Hydrogen Sulfide as Potential Regulatory Gasotransmitter in Arthritic Diseases

Abstract

The social and economic impact of chronic inflammatory diseases, such as arthritis, explains the growing interest of the research in this field. The antioxidant and anti-inflammatory properties of the endogenous gasotransmitter hydrogen sulfide (H₂S) were recently demonstrated in the context of different inflammatory diseases. In particular, H₂S is able to suppress the production of pro-inflammatory mediations by lymphocytes and innate immunity cells. Considering these biological effects of H₂S, a potential role in the treatment of inflammatory arthritis, such as rheumatoid arthritis (RA), can be postulated. However, despite the growing interest in H₂S, more evidence is needed to understand the pathophysiology and the potential of H₂S as a therapeutic agent. Within this review, we provide an overview on H₂S biological effects, on its role in immune-mediated inflammatory diseases, on H₂S releasing drugs, and on systems of tissue repair and regeneration that are currently under investigation for potential therapeutic applications in arthritic diseases.

1. Introduction

Hydrogen sulfide is an endogenously produced biological agent belonging to the gasotransmitter family. The physiological role and the relevance of this molecule are rapidly expanding. Endogenous H₂S plays pivotal roles in the biochemical pathways of the central nervous, respiratory, and cardiovascular systems. This gasotransmitter is physiologically present in the human body, and it is mainly produced endogenously by four enzymes: cystathionine beta-synthase (CBS EC 4.2.1.22), cystathionine gamma-lyase (CSE, EC 4.4.1.1), 3-mercaptopyruvate sulfotransferase (MST, EC 2.8.1.2), and cysteine aminotransferase (CAT) (reviewed in references [1,2,3,4,5]). However, other enzymes such as thiosulfate sulfurtransferase (TST) [6] and the more recently discovered selenium-binding protein 1 (SELENBP1) are able to catalyze H₂S production [7].

Although there are limits of measurement techniques and the quantification of biologic H₂S levels is debated, H₂S physiological levels may range from 50–160 μM in the mammalian brain to 30 nM–100 μM in the peripheral blood and 25 μM in the synovial fluid of patients with non-inflammatory arthritis [8,9,10,11,12,13]. It is known that a relevant fraction of H₂S is bound to proteins in several tissues, such as hemoglobin [14,15]. An endogenous source of H₂S is also represented by the enterobacterial flora and by the non-enzymatic reduction of sulfurs [4].

As a gasotransmitter, H₂S can pass freely through cell membranes and does not require a specific receptor to mediate its effect. Only recently, H₂S was considered an important signaling molecule. The biological effects of H₂S are multiple and opposite, depending on its concentration. The first H₂S biological effect was discovered in the vascular system, with the ability to induce the relaxation of vascular smooth muscle, causing vasodilation [16]. Despite the controversial role initially attributed to H₂S, it is to date recognized that, at low concentrations, it exhibits anti-apoptotic, anti-nociceptive, cardio-protective, and blood pressure-lowering effects, while also improving angiogenesis, via the activation of K_ATP channels and extracellular signal-regulated kinases, such as Akt pathways [1,17,18,19,20,21,22]. Moreover, H₂S shows neuroprotective and anti-inflammatory effects in general due to its antioxidant effects and inhibition of pro-inflammatory cytokines [23,24,25,26,27,28]. The potential effects of H₂S were also discussed in several review articles [29,30,31,32] and are here summarized in Figure 1.

In the last few years, many studies demonstrated a relevant role of H₂S to mediate the inflammation and the processes of tissues repair. Chronic inflammation is the key feature of inflammatory arthritis, such as rheumatoid arthritis (RA) and psoriatic arthritis (PsA). The impact of chronic inflammatory diseases on the quality of life and autonomy in the daily activities in a wide population with different ages and the consequent high economic costs explain the growing interest in this field. Recently, the connection between H₂S and joint inflammation, in the context of arthritis, is growing, either as a pathogenic or potential therapeutic role. Therefore, in this review, we describe the effects of H₂S on inflammatory arthritis and its potential therapeutic approach.

