1. Introduction
The human body survives in the environment due to a dynamic balance called the homeostasis process. The skin has a major role in maintaining homeostasis, being a protective barrier between the body and the environment [
1]. Every day, the skin is exposed to multiple physical and thermal aggressions and the cutaneous lesions need a specialized medical service that usually implies a high cost [
2]. Finding less traumatic methods of treatment is imperiously required and the final goal in wound healing research is to achieve a cure through a regeneration process. The dermis contains a series of proteins of which the collagen polymer, responsible for the tensile strength of the skin, has an important percentage (~70–80% of the dry weight) [
3].
Collagen is a fibrous material entity that has a specific three-dimensional conformation–triple helix structure–with high mechanical strength and good cell recognition [
4,
5]. Collagen-based materials have numerous applications in the tissue regeneration field due to their biocompatibility properties. On the other hand, this polymer is one of the main materials present in the architecture of the living matter and can be efficiently extracted from animal’s tissues such as skin, bones, and tendons [
3].
Chitosan belongs to a class of polymers widespread in nature, based on glucosamine monomers, known for their antimicrobial activity. Chitosan is a non-toxic hydrophilic polymer obtained by N-deacetylation of chitin in the presence of 40–50% NaOH at 180 °C [
5]. It is widely used in pharmaceutical, cosmetic, and food industries due its antioxidant, antifungal, antibacterial and hemostatic properties [
6]. In the human body, chitosan is degraded by an enzyme called lysozyme, leading to degradation products that are able to stimulate macrophages, positively influence collagen sedimentation and, consequently, accelerate the healing of wounds [
4,
7].
Another natural polymer is the ovalbumin found in lyophilized egg white. Due to its property to create a protective film on the surface of the wound, it is a good choice for treating skin lesions [
8].
In this context, our paper aimes to formulate four ointments based on different polymers (CH–chitosan, CO–collagen, AL–ovalbumin from lyophilized egg white of Gallus gallus domesticus, and POL–a mixture of CH, CO and AL) and to investigate their wound healing potential in vivo on incision, excision, and thermal burn wounds models. The inclusion of polymers in the ointments formulations has a very important effect on the spreadability and, of course, on the structural properties of the pharmaceutical form. In order to provide a good description of these aspects, rheological analyses were performed. Thus, the ointment formulations were studied using the oscillatory tests (amplitude sweep, frequency sweep, and temperature test) and rotational tests (flow curves).
3. Discussion
The spreadability and structural stability are important parameters of the ointments. The inclusion of polymers in the ointment formulation has a significant influence on these properties. Useful information about spreadability and structural stability can be obtained by performing oscillatory and rotational rheological tests. The reproducibility of the results was verified by performing rheological tests on three samples of each ointment.
The amplitude sweep was used to determine the limit of the linear viscoelastic range (γ = 0.01–0.05%). This test confirmed the structural stability of the samples at small deformations for both temperatures (25 °C and 37 °C). The samples presented a high rigidity and the structure was more sensitive to deformations at 25 °C. At a physiological temperature (37 °C), the sample structure was flexible due to the slight decrease of the viscosity and the increase of polymer chain flexibility. Therefore, at a physiological temperature, the ointments offered a good sensation and a good spreadability on the skin.
The frequency sweep test highlighted the solid-like behavior of the sample at both temperatures due to the higher G’ (storage modulus) values than G” (loss modulus) over the entire domain of frequency. The parallel dynamic modules and their small frequency variation suggested the presence of a stable tridimensional network. At a physiological temperature, the values of the dynamic modules are lower than at 25 °C suggesting a smooth feeling and a good spreadability on the skin.
The structural stability and the degree of fluidization of the ointments at physiological temperature were both highlighted using the temperature test. Obviously, the values of the dynamic moduli decreased with increasing temperature, as explained above.
The high values of zero shear viscosity calculated with the Carreau-Yasuda model using the flow curves also emphasized the structural stability of the samples [
9,
10,
11].
