Three-Dimensional Printing Using Recycled High-Density Polyethylene: Technological Challenges and Future Directions for Construction
Round 1
Reviewer 1 Report
This manuscript summarized the broad applications of the AM in the construction field and described detailed information regarding how the virtual model transforms to physical object. The authors also briefly discussed challenges and future directions.
It appears that recycled HDPE in the concrete increases tensile strength. Regarding the use of recycled HDPE, does it alter any innate physicochemical properties when recycled?
Are there any other materials that may offer comparable properties?
As the title of this article includes the sustainability aspect, can the authors comment on sustainability and economic advances using this materials more in details?
Please revisit a list of references to unify its listing style.
Some legends for the sectioned figures are needed to be modified (e.g. (a) and (b) are needed to be separately explained).
Author Response
Reviewer’s comments ( Reviewer 1) | Authors’ explanations |
This manuscript summarized the broad applications of the AM in the construction field and described detailed information regarding how the virtual model transforms to physical object. The authors also briefly discussed challenges and future directions. 1) It appears that recycled HDPE in the concrete increases tensile strength. Regarding the use of recycled HDPE, does it alter any innate physicochemical properties when recycled? 2) Are there any other materials that may offer comparable properties? 3) As the title of this article includes the sustainability aspect, can the authors comment on sustainability and economic advances using this materials more in details? 4) Please revisit a list of references to unify its listing style. 5) Some legends for the sectioned figures are needed to be modified (e.g. (a) and (b) are needed to be separately explained).
|
1) Yes, this is correct. Recycled HDPE can lead to changing both physical and mechanical properties as well as chemical condition in the materials. 2) Any kind of brittle materials can be used which would be comparable. Examples of brittle materials include cast iron, concrete, and some glass products. 3) This topic came up with an idea about the optimization. In this research both thermal and mechanical optimization in lab scale sample numerically checked. The main advantages is to suggest a technique where would be fast and efficient in construction and the input materials economically would be justified. The suggested technique can present future construction in the countryside and rural areas. 4) All of the available references were revised. 5) Further explanations were individually added.
|
Author Response File: Author Response.pdf
Reviewer 2 Report
This paper dealt with a methodology for 3D printing using recycled high-density polyethylene in construction processing and architectural design. In addition, the authors showed their technological challenges and sustainability. The proposed method is well explained and the case study also illustrates the validity of the research.Author Response
Reviewer’s comments ( Reviewer 2) | Authors’ explanations |
This paper dealt with a methodology for 3D printing using recycled high-density polyethylene in construction processing and architectural design. In addition, the authors showed their technological challenges and sustainability. The proposed method is well explained and the case study also illustrates the validity of the research.
| The authors would like to deeply express their appreciations. |
Author Response File: Author Response.pdf
Reviewer 3 Report
The paper presents a research on three-dimensional printing by using cement mix incorporated with recycled waste product High Density Polyethylene (HDPE). The methodology applied is interesting, the organization is good and the text is sufficiently clear.
Author Response
Reviewer’s comments ( Reviewer 3) | Authors’ explanations |
The paper presents a research on three-dimensional printing by using cement mix incorporated with recycled waste product High Density Polyethylene (HDPE). The methodology applied is interesting, the organization is good and the text is sufficiently clear.
| The authors would like to deeply express their appreciations. |
Author Response File: Author Response.pdf
Reviewer 4 Report
Minor language check required.Author Response
Reviewer’s comments ( Reviewer 4) | Authors’ explanations |
Minor language check required.
| A comprehensive (language) proof reading was conducted. |
Author Response File: Author Response.pdf