2. Oxidative Stress and Inflammation in Arthritis

RA and PsA represent the most common chronic inflammatory arthritis. They share common pathogenic features, both linked to chronic inflammation secondary to a dysregulation of the immune response; however, the clinical manifestations and outcomes are usually different. Despite the clinical and pathological differences, both diseases share some similarities in the inflammatory pathways. In the course of active arthritis, joint inflammation is overall characterized by increased vascularization, oxidative stress, and infiltration of immune cells in the synovium (Figure 2); these events induce fibroblast-like synoviocyte (FLS) hypertrophy which, ultimately, perpetuates the inflammation, generating a chronic loop. In the early stages of arthritis, the oxidative stress seems to have a key role in initiating the inflammatory process, as demonstrated in some studies [33,34]. Moreover, oxidative stress may account for post-translational modifications of proteins, potentially responsible for autoreactive antibody production [35], particular to RA. Synovial angiogenesis is also an early alteration in the arthritic joint and is characterized by endothelial swelling, cell infiltration, and tortuous vessels. The amplified expression in the synovium of pro-inflammatory cytokines and growth factors, particularly vascular endothelial growth factor (VEGF), contributes to increased vascularity [36]. However, the new vessels are mostly dysfunctional and, consequently, the RA/PsA synovial membrane results hypoxic. Unsurprisingly, the resulting synovial hypoxia was correlated with local joint inflammation [37]. In the inflamed synovium, altered mitochondrial function and oxidative damage were also observed, which are both possibly related to hypoxia [38,39]. The perpetuation of inflammation leads to damage of the cartilage, which allows the invasion of the subchondral bone by FLS, immune cells, and pro-inflammatory cytokines [40]. The exposure of the subchondral bone to the action of proteinase and activation of osteoclasts (OCs) leads to the characteristic bony erosions (Figure 2). Additionally, PsA is also characterized by inflammation of the enthesis associated with a peculiar osteoproductive phenomenon, which leads to calcification of tendons, ankylosis of joints, and consequently to impaired quality of life. This phenomenon is possibly related to impaired mechanisms of tissue repair. Despite the recent progress and advances, the pathogenic mechanisms behind RA and PsA onset are far from being completely understood. The pathogenesis of inflammatory arthritis is characterized by an immune dysregulation, which involves the activation of both innate and adaptive immunity. Immune-mediated pathogenesis was demonstrated by different evidence, such as the presence of auto-reactive T cells in the synovium [41], the association with major histocompatibility complex (MHC)-I, and the good response to immunosuppressive drugs [42]. An altered metabolic response of the immune cells may also contribute to the perpetuation of the inflammatory loop in the inflamed synovium. FLS and synovial macrophages are enhancers of joint inflammation, which ultimately leads to cartilage disruption [43]. In fact, FLS have a tumor-like behaviour in PsA joints. They are characterized by a few key features, i.e., the increased proliferation and invasiveness, the resistance to apoptosis, and the active production of matrix-degrading enzymes and pro-inflammatory cytokines, such as tumor necrosis factor-α (TNF-α), and interleukin 17 (IL-17) [44]. Regarding innate immunity, dendritic cells (DCs) are present in the synovium, synovial fluid, and ectopic lymph tissue of RA inflamed joints compared with osteoarthritis; in the context of inflammation, DCs have a role as antigen-presenting cells (APCs) and as a producer of pro-inflammatory cytokines, i.e., IL-23 and IL-12, which induce the differentiation of T helper 17 cells (Th17) and Th1 subsets, relevant in joint inflammation [45]. Moreover, defective regulatory T cells are associated with autoimmune disorders, such as RA [46]. Furthermore, macrophages play an active role in the pathogenesis of inflammatory arthritides because of the high expression of pro-inflammatory cytokines and matrix metalloproteinases, and they are APCs for T cells and B cells, representing a source of osteoclast precursors in an inflammatory context [47]. Lymphocytes infiltrate the synovium, where aggregates of T cells and B cells are found, and their absence is associated with remission [48,49]. Despite the progress in arthritis treatment over the last few decades, up to 40% of patients are still non-responders to the available treatments; for this reason, research toward a better understanding of the pathogenesis is continuously growing with a particular interest in new pathogenic mechanisms and possible therapeutic targets.

3. H₂S as Inhibitor of Oxidative Stress and Inflammation

H₂S can be an endogenous mediator to limit free radical damage and inflammation [50]. A relevant role is played by H₂S in balancing oxidative and reductive species, thus influencing the cell’s redox state. H₂S is a strong reducing agent able to directly react with multiple oxidant stressors including superoxide radical anion [51], hydrogen peroxide [52], and peroxynitrite (ONOO⁻) [50] (see Figure 3). Furthermore, H₂S is able to antagonize lipid peroxidation and oxidation of thiols, to reverse mitochondrial dysfunction [53], and to increase the activity of the most important enzymes involved in the cell’s antioxidant defense. One of these enzymes, the Cu/Zn superoxide dismutase (SOD) [54], is a target of H₂S, which binds to the catalytic Cu center, thus increasing the ROS scavenging activity. Moreover, the persulfuration of Cys-111 of the human SOD1 stabilizes the enzyme against oxidation-induced aggregation without affecting its activity [55]. The activity of other enzymes, also implicated in the cell’s antioxidant response, such as catalase (CAT), glutathione reductase (GR), glutathione S-transferase (GST), quinone reductase (QR), and glutathione peroxidase (GPx), was likewise augmented in rat kidney upon treatment with diallyl sulfide (DAS), which is an H₂S-releasing molecule [56].

H₂S is also able to upregulate the antioxidant response elements (ARE) gene transcription [57] (Figure 3) and to produce glutathione persulfide (GSSH) in mitochondria [50,52], a more efficient H₂O₂-scavenging molecule than GSH. In more detail, H₂S induces the dissociation between nuclear erythroid factor 2-related factor 2 (Nrf2) and Kelch-like ECH-associated protein 1 (Keap1) through the sulfhydration of Keap 1 at the Cys-151 residue and induction of a disulfide bond between Cys-288 and Cys-613 residues, thus allowing the Nrf2 nuclear translocation and binding to AREs (Figure 3) [58,59,60,61,62,63]. The antioxidant activity of this gasotransmitter is also related to the activation of K_ATP channels to reduce oxidative glutamate toxicity [64]. Moreover, the anti-oxidative effects of H₂S are also related to the anti-inflammatory effect via an increase in the expression of anti-oxidant enzymes, such as indoleamine-pyrrole 2,3-dioxygenase 1 (IDO1) and heme oxygenase 1 (HO1), SOD, CAT, and GPx, which lead to the suppression of reactive oxygen species (ROS) production (Figure 3) [65,66]. Surely, the direct antioxidant effect as a free radical scavenger and as an inducer of antioxidant enzymes might have a potential anti-inflammatory effect in joint inflammation [67,68].