Considering that burn injuries are a major cause of morbidity and mortality worldwide [
12], the accurate description of the microscopic pathological aspects of these lesions aims to understand the healing processes [
12,
13,
14] and consequently therapeutic efficacy. As mentioned by some researchers [
12,
13,
14], there is still a need to develop studies for the integration of the healing process in the current therapeutic context. Thus, using different materials, some research teams [
12,
13,
14] managed to rank burns/injuries based on the design of scoring scales that show the extent of these lesions.
Using the same scoring systems, but under different study conditions, our results enabled the comparative analysis of different study models. Thus, the scoring of the inflammatory process allowed for the highlight of the reduction of inflammation in all models analyzed in relation to the day on which the biopsy was performed (day 3, 9 and 21, respectively) with downward scores from S3/S2 on day 3 to S1 on day 9 and day 21, respectively. This reaction pattern is characteristic of the NC, OB, CH and POL groups respectively for the incision model. For the excision category, the scores are decreasing, often by one degree (from S3 to S2 for the NC, OB groups, or from S2 to S1 for the CO, AL, and POL groups). The values of the scores are therefore relatively close for the groups used (NC, OB, CO, CH, AL, POL) and there is a favorable evolution for each category. Also, the depth of the burn (D) shows a favorable evolution, from D1 to D0 in the groups NC, CO, CH, POL, the only group evolving from D1 to D2 being AL on day 9 and with regression to D0 on day 21, thus demonstrating a favorable finality.
The inclusion of natural polymers in the tested ointments was based on the idea that the response of biological media (i.e., living tissues: traumatic wounds or various types of surgical wounds) to their contact with collagenous materials is embodied by specific phenomena: hemostasis, immunological response and cell proliferation, as presented in scientific literature [
15]. The hemostatic activity, one of the most important biological properties of collagen, causes the blood to coagulate when it comes in contact with it: platelets adhere in the first phase to the surface of the collagen gel, then they desorb and become involved in the aggregation process and next, they activate the thrombin reaction on fibrinogen, which ends with the appearance of platelet thrombus [
16]. Collagenous materials also have the property of generating new tissue [
17], which was demonstrated in the present study.
Collagen is involved in wound healing due to its integrin binding domains, which promote cell attachment, a phenomenon necessary for cell growth, differentiation and metabolic activity [
4,
18].
Collagen is naturally degraded by metalloproteinases, specifically collagenases and serine proteases, so that its degradation is under the local control of cells in cultured tissue [
3]. Literature data also mention collagen and chitosan-derived hydrogels used in the treatment of wounds due to hemostatic and antimicrobial effects, correlated with good biocompatibility [
19].
In fact, the chitosan ointment used in the present experiment proved to have an important role in the regeneration of the affected tissue, which was confirmed by previous studies [
6,
20]. It acts favorably both in terms of the recovery of the affected tissue and the short regeneration time for the three types of lesions, respectively nine days of treatment for incision and excision model and 12 days for the burn-type lesion. Moreover, the clinical results may be observed from the ninth day, and were confirmed later histologically, on the 21st, as shown in the histological images. The antimicrobial and bactericidal properties cited in the literature [
5,
6], were also demonstrated in the present study. These effects resulted from the anatomopathological analysis, which noted the presence of abscess and inflammatory infiltrate in the lesions of the untreated group and the one treated with only ointment base, and the lack of these characteristics for the batch treated with chitosan ointment.
It is known that too high a level of collagen can compromise the end result of the wound healing with formation of hypertrophic scars. Normal collagen production during the cicatrization process is essential for epithelial migration and post-injury proliferation [
21]. In the present study, a normal collagenization was observed due to the use of chitosan that was included in the ointment base, which led to a restitutio ad integrum healing.
Chitosan molecules can induce a migration of inflammatory cells and fibroblasts, stimulating the production of cytokines and wound healing. Moreover, it is shown that wound healing with the aid of chitosan stimulates not only the migration and proliferation of fibroblasts, but also the production of collagen [
6,
21]. Fibroblasts stimulated by chitosan molecules secrete interleukin-8 (IL-8), which is an angiogenic and chemotactic factor of both cell types (endothelial and epidermal), which produce fibrosis and epithelialization [
21,
22].
