines and recommendations of the SASRO. The assessments of ARSR Grades 1, 2, 3, and 4 were performed according to CTCAE. Lotion (0.4% CSNF) was applied 2x per day 7 days before RT—during RT on irradiated zones (but not directly before the RT), 4–8 weeks after RT if necessary. CSNF prophylactic gel (2.5%) was applied 1–2 h before each RT session on the day of irradiation. Irradiated zones were: thoracic and supraclavicular zones, front and back.	Composition unavailable. The only information available concerns the % of extract in the given form of preparation and that the extract is proprietary. Comparative preparations were various market preparations such as Excipial® hydrolotion (oil-in-water emulsion containing urea), Bepanthol® body lotion or Bepanthen® cream (preparations contained dexpanthenol and sodium hyaluronate or sodium hyaluronate and silver sulfadiazine.	The study showed that combined use of gel and CSNF balsam retarded the occurrence of ARSR ≥ G2 and can reduce the risk of moist desquamation of irradiated skin by 50%. The proportion of patients requiring rescue treatment during RT and follow-up was markedly higher in the control compared to the CSNF group (1% to 51% vs. 0% to 15%). CSNF gel and lotion were well tolerated both during and after RT. Camellia Sinensis Nonfermentatum Extract is potentially effective in healing skin irritation in women with breast cancer.	Comparative studies with the data from hospital files. The first study in which two types of skin care preparations were used, they contained the extract from a given plant but there was no comparison with the placebo group. According to Authors, preparations containing oils cannot be used directly before the RT because they can increase the risk of skin irritation following radiation concentration in tissues. The CSNF extract reduces oxidative stress and DNA damage, downregulates numerous factors related to apoptosis, inflammation, and carcinogenesis in experimental studies, and showed a similar protective effect for skin of healthy volunteers exposed to UV-light.	[92]
Hypericum perforatum L.	ointment (gel) oil	Effectiveness of Holoil® series in treatment of acute skin toxicity (G2 acute). Sigle-arm, prospective observational study. Patients undergoing RTor chemo radiotherapy for head and neck cancer (70 Gy/35 fractions (2 Gy daily). Medical evaluation consisted of a weekly clinical evaluation with a visual examination of the neck region skin performed by the physician in charge of the patient and a consequent physician-rated score of acute skin toxicity up to 90 day after end of treatment (according to RTOG/EORTC toxicity scale). Holoil® product series treatment were started whenever bright erythema, moderate oedema or patchy moist desquamation were observed. For erythema and/or oedema gel preparation was employed. For patchy moist desquamation the oil preparation was administered. Holoil® was used during all RT course and during follow up time, until acute skin toxicity recovery. Before the lesions appeared, patients received moisturizing cream. Holoil® was applied on the bilateral neck 2–3 times a day, at least 3 h before treatment session. Other creams or cosmetic products in the irradiated area were prohibited.	No information available on the product composition (market products). Carrier for Hypercium perforatum L. was neem oil. According to [93]: Holoil® gel: Ingredients: Melia Azadirachta Seed Oil; Olea Europaea Oil; Hypericum Perforatum Flower Extract, Excipients: Aqua; Propylene Glycol; Ciclodextrin; Carbomer; Triethanolamine; Phenoxyethanol; Benzoic Acid; Dehydroacetic Acid; Sodium Dehydroacetate; Ethylhexylglycerin; Aroma. Holoil® oil: Ingredients: Melia Azadirachta Seed Oil; Olea Europaea Oil; Hypericum Perforatum Flower Extract.	The maximum detected acute skin toxicity was Grade 1 in 7% of patients, Grade 2 in 68%, Grade 3 in 25%, while at the end of RT was Grade 0 in 3.5%, Grade 1 in 32%, Grade 2 in 61%, Grade 3 in 3.5%. G2 acute skin toxicity mainly started at weeks 4–5; G3 begun during weeks 5–6. Median times spent with G2 or G3 toxicity were 17.5 and 11 days. Time between maximum acute skin toxicity and complete skin recovery after RT was 27 days.	Various physicochemical forms were used in the studies, depending on the radiodermatitis type: Holoil® as gel (erythema and oedema) or oil formulation (moist desquamation). Patient’s compliance was consistent, with no particular complaints or difficulties. Carrier neem oil itself has anti-inflammatory, antioxidant and regenerating properties. No information available on the concentration of Hypercium perforatum L. in products. According to Authors Holoil® proved to be a safe and active option in the management of acute skin toxicity. A prophylactic effect in the prevention of moist desquamation may be hypothesized for hypericum and neem oil and need to be tested within a prospective controlled study.	[94]
