Study of the Sloshing Dynamics in Partially Filled Rectangular Tanks with Submerged Baffles Using VOF and LES Turbulence Methods for Different Impact Angles
Round 1
Reviewer 1 Report
Journal Computation (ISSN 2079-3197) Manuscript ID computation-2025987 Type Article Title Study of the sloshing dynamics in partially filled rectangular tanks with submerged baffles using VOF and LES turbulence methods for different impact angles Authors Xavier Vallés-Rebollo , Ehsan Sadeghi , Ibuki Kusano , Andrés-Amador García-Granada *
1- Please just make similarities zero in the abstract and reduce the
similarities from two sources to less than 1%.
2- Authors should add in a section of conclusion the applications in physics.
3- The authors obtained governing equations of the steady-state responses by using a regular semi-analytic perturbation method, comparison with analytical and numerical methods.
4- The style and English language can be improved.
5- The first sentence in Abstract need modify.
6- Page 2 line 13 correct the sentences and rewrite them.
7- Page 3 line 8 correct the sentences and rewrite them.
8- Modify the description of method and give details about it.
1. Physica Scripta, Vol. 67 (2003) 340-349.
Chaos, Solitons and Fractals 157 (2022) 111888.
Author Response
please check attached document
Author Response File: 
Author Response.pdf
Reviewer 2 Report
The paper is an important demonstration of how LES and RANS are two different worlds! The comparison between different turbulence models in the context of interfacial flows for complex and real-world applications is a very interesting research topic.
I feel to recommend the publication of this work on Computation after that the following minor corrections are addressed:
- It seems that the value of the Reynolds number is not given. Could you provide it?
- Could you insert some details in more about the mathematical formulation of the turbulence models that you use in Sec. 2?
- I believe that the following references on recent developments in the LES context could be added to the bibliography:
Girfoglio, Quaini, Rozza, A Finite Volume approximation of the Navier-Stokes equations with nonlinear filtering stabilization, Computers & Fluids, 2019
Girfoglio, Quaini, Rozza, A POD-Galerkin reduced order model for a LES filtering approach, Journal of Computational Physics, 2021
- Be careful to typos (see for example "Fluif" in the title of Sec. 2.2) and review the English style. I recommend a careful reading before the resubmission.
Author Response
please check attached documente
Author Response File: Author Response.pdf