Interestingly, H₂S is also an inflammation modulator that can have both pro- and anti-inflammatory effects on immune cells, depending on the concentration [68]. Commonly, a pro-inflammatory effect was observed at high H₂S concentrations, whereas an anti-inflammatory effect was observed at physiological concentrations. Overall, the role of H₂S in resolving ongoing inflammation and inducing tissue repair was suggested [26,31,69,70,71]. The exogenous administration of H₂S at physiological levels enhances T-cell activation in T-cell lines and upregulates the expression of cluster of differentiation 69 (CD69), IL-2, and CD25 [72]; H₂S-induced signaling plays a key role in T-cell activation. Moreover, H₂S shows a regulatory interaction with IL-10. Furthermore, the upregulation of IL-10 expression was observed after the exogenous administration of H₂S [73]. The ability of H₂S donors to modulate the expression of genes for many pro-inflammatory cytokines, chemokines, and enzymes is largely linked to effects on NF-κB activity. In rodent models of colitis, treatment with H₂S-donors significantly reduced tissue expression of IL-1β, interferon-γ, TNF-α, IL-12 p40, IL-2, regulated upon activation, normal T cell expressed and presumably secreted (RANTES), and inducible nitric oxide synthase (iNOS), without affecting the IL-10 expression [71,74,75]. Allyl disulfide treatment significantly inhibited NF-κB activation and production of TNF-α, as observed by biopsies from patients with ulcerative colitis. It was shown that H₂S donors are able to reduce TNF-α release following lipopolysaccharide (LPS) exposure in RAW 264.7 cells, a murine monocyte/macrophage-like lineage [76]. Moreover, it was recently demonstrated that H₂S can shift the macrophage phenotype from pro- to anti-inflammatory [70,77].

Additionally, H₂S plays also a relevant role in orchestrating immune cell tissue recruitment and infiltration, which are vital in the generation of the inflammatory processes. Leukocyte recruitment and tissue infiltration at the site of inflammation are initial events in inflammation response that are linked to the increase of the production of vascular cell adhesion molecule 1 (VCAM1) and intracellular adhesion molecule 1 (ICAM1) in endothelial cells. H₂S donors and non-selective inhibitors of CSE and CBS specifically inhibit the migration of leukocytes by directly reducing the adherence of circulating cells to the inflamed vascular walls (as shown in Figure 1); consequently, H₂S reduces the infiltration of neutrophils and lymphocytes in tissue [78]. H₂S downregulates ICAM expression in high-glucose-treated [79] and TNF-treated human umbilical vein endothelial cells [80]. Moreover, the upregulation of heme oxygenase 1 (HO1) and inhibition of the NF-κB pathway due to H₂S-donors can induce the inhibition of VCAM1 expression [81,82]. In neutrophils, H₂S may also induce the apoptosis, amplifying the anti-inflammatory effect [83].

Moreover, several enzymes involved in the inflammatory response can be inhibited by H₂S. The majority of protein tyrosine phosphatases (PTPs) have a conserved catalytic domain that contains a cysteine residue, which is able to perform a nucleophilic attack on a substrate; this catalytic residue can be sulfhydrated, as well as in the case of PTP1B. PTP1B is ubiquitously expressed [84] and plays a regulatory role in the control of immune cell signaling in macrophages, monocytes, and granulocytes [85]. PTP1B is important in the release of inflammatory cytokines such as IL-4, IL-6, TNF-α, extracellular signal-regulated kinase (ERK), protein kinase B (PKB/Akt) (see Figure 3), human epidermal growth factor receptor 2 (HER2), and NF-κB [84,86,87]. Although PTP1B is a negative regulator of inflammation able to regulate inflammatory processes [88,89], it was also demonstrated that the administration of an inhibitor of PTP1B attenuates the LPS-induced neuroinflammation in mice [90]. PTP1B was the first phosphatase that was shown to be sulfhydrated [91]. The PTP1B sulfhydration occurs at the Cys-215 residue in the active site and leads to inhibition of the PTP activity at a second-order rate (22.4–1.8 M⁻¹∙s⁻¹) with a rate of H₂S-mediated PTP1B inactivation of 10–1.4 M⁻¹∙s⁻¹. In a model of endoplasmic reticulum stress, the sulfhydration of PTP1B decreases its activity, increasing the phosphorylation and activation of eIF2a kinase protein kinase RNA-like endoplasmic reticulum kinase (PERK) Tyr-619, which is a direct PTP1B substrate and has an important role in the endoplasmic reticulum stress response.

