- Review
Animal shelters play a vital role in providing care for homeless animals and preparing them for adoption; however, homelessness still poses a significant challenge to the animal welfare system. In the case of dogs, the success of the adoption process is strongly influenced by their behaviour, which is shaped by both their previous life experiences and the shelter environment. The aim of this study was to evaluate the significance of behavioural problems in shelter dogs for the adoption process, with particular emphasis on the relationship between welfare, animal behaviour, the preferences of prospective adopters and the behaviour of the dogs following adoption. This review proposes that the effectiveness of adoption should be considered not only quantitatively, i.e., in terms of the number of animals leaving the shelter, but also qualitatively, i.e., regarding the suitability of the dogs to their new environment and the longevity of the relationship with their owners. The adoption process can be supported by improving welfare, reducing stress and enriching the environment in the shelter, and by conducting individual behavioural assessments, preparing the dog for life in a home environment and presenting the animal appropriately; it is also recommended to educate prospective owners and offer support where necessary. By following a comprehensive approach that promotes dog welfare and employs a responsible adoption process, it is more likely that the animal will find a permanent home with less risk of being returned to the shelter. Hence, to ensure the effective functioning of animal shelters within the animal welfare system, animal behaviour and welfare should be treated as integral elements of strategies to combat dog homelessness.
19 November 2026





![Schematic cross-domain cascade and Five Domains overlap in Pugs. Dashed ellipses indicate the Five Domains of Welfare [57]; nodes positioned within overlapping zones represent conditions that simultaneously compromise more than one domain. Extreme skull foreshortening is the single structural root cause common to all cascades. Illustration by Cristina L. Wilkins.](https://mdpi-res.com/animals/animals-16-02867/article_deploy/html/images/animals-16-02867-g001-550.jpg)