Nigela sativa L.	gel	Evaluate the effectiveness of Nigella sativa L. extract on preventing the incidence of ARD. RCT. BC patients undergoing RT after breast surgery (minimum total prescribed dose, 50 Gy). 2 group: placebo and N. sativa 5% gel. The severity of ARD, the incidence of moist desquamation, worst experienced pain, and skin-related quality of life (SRQOL) scores were assessed weekly during RT. Preparations application: twice daily during RT period at least two hours before and after RT. After applying the gel, patients were asked to wait for at least 10 min before dressing and not to wash the affected area for at least 2 h.	N. sativa dried extract (5% w/w), Glycerol (5%), Carbopol®940 (1%), Triethanolamine (0.09%), Methylparaben (0.18%), propylparaben (0.02%), water up to 100% Placebo gel contain all of these ingredients except the N. sativa extract.	Group of patients treated with the N. sativa gel developed ARD significantly less frequently compared to those who used the placebo. The incidence time of grade 2 and 3 dermatitis was prolonged significantly with N. sativa gel as compared to placebo (35 vs. 29 days and 42 vs. 40 days, respectively). Also occurrence of moist desquamation was delayed 37 vs. 33 days for N. sativa gel vs. placebo respectively. At week 3 the mean score of the worst pain that patients experienced in N. sativa gel was significantly lower than in placebo group. No significant effect on the SRQOL after application of N. sativa gel was observed.	Both extract and gels were obtained by the authors. Active substance in the isolated extract was Thymoquinone the concentration of which in gel was 0.01% Gels were also studied with respect to their microbiological purity and stability. Participants with known allergy or hypersensitivity to N. sativa or any ingredients of the gel were excluded from the study.	[95]
Silybum marianum (L.) Gaertner	gel	Investigate the efficacy of silymarin gel in prevention of RD. RCT. Patients with BC received placebo or silymarin gel on chest walk skin following modified radical mastectomy (total radiation dose of 50 Gy). RD severity was assessed weekly based on RTOG and NCI-CTCAE criteria radiodermatitis grading scale for 5 weeks. Preparations (half fingertip unit) applied daily starting at the first day of RT for 5 weeks.	1% silymarin gel Used in the recipe dry extract contain 80% active ingredient based on silymarin flavonolignans (including silybin, silychristin, silydianin, 2,3-dehydrosilybin, and 2,3-dihydrosilychristin). No information available on the remaining components for both placebo gel and silymarin gel	The median NCI-CTCAE and RTOG scores were significantly lower in silymarin group at the end of the third to fifth weeks. The scores increased significantly in both placebo and silymarin groups during RT but there was a delay in RD development and progression in silymarin group. Prophylactic administration of silymarin gel could significantly reduce the severity of RD and delay its occurrence after 5 weeks of application (80% patients in this group remained asymptomatic). None of patients in silymarin group experienced grades higher than 1 during RT in contrast to placebo group were was patients with grade 2 and grade 3.	Were excluded from the study people with history of allergy to silymarin, history of autoimmune and connective tissue diseases, concomitant use of nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs, corticosteroids, and other immunosuppressive or antioxidant medications. Because Silymarin could reduce the severity of radiodermatitis the silymarin gel should be prescribe before the beginning of the RT. The authors of the study suggest that the silymarin 1% gel, and increasing the silymarin content of the gel may increase its efficacy in RD prevention.	[96]