Furthermore, H₂S can have an inhibitory effect on some phosphodiesterase (PDE) enzymes and, consequently, a positive effect on inflammation [92,93]. PDE inhibitors can have beneficial effects in inflammation by increasing cAMP level, as well as inhibiting the production of ROS and cytokines such as TNF-α and IL-1. Furthermore, PDE5 inhibitors, which increase cGMP levels, can inhibit the production of IL-6 and TNF-α [94,95]. Both endogenous and exogenous H₂S serves as an inhibitor of PDEs [96]. With a half maximal inhibitory concentration (IC₅₀) of 1.6 µM, H₂S can inhibit the activity of the cGMP-specific PDE5 widely distributed in the cardiovascular system [97,98] and of the mitochondrial PDE2A stimulating mitochondrial electron transport [99]. However, the H₂S selectivity among different PDE isoforms should be deeply investigated. Notably, the inhibitor of PDE-4, apremilast, was approved for the treatment of PsA [100]; this further highlights the possible therapeutic role of H₂S in inflammatory arthritis, due to its effect on PDE enzymes.

The effects on the gastrointestinal tract are representative of the behaviour of this gasotransmitter in inflammation. In detail, H₂S is able to promote healing of experimentally induced stomach ulcers in rats, while treatment with dl-propargylglycine (PAG), which is a CSE inhibitor, has the opposite effect [18,101]. Moreover, ABT-346, which is H₂S-releasing naproxen, showed significantly less or even the absence of gastrointestinal toxicity compared to naproxen in rats [102].

In the last few years, the molecular mechanism of the H₂S effect on inflammation was widely investigated. IκB/NF-κB (inhibitor of κB /Nuclear factor κ B) is an important molecular pathway that is a key target of H₂S. NaHS inhibits IκB-α degradation and, therefore, reduces NF-κΒ translocation into the nucleus [103,104]. The first evidence was that LPS-induced NF-κΒ activation in cultured mouse macrophages was inhibited by H₂S [105]. Subsequently, other studies showed evidence that, in different cell lines, H₂S regulates the transcription, via NF-κΒ downregulation, of a plethora of pro-inflammatory mediators such as TNF-α, IL-1β, IL-6, IL-8, IL-18, inducible nitric oxide synthase (iNOS), cyclooxygenase-2 (COX-2), and some adhesion molecules. Additionally, slow-releasing H₂S donors such as GYY4137 (morpholin-4-ium 4 methoxyphenyl (morpholino) phosphinodithioate) S-diclofenac, and S-propargyl-cysteine (SPRC) have similar effects [106,107,108,109]. Furthermore, H₂S can also promote cell survival via sulfhydration of the p65 subunit of NF-κB at Cys-38 leading to an anti-apoptotic effect of NF-κB in response to pro-inflammatory agents such as TNF-α and LPS in macrophages [110]. Although the effect of H₂S on NF-kB is relevant in the inflammation, other transduction mechanisms such as Akt/PKB and MAPK pathways, signal transducer and activator of transcription 3 (STAT-3), and Nrf2 cannot be ruled out as mediator of the inflammatory response to this gasotransmitter [56,60,106,111]. Additionally, it was recently demonstrated that H₂S can induce the activation of forkhead box P3 (FOXP3) and, consequently, the differentiation of T regulatory cells. The functional enhancement of T regulatory cells by H₂S highlights the role that this T-cell population may have in the H₂S regulatory network of autoimmune inflammation, i.e., inflammatory arthritis [112].

Interestingly, the stage of inflammation is also relevant for the effect of H₂S-releasing donors that can be either pro- or anti-inflammatory.

In addition, lower plasma/serum H₂S concentrations were also related to vascular inflammation associated with childhood disorder Kawasaki disease (autoimmune blood vessel inflammation) [113] and skin inflammation associated with psoriasis [114].

More studies are necessary to not only fully understand the complex role of H₂S in inflammation, but also to investigate further opportunities for the treatment of existing inflammatory diseases.

4. H₂S and Arthritic Diseases

The effect of H₂S on joint inflammation was investigated in the last few years due to the anti-inflammatory effect of the gasotransmitter. The beneficial effect of H₂S seems to be dose-dependent; in fact, different studies demonstrated opposite results. At low concentration, H₂S exerts an anti-inflammatory effect on tissue and cells, suggesting a potentially positive effect on arthritis. The effect of H₂S on the monocyte/macrophages compartment [69,76] seems particularly relevant due to the central role that macrophages play in the pathogenesis of inflammatory arthritis. Pro-inflammatory macrophages are vital APCs and can differentiate into osteoclasts, cells responsible for irreversible bony erosions; furthermore, macrophages are one of the major sources of TNF-α.

In murine macrophages stimulated with LPS, H₂S at low concentration inhibits the activation and the synthesis of several pro-inflammatory mediators, i.e., NO, NF-κB, IL-6, and IL-1β; however, at higher concentration, H₂S stimulates the production of pro-inflammatory molecules by macrophages [107]. This dual effect was also demonstrated on RA FLS by Kloesch et al. [115] in two different experimental stings, showing that short-term exposure to H₂S induces IL-6 expression, while long-term exposure has the opposite effect [115,116]. Interestingly, in RA synovial fluids, levels of H₂S were found to be higher than in patients with osteoarthritis (OA); furthermore, the levels detected were positively correlated with disease activity and inflammation. In addition, H₂S concentration in the bloodstream was increased in patients with RA, and it was also associated with high numbers of circulating leukocytes [13]. As further support of a possible pathogenic role in inflammation, d-penicillamine, used in the past for the treatment of RA, resulted as a direct inhibitor of the synthesis of H₂S and as a direct inhibitor of CSE activity [117]. In particular circumstances, the pro-inflammatory effect of H₂S seems to be mediated by the induction of the expression of the intracellular adhesion molecule (ICAM)1, which may increase cell migration into the inflamed tissues [118].

However, H₂S was found elevated in inflammatory models, and it can represent an attempt at increasing synthesis, to reduce the local inflammation. Various studies demonstrated numerous anti-inflammatory properties of H₂S mainly explained by the reduced expression of pro-inflammatory mediators and adhesion molecules. In animal models, the administration of H₂S donors reduced the leukocyte adherence and infiltration and repressed carrageenan-induced paw edema.

The inhibition of endogenous H₂S synthesis had the opposite effect, enhancing leukocyte migration [118]. Notably, chondrocytes and mesenchymal stem cells which differentiate in chondrocytes express CBS and CSE, responsible for the synthesis of H₂S, most probably used as a preserving mechanism [119]. H₂S showed a protective effect on cartilage damage in OA patients in different studies [120,121]. This effect seems mediated by the inhibition of matrix metalloproteinases and the production of extracellular matrix proteins induced by H₂S-releasing compounds, which reverted the catabolic effect of IL-1β [122,123]. In addition, H₂S was demonstrated to reduce the IL-1β-induced expression of IL-6, IL-8, MMP-2, and MMP-14 in OA FLS [124]. Remarkably, H₂S can also inhibit TNF-α activity, an essential cytokine in inflammatory arthritis pathogenesis, by binding the zinc-proteinase TNF-α-converting enzyme (TACE), as demonstrated by Li et al. [121]. This inhibitory activity may account for the potential anti-inflammatory effect of H₂S in inflammatory arthritis. Moreover, the NF-κB pathway was inhibited by H₂S in different experimental studies [117,125]. Hence, the anti-inflammatory role is highly probably secondary to the inhibition of the transcription factor NF-κB, which has a key role in the pathogenesis of inflammatory arthritis as described above (see Figure 2 and Figure 3) [126,127]; furthermore, it can induce the synthesis of the anti-inflammatory cytokine IL-10 [106]. The inhibition of NF-κB activity by H₂S is, therefore, able to reduce the production of the pro-inflammatory cytokines, mediating the anti-inflammatory effect of the gas in an animal model of sepsis [128], however it may also play a role in joint inflammation. Moreover, NF-κB is a key factor also for the differentiation and maturation of osteoclasts, responsible for bone erosions in arthritis [119]. Interestingly, H₂S conjugated to the non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drug (NSAID) diclofenac inhibited mature osteoclasts and osteoclastogenesis, thus preventing osteolysis in an animal model of breast cancer metastasis; the inhibitory effect was demonstrated to be dependent on IκB kinase (IKK)/NF-κB [129,130]. This result is particularly interesting, because it may represent a relevant added value to drugs currently used for inflammatory arthritis, not only because H₂S has a pleiotropic anti-inflammatory profile, but also because it may potentially act on bone erosion, the main long-term target in the treatment of arthritis. Moreover, as described above, H₂S can directly inhibit the migration and adhesion of leukocytes to endothelial cells (see Figure 1) and the infiltration of neutrophils and lymphocytes [78]. Therefore, defective H₂S compensatory production can contribute to the pathogenesis of joint inflammation in immune-mediated arthritis.

5. H₂S-Donors as Potential Anti-Arthritis Drugs

H₂S-donors acquired great therapeutic potential for widely diffused pathologies, such as cardiovascular [131,132], neurodegenerative [133,134,135,136], and gastrointestinal diseases [137,138]. Their H₂S release can also be prolonged and potentiated by biological thiols that are normally present in biological systems such as protein thiol groups, cysteine, and glutathione (GSH). Furthermore, one of the speculated mechanisms is that H₂S donors can induce the synthesis of glutathione by increasing the metabolic pathways and enzymes leading to its production [139].

As discussed above, recent evidence of the anti-inflammatory properties and the tissue repair effects of H₂S increased the interest in its therapeutic potential in arthritis. The research on human species was developed mainly for OA patients, but that on inflammatory arthritis is also promising. Several non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs (NSAIDs) were conjugated with H₂S (

Table 1. H₂S-releasing drugs as potential anti-inflammatory drugs in arthritis.

H2S-Derivative Drug	Drug	Company	Clinical Phase	Clinical Applications	References
AVT-18A	Sulindac	Avicenna T.	Preclinical	Cancer, inflammation	[143]
NBS-1120	Aspirin	Avicenna T.	Preclinical	Cancer, inflammation	[144]
ACS-14	Aspirin	CTG Ph.	Preclinical	Inflammation, cardiac injury, Arthritis	[149]
ACS-21	Aspirin	CTG Ph.	Preclinical	Inflammation, cardiac injury, Osteoarthritis	[149]
ACS-6	Ketorolac	CTG Ph.	Preclinical	Arthritis Antioxidant	[149,150]
ATB-337/ACS-15	Diclofenac	Antibe T.	Preclinical	Arthritis, inflammation	[149]
ATB-343	Naproxen	Antibe T.	Preclinical	Inflammatory diseases, Alzheimer’s disease	[149]
ATB-346	Naproxen	Antibe T.	Phase II	Osteoarthritis, inflammation	[102,141,149]
ATB-345	Naproxen	Antibe T.	Preclinical	Inflammatory diseases	[102]
ATB-429	Meselamine	Antibe T.	Preclinical	Cancer, inflammatory diseases, colitis	[75]
GYY4137 DAS/DADS		National Uni. of Singapore	Preclinical Preclinical	Inflammatory diseases, cancer, hypertension, arthritis Cancer, arthritis	[82,107,122,151] [147,148]

), allowing a slow release of the gasotransmitter into the target tissues. The molecular structures of H₂S donors that are under study for clinical applications are shown in Figure 4. In animal models, NSAIDs conjugated to H₂S, i.e., naproxen and celecoxib, demonstrated a strong protective effect on gastrointestinal epithelium compared to the toxic effect of the parent drug [102]. For example, the H₂S-releasing naproxen, called ATB-346, which releases H₂S via a hydrolytic mechanism [102], was demonstrated to have a greater anti-inflammatory and chondro-protective effect on osteoarthritic joints in animal models, reducing leukocyte migration and reducing TNF-α and NF-κB expression, and less gastrointestinal toxicity [102,140,141]. Recently, a phase II clinical trial investigating 244 healthy subjects demonstrated a drastic reduction of gastric ulcer investigated with endoscopy when treated with ATB-346 (42.2% vs. 2.5% ulcer development with naproxen and ATB-346, respectively). This effect was associated with an increased suppression of COX activity [141]. The efficacy of ATB-346 was recently evaluated in patients with OA, demonstrating that ATB-346 can reduce joint pain, possibly to a greater extent than other standard NSAIDs, such as naproxen or celecoxib [142]. Another derivative drug-releasing H₂S is S-mesalamine (ATB-429) (Figure 4), used for the treatment of inflammatory colitis. ATB-429 exerted a protective role to the gastrointestinal mucosa and higher anti-inflammatory properties than the parent drug [75]. Therefore, ATB-429 could be a good candidate for reducing inflammation in arthritis. Moreover, the synthesis of other compounds able to release both NO and H₂S recently led to the development of new potential drugs for the treatment of inflammatory arthritis, such as NOSH (nitric oxide and hydrogen sulfide)- sulindac (AVT-18A) and NOSH-aspirin (NBS-1120) (see Table 1). NOSH-sulindac was similar to sulindac in inhibiting the inflammatory response and demonstrating safety in the carrageenan-induced arthritis animal model, but with a larger effect on the reduction of circulating TNF-α level [143]. Similarly, NBS-1120 had a better safety profile in an animal model of systemic and local inflammation when compared to aspirin [144].

Another potential candidate drug for clinical trials in inflammatory diseases is the slow-releasing H₂S donor, GYY4137, as discussed above. This compound was demonstrated to directly inhibit joint inflammation in a mouse animal model by reducing the production of pro-inflammatory cytokines in macrophages [107]. In particular, GYY4137 inhibits several inflammatory molecules such as IL-1β, IL-6, and TNF-α, in LPS-challenged macrophages in culture [107]; moreover, GYY4137 is able to reduce LPS-evoked septic shock [106] and knee-joint edema in response to intra-articular injection of Freund’s adjuvant [122]. The administration of GYY4137 leads to an anti-inflammatory effect on knee-joint swelling and might be used for clinical applications [82].

Moreover, the endogenous metabolism of natural organosulfur compounds (OSCs) derived from garlic can also lead to the slow-releasing production of H₂S [126,145] and, consequently, to an antioxidant and anti-inflammatory action [146] with organ/tissue protection. Therefore, OSCs can be considered as potential natural drugs for arthritis. The effects of diallyl sulfide (DAS) on arthritis were investigated in a model of crystal-induced arthritis, human synoviocytes and chondrocytes. DAS was able to inhibit the inflammatory response both ex vivo and in rat with induced joint inflammation [147]. In a recent study, the efficacy of diallyl disulfide (DADS) in controlling joint inflammation was evaluated in an animal model of Freund’s adjuvant-induced arthritis. DADS was demonstrated to be effective in reducing paw edema and joint and cartilage destruction [148]. These studies highlight the therapeutic potential of natural H₂S donors for the treatment of inflammatory arthritis; however, more in vivo studies are needed to confirm the efficacy of these natural H₂S donors, their safety profile, and their potential application in inflammatory arthritis.

6. Tissue Regeneration as a Therapeutic Approach in Arthritis

The chronic inflammatory process of arthritis leads to the disruption of the cartilaginous tissue, which ultimately contributes to subchondral bone erosions, articular deformities, and impaired quality of life. Physiologically, the cartilage tissue is avascular, aneural, and hypocellular; therefore, there is no self-reparation. A potential therapeutic approach for arthritis is to facilitate its regeneration and/or repair. Linked to the above-cited properties of H₂S, H₂S donors could be used as biochemical factors able to induce cartilage and bone repair in the context of arthritis. Therefore, the possibility of fabricating systems conditioned with H₂S-releasing agents able to improve the repair/regeneration of cartilage and bone in degenerative diseases, as well as RA, is currently being investigated.

Two main approaches able to improve tissue repair and regeneration were investigated: the injection of stem cells (scaffold-less approach) and of three-dimensional (3D) scaffolds. In the scaffold-less approach, mesenchymal stem cells (MSCs) are the most used kind of cells showing a multipotent property [152,153]. MSCs, under appropriate differentiation stimuli, are able to express chondrogenic potential and improve the repair of cartilage [152,154,155].

Intriguingly, the MSC-based approach has the potential to solve some symptoms related to osteoarticular loss; however, it presents various problems such as cell senescence, de-differentiation, and expression of the hypertrophic phenotype. Some of these problems could be solved using the pre-conditioning of MSCs with H₂S donors. Recently, it was demonstrated that the pretreatment of MSCs with H₂S provided protection of MSCs upon exposure to hypoxia–ischemic insult whether in vitro or in vivo [156].

The lack of mechanical support in joint repair strategies led to relatively poor results in the clinical application of the scaffold-less approach. Consequently, substances and polymeric supports (both natural or synthetic) were designed with the aim of providing a scaffolding structure and, finally, promoting tissue regeneration more efficiently.

Many synthetic polymers with chondrogenic properties were studied, such as polylactic acid (PLA), polyethylene glycol (PEG), and polycaprolactone (PCL), but only some of them are now commercially available for clinical use [152,157,158,159].

One of these is a poly (l-lactide) (PLLA) scaffold with fibrin gel [157], available in trade under the name PLA-based, is made of a porous microstructure with fibrin which results in an excellent combination of mechanical stability, resistance to mechanical stress, and retention of the cellular component. The high level of hydration of the gel is an important requirement for having a homogeneous cellular distribution and excellent values of cell viability.

Injectable gels, based on alginate and hyaluronic acid (HA–MA) were produced to induce cartilage repair [160,161]. Alginate hydrogel showed a highly organized structure with uniform pores, which demonstrated the stimulation of a gradual increase in the cell population and an increase in type II collagen production, which is the principal ECM component of articular cartilage, even if a downregulation of collagen X was observed [160]. The polymerization of this material was obtained directly in situ using an argon laser at 512 nm, and its mechanical properties were easily modulated by the chemical composition.

Another PEG-based hydrogel scaffold with three-layer composition was also synthetized [158], showing significant effects on cartilage repair. In this scaffold, chondroitin sulfate (CS) and matrix metalloproteinase-sensitive peptides (MMP-pep) were in the upper layer, while CS was in the middle layer, and hyaluronic acid was in the lower layer. This multi-layer composition mimicked the structure of native articular cartilage with mechanical and biochemical properties that change in space. Furthermore, it was seen that this structural variability can stimulate tissue regeneration, leading to an increased production of both collagen II and X.

Another cell-free product that had excellent results for cartilage repair is Gelrin C, a hydrogel scaffold made of PEG–fibrinogen [162,163]. It was demonstrated to effectively induce cartilage repair measured with the Magnetic Resonance Observation of Cartilage Repair Tissue (MOCART) score (84.4 out of 100 MOCART score after 24 months). At the moment, Gelrin C is in clinical phase II for cartilage repair.

All these biomaterials can be functionalized with H₂S-donors in order to improve their potential in tissue repair and regeneration. PEG–fibrinogen was, in fact, functionalized by embedding albumin microbubbles able to catalyze the production of H₂S [164]. This functionalization improved the proliferation of human cardiac progenitor stem cells, promoting their spindled morphology and suggesting a potential application in repair for other biological tissues, such as human cartilage. H₂S-releasing biomaterials can have several protective actions, including antioxidant and anti-inflammatory effects, angiogenesis, and vasodilation, thus improving the regenerative capacity of polymers. At the moment, there are few in vitro and in vivo studies on scaffolds able to release H₂S. Scaffolds based on PCL and PLA were produced using an electrospinning technique, and they were respectively functionalized with N-benzoyl thio-benzamide (NSHD1) and phosphonamidothioate templates that generate H₂S in a pH-controlled manner, as well as slow-releasing H₂S donors extracted from garlic (GaOS and DADS) [159,165,166]. These three scaffolds showed protective effects on the oxidative damage of ROS and the ability to improve cell viability. A sponge H₂S-releasing silk fibroin (SF) was also doped with GYY4137 [167], resulting in a scaffold with the same mechanical properties, which was able to induce a significant increase in differentiation to mature osteoblasts (OBs) and expression of osteogenic genes after three weeks of growth in a 3D culture of human MSCs.

Table 2. Scaffolds and H₂S-releasing scaffolds for potential applications in the therapy of arthritis.

Scaffold	Characteristics and Effects	Type of Cells	Commercial Product	Phase of Study	References
PLLA/fibrin 1PLLA/chondrocyte/atelocollagen	Improved cell proliferation and expression of type I and type II collagen	Chondrocytes	PLA-based BioSeedR-C (BioTissue, AG, Zurich, Switzerland)	In vitro	[157]
PEG dyacrylate systems PEG/chitosan PEG/albumin	In situ photopolymerization and potential modulation of its mechanical properties, increasing of the expression of type I and II collagen and the amount of sulfated GAG	MSCs		In vitro	[158]
Alginate	Increase in chondrocyte viability	Chondrocytes		In vivo (SCID mice)	[160]
Hyaluronic acid/fibrin Hyaluronic acid/collagen type I	In situ photopolymerization, potential modulation of its mechanical properties, stimulation of ECM production and proteoglycan synthesis, and improved chondrocyte growth	Chondrocytes	Hyaluronic-based HyalograftR C autograft (Anika Therapeutics, Inc., Bedford, MA, USA)	In vivo (human)	[161]
PEG-DA/denatured human fibrinogen (DHF)	In situ photopolymerization, potential modulation of its mechanical properties, gradual resorption by the body being replaced by new cartilage tissue	Cell free	GelrinC (Regentis, Haifa, Israel)	Phase II	[163,164]
H2S-releasing scaffolds
PCL/NSHD1	Significant decrease in apoptosis in a model of tissue transplantation, protection from ROS damage, and increase in expression of collagen type I and type III	3T3		In vivo	[154]
PFM/GaOS or DADS	Improved MSC proliferation and anti-microbial activity and protective effect against oxidative damage	hMSCs		In vitro	[166]
TSTMBs-PFHy	In situ photopolymerization, potential modulation of its mechanical properties, induced spindled morphology of cells and cell proliferation	HFFs hCPCs		In vitro	[164]
ALG-CHO/2-aminopyridine-5-thiocarboxamide/tetraaniline	Increase in ejection fraction value, reduction of the myocardial infarct size in rats	ADSCs		In vivo	[168]
SATO/CaCl2	Decrease in intimal hyperplasia in human veins	Endothelial cells		In vivo	[169]
SF/GYY4137	Significant increase in osteogenic differentiation of stem cells, upregulation of osteogenic and angiogenic genes and integrins	OBs, hMSC		In vitro	[167]
HA or PCL/JK1	H2S release in pH-dependent manner, improved cell proliferation. tissue regeneration, re-epithelialization, collagen deposition, angiogenesis	Raw 264.7		In vivo (mouse Male C57BL)	[165]

¹PLLA—poly (l-lactide); PEG—polyethylene glycol; PCL—polycaprolactone; NSHD1—N-benzoyl thio-benzamide; GaOS—garlic oil soluble extracts; DADS—diallyl disulfide; SF—silk fibroin; HA—hyaluronic acid; ECM—extracellular matrix; MSC—mesenchymal stem cell; HFF—human foreskin fibroblasts; CPC—cardiac progenitor cell; ADSC—adipose-derived stem cell; OB—osteoblast. TSTMBs-PFHy— fibrinogen hydrogel incorporating albumin microbubbles functionalized with thiosulfate:cyanide sulfurtransferase; ALG-CHO—Partially Oxidized Alginate; PFM poly(lactic) acid fibrous; SATO aromatic peptide amphiphile and the H₂S moiety, S-aroylthiooxime; PEG-DA—polyethylene glycol diacrylate; JK1—H₂S donor synthesized from phenylphosphonothioic dichloride.

summarizes scaffolds and H₂S-releasing scaffolds that are currently under investigation for tissue repair. The H₂S-releasing scaffolds could have a potential therapeutic application in the degenerative stages of inflammatory arthritis.

7. Conclusions

Currently, the interest in the pathological and therapeutic role of H₂S in inflammatory diseases is growing. Recently, the evidence of the anti-inflammatory properties of H₂S at physiological concentrations increased. As a gasotransmitter, H₂S is involved in the regulation of production and release of several cytokines, as well as in the differentiation of adaptative and innate immune cells. Moreover, H₂S plays a role as a radical scavenger in hypoxic conditions, frequently associated with inflammatory arthritis, and as a promoter of tissue repair.

Due to the growing evidence, several therapeutic approaches were investigated in different inflammatory diseases. In the context of inflammatory arthritis, the most interesting approaches result in the conjugation of anti-inflammatory compounds with H₂S and the induction of tissue repair.

The first therapeutic approach aims to target the early stages of the inflammatory process or active inflammation. Despite the recent advances in the approach to inflammatory joint diseases, a significant number of patients need multi-therapeutic strategies with not always successfully outcomes. In this context, the use of H₂S-conjugated drugs may be a potential add-on treatment. NSAIDs conjugated with H₂S were already demonstrated to be effective in managing pain in OA patients with significantly reduced toxicity.

The modern treatments for inflammatory arthritis are able to target the active inflammation; however, strategies to treat established bone and cartilage damage are currently lacking. Scaffolds and H₂S-functionalized scaffolds, with or without cell deliveries, are opening a completely new therapeutic approach in the arthritis field. Currently, a surgical approach is the most used in advanced cases; however, it can have its limitations in elderly patients and with contraindications, and this treatment is not always indicated in patients with mild joint damage. The possibility to induce tissue repair in a damaged joint with the associated anti-inflammatory effect of H₂S represents a very promising new potential approach. H₂S-functionalized scaffolds are still in early clinical studies as most of the studies applied them in vitro or in animal models. It will be promising to combine injectable hydrogel scaffolds that stimulate cartilage repair, such as Gelrin C (Regentis, Haifa, Israel), which is in a phase II clinical trial for early OA, with H₂S-donors and MSCs for further potential clinical applications in both OA and inflammatory arthritis.

Clearly, more work is needed to improve the sensitivity and specificity of H₂S assays, as well as to improve the patient selection in studies assessing the efficacy of this new promising treatment strategy.