By observing the collagenization process, from the third to ninth day of this experiment we noted that in the group treated with the chitosan ointment, the healing process progresses from inflammation of the epidermis and dermis to the stage of dermal collagenization in only six days for the incision-like lesion, and also for the excision-type lesion. For the burn-type lesion, in the same period of time, there is an evolution from inflammation in the hypodermis to the stage of important dermal collagenization due to the maturation of the granulation tissue, as confirmed by anatomopathological evidence. Therefore, in the case of the present study, chitosan acts both by stopping the inflammatory phenomenon and by stimulating the collagenization and maturation of the granulation tissue. Both effects were not found for the group treated with ointment base or for the untreated group.
It is also possible to deduce the effect that the chitosan-based ointment has on the normal regeneration processes, by observing that in the untreated group there were noticed phenomena of vacuolar degeneration and exocytosis even from the third day of the experiment. At the same time, also within the normal regeneration, we can say that the chitosan ointment intervenes beneficially on parakeratosis, which was observed in the case of the ointment base batch, on the third day, for the thermal injury type experiment.
In lyophilized egg whites, the active ingredients are proteins, zeaxanthin, lutein, riboflavin, selenium, choline, essential and non-essential amino acids [
23]. Ovalbumin, protein contained in egg white (54%), forms a protective layer adherent to the lesion, inducing the regeneration of the affected skin tissue [
8,
24]. Not negligible is the fact that the lyophilized egg white alone included in the ointment base showed good effects in terms of wound healing. The preparation obtained with compounds biocompatible with the human body determined the regeneration of the affected skin tissue by forming a protective film adherent to the lesion.
In the present study, an ointment containing a combination of collagen, chitosan and lyophilized egg white was also used for wound healing. Fresh egg white is used in folk medicine in the treatment of lesions, especially in the heat burn injury, by direct application, forming a protective protein film on the surface of the lesion. The mixing of collagen with chitosan led to an increase in the release time at the level of the lesion, which allows a longer lasting action of the active ingredients. Based on literature data, the polymeric preparation obtained and tested in this experiment contains compounds biocompatible with the human body, with a role in regenerating the affected tissue, with hemostatic activity, and antimicrobial effect [
5,
25,
26]. Moreover, the results obtained by testing ointments that involved the incorporation of the mixture of polymers in the ointment base, both clinically and by analyzing histological samples, reveals a superior therapeutic effect in terms of skin tissue regeneration. It was observed (for POL group) on the first day when the experimental models were made, for incision and excision lesions, an increased capacity of hemostasis. Moreover, the ointment intervenes favorably in the regeneration processes, noting the granulation tissue and, finally, a newly formed, young, maturing epithelium that was elastic and without traces of vicious healing, which is remarkable and noteworthy. The study opens a broad perspective for the formulation of new polymeric support types, which include bioactive compounds with controlled release system.
4. Materials and Methods
4.1. Ointments Preparation
The ointment base was prepared by mixing lanolin and vaseline in equal amounts on a water bath at 40 °C until a homogeneous base was obtained. The 0.5 g collagen polymer was solubilized in 10 mL of bidistilled water at 40 °C followed by the addition of 25 mL anhydrous glycerol. The solution thus obtained was incorporated into 100 g ointment base and thoroughly mixed (the ointment with collagen).
An amount of 0.24 g chitosan was dissolved in 30 mL apple honey vinegar and added to 100 g ointment base (the ointment with chitosan).
In order to obtain the ointment with lyophilized chicken egg white (Gallus gallus domesticus), the albumen of fresh eggs was separated from the yolk. The samples containing the egg white were frozen in Petri dishes and lyophilized. After the lyophilization process, the egg white was finely ground and 3 g were added to 100 g ointment base and mixed continuously (the ointment with lyophilized egg white). For the ointment based on total polymers, equal amounts of the three ointments described above were mixed.
4.2. Chemical Reagents
The ethyl alcohol, chitosan and collagen were purchased from Sigma-Aldrich (Steinheim, Germany), lanolin and vaseline were from Farma Chim (Ploiesti, Romania). The fresh eggs were obtained from a commercial source.