Silybum marianum (L.) Gaertner	cream	Silymarin-based cream (Leviaderm®) was tested in efficacy in prevention of RD comparison to standard of care (SOC). Patients with histologically documented diagnosis of BC were evaluated after breast-conserving surgery followed by RT with 50.4 Gy plus boost 9–16 Gy. Participants were documented consecutively before, during, and 4 weeks after the scheduled end of RT. The occurrence of side effects and adverse drug reactions were recorded unblinded by the medical staff of the department during the weekly clinical examinations. One group of patients were treated with the silymarin based cream, second group were documented receiving a panthenol-containing cream interventionally, if local skin lesions occurred. The acute skin reactions were classified according to the RTOG and VASscores. SOC treatment consisting out of 5% dexpanthenol containing cream, which was applied as an interventional treatment to the affected breast skin after occurrence of the first signs of skin alterations (e.g., erythema) every day during RT and, thereafter, until skin recovered to normal. Silymarin-based cream was applied to the skin three times a day, 2 weeks before beginning RT, during RT, and 2 weeks afterwards. During RT, silymarin-based cream was applied daily at least 2 h before radiation. Silymarin-based cream was not applied to open wounds.	Leviaderm® market product, patented. It is mainly based on silymarin (Silybum marianum, content 0.25%), Adelmidrol®, vitamin E, bisabolol, and extracts from Vitis vinifera, Epilobium angustifolium, and Hordeum vulgare. The reference cream was the cream used in standard care. No detailed recipe for the product (contains 5% dexpanthenol)	The median time to toxicity was prolonged significantly with silymarin-based cream (45 vs. 29 days (SOC)). Only 9.8% of patients using silymarin-based cream showed grade 2 toxicity in week 5 of RT in comparison to 52% with SOC. At the end of RT, 23.5% of patients in the silymarin-based study group developed no skin reactions vs. 2% with SOC, while grade 3 toxicity occurred only in 2% in the silymarin-based arm compared to 28% (SOC).These results reaching statistical significance for RTOG are in line with those determined for subjective toxicity (VAS). Silymarin-based cream was well tolerated and can, thus, be used over several weeks.	Patients with allergies to the product were excluded from study. According to Authors Leviaderm® represents a new concept of cream by combining prevention and therapy of RD. It may induce antioxidative actions when skin is exposed to irradiation because silymarin, protect against free radical-induced inflammation. Additonaly Adelmidrol®, or N,N-bis (hydroxyethyl)-nonandiamide, here used in a subclinical concentration of 0.5%, belongs to a family of lipidic molecules collectively defined as ALIAmides, which in preclinical and clinical testing using therapeutical concentrations (at least 2%) have been reported to restore skin reactivity by down regulating mast cell hyperactivity. To confirm the results of this nonrandomized, observational trial, this product should be tested in larger multicenter studies in this setting.	[97]
Thunbergia laurifoliaLindl.	cream	The same as Centella asiatica research [88]	Thunbergia laufrifolia 5% (w/w) No information available concerning the remaining components. They do not contain fragrance Market creams available in Thailand.	Topical application of all herbal cream or the moisturizing cream could neither reduce the severity nor delay onset of dermatitis compared with no treatment group. Cucumis sativus cream wash shown to help with skin recovery post-irradiation. Authors recommend prophylactic application of moisturizing preparations on irradiated area of skin.	One clinical study in which three plants were analyzed: Centella asiatica L., Cucumis sativus L., Thunbergia laurifolia. Before the study, allergy tests were carried out to prevent side effects of extracts and moisturizing cream.	[88]
Turmeric curcuma longaL.	cream oil	Assess effectiveness of Vicco turmeric cream (VTC) on radiodermatitis. RCT. Patients with head and neck cancer scheduled to receive chemoradiotherapy or RT (dose 60 Gy). Two groups of patients first received topical Johnson’s baby oil (JBO), second group received VTC. Acute skin reactions were assessed twice weekly (according to RTOG scores) by an investigator who was unaware of the details. Time of application: 2 weeks after the end of the RT, starting on day 1, preparations were applied 5 times per day on the irradiated area.	VTC contain: extracts of Turmeric curcuma longa (16% w/w), Sandalwood Oil in a non-greasy base Oil—petroleum oil Oil and VTC cream both are market preparations.	Cream based on Curcuma longa and Sandalwood oil was effective against post-radiation dermatitis. Significant reduction in grades of dermatitis was seen at all time points, including 2 weeks post RT. The occurrence of grade 3 dermatitis was lower in the cohorts using VTC and was statistically significant. No adverse effects (allergic reactions) were found in the groups, indicating that Curcuma cream is safe for patients with head and neck cancer.	VTC was shown to be effective in preventing radiodermatitis and needs to be validated in larger double-blind trials.	[98]
Turmeric Curcuma longaL.	cream oil	To ascertain the benefit of Vicco turmeric Ayurvedic cream (VTC) in preventing radiodermatitis. Investigator-blinded randomized trial (double blind). Women receiving breast radiation therapy (50 Gy in 2 Gy fractions daily for 5 weeks). Two groups of patients first received topical Johnson’s baby oil (JBO) second group received VTC. To assess the delay in the appearance and the degree of severity (RTG score) of dermatitis throughout the study period. Application of products 5 times a day.	Market preparations. No information on composition available. VTC contain: extracts of Turmeric Curcuma longa (16% w/w), Sandalwood Oil in a non-greasy base.	Topical application of VTC delayed and mitigated the radiodermatitis. Compared to the JBO significant decrease in the incidence of 1 grade was seen at two week, and also in grade 2 and 3 at week 3 and 4 respectively in the VCT cohort. VCT cream significantly reduced radiation dermatitis.	Studies extended with regards to Pallaty [98]. Studies carried out with Johnson&Johnson company. Cream dose 5 g at each application and 5 cm3 for the oil. The authors tend to attribute the effectiveness to the curcuma and oil properties such as: anti- inflammatory, antioxidant, modulating cytokines and enhancing wound healing process. All of it contributes to the mechanism giving protective effects.	[99]
Turmeric Curcuma longaL. Valeton	gel lotion	The assessment of the prophylactical application of topical means in preventing or reducing RD and associated pain. RCT. BC patients, scheduled to receive conventional fractionated RT (total dose 44 to 66 Gy). Market preparations: Psoria Gold Curcumin gel (containing Curcumin extract), HPR Plus and placebo gel were applied. For pain assessment Skin Pain Inventory form was used. The evaluation of RDS (radiation dermatitis severity) was done by the physician or by qualified personnel. Preparations were applied on irradiated areas three times daily starting the first day of RT until 1 week after treatment completion. Standard self-care was recommended.	Psoria Gold Curcumin gel: Water Aloe Vera Leaf Juice Powder, Curcumin Extract, Hydroxypropyl Methylcellulose, Isopropyl Alcohol, Glycerin, Niacinamide (Vitamin B3) Acrylates/C10-30 Alkyl Acrylate Crosspolymer, Aminomethyl Propanol, Caprylhydroxamic Acid, Glyceryl Caprylate, Citric Acid. HPR Plus (lotion): Sodium Magnesium Fluorosilicate, Cyclomethicone, Phosphoric Acid, Sodium Chloride, Sodium Bicarbonate, Hypochlorus Acid, Water. Placebo gel (Psoria Gold)—composition unavailable	Mean RDS scores did not significantly differ between study arms. Additionally, no differences were detected in self-reported skin problems or pain ratings between the treatment groups in the total study sample. Exploratory subgroup analysis suggests that prophylactic treatment with topical curcumin may be effective for minimizing skin reactions and pain for patients with high breast separation who may have the worst skin reactions.	In the recipe including curcumin there’s also aloe vera extract.	[100]
Turmeric Curcuma longaL. Valeton	gel	Determining the effect of topical curcumin treatment on radiation burns Mini-pig model. Histological and clinical changes (ulceration, erythema, moist desquamation, dry desquamation) were observed five weeks after radiation exposure (total dose 50 Gy). Curcumin gel with ethanolic extract applied twice a day for 35 days. First application just after radiation. The reference sample was vehicle cream. The preparation dose was 200 mg/cm2 of skin.	Curcumin gel: Carbopol 934P, Water, Methanol, Ethanol, Triethanoloamine Dose of curcumin 200 mg/2 cm3 ethanol on 200 mg carbomer. Vehicle cream (hydrogel): the same ingredients as curcumin gel but without active ingredients such as curcumin extract.	Decreased the epithelial desquamation after radiation group treated with curcumin—showed reduced expression of cyclooxygenase-2 and nuclear factor-kappaB. Curcumin treatment stimulated wound healing.	The authors obtained the gel with the extract themselves. They also refer to the results of study [101] which demonstrated that the gel showed the highest permeability of curcumin without skin irritation or anti-inflammatory effects. Physicochemical study of the preparation was not presented. Besides, in the study the authors use the terminology vehicle cream whereas it is a gel (hydrogel) with no active substance (curcumin) added.	[102]

4. Discussion

In this literature review we quoted the results of 34 studies (between 1996 and 2021), three of which concern preparations containing more than one herbal extract (paste with a mixture of Aloe vera L., Turmeric curcuma longa, Azadirachta indica and Ocimum sanctum [74,75], ointment Jaungo containing Angelica gigas, Lithospermum radix [78,79]). In addition, in two presented studies, two or more preparations were analyzed in parallel: specifically, preparations containing Achillea millefolium or Glycyrrhiza glabra [59], or the preparations containing respectively Centella asiatica, Cucumis sativus or Thunbergia laurifolia [88]. In the study by Franco et al. [94] the carrier of Hypericum perforatum extract was neem oil with curative properties.

In total, 36.4%, which is the highest fraction of the quoted studies, used Aloe vera L. (12 studies). This is due to the fact that Aloe vera L. is the most used plant with soothing properties. The most important therapeutic effects described after applying Aloe vera L. are: the reduction of dermatitis, reduction of skin colonization by bacteria and healing acceleration. Second place is occupied by studies concerning Calendula officinalis (15.2%, 5 studies). In total, 4 studies (12.1%) concern the application of Turmeric curcuma longa, and 2 (6%) Silybum marianum.

Plant materials are one the best remedies for the treatment of wide variety of persistent diseases due to the presence of large number of bioactive natural products with potential biological properties. The plants used to carry out the study were characterized by various actions and indications in skin care after radiotherapy following due to presence of compounds such as flavonoids, saponin, polyphenols, polysaccharides, phytosterols, tannins, etc. (Table 5).

Table 5. Selected plants with confirmed therapeutic and care effect, applied in preparations for radiotherapy.

Action	Plant Species	Chemical Compounds	Indications
Anti-inflammatory	Achiellea millefolium L.	flavonoids	skin irritation sensitive skin dry skin
	Aloe vera L. Burman	polysaccharides, mucilage
	Annona muricata L.	flavonols, sesquiterpene lactones, acetogenins
	Azadriachta indica A. Juss	isoprenoids, catechins, tannins,
	Boswellia serrata Roxb. ex Colebr.	boswelin acids
	Calendula officinalis L.	saponins, flavonoids, polysaccharides
	Centella asiatica L.	triterpene saponins
	Chamomilla recutita Rauschert	flavonoids
	Cucumis sativus L.	cucurbitacins, phytosterole, unsaturated fatty acids
	Glycyrrhiza glabra Torr.	triterpene saponins, flavanones
	Green tea	polyphenols
	Hypercium perforatum L.	flavonoids, oligomeric proanthocyanindines, xanthones, acylfluoroglucinols, derivatives of caffeic acid
	Lithospermum erythrorhizon Siebold and Zucc.	naftochinony
	Nigela sativa L.	flavonoids, alkaloids, unsaturated fatty acids
	Ocimum santum Linn	terpenes, unsaturated fatty acids, saponins
	Silybum mariannum L. Gaerther	unsaturated fatty acids, flavonolignans
	Thunbergia laurifolia Lindl.	iridoid glucosides, rosmarinic acid
	Turmeric curcuma longa L. Valeton	curcuminoids
accelerating skin healing and regeneration	Aloe vera L. Burman	glycoprotein, mukopolysaccharides, amino acids, hydroxyquinone glycosides, minerals	wounds burns scars sensitive skin
	Hypercium perforatum L.	hyperforin, flavonoids
	Annona muricata L.	lactones, acetogenins
	Lithospermum erythrorhizon Siebold and Zucc.	naphthoquinones
	Cucumis sativus L.	phytosterols, tannins,
	Calendula officinalis L.	saponins, flavonoids
	Azadirachta indica A. Juss	tanins
	Centella asiatica L.	triterpenes, flavonoids
antimicrobial (bacteria, fungi)	Achiellea millefolium L.	polyacetylenes, flavonoids, sesquiterpene lactones, tannins	skin infections protection of the skin against infection
	Angelica gigas Nakai	tannins, tannins, aliphatic acids
	Azadirachta indica A. Juss	isoprenoids, tannins, polyphenols
	Calendula officinalis L.	aliphatic acids, polysaccharides, saponins, flavonoids
	Camellia sinesis L. Kuntze	catechins
	Centella asiatica L.	triterpene saponins
	Chamomilla recutita L. Rauschert	cyclic ethers, sesquiterpene alcohols
	Glycyrrhiza glabra Torr.	flavonoids, triterpene saponins
	Lithospermum erythrorhizon Siebold and Zucc.	naphthoquinones
	Nigela sativa L.	alkaloids, triterpene saponins
	Ocimum santum Linn	phenols, triterpenoids, tannins
	Turmeric curcuma longa Valeton	curcuminoids
moisturizing	Aloe vera L. Burman	polysaccharides, glycoprotein	dry skin sensitive skin
	Azadirachta indica A. Juss	polysaccharides, proteins
	Cucumis sativus L.	amino acids, minerals, pectins,
antioxidant	Annona muricata L.	phenolic compounds, vitamins, carotenoids, enzymes	neutralization of free radicals, protection of DNA strands and support of collagen and elastin production delay in lipid oxidation regeneration of primary antioxidants
	Azadirachta indica A. Juss	polyphenols, limonoids
	Camellia sinesis L. Kuntze	polyphenols, flavonoids, phenolic acids, vitamins
	Centella asiatica L.	flavonoids, triterpenes
	Chamomilla recutita L. Rauschert	flavonoids, phenolic compound
	Cucumis sativus L.	phenolic compounds, vitamins,
	Glycyrrhiza glabra Torr.	flavonoids
	Green tea	Catechins
	Lithospermum erythrorhizon Siebold and Zucc.	naphthoquinones
	Nigela sativa L.	tannins, vitamins, flavonols
	Silybum marianum L. Gaertner	flavonolignans, phenolic compound
	Thunbergia laurifolia Lindl.	flavonoids, polyphenols,
	Turmeric curcuma longa Valeton	feluric acids, polyphenols
antiseptic—disinfecting	Angelica gigas Nakai	tannins, alifactic acids,	cleansing of skin and wounds
	Azadirachta indica A. Juss	isoprenoids, polyphenols
analgesic anesthetics	Achillea millefolium L.	flavonoids, alkaloids	local analgesic effect
	Boswellia serrata Roxb. ex Colebr.	boswellic acids
	Ocimum santum Linn.	triterpenoids
antipruritic	Ocimum santum Linn.	terpenes, tanins	itch
anti-edematous	Cucumis sativus L.	tanins	swelling

The dominant actions among the plants presented in the table are: anti-inflammatory, antioxidant and antimicrobial. This is linked to the mechanism of formation and healing of radiodermatitis but also to the physician’s actions aiming at preventing and treating inflammation, pain or skin damage and bleeding which are prone to bacterial superinfection. Some of the plants used in the study prove efficient in skin smoothing and moisturizing because dry skin with a pathological basis caused by dermatosis requires the same care as dry non-pathological skin [23]. Works of Hoopfer et al. [65], Byun et al. [2], Pajonk et al. [91] were the only ones including the analysis of the herbal extract as such. The main purpose of these studies was to discover skin protection mechanisms for the given extract and to link it to the effectiveness in reducing radiation skin reaction severity.

For a cosmeceutical to be effective, its recipe is essential. Recipe assumptions concern not only the esthetic aspect such as application, scent, sensation on the skin (which are certainly important for oncological patients), but they also allow for the maximum action during regular application [103]. Therefore, the recipe is an integral part of the system for providing active substance aiming at maximum action and visible effect for the consumer, meaning the cosmetic is effective. The effectiveness concerns immediate effects, short term effects and effects occurring after 30–60 days. Besides, the process of healing for the skin takes 4–5 weeks. Hence, the studies evaluated the skin condition weekly, after various time lapses until, on average, 2–6 and even 8 weeks after the end of the radiotherapy. They allowed us to demonstrate the preparation’s long-term effectiveness. The longest study of preparation impact on the skin was analyzed in [74,75] and lasted 6 months. To determine the timing of application resulting in the best effect, in studies [60,97], cosmeceutical was applied beginning on day −7, 0, +7 relative to the day of irradiation (day 0) and continued for 5 weeks and applied beginning on day −14, 0 +14 respectively.

For a full assessment of the cosmetic’s impact on skin after radiotherapy, a threefold approach should be considered: instrumental measurement of skin condition, expert’s evaluation, and self-evaluation by the participants to the study group. A double-blind testing with control group using placebo or positive control of the prescribed product carried out by independent experts using a statistically significant number of participants are also acceptable sources of information. In total, 83.5% of the studies presented by us were randomized clinical studies and clinical studies. Studies on animals included 11.76% of the quoted studies. In most discussed clinical studies, the assessment was done by a team of experts or the members of the study group. To do this, the assessment tools were: the scale (guidelines) RTOG/EORTC [59,66,67,71,74,75,78,81,82,83,84,85,86,88,89,90,94,96,97,98,99], Acute Radiation Morbidity Scoring Criteria [73], Common Toxicity Criteria [63,64], modified 10-point Catterall scale [65], Common Terminology Criteria for Adverse Events [92] or National Cancer Institute Common Terminology for Adverse Events [96]. Photographs of skin were taken in studies [11,63,72,81,89,90]. To measure erythema Near Infrared Spectroscopy, Laser Doppler Imaging and Digital Colour Photography were applied [72]. A subject’s skin comfort [64] and skin-related quality of life (SRQOL) [95] was also evaluated, mostly using QLQ-C30 questionnaire [74,75]. The effectiveness was also evaluated by defining the degree of improvement of skin lesions [69].

The availability and the effectiveness of the given component can be modified depending on the phase in which it was added to the preparation during production. The type of the solvent used for extraction is hence essential. The effectiveness can be increased by using a proper substrate and carrier system. Known ways of delivery of herbal extract in topical therapy are: creams and water-based liquids, ointments based on oils and waxes, powders and pastes, masks from freshly cut herbs, warming compresses or compresses from warm soaked herbs [104]. Among the analyzed physicochemical forms including extracts, 42.9% were gels (15 studies), 28.6% were creams (10 studies), 11.4% ointments (4 studies). Rarely used substances were (5.8%): lotions and oils (2 studies each), but also pastes and solutions (single studies, 2.8%). One work among presented studies analyzed more than one physicochemical form of the preparation [94]. A gel preparation gives a refreshing sensation, and it is oil-free, which is a more appropriate formulation to apply in skin exposed to radiation therapy, avoiding a bolus-like effect and making it easier to remove before the next radiation therapy session.

In terms of products’ effectiveness assessment, it should be emphasized that in case of radiation reaction, its characteristics should be analyzed, and appropriate treatment and care should be adopted for the given degree. In the case of dry desquamation, treatments aim mainly at moisturizing the skin and reducing the skin discomfort linked to burning and itching. Hence, hydrophilic preparation (mostly gels) with neutral pH are most appropriate. They are often combined with the topical application of corticosteroids. Corticosteroids however have a lot of side effects. In works [74,75] the effectiveness of the paste with herbal extracts was compared to Beclomethasone cream. The evaluation of paste effectiveness as compared to corticosteroids was analyzed in [79]. In case of moist desquamation, the principle of treating the moist with the moist is applied; hence, the best option seems to be hydrocolloid dressings.

Most of the quoted studies aimed at preventing dermatitis. Hence, the studied preparation was applied throughout the whole treatment. Possible changes in treatment were linked to allergy or to development of dermatitis of second degree or higher, which required the introduction of corticosteroids, antibiotics or analgesics. In the case of moist desquamation, individual works [71,88] stopped the application of the preparation in the area of occurrence. Only the studies carried out by the team Franco et al. [94] included the application of two forms of preparations depending on the type of radiodermatitis observed. Thus, for erythema and/or oedema, gel preparation was employed. For patchy moist desquamation, the oil preparation was administered.

In the works quoted, multiple forms of preparations were compared simultaneously during the study; for example, cream and oil or powder [65,71,98,99], creams with water infusion [88], gels with creams [11,62,63,64,72,89,90,100], gels with soap [67], gels with ointments [60], gels with oils [94]. We know currently that the skin barrier layer should not only be moisturized but also rebuilt, which cannot be done with preparations such as soap. Besides, in studies [11,61,67,78,83,84,100] standard care was recommended or moisturizing preparations were applied together with the analyzed one [88,92]. The study results presented in [65] speak in favor of dry skin care instead of applying moisturizing creams enriched with herbal extracts.

In some of the clinical studies [60,64,66,71,72,82,83,84,88,91,92,94,97,98,99,100] generally available, market products were applied (they were not registered as medical products hence they did not have any specific use recommendations). They had no antioxidant, moisturizing or redness reducing action, which should characterize preparations after radiotherapy. Market preparations played a role of placebo [60,72,83,84,87,92], or extract carrier [59], but were also a well-known preparation containing active substances of plant origin like Juango ointment [78,79] or Vicco Turmeric cream [98,99]. Besides, some of the placebo preparations contained active substances [60]. One of the certain defects of the presented works [11,61,62,63,67,71,79,84,88,89,90,91,92,96,99] is the lack of composition for evaluated products.

From a scientific but also from practical point of view, the time of application of cosmeceuticals and the dosage are important. As shown in [60], there was no effect if the gel was applied only before irradiation or beginning 1 week after irradiation. According to [97], the minimal application time is two weeks before the beginning of radiotherapy, while a significant part of the works concerned studies in which the preparation application started at the same time as the irradiation. Studies [73,79,102] mentioned the doses of applied products.

5. Conclusions

In the current review paper, the literature data have been systematically reviewed and we discussed the connection between the type of applied skin care (type of preparation, its composition, the dose), the properties of the herbal extract, and the evaluation of its efficiency in preventing and treating radiation reaction on skin.

From this research, the following conclusions can be drawn:

• The application of herbal extracts in preparations preventing radiodermatitis is important and still up-to-date (most recent publications about ongoing clinical studies are from 2021). Moreover, many herbal extracts such as Dilenia idica, and the Lamicale Family show potential in treating dermatitis but have not been introduced in the recipes of ointments, creams or gels.
• Herbal extracts obtained from plants can be added to recipes because they are part of a category of cosmeceutical supplements which are not subject to regulations and can be introduced into preparations without prescription. Herbal extracts can be a raw material from which active substances are isolated. For example, tea is a source of epigallocate-hin-3-gallatechin. Polysaccharides can be obtained from Annona muricata L. Both have potential in the treatment of dermatitis.
• The dominant actions among the plants are: anti-inflammatory, antioxidant and antimicrobial. This is linked to the mechanism of formation and healing of radiodermatitis but also to the physician’s actions aiming at preventing and treating inflammation, pain or skin damage and bleeding which are prone to bacterial superinfection. Some of the plants used in the study prove efficient in skin smoothing and moisturizing because dry skin with a pathological basis caused by dermatosis requires the same care as dry non-pathological skin.
• In the available study results there is conflicting information concerning the effectiveness in treatment and prevention of radiodermatitis by the products containing herbal extracts in their recipe (e.g., Aloe vera). There are also works mentioning that preparations such as ointments are poorly tolerated and appreciated by patients, and that some preparations cause allergies. Hence there are premises indicating that there is a need to widen the preparations offer for radiotherapy patients, the recipe of which is projected already at the evaluation stage of herbal extracts.
• The effectiveness evaluation for herbal extracts in radiotherapy is not an easy task since there are no strict guidelines. Studies should include both apparatus analyses of the skin condition and clinical studies including patients. They should also be preceded by the analysis of herbal extracts and recipe in terms of physicochemical, dermatological, and performance characteristics.