4.3. Rheological Characterization of Ointments
Rheological tests were carried out on a Physica MCR 501 (Anton Paar, Graz, Austria) modular rheometer equipped with a Peltier temperature control device. Parallel plate geometry (50 mm diameter) with serrated plates was used to avoid slippage of the sample. A thin layer of low viscosity silicone oil was applied on the edges of the sample to avoid moisture loss during studies. The rheological parameters of the samples were measured using oscillatory tests (amplitude sweep, frequency sweep, temperature sweeps) and rotational tests (flow curves). All experiments were performed at two different temperatures (25 °C and 37 °C). Rheological tests reproducibility was verified on three samples of each analyzed ointment.
4.4. Experimental Skin Lesions
The skin lesions were performed on laboratory adult male Wistar rats, with a body weight of 220–250 g fed a standard chow pellet diet and water ad libitum. The study included six Wistar rats groups with 7 animals per group as follows: NC group (negative control group–not treated), OB group–ointment base group (treated with the ointment base), CO group (treated with the collagen ointment), CH group (treated with the chitosan ointment), AL group (treated with ointment based on the lyophilized egg white, POL group (treated with the ointment based on the mixture of polymers).
The animals were anesthetized with Ketamine intraperitoneally (100 mg/kg) before inducing the wounds. The hairs on the dorsal part of the rats were shaved and cleaned with 70% alcohol. The treatment was applied topically once a day for 21 days. Each group of rats was housed in a separate cage with free access to standard laboratory diet and water.
Three experimental wound models (linear incision, circular excision, thermal burn) were applied on each animal. In this study the design of the lesions was based on previously described models [
11,
27,
28].
The evaluated parameters were clinical examination, determination of lesion area, wound contraction rate, period of re-epithelialization and histological examination performed at days 0, 3, 9 and 21 of treatment. Therefore, a tissue sample was removed from the rats.
4.5. Wound Healing Evaluation Parameters
Circular lesion area (for excision wound model) was calculated according to the formula A = πr
2. The elliptical area resulting from the lesion contraction process was calculated according to the formula:
where
a represented the high axis and
b represented the small axis.
The wound contraction rate (WCR) was determined by the formula
where A
0 is the original wound size (50.27 mm
2) and A
t is the wound size on day 6 and 9, respectively.
Wound closure was considered the endpoint of the epithelialization process and days needed to complete epithelialization were considered the period of epithelialization.
4.6. Histological Examination
In order to observe the epithelialization process, tissue skin samples were removed from the rats with a 3 mm biopsy punch, after the rats were anesthetized intraperitoneally with ketamine (100 mg/kg). The samples were inserted in 10% buffered formalin for at least 24 h, progressively dehydrated in solutions containing an increasing percentage of ethanol (60, 80, 90, and 98% v/v), clarified with amylic alcohol and finally, embedded in paraffin under vacuum condition. Further, the skin tissue was sectioned at 5 µm thickness, deparaffinized, and stained with hematoxylin-eosin (HE).
The scoring of the dermal inflammatory infiltrate was performed based on scores from the scientific literature, adapted [
29,
30]. In order to establish the score, five microscopic fields with a magnification of 400× were examined, at the level of the papillary and reticular dermis and also at the hypodermis and striated muscle tissue and chosen as representative for each case. The value of the final score was represented by the average value of the five fields observed. A score of 0 (S0) represented no inflammatory infiltrate, score 1 (S1) mild/rare/occasional inflammatory infiltrate (<10 lymphocytes/HPF), score 2 (S2) moderate/focal inflammatory infiltrate (11–30 lymphocytes/HPF), score 3 (S3) severe inflammatory infiltrate (numerous lymphocytes > 30/HPF).
The evaluation of the thermal burn depths (D) was also achieved based on adapted scores from the literature as follows: D0–normal skin, D1–epithelial necrosis within the epidermis, the basement membrane remains intact, D2–necrosis of skin appendages and dermal connective tissue; D3–extensive necrosis within the hypodermic tissue [
12,
13].
4.7. Statistical Analysis
The data obtained from excision wound model were analyzed by one-way ANOVA followed by Bonferroni test. Statistical analysis was performed using SPSS version 15.0, (SPSS Inc., Chicago, IL, USA) where p < 0.05 was considered statistically